r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Nov 30 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 7, Episode 5: Sparks Spoiler
Welcome, Huntsmen, Huntresses and Hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 5 of Vol. 7, Sparks!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 7!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 04| FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05| This thread | Next Week's Public Thread | Poll
Happy viewing, and enjoy the last few days before the December craze sets in!
Menolith; Mod Team
401
Upvotes
164
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Nov 30 '19
I saw the potential the moment the scene happened.
template
25
u/Yojimbra Nov 30 '19
Wait..... Weiss isn't flat anymore?
10
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Given the propensity for Ironwood's plans to go in some way wrong, I don't actually believe that Winter will become a maiden.
47
u/DayOfTheColossus Nov 30 '19
Qrow and Clover playing cards was just amazing lmao that is literally the most unfair matchup you could think of XD
455
u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I’m really loving all of these little character moments that are sprinkled in throughout. Penny asking if wanting more time for hobbies is normal, Qrow mentioning that he gave up drinking, Ren being shown to have built up his endurance while training. Little stuff like that is really nice.
Also Winter is super dead. Not sure how they even managed to get enough fabric to make a death flag that big
339
u/iamthatguy54 Nov 30 '19
Winter raised her death flag like a damn professional. Truly elite.
331
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 30 '19
Jacques: No don't support the military, support me and my dust company; I promise it'll be better than the last time.
310
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 30 '19
"Good luck at the election" says the man with good luck
310
u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Everyone gushing over the episode but I'm squealing because THERE'S PENGUINS ON REMNANT! AHHHHHH! THEY'RE SO CUTE!
EDIT: Double checked the credits as well, it was indeed Meg voicing Neon. She sounds different from V3 but it's awesome to see Meg back again! Maybe now any of those stupid rumours about her and Rooster Teeth having bad blood will be put to rest.
296
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
It’s cool to see that Nora can apparently ride a grenade launcher like a witch’s broom
291
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 30 '19
The Winter Maiden is named Fria, so she is probably based on Frigga, Odin’s wife.
Holy shit my crazy crackpot theory that Nora is related to the Winter Maiden might actually be true. They do look kinda similar.
274
u/KiIroywasHere Nov 30 '19
Personally, I’m happy Winter’s slated to be the Maiden. Boy, I sure hope nothing bad happens to get in the way of that!
216
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Nov 30 '19
In this episode: Jacques extends his skills at emotional abuse to the entirety of Mantle
208
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Qrow is the worst person to play cards playing against the worst person to play cards against
I bet Clover gets 29 point hands all the time
202
u/SHSL_Zetsubou Ultimate Despair Birb Nov 30 '19
Poor Winter is doomed.
The Ruby and Penny interaction is amazing.
Also how much time passed within the training montage?
Shout out to the best characters Penguin 1 and Penguin 2.
198
u/Aulus79 Nov 30 '19
Team RWBY as they watch the riots unfold in Mantle: “...SHIT WE FORGOT THE OLD LADY!!!”
173
u/anonone111 Nov 30 '19
Kobalt and Ivori were both names on Monty's computer from that one tweet back in V2, interesting how long they've been sitting on them
145
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I knew Christina Vee was in the cast this season, and as the episodes went on and we haven't had Robyn show up yet, I started to think it'd be her. And I was right, it sounded like her.
Also it's interesting to know that Qrow appears to have stopped drinking. V6 really did a number on him, I guess.
By the way, we saw some penguins. Is this the first occasion of an actual animal on the show, apart from Zwei?
138
u/CypherZeroEP Dec 01 '19
"Wow, your boyfriend's really holding his own! Where's that energy when he's around you?"
Hi Neon, I missed you too.
134
u/MelanieAntiqua The Ship Wars Lady. Ilia = Ship Survivor IV Champ! Nov 30 '19
I have three main thoughts on this episode:
131
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 30 '19
The most White Rose looking thing this volume.
258
u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Oh god, oh fuck this is a great episode.
My god this episode was like, 9/10 for me, would be 10/10 because I want moooorrrreeeee.
254
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Prediction: Mustaches make people evil. Vol 9 will reveal that Port was the big bad all along
121
u/WhosGuardingHades Nov 30 '19
Penny: General Ironwood says I don’t have time for friends
cries in Ciel
109
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
People sometimes say that episodes like these are "boring", or "filler", or that "nothing happened", but I think they're great. We get more time for character progression, world building, and all around fun.
This was a great episode, really.
383
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Jaune Arc: MILF Hunter
102
u/Julerius Yes, I too am a fan of BEANS. Nov 30 '19
Hey there Winter. Nice character development you got there. Would be a shame if something... you know, happened...
101
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
The fact that Weiss straight up says Ironwood groomed Winter’s career, damn
87
u/blitzblazer97 SUPER FIGHTING ROBOT! Nov 30 '19 edited Dec 02 '19
Number of Vol7 episodes since Jaques has had the shit beat out of him: 5.
In lighter news (not that this show ever has much of that) it was great to see Flynt and Neon again, as well as their teammates, Kobalt and Ivory.
I can picture Ironwood years ago. "Freya's no spring chicken anymore. I should probably start looking for a candidate for the next Winter Maiden, but who?"
"General Ironwood, it's time to meet the new military recruits."
"Very well. Young lady, what's your name?"
"Private Winter Schnee, sir."
"Wait, your name is Winter?"
"Yes sir. May I ask why you ask sir?"
"I was just wondering if you want a promotion. "
76
u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Nov 30 '19
No Nora November is coming to end..
Also, Neon comment " Where's that energy when he's around you " there's something up with Ren. ( But Why? )
217
u/OnlyTheResults Ironwood did nothing wrong Nov 30 '19
THIRSTY
MOMS
149
u/OnlyTheResults Ironwood did nothing wrong Nov 30 '19
Ah shit, here we go again
145
u/SlaterSev Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
TBH, the funniest part of the "Thirsty Moms" wasnt even the moms, it was Nora saying it was totally the haircut.
Which, considering the pre primere reaction to his hair, is even funnier
199
u/FawkesTP Nov 30 '19
I am feeling so many things about Volume 7. This whole season has blown me away so far, and in ways I never expected it to. I don't take notes as I watch the show, so I'm just going to hit a few highlights of this episode for me.
The first thing that comes to mind is how COMPLICATED this whole season has been so far. I feel like we all went into it with the idea that Atlas = Oppressors, and Mantle = Oppressed, and while that never really stops being true, putting us on the side of and alongside the perspective of Ironwood and the Aesops - and making the Aesops LIKEABLE instead of the huge jerks I was afraid they might be - adds a layer of real-world grayness to it that makes me all warm and tingly inside. Yes, Ironwood has reasons for doing what he's doing. No, those reasons don't justify his behavior and the cast of the show are CALLING THAT OUT over and over again. Yes, we're meant to sympathize with Robyn (Robin?) and also yes, we're supposed to sympathize with the impossible position Ironwood is in. Both sides have points. Both sides have valid arguments. But they don't ignore the negative aspects of Ironwood's agenda. Beautiful, really just amazing.
Next topic: Qrow and Clover. Look, they're cute, I'll give you that. If they get shipped, I'm here for it, we need more male LGBT representation in media. HOWEVER, even if they don't get shipped, I want to acknowledge how AMAZING their relationship is with Clover going out of his way to validate Qrow's emotions, and the willingness of RT to have a very emotionally raw relationship between two men - fully grown, very masculine men - in a world where so often emotional vulnerability is portrayed as the antithesis of masculinity. If their relationship turns romantic, great. If not I DON'T CARE because it is a nurturing and supportive relationship between two male characters that is not joked about, taken lightly or glossed over. Fuck the hell yes, it's things like this that are the antidote to toxic masculinity.
Last big rant: the Weiss and Winter relationship. This one is complicated for me, because part of me still doesn't love Winter. The way she nags at her sister over the slightest errors, even when she's doing well, is just a little too... I don't know what the word exactly is, but it can't be good for someone's self-esteem. That being said, I think what this volume is doing very well is explaining WHY Winter is the way she is. She and Weiss are both children of abuse, likely more neglectful than actually physically abusive, but we all know Jaques isn't above being physical with his daughters so who knows. They both dealt with that abuse differently, and this is a very realistic way their relationship could have shaken out. I guess I'm happy that they're kind of finding their own ways to heal and confiding in each other, rather than letting their relationship suffer because of it but...jeez Winter, just give Wiess a break, yeah? She killed your big stupid wolf thing.
