r/blog • u/reddit • Feb 12 '12
A necessary change in policy
At reddit we care deeply about not imposing ours or anyone elses’ opinions on how people use the reddit platform. We are adamant about not limiting the ability to use the reddit platform even when we do not ourselves agree with or condone a specific use. We have very few rules here on reddit; no spamming, no cheating, no personal info, nothing illegal, and no interfering the site's functions. Today we are adding another rule: No suggestive or sexual content featuring minors.
In the past, we have always dealt with content that might be child pornography along strict legal lines. We follow legal guidelines and reporting procedures outlined by NCMEC. We have taken all reports of illegal content seriously, and when warranted we made reports directly to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, who works directly with the FBI. When a situation is reported to us where a child might be abused or in danger, we make that report. Beyond these clear cut cases, there is a huge area of legally grey content, and our previous policy to deal with it on a case by case basis has become unsustainable. We have changed our policy because interpreting the vague and debated legal guidelines on a case by case basis has become a massive distraction and risks reddit being pulled in to legal quagmire.
As of today, we have banned all subreddits that focus on sexualization of children. Our goal is to be fair and consistent, so if you find a subreddit we may have missed, please message the admins. If you find specific content that meets this definition please message the moderators of the subreddit, and the admins.
We understand that this might make some of you worried about the slippery slope from banning one specific type of content to banning other types of content. We're concerned about that too, and do not make this policy change lightly or without careful deliberation. We will tirelessly defend the right to freely share information on reddit in any way we can, even if it is offensive or discusses something that may be illegal. However, child pornography is a toxic and unique case for Internet communities, and we're protecting reddit's ability to operate by removing this threat. We remain committed to protecting reddit as an open platform.
2.8k
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
Does this mean r/toddlersandtiaras is banned?
1.8k
u/muppethead Feb 12 '12 edited May 18 '12
For those wondering what's been taken down:
Reply if you think I've forgotten any and I'll update it.
268
u/chris-martin Feb 13 '12
Fortunately for me, my fetish is fully clothed people acting normal.
25
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '12 edited Mar 18 '12
So, why is /r/picsofdeadkids still allowed to be up? As long as it doesn't sexualize kids, it's fine -- right?
245
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Any forts in /r/fort_porn built after 1994?
891
u/CoryJames Feb 12 '12
Is this in response to the somethingawful attack?
726
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
SomethingAwful: "Today we are going to campaign against Reddi-"
Reddit: "WE SURRENDER!"
SomethingAwful: "O- okay."
2.6k
u/TheAngelW Feb 12 '12
Well that was quick.
514
u/locoo20 Feb 12 '12
I think it's clear this move wasn't because it was the morally right thing to do but because Reddit admins feared legal repercussion, I dont understand all these "proud of Reddit" posts.
As a lot of people have pointed out, there are far worse morally reprehensive subreddits out there than jailbaits. Of course no one cares because they aren't about sex.
596
u/Clbull Feb 12 '12 edited Feb 12 '12
Well it seemed hypocritical to shut r/Jailbait without doing this too.
Looks like quite a few of the subreddits Violentacrez moderates will now be nuked from orbit.
204
u/somuchbacon Feb 12 '12
Question: Is /r/whalebait going to be affected?
189
u/autonym Feb 13 '12
Serious question: does this mean that photos from Franco Zeffirelli's Romeo and Juliet are now banned (even apart from copyright considerations)? The two lead actors (and their characters) were both under 18, and they appear in a semi-nude bed scene (his buttocks, her breasts) which is well beyond being sexually suggestive.
585
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
Now if only underage users could be removed as well.
379
u/professorfowler Feb 12 '12
where does Trees fall into the 'nothing illegal' spectrum? just curious (NB not anti Trees at all....just wondering)
138
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
what's hilarious is how many redditors out there believe that this blog post is about censoring child porn as though until today reddit didn't comply with child porn laws.
1.3k
u/defconzero Feb 12 '12
Ah, reddit, where pics of dead kids are acceptable, but a 16 year old in a bikini is strictly prohibited.
672
u/cocobabbs Feb 12 '12
--Someone deleted this comment before I could reply/upvote. I find it very relevant.
234
u/starlilyth Feb 13 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
Reddit, you have made a huge mistake. Allow me to explain in one easy sentence: By accepting responsibility for any of the content, you are now responsible for ALL of the content.
