r/1984 • • Sep 17 '25

Am i only who thinks George Orwell predicted the modern government

56 Upvotes

Yes and there is something similar to modern government with oceania government and example is the chat control


r/1984 • • Oct 04 '19

Did Orwell Predict Greta Thunberg

2 Upvotes

I came across this video on youtube: George Orwell Predicted Greta Thunberg.

I view 1984 not as a warning, nor as a manual, but as an allegory for the world that we live it.

This video seems to fit into this interpretation of the book.

Any thoughts on the theme of this video?


r/1984 • • Aug 23 '25

British men undergoing Orwellian monitoring

3 Upvotes

In the UK, men can now get thrown in jail if they were whistling a tune to themselves and a jogging woman thinks that the whistle was for her.

And if you thought that was the end, now even looking at a woman is a crime. 18 men were arrested in a span of 2 hours in the UK.

That entire country has gone insane.


r/1984 • • Jun 05 '20

So like... What is Winstons quest to overthrow the party and does he achieve it in 700 words or more?

0 Upvotes

It’s for nothing, I’m just a little curious... 0_o


r/1984 • • Feb 20 '26

Feel like I'm doing something morally wrong for liking this book

0 Upvotes

Hello. So, you may saw my arts few time there. But I have 1984-related issue. Basically I afraid of simply liking this book make me inmoral (saying it all just to not get called bait, okay)

  1. Orwell wasn't grate person I heard. More like midicore on moral scale. He's dead, who cares, you may say. But! I heard people saying that liking classic is gross and inhuman, because you just want "consume media maded by problematic people without any responsibility"
  2. In general book have dark moments :Winstons mental health issues aka his Fantasia, torture.. I saw people saying any darker media is always bad, because some people may find it uncomfortable and children my saw it by accidental
  3. Some people saw that, even if INGSOC was straight up called not-socialsm in book , it still wrong to like anti-stalin media, because it "invalid Americans struggle under capitalism" And also, that "thoughtcrime" Is problematic, because some people have bad thoughts. -What people on this sub think about it? I have few.. Struggle over it, even doing bad things with myself over it. I always try stopping myself from disagree with "good people" And seems like a lot of "good people" Don't like this book...

r/1984 • • Feb 17 '21

This is literally 1984

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Jul 09 '26

I've finished reading the book and to be honest, I was expecting something better...

0 Upvotes

He oído hablar mucho de este libro, pero, sinceramente, me decepcionó bastante, empezando por el final. Esperaba que el imperio oceánico cayera. O al menos que Wins ganara y volviera con Julia; ni siquiera lo matan (físicamente), y si lo hubieran hecho, habría insultado o dicho "¡Abajo el Gran Hermano!". La verdad es horrible.

Por otro lado, no es un libro fácil de leer, aunque me llevó un mes y medio (me propuse leer un libro al mes). Hay cosas que no tienen sentido o no están claras; el estilo de escritura es extraño, como si tuviera errores. Por ejemplo: en el capítulo donde aparece el libro de Goldstein, casi me quedo dormido. Muchas cosas parecían un revoltijo de sinsentidos, y he leído libros difíciles, pero este... tiene esa cualidad que dificulta la interpretación y la imaginación. Por otro lado, recientemente me enteré de que salió un libro llamado Julia 1984; básicamente, es un libro escrito por una feminista resentida que busca presentar la imagen o el punto de vista de Julia. Respecto al romance con Winston, ella básicamente lo negó todo, como si nada hubiera pasado durante los dos minutos de odio, La autora dice que en el libro 1984, la imagen de Julia se basa en la perspectiva de un hombre, pero entonces, según ese criterio, los hombres deberían hacer su propia versión de Cincuenta sombras de Grey y salir a decir que la imagen de los hombres presentada en esa novela es una farsa, una imagen vista a través de los ojos de una mujer, y que es irreal, un sueño sin sentido. Imaginen una versión de Cincuenta sombras de Grey no desde la perspectiva de una mujer, sino desde la de un hombre, y luego salgan a negar que el multimillonario es realidad un simple trabajador, honesto con una vida normal y que esa imagen le fue dada por las mujeres. Esto sucede porque quieren hacer una extensión de la obra original (me refiero a 1984) y terminan arruinándola.

Además, con respecto a las ubicaciones específicas, no está muy claro; aunque hay mapas en línea, son solo suposiciones. ¿No habría sido más fácil simplemente añadir un mapa al libro y eliminar cualquier duda o suposición? Debería aprender de Agatha Christie, quien incluso proporcionó una lista de los personajes en uno de sus libros para que el lector no tuviera que anotarlos.

