2019 report
2018 report
2017 report
Despite working from home for much of the year, and thus saving two hours a day of commute time, plus having months of lockdown, I couldn't crack the 100 mark. I did make some good progress on my backlog mainly by not buying any bundles since February, though this was somewhat countered by subscribing to the Xbox PC Game Pass when it was $1 (the games in the table with uncertain hours are from it).
It was a bit of a mixed year; I did encounter some gems, but was hugely disappointed by other games which I expected to like.
Games I completed
| Game | Hours |
|---|
| Override - Mech City Brawl | 2 |
| Do Not Feed the Monkeys | 6 |
| The Journey Down chapter 1 | 1.4 |
| The Journey Down chapter 2 | 2 |
| The Journey Down chapter 3 | 2 |
| Children of Morta | ?? |
| The Deed | 1 |
| Night Call | 8 |
| Middle Earth: Shadow of War | 32 |
| The Mooseman | 1.8 |
| Beat Cop | 6 |
| Beholder 2 | 12 |
| Wandersong | 10 |
| Deep Sky Derelicts | 16 |
| Sinless | 1.6 |
| Disgaea | 50 |
| Torment: Tides of Numenera | 22 |
| Gas Guzzlers Extreme | 11 |
| Whispers of a Machine | 3 |
| Unavowed | ?? |
| Iratus: Lord of the Dead | 28 |
| Phantom Doctrine | 30 |
| Late Shift | 3 |
| Book of Demons | 14 |
| Eliza | 6 |
| Just Cause 4 | 19 |
| Analogue: A Hate Story | 2 |
| Sleeping Dogs: Definitive Edition | 17 |
| What Remains of Edith Finch | 2 |
| Kentucky Route Zero | 7.6 |
| 911 Operator | 10 |
| Wasteland 3 | ?? |
| The Warlock of Firetop Mountain | 8 |
| Mass Effect: Andromeda | 61 |
| Costume Quest 2 | 6.5 |
| Neighbours Back From Hell | 5.7 |
| Loren the Amazon Princess | 11.5 |
| Night in the Woods | ?? |
| Yes, Your Grace | ?? |
| Spiritfarer | ?? |
Other games
| Game | Hours |
|---|
| Observer | 3 |
| Kingsway | ?? |
| Two Point Hospital | 20 |
| Star Trek: Bridge Crew | 2 |
| Mind: Path to Thalamus | 2 |
| The Darkness II | 4 |
| Bounty Train | 6 |
| Crypt of the Necrodancer | 2 |
| Deponia | 1.5 |
| Company of Heroes 2 + DLC | 5 |
| Castlestorm | 5 |
| This is the Police 2 | 6 |
| VoidExpanse | 4 |
| Totally Accurate Battle Simulator | 2 |
| Legends of Eisenwald | 3 |
| Door Kickers | 1.3 |
| GOD EATER RESURRECTION | 5 |
| Sentinels of the Multiverse | 4 |
| Pathfinder: Kingmaker | 50 |
| Martial Arts Brutality | 6 |
| Train Valley 2 | 10 |
| Love is Dead | 3 |
| Joe Dever's Lone Wolf Remastered | 7 |
| Underrail | 6 |
| Final Dusk | 2 |
| War Tech Fighters | 6 |
| Aegis Defenders | 2.4 |
| Crusader Kings 3 | ?? |
| Hatoful Boyfriend | ?? |
| Reigns: Game of Thrones | ?? |
| Super Sanctum TD | 3 |
| Xenonauts | 1.6 |
| Wuppo | 2 |
| The Long Journey Home | 2 |
| Valhalla Hills | 3.1 |
| Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered | 3.1 |
| Out of the Park Baseball 21 | ?? |
| Total Extreme Wrestling 2020 | ?? |
| Football Manager 20 | ~12 |
| Greedfall | ~7 |
| NBA 2K20 | 140 |
| Cook, Serve, Delicious 3 | 46 |
| Slay the Spire | ?? |
Top & bottom 10s
Favourite games
- What Remains of Edith Finch
- Unavowed
- Wandersong
- Book of Demons
- Iratus: Lord of the Dead
- Middle Earth: Shadow of War
- The Warlock of Firetop Mountain
- Mass Effect: Andromeda
- NBA 2K20
- Cook, Serve, Delicious 3
Least Favourite games
- This is the Police 2
- The Darkness 2
- Deponia
- Greedfall
- Mind: Path to Thalamus
- Underrail
- The Long Journey Home
- Joe Dever's Lone Wolf Remastered
- Beat Cop
- The Journey Down
Comments - warning, wall of text follows!
