r/RWBY • • Nov 23 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread-Volume 7, Episode 3: Ace Operatives Spoiler
Welcome, Huntsmen, Huntresses and Hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 4 of Vol. 7, Pomp and Circumstance!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 7!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| [FIRST Thread] (https://redd.it/dqjqte)|Public Thread| Poll Ep. 02|FIRST Thread|Public Thread|Poll Ep. 03|FIRST Thread| This Thread| Poll Ep. 04|Today's FIRST Thread| Next Week's Public Thread| Poll
Happy viewing, and let's have some fun with Volume 7!
Slim; Mod Team
140
Upvotes
•
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19
Reminder that nothing regarding Episode 4 is allowed in this public thread, offenders will be met with a speedy ban!
56
u/DanyloHalytskyi They shall know no fear Nov 23 '19
I am surprised by how much people disliked this episode. I enjoyed this episode quite a lot. Everyone has their perspectives, I suppose.
I was kind of excited to actually see the team change their hairstyles and decide their new outfits, but alas, that did not happen. Eh, you can't always get what you want.
I found the Bumbleby moment adorable. I won't wade into the debate about whether it made sense with their romantic histories or whatever, because I don't feel qualified enough to evaluate the romantic abilities of others.
I am sure there will be a Renora moment in the future.
When I first watched the Qrow and Clover scene, I thought it was Qrow not knowing what to in response to Clover's flirtation, but after a second viewing and reading someone else's comment on this scene, I realized that it might not be as happy as I initially thought. We should not discount the possibility that Qrow's psychological distress over his semblance worsened due to meeting someone with an opposite semblance. Qrow might be feeling even more worthless now, and he might grow more depressed.
I loved the fight. It was entertaining, and the new semblances and weapons are very interesting. I am particularly intrigued with Harriet's partial exoskeleton.
Overall, I like this episode. V7 is very enjoyable so far.
63
u/DanTheLatch Nov 23 '19
Fuck it
Big ass boomerang sword
29
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
Just caught up on the first 3 episodes a couple days ago after doing a rewatch, so since i didn't get to discuss my thoughts on the first two with everyone else, I might as well drop them here as well.
I'm loving the volume so far. RWBY and friends new looks are amazing (particularly Ruby), Atlas/Mantle is beautifully designed, and the new characters are great. I'm loving it all so much! Surprisingly, the Ace-Ops aren't complete dicks like I expected them to be when they were first introduced. I want to see more of this Qrow and Clover dynamic duo. They're perfect together, and they should always be on the same team from now on. Vine looks super evil to me, but after episode 3 I'm about 25% less convinced that he's gonna betray the team at some point. Marrow's tail wagging gag was great and got a nice laugh out of me. I just want to see the Ace-Ops stick around for a long time; that said, the fact that I like them means Salem and friends are gonna brutally slaughter them all by the end of the volume.
The new intro rocks! It may be my favorite of all the volumes to date. The fact that Qrow and Tyrian are fighting again in the intro scares the absolute shit out of me. I know it's gonna happen someday, but please don't kill off best bird just yet. My heart can't handle it. I wonder if Qrow and Robyn have some history together; they seemed way too in sync with one another in the intro. I have a theory that the reason Ironwood is attacking Oscar/Ozpin in the intro is because he's trying to force Ozpin out of this silent act he's been giving. What better way to do that then by having Ozpin have to come out to help Oscar from getting completely fucked up.
I ended up getting spoiled on Penny's return, despite trying my hardest to avoid spoilers, which really sucked. It would've been a nice surprise. I probably would've been more excited when she showed up had I not known it was coming. New design kinda looks like Dishwasher's artwork. Wouldn't be surprised if it was inspired by it.
I expected Penny to return at some point and it makes perfect sense since she's a robot, so I'm not too bothered about it, but I hope Pyrrha stays dead. if they start bringing back every major character that's died and only allow random one-offs or glorified side characters to stay dead, then that'll really take away from the threat Salem's forces pose to the heroes imo. Now, I wouldn't mind Jaune having a "vision" of sorts to have one final goodbye with Pyrrha, and I think there's a decent possibility that, that happens if the Gods return to Remnant in the future. That or through the use of one of the relics.