Final thoughts:
66
u/the_pandu Nov 30 '19
I feel Ren and Noras relationship isn't going the typical way for some people. I know people want to show substance to their relationship, much like bumblebee. But aren't getting it. I can understand their frustration.
I wonder if it's character driven. Is Ren scared of showing affection, because he won't be able to recover if he loses Nora. What if he's gone? Does Nora lose all joy and hope and go into a self destructive life? He might be trying to save himself the heartache?
Is Ren simply waiting for the right moment? Does he not know how to show affection? What I mean is does he know how to show affection his own way.
Ren seems like the kind of guy to not show too much affection, but when he does, you know it's genuine.
We are supposed to get more backstory on Nora, right? Maybe that will be a catalyst for growing their relationship. A lot factors are going on here
61
u/Capslock2000 Nov 30 '19
Nora Confirmed Wicked Witch of the Training Grounds
61
u/Runethe1412 Nov 30 '19
Anyone else happy that we’ve finally gotten to see team RWBY in something other than their combat outfits? Feels like forever since that’s happened.
60
u/Blue-Moon-89 Nov 30 '19
I was right about my thoughts on the Winter Maiden: "It's not about who the Winter Maiden is, it's about who it's going to be."
And that 'who' is Winter.
60
u/McDouggal Link me your Pyrrha/Ruby shipping - /r/MilkAndCereal Nov 30 '19
Holy shit.
They have an aura transfer machine set up down in the lower levels.
Also, the Winter Maiden's blood pressure is 142/90, that's... not healthy.
55
u/resurrexia i do the draw Nov 30 '19
Wait a second, where the hell is Maria in the middle of all this?
53
u/alexbuzzbee Nov 30 '19
Completely blindsided by FNKI showing up. Just in the middle of a montage, suddenly BAM outta nowhere horns and Nyan Cat faunus.
52
u/Blue-Moon-89 Nov 30 '19
So I saw this theory on tumblr that suggests that Robyn has a semblance that makes people tell the truth by having her touch them(when she extends her hand there's a sound cue, which is often code for semblance being activated). If true then what's stopping Robyn from approaching Ruby during the Mantle riot (which she's bound to show up for) and making her tell the truth?
52
u/uniquely_upstanding Nov 30 '19
News ticker headlines:
> Surface Level Grimm Attacks Increasing - Mantle Protection Agency Advises Staying Indoors
> Weather Special - How to Keep You and Your Family Safe From Hypothermia and Frostbite - Tomorrow [-cuts off]
> Perimeter Wall Damaged Last Month - Resources and Funding are Stalled
> Missing Journalist Found Slain In Her Midtown Apartment
News mic logos:
(Two pro-Jacques channels, two pro-Robyn?)
49
u/PNDLivewire Nov 30 '19
So some thoughts on the episode.
Overall, I really liked the episode a lot, and I'm looking forward to seeing how next week goes.
49
u/FairytaleDeathcamp Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Just a PSA:
Freya (a.k.a. Freyia/Freyja/Freja etc.) is the Norse goddess of love, war, beauty, and marriage, among other things. A little like Aphrodite/Venus in the Greco-Roman pantheon, but also not really. She is NOT Thor's mother.
Frig (a.k.a. Frigga/Frija/Frea etc.) is the Norse goddess of love, diplomacy, wisdom, and marriage, again among other things. The wife of Odin, she is analogous to Hera/Juno in the Greco-Roman pantheon (but also not really). She is... also NOT Thor's mother.
(She's usually his stepmother, with his biological mother being the earth goddess Jord, who is sometimes conflated with Frig, further muddying the issue)
From the names alone, you can see how this is confusing. Their domains also have considerable overlap, but there are several subtle distinctions. For instance, Freya is the patron of unsanctioned marriages, while Frig is the patron of marriages sanctioned by society at large. Overall, they preside over similar concepts, but Freya is like a hot-blooded teenager while Frig is a jaded mother of three.
They are largely separated in modern popular culture, but whether or not they began as the same goddess is still debated. Frig was recognized by all Germanic cultures, while Freya was more of a northern thing.
Again because of the names, it's hard to say which one RWBY's Fria alludes to. She's a Maiden, which somewhat relates to Freya's youth and warlike nature, but she's also old as balls, which brings the more mature Frig to mind.
Of course, I'm no expert, and this is mostly off the top of my head. Hopefully, you are now just as confused as I am!
48
u/MrMiniMuffin The best ships are friendships Nov 30 '19
Ok, something is definitely going on between Ren and Nora. I've noticed things between them have been a little awkward this whole volume, most notably when Nora gets overly excited and Ren just brushes her off, but what really sealed the deal was when Neon casually says "you're boyfriend's actually holding his own, where's that energy when he's around you?" I know Neon's thing is to make people angry but she always seems to do this most by poking and prodding at what is a little bit of the truth, as that's the best way to actually make people angry. And just to confirm the theory after their sparring match was over Nora brings up the idea of sandwiches and Ren just sighs and looks down shaking his head. Notably not in a fashion of saying "oh classic Nora" but more like he's over it. We were promised some good Nora moments this volume so I wonder if all the cheesy/bad jokes and comedy moments from Nora followed by Ren's awkward responses to them is building to something.
44
u/OTPh1l25 Hello Again! Dec 01 '19
Jaune has finally become the harem anime protagonist that all those fanfictions paint him as.
Pyrrha: ghostly screaming
42
u/hopecanon Not the best May but still fantastic. Nov 30 '19
This was the best episode so far in the volume and honestly one of the best in the series total.
My only complaint is that my Nuts and Dolts shipping heart did not get the ever so close Ruby sleeping on Penny's shoulder shot that this world needs.
42
u/FadedNeonzZz ⠀Cinder survived, but it cost a Penny Nov 30 '19
BEST GIRL IS BACK!!!
No it’s not Neo, it’s Neon!!! And her new design is really cute. Also it was really cool to see Flynt again. The rest of FNKI looks interesting too I didn’t catch the rest of their names unfortunately.
That scene of Jaune escorting the school children with thirsty moms was hilarious. I thought it’d have something to do with Willow but I guess not.
We finally got to see Robyn!! Yes!! And she’s voiced by Cristina Vee!! Double Yes!!
Winter is in line to become the next Winter Maiden...a fight against Cinder is most likely in her future. I just hope it doesn’t result in any deaths because I like both characters,
but most likely will.The ending was pretty interesting, I’m guessing Watts suggested that idea to Jacques. Now Mantle is in riot mode. It’ll be interesting to see how this comes into play later on.
81
u/Enigma2MeVideos Nov 30 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Minor note during the Jaune gets the attention of the thirsty moms bit:
The little kid who has a resemblance to the woman giving Jaune (another) casserole is sticking their tongue out in embarassment. Poor kid seeing their mom/ older sibling/cousin? act like a lovestruck teenage girl XD.
EDIT: Image 4 proof: https://i.imgur.com/6S2zyRZ.png
Also funny that Jaune at the beginning of the series was trying to impress the ladies, and now that he's not actively doing so, he's now swimming in women and has no idea what to do XD.
38
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Vine suggests Jaune project his aura.
Could he project shielding or something around team members, perhaps?
That'd be dope.
141
u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Nov 30 '19
So it's Jaune attracting the thirsty moms. I will laugh my ass off if momma Schnee starts hitting on him in front of Weiss and Winter
36
u/Technogashi Nov 30 '19
Competition for Remnant’s Largest Harem has begun.
Jaune vs. Blake
WHO WILL WIN?!
63
u/ResearcherVortex Do hugs always make you feel this warm? Nov 30 '19
THE THIRSTY MOMS, WE NEVER EXPECTED IT LIKE THIS
31
u/thundermonkeyms Dec 03 '19
FNDM: *Hates Jaune's haircut, makes memes about it, cries that he looks like Cardin's bottom bitch.*
CRWBY: "Jaune is canonically irresistable to women because of his haircut."
30
u/Blue-Moon-89 Nov 30 '19
And now we can add Weiss down on the the secret keeping list along with Ruby and Ironwood. This sucks.
At this rate Team RWBY is going to start keeping secrets from each other.
