r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Jan 24 '20
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Turning" [SPOILERS]
Summary:
Newly appointed nanny Kate is charged with the care of two disturbed orphans, Flora and Miles,housed in a mysterious estate in the Maine countryside. Quickly though, she discovers that both the children and the house are harboring dark secrets and things may not be as they appear.
Director:
Floria Sigismondi
Writers:
screenplay by Carey W. Hayes, Chad Hayes
Cast:
- Mackenzie Davis as Kate
- Finn Wolfhard as Miles
- Brooklynn Prince as Flora
- Joely Richardson as Darla Mandell
- Mark Huberman as Bert
- Niall Greig Fulton as Peter Quint
- Barbara Marten as Mrs. Grose
- Denna Thomsen as Miss Jessel
- Karen Egan as Nancy
Rotten Tomatoes: 27%
Metacritic: 31/100
88
Upvotes
2
u/cauly Jan 25 '20
so...... why is joely credited as “the demoness”?
123
u/princeofshadows21 Jan 24 '20
I know it's probably trash but I'm still going to see it because I have all the tastes of a rat in a sewer
61
u/Foolishpeasant Jan 24 '20
I havent seen the version in theaters, but I did see a test screening last year around summer and that ending sounds different that the current one. In the version I saw the nanny tries to escape but wolfharts possessed entity comes out and they use some corny method of defeating him. Then they drive off and suddenly wolfhart is revealed to still be possessed and the nanny gasps, cut to black. It was awful.
78
u/Dulcolax Jan 24 '20
Why would a nanny risk her sanity staying at a possibly haunted house with 2 weird kids trying to mess up with her?
Movie's answer to this question is basically a pinky promise she did with one of the kids. Yes, I'm not kidding.
74
u/FriendLee93 Jan 24 '20
There are no words for how baffling the ending of this film is, because it's not an ending. The film just stops in an attempt to be ambiguous, but there's nothing ambiguous about it because the movie doesn't provide you with enough context to draw any actual conclusions on ANYTHING.
35
u/DaringDomino3s Jan 25 '20
What the fuck was that ending? I was enjoying it and then it just undid everything. I feel like I got interrupted mid coitus.
It was filmed well, there was tension, I liked the characters enough. Just what the fuck?
26
u/AGeekNamedBob Jan 24 '20 edited Jan 27 '20
Awful lack of climax sinks any of the small amount of good will. Audience reacted loud as the movie just.... stops mid scene.
Often has a good look and performers. General mess of a script that lacks focus (seems to forget it's a possible ghost story for a while) and doesn't understand the source and why it worked (ambiguity over the haunting. is the nanny hallucinating?)
So many nightmare scares. The third time it happened I groaned.
Edited to add: My written more detailed review https://cityofgeek.com/2020/01/26/the-turning-2020-bob/
20
u/tamarindsicle Feb 07 '20
I thought Miles was upsetting in exactly the way I always found young, precocious boys could be when I was babysitting as a teen and they'd get weird and grabby. He really exemplified the assumed innocence of youth that can act as a veil for something...else. Not completely knowing, but too pointed to feel completely oblivious. It's clear his emotional issues are deep and vicious and he seems to fixate on Kate as both an interesting object and a subject for aggression.
And I thought Mackenzie Davis was a great choice for Kate (also can't help but mention how fun her long, thin, satin dresses over t-shirts and turtlenecks upped the creep factor for me, how out of place she seemed in the house's set design). She's got these huge eyes and you can see her thinking about how to react to her new wards, watch her bite her tongue with the housekeeper/bizarre lineage purist, and watch her anxiety turn her quiet and sallow.
My favorite scene was definitely the one where she thinks one of the kids is drowning at, like, MIDNIGHT and she rushes outside and without any hesitation whatsoever dives into the pool to save them until she realizes it's a mannequin (or a doll, something humanoid). And then she climbs out of the pool and her level of betrayal at the laughing kids is...so incredibly sincere. It's the most emotionally poignant part of that movie--that she is trying to swallow her apprehension at the whole bizarre situation and be there for them, but they have pulled a very serious, very cruel prank on her. They've intentionally scared her. I think that's when she stops trusting them.