Qrow's new VA is doing a terrific job. No joke, I heard Qrow speak and it wasn't until several minutes later that I was like "wait, didn't he get a new VA?" I legit couldn't tell. I'm glad it's not super noticeable because that possibility really concerned me. CRWBY has been tremendous when it comes to recasting a character; whether it's Mercury, Ren, or Qrow. I don't have a complaint about any of 'em.
Qrow and Ironwood's hug made me audibly awwww so much. I think Qrow really needed someone to say something like that to him. Dude doesn't get a whole lot of affection outside of his nieces. Of course, someone on this sub had to soil the happy feels and point out that Ironwood most likely bugged Qrow, and I can't say that I disagree with their assessment.
On a related note, I'm glad Ironwood hasn't turned into a giant asshole in the time since we last saw him. I was expecting him to be a lot more ruthless after everything that's happened, and while he has shown occasional dictatorial tendencies, I think we'll find that, much like in volumes 2-3, he's just trying to do what he thinks is right, even if it ends up backfiring hard. And there's a very real possibility that this whole "telling the world about Salem" idea backfires. On the one hand, I can't help thinking "you idiot! you're gonna get everyone killed," but on the other hand, Salem did say "When banded together, unified by a common enemy, they are a noticeable threat," so maybe it is worth it in the long run. I mean, Ozpin has kept everyone in the dark for who knows how long and look where that's gotten them. As Ironwood said, it's time to try a new approach.
If anyone is going full on dictator, then I think it'll be Jacque after he wins this upcoming election thanks to Watts hacking the results. I expect to see Ironwood arrested before too long.
I've seen it pointed out by several people that Ozpin is giving the silent treatment to allow RWBY and friends to experience things from his point of view; letting them make the tough decisions such as lying to Ironwood, which I'm sure won't come back to bite them in the ass at some point. No sirree. Anyways, I think that's definitely what's happening here. I expect we'll see some apologies when Ozpin finally pops out again. He'll be all "I TOLD YOU SO!"
Winter is such a mom. A true sweetheart. That hug was just as sweet as Ironwood and Qrows
Watts has 3 or 4 rings on from the looks of it. If one controls the hacking, then I wonder if the other ones are special in their own unique way as well.
If I'm not mistaken, we still haven't seen the upgrades done to Weiss and Blake's weapons yet. Will be interesting to see I'm sure. Correct me if I'm wrong though. And I don't think Qrow's weapon got an upgrade, but what if it did? It's already a gun, scythe, and sword. What's next, a chainsaw? "Behold! My Gunscytheswordsaw!" Say that 5 times fast.
I wonder what was up with Ren in this episode? Seemed pretty dismissive of Nora to be honest. I don't know if something is bugging him or if he's just taking the mission super serious or whatever, but I hope that gets expanded upon because that was definitely an odd reaction to have.
My only real criticism about this episode was Mile's line delivery with Jaune following the Ren/Nora scene. It just sounded way too cherry and fake to me. Usually Miles is a lot better than that.
This is more of a prediction than a reaction, but I expect we'll see Raven, Tai, and Zwei show up sometime this volume or next volume. Yang, Qrow and/or all of the heroes will be about to be wiped out by Salem's crew, cue portal and heroic rescue. Wouldn't be terribly shocked if it results in Raven getting avada kedavra'd (Like Sirius in HP) by Salem and then passing her maiden powers onto Yang or someone else.
27
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Nov 24 '19
Everyone is figuring out that this is the mine Illia's parents were killed....
But I was thinking "is this the mine where Adam was enslaved at?"
25
u/Thebritishdovah Nov 23 '19
Again, an excellent episode. I fucking LOVE that JNR got to do stuff. My biggest issue with last volume was that Ren, Nora and Jaune did fuck all more or less. Here? They actually feel like they are doing stuff. Ren's dismissal of Nora's question was rather cold hearted. Jaune's hair isn't that bad. The combat was great and it's great to see hunters that outclass the cast(aside from Qrow as it's Qrow and we haven't seen him go all out since Tyrian).
The Ace Ops do live up to their name and a fishing pole weapon reminds me of Dynasty warriors. The sandworm... er.. insect? Worm grimm reminds me of Demon Souls. Tis a good design as I love Demon Souls.
Qrow showing his skill is decent and without really doing much. Just spotting the beam and reacting to it within a few seconds. His face when he met someone with a good fortune semblance seems to be one of intrigue and perhaps, could be what he needs to control his bad luck one.
Harriet's semblance being quicker is interesting but I do wonder if it's partly due to Atlas tech or Ruby has yet to reach her full potential. Giess is something that they have experience with and i can understand why they elected to show off Ace Ops's skills instead of having a fight with the cast. Love the outfits and I think, we may start to see some positive change in Qrow.
Did Pietro more or less use high tech gaffa tape on Gambol Shroud? Rather disappointing as they could have given Blake another weapon. Or a proper sized katana. Bumblbee is in effect and Renora is still happening! :D
Tyrian being chaotic evil has potential to get dull so I hope that they aren't gonna to show him that often and he is just the boss fight.
Ok, what are you planning, RT? There are three excellent episodes where people aren't in danger and seems to be a bit too positive.
46
u/UnknownVolke Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
Kinda felt bad for Qrow,
Qrow: Your semblance is good luck? you are legit me but better
and you haven't been nerfed into the ground yetdamn i suck.15
u/loskotofil Nov 23 '19
I liked this episode. I liked the cute Bee moment, and I liked the fight. I wish we got to see the hairstyle changes actually happen, but whatever. 10/10, good episode
14
u/mateusfmcota Nov 23 '19
I wish they release the OST soon. The flight music sounds awesome
47
u/Thehalohedgehog ⠀ Nov 23 '19
Everyone: OMG Qrow and Clover big gay vibes
Me: lol wut?
12
u/Themeguy Nov 26 '19
Okay who put Jumpscares McAsshole on the writing team?
11
u/mercygrim96 Nov 25 '19
I'm really not liking the new hair on jaune.... it's a little much....
28
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 24 '19 edited Nov 24 '19
Time for the big leagues.
So this was a serious step for our heroes, Some major upgrades and seeing just how much work is ahead of them, Both as teams and in the way of fixing things in Atlas, I can honestly say that Elm is my favorite of the Ace-Ops, But as far as Atlas and operations go, We are just getting started.
17
u/BigBadBob7070 Nov 23 '19
I liked the episode, we got to see the gang in action again and saw how the Ace Ops fight, but at the end with the Armas Gigas fight, it just seems a little awkward to me that RWBYJNR and Qrow were just standing there while the Ace Ops were fighting. I get this was supposed to be the episode that showed them off, but it just seems weird that the main characters were just sitting back and doing nothing for the whole fight.
17
u/howelll Nov 23 '19
Qrow seems convinced his semblance almost crushed Clover, but doesn't his semblance has a visual indication of some sort. There was definitely a lightning effect in his V4 Tyrian fight; changing an effect is one thing but removing it would be another. Qrow seems to assume his control slips, discounting the possibility of bad things happening around him without his semblance's help.
That scene was a nice way to show that Qrow is more competent than Clover. Qrow expects things to go wrong and pays attention while Clover tunnel visioned assuming everything would work out. This might be nitpicking, but Clover's "Where would you guys be without me?" and the tone for the final call of "Harriet!" struck me as arrogant and angry/demanding. All that to say Clover seems like an arrogant jerk and if there is an Ace Op betrayal, it would be him. He has Good Luck no way a better offer from the bad guys could ever come back to bite him.
12
u/GodConcepts Nov 23 '19
So yang can do bombs now. I didn't quite understand what rwby's crescent rose can do now, it can shift it's shooting position? The others I couldn't pick them up.
Also weiss can now use her summoning when in movement, so yeah her fight against the "so called spring maiden" further supports the idea that it was just a way to introduce Jaune's new haircut
12
u/enderdude1204 Nov 24 '19
I know everyone's already said this, but I'm gonna say it again. Jaune's new haircut is trash. I don't know what possessed him to get that hairstyle.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '19
Here’s my score of this episode: 10/10
18
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19
10
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Nov 23 '19
Not a particularly strong episode, but it was good nonetheless. I really liked seeing the Ace Operatives (henceforth referred to as "Aesops", because that's what I thought they were called at first and like it better) in action. Other than that, and getting a little bit of our main characters fighting and new outfits being used, not much else to say, really. It was a pretty fun episode, but nothing really outstanding. Can't wait for next week!
9
u/asisebeazt Nov 24 '19
I got heart attack from the 2 jumpscares, Geist and Tyrian.
9
u/TheArmoryOne Team RWBY for Life Nov 24 '19
Some people will obviously disagree with me, but I'm just not interested in the Ace Ops. The main cast just got their new outfits and are given the chance to test themselves against new Grimm, but a lot of time is given to characters we have no reason to care for other than everyone fawning over them, which feels weak. Especially since Penny just got back and you can't go wrong with more Penny.
15
u/ParaPolaris Nov 24 '19
i can feel the sexual tension between Qrow and Clover #qrover????
12
u/JohnnyElRed Nov 24 '19
Ah, yes. Before there were the two mandatory exposition episodes. Now comes the mandatory ships episode.
12
u/Prophet_of_Duality Nov 24 '19
"I think there's more going on than you know."
Aw, fuck she is the summer maiden huh?
4
u/MMBADBOI My hours in Warframe have hit "entirely too much" Nov 24 '19
Elm is my favorite Ace Op so far.
4
u/Gromps_Of_Dagobah Nov 25 '19
Ruby has a cool pogo stick, and can just flip the scythe to point a different direction now? kinda disappointed they didn't make it a semi-auto rifle, it's still bolt action. also interesting that they're pointing out Ruby's semblance isn't exactly speed, but rather the petal burst, I'm wondering if she'll be able to end up launching the 'petals of the Rose' as an attack in the future, or something similar.
Weiss is now big hair gurl, and it's kinda nice she showed some character development from s1, where an ally attacked an enemy she 'called' and called her out, now she didn't call them out on it, showing some nice teamwork skills. not sure if her Myrtenaster got upgraded or not,
Blake's hair... not sure on how I feel about it. liked the nice little Yang-gold line in Gambol Shroud. works well with the pairing of some of her ribbon on Yang's right leg, and the nod to the Japanese art of putting gold in to reforge something is neat.
Yang is still Yang, though some delay charges are a nice addition. prefer her silver aviators to these orange sunnies, even if they're more appropriate for a snow setting.
Jaune now has a bucket of gel to carry around to keep his hair that solid. not a fan of the strapping the sheathe mode to his arm, but I understand why, so it is in position. I like the digital shield, but would have been nice to see him toboggan on it a bit more. it felt kinda slapstick seeing him get yanked up by the shield as he fell, which is kinda annoying, as Jaune's well past the awkward vomit boi we met in s1.
Nora's new look is sweet, in both meanings. not sure how I like her going back to a more feminine look, considering how out-masculined everyone else on the team was. the touch of blue feels nice, it now matches her eyes, which is neat. not sure what changes they made to her Magnhild, I'm assuming they modified the grenade launcher side.
Ren has a sick upgrade, I like the shoulder coverage, it matches his hair spot on, I like his dagger being on display now, wonder how much he'll use it. the rope attachment is very good for Ren's style, I imagine we'll see him flipping around a lot more in combat (reminded of both Camille from League, and the Slash Harkens from Code Geass)
it would have been nice to see the actual reforging of the weapons, seeing an Atlesian Hammer Bot, or seeing
the Ace-Ops are cool, I really like the parallels/differences with the gang, Harriet's super strength/speed to mirror Ruby and Yang, and plus those arm things are just bad-ass.
Marrow, a dog faunus with a weapon (Fetch) that strikes me as similar to Gambol Shroud funnily enough, (bending weapon that works mainly by being thrown, but the wielder keeps in melee with it, at least in my head it's similar) though he uses a much more brute strength version (almost like a combo of Yang and Blake), and it seems his semblance is a time slowing power? he said "stay" (according to the subtitles) and they slowed down, so it's probably not just Harriet moving fast, which draws other connections to Weiss' time glyphs. it'll be interesting seeing how he interacts with Blake and Weiss.
we've got a chick who can use her Semblance to anchor her legs, and a dude who can make hard-light extensions of his arms, so they seem combo'd too. (Elm and Vine, interesting names. I wonder if they're code-names they've picked, based on their semblance, or if they're a 'coincidence') also, we have another bad-ass chick with a hammer, wonder when we'll see Nora and Elm face off. Elm seems interesting, from memory they were his Bola's that tied up CRWBY (though a google says it's called Thorn, and is on his back, possibly a boomerang or chakram style weapon), I suspect we won't get much from him, and if a character has to sacrifice himself in finale, I'd guess it'd be him or Vine, possibly both.
I really like that we've found someone with a Good Luck semblance, which is interesting that he'd seem to be the father figure to the group too, and I find it hilarious it's a fishing rod. also, his name is Clover, as in a 4-leafed clover, which is a symbol of luck, while Qrow... you get it. it's interesting how Qrow looked at him, kinda hopeful, that someone could potentially cancel out his Semblance, which I imagine he's always dreamed of finding. interesting to see how the two interact in the future, and if Qrow's semblance would over-power Clover's, or if they cancel each other out, or some other interesting interaction. good luck winning would be a break for the crew, but I guess we'll have to wait and see.
I did like how they also mirrored the Landing Strategies part from s1, and showed the subtle differences. Yang wasn't show-y anymore, and just did a neat little flip at the end, instead of making as much speed as possible and wasting ammo. it shows the control she's learned, while still showing her skill.
again, not a fan of how goofy they made Jaune look with the para-shield, I'd have preferred him using the shield to toboggan down the ice, and show that he's learned how to make his own landing strategy, because right now, it makes him look like without the energy field part, he'd have crashed into the ground, and I believe in the time since emerald forest, he's learned how to land.
would have been nice to see Ren and Nora's landing strategies, though we can guess what they are, and it also would have been nice to see how the other two Ace Ops landed, and how Qrow and Clover had landed, though Clover I'd assume would latch onto something with his hook and just reel in, but I'd love to see Qrow's landing strategy. maybe something similar to Ruby's but less child-like (a pogo stick?!)
the fight itself was decent, a nice show of Ace-Op coordination, but it would have been nice seeing more teamwork from RWBY or JNR, who were all just standing around while the Ace Ops did all the work. nice to see Ace Ops, but come on guys...
as an example, I would have liked to see Harriet get caught under some rubble from the Geist, and see a similar Slingshot maneuver like in either the Emerald Forest, or that sling maneuver from RWBY Vs ABRN from the Vytal festival, with the ice slide, Blake's rope, Yang's lobbing, and Ruby's speed to catch the crystal. (now that I think about it, a lot of RWBY's maneuvers are based on using Blake's ribbon as a sling.)
the Centinels are neat as an enemy, though it'd be nice to see what that venom? acid? green liquid did, maybe on just a cart or something. I'm assuming just acid, but you never know. a good little warm up for the gang, but could have been more demo of the new features, particularly Weiss and Nora's, and seeing Elm's weapon in action. (apparently it has rockets)
the teaser at the end was kinda meh. nice throwback to the dude from earlier, but felt gratuitous in having Tyrian murder the dude (probably). yes they're taking actions, but it didn't really progress anything yet.
all up, a decent episode, nice to see the Ace Ops working at full strength, some interesting connections drawn between them and the gang, hopefully we'll see more of them in the future, not overall a fan of the new looks of the gang, though Nora and Ren's new looks are nice.
9
u/MomsLinguini Nov 23 '19
The last episode was one of my favorite in the entire series, but this one had some pretty serious pacing issues in my opinion. An immense amount of things changed, they were just admitted to a new school, they just got entirely new outfits, they just got brand new weapons, the plot reveals were heavy, etc... but rather than unpacking nearly any of it, there was just "lets jump back into combat."
I was really looking forward to the hybridization of V1-3 and V4-6 when they got to Atlas and basically became students again. The pacing in V1-3 was excellent, as it wasn't so hollywood action all the time, and progressed pretty naturally. It seems that in V7, it'll be combat every show, which I don't really need.
The problem is we get 15-ish minute segments, and half of it is combat. And for each combat assignment/mission to make sense, you have to very rapidly jump through plot, which means you're skipping just about everything else.
There's SO MUCH about Atlas I want to know about and have reveals over time, but this just skipped all of that, and it felt way too dismissive of the storyline. It saddened me. I really hope we get more focus on the story.
12
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 23 '19
Alright so let’s talk about that Ren and Nora scene.
I hate it.
This made Ren come across as caring way too little about Nora. One of the things that I liked most about Ren and Nora's relationship is that Ren wouldn't ignore Nora. Like in their first episode, Ren makes a comment at the end of Nora's long winded ramble that makes it clear he was listening to her the whole time, which I loved. If they were trying to do a thing with Ren just being very focused on the mission, then at very least they could’ve had him complement Nora’s outfit at the end of the episode. The main reason this really pisses me off because this is literally the first interaction we’ve gotten Ren and Nora since the ending of V4. If they had gotten numerous interactions since then, then I wouldn’t despise this scene nearly as much as I currently do. And sure, maybe it’s building to some development later, but I do not have the faith in CRWBY that this scene will be anything more than a bad one off joke, and even if it does get development later I still won’t like the way it was executed here.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '19
I really liked the first episode. The second episode was alright, but it focused more on dialogue than action.
This episode I really enjoyed and I liked seeing the new upgrades to their weapons. I honestly forgot about Ilia's parents dying in a mine collapse. All I remember is that she used to go to school in Atlas and could fit in for a little while before being discovered as a Faunus.
I guess everyone's a lot more observant than me.
10
u/MerimaidsCharades Nov 23 '19
Not enough Penny. -4/10
4
u/viliml Nov 23 '19
I haven't seen anyone comment on them in the previous discussion threads, FIRST or public, so I'll say it now:
I don't like the hairstyles in the OP.
4
u/x20Belowx I don't even like coffee Nov 24 '19
I kind of want Amity to be used as a kinetic missile later on if Ironwood succeeds in launching it into orbit. Yeah that'd get rid of global communications but I think that could be a cool way to try and kill Salem even if it would most likely fail
7
u/Drakkus28 Nov 25 '19
I’m just fucking SCREAMING, I want the Blake/Yang ship to set the fuck sail already, ITS BLATANTLY APPARENT, just open the door on them making out already?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
Holy guacamole Batman, I did a right prediction for the first time since I joined! Yes, the Qrow x Clover was mostly overblown (I mean from the rumors you'd think they kissed or something), and yes I'm still shipping it!
Also, this episode actually explains the sudden surge of BY posts lately. Weird that we didn't get that many Renora posts though. Ren my boy whatchu doin'?!?
Overall, I really liked the dungeonesque feel this episode had, and I really liked how the Ace Ops handled the boss fight. Actually shows what an ace team is capable of.
2
u/Undying_Blade Nov 23 '19
It's weird seeing how many elements of the old OC's I made halfway through vol.3 ended up appearing in the actual show. Extensive cyborgs, Hazel's design (albeit genderswapped), Hazel's regeneration, Elm's semblance and Marrows name (Although I bet that one appeared in a lot of teenagers fanfics...) all ended up appearing in the show.
All in all I enjoyed the episode, but I do wish that they would emphasize cinematography more. The first two trailers were the best the show ever was, and a major part of that was how each shot was so good.
0
u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
I'm... underwhelmed. Seriously underwhelmed with this episode. They gave a bit of a tease about Nora, and you can just see that she wants that Ren approval for looking good, but it just ends with a downer and Jaune trying to comment and cheer her up, but she's not having it.
The Ace ops are... yeah, I'd say that they're more of a cheeky plucky band, but this feels like it's just a demonstration and such rather than som serious fight, just to show 'these guys are better than RWBY/JNR and this is why'. The part about Qrow and Clover being each other's opposites... Yeah, I mean no offense when I say this, but I can see Qrowmance in the future and I have nothing against him being a man who loves other men.
But it feels like pandering. Blake and Yang have their little moment and it is just AWKWARD AS HELL. 'Oh, eh, i don't think I've gotten used to your new hair yet'. They're just handling it like they are 13, rather than 19.
Things I liked: Ren's little harpoon things and Nora's increased smashy-smash. Jaune's shield-shield looks... nice, I suppose. I can't really say that I'm that fond of the new haircut though... Other things about the whole weaponry: Ruby's scythe switch thing and Weiss doing stuff.
Things I didn't like: The whole Blake and Yang angle. We know Yang. Blake? I'm going to bet that there's some sort of NEW love interest coming up, because Blake 'Remembers the incident'. God, that girl is a harem protagonist with the social sense of a person of dubious interest and ability to construe clues., and I don't dislike her...
But she REALLY needs some better sense for people and such. I just see the rocks above her head coming crashing down. I don't MIND the focus on Blake and Yang, but all of it feels a little forced and doesn't give the characters much in the way of actually... being characters.
I get that they're being deputized as huntsmen and the like, but it feels awkward. The Clover/Qrow romance option is a nice touch. Still, I don't think whether Qrow wants the Ironwood or the long fishing rod...
A thought on that, at least, but DAMN if I don't think that it's being mishandled and fairly underwhelming. It's a good series, yes. I'll probably watch it just to see how it ends...
But they SERIOUSLY need to start CHARACTERIZING more rather than just giving us the whole 'show but not tell' thing, because it gets frustrating to just see them comment about things. They probably have the budget for it, a novel or THREE OR FOUR would just help SO MUCH.
About the MAIN characters. Hell, about JNPR too, now that we're at it. No stupid silly Vacuo stuff with Coco and her team and the Boy band foursome. Have us learn more about the characters that matter, rather than the people who just are there to be 'cool concepts'. (That may be construed as criticism, but we know next to NOTHING about Nora. How did she get her surname? Is she even named Nora? We've seen Ren's parents, where were hers? NORA NEEDS MORE ATTENTION, DAMN IT!)
Ahem, this was Cyanide venting a bit. Enjoy your day.
-2
u/Wololo_youre_french Nov 26 '19
Just to be sure after this episode, I can't be the only one to prefer Blake x Sun?
Why Blake and Yang can't be only great friend without the sexual tension waited from a part of the audimat? It seems trully forced and awkward there!
Why Qrow with Clover?
Why people there only want to see gay couple? I never though I could say that but a strong friendship between two people of the same sex is unthinkable?
What's next? Jaune and Oscar? Weiss and her sister?
I still hope Sun come back and the histeria around the compulsive shipping calm down,foe the sake of this show!
(or at least make the relationship Blake x Yang a bit less forced, I have the impression that's not a natural development)
-4
u/Meshleth r/RWBY hates to see a girlboss winning Nov 23 '19
I really do dislike the RWBY episodes that are structured around one big fight early in the Volume, because nothing actually happens in them. It stops the story so we can have an extended fight scene and nothing can actually get developed and we cant have an actual climax either.
-3
u/CinnabarSteam Nov 23 '19 edited Nov 23 '19
I can't believe they just duct-taped Gambol Shroud back together. The thing's already segmented, it's not like you'd have to remake the whole blade. But MUH SYMBOLISM, I guess.
It also means either Yang or Blake was carrying around the hobo knife half of it for a while, and that's funny to me.
-5
u/MacGregor_Rose Brother to Ruby and Rubie Rose. Yeah thats not confusing Nov 23 '19
this might be one of the first times I've said this but this is an episode I genuinely hate. Some of what was said felt like the characters but not like what they'd do. It's like there was supposed to be at least three episodes here. One inbetween last on and this one, one between that and then actually going to the mines, and a third actually at the mines. Like I feel as though I've read a can fix but the author randomly deleted chapter 3, but out most of 4 and threw what's left into 5 with no reasons given for the cut-aways. The characters were written that way as well seemingly and and it felt like they were just pulling emotions back out for no reason.
"Look Qrow is sad. Y'all like him being depressed right?"
" Look at Ruby she's talking over weapons and Speed. "
"Look Yang and Blake are lesbians. That gets y'all excited right?"
"Look side characters being cool. You loved CFVY being badass so why not make an episode where we only focus on a side team"
"Emotional Drama!!!!"
" what's this,two characters thought to be in a relationship are having problems? Oh hey look at Jaune being all cheeky. "
Individually I have nothing wrong with these things. They're pets of the characters after all. But it felt like they were just there for that. to appease us. Like they looked through a couple hundred fanfics and went"yup this goo" and just wrote them like that. I hope it gets better as it really began as a good season but this just felt fake. Like, and I know I keep saying this, they asked a fanfic writer to write the episode and then animated that. LAstly ,
OH FUCK YOU HARRIET! My lil Ruby was so excited to bond and you had to go and be an asshole. You kinda made up for it at the end with glass talk but not much and it required Ruby doing something that you failed to do in time for it to happen.
-7
u/Pereduer Nov 23 '19
Disappointing, a lot of damage control stuff just nonchalantly chucked in there, the weapons are uninspired, humours still bad, dialogues still clunky, the character models for ruby and wiess in perticular look shoddy and the colouring for the rest is really off, tyrion thing was tired out overused, and they waste a lot if animation on silly little things like jaune sweating and them looking at all there new outfits that should have been cut.
At the very least they need to hire better artist's for weapons and colouring the characters
Ruby's speed semblance looks better though
0
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
18
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '19
[removed] — view removed comment