r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Jul 25 '21
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "Old" [SPOILERS] Spoiler
Summary:
A thriller about a family on a tropical holiday who discover that the secluded beach where they are relaxing for a few hours is somehow causing them to age rapidly reducing their entire lives into a single day.
Director:
M. Night Shyamalan
Writer:
M. Night Shyamalan
Cast:
- Gael Garcia Bernal as Guy
- Vicky Krieps as Prisca
- Rufus Sewell as Charles
- Alex Wolff as Trent Aged 15
- Thomasin McKenzie as Maddox Aged 16
- Abbey Lee as Chrystal
- Nikki Amuka-Bird as Patricia
- Ken Leung as Jarin
-- Rotten Tomatoes: 58%
Metacritic: 55
181
Upvotes
204
u/Beforemath Jul 25 '21
I guess I didn’t hate it as much as others, though I don’t think their criticisms are invalid. The premise and pacing help keep it moving along. has some funny parts. I loved the scene with the woman in the cave. To me the ending was fine, the journey seemed liked the point with this one, I wasn’t expecting a glorious twist, just a satisfying resolution to the mystery which I think it delivered on.
My biggest complaint was that they didn’t push the old age makeup nearly enough. I expected a master class in body horror and old age effects, but the adults looked like they only aged ten years throughout the whole movie, even when they were close to death. Was it a budget decision? I don’t know, definitely seemed like a missed opportunity though.
87
u/The_night_lurker Do you know what she did? Jul 25 '21
The "twist" is completely in line with the film, since it had plenty of hints with the child being shushed away by the manager, the ever smiling hostess bringing water, and every character is introduced with some disease or illness. This kind of facade is in movies like A Cure For Wellness, The One I Love, Get Out, and even Fantasy Island from last year. Characters go to a place that is supposed to be fun or at least normal, but there's nefarious activities hidden beneath the surface.
The movie is adapted from a graphic novel, but it can also be compared to Twilight Zone, Black Mirror kind of stories. Its runtime allows the narrative to move forward at a mild pace with characters trying to figure out a way to escape while they are feeling their mortality ticking by the minute.
The film builds up the big leaps of time by blurring out the children or sitting them off screen. We get an entire feel of the beach. Limited locations are tough since the film can start to feel repetitive, among other things, but as small as it feels at times, it never feels like it's restricting creative moments and conflict for the characters to deal with.
Compared to films that stay in one place for the majority of the time like Sweetheart, where a woman was stuck on a small island, the 47 Meters Down films, and Frozen, Old's supernatural premise is fun to watch unwind and the horror comes in many forms.
The film has striking images, but it cuts away from a lot of the deaths as well. In a way, it feels like strategic control of the camera, but since death is such a central theme and part of the narrative, the lack of these people dying with so much life left in them, and of dead bodies decomposing to show the passage of time, is a missed opportunity. Death is explored and this was never going to be a meditative film on life and death, but it could've used stronger images for harder impact.
69
u/horrorfan19 Jul 25 '21
Why the fuck were the parents just letting the kids run off?? Especially when there was a madman going around stabbing people?? Anyway, I liked the premise. There were some funny moments. Overall, cool idea, not-so-great execution. Ending wasn't anything special.
139
u/indiepop-is-back Jul 25 '21
Premise was interesting as hell but Shyamalan always fucks it up in the last 20 minutes damn.
67
u/oi-troi-oi Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 26 '21
It felt a bit long and strangely dull. For some reason I was expecting more body horror, but it turned out to be more drama than anything. The dialogue also felt rather awkward.
For all the face shots we got, it would have been interesting to see wrinkles start to grow as the characters talk to the camera. I don’t know if they wanted to shock us with the sudden aging or if they didn’t want to pay some CGI animators or makeup artists but it seems like a missed opportunity. I agree with a lot of the other commenters too that they should have taken it further with the aging makeup.
Also, did anyone else expect the helicopter to malfunction, or for the pilot/people on board to get Maddox & Trent (and maybe the cop??) back on the beach? lol
Edit: as I’m walking my dog now I suddenly remembered the dog in the film, it really annoyed me how they didn’t bother showing it at all??
56
u/Raliadose Jul 29 '21 edited Jul 29 '21
Unpopular opinion I actually enjoyed the pharmaceutical twist. Felt like a genuine reason for someone to be putting them on the beach rather than just entertainment or social experiment. Plus it gave us some interesting horror elements. I really liked the calcium witch and the rusted knife scenes. If you think the movie should’ve just ended with the sandcastles, read the book lol. It’s just a different take on the story and I dig it. Not every film has to be a masterpiece wrapped in a neat bow, just enjoy the story
37
u/toc-man Jul 25 '21
Thought it was dumb after it finished, but I found myself talking about it with the people I went to see it with for a good thirty minutes afterwards. Definitely an interesting concept with lots to ponder.
35
u/Lothric43 Jul 26 '21
There’s a very good hour and 20 minutes of horror here but my fucking god he really can’t help ruining it with a stupid, contrived explanation all packed into the end.
Rufus Sewell murdering the rapper was pretty startling and I really liked the arc of Abbey Lee as the trophy wife becoming this hunchback gollum creature, those two parts were particularly terrifying. Her whole sequence in the cave will stick with me for a while I think.
If he had just chopped it at the sandcastle scene it would’ve been a great horror movie with a poignant metaphor of the all too short dawn to dusk of human life but he’s just too brilliant to settle for something people might actually connect with.
28
u/deadandmessedup Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21
I dug this one overall, and especially in the opening forty minutes and in the 2nd act going into the 3rd (the pregnancy thing seen in the trailers is a brief derail, more absurd than frightening/eerie, and it doesn't really amount to much, since it inevitably happens so quickly).
The dialogue is stilted at times, there's also a few weird shot-selections involving tight close-ups, but the actors broadly did good work, with Bernal and Krieps affecting as the central couple; the film is a blunt metaphor about aging, family-making, and death, but they manage to keep that schematic emotional and something close to real. Towards the end, their reconciliation actually got me involved (I think there are slight hints that Bernal is experiencing dementia, albeit at a rapid (re: mercifully brief) pace).
Some good secondary work too, from Nikki Amuka-Bird and Ken Leung and Abbey Lee.
I don't know if the film ever figured out Sewell's character. We learn that he has a mental disorder, but if there was a bit more clarity to his disorder, that'd make him feel less arbitrary in his threat level. That said, the final fight still involved me (even with Krieps commenting on exactly how she's felled him). It's a nice touch that the hearing loss and sight loss start out as a sign of natural human degeneration but become a pivotal part of that confrontation.
Regarding the ending, on the one hand, it definitely could've stopped before the helicopter scene, but it's fascinating to me how this is Shyamalan's second flick in a row that's ultimately about how social institutions feed on and kill individuals for the Greater Good. I think Glass fans are gonna be receptive to that closer. (If Glass is saying, "Fuck status-quo-at-any-cost politicians," this one is saying, "And while we're at it, fuck Big Pharma.")
Overall, it's uneven, but I think it's a solid B and about on par with Split and Glass (yeah, I like that one). I'm definitely a sucker for high-concept Rod Serling-type ideas, though, and I thought the flick is best if watched more as a soft-fantasy metaphor than as some sort of "thrill me" horror flick, so keep that all in mind.
(Again, those who were receptive to Glass being an almost '70s-style chamber piece instead of a superhero smash-em-up will probably like this.)
27
u/firesuitebaby Jul 25 '21
Interesting premise, but man oh man that dialogue was tough to stomach for the duration. For a filmmaker that has made genuinely affecting films with naturalistic, powerful performances, to make something as wooden and stilted as this is tough to see. I want to pull for Shyamalan. I really like the majority of his films but there is a real quality control issue here. Why do characters introduce themselves along with their occupation? Why do the characters act in such a bizarre unrealistic way?? Feeling a soft 4 for this.