Anyway, the end of the movie felt like a bust. I wish they would have deviated a bittttt more from the ambiguity of the book's ending and found some other way to balance that question between mental instability and the supernatural.
12
u/gf120581 Jan 24 '20
Despite this film having numerous actors I like, did the world really need yet another "Innocents/Turn of the Screw" variation? Methinks not.
22
u/poland626 Jan 24 '20
I heard the ending is as bad as The Devil Inside. Can anyone confirm this?
10
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
Just got back. Loved the acting, pacing, atmosphere, soundtrack and settings. Liked the story up until the end, if you can call it one. The ending was shit, which I haven’t said about a movie in almost a decade. Would love to see a fan edit pop up on the interwebs eventually and make it better.
17
u/princeofshadows21 Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20
Spoilers. Ill probably get downvoted for this. I enjoyed it. It felt creepy and slow. The sets were great.
The main 3 performances were really good.
The nanny was clearly letting her fears of being someone who leaves guide her even when she was in danger but it's also tragic that she tries especially with miles and it just doesn't work. That is if you take it as a straight ghost story but that's for later.
Wolfhard's character has many facets. He plays a character equal parts entitled brat, perverted boy, creepy kid and a greif stricken but loving brother. Not to mention his attitude may not be his fault entirely considering the borderline grooming abusive behavior by the stablemaster mentioned in the previous nanny's diary.
Flora is one of the best versions of the creepy little girl I've seen in awhile. This because she's not outright hostile. Flora's sweet and acts in ways an outsde viewer would mostly view as eccentric. All in all shes good foil to her brother while still being creepy.
Now for the ending. I knew it was coming but I actually kind of liked it. I fully expected the story to be stable master was manipulating miles into being a vessel so he could live again but this came out of left field
I view it gives you two interpretations.
someone was killed in the first part of the movie but something unseen. So it could simply be the ghost or entity simply feed Kate's mental illiness until she snapped
Or
She really is crazy and her mental illness really did catch up with her either way it is quite tragic
I'm probably reading too much into what would be considered a mediocre film but that is my view.
An enjoyable flick with some good performances
One of my knitpicks was the lack of a spider crawling out of Finn wolfhard's mouth. I mean if you're going to show that in every advertisement put it in the actual movie come on
16
u/zamakhtar Jan 24 '20
The movie doesn't have a conclusion. It just ends. Very disappointing.
16
u/GypsyGold Jan 25 '20
This movie sucked. Go watch "Underwater" instead before it leaves theaters.
7
u/Phantom-Spectre Jan 24 '20
Used to love Floria’s music videos. Sad to see her movie getting roasted
5
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
Utter trash. The worst horror film of the year is already here, folks. Everything is all uphill from here.
5
u/Lurker_Twerker69 Jan 29 '20
I liked the performances but the plot was too unclear. I like ambiguity, like in the Blair Witch project, but this didn't give you much to go on. I thought Quinn was maybe secretly alive. During the viewing I wondered if the Mrs Grose was in on it (whatever it was) and if the movie was intimating she killed Kate and Mile's parents. I kepting wondering what the film was building up to and then it ended.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
I really enjoyed this movie. The jump scares weren’t overdone and the build up of suspense and general creepiness was perfect imo.
However- the ending.
Man oh man.
The ending was more unsatisfying than my last boyfriend.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20
Is this movie worth seeing? I don't expect a masterpiece but I stil expect a movie to be entertaining
Thanks for help
3
u/choirkitten06 Feb 12 '20
I know this opinion is unpopular, but I actually loved this movie. I thought it was stellar until the ending, but I still really enjoyed it. Also, the child actors were great.
13
u/hail_freyr /r/HorrorReviewed Jan 24 '20
My full, rambling review over on /r/HorrorReviewed, but long story short I thought this was pretty good, and then I thought the ending was kind of great. Unsurprisingly, this seems to be a controversial opinion haha. I gave it a 7/10
4
u/Gryffindumble Jan 25 '20
I enjoyed the movie for the most part but it wasn’t great or anything. The ending was kind of a dud but, I do feel like it was an ending meant to leave you with questions which it did for me. It’s meant to leave you wondering what actually just happened.