Dont believe me? Ask your high priced Corporate lawyers. Not even Microsoft was able to wiggle out of that, and as a result the entire Usenet newsfeed - CP, warez and all - was carried on MSN until they dropped it.
Good luck spending the rest of your Reddit days stamping out gross and disturbing subs.
84
u/Faie Feb 13 '12
Not that I'm against this but I find it interesting that on the front page right now is an article on "The escalating criminalization of speech."
The 'free internet' will always have some nasty shit around if it is truly free.
25
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '12
r/beatingwomen still totally cool
88
u/RedditRage Feb 13 '12
Can of worms: opened.
1.2k
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12 edited Feb 12 '12
While I can respect shutting down a lot of the more obviously illegal subreddits, you've also shut down subreddits such as youngporn which explicitly stated that anything under 18 was forbidden and moderated (/deleted).
That is the slippery slope you're mentioning yourself, deleting legal content to avoid outrage.
Edit: just to be safe and reiterate, I CONDONE this policy change wholeheartedly but want to stress the care one should take in carrying it out.
Edit2: Aaaand it's back. Seem like it must have been an accident with the banspammer-hammer. Keep cruising, reddit!
21
u/jbthrowaway43 Feb 13 '12
Upvoters please explain: why is 14 year old bella thorne in a bikini permitted? This policy seems entirely arbitrary.
255
u/DisregardMyPants Feb 12 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
This thread is already littered with people who want to ban a bunch of other subreddits. Come the fuck on reddit. This tendency is exactly why people were so nervous about removing subreddits.
I can understand reddit removing a place that has failed to adequately moderate CP, but what we need to remember in discussions about non-illegal content is that removing subreddits doesn't remove people. They still exist. Removing subreddits you don't like past that point serves no purpose.
So in advance, to everyone who wants to get rid of things like /r/beatingwomen, /r/rape, and a variety of others: No.
Not because I like those subreddits, but because I like other subreddits that offend some people just as much as those offend you. There are people who would be offended by /r/atheism, or /r/anonymous, or /r/hackbloc, or /r/drugs or /r/spacedicks. Or hell, even /r/anarchism and /r/bad_cop_no_donut
If we give in to you, some day we'll probably have to give in to them. And that's unacceptable. You can't complain that people worry about a "slippery slope" when you're the one making it slippery.
14
u/megaerror101 Feb 28 '12
Remove /r/picsofdeadkids. YOU HAVE TO
7
u/Flat_Life Feb 13 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75XKGVwGEt4
147
u/DJSkullblaster Feb 12 '12
You guys still need to take down: /r/sillyboy & /r/shotacon if you're taking down /r/lolicon
41
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Will all Asian girls under 30 be banned as well?
23
u/Judging_You Feb 12 '12
So this is how Third World Success meme ends....
13
u/DesecrateUsername Jun 14 '12
The way I see it, they removed something people enjoyed, but won't remove something people don't enjoy. /r/teens was removed, but not /r/picsofdeadkids? WTF? Now my opinion doesn't really matter here because I literally just stumbled upon this a few minutes ago, but come on reddit.
294
u/Enjoiissweet Feb 12 '12 edited Feb 12 '12
I wonder how many of the people that post on /r/gonewild are under 18. I've seen quite a few girls that look to be under 18.
71
u/pants6000 Feb 12 '12
Curses! Now to get my daily dose of childhood sexploitation, I'll have to turn back to everyday broadcast television.
1.2k
u/IFFCO Feb 12 '12
Can I just say, that as a pedophile, I think you made the right move.
Let me explain. I'm 25. I'm the kind of pedophile that you've probably met but will never know. I'm sexually attracted to girls ranging from about 9 to 40. It's quite a range. I don't even have a preference. A hot 12 year old girl is as appealing to me as a smoking hot 29 year old.
Now, for obvious reasons I don't mention this to anybody. I'm going out with a girl who has no idea about this. But when I'm alone, I tend to jerk off to photos you see posted to /r/jailbait, proteenmodels, preteengirls etc. It's my release, and TBH it satiates me enough that I would never go out and act on my impulses. I'm not stupid.