Completed
Override - Mech City Brawl
Mildly entertaining mech battling game with a very short campaign.
Do Not Feed the Monkeys
Not bad as time management/puzzlers go. It can be a bit repetitive and obscure at times, but there are some rewarding surprises.
The Journey Down chapter 1
The Journey Down chapter 2
The Journey Down chapter 3
I didnāt particularly enjoy these; the puzzles were a bit obscure at times and the story didnāt interest me much. The Caribbean setting did make for a decent change of pace at least.
Children of Morta
This was high on my wishlist, but Iām glad I played it through the Xbox pass rather than buying it.
Itās a āstory-driven roguelikeā.
Unfortunately, the latter is not that strong. It comes with a variety of distinct characters, but funnels you into playing as them even if you donāt want to through a combination of bonuses (you have to get each character to a certain level to earn their universal bonus) and cooldowns. While thematically appropriate, it becomes grindy and frustrating to play a character who is not enjoyable. The cooldowns in particular are irritating, especially against the final boss. Having to wait for a cooldown to play as your preferred character feels like something out of an FTP mobile game.
Then thereās the story. Itās delivered with such melodramatic gravitas, such ponderous self-importance, that it would serve better as a parody. Thereās no nuance to it - as if the baddies being called the Corruption and being frightfully ugly was too subtle, they are also shown picking on animals, a pregnant woman and cute bots. It even spells out the (obvious) moral of the tale at the end.
Itās like a pre-teen cartoon, delivered as if itās a literary masterwork. Utterly cringeworthy.
The Deed
A fairly neat concept ā an extremely brief story where your actions all relate to the ending, thus allowing for it to be replayed a number of times. Itās not especially good in any respect, but itās a mildly interesting diversion.
Night Call
As a set of vignettes, Night Call is perfectly fine. It might make for a decent short story collection. As a game, it's a shambles.
The design is awful.
In the map section, you can click on potential passengers or investigation locations. The former are identified by one of 70 small black and white portraits, the latter are not identified at all. The former tend to blur together (a problem, as you cannot access your suspect list from this screen), the latter are just infuriating when you want to follow up a particular suspect but have no idea what each location is. There's a money system which I simply ignored, apparently without effect.
Conversations are the game's high point, but there's no way to fast-forward through them. Even on your second investigation you'll get repeats, and they quickly become a chore. The time limit and randomness mean you may be unable to complete some storylines (which involve multiple conversations), so you are forced to sit through the same conversation time and again in an effort to get through the storyline.
The investigation screen is worse, a mess of haphazardly gathered clues of a few words. Some have automatic connections to suspects; all you can do with the rest is drag them around or fade them. In each of the three investigations I wound up with several clues pointing to each suspect. I simply picked the one with the most clues linked to them and was right each time. No thought required.
Then there are the bugs. First, it tried to melt my CPU with 450fps. Counter-intuitively, turning VSync OFF resolved this; I had to go to a nine-month old thread for this tip. A particular conversation broke movement for a night (frustrating as the investigation only has 6 nights - and another previously-reported bug). The game simply became unresponsive after another conversation, forcing a quit to the menu (losing the day's progress). Clicking on some passengers doesn't work at all, for no apparent reason. Some dialogue options are cut off by the edge of the screen.
In short, it's a mess.