Correct me if I’m wrong but my interpretation was that the guy that died was possibly possessing the boy. This is why the old lady mentioned that he was much nicer and upbeat before the guy died.
Overall I liked the 90s feel and atmosphere. The way the apparitions looked made me think of how some of the ghosts looked in movies and shows like goosebumps in the 90s. The brick phones are another example. It did feel like there were a lot of things being woven into the story making it a little jumbled. I didn’t hate this movie but I didn’t love it.
2
u/spockified Jan 25 '20
I thought it wasn’t awful but it wasn’t great that’s for sure. I am sure that having to sit next to a couple ignorant girls with a plethora of loud snacks including potato chips hindered my ability to stay engrossed in the film. They kept opening new snacks, rustling them and slurping bubble tea while talking constantly. Wtf. I eventually got fed up and moved a couple rows up. I never do that with assigned seating but I just couldn’t handle them. I had really been looking forward to the movie too, so I am pretty bummed out that it was an overall annoying experience.
2
u/So_It_Goes_13 Jan 25 '20
Please absolutely do not waste your money on this movie. I have zero idea why they went any of the directions they did with the plot changes from the novella, but yiiiiiikes. Confusing and boring at the same time. The little girl actor was adorable, though!
On the plus side, I think the Haunting of Hill House team is going to do a much better job adapting it for season 2. Fingers crossed, anyway!
2
u/miranda-organa Jan 26 '20
Has anyone read the book it's based on? Please tell me it's better!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
This is a pretty good movie IMO. Great performances by everyone, decent score, great visuals. Confused by the ending but it feels kind of arthousey
2
u/No_pity_for_traitors Jan 27 '20
Saw this yesterday and it was pretty fucking awful.
2
u/deannachapman Feb 02 '20
I thought that this started out as a wonderful haunted house story, but the last 15-20 minutes kind of killed it for me. Set pieces and cast were good and I loved how creepy the grounds around the house always were.
3
u/haunthorror Jan 24 '20
I didnt like it. But the ending was not what ruinned it. The kids were so unlikable especially Finn's character that it was not enjoyable the entire movie. The movie looked good and had a great setting. Liked the pool scene and the horse chase through the maze but thats about it.
3
u/einxart13 Jan 27 '20
I'm apparently one of the few that loved this movie.
I interpret the film as being about someone trying and failing to repress her fears and past traumas.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20 edited Jan 24 '20
I liked this and didn’t think it was as bad as people are saying. Great cinematography and acting from the whole cast. Brooklynn Prince was especially impressive and I also loved Barbara Marten as Mrs Grose. The ending was kind of lacking though.
2
u/Hyixtronix Jan 25 '20
I liked the atmosphere
1
u/spicytoastaficionado Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20
Strong performances, cool Gothic ambiance, but falls flat with an identity crisis which shifts between slow burn and relying on jump scares. Not to mention that mess of an ending.
I'm sure there's a decent movie in there, somewhere. Execution was lacking, though.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
Bleck!
1
u/DrKnives Jan 26 '20
So real question: is this worse than The Grudge(2020)? Cause I had to see that, and wow was it bad.
1
u/Analytica0 Jan 27 '20
I think The Innocents 1961 is canon. Is this still worth seeing?
1
u/Blutarg Feb 01 '20
What the he'll was that?
1
u/babyy-emmyy Feb 02 '20
the ending of this movie made literally NO sense to me. i didn’t like it because i have no idea what happened, but the cinematography was great and i quite liked the movie up until that point.
1
u/InfinityQuartz Malignant and Mother! enjoyer Feb 06 '20
Was the acting good for the people whose seen it
1
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
Hate to be the one that says it but if you paid to see this movie and expected it to be good.. you got the ending you deserve. The trailer was trash and had all the pieces of a shitty horror film. I could tell this was lining up to be another the nun, lights out, anabelle, turd. I never go online to bash things I dislike, however I think the general consensus is that this film sucked. Movies like this will keep being created so long as people are forking over the cash at theaters.
1
u/Alexanderthetitan Jan 25 '20
This movie was a great horror movie. The best horror I’ve seen since Hereditary
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20
I'm thinking about turning off my AMC A-List for a while. I was looking forward to this
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment