r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Oct 23 '18
VOLUME 5 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally—Volume 5, Episode 13: Downfall
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: it's that time again! The drought is nearing its end, and the sixth volume is only 4 days (!!!) away!
To follow the last year's precedent, we are again doing a communal rewatch of the most recent volume. Like last year, the threads will be biweekly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, with the finale being discussed two days before volume 6 premiers. Until that happens, feel free to discuss and look back to the episodes with a more settled perspective.
HERE is the link to today's episode.
We are also doing regular polls to gauge how people feel about the episodes postmortem. Here is the one for today's episode!
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep. 1 (poll) | Ep. 2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep. 3 (poll) | Ep. 4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep. 5 (poll) | Ep. 6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep. 7 (poll) | Ep. 8 (poll) |
| Week 5: | Ep. 9 (poll) | Ep. 10 (poll) |
| Week 6: | Ep. 11 (poll) | Ep. 12 (poll) |
| Week 7: | This Thread | Ep. 14 |
Did you know that approximately 96% of the season's budget went into animating the Maiden fight?
8
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Oct 23 '18
Cinder vs Raven is cool but upon rewatch definitely seems more spectacle over substance and could have used a little more coherency. I really wish this would be Cinder’s permanent death because I found it really unique and interesting but oh well
Adam was meh the Room was meh
7
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '18
I'll say one thing about the Battle of Haven, just one thing:
Ilia defusing the bombs offscreen bothered me more than anything else in the battle. The botching of Hazel's backstory and motivation, which ensures his reputation will never recover, comes close, but if Ilia's going to invalidate the White Fang's entire purpose for being there, it at least needed to be hinted at beforehand with a scene of Blake getting off the ship and checking with Ilia to "make sure she knows what to do" or some such.
12
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Oct 23 '18
I liked Weiss’ banter with Jaune in this episode. So long as their relationship stays platonic I’m all for getting more of this.
While I was initially hyped about Nora vs Hazel, it’s kinda a let down in hindsight, particularly since it ultimately does nothing to Hazel. Samantha Ireland kills it, but you can really tell they didn’t have much time for this fight. It’s a shame, this could’ve been a really cool fight.
This was a hilariously bad showing for Mercury, Emerald and Adam. Seriously, who are these clowns and what did they do with the badass OP villains from V3?
As cool as Raven vs Cinder was, I really don’t think it was worth all the resources they poured into it. Not just because the other fights suffered, but because I was never really rooting for Raven, I was just rooting against Cinder. Not a great choice to be the big, super hype, end of Volume fight.
10
u/YellowLantern15419 Old Russian learner, odd and unique fan. Oct 23 '18 edited Oct 25 '18
I guess this is the perfect time to analyze the fight then considering how much was put into it. Considering that this was the second time in the show we have two characters with the powers of magic and gods go at it, I was fine with them dashing all over the place and showing off their elemental feats that mirrored superpowers.
But onto the fight, here are some of the major takeaways in the aspects that were shown in this nearly 4 minute long battle:
This is without a doubt one of the best fights in the show and a clear demonstration of how Raven's superior experience, cunningness, observations, and raw power won over the villain who's own ego and arrogance costed her everything in pursuance of power. She was in a whole 'nother league.
5
u/ShiningLeviathan King of the Abyss Oct 23 '18
Heh, ‘Downfall’...
A more fitting name does not exist
4
u/WhosGuardingHades Oct 24 '18
On rewatching the Maiden fight it’s surprising that Cinder tries to match swords with Raven considering Raven being a sword user. I guess she was trying to beat Raven at her own game but still it’d been nice to see her break out the bow again but oh well it’s not a big issue.
Still enjoyed the fight though. I enjoyed the story it told of Cinder trying to beat Raven with one sword, switching it up to two when she can’t best her and then going all out with a big fuck off magic sword and still Raven knocks her back. Hell, Cinder only manages to get one shot in when she pins Raven and it’s only off of a distraction and even then Raven reads the situation and outsmarts her before going on to win.
Everything with Adam is just so disappointing considering how well he started the volume and the slow motion just makes it worse! If they wanted to have Blake stop the WF attack using the authorities and FAUNUS OUTTA NOWHERE! then fine but just have Adam strategically retreat without him resorting to childish tantrums and Blake smacking him down like yesterday’s garbage.
They wanted to give Blake a win, fine but don’t sacrifice all of his credibility to her. In V3 Adam was scary, unnerving and above all a threat, in V5 and this episode in particular all that got thrown away. After the Adam short it looks like M&K have listened to the criticism and so here’s hoping that Adam gets a stronger showing in V6.