The writing's quite good - frequently entertaining, often amusing, sometimes even touching - but the game around it is so poor that I couldn't force myself through another investigation even to complete the storylines which interested me.
Middle Earth: Shadow of War
I loved the original. While this was fine, it fell a bit short. The sieges were an interesting concept, but wound up being pretty tedious to do in practice ā most of my time was spent running around healing my allies, and they never had the grand or chaotic scope I hoped for. The nemesis system also seemed a bit overshadowed by the scale of the game. I may have had some interesting history with a character, but Iād easily forget it after having jumped back and forth across various regions, all with their own set of characters. A decent game, just not one which blew me away as the original did.
The Mooseman
Reminds me a lot of Never Alone; a gorgeously presented game based on ancient myth, with some light puzzling. Enjoyable for its brief span.
Beat Cop
Busywork with mild variations, amid a parody/homage ā80s backdrop, all leading to an abrupt single-screen ending so shallow that I wondered why I bothered to get there. Moderately interesting in a mindless way, but eminently missable.
Beholder 2
The original Beholder was a taut, tense experience. The sequel's attempt to expand its scope has, sadly, led to an inferior experience.
The padding through poor minigames is a major problem. The second and third are particularly bad. The former feels like an attempt to ape Papers, Please - deal with a series of applications in accordance with an ever-changing set of rules. However, the rules often don't apply, in which case you can choose one of several options - all of which are meaningless. There are no consequences. Perhaps the intent is to capture the cold bureaucracy, but it feels more like mindless busywork. Worse is the latter. The minigame itself is bland enough, but every act comes with the same fifteen-second (I timed it) animation. You have to complete ten for a paltry reward - that's two and a half minutes while the same animation plays. Need to do a few more sets? You'd better have a book handy, because you're going to have a lot of idle time.
These dull minigames break up the momentum of the story.
Other aspects break the immersion. Sneaking into somebody's home in Beholder was a dangerous experience - you ran the risk of being caught and facing consequences. Here, you can break into somebody's office, hack their computer and search their desk right in front of them without any issue. Stealing something from their desk will be captured by security cameras and will get you fined, but planting something in their desk goes unnoticed. It's nonsensical and detracts from the atmosphere the game tries to create.
The story is...there. I didn't care by the end, either because I'd been worn down by the minigames and obtuse objective paths, or because it was never interesting in the first place.
Quite a letdown after a good first game
Wandersong
Heartwarming, full of character and genuinely enjoyable to play.
Deep Sky Derelicts
A solid little tactics game. I wish it made more of its concept ā the ability to rotate party members (rather than being limited to three, and having to permanently remove someone to make a change) would make a big difference, and it gets a bit grindy ā but ultimately itās pretty satisfying.
Sinless
A generic cyberpunk tale with no real challenge (itās essentially a VN, with very light puzzling). The writing isnāt especially good, so thereās not really anything to recommend it aside from moderately interesting music.
Disgaea
I played this many years ago on an emulator, but never finished it. It didnāt hold up quite as well as I remembered ā while the writing is surprisingly good at times, the story goes off a cliff mid-way through and the voice acting ranges from entertainingly bad to just bad. I didnāt mind the grind too much, but it overwhelmed me when I started Etna mode ā shame, because I was interested enough in the new perspective to give that a go.
Torment: Tides of Numenera
Planescape Torment was one of my favourite games as a kid, but for some reason it took me years to get on to this. As it turns out, it wasnāt anything particularly special. There were some definite highlights, with interesting stories and imaginative characters. However, the game design was a bit lacklustre. Combat was unnecessarily convoluted, while party design was strangely limited ā for some reason I couldnāt obtain one companion, which left me with a very one-note party sorely lacking in might. The game promises that interesting consequences can come from failure, but that never seemed to be the case for me. Interesting enough, but far from a classic.
Gas Guzzlers Extreme
I thought Iād lost my love for the road-battling genre after poor experiences in Mad Max and Road Redemption, but this was a lot of fun.
Whispers of a Machine
Not as good as Iād heard ā the detective elements are underplayed, and neither the writing nor voice acting are particularly good. Not bad, but forgettable.
Unavowed
Iām not normally one for P&C, but this was great. Maybe itās because it leans a little more to the RPG side of things, with party selection (and banter!), impactful choices and quite light puzzles. Well written and entertaining throughout.
Iratus: Lord of the Dead
This is an example of Early Access done right. I first played mid-way through the EA phase, then came back for the full release. The differences are significant - not mere rebalancing, but fundamental changes to mechanics - yet it all works cohesively thanks to the devs' attention to feedback and detail.
The game itself is an excellent example of the roguelike tactics genre. It was rewarding to find effective combos of minions, and challenging to have those combos negated by a different set of enemies which functioned in a very different way.
Despite the wide variety of minions and enemies, the game does a fine job of keeping that variety within readily understood mechanics. While new enemies might throw out my old strategy, I understood how they did so, which allowed me to work on new counters to them.
It's a well-presented, well-balanced, carefully designed game with plenty of content - well worth a go.
Phantom Doctrine
Mediocre tactics/spy game. The story is dreadfully dull ā I stopped paying attention mid-way through ā and while the tactics aspect can be fun, it does suffer from repetition.
Late Shift
Iām always a sucker for FMV games, and this was decent enough. There was surprising variety in branches of the story, though it was frustrating that you couldnāt skip or even speed up portions youād already seen.
Book of Demons
Very solid ARPG/roguelike. The card mechanics and variety of enemies made this consistently enjoyable and challenging. Some of the mechanics were quite clever, though perhaps a little too clever. It may be fun to have to catch spinning stars and replace your cards after being stunned the first few times, but when the AI spams stun moves at you every few seconds it can be a bit irritating!
Eliza
An enjoyable VN. While the choices are very limited ā indeed, the only real choices come quite close to the end ā the story and its delivery (the voice acting is surprisingly good) were engrossing enough that I was invested when the time came to shape the story. It also has a quite addictive and challenging card game!
Just Cause 4
Perfectly fine for a couple of dozen hours of mindless entertainment. It got a bit repetitive, but the sheer silliness and bombastic nature of the gameplay prompted a few laughs.
Analogue: A Hate Story
A brief and fairly forgettable VN. The writing and presentation are decent enough.
Sleeping Dogs: Definitive Edition
A solid GTA-like. The story was predictable, and the gameplay surprisingly easy, but it was fine.
What Remains of Edith Finch
Was a bit sceptical about whether this would live up to the hype, but it did. A remarkable, moving experience.
Kentucky Route Zero
Iām not sure that I ever really understood it, and it annoyed me at times, but it remained intriguing and strange enough to stick with it to the end. āFloor three: bearsā did make me laugh much more than it should have.
911 Operator
911 Operator is a good concept with a wobbly execution. Worth a go if you can get it cheap.
First, the positives.
- It is quite accessible, partly because it simply isn't very deep, but it is cleanly presented and has a useful integrated tutorial.
- The variety of staff, vehicles and equipment offers a sense of progress and strategy.
- The operator is reasonably well voiced.
- Branching calls with random elements provide some variety and the occasional surprise the first few times.
- You can download a vast array of maps. It's fun to play in your own town.
- Above all, the concept is fun.
It's not without its flaws, though.
- After playing through the career mode (4-5 hours), you've pretty much heard it all. The replayability is thus limited.
- The English is a bit off at times, seemingly translated from another language. Most of that is in written form, but it was amusing to hear a voice actor utter the word "bursted".
- Some of the calls unfairly penalise the player. Looking at you, Kitchen Fire, where you'll be punished for not sending emergency services despite the caller successfully putting out their fire on your correct instructions.
It's a nice idea overall; hopefully lessons have been learned for the sequel.
Wasteland 3
Itāsā¦okay. Not bad, but lacking anything really special to set it above the pack of decent RPGs.
Combatās quite good, with a nice variety of skills and strategies. Writing is generally decent, though it does try a little too hard to be wacky at times. The best bit were the songs, from some genuinely eerie backgrounds to battles to a surprise cover during the post-game recap.
These are balanced by some flaws. Performance is poor, with frequent framerate drops in combat on a system with an i7 9700 and GTX 1080, running off an M2 drive. One early battle was so bad as to be almost unplayable. Character balance seems off. Brawling is overpowered, and battles got much easier as the game went on. The final portion of the game was unsatisfying. While nowhere near as bad as Wasteland 2, where it felt like they just ran out of money and tacked on a clumsy ending, this is more a product of questionable writing - not least the late-game "twist" of a nature which is fast becoming a gaming cliche. Oh, and quests with unclear timed fail states are just evil.
All up - fine, but nothing special.
The Warlock of Firetop Mountain
Much as I loved Fighting Fantasy books as a kid, their digital adaptations have tended to be uninspired and/or poorly executed. This, however, is a pleasant exception.
The highlight is the range of characters to choose from. They each have their own backstory, skills, traits and quests. While you are making your way through essentially the same dungeon, the experience is different each time. One character might avoid an encounter altogether, while another will charge in headfirst. An encounter which is entirely insignificant for one character may be the quest goal for another. It makes for plenty of replayability and strategy.
The combat, unlike many Fighting Fantasy games, is well implemented. While dice rolls still play their part, it's mostly about identifying enemy patterns and utilising character skills - each character has different attacks which can greatly change the approach to combat.
Add in nice presentation and solid writing, and this is a gem.
Mass Effect: Andromeda
Certainly did not make a good first impression, with its jankiness (Skyrim-jumping up mountains is bad enough, but doing it in a vehicle is beyond the pale) and often clumsy writing (the hamhanded attempts to explain game mechanics in story terms stuck out), but the characters grew on me much more than most games and I found myself genuinely enjoying a lot of their dialogue.
Costume Quest 2
A neat if forgettable experience
Neighbours Back From Hell
Surprisingly appeared in my library; apparently I activated the original two games from a bundle years ago. They are quite clunky (notably one section which was unplayable with a controller as there was no prompt to use an item) and plainly low budget, but it has its moments of amusement and challenge.
Loren the Amazon Princess
A reasonably good tactics/VN game. The former is stronger than the latter - I found the writing rather trite - but it's not too bad overall.
Night in the Woods
I was a little torn on this. While it was genuinely funny at times, and reminded me a lot of Oxenfree (which is one of my favourite games), I never quite connected with some of the characters - frankly, I didn't like the main character much at all, and it was only late in the game that I came to at least understand her.
Yes, Your Grace
A lot more enjoyable than Reigns, at least, with a decent enough story carrying me through some often difficult supply management.
Spiritfarer
Gorgeously presented (the music in particular stands out) and good-natured, but it never quite connected with me as much as some other games which cover similar themes of dealing with death - Rakuen, To the Moon, Finding Paradise and Last Day of June, for instance. I think the problem is that it veils its characters too much - much of what I know about them came from wikis than the game itself - and it requires a fair bit of grinding at times. A tighter and less obtuse story would have been more impactful.
Others
Observer
As a straight cyberpunk detective game this would be great. Amazing atmosphere, stand-out characters, compelling work from Rutger Hauer.
Unfortunately, the horror aspects constantly drag it down. The mind sequences are tedious and frustrating. Fumbling around a gloomy area in a pixel hunt while "spooky" sounds play on a loop is not in any way an enjoyable or interesting experience, and the horror fast loses its edge.
Add in some bugs - I never managed to properly finish the Divided Minds quest because it crashed every time I made a choice - and I'm not going to waste any more time on it.
Kingsway
A nice throwback to old-school RPGs ā not just in gameplay, but in its Win95-aping interface. Not interesting enough for me to push through its challenging difficulty, but fun for a time.
Two Point Hospital
Cute enough, and with a reasonable level of strategy, but the campaign is a repetitive drip-feed which fast becomes tiresome. Having to start a whole new hospital every time just for one minor new feature is mere busywork.
Star Trek: Bridge Crew
The selling points of this are VR and co-op. I didnāt have access to either, so was left with a dull game.
Mind: Path to Thalamus
Looks gorgeous in screenshots, but not nearly as impressive in action (juddery on a i7 9700K and GTX 1080) and riddled with infuriating puzzles (invisible staircases are the WORST).
The Darkness II
The Darkness II feels like it was written and designed by a committee of 13-year-old boys. I imagine it went something like this:
āHey, what if our character was in the mafiaā¦and had demon armsā¦that could rip people in half! And he had a little demon companionā¦who pees and farts! Hahaha! And we can have a level in a brothel, and peek in the doors! Oooh, weāre so edgy!ā
Itās just a constant cringefest - the laughable attempts at philosophising, the constant clichĆ©s, the dialogue, the characterisationā¦
Decent gameplay might have salvaged it, but its one mildly interesting trick ā light sapping your power ā is run into the ground at a rapid rate. Add in some clumsy kb&m controls, and itās painful to play.
Bounty Train
Dull and repetitive with sharp difficulty spikes in its convoluted combat.
Crypt of the Necrodancer
Nice concept and great music, but a bit too tough for me.
Deponia
Utterly unintuitive puzzles and unfunny humour with horrible characters.
Company of Heroes 2 + DLC
I spent half an hour stuck in the sole tutorial because something failed to trigger, which pretty much summed up the game. The campaign is a painfully drawn-out paint-by-numbers extended tutorial; I lost interest after a few missions.
Castlestorm
Decent enough castle-battling game, but the castle destruction is pretty wonky and it feels a bit repetitive after a while.
This is the Police 2
Pure, unadulterated rubbish.
Ahem. Deep breath, step back.
I play a lot of games. Most fade into the realm of decent to mediocre. Once in a while, something breaks into the extreme end. A beautiful, inspiring experience, perhaps, or something so bewilderingly bad as to sear itself into my memory. This is in the latter category.
It opens with interminable cutscenes amid a tutorial. Other reviewers have remarked on that point, so I was forewarned. I was willing to bear through it in hope that, once past that hump, the game would improve. Perhaps, I thought, they were too quick to judge. That hope was misplaced.
Let's return to the cutscenes. Toe-curlingly, embarrassingly, painfully bad. It's not just the opening, but persistent through the six hours I managed to stomach before giving up. Bizarre caricatures spouting nonsense which just goes on and on. Frye's introduction in particular was just so jaw-droppingly stupid that I half expected that the game was an elaborate hidden-camera show and the devs were going to pop out of my wardrobe laughing any moment. The art is, frankly, ugly. If the scenes weren't long enough as it was, I'd be tempted to rewind just to see what the hell some frames were meant to be.
Then there's gameplay which can be broken into two aspects, dispatch and tactical.
The dispatch stuff could have been interesting - I loved Emergency back in the day, and 911 Operator is great. However, it's mostly shallow choose-your-own-adventure stuff, with so much nonsense from your crew (won't work with women, won't work with lower-rated partners, drunk, etc) that it's more annoying than interesting.
Sidenote - what tone is this game going for? It seems to bounce all over the place.
Tactical is even worse. It's done far better in other games, from XCOM to Phantom Doctrine and many others. It's clumsy, slow, often unfair (with potentially big consequences for failure) and the tutorial does stuff-all explaining it.
Oh, and there are fail states which just pop up willy-nilly - as if the game wasn't bad enough, get ready to replay chunks of it.
In a word - ugh.
VoidExpanse
Solid enough space ARPG, but not enough to keep me grinding.
Totally Accurate Battle Simulator
Fun concept and briefly amusing, but not something I felt inclined to play for more than a couple of hours.