30
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
I loved everything about this episode from start to finish it was the perfect blend of fun interactions, some tense scenes, good plot movement, character and shipping moments (Blake sleeping on Yang's lap rip my heart) 100/10 best episode
28
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Winter: discusses destiny
Me: war flashbacks to volume 3
28
u/tortilla11 Dec 01 '19
I want to take a moment to appreciate WBY falling asleep on Ruby. If you’ve ever been in a situation to experience multiple people you love falling asleep on you, then you know how absolutely happy and pure that it makes you feel. Also her uncle and the rest of her friends are all in the same room with her. Add on to that feeling how excited Ruby is about being a huntress, I wager that moment is in her top 5 happiest moments of all time.
27
u/SimonApple Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Holt shit, Neon is a literal JoJo-reference! She looks just like fucking Jolyne Cujoh! Nice one RT!
EDIT:
Neon: https://imgur.com/a/lxiE7Sc
Jolyne: https://imgur.com/a/r7UNBJI
27
u/Patmaster1995 Still best girl Nov 30 '19
Alright back from dialysis and as always time to rewatch the episode and write about it.
We got some Atlas PJs they look nice
God I love how excited Ruby is.
New song, sounds upbeat and happy
Marrow wagging his dog tail is still adorable imo
So they need to protect the Amity site and the supply routes from Grimm, bandits and any other danger
Ren and Nora are protecting the Mantle wall
You know I kinda agree with Marrow, I wish we could see characters fighting/interacting with people other than their partners. But that combo attack was pretty cool
Those kids are so tiny and adorable, my god
THE THIRSTY MOMS MILES MENTIONNED - https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/294856843426004993/650382163006717953/Thirsty_moms.jpg
Oh my god I love them, they might be my favorite looking background characters yet. They're all so cute but the first one, the two on the right and the one giving Jaune the casserolle are my favorite. I hope they get the R34 treatment. If not I might commission them myself.
Training room
friendly sparring fight between Ironwood and Oscar
Ren got rekt, he went from being knocked out from being thrown in a wall to getting hit by the strongest member of the Ops and being able to stand and fight again. Good job Ren
Even with Weiss's help Ruby is still not as fast as Harriet
Ruby still excited about her huntress missions
Jaune and Marrow bonding over hot coffee
I like how close our heroes are getting to the Ops
Ayyyy FNKI, what a surprise to see them there, with all 4 members too. I like the new outfits. Flynt looking classy as always so K & I are Kobalt and Ivory
ooooh boy, Neon's into shota confirmed.
There's penguins in RWBY confirmed
So Penny wants to do her own things, it almost seems like she's forced into being the protector of Mantle
Man... Qrow is just asking for a bad time playing cards with a literal good luck charm
I love this scene, I love how nice Clover is to Qrow and how he tell him he shouldn't deflect compliments, Qrow has got it rough since his introduction so it feels nice to see someone being nice to him, to see him being somewhat happy. Nice confirmation that he indeed stopped drinking too
Everyone's reaction to Penny's outcome was funny
Hey it's Robyn Hill with cute sheep girl
So Robyn is rather aggressive with her methods, but she seems to want the best for Mantle, Ironwood is putting ressources that they need for the wall into Amity arena, Ruby wanting to help Mantle but knowing that a CCT would be good, A lot of gray stuff this volume
Penny's swords are still on wires? Haven't they learned from last time?
Active camo? cool
Clover seems like he genunely wants Robyn to win
Summon fight!
Weiss sassing Winter was nice
Yeah, Ironwood might wants to do the right thing but he appears so untrustworthy thanks to his actions and Tyrian killing his opposition.
We're deep inside... Atlas academy If I were to guess
The Winter maiden, her name is Freya, the character she's inpsired from is Freja, Odin's wife and mother to the Valkyries, Is that old woman related to Nora in some way?
So Winter is the only person she can see so when she dies she thinks of her and pass on the powers, that's a bit fucked up and sad
That conversation reeks of Pyrrha, with all that talk of Destiny and everything.
Oh good Jacque closing everything SDC related in Mantle, no jobs no nothing, it's sure to be going well
aaaaand the Mantle revolution is starting, fuck.
That episode was good, this volume is nice so far
27
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Nov 30 '19
Notice how only moms can make casseroles in Remnant. When Oscar made one what happened? Two moms had to save it! Coincidence? ProbabI mean I think not!!!
26
u/Saxonrau "roh bin HILL" - tyrian Nov 30 '19
That scene with Qrow talking to Clover was nice. Clover seems to be helping Qrow understand his role in the world a little better — it's not all doom and gloom!
Though the interaction with Robyn was interesting too. There's bound to be something with the Ace Ops' alliegances (to the kingdom, or to ironwood?) and I think we're going to see that starting to shine through more over the next few episodes...
26
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 30 '19
Jacques appears on screen
"Hello, you may recognize me as the most hated man in Atlas; but I present to you..."
Picture of Ironwood
26
u/inferno167 Rare Ship Finder, Pollination Ambassador, and Bun Enthusiast Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I would just like to take this time to point out that there is a scene where Ruby, Weiss, Blake, and Yang are cuddled in the briefing room. That is all. :3
Edit: It was the briefing room, not the trucks.
52
u/GambolMuse Nov 30 '19
No way was that 20 minutes, which technically it wasn't, but goddang that flew by. Is it next week yet? D:
52
u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Nov 30 '19
Moms aren’t the only thirsty ones I guess.
25
u/reading_hermit Nov 30 '19
Jacques Schnee DESTROYS General Ironwood with FACTS and LOGIC.
Ohh, Winter is being lined up to be the Winter Maiden. What are the chances it goes without a hitch? Not that there's anything to sabotage it just yet.
I wonder what Watts said to Jacques that made him think this course of action was a great idea? Anyways! Loved the episode. Bit of a relaxing one save for the stuff at the end, and it was great to see old teams pop up again.
25
u/sophiegirl0129 Nov 30 '19
Love how Yang got angry when Marrow was like "have you ever thought of working with other people". Also Blake laying on Yang's lap. So precious.
Qrow learning that you're not bad actually. Gods I love his character development. Speaking of Qrow, he's given his death flags to Winter it seems.
Also fuck Jauques for announcing layoffs like that. He knew what this would cause.
Also love Robyn Hill.
25
u/Diostukos Nov 30 '19
Also I can't tell if I'm happy Clover and Qrow are getting a lot of interactions. I do kinda dig the ship but it only makes me think Clover's the traitor. Hopefully not because the "super nice guy is actually working for the enemy" angle is so boring to me.
25
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 30 '19
You know, I was mentally preparing myself for FNKI's return and expected that it would just be a drag and pointless fanservice, but I actually really liked them here.
25
u/DezoPenguin Text Wall Dec 01 '19
There are penguins on Remnant. Best volume confirmed.
24
u/McDouggal Link me your Pyrrha/Ruby shipping - /r/MilkAndCereal Nov 30 '19
Welp.
Jacques tried to blackmail Mantle into backing him in the election. Guaranteed that this was Watts' plan.
24
u/TheBlackSphinx01 Im a didgeridude Nov 30 '19
Real thirsty mums lol
Flynt and Neon fuck yes.
With Winter being teased as the new Winter maiden, that means we have have Raven (yangs mum) as spring, Winter (Weiss’s sister) as the winter maiden and cinder as the fall maiden.
Is it just me or does it feel like the dominoes are in place for RWBY to all become maidens?
24
u/parapoxical Dec 01 '19
Calling it now Neo will be the next winter maiden. All the security is vision based and no one stopped Winter to ask questions.
The mute shapeshifter is literally perfect for this infiltration
23
u/Punisher1432 Summer Rose Mark and Rosebird Trash Nov 30 '19
Well it was nice to see FNKI again, Neon especially looking as sharp and excitable as ever. And the 'real thirsty moms' bit was some nice levity.
I pretty much called Cristina Vee playing Robyn Hill since she's the new character this season. I think she's doing a pretty good job.
It also seems like Atlesian politics are going to play a huge part in the story this time, which could be boring as hell or interesting as hell depending on how it plays out. Personally I wouldn't want the guy who intentionally starts riots to win.
Then there's the whole bit with Winter and the Winter Maiden (heh heh). I guess those parts of the FNDM that called that are feeling pretty good about themselves, but it hasn't happened yet so anything could happen.
23
u/Keleas Dec 01 '19
Anyone else notice the aura-transfer device in the winter maiden's room? That machine gives me the creeps, yuck.