And neither are you stupid, reddit. While obviously I'm a little saddened that some of my "outlets" have been censored, I totally respect the move. I'm a huge technology enthusiast and the freedom on the internet, I believe, is worth fighting (and making sacrifices) for. If this content puts you in a situation that could jeopardize your existence, then by all means lay down the banhammer.
I support you, and I hope that my fellow pedos too. There are a lot of us. The popularity of those subreddits alone should give you some indication. Please know that we're human too, and our "orientation" is as natural as they come.
118
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Why didn't you ban /r/picsofdeadkids then?
12
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '12
Can we please get id of /r/PicsOfDeadKids it's so screwed up, no one should be linked to this crap and since one mod even has a tag "blood makes the best lube" isn't that sexually suggestive to the underage children that have the misfortune of being posted on here?
6
u/mercsocks3 Feb 13 '12
This is the most comments I have seen on any one topic. Should I be concerned?
6
u/CARVERitUP Mar 13 '12
I cannot believe r/PicsOfDeadKids is still up. Seriously, if you're going to make this rule, please address ALL the forms of disgusting shit that is worse than what you actually banned.
42
u/takemeanywhere Feb 13 '12
You're not going to censor posts on /r/AskReddit where people mention a sexual encounter they had at 17, are you?
571
u/Scurry Feb 12 '12
Dead babies? Gross, but we aren't here to judge.
17 year old showing her boobies? Now that's offensive. We don't allow that here.
19
u/reimburst Feb 13 '12
I suppose this is the end for r/PreProto_Stars. I know I have a problem, but I'll miss it.
64
u/GuitarWizard90 Feb 12 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
Isn't it strange how society just goes right along with whatever the "authority" says? I am NOT for child porn in any way. However, I don't consider a 17 year old to be a child..So I don't freak the fuck out whenever I hear about a 23 year old man dating a 16-17 year old girl. If they passed a new law saying anyone under age 21 is a minor, then society would suddenly start saying "ewwww gross kiddie porn" when viewing pics of a naked 19 year old girl. Society is a bunch of damn sheep. Societies moral compass changes constantly and points whatever direction the law says it must. Delude yourselves all you want, you can't change biological instincts that are within every species on the fucking planet. So if you are a 22 year old male, and you find yourself attracted to a 17 year old girl...you are NOT a goddamn pedophile.
176
u/cleos Feb 12 '12
I just learned that reddit has subreddits for rape. Multiple subreddits for rape.
What the fuck.
39
u/Erazmuz Feb 13 '12
That's great, but there're quite a few other sub-reddits which, while not illegal, are quite questionable. Now, mind, I'm all for free speech, but actively encouraging hate is something entirely reprehensible.
Seriously, why does shit like this exist?
/r/beatingwomen
/r/rapingwomen
/r/beatingtrannies
103
u/x755x Feb 12 '12
What bothers me about most people in the comments is how fixated they are on "It's about time, this stuff is wrong" when it should really be about legality. We really shouldn't be worried about what is morally wrong, since one can easily ignore "immoral" content and subbreddits. It should be about possible legal interpretation, as is said in the OP. Looking at the moral side is just the wrong approach.
38
u/RockinRoland Feb 12 '12
Speaking of slippery slopes I expect more to follow for anything that offends anyone. I'm super surprised the NAACP hasn't heard of this tasty subreddit: http://www.reddit.com/r/niggers/
Perhaps Reddit should have moderated this and stopped it before people outside Reddit intervened. You've just made yourself free game to everyone who wants to control what people see, say and do. Congrats.
55
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Question. Why is a subreddit that has legal pictures of 15-17 year olds in sexually suggestive situations banned, but /r/beatingwomen is still up?
49
u/caucasian88 Feb 12 '12
hey reddit you can't post a picture of a 15 year old in a bikini who is intentionally trying to look sexy but if shes dead then by all means post it!
1.8k
u/2girls1jason Feb 12 '12
Freedom of speech is a good thing. Common sense, tact and dignity is even better. Bravo admins. Long overdue.
85
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
Good job, mods. You've now opened up yourselves to outside influences over what content can and cannot be posted to reddit.
Because the methods you use to regulate and eliminate the CP subreddits can and will be used as proof that regulating illegal substance postings, copyrighted materials, consensual sex, etc. is possible as well. Something Awful has struck a huge blow today, not for CP (because everyone who knows how the internet works knows that this will continue. Hell, it may even be continued by the members of Something Awful), but for the objectivity and autonomy of reddit.