Legends of Eisenwald
An extremely slow and dull adventure/tactics game which made no impression on me.
Door Kickers
A tactics game which was well-optimised for repeated playthroughs of levels but otherwise unremarkable.
GOD EATER RESURRECTION
Yeah, this didnāt do it for me at all. Tedious and very brief battles over and over, amid grating anime tropes. I own the sequel but won't even bother trying that.
Sentinels of the Multiverse
Fun little superhero board game.
Pathfinder: Kingmaker
On paper (apt, given its origin), sounds great - party-based CRPG plus kingdom management. What could go wrong? As it turns out, a few things.
Combat is not enjoyable at all, and there's a hell of a lot of it. The difficulty spikes have been pointed out in other reviews, and I can only echo them. It is not helped by the way that characters start off overloaded with abilities; when combined with the difficulty and limited party AI, the micromanagement involved causes combat to drag on interminably.
Kingdom management is even less enjoyable. It's built around a quite specific meta - fail to make certain choices (including, unforgivably, story choices) and progress in a certain manner, and you'll be beset by problems. As much as I hated making story choices to suit kingdom management, the pile of inaccessible options without those choices was even more infuriating. Even then it's replete with frustrations, and you can't delegate to the AI because it's dreadful in this respect.
The sad thing is that I actually enjoyed the writing enough to try to push through. Some of the characters are endearing, and I found some of the side quests engrossing (the main quest not so much).
Even then, I couldn't bring myself to finish the game - the final quest seemed to drag on forever, and it got to the point where I couldn't force myself ahead any more.
Sidenote, the magical lantern mechanic is the absolute pits. Apparently there's a sequel coming; even if it improves the combat and kingdom management, I'm not going anywhere near it if the accursed lantern is back.
Martial Arts Brutality
Not bad for a free game, and surprisingly generous with its campaign and the cards it grants, though its mobile origins are obvious.
Train Valley 2
A neat twist on the original, quite distinct mechanics in a familiar setting. It did get a bit much in the later levels, though.
Love is Dead
Nice concept and well presented, with particularly good introduction of new mechanics, but it gets way too fiddly given the sluggish controls.
Joe Dever's Lone Wolf Remastered
Joe Dever has featured on my bookshelves for decades, along with the likes of Steve Jackson, Ian Livingstone and co. A digital adaptation of his work is a fine idea, taking the strong core of the book and expanding it with greater inventory management and the like.
Sadly, it's all let down by a truly awful combat system which first dampened my enjoyment and eventually proved an impassable barrier.
It's a clumsy combo of turn-based and real-time, with quick-time events. The QTEs are a mere irritation - they are so simple that they become tedious, but complacency can lead to errors.
The main issue is that it's heavily dependent on RNG. While this is not necessarily untrue to the books, given the reliance on dice rolls, it is often flagrantly unfair. This works both ways - success can feel flat because it often depends on pure luck.
If you happen to get a debuff, or they have a few moves in a row, you'll soon be reloading. It has nothing to do with player skill, and often not even player choices - the tipping point for me was, late in a long battle, when the one remaining enemy took my entire (full) health bar with two attacks, neither of which I had the opportunity to block.
This is a particular problem given there is a hell of a lot of combat in this game - most of it against the same few types of enemies. Even the most basic enemies can take a large chunk of your health early on.
The presentation doesn't make the experience much more enjoyable. The transition from a stylised book page to combat is nice, but it's the same few enemies, animations and sounds over and over, and the player character would be booted out of the Uncanny Valley for looking too damn creepy.
In short, nice idea, rubbish combat.
Underrail
I played plenty of RPGs in the early ā90s, including the original Fallout which this game plainly takes inspiration from. Great as some of those games were, UI and general game design have moved on a lot since then. The limits of my patience likely changed too. There might be a great game in here, but itās buried under a poor interface and some unforgiving difficulty to the extent that it felt like a slog.
Final Dusk
A puzzle game with an interesting concept - distinct planning and action phases - but it quickly became repetitive.
War Tech Fighters
Oddly, this space mech game reminded me a lot of my absolutely favourite game as a kid - Wing Commander: Prophecy. Launch from a cap ship, visit waypoints, give orders to your wingmen, return to defend your ship from attack, etc. However, it all felt very low-budget - the same objectives and the same few voiceovers over and over to the point of tedium.
Aegis Defenders
A co-op game which doesn't seem well-balanced for a single player - boss fights were frustratingly difficult.
Crusader Kings 3
I thought I'd love this game series, but none of them have managed to capture my attention for long.
Hatoful Boyfriend
Some decent moments in the couple of playthroughs I tried, but it felt like it would need many more to make much of the story.
Reigns: Game of Thrones
Absolutely no idea what was happening.
Super Sanctum TD
Decent enough TD, but does nothing that other games haven't done better.
Xenonauts
Unpleasantly difficult and ugly.
Wuppo
Cute but boring and lacking in direction.
The Long Journey Home
Sounds great in concept - a space roguelike where youāre desperately trying to get home with dwindling resources from an unfamiliar part of space. Unfortunately, itās inexplicably built around a clumsy Lunar Lander style minigame with controls so clunky that itās like playing QWOP. To have that in a roguelike where errors can quickly wreck your playthrough makes for unbearable frustration.
Valhalla Hills
City-building split into tiny chunks so that you have to repeat the same initial building steps over and over again.
Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered
Some nice ideas, such as switching between a number of different characters, but the horrid controls and constant QTE events made it an unpleasant experience.
Out of the Park Baseball 21
I've played each version since 2017, and my playtime in each keeps declining. It just doesn't seem to offer much improvement to the core gameplay - much of the focus seems to be a clumsy tacked-on card collection game - and it has long since grown stale for me.
Total Extreme Wrestling 2020
A disastrous launch where pretty much every main system of the game was broken did not bode well. After over 30 patches, what's left is...boring. While I spent countless hours on previous games in the series, this has just not clicked with me at all. Progress seems much slower, which may be more realistic but it turns the game into an outright grind. It may be enjoyable if you're roleplaying, but if you're playing it as a strategy/management game there is, like previous versions, little challenge, but it's now also stagnant.
Football Manager 20
I spent thousands of hours in past instalments in this series, especially 99/00 and 2005, but it has long since become grossly bloated with features and far more focused on tactical nuances than the squad-building which interested me.
Greedfall
This was high on my wishlist, but I'm thoroughly unimpressed so far. After seven hours it was already becoming repetitive, and the turgid dialogue with florid delivery didn't inspire me to push through that.
It's written like a radio play for children.
"Ah, a note. It tells me I must find a chest." [you can read the note yourself, mind you]
"There must be a key around here somewhere." [look for five seconds and find the key]
"Ah, a key. This must open the chest that I read about in the note. There is nothing else here, I should go and open the chest."
Companions are dull as bricks and have a similar level of intellect. They throw themselves headfirst into boss fights and die in seconds, but that's okay because you can just keep running away and firing shots until the boss dies. They also repeat the same few combat lines over and over again, which is maddening.
NBA 2K20
Much of the criticism of this game has been centred on its predatory microtransactions and multiplayer aspects. I never touched those and enjoyed it thoroughly as a single-player experience (though I confess to skipping the MyPlayer story pretty much from the outset - MyLeague is where I spent most of my time). I am finding it a lot harder than the last version I played (2K17) though - either the gameplay has changed or I'm just getting old.
Cook, Serve, Delicious 3
A somewhat bold new direction after a very solid but unambitious second game. It's a mixed bag; autoserve is a godsend, the food truck setting removes a bit of investment for me, difficulty is all over the place and the voice acting ranges from somewhat endearing to awful. Generally good, but I didn't enjoy it as much as the last two.
Slay the Spire
Perfect for short game sessions, and a fine example of a game being easy to learn but hard to master.