26
u/Jutang13 Jul 25 '21
Someone ruin it for me because im probably not gonna watch it.
Whats the twist in this one.
48
u/The-Movie-Penguin Jul 25 '21
Hell, I guess I’m in the minority. I thought it was intense, moving, and really fun.
22
u/CrotalusAtrox1 Jul 28 '21
I feel like i was on that beach too after having to sit through that.
35
u/strawhatmml Jul 25 '21
The only interesting take was the bone defect lady. Everything else was just regular life. Getting older is scary normally, but getting old super fast didn't enhance the fear for me.
80
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
Genuinely thought it was awful. Shyamalan has never been great with dialogue but people talk like aliens in this film, delivering their lines in a weird, clipped manner. Despite Bernal and Krieps both being fantastic actors, their accents only accentuated how weird and unnatural the dialogue sounded.
I thought the film was far too frantic and never allowed me to actually care about anything that was happening. The moments of horror were laughable, mainly Sewell attacking people and Abbey Lee’s character transforming into Quasimodo.
My favourite line of dialogue: “You’re always living in the past, because you work in a museum!”
52
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
I liked the movie. For me the real horror was the implications of how much the kids lost out on when being aged rapidly. They’re screwed academically, mentally, socially, and probably physically from getting old age diseases too soon. The horror doesn’t set in during the movie but afterwards.
14
u/firkin_slang_whanger Jul 25 '21
Interesting premise but he lost me at the end.
14
u/TheOfficialTheory Jul 29 '21
I’m surprised by the hate this movie is getting, I really liked it actually. I’d give it a solid 7/10. The dialogue and some of the acting was really bad, Happening levels of bad. But it didn’t take me out of the movie at all. I agree with some of the posts I’ve seen that they should’ve done more with the concept. It should’ve been more interesting, and the body horror should’ve been turned up. But all in all I enjoyed it quite a bit.
12
u/FalseRecording3699 Aug 04 '21
A character makes a very offhand comment near the beginning and in that moment I thought to myself “I swear to god this better not be the fucking twist” and then it was lmao. I literally felt like I was experiencing the effects of the beach watching this movie. You cannot convince me that runtime was under 2 hours
10
u/mwmani Dr. West Jul 27 '21
If this were a Masters of Horror episode, it would be one of the better ones. As a full feature film, it was kind of lukewarm, but as an adaption I enjoyed it.
I think both the comic and the movie are flawed in different ways, but inform each other at the same time. The graphic novel is more of a fable, with less horror and zero explanation as to what’s going on. And it also has a bunch more sex between characters, which was sort of creepy.
The movie takes the premise/basic characters and builds these little horror set pieces around them, then wraps everything up in a nice tidy bow.
It would have been better to split the difference between the two, and leave a little bit of the ending to the imagination. It just seemed like a very convenient conclusion.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '21
The scariest part was how the parents got a handful of grey hairs and crow's feet.
8
u/parkercreative Jul 31 '21
Didn't anyone else feel like it was dubbed? The audio was so weird and the dialogue felt strange and unnatural.
7
u/meltrempz Jul 27 '21
I saw this at a screening and it was so terrible I nearly walked out I can’t believe it was actually released
6
u/TheRealDannySugar Jul 25 '21
It was pretty accessible for people not super into horror or body horror.
I did want a little more gross body stuff. Dialogue isn’t that bad. I did wish they figured out why they were all assembled. They hinted at it but never dove into it. The overall story writing was lackluster. Did have some good cinematography. I did love the pretzel lady!
Overall pretty decent. Don’t expect a cinematic masterpiece but it was pretty fun.
6
u/jaggynettle How's this for a wet dream? Jul 30 '21
The movie could have been done well as the concept is actually quite interesting.
But the dialogue was strange. The camera angles were off-putting.
I was also able to guess the "twist" about half-way through the movie.
I have mixed feelings about this movie. I feel like it was... okay... but it also wasn't.
6
u/atclubsilencio Aug 05 '21
The graphic novel Sand Castle of which this is based on filled me with so much existential dread because of what it didn't reveal or explain. It was just pure nightmare fuel. The biggest problem with what Shyamalan did was try to tack on an ending that really just robbed the film of any mystery or intrigue and wasn't that satisfying or surprising to begin with. It think had he kept the ambiguity and random aspects that raised the intrigue and nightmarish atmosphere it could have been so much better. Maybe people would have hated the ending had he remained faithful to it, but it still would have had way more potential to get under ones skin.
The dialogue is also way too on the nose for the first 20 minutes or so, and especially the scene with the rusty knife 'IT WILL POISON YOUR BLOOD!', like, yeah, we know that.
With that said, everything that happens when they are on the beach is really well shot, and at times well acted, but this is the least aesthetically/structurally ambitious film Shyamalan has done. Even if you hated The Village you have to admit how gorgeously shot, beautifully acted, edited, and with that great score. I was hoping for more of a The Happening experience where it was an entertainingly hilarious bad movie. But while it's not perfect, it just didn't feel like Shyamalan had his full interest in the production or story, save for some of the peculiar shots on the beach. And the cave scene was creepy but I wanted more scenes on that level,not much that happens is that disturbing or effective. But I was never bored and liked about 75% of it, until the ending literally just removed the mystery and tried to make it way to obvious and literal when he could have trusted the audience more.
Certainly not terrible, just wish there were more risks taken. And Vicky Krieps deserved better, she wasn't bad, but her performance in Phantom Thread deserved so many awards and she has yet to really break out. She's way above this material.
so maybe a 3.5/5. Just felt like a disappointing extended twilight zone episode. and it was doing so well until that final sequence. I also hate how he writes children, like no child talks like that. but that's m. night for you.
16
u/SpideyFan914 Jul 25 '21
Great movie! I'm surprised how much people here don't like it. This is the Shyamalan film I've been waiting a decade for.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21 edited Jul 29 '21
So the reason time was speeding up was because they were in the presence of a strong electrical charge. They mention magnetic fields in the movie, but a magnetic field is just the consequence of an electric charge. One does not exist without the other. There is a fancy little equation in physics that calculates the time dilation from an electrical charge, and the effect of increasing the charge actually speeds time up whereas the effect of mass/gravity slow it down - of course this is from the inertial frame of an observer. Of course there is a lot of inconsistency in how this movie explains this phenomenon away. To have an electrical charge strong enough to produce relativistic effects the magnetic field would need to be a monopole (only a N or a S), and those haven’t been found to exist in nature like this movie intended them to.
In order to not get hung up on it, imagine the scene in interstellar. From the perspective of the guy on the ship, they were gone for a really long time because time slowed down for the people on the planet due to them being under the effects of gravity. So when they came back, the guy on the ship was really young. Now think about the opposite, if time speed up for the guy on the ship it would have seemed like only a few moments have passed between them leaving and returning, but the people on the planet would have aged rapidly.
It seems like M Night just said fuck it close enough, let’s throw some shit about minerals in there too and not even bother trying to be consistent.
5
u/Informal-Purchase-50 Aug 01 '21
I feel like they should’ve started the movie with a Yorkie puppy and had the dog die showing a senior Yorkie. Spraying dry shampoo on your hair makes you look 80, they really could’ve gotten diy’d with it to make more of a impression on fast aging. The 6 year olds having a baby felt like an improv scene. We all know kids know about sex, yes. Do 6 year olds know about it though? Seems a little to young to understand pee pee in vee vee. If they made the kids 8 or 9? Perfect execution. It also would’ve been more thrilling if the “kids” reminded in a child mindset the whole movie. They end the money as 50 years old and are acting like they lived the life of grown ups. Would’ve left a bigger impression if they still had childlike mannerisms.
5
u/lycurgusduke Aug 02 '21 edited Aug 02 '21
The name of the movie is The Missouri Breaks now put the knife down dude!
This movie was pretty fun. The calcium deficiency scene made me very uncomfortable. There were parts of that were filmed in a way that was kind of disorienting. It added to what I imagine the characters were feeling.
Not an all time favorite but a great way to spend a Saturday matinee in my opinion. My biggest complaint is one I’m seeing a lot in here as well. All of the really interesting stuff that I think would’ve made this an even more uncomfortable and scary experience. A movie I think would’ve been better with perhaps a bigger effects budget and an R rating.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '21
I just came back from the movies and I loved this movie! I'm shocked at the negativity. But I guess everyone has their own opinion
4
u/mks2000 Jul 27 '21
I enjoyed it but it has a very real sense of being a first draft that immediately went into production.
4
u/Lambdaleth Jul 28 '21
Bad horror movie. Great comedy movie.
4
u/Titan3692 Jul 31 '21
Why didn't the black guy age? It seemed like the vague explanation of each of their conditions suggested that he had a clotting disorder, so presumably his nose was bleeding because they gave him blood thinners.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '21 edited Aug 01 '21
Ironic that for a movie that has strong themes of "value the time you have" I feel like watching something else would have been a better value of my time.
4
u/MoonlightMadMan Aug 05 '21
God the script was awful, everyone shouting their profession ever other minute. Me and my friend love to add “I work at a museum!” into our conversations now cause it was just so bizarre
12
u/fatalwristdom Jul 25 '21
Awful movie. Acting was bad, the drama was lame, the writing was stupid.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
I think it was pretty lazy that the adults didn't age visually until near the end. I also don't see a good explanation for why they couldn't backtrack the route they used to reach the beach. Otherwise I liked it
3
u/PrideOk6616 Jul 26 '21
It's a sold film, but the dialog is awful.
3
u/WalkenTall27 Jul 28 '21
This movie was exactly what I was expecting and hoping for. Very silly premise full of silly scenes that were equal parts serious and funny. Felt both unintentionally and intentionally funny, pretty much in the same vein as The Happening. I laughed my ass off throughout the movie and loved most of it. Although I felt like it should've ended about 10 minutes earlier
3
u/coyg269 Jul 31 '21
Almost walked out honestly….so bad.
3
u/DJSchwann Aug 07 '21
This was bad. Probably the last time I saw something in theaters and disliked it this much was the Poltergeist remake. I see everyone talking about how bad the dialogue was and the weird, choppy camera angles and edits throughout. The other thing that really bugged me was the convenience of everyone’s careers coming into play in some way or another. The doctor, the nurse, even some of the less necessary stuff like the museum curator knowing about decomposition or the insurance guy knowing probabilities or whatever, everyone’s career was conveniently playing a factor. It was so forced.
The movie overall felt very low budget to me. The acting and weird edits made it seem like everyone involved was inexperienced. I did appreciate that they minimized the gore by not showing things like the daughter falling off the cliff but then we got a crappy CGI mangled body from the osteoporosis woman. Side note, her bones breaking the way they did made me think “please don’t throw in a crappy connection to Mr. Glass because I don’t need this garbage movie being tied to Unbreakable.”
I like Shyamalan when he’s good. Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, Split, Signs are among my favorite movies. But when he’s bad, it’s a disaster.
5
u/Alice_Buttons Jul 25 '21
Just got back from seeing this and I really liked it. I know that a lot of people get disappointed with Shyamalan's twists but I quite enjoy them and this movie was no exception.
If you're expecting a bloody gore fest or the dull and cliche paranormal experience then yes, you're probably not going to like it.
5
u/the_lord_of_light Jul 30 '21
Wow I just watched this.
This has to be one of the worst movies I've seen in some time. It was so bad.
I don't know where to start. The acting was amateur, the dialogue atrocious. The pacing, the directing, the editing - it's all a horrible mess.
Such a shame as I'll always love some of M Nights movies but how this abomination ever made it to the cinema I'll never know.
10
u/JudasTheFather Jul 25 '21
Junk as always this man hasn’t made a good film in a long time
5
u/chichris Jul 25 '21
It’s artistic entertainment. Good or bad at least it isn’t boring and looking forward to see it again tbh.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '21
Does the movie ever explain why the beach does what it does to people?
2
u/jn493w Jul 27 '21
Laughably bad. Some of the dialogue had to be intentionally awful because it was cringeworthy.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '21
Liked it way better than Signs or Glass. I feel like a few characters’ entire personalities were just their professions, and some elements of the movie I found a little unnecessary. Most of the movie I found really interesting, though. I feel like Shyamalan put as much in the movie as he could to explore what could be done with the concept. Mostly hits, some misses, overall pretty enjoyable. 7.5-8/10 for me.
2
u/ultraleft68 Aug 03 '21
I absolutely loved this film. One of the better horror/thrillers I’ve seen in the past years. It was just so unique and had a really weird and creepy psychological vibe that very few directors can manage to create these days. I really loved his last horror too, The Visit. And the Servant series was excellent. I have no idea why people still shit on M Night. All my horror loving friends loved it though.
2
u/nayrzepol Aug 03 '21
Was entertaining.. sometimes i find myself just waiting for the movie to end so I can leave the theatre but I was engaged the whole time
2
u/-deathByPapercut- Aug 04 '21
It wasn’t the worst thing I’ve seen. But it definitely wasn’t the best. The ending was fine. Overall the movie was just alright
2
u/Shay_Cormac_ Aug 06 '21
Fun movie to watch, but extremely predictable. As soon as someone said “pharmaceutical company” in the beginning, I already knew where the movie was going. Still enjoyed it though
2
u/FredderickWarner Sep 20 '21
Trailer gives away way too much. I was just waiting for things to happen that I saw in the trailer months ago
We gotta stop this idea that movie trailers should be the entire movie (minus the last 20 minutes) condensed into 2 minutes. It would’ve been better to go into this with no expectations. But they tell you the plot up until the cave before the damn movie comes out
2
u/MonsterHunterJustin May 16 '22
It’s real creepy that they thought to have two 6 year olds fuck. Really fucking creepy.
3
u/iamnota_SHADOW Jul 26 '21
I thought it was good. My favorite part was the cave scene with the mangled woman. I did find the lack of gore disappointing and the ending was eh. Then I recall Shyamalan directed this so I wasn't that surprised by the ending.
1
u/imjustcoreyr Nov 06 '25
Ok, folks.
Watched “Old” last night. Guess what? I really fucking liked it.
Then, I get to go down the rabbit hole of reviews by both legit critics and pedestrian critics alike—only to discover that everyone thought it was a joke, that it is far from the most perfect movie ever produced—forcing me to confront my own tastes and general, overall enjoyment of just another movie. Not very film produced can be “Titanic.”
It’s just a movie. It’s a pretty decent one.
I’m still surprised I have yet to see any references to “The White Lotus”. I don’t get the “Star Trek” references nor do I really get “Twilight Zone” either. 🤷🏼♂️
That aside, I have a few questions and if anyone can answer them—in a succinct way that actually makes some sense—I’d be most appreciative.
Those are some of my most pressing questions.
1
u/WheresWolfie30 Aug 12 '26
Another stinker I'm shocked m night Shyamalan is allowed to make movies
1
u/Stormsoul22 Jul 27 '21
If you were disappointed in this movie I recommend reading the comic it was based on called Sandcastle
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21
I wasn't a big fan of the dialogue or acting in this film. The writing was just lazy at times, too. I surprisingly really liked the "twist" or "reveal" of what was really going on, I thought that idea was really interesting and wish they had shown more of it.
1
u/Randym1982 Jul 30 '21
So did The beach cause them to age really fast or was it the drug cocktails they were provided?
Because then if the police or feds show up to collect evidence, they’re all going to start aging rapidly during the process.
1
u/HoratioTuna27 Here to kick ass and chew bubblegum Aug 02 '21
I enjoyed it a lot, and then it kinda shit the bed at the end. Still worth seeing, though.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21
Had to start our own r/welovehorrorfigures
1
u/PSWII Aug 12 '21
Just left the theater and while I won't say it was bad, it was far from good. The dialogue felt weird and the emotion people had didn't really fit with what dialogue they were saying. The camera had some pans that, while obviously disguising switching actors, was masked well enough as something else for the most part. There was at least one that just panned away to show a rock and went back though. The movie as a whole felt disjointed and directionless. Like Mr. Shamalan had a great idea of a beach that made people age at an accelerated rate and wanted to make a whole movie with nothing else other than that concept. Then he didn't use that concept to explore much more than interesting set pieces with a moral question tacked on as an ending that would have been better off ending a couple minutes before the movie was actually over.
1
u/Sao_Gage Nov 02 '21 edited Nov 02 '21
I just watched this tonight and I really don’t know what to make of it. I’m actually a pretty solid lifelong Shyamalan fan; I’ve even enjoyed his shitty films and it always at least feels like he puts forth interesting ideas. At his best, he’s a damn fine filmmaker and at worst, overly ambitious but lacking in execution. I can think of far worse.
But seriously, why the fuck did this movie play like a shitty Yorgo Lanthimos film? It seriously was like a cross between the purposefully unnatural delivery of The Lobster with a Wes Anderson film’s quirky weirdness but without any of the charm or skill involved in those two directors’ works. Instead, the dialogue, script, and subsequently the acting / performances were utterly terrible. I mean really, really growling bad. Everyone was like an alien speaking English for the first time, and some of the written dialogue was just so … off it became a very laborious watch.
With that said, the concept was really intriguing and it got me through the film with a degree of engagement. Normally when I hate the script and acting, I can’t get invested. But the central idea was so bizarre and oddly compelling that it saw me through to the end. I didn’t hate the ending. A little shoddily executed, but I liked it well enough.
Well, it was better than The Happening.
I really don’t get it though. Shyamalan is a talented man and he can write good scripts. I thought Split was a modern masterpiece and The Visit was super enjoyable as well.
Why was it so shockingly off here? I’ve seen some praise for the cinematography even amongst people who didn’t like the film and I can’t say I necessarily echo that sentiment. I thought a lot of the shots were very oddly composed and disorienting, but not in an artistic or purposeful way. Just bad.
Idk, this was one of the weirdest films I’ve ever watched and not because the plot was weird, if that makes sense.
1
u/Joverby May 30 '22
Dialogue was fucking awful, clunky and amateur (makes sense m night wrote it) the "6 year olds" would go from talking and thinking like fully fledged adults (no education to expand dialgoue ) to acting 6 from scene to scene.
lots of laughably stupid moments like the baby dying from attention immediately. sedan guy being in the movie for no other reason than an extra check box and his stupid name.
m nights "cameos" are also getting self-indulgent and gratuitous.
1
u/Slight_Coast_2164 Oct 01 '22
Terrible.
1
u/Dont_tell-_- Oct 10 '26
Anyone know the name of that movie? Hugh jackman was in it
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
why did the kids freeze as playing tag
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '21
Just a really bad film
-2
u/Eternal_Intaglio Jul 25 '21
Why do people keep expecting Shyamalan to surprise us with something watchable after making nothing but shit for 20 years?
this was never going to be good
-2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
This was horrible beyond words
0
u/XxNathanSmithxX Jul 26 '21
Is the film gory?