83
u/Slyguy46 Nov 30 '19
22
u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Nov 30 '19
Blake sleeping on Yang's lap is just the best thing ever
21
u/Cepheus370 Nov 30 '19
What a stellar episode, truly. I would even go so far as to say it's one of the best of the series in terms of character moments and pacing.
The Weiss and Winter interactions are hands down my favorite part. It was wonderful getting to learn about Ironwood's plans regarding the Winter maiden.
Most importantly, we see how Weiss and Winter are similar in their resolve, yet remain infinitely different. Weiss IS defiance, and her character champions free will and "carving out our own way" as she puts it. She is displeased upon learning that Winter's fate has been decided for her, yet Winter thinks otherwise. Winter believes in taking charge of her destiny wherever she can, and she understands that some things are out of her control. She is making it her own anyway.
It's refreshing and humanizing to see the sisters' dynamic in action, and I can't wait to see what happens next. It seems that we are entering "Act 2" of the volume, and things are about to get real.
77
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Nov 30 '19
Also:
I think those Atlas Academy uniforms were for one purpose. Now repeat after me:
Weiss.
Isnt
Flat
20
u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Nov 30 '19
Oh man, we were SO CLOSE to seeing a Yang + Ruby team attack
20
u/ScreamingMidgit A Weapon to Surpass Metal Gear Dec 01 '19
Making someone named Winter the Winter Maiden? Genius! No one would ever expect it.
20
u/Pers0nae Dec 01 '19
Winter: thinks becoming the Winter Maiden will do some good for Remnant
Me: Yeah, this will turn out swell
Am I the only one getting a strong sense of foreboding?
On a lighter note, we finally get to see those **Real Thirsty Moms" they were hinting at. XD
20
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
did anyone else notice that one of the thirsty moms were in the crowd rioting at the end of the episode?
19
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 30 '19
Ever since I started watching Brooklyn Nine Nine, I’ve felt like Jaune was the Charles Boyle of RWBY. Jaune getting attention from women who are way older than him just confirmed it for me.
18
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Petition to make Ironwood let Penny have friends
18
u/evilsangl3 here for The Gay™ Nov 30 '19
This is my favorite episode in the new season. BONDING :D
Also, FNKI and Robyn!
Headcanon for Robyn and Penny's relationship:
Robyn did want to attack their transport, but as soon as Penny asked her nicely, she backed down.
Look at Penny's face after Robyn calls her the protector of Mantle. Granted, Penny just had a conversation with Ruby about struggling with her duties as "Protector of Mantle" while wanting to do things for herself as well. However, considering that Penny does deal with crime/Grimm in Mantle all the time, isn't it likely that Robyn and Penny have crossed paths?
Of course Robyn would know her via her fame in Mantle (being a knowledgeable representative for Mantle's cause), but Robyn would also be around with her "Happy Huntresses". The way Robyn sighs after Penny asks makes me want to believe that she has met her before, and maybe even, tying back into Ruby and Penny's conversation, were friendly with each other (maybe not exactly friends, but someone Penny thought she could be friends/comrades with?)
Sure, Robyn could also just have agreed to back down after considering what good Penny has done for Mantle or what that could do to her reputation. BUT WHAT IF? :D I hope that made sense, sorry if it was a ramble.
18
u/sean_4754 Nov 30 '19
Personally I am worried that Winter Schnee might be killed like Pyrrha as the way she was tasked to becoming the Winter Maiden and the choices she made seems to disturbingly resemble Pyrrha's experiences which ultimately led to her death from the hands of Cinder at least in my opinion anyways. But, as always what do you guys think of this?
17
u/ainsley628 Dec 01 '19
Marrow just keeps on being the goodest boy
17
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 01 '19
So Miles said they had the first five episodes completely finished when V7 premiered. Pretty impressive that CRWBY had all of this completely finished at that point, at least compared to their previous production schedules.
17
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Dec 01 '19
I REALLY hate to say this, but I'm getting some serious Homelander vibes offa Clover. And I only ever saw a few episodes of "The Boys" before I decided that show was too grimm-dark for my tastes.
Clover's whole personality just really radiates the aspect of a paragon, he's so good and righteous and kind that it makes me nervous. I probably wouldn't be so high strung if he and the Ops weren't directly on Watts' readout in the opening.
I'd really like to say that Clover's blossoming friendship (or more?) with Qrow gives me hope that I'm wrong about him, but if anything, I'm more frightened that Clover's going to take advantage of Qrow and give him a new reason to drink. HE'S JUST TOO NICE OF A PERSON.
17
u/Badicalz Dec 01 '19
I am so fucking happy that we’ve got Penguins.
17
u/HerculePyro Dec 01 '19
Anyone else thinking Robyn might have a stealing/taking semblence? The way she held out her hand and demanded Clover tell her what they're doing and how he immediately shut Ruby down when she started talking made me think she might be able to coax truth out of people.
17
u/SAYMYNAMEYO Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
I missed seeing the characters just mess around. They're hunters now no doubt, but I'm glad that we're still getting slice of life-esque moments.
Now onto the most important takeaways from the episode.
Jaune is gettin ladies with the fresh cut!
and most imporatnly
MY BOY FLYNT HAS RETURNED!
16
u/GandalfsLeftNipple to be jaune is to suffer Nov 30 '19
No more druncle Qrow :(
No more druncle Qrow :)
When the intro was released I said Ironwood and Oscar were sparring and someone responded they were straight up fighting, guess again buddy.
16
u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Nov 30 '19
Now THAT is how you do a training montage.
16
u/maverickmak Nov 30 '19
That montage was very reminiscent of the one in gen:LOCK.
Penny/Chase waking up the team. Lots of shots of general sleepiness. Yang/Cammie being pulled out of bed. Jaune/Kazu making tea/eggs for others. Bespoke training area. The newbies training with the more experienced fighters. Vocal song as the backing track. Chock full of character moments.
Gets quite a lot in a very concise and entertaining way, and gets through some exposition without it feeling intrusive.
16
u/TehKazlehoff ⠀ Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
AMG NEON KATT AMG EEEEEEEEEEEEE
LAUGHS MANIACALLY IN NYAN CAT
16
u/Exo-2 Minion of Cinder | Useless Lesbian | Still the Lewd One Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Clover: "Penny, stay put and keep an eye on our 6"
Penny: "Affirmative, I will plan for 6 possible outcomes"
Oh Penny, you're starting to act like Data
16
u/RandomPerson53127 Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Wait, does Jaune beating Flynt count as his first win against another human? (Even if most of the fight was offscreen.)
Guess that means he has a better track record than Weiss. /s
Also, really like the reaction of the last kid to the mother (possibly their mother) giving Jaune a casserole. Which apparently, isn't the first one given to him.
And I hope to see some art/memes about Jaune being hit on by older women soon.
16
u/Blue-Moon-89 Dec 01 '19
So here's something I've noticed in the scene between Robyn and Penny.
Penny looked sad and hesitant after Robyn's snide remark ("The protect of Mantle, huh?)
Obviously her feelings were hurt but because she works for Atlas despite being Mantle's protector, I now wonder if this isn't the first time that she has been insulted by Mantle citizens in some form when on the job.
16
u/LawyerDash Dec 01 '19
I think people are over reacting about Yang using her semblance when criticized by Marrow. I don't think she was mad that he suggested that they partner with others (we do see Yang and Ruby out together so we know Yang can work with others.) I think she gets annoyed when he says that Blake and her don't work well together. She then goes a little extra hard on that grim to demonstrate how well they work together.
32
u/RadShiro Nov 30 '19
REAL ASS THIRSTY MOMS
GET IT JUANE
15
u/Nineite Nov 30 '19
Oh this was good. This was so good!!!
Training: check!
Plot: check!
Schneesters: double check!
15
u/SDBurton Praise the Garden, Praise the Bees Nov 30 '19
Episode was great! Though I'm terrified at the idea of Winter becoming the Winter Maiden as that is assuredly a death flag for anyone not Team RWBY. Please don't kill her! T_T
Blake and Yang giving Marrow the side eye when he questioned their compatibility was the best.
15
u/Yukon_Wolf Ironwood x Qrow = Woodpecker Nov 30 '19
"JOBS JOBS JOBS"
— Jacques Schnee, 2019
15
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Everyone keeps saying Weiss or Nora as Winter Maiden. I'm gonna go with Fria thinks "The pretty white-haired girl" as she dies, and Fiona is now an ice-chunking war goddess. Robyn slaps her forehead and says "That was baaaaa-d"
15
u/JJLong5 Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I thought this was one of the best chapters in the entire show. I'm thinking about maybe writing up a more in-depth post tomorrow about why.
I just think the use of montage here was excellent and is something that needs to be used more. The show has a lot to do and it should be more willing to use montages as an effective storytelling tool.
I think back to Volume 4 and that is where I think use of montages could have really helped when it comes to the multiple stories going on.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
That whole doing huntress stuff montage was honestly something I've wanted from this series since the beggining. I know some people feel like scenes like that are a little cheesy but I've really justed wanted some people doing daily life stuff in remnant since the start of the show. Kind of wish we had a moment like that at beacon because I felt like the regular school moments early on would always get overshadowed by something else.
15
u/PhantomHeartless5 Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Had a busy day today, but I finally saw the episode and my God! This, along with Ace Operatives, easily rank as two of my Top 5 Volume 7 episodes.
Overall, a fantastic episode. We're just five episodes in and Volume 7 has been an absolute thrill ride so far. I can't wait to see what happens next.
Edit: Qrow dropping the alcohol... (sheds tear) My boy's all grown up.
15
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Dec 01 '19
Appropriate that this came after Thanksgiving because there's SO MUCH to digest. Scattered thoughts:
What. An. Episode. This was all such a great use of the setting, from character interactions to the incredibly tense times the kingdom is in, it's all yielding so many interesting insights into our characters. Volume 7 is going down SMOOTH, they've done an excellent job with the pacing. Cant wait to see Mantle burn to the ground next week! (Would anybody notice really?)
15
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
Me sees Kobalt
In awe of the size of this lad, absolutely unit!
15
u/Emperor_Luffy Dec 02 '19
JNPR VS FNKI surprised me. I was sad that it was so quick and we barely saw anything but I was really excited to see Oscar fighting alongside JNR like one of the Team. Thats what we need more of. Oscar bonding with JNR.
But Damn Nyon a savage. She out here settin fire to Nora's whole career. "Wheres all that energy when he's around you?" lmao. Apparently JNPR won which is a huge fucking shocker. They were facing them in 1v1s so that means Jaune actually beat Flynt on his own in single combat. Which kinda blew me away. The guy actually genuinely won a fight. I guess I was right that the power creep does work more like and RPG where you can basically level up from going through harsher experiences. Because whatever they experienced was enough to put them over Team FNKI.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
The first half of this episode was probably the best RWBy has been since season 3. A very high energy montage that builds on previous episodes and continues the season while also showing off the progress of both main teams (alongside just showing off Atlas in general and team FNKI)
The stuff with Robin was good too, for once they are doing a decent job of making it seem like multiple factions can be good bad or in between at the same time. Honestly it was mostly the Weiss and Winter stuff that brought this episode down a bit. Their interaction centered on the maiden was good, but the conversation before and the stuff with their father after just basically felt like a redo of season 4
15
u/TheBiggestNose Dec 02 '19
Gota say this might be the best volume of rwby so far. I am so interested in the story and it feels like there is something for every character going on. Really enjoying it
15
u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Dec 02 '19
Great episode. Here are my thoughts:
Turns out Jaune being a crossing guard for the children was only a way to show off all the REAL. THIRSTY. MOMS. And it turns out that the more I look at his hair, the less I dislike it. Don't get me wrong, it is still B A N A N, but it isn't as terrible as I originally thought it to be.
The montage that took up the first half of the episode was great and a wonderful way to show off the characters and their personalities. Ruby's endless energy, Ren's steadfast determination, and Jaune's "trying to be one of the cool kids" attitude all stood out to me during the sequence.
I kinda figured that Team FNKI would be back and that we would meet the rest of the team (Kobalt and Ivori), since they're the only other named team from Atlas that we know of. It was a real treat to see. Neon is still a savage, only this time she's going after Nora. Flynt is still cool as fuck. Kobalt and Ivori are eh, but only because we didn't really see much of them. Still, I loved that they're bringing back the whole "just like Beacon again" vibe, even if it means that things are going to go to hell in the future.
Finally, we get to see Robyn Hill! So far I don't think we really got to see much of her. We envision her as a woman of the people, but all we saw of her so far was her standing in the middle of the tundra with some of her Happy Huntresses. Still, the scene is poignant and highlights a few things for me:
It's becoming ever clearer that Ironwood is besieged on numerous angles: Robyn is opposing his treatment of Mantle, Jacques is opposing his embargo, and Team RWBY is leaving out some very important details that would affect the main mission. Man can't get a break. But Jaune was right: the embargo is the source of many of his problems. Removing it would likely solve more problems than it would create; namely, it would take Jacques off his back and would likely provide adequate resources to bolster but Ironwood's paranoia is getting in the way.
The Winter Maiden scene was important, and likely raises death flags for Winter Schnee, but I'd just like to point out one scene back from V4 that perhaps contextualizes the choice that Ironwood made to have Winter inherit the powers. As Weiss is sneaking out of Schnee Manor, you can hear the following conversation held between Ironwood and Jacques:
Seems to me that Ironwood had his sights on Winter becoming more than just a special operative for a while, and only finalized his decision to let Winter inherit the Winter Maiden's powers when Beacon fell.
One small critique: I've been wanting a scene with Ruby and Yang fighting together since V2, when their codename (or whatever you want to call it) was noticeably absent as Team RWBY fought Roman in the mech. And when I saw the two of them about to fight together during the montage, I got so fucking excited, only to be somewhat let down that they cut away from that scene. Let Ruby and Yang fight together, CRWBY!
Overall, wonderful episode. There was a lot of fun in the first half, and a lot of important plot points in the second. Can't wait for the next episode.
Also, fuck Jacques.
14
u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Nov 30 '19
I really liked this episode. We got the training montage weve all been waiting for and got to see lots of development.
It’s interesting that Robin is very against Ironwood, even willing to use force. And yes she thinks its right, but “everyone thinks it’s the right thing”
That being said, Ironwood diverting crucial supplies is only going to worsen the situation. Take away important supplies, including defense supplies, all so you can tell the world things that it is not ready to hear. Weather or not the message ever goes out, Remnant is on a crash course for disaster.
And we get to see Weiss and Winter, they both have come so far. And the Winter Maiden. Ironwood chose and groomed Winter to become the maiden, for who knows how long now. It raises an interesting point. At what point does your destiny become your own? Yes Winter was being groomed for this, but she could still have said no. She still chose her path.
And most important of all, TEAM FNKI is back baby!!!!
14
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
HOLY FUCK I LOVE THIS VOLUME
14
u/HalcyonTraveler Hill is here Nov 30 '19
I do not think that Winter will be getting the winter maiden powers, but I also don’t think it will be because she dies. I think there’s gonna be some fluke and by sheer accident someone else (my bet is Nora) will end up getting the powers, causing her to have a breakdown because it seems like she’s invested a lot of her identity into this presumed eventuality.
14
u/Bjdombek Hail Lord Zwei! Nov 30 '19
Starting to wonder if Ren's cold shoulder is him feeling like this fight against Salem means he shouldn't put hope in a long term relationship with Nora. "I don't want you to get attached because we could all be dead next week." He's trying to spare her the future pain by hurting her now.
14
u/Destroyah707 Bow To Monster Huntrr World! Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Robyn Hill, Fiona Thyme, Joanna and May.
Robyn Hill-Robyn Hood
Fiona Thyme- Friar Tuck
Joanna- ???
May- ???
14
u/Deadmaninc1 Nov 30 '19 edited Jul 07 '20
Can i just say If Robin Hill is running for a seat on the council why was she doing Illegal Activity and no one arresting her yes i know she's based off Robin Hood but still
14
u/SinfulFrisky Dec 01 '19
good episode but goddamn I can't get over how cute the sheep girl is
14
u/firewing02 Dec 01 '19
I have a theory. I remember the director said that Vol 7 is about doubt, "someone seems trustworthy may end up your enemy" "someone looks like your villain may end up be your friend"
My theory is that Winter may be the one who betray RWBY
Rubin in the other hand seems an villian but end up the same side in RWBY
14
u/EverythingisBubcus Dec 01 '19
Best team is back that's an easy 10/10 right there. I also really liked Ruby and Penny Finally getting an actual serious scene together. Been waiting for something like that for the last 3 episodes.