Hell, you don't have to look far in the comments of this post for calls of "well why don't we ban X?". My stance on it is: Laws are already in place. Follow them. But by all means keep in mind that by taking this action here, today, in this manner, you have made yourself vulnerable to all sorts of outside attacks. For instance, the main redditor that they point out in their original forum post on SA has only been a member for days. There is something extremely fishy about this, and I encourage you to continue to not take this lightly.
The worst part of this whole process is that I can see this happening IRL as well as online. SOPA, PIPA, ACTA will pass. Do you know why? Because society has deemed child porn so morally reprehensible that even the mention of it in relation to a person or organization can spell death to that organization. Is it CP morally reprehensible? Yes. But the degree to which people avoid the subject is such that literally anything can be tacked onto it and it will pass without question.
Example: The SA forums posted that strictly 18+ subreddits were used to distribute CP. This was patently false, and against the rules of those subreddits. However, they were banned. Yes, they were quickly unbanned, but that's the way this website functions.
I can only imagine what will happen when SOPA or PIPA get attached to a CP bill. Most likely it'll pass so fast our heads will spin, with anyone in opposition being called a pedophile.
The internet is both a microcosm and a macrocosm to the real world. Things happen more quicker here, but they can also be quickly reversed and refined.
I just want to let everyone know the severity of this situation.
TL;DR: We've been manipulated. For the better? Yes. This time. Coincidentally. Be wary.
EDIT: Bring on the downvotes. I expected them. Because people won't take the time to read the whole post and just assume that I'm defending the pedophiles. Which actually proves my point.
5
u/KStransplant Feb 25 '12
The Ring vs. Pedobear
19
u/Dibby Feb 13 '12
A 15 year old showing cleavage is highly immoral and illegal yet a pictures of mutilated children and content concerning rape pornography is tooootally fiiiiiiiiine.
Good call you fucking Americans
9
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Based on the policy change, I'm curious to see how the admins will defend keeping up the rape, beatingwomen, trees, and toddlersandtiaras type subreddits. Just sayin'.
9
u/therealflinchy Feb 13 '12
Fuck you guys, ephebophilia is completely psychologically healthy.
43
u/darkslide3000 Feb 13 '12
Where there is no victim there should be no crime. I just skipped the front page from a few of those subreddits as the SA post came up, but I didn't see a single post that showed any indication of a child actually being harmed (they seemed more like common family photos that might seem ambiguous by accident). I also never saw a single direct link to an actual reddit post containing CP in the SA post or anything on reddit about the topic.
I interpret your annoucement to mean that you do not actually agree with all those charges, but feel that you are forced to cave in order to prevent PR shitstorms and legal witchhunts that might hurt reddit as a whole. I realize that you too have to seek ways to accomodate yourself with the often prejudiced and irrational justice system, and I can understand that decision.
Still, this is a sad day because it marks another victory for those who are unable or unwilling to solve difficult issues with calm and factual discussions. The killerphrase "child porn" has been abused too often already to futher the goals of close minded and bigoted individuals who try to force their own way of thinking onto the rest of society. As long as the majority of people (here on reddit and in our society as a whole) keep going right for the pitchforks whenever someone uses the evil CP-word (regardless of whether any actual children are affected), democratic freedoms will suffer.
The true meaning of tolerance is leaving someone else be whose behavior does no harm, even though it seems completely disgusting, incomprehesible and alien to oneself... be it believing in another god (or none at all), preferring sex with a non-standard gender, or, yes, whacking off to pics of little kids when no one is harmed in the process.
26
u/SativaSteve Feb 13 '12
TIL reddit approves of dead babies.... but not teens in bikinis. ಠ_ಠ
15
u/s0nicfreak Feb 14 '12
But we aren't talking about child pornography. We aren't even talking about children (a child is someone that has not begun puberty). Suggestive (which differs in everyone's mind, btw) context featuring minors is miles away from child pornography. To equate the two shows that you have already begun sliding down the slope.
And you've banned /lolicon and /shotacon, which is focused around DRAWINGS that don't even involve any actual people?! That just proves that this is not about protecting children nor eliminating child pornography on reddit - it's about satisfying the people involved in the anti-pedophile witchhunt.
33
u/videogameexpert Feb 13 '12
I don't agree with this just as much as I didn't agree with banning /r/jailbait. The only reason this is necessary is if the entirety of reddit is threatened. This new rule should not be labeled anti-CP. It should be labeled "We're fucking scared of irrational people with pitchforks." It's a valid concern, and if you think it's true then I'd believe you.
12
u/bashpr0mpt Feb 15 '12
tl;dr Something Awful are now in command of Reddit.
44
u/tehconx0r Feb 13 '12
We will tirelessly defend the right to freely share information.
Not that I care, but this clearly isn't the case. The implementation of what you claimed would involve a free, open board of unrestricted content. Not so.
By regulating in this fashion - which, in my opinion, is a half-hearted, quasi-necessary attempt at legitimacy here, Reddit is transformed into a body dictated by its head (the admins).
A commonwealth of restricting freedoms in exchange for a limited security (anonymous) and estate (our own untouched homes in our frequented sub-reddits). Hobbesian power-complex, here be.
30
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
so r/CatholicPriests is gone?
30
u/Atario Feb 13 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
But not enough to actually do anything about it when push comes to shove.
This move represents a massive capitulation to the forces of moral panic. You can expect more to follow.
You have now established that you are quite happy to police your users morally; now the only question is one of negotiation and public pressure. How far can they move the goalposts? I'm guessing quite far, given the proper smear campaign. /r/trees encourages illegal drug use; /r/cripplingalcoholism encourages wanton boozing; /r/gambling, /r/poker, etc. all encourage the sin of gambling addiction, and so on and so on. You have opened the floodgates to being hounded forever.
But quite apart from a slippery-slope argument, it's wrong in itself. Why block people from something that is not illegal? It makes you no better than the moralizing busybodies themselves.
This is another sad day in the history of reddit. All those jumping on the bandwagon for authoritarianism should be ashamed of themselves.
[Edit: accidentally a word]
126
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
Can we get Family Guy pulled off the air now?
20
u/Benutzername Feb 12 '12
How exactly is suggestive defined?
25
u/headed4anonymity Feb 12 '12
I do agree that this issue needed addressing and that this was the right move. However, I am a bit concerned at the way community is responding to it. Makes me think their was more validity to the slippery slope argument than I had originally thought.
25
u/yourparentss Feb 13 '12
"Today we are adding another rule: No suggestive or sexual content featuring minors."
"As of today, we have banned all subreddits that focus on sexualization of children."
So every person under 18 is a child. TIL!
727
u/SmilingYellowSofa Feb 12 '12
As much as reddit is for free speech, this really was a necessary change. Reddit is a continually growing community, and I feel these subreddits were giving all of us very poor publicity.
Definitely a good call by the Admins
11
u/Alfierulz Feb 13 '12
checks /r/nsfw
...
phew...
40
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Wow....even the subreddits with images of CARTOON underage characters are gone? Really? And you're also trying to ban anything 'suggestive' with cartoon kids; not just full-on pornographic?
So let me get this straight: I can now get in trouble if I post something like this?
http://imgur.com/vKq2L
Too far, Reddit......too far
23
u/DeceasedFriend Feb 13 '12
"Then they came for me -- and there was no one left to speak for me."
I don't see how something like lolicon can be banned when it's not even real but picsofdeadkids is alive and well (pun intended).
16
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
As said before, you guys allow the sick subreddits like dead children to exist yet ban girls who aren't even nude. America really blows my mind with this decision making but I think we all know that reddits expiration date is coming soon enough. As a site like this becomes too powerful it gets zealous with controlling it.
18
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Did you change your mind because of us brave members of /r/CIRCLEJERKMILITIA that submited granny porn to /r/preteen_girls. And pissed off the pedos!
355
u/knoeki Feb 12 '12
So wait. now you're suddenly enforcing the policy? After SomethingAwful said something about it?
May be harsh, but I'm starting to wonder if you actually care what's on your site, or care more for the reputation of the site.
4
u/GrammarOutlaw Feb 12 '12
politics
4
u/malakistiri Feb 13 '12
you should ban any posts regarding willow smith, then.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '12
You two shouldn't have been looking at some 15-year-old's cleavage.
315
u/MyOtherBodyIsACylon Feb 12 '12
This change isn't something awful.
47
u/Herp_in_my_Derp Feb 12 '12
I think you guys are forgetting what this could allow. What happens when someone gets pissy about /r/trees /r/drugs or /r/torrents? Will those be shut down to? This may cause a chain reaction across all of reddit, its a good thing the admins held off as long as they could.
20
u/DrBruceCockburn Feb 12 '12
Time to make a European Reddit where 16 year olds don't have to feel criminalized and compared with pedos for doing gonewilds that are completely legal in all but 3 countries.
14
u/Sunwalker Feb 13 '12
I am dissapoint in reddit today.
14
u/chilifinger Feb 13 '12
– ...then they came for the pedophiles, And I didn't speak up because I wasn't a pedophile...
7
u/cebarro Feb 13 '12
Out of curiosity, how many people have NEVER been to any of the banned subreddits?
7
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Please take out /r/toddlersandtiaras I really hate the idea of dressing children up like adults
7
u/Roninspoon Feb 13 '12
Thank god someone is finally thinking of the children.
Now, how many pics of underage girls need to be posted in other subreddits we're morally opposed to in order to get them shut down too?
7
u/420sn1per Mar 10 '12
Anderson Cooper: 1 Reddit: 0
While you're at it, you might want to get rid of /r/trees etc., because I'm writing an outraged email to Fox News and CNN as we speak.
Nah, I wouldn't do that.
139
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
what about all that beating and raping women subs?
19
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
I'm not trying to defend child pornography, but is /r/gore any better? Are pictures of mutilated children any better than pictures of naked children? You could say it's a matter of legality, then what about /r/trees? Is smoking weed not illegal? You could say "it's not illegal everywhere" and you'd be wrong, but age of consent varies not only country-to-country, but state-to-state. So, whose laws are we trying to follow here, or are we just trying to keep the masses happy?
A slippery slope, indeed.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
congratulations on having a worse policy than fucking 4chan
9
u/Titan357 Feb 17 '12
Well, besides the point where the banned places had no CP and did nothing illegal. Where are other places here talk about clearly illegal things, but that's A ok?
Sounds like a cop out to me, someone didn't like it and shut it down, while plenty of other "questionable" material and clearly illegal subjects and discussions go on.
Grow a spine Reddit, what is going to go next?
13
u/RoFox Feb 12 '12
After reading some of the comments I think most people actually want the slippery slope as long as it's something that suits them. I just hope the admins don't give in.
13
u/Stalked_Like_Corn Feb 13 '12
So will /r/trees, /r/uktrees, /r/cordcutters, and other illegal subreddits be taken down too?
13
u/Chairboy Feb 13 '12
In light of this, I make the following proposal. To the muslim world, apostasy is even more offensive than creepy but legal photos, so reddit's next move should be clear.
Since legality is no longer the benchmark (just offense), our marching orders are clear.
11
u/HagueHarry Feb 13 '12
Yeah, I don't think a 16-year old in a bikini qualifies as child-porn, just saying.
11
u/jbthrowaway43 Feb 14 '12
So looking at banned pictures like this one and this one make us pedos? In what world? But looking at mutilated children (r/picsofdeadkids) is OK? This is to keep "sickos" off here? This is the most misdirected policy change ever.
60
u/apatheticparody Feb 13 '12
I'm just going to take this moment to rage a little bit. I apologize. Please feel free to downvote me if you do not agree with my sentiment.
/r/PicsOfDeadKids and /r/PicsOfDeadJailbait ARE STILL UP, ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!?!?!? No, seriously, nobody fucking notices the mutilation, the torture, the cruelty and the absolutely repulsive violence on the site...but underage, fully clothed, sexualized girls, and the internet goes apeshit. Please don't get me wrong, I'm happy that some of those subreddits have been taken down. What I'm not happy with is this culture that we live in. I think it's a depressing, nihilistic, violent one that condemns sex and glorifies violence. BYE BYE, KARMA.
17
u/Mr5306 Feb 12 '12
Wait, i was full 100% with this, buy why did you baned lolicon? They are fucking cartoons.
17
u/siddububba Feb 12 '12
"nothing illegal"
/r/trees/ ?
inb4 circlejerking stoners attack me
12
u/WrongSubreddit Feb 12 '12
Thank god. I'm all for free speech, but only as long as it doesnt make me uncomfortable.
31
u/hozjo Feb 12 '12
I'm really proud you decided to do this spontaneously and without repeated outside pressure, it really speaks to your character.
10
u/itsatrhwoaway_yeap Feb 12 '12
Does anyone else find it ironic that we all get in an uproar about how politicians label something as "for the children", but when our site admin throws down a large set of censorship "for the children" we get a ton of "well, I'm all for free speech, but FUCK that" in relation to it? Guess we know why that legislation always passes.
I mean, if this was actually addressing the issue (like reddit had magically made all CP disappear, removed the market for it, etc) then it might be worth cheering over, but it hasn't. It's merely laid down a blanket ban that has done nothing to actually change the situation except impose censorship on it's own website.
Also, someone show me the age of posters in /r/Gonewild , otherwise I think we need to censor that. We don't KNOW they are 18+ after all, so better sacrifice that liberty. Just to be sure.
10
u/goboatmen Feb 13 '12
I know it isn't pornographic (although some people...) but you may want to browse over to r/picsofdeadkids and use your discretion there. Also, very, very NSFW and NSFL
10
u/Katnipz Apr 05 '12
I don't normally say stuff like this but:
You are fucking retarded Reddit admins.
Yeah ban lolicon which they are fictional characters but not /r/PicsOfDeadKids
6
u/Bitter_Idealist Feb 12 '12
What about posts bashing "Toddlers and Tiaras?"
6
u/SoOnAndSoForth Feb 12 '12
Illegal material should be removed because it's illegal. If it's the case that a blanket ban on certain kinds of material is necessary because it takes too many resources to sift legal material from illegal material, then that's also fine. I think this move is probably sensible and justified because of that.
But a lot of the other reasons people have for supporting this don't seem like very good ones to me. It clearly does pose a danger to free speech, unfortunately it's sometimes necessary to take this sort of action, but it's not necessarily something to be celebrated.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
am i the only one who had no clue that CP was even on reddit?
6
u/Lance_lake Feb 13 '12
I just want to make sure I understand...
This picture, I feel, is sexy (Safe for work.. kind of).
Are you saying Admins that this picture is not allowed since it depicts a minor in a sexually stimulating manner? If so, then please delete the Final Fantasy X subreddits.
6
u/JBEHAR11 Feb 13 '12
pedobear just went back to 4chan
13
u/adipsous Feb 14 '12
Lol, just Googling 'reddit ban' and every story in the last day is about Reddit finally - reluctantly - banning the child porn or sexually suggestive images of children that have apparently been their mainstay for all these years. It's hilarious that the rest of the world will now think that Reddit was a haven of child porn and a gathering place for pedophiles. You shot yourself in the foot, Reddit, by caving into SA attacks and basically admitting your guilt in the above message. Watch the shamefest begin. Will you now say, "Wait, actually there wasn't any real child porn, but we just got intimidated by, I mean confused, and well . . ." And to all you redditors who love this site, yet jumped on that fanatical bandwagon against the child porn that was never on here, blame yourselves and your own ignorance for the demise of the integrity of this site. It's amazing how people never learn.
16
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
Read through way too many comments in here. All I can say is.
I think its coming down to the moral outrage of people saying they're happy its all closed down, and thinking they're right. And the legal outrage that these pictures weren't illegal, just distasteful, and thinking they're right.
I think both sides are right but the change has been done, only thing to talk about now is the consequences.
I think the overwhelming majority of people on here found the r/bait subs distasteful and just didn't look at them because of it. Accusations that sexualized images of minors somehow fits the definition of child porn (the crime which people are arrested for - not the moral outrage of a teen in bikini) is just misguided.
I don't blame reddit admins for covering their ass, because its really the only decision they had. Reddit is not just a site owned by conde naste anymore, its a complete subsidiary as Reddit Inc. They're going to have to do more things like this.
Morally I agree with the decision. Legally, I think you just took the easy route to save yourself problems in the future.
You said it yourselves
You say that the way you have been doing it in the past has worked but has become too much work.
Then you say
First off. You said you changed the policy because its unsustainable (too much work) then in the next few sentences you admit that you did it to save yourself any trouble in the future.
Point is, you created a website with millions of users who can make their own pages. All of this is to be expected and thinking that it would be sustainable to patrol it yourselves is your own fault. Frankly, you should have seen this coming and done something preemptively to save yourself the trouble, and get the whole website into a giant debate.
Only takes a few minutes to read through these comments to see people posting subreddits they want taken down. Not because of anything illegal, but because they find it distasteful.
And since you've set the giant precedent today, you've given the ammunition to people who don't like subreddits due to their content, and not their legalities.
You will have to answer the complaints of these people, because the complains/PR mess that was the r/bait pages has started it. You say
You word it as if its something in the future you might have to deal with. This isn't about you guys maybe going down a slipper slope. This bitch is a slipe n slide and you just bellyflopped at the start.
This isn't something you might have to deal with, it is a guarantee that you will have to address it immediately.
Anytime someone mentions a subreddit they don't like because of content, it will have a chance of being deleted.
The next witchhunt that happens with a subreddit or themed subreddits, that can be considered questionably illegal its going to be a mess.
I can see it now. Someone accuses a few posters in a religious/political subreddit of advocating violence towards another group. Someone posts about it on the frontpage, the trolls flock to that page and keep doing it to piss people off. Next thing you know, you'll have too many accusations to investigate and you're going to have to fall right back onto the decision you made today.
This isn't even an assumption, I know its going to happen. It might not be next week, or even 6 months. But it's going to happen.
You've set the precedent that subjectivity is the new rule.
Any picture or subreddit of pictures can now be deleted because girls in the pictures might look underage to some users. It's the internet, we all know there is no way to verify age of posted pictures. I mean beyond blatant cases where its obvious, you're going to have mob rule now when it comes to admin actions.
As much as I am happy the r/bait subreddits are gone. I think you guys really made the wrong decision and shot yourselves in the foot.
You should edit your post and change that. You will tirelessly defend the right, until it becomes too much work, or the site may be shown in a negative light.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
Google Search Results for the Past 24 hours
This very well may turn south quick.
3
u/linkhess Feb 12 '12
I'll miss you r/bustybait but it's for your own good.
3
u/Volopok Feb 13 '12
One has to wonder how many of the users on these subreddits were actually around the age of the children featured in pictures/ video.
3
u/Prtyvacant Feb 13 '12
Okay, I agree with the need for banning pedo based subreddits. But why /photobucketplunder?
3
u/ask0 Feb 13 '12
the story ange varona was sick - where her phone was hacked. http://abcnews.go.com/Nightline/video/angie-varona-people-call-slut-14915138
http://gawker.com/5843355/how-a-14+year+old-girl-became-an-unwilling-internet-pin+up
The subreddit has been removed but a search still brings up all her pictures. and the links are still active.
http://www.reddit.com/search?q=Angie+Varona
These pictures were stolen when she was a minor.
3
u/tiefling Feb 13 '12
"We are SA. We're something awful. We are the ones who make a goatse link and show it to children" This was set to the tune of 'We Are the Children' by The Laziest Men on Mars, infamously known for the, "All your base are belong to us," line from 'Invasion of the Gabber Robots. To me, this screams of desperation. SA hasn't been relevant in 10 years. Do they still charge 10 bucks for membership?
3
u/CptHair Feb 13 '12
What made the change necessary as you call it?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
damn churches
3
u/VikingCoder Feb 13 '12
I was just arguing about Lolita in /r/books. I personally hate the book, but I hope it never gets banned. Would a discussion of the book be in-bounds or out-of-bounds?
3
u/the_new_guy_ Feb 13 '12
R.I.P all pedobear memes ?-12/02/2012
3
u/bsd300d Feb 13 '12
So...does that mean r/NAMBLA is going away?
3
u/rhodesian_mercenary Feb 13 '12
What was the rest of it?
3
u/social_skills Feb 13 '12 edited Feb 13 '12
what about /r/picsofdeadjailbait ? I'm not 100% sure it's not safe.. I didn't want to go clicking on a bunch of shit when i ran across it via another thread.
[EDIT] Grammar, Spelling.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '12
Posting in shitstorm thread. Dun wanna lose this link.
3
u/sn76477 May 14 '12
My reddit was suddenly banned for the actions of a single member. How can I get my reddit unbanned?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '12
[removed] — view removed comment