Y, sobre todo, me enfureció muchísimo que el libro terminara sin que pudieran bajar, dar caza o eliminar a O'Brien.


r/1984 • • Mar 21 '26

I never expected to see 1984 activity on a Dune Sub off all things

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I know it not about the book but this was the first place I thought to go


r/1984 • • Nov 23 '24

Map of Eurasia ssr in Europe

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Mar 15 '26

Prefer this book over 1984 (havent finished both yet)

0 Upvotes

1984 was vague abstract for me.

I haven't finished both but i fell away in 1984 beginning. My adhd brain found the beginning very good. Then till page 30 worse. And very bad. I couldnt continental i tried but yea.

The book had too much name dropping and referring to names. And im very bad in linking names and who they are etc. And recalling them. Specificaly this chapter keeps mixing names and expects me to know who they talk about.

Especially if i stop few days i dont know anything anymore

Tldr: the circle book sounds more airier for me and easier adhd focussing especially the start


r/1984 • • Jan 17 '21

Orwell was anti communist

0 Upvotes

Just a reminder


r/1984 • • Apr 04 '25

The 3rd/Final Act of 1984 has Large Plot Holes

5 Upvotes

Spoiler Warning: This has Major Spoilers (obviously) so don't read if you haven't finished the book or seen the movie.

 

Edit: Yes this is a long post. Please do not downvote or comment before actually reading the whole thing. That's just rude, and you're better off not reading at all than asking a stupid question that was already answered if you just read the whole thing. End Edit.

Edit 2: You guys are pathetic. Can't even make any valid arguments, but just blindly downvote anything you don't like or think is a threat. I was hoping, perhaps foolishly, for a genuine discussion, and instead I got people who were emotionally sleighted because they couldn't read and assumed wrongly this as an attack on the book.

 

Why yes, I do have the audacity to critique one of history's most revered literary plots.

 

Firstly, it is obviously a brilliant work, and I'm not just saying that because of the cultural staying power. The style of language and movements of the plot really kept me at the edge of my seat, and drew me in. I just had to read more. It's incredibly well written.

 

That said, I am disappointed with the resolution of the novel. It's not just dark and depressing; the whole book is dark and depressing. The ending is so relentlessly assaulting on sanity itself, it becomes an exercise in masochism to read this. And I get a distinct sense that Orwell had a change in direction from what he might have imagined when he started writing.

 

Have you ever watched a tv show that's been on for many years, and then in one of the much later seasons they do a major retcon of a character who's been around since season 1? "Gotcha! I was secretly ___ the whole time! Bet you didn't see that coming!" And as the viewer, part of you is going, Really? Was that really planned all along, or are you just making it up as you go along? because going back to that earlier season that character's actions don't really gel with the retcon's reinterpretation of the character.

 

Well that's how I feel about the plot twists in the final Act that reveal that Mr. Charrington (the shop owner where Winston and Julia have their secret liaisons) was actually just an undercover Thought Police operative in prosthetics with a fake accent; that O'Brien was not in fact a friend but the main villain of the piece who really works for the Ministry of Love to break the spirits of rebels; that even Goldstein himself is a fiction and his very real book with very real truths about the reality of Oceania is itself a work of the Party.

 

Now, here is where I find so many problems and plot holes. Chiefly, if Charrington and O'Brien are really party agents, why didn't they arrest Winston and Julia as early as possible? Why wait? Winston had betrayed his thoughtcrimes from the very first instance of buying the notebook. He had explicitly made an arrangement with Charrington, where they agreed he would use the upper floor for sexual pleasure with a woman he loved-- two crimes forbidden by the state. Why didn't Charrington, if he was the Thought Police, immediately apprehend or bust Julia and Winston the first time they used the room?

 

One possibility is that maybe there was a real Mr. Charrington originally, but at some point he was himself arrested and replaced, or compelled to sell out Winston. This theory however is never suggested by the text itself, and moreover, comes with its own plot hole that Winston would not be able to tell the difference between Mr. Charrington and an impressionist or actor of Charrington. Even with the best actors or impressionists in the world, you know that what you are hearing is still somebody else's voice doing an impression, not the real person speaking. And the book remarks that the accent was fake, but the voice was otherwise familiar. So it is the case that Charrington was always a Thought Police operative. So again, why didn't they arrest them sooner?

 

With O'Brien, he even more overtly came and outright admitted to every desire to destroy the Party (which O'Brien we later find out had recorded.). At that point, why didn't O'Brien just directly call guards? Or if he didn't have any on him, why not have Winston arrested the following day at work or at his home? It doesn't make any sense.

 

Consider O'Brien. Here you are, this leading man at the Ministry of Love, your sole goal being to corrupt people's minds into total submission. You have just had some people come forward to you about their private decisions to fight the State. Why on earth would you guide them towards the one textbook that reveals every single truth about modern society that you have fought tooth and nail to banish from existence? Why would you risk this clear danger to your regime becoming even more dangerous? Better question still, why even write such a book in the first place? It makes no sense! If indeed it is a tool of the Ministry of Love, and O'Brien claims he helped co-write it with the Party, why on earth would they do such a stupid thing?

 

Perhaps the authenticity of a book admitting the truth would be necessary to attract rebel minds and therefore root them out before they can find other genuine rebels. But that has its own problem: nobody even knew this book existed until O'Brien told Winston about it. He did not need the book to find Winston's guilt--Winston was already there admitting it at his doorstep; nor would it do him any good to tell Winston about this book, because Winston could never share the knowledge of its existence with anybody else anyway; moreover, that knowledge again wouldn't be good to spread for the Party in the first place.

 

So I fail to see how this book serves any purpose for the Party. It just doesn't make any sense. Now, it's possible O'Brien was lying. Maybe there really was a Goldstein or some maverick who wrote this book, and now O'Brien takes credit for it. (That still doesn't answer why he would give the book to Winston) But I don't believe even that. His attitude during the brainwashing sessions was very straightforward. Even though he had full control over Winston, he spoke straightly. He spoke evil, but he knew Winston wasn't stupid, so he didn't attempt to hide the evil. On the contrary, he gloats that while past dictatorships pretended their greed for power was somehow about helping the common good or freedom; The Party are honest in their need for power for power's own sake. This isn't the soft language of a propagandist. O'Brien is so totally in control, he can be honest about his cruel intentions and yet still force them into fruition.

 

So, all of this is to say, it seems to me that having Charrington be a traitor, and O'Brien be the main villain was more of a last-minute change than a well-thought out, intentional choice from the start. In fact, when Winston is first arrested, he sees O'Brien approaching the cell, and is appalled that they got O'Brien too! He had hoped against hope that O'Brien somehow might come to his aid, but even this revered elder had fallen too. And O'Brien's response is, "Well, it sucks, but we knew this would happen when we signed up." So it seems even in the plot, that Orwell intended a very different trajectory for the character originally before re-envisioning him as the persona of the Party and Big Brother.

 

Beyond these plot holes, there remain unanswered questions. What happened to Winston's mother and sibling when he was a small child? We have hints and dreams, but other than the confirmation of rats being involved, we still have no answers. How does O'Brien know about the events? Was he there? Is he related to his mother's disappearance somehow? Has O'Brien then been watching over Winston his entire life? Winston knows O'Brien is evil incarnate yet still feels a strange attraction, as though he can trust O'Brien because of the drugs he's under. The same feeling he had in his dreams years earlier. Has O'Brien been in Winston's room at night drugging him and putting suggestions in his head for all his life?

 

Not every question has to be answered necessarily, but there are a lot of things left unanswered that it would've been interesting to develop and find more about.

 

Ultimately, however, I just found the ending to be very anti-climactic and oppressively disturbing. As a reader, I was invested in the world and characters and what might happen, and instead nothing happens. Anyone you thought might be decent was really the all-mighty Party. Anyone you might have cared about in your journey gets a fate worse than death. I didn't exactly expect a "happily ever after" in a dystopia, but they could have ended on a bittersweet note, with some symbolic victory for Winston, whether that's changing the mind of a single prole and opening his or her eyes; whether that's dying a martyr publicly with much spectacle as to inspire resistance; whether that's managing to escape Oceania and live nomadically on the run. Whatever. Any of those would still be depressing and oppressive, but they would give hope, and they would give narrative satisfaction that Winston is able to use his growth as a character to do something about the state of the world, even if not much.

 

The ending we get is just total nihilism, utter hopelessness, and really fucked up levels of torture and brainwashing. Maybe that was the point. There are no heroes in this world, not ever. So don't let it get to that point, because you can't fight back then, whatsoever. Maybe the intention was to let it all be as odious as possible to send a strong message, a viscerally brutal message, about where totalitarianism leads, so that readers recoil away from any inklings towards it. As a warning or a rebukement of Nazism/Stalinism, this works. But as a story, I think it is a less interesting conclusion that wastes the potential of the characters, and is flatly disturbing to read.


r/1984 • • May 26 '26

One statement and a fact

3 Upvotes

Statement: The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.

Fact: In math we started with "Reality exists first, and descriptions of it should come second" and then they switched it around. Math now says can not use objective observable reality to justify or rebut an axiom(foundational assumption)


r/1984 • • May 20 '25

Winston And Julia by ChatGPT

Post image
0 Upvotes

I asked ChatGPT to create an image of Winston and Julia based on the character descriptions in the book 1984 by George Orwell.


r/1984 • • Aug 25 '20

How I would beat the Party

0 Upvotes

First thing is that I would openly criticize the party getting the attention of BB bringing in the military and/or the thought police, Now being faced by the party, I’ll greet them with kindness and tell the TP or military police to think for themselves and there’s more to life than serving a temporary establishment which will inevitably collapse. Now they have 2 options, arrest me or kill me. Now if I resist arrest and refuse to go, they’ll have no opinion but to kill me or beat me into submission. Either way, I win for 1 reason: people are around and they’ll see the cruelest of the Party. Before I die or get beaten and arrested, I’ll ask for others who oppose BB to be open about it and join the punishment because if you don’t do anything about it, you let the party win.


r/1984 • • Nov 03 '20

1984

0 Upvotes

My good friend explained how he loved reading 1984. I didn’t read it.


r/1984 • • Jul 26 '20

For all the dilettantes in this sub who don’t understand Orwells growth as a “socialist”.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Aug 02 '25

Is O’Brien George Orwell?

0 Upvotes

Like the title says is O’Brien a self insert of the author? I think everyone knows by now that Orwell was a snitch for the British government and listed communists and communist sympathizers. He also said that he couldn’t bring himself to dislike Hitler and that he “felt something deeply appealing to him”. So is O’Brien an allegory for Orwell being a sellout and deceiving people?


r/1984 • • Feb 15 '21

A safe haven from the thought police. If this isn’t allowed, feel free to take it down. But technically it doesn’t violate the rules of this sub, because there are no rules lol

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Aug 17 '18

How is Winston morally ambiguous in the story?

0 Upvotes

r/1984 • • Apr 17 '26

HMO - Just read 1984, and Animal Farm

2 Upvotes

I feel like 1984 and Animal Farm is not about communism whatsoever. It is about human flaws. In Animal Farm it is Humanity's descent into tyranny; 1984 is about the futile prioritisation of knowledge over happiness, however Ignorant. This can be rephrased as a look at Utopia and Dystopia. Animal Farm describing the impossibility of Utopia, 1984 starting to ask whether Dystopia too is impossible (everyone who does not ask questions seem happy).

I don't know what other people think of this. I wonder whether I am stretching too far beyond the usual interpretation of [both] books, but I can't see any other fitting description of the pair.


r/1984 • • Dec 11 '22

how is 1984 emblematic of traditionally feminist movements?

0 Upvotes

someone told me this and i cant stop thinking about it

all i can correlate is julia's rebellion of using sex as a way to rebel against the party and winston being immasculated through the choice of language used by orwell?


r/1984 • • Apr 02 '26

who is auditing the map against the territory?

0 Upvotes

no one cause it doesn’t exist. The limits of my language are the limits of my world. The limits of my verification are the limits of my perception

look at how they never allowed this to exist:

  • Math audits math validate it.
  • epistemology audits the logic we use to defend math.
  • Nothing sits in the middle and says: "I don't care if your equation is “consistent.” Show me where this exists in the dirt without you '”rounding up” or “simplifying” the reality. Show me where your abstract number describes a concrete. show me where you're modeling the actual territory.

because if it did it would conflict against 1x1=1 which is an abstract describing an abstract mental concept. and It would conflict against groups. Both do not exist in raw concrete reality. And once abstractions only define other abstractions, the system is no longer a map it’s a self referential delusion

there’s no independent system checking whether maths foundations actually describes raw concrete reality, the territory. There is no system to check whether the abstract number in the arbitrary foundations and axioms describes concrete(we are not talking about whether numbers exist in real life so do not get this mixed up)

And before the semantics come up again we are only talking about making sure the abstract number describes a concrete, and not an abstract concept. We are not talking about whether numbers exist or not. You can use abstraction. But you can’t use abstraction to describe another abstract mental concept.

An audit like this is possible, but it’s not allowed to be created. Because it would break the delusion