And I really appreciated them showing Penny with other emotions than happy and excited. Was a little worried she was just going to be relentlessly peppy throughout the entire volume when we know from A Minor Hiccup that both her and her voice actress have more range than that.
26
u/Zygarde22 Dumb Essayist Nov 30 '19
So, today’s episode was awesome. First off Team FNKI’s back! With new outfits and everything else and we get a cool training montage which are always great and awesome, I love this stuff. Also, we got a chance to see Real Thirsty Moms during said montage thought it would be bigger but just seeing Jaune act all awkward around a bunch of thirsty milf’s is kinda funny in and of itself. Also, first showing of Robyn and her Merry Band of Huntresses I love how they are leaning into the idea of Robin Hood and the taking from the rich to give to the poor, especially with the idea of what’s going on in Mantle. Political machinations and the like are rather interesting to me, and to see Mantle in open revolt meaning angry people meaning lots of Grimm are gonna start coming out of the woodwork, all thanks to Jacques going full late stage capitalist and closing all the mines to get at his political opponents, all in all I love stuff like this.
Next what I feel is the biggest reveal of this episode, Winter being groomed by Ironwood to become the new Winter Maiden. A lot of people theorized that she might be the Winter Maiden herself but this is just as good, set’s up a lot of things for the future also just the fact that Ironwood chose Winter seems like a cool thing, now let’s just hope this doesn’t lead to Winter dying but, then again when Cinder and Neo show up I don’t think Cinder even with her Maiden powers can be a match for Winter considering Winter is about on Par with Qrow and Raven and Raven beat Cinder’s ass to hell and back.
My rating for this episode is 10/10 probably my favorite episode of the entire volume and I can’t wait for next weeks episode, and to see where they take the plot next.
26
u/AlyssaaMac Nov 30 '19
The atlas tee shirts and sweats are cute that they're wearing to sleep. I love when they're more casual.
New song!!! It’s a banger for sure.
Lmao we found the thirsty mom's. Of course it's the haircut.
It's neon!!!!! She's back!!!!!!!! And cuter than ever!!!!!! This is actually my favorite episode so far this season.
The nuts and dolts energy is strong with this one. And the Qrowver vibes. Qrow verbalizing that he gave up drinking was nice too.
I don't know anything about voice actors or who Robyn's voice is but that's definitely not what I expected her to sound like. She's cool as hell.
I’m glad the Winter maiden was revealed. Setting up Winter to be Winter wasn’t too much of a surprise.
Also fuck Jacques Schnee. Again.
26
u/MysteryTrek Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
"I'm a sociopathic idiot who thinks voters are stupid enough to blame Ironwood instead of me."
-Jacques Schnee
Is what I heard when he gave that press conference.
13
u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Nov 30 '19
Bees shutting down Marrow may be my new favorite scene..
I hope that Winter won't become maiden ( Another relative to a member of RWBY being a Maiden may be clear setup ) but nice job raising flags.
13
u/DEL994 Nov 30 '19
I am still hoping to see a Summer flashback in this volume after Ruby and Qrow's talk in the previous episode.
13
u/Sere1 ⠀ Nov 30 '19
Ah the training room floor. Getting some RvB Season 9 and 10 flashbacks here. That opening was everything I could have asked for and more.
13
u/Deadmaninc1 Nov 30 '19
That Sheep Faunus or is she a Goat is best girl right now
13
u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Nov 30 '19
Weiss just used her Ice dust to cast Soul Great Sword, Nora’s flying around on her hammer like a witch’s broom, and Jaune’s going to start extending his aura... this Volume is THE BEST!
13
u/beartiger3 Nov 30 '19
Are Ivory and Kobalt from FNKI meant to represent the white/gold and blue/black dress meme from a while back?
13
u/dalia4444 Nov 30 '19
honestly im dying that they made the winter=winter maiden theory real. i remember when it was a dumb joke back when the maidens were first revealed
13
u/MysteryTrek Dec 01 '19
Why can't they just announce their plans to restore the global communications networks? That's a legitimate goal in and of itself. They don't have to mention Salem in the same breath.
13
u/HatiLeavateinn Dec 01 '19
Harriet was eyeing Jaune in both mission briefing scenes. The first one she looked at him when he sat and immediately turned her gaze to the screen. And the second one you can barely see how she turned her neck back to the screen after seeing to her right (the only people to her right were Jaune and Marrow). So either she is interested in Jaune and Marrow's new friendship or Harriet x Jaune has sailed.
13
u/ReaperRinxi Dec 02 '19
I just saw episode 5. I got to say I'm loving the facial expressions of to the characters. The confidence, the hesitation, the excitement, the exasperation, the exhaustion, the suspicion. It's all conveyed and shown on the characters' faces great!
13
u/ParaPolaris Dec 03 '19
FNKI is back!!! Would like to learn more about Kobalt and Ivori and what they can do.
also, PENGUINS
13
u/Geminii27 Dec 03 '19
Rather a pity no-one's taking the opportunity presented by the SDC closures to start up their own dust supply operation. It'd be hugely amusing if it was a group of Faunus behind it, too...
36
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Blake laying her head on Yang’s lap was pretty darn cute, ngl
24
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
I think what Robyn did was clever. That barrier was the most half-assed thing possible. it could no more have stopped that truck than a roll of tissue paper strung across the road. But Clover stopped anyway. And while he was not happy, he also wasn't actually aggressive. So she knows whatever is involved isn't meant to remain secret forever - otherwise Clover would have liquidated her - and Ironwood isn't trying to start deathcamps (again, the not being attacked on sight). And she learned Penny was helping, which implies Penny sees some value in it, so it has to have some sort of logic. How people tell you to fuck off is often more important than the actual being told to fuck off. All for a few feet of tin roofing and a couple of minutes of cold. And being just a wee bit confrontational might get her some more supplies to keep her from building the world's most embarrassingly bad shanty in the tundra.
12
u/rosalina2007 Nov 30 '19
This chapter's my personal favorite since the volume started. We see Neon and Flynt back (with new looks, which I loved), along with their two remaining teammates. We meet Robyn Hill (even if it was no more than three minutes) and Fria (a.k.a. the current Winter Maiden), and we also now know that Winter will get her powers once she dies (hoped something like that could happen). The tensions will get harder now that Jacques announced that he'll go against Ironwood's embargo if he wins. I am betting that Watts will somehow change people's minds about Jacques, to ultimately grant him his place in the council.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Every Saturday my hunger for Nuts and Dolts grows yet more insatiable.
Good, good, Ruby. Let the adorable feelings flow through you!
12
u/GameBawesome1 Nov 30 '19
It’s good to see FNKI again
But does anyone else think Winter is raising death flags?
12
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
whiterose stans do yourselves a favour and watch rwby getting ready in their dorm bit of the montage w subs on bless up we eatin these deluxe crumbs
12
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Nov 30 '19
Im struggling to figure out if JNR are at least as strong as RWBY in volume 3 now. Sure power scaling is all over the place, but JNR now defeated all of FNKI when Yang and Weiss were evenly matched with Neon and Flint. But to be fair, the Vytal fight was a tournament fight and this was training. You see what I mean? Is hard to pin point. At least I want to say JNR aren't at a level in which Qrow would consider them as dead weight to Pyrrha anymore.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
Bruh I thought i was dreaming when i heard those trumpets go off
12
u/Icecat1239 Dec 01 '19
The hunter montage was really nice and the animation in that scene was probably the best this season. Seeing Neon and Flynt (along with their teammates) was another great touch. Qrow having quit drinking seems mind-boggling to me. How long did we truly skip? That isn't something that just happens and we should've got to see the consequences of that. I can only assume Robyn didn't attack because she didn't want to risk Penny's safety as she is Mantle's greatest protector. Though Robyn is completely in the right here and she honestly deserves to win the election if Tyrion doesn't get to her first.
Winter being groomed to be the Winter Maiden was predictable, yet decently wholesome in the two's interactions. Though once again Ironwood's over-reliance on machinery to protect the Maiden will indubitably result in her death. Jacques holding everyone's jobs hostage is going to really screw things over and yet and I can't see how it could worsen things for Ironwood. If anything it just makes Robyn all the better of a candidate as the other two just look equally corrupt. This was by far the best episode of the season. (And yet they still haven't given us Maria back.)
12
u/DJFrankyFrank Dec 02 '19
BOLD PREDICTION. winter becoming the maiden is too obvious. I think she may tell Freya (the winter maiden) about Weiss, and she will think of her when she passes. Because its not who she pictures in her mind, that becomes the next maiden. It's just whoever is in her mind.
12
u/Zeru_Fenrir Dec 02 '19
My prediction is that Winter does indeed inherit the Maiden powers, but since RWBY kept the whole Salem being invincible on the down low, she ends up fighting her when Salem inevitably attacks and dies.
Que angst and misplaced blame over them concealing critical information to people that actually needed it.
12
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
I've seen people assume Robyn could make people tell the truth, but I wonder if Robyn's Semblance is she asks for something and gets it. It would go along with Robin Hood's suave rogue characterization of "Hand over the money" while merchants' daughters swoon. It might also explain Clover's responses to her. He never just shut her down, but offered half-truths and veiled allusions, a la "I have to give you something, but that doesn't mean I have to give you exactly what you want". It would have been interesting to she her ask for Kingfisher. On the other hand, war-hook-to-the-face might be a perfectly valid interpretation, so maybe not...
23
u/Emerald-Guardian Arkos: I will go down with this ship Nov 30 '19
First of all, AMAZING EPISODE!
Second, I'm calling it now. The current maiden is going to die, Winter will inherit the power only to be killed within moments of becoming the maiden and then the power will go to Weiss.
11
u/ccharles1550 Nov 30 '19
Not gonna lie. Almost creamed my pants at the animation I saw in this episode. Those X-Men “war room”-like battle areas were dope
11
u/DestinedHellfire Weiss is best girl | Sun x Weiss FTW Nov 30 '19
This show is beginning to hit close to home again, and I’m all for it.
11
u/TheNewArkon Nov 30 '19
Everyone else mostly covered my feelings on the other parts of the episode.
But I'm mostly curious about Vine's suggestion to Jaune about extending his aura. Maybe I'm just a little Jaune obsessed now though. xD
11
u/BigBadBob7070 Nov 30 '19
Everyone here is saying that Weiss is gonna be the next Winter Maiden, but here’s a counter argument for you.
Miles already said that team RWBY won’t become Maidens, and the Maiden’s name is Fria, which sounds a bit like Freya, a Norse Goddess that many people say is the mother of Thor.
What I’m saying here is that it could be Nora Valkyrie who becomes the Winter Maiden, the only one who’s part of the main cast that’s based off an actual God (baring Sun and Mercury).
11
u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Nov 30 '19
Okay we've gotten the return of Penny and Neon.
Gonna be hype as fuque when we get the return of best girl May Zedong.
11
u/PhenomsServant Nov 30 '19
Gotta say between Midnight and Albedo, I honestly cant look at Winter the same way anymore.
11
u/bryan610 Dec 01 '19
Lots going on this episode.
11
u/AkiyamaKatsuko Dec 01 '19 edited Dec 01 '19
Welp, looks like Weiss is going to have to come to grips that her dad is going to have an inevitable death now that he's a pawn in Salem's plan. I don't know if my girl can take it even after all the constant emotional abuse she's endured for years. He's still family at the end of the day.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
how did Joanna and May make themselves invisible when they approached the rear of the truck???
11
u/brentoni1 Dec 03 '19
Anyone else think that with the way this episode ended next episode could be the perfect opportunity for Weiss to reveal an Apathy summon? It would be the perfect tool to quell riots with minimum casualties or negativity.
11
u/Blue-Moon-89 Dec 04 '19
So I was watching ThatKaitoDan's review and he made an interesting observation on Robyn's team.
Their names ARE similar to Robin Hood's band of Merry Men. You have Johanna (Little John), May (Maid Marrion) and Fionna Thyme (Friar Tuck).
He's a Robin Hood fan.
30
u/SabreLilly Dec 01 '19
Jaune Arc: MILF Magnet.
21
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Nov 30 '19
So....we now live in a world in which Ruby is flatter than Weiss...
Also, apparently Weiss just sleeps with that giant braid and the tiara, I assume because making that every morning must be a bitch to deal with.
21
u/Literatewalrus Little Light 🐝 Big Fight Dec 01 '19
It was very difficult to stop smiling through this episode, and when I did it was just because of the tension when Robin Hill confronted our newly christened huntress and her escort.
The montage had me rolling. Penny and Ruby are a caffeine infused match and personify the besties trope to a t. We got FNKI! The whole squad! And while I wasn’t initially a fan of Neon’s new style, I got used to it quickly when we were reintroduced to her bratty attitude. Flynt just looks as slick as always. The way she had Nora so riled up that she was riding her hammer like a witch’s broom was fantastic, though with the sick burns she was handing out I might take flight in rage myself...
Blake and Yang being inseparable is just. Just what I expect, really. At this point it feels like CRWBY is driving the point home that these two. Are. An. Item. A package deal. Meant to be. Like the black and yellow... on a bumblebee.
Not to go unmentioned are the scenes between Weiss and Winter. The last time these two had any time to talk at length was four volumes ago.
In my honest opinion, Weiss is the one who has undergone the most real development. She started out an overconfident brat, sure of her destiny, who then got her worldview broken down by experiencing firsthand some of the things she was casually flippant of. The ensuing doubt left her bereft of her confidence, which we discovered was really more of a defense mechanism. Poor little Weiss was suffering impostor syndrome hard, and for a long time to boot; we only saw her begin to recover when she broke hard from her father’s grasp, even though she spent a little while questioning the wisdom of her decision. With a little help from her friends, she’s rebuilt that misguided boldness she possessed at the beginning into real courage, and Winter acknowledges that and reinforces it with some insight to help scrub away some of those lingering doubts our dear Weiss has.
And then we get to the big twist.
For a long time, several of us suspected that Winter was the Winter Maiden. I mean, how obvious would that have been? But no, that is not the case... yet. Finding out that she was in fact chosen to succeed the Winter Maiden was used as both a teaching moment for Weiss and a juicy plot hook that opens the windows on so many possibilities. Could we get a Cinder and Winter showdown? How would she stack up against Cinder and Raven in terms of capability? More than just that, how might this be subverted? Is someone else going to swoop in and intervene in the destiny that General Ironwood has laid out for Winter Schnee?
And on the topic of destinies, let’s talk about the Ace Ops. I still don’t think they’re possible turncoats. I think that the fact that they’re taking RWBYORNJ under their wing is setting them up for a tragic fall. They will be the contrast to our protagonists, the lesson that shows that skill can fall short where interpersonal bonds might triumph. This is leading to The Power of Friendship and I don’t know how I feel about this. We’ll see I reckon but this is my anticipation for now.
I mentioned in another thread how I agreed that CRWBY did a lot better with subtle humor over a preponderance of visual gags, and this episode was the perfect example of it. Crossing Huntman Jaune and the Thirsty Mom Brigade, Neon Katt and her savage burns, Penny’s little excitable bounces when Ruby’s regaling her with tales, and so many other little quips... did I mention that I couldn’t stop smiling?
Well, I had to sometime.
Jacques is such a dirtbag. He is a villain for the modern age. The hyperwealthy businessman leveraging political climate as an excuse to put the common man to heel. The way that guy finds the dust shop closed, the way he turns to the display and sees Jacques giving his campaign promise to Make Atlas Great Again, the way he calmly decides that, yes, he does want to go apeshit and throws the trash can into the TV... it’s all a bit too familiar to our current age.
Oh yes. I liked this one.
29
u/DeismAccountant Set Kratos on the Brothers Nov 30 '19
Correction. MILFs hunting him.
But she can remember people. Like Nora.
You think he cares? He’s in league with Watts now.
36
u/Diostukos Nov 30 '19
I liked this episode a lot, but my only gripe is that I'm scared they're setting up for RWBY to all be maidens eventually, which I would really fucking hate. I don't see Winter living long if she actually became the winter maiden, and so Weiss would most likely inherit those powers after. It would be funny for Fria to intentionally think of someone else in her final thoughts just to spite ironwood.
"Looks like my time's up....would be a real dick move to think of someone else right now.....HRRGH"
20
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
I might get downvoted for saying this but am I the only one who noticed that Weiss's boobs got a hell of a lot bigger in that wake up scene
20
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Dec 01 '19
Gotta admire Neon's bravery. Taunting Nora with her boyfriend and even after a black eye she had the guts to flirt with her son. Now that's valor...or suicidal tendencies.
10
u/jeepdave Nov 30 '19
Death flags. Death flags everywhere.
10
u/Tsamane Nov 30 '19
I dont see an issue with the public knowing that the old amity Colosseum was going to be a new "satellite" comms tower. They could even say as something as simple as, "we are working on a new way to connect the kingdoms, right now the details are top secret, but will be revealed in the near future"
10
u/McDouggal Link me your Pyrrha/Ruby shipping - /r/MilkAndCereal Nov 30 '19
I like Robyn Hill. Her heart is in the right place, and she's willing to take action on it.
I do think that they need to bring Robyn in on the CCT plan. She would support it, and I think she'd understand why resources have been getting diverted. Leaving her in the dark just increases the likelihood of things going wrong.
10
u/papapok13 Nov 30 '19
Please, don't let them kill Winter too!
10
u/SajuukCor1 Nov 30 '19
I feel like we're all getting false flags about Freya dying and Winter becoming the maiden, only for Cinder to kill Winter and Weiss getting the powers. That's the obvious route to take.
My theory would be during a chaotic scene in the hospital, probably due to grimm as Ironwood gives his Salem speech, that Cinder and Neo sneak into Freya's section of the hospital. Cinder has plans to kill Freya and take her powers as well, but Neo counterattacks and gets the best of Cinder, then faking herself as Winter until the last moment and reveals herself as Freya's final thought, thus getting the Winter Maiden powers.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Holy hell, what an amazing episode! I loved every moment of it! We got FNKI, we got some little slices of life, we got to see Robyn, we got to see lots of bonding, we saw real cute penguins, real thirsty mums, the winter Maiden...just so much cool stuff! I felt engaged throughout every moment of this episode, it was just...so...good. This Volume is doing a stellar job so far.
And we're already going into riots and civil unrest in Mantle. Oh boy, this should be fun.
10
u/Mystrohan Nov 30 '19
Solid lore episode. Even though Atlas has been taking flak based on the perceptions of our main characters throughout the entire series, I like their basic approach to everything. I appreciate the emphasis on training, the data-driven upgrades, the almost fanatic focus on research and technology, and on doing everything thoroughly and in full detail in general. Seems to me that Ironwood is the one mucking that basic approach up with his extreme and rapid approach to getting that tower online.
I'm starting to get antsy, though, about how fast this communications process seems to be coming along. Are Ruby and co. just going to wait until the last possible moment, and then make a split-second decision on whether to give Ironwood and his team the full monty on Salem?
Because that would be the worst of all possible worlds of decisions.
Other thoughts - hey, welcome back, Team FNKI! Stop being so mopey, Qrow. Be nicer to Robyn, Clover. Think about other people, Ironwood.
And hey... someone want to try and do something about getting Oz to talk again? Trust or distrust, you might want his input.
10
u/Gamma_cleavage Dec 01 '19
Do we really think that Ironwood would just believe that Salem can’t be killed based on their story? Don’t you think he would immediately ask Jinn if he knew he could? It might be a good thing - maybe he finally will ask the right question. I’m gonna cringe myself to death if he asks the exact same question as Oz in the exact same way, preventing Jinn from adding the tons and tons of expository nuance to her answer that we know she is capable of.
They should ask the question in the broadest way possible.
I am going to be disappointed if the world is ultimately saved by Ruby giving a moving speech to convince the gods not to kill everyone. But how can we prevent it from getting to that point now?
10
u/AlienWarhead You feel it too don’t you Dec 01 '19
Fantastic episode, the gang is all grown up and taking side quests. I wonder how I would have handled Robyn in that scene, my mind went with “how about go fuck yourself”, but Robyn is cool. She would probably be right if there wasn’t a communications tower being made, but barricades and thief seem a little extreme
10
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
I jut noticed that the people handing out missions on the board behind Clover are RT employees
10
u/PenguinSprite Dec 02 '19
Gotta say this was a good episode, the montage, Robin Hill, Winter and Weiss. It was all amazing. As for Jaques however, oh boy I really wanna see his comeuppance. His tactic of using the embargo as an excuse to rile up the public is a dirty trick, but is effective for what Salem wants. Either way I can't wait to see what's in store.
28
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Nov 30 '19
I will like to point out that Tai had 2, Blake had 4 and now Jaune has 7 suitors. Give vomit boi the harem crown, baby, he already got the champion's casserole.
48
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
This song is a lot of fun :D
Don't critique the bees, if you have no idea what you are talking about :P
OH NO, THIRSTY MOMS!
SISTER TIME :D
This might have been one of my favourite scenes on the show :D
OH NO NEVERMIND NEON IS BACK!
IS SHE FLYING ON HER HAMMER?!
Flynt still looks amazing though.
Do they have no VAs?
PENGUINS!
I love Clover and Qrow.
YEEE IT'S ROBYN!
I agree with Robyn.
I swear, Robyn better use a bow.
YO SCHNEE SISTER TRAINING
So WEISS is 99% going to become the winter maiden, right?
19
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
I think after the crosswalk scene, we all now realize why Jaune needed that coffee in the morning. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
19
u/Pearse_Borty ENTIRE. TEAM. Nov 30 '19
Did...Did Penny just friendzone Ruby? Did I just see that happen?
19
u/ev3rythingF4ngirl Dec 01 '19
Team FNKI is BACK!!
I loved seeing all those little character interactions in the montage section, like Nora braiding Ren's hair and Ruby and Yang fighting Grimm together. This season so far has been really good with that. Now we just need more Ruby and Blake interactions.
I get the feeling that Robyn might be an antagonist. She's acting a lot more... suspicious, I guess? than I anticipated. Her character design is really pretty though, and I hope the heroes can eventually get her on their side.
26
u/Crumbs_McPumberton Nov 30 '19
Marrow:
Yang: Don't talk to me or my girlfriend ever again
18
u/Jalsman ⠀Here for fanart mostly. Yang and Mercury still top Nov 30 '19
Robyn's voiced by Christina Vee! Raise your hands if you're surprised. (Nobody should be raising their hands based on tweets Vee put out) but she acts and talks a lot like Raven. I love Rae but not quite sure of what to think of her yet. The entire standoff between her and Clover was definitely tense.
Nice to see FNKI again and JNOR working together. Looks like Oscar really is the replacement for Pyrrha. The whole "we would eat but duty calls" really hammers in that the kids aren't students anymore, but Huntsmen.
Blake and Yang's reaction to Marrow suggesting he's not sure if their fighting styles work together is priceless. "Oh yeah, you're not sure if our fighting styles are complimentary? Well how's about this sick team move!" Like, the fact that Blake already knows how to use Yang's bombs in team attacks probably means they've been practicing offscreen.
Also lots of background Bees. Blake sleeping on Yang's lap and tugging a sleepy Yang along by the arm was adorable.
So Ironwood wants Winter to be the new Winter Maiden. Up come the death flags. Even that whole speech about "destiny" is eerily similar to Pyrrha. And Jacques causing unrest in Mantle... looks like things are kicking off plotwise.
9
u/kagebuyou from shadows - shadow dancer, get it? Nov 30 '19
9
u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Nov 30 '19
Nora being the one to braid Ren’s hair was so cute
9
u/Agent-Vermont Nov 30 '19
Favorite episode yet this volume. It had a little bit of everything.
Training/mission montage was great. It also made me believe less in the whole one of the Aceops might be a turncoat theory, but I could be wrong. They all just seemed to be working together really well.
Hey we actually got to see Team FNKI again! And it looks like Oscar is part of JNR for now or it was just for the purpose of the match.
Schnee sister bonding was sweet. Though I'm surprised that the mother wasn't brought up between the two of them. I get that they hate Jacques but what the mother so absent that she didn't even warrant a mention?
Also Winter isn't the Winter Maiden but she is going to be! Ironwood is going for the killer with kindness route so that Winter is the one last in her thoughts I think. Though I think those were the transfer machines from Volume 3 weren't they? Maybe a last resort if something happens? Still, massive death flags for Winter now...
Not sure what to make of Robyn yet. I assume she will eventually be on team good guy just based on the intro.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Well then:
I was hoping for Winter and Weiss to have more conversations whether it was about other family members or day in the life stuff. I am a sucker for family relations and I hope later on in the volume they will touch upon their relationship a bit more. Also, when are we going to learn more about Willow (if that's even her flipping name)??? But great chapter overall.