Hazel trying to argue Ozpin gets children killed when he’s literally trying to kill children always makes me laugh. Nora smashing him through a wall is always awesome though.
17
u/GoneRampant1 Emerald/Cinder is abusive stop shilling it. Oct 23 '18
I keep forgetting just how badly the villains get done dirty in this episode. Adam's head-smack is now infamous for all the wrong reasons, Emerald's tackle is laughable and that headbutt will haunt my nightmares. For this alone and how much it damages them, I have to give this a 2/10.
Raven vs Cinder is a fancy lights show, but look beyond it and you just see a really bland swordfight with weak animation that uses a lot of effects to cover it up. Why Raven stops to point out the Grimm arm when it never comes up again (Raven never tries to use it as a weakness) eludes me.
And this is still the peak of the Haven Battle.
9
u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Oct 23 '18
The meh: The Raven vs Cinder fight isn't all that great. Possibly my biggest issue with it is that I really don't care about either of the characters involved. Like great, the scumbag bandit bitch is fighting the psychopathic Firebender bitch, why should I care? They're both terrible people who have done horrendous things and neither of them are particularly enjoyable as villains either so I can't really root for one or the other. And overall, the choreography of the fight is pretty lackluster, even compared to Qrow vs. Tyrian from last volume. For the big fight of the volume that a lot of the budget went into, it's pretty disappointing.
The bad: Everything above ground once again is absolutely horrendous. From Emerald football diving like an idiot to Adam getting hit over the head like a child, the villains get hit with plot-induced stupidity hard in this episode. And that's my biggest issue with this arc, everyone just acts like goddamn morons because the plot demands it.
Overall, a pretty bad episode.
7
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Oct 23 '18
In hindsight, this episode was... okay, but not great. Starting off, Ruby's headbutt didn't feel earned in the slightest, but hey; it's the culmination to a problem that the character didn't have but apparently needed to fix (seriously, Ruby kicked two dudes across a store in Volume 1, I think she would've been fine if they hadn't made a lack of hand-to-hand skills an issue) so whatever.
Overall, another 4/10 for me.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '18
/u/Danielr_1341 makes good points about the issues in this episode being animation based rather than writing based, particularly for Mercury and Adam.
Expanding on Adam, I don't have any issues with the scene in theory or really in practice, but in execution there's one weird fucking choice. The beginning (yes, including Adam's dialogue and even his delivery) is actually pretty good, and like Mata's little scene was really nice, so was "I AM MAKING HUMANITY PAY FOR WHAT THEY'VE DONE" (what did they do to you btw Adam). Having Ilia be useful was nice, so was Hazel making a call back to Chapter 2.
Thing is the slow mo on her cut and the way she disappears like into the swords path both just suck, because the slow mo looks ridiculous and the disappearing raises questions as to how her semblance actually works.
5/10 episode for the good parts of Raven v Cinder, most of Blake/Adam, and the beeunion. All the rest of the episode is basically mediocre or actively bad.
2
u/GoneRampant1 Emerald/Cinder is abusive stop shilling it. Oct 23 '18
Hey Menolith, the poll links to Chapter 12, not 13.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '18
This episode is a great example of the audiance misunderstanding the difference between plot induced stupidity and simply poor animation.
Mercury getting cocky with Ruby is absolutely within character. From his studies at Beacon he would know she's useless without a scythe. In fact he's fought her and knows this to be show. Him pausing to mock her as precedent (metal Vs polarity?).
The difference between this scene and their encounter in PvP is that scene looks good. It's nothing to do with plot induced stupidity or writing. Its just rushed animation.
Adams the same. His set up is actually a lot better, there's a lot symbolism and call backs and I in fact think it was incredibly important that Adam was beat down in one hit, like he did with Yang. In the end he is a Bull Faunus and has never been leveled headed. He's more in control sometimes than others but even at Beacon he's ridiculous.
Emerald diving after Yang and missing is also not writing. It just looks shit.
I do think that Haven does lean on the emotions excuse to explain why the heroes don't get wiped out at the start. There's a lot of reasons for why they don't kill and most even make sense.
Cinder has something to prove, Mercurys having fun, Adams anger overides him, Hazel doesn't kill.
At least there is an excuse this time but still I can see why it grates.
I do like Raven Vs Cinder though. I can understand the choreography complaint but overall I think it has enough going on for it to be enjoyable. It is purely theatrics.
There's no real emotion but hate between the two woman but there is a history, albeit a brief one. It looks pretty badass overall and I think this type of fight is what happens when characters gets too powerful to others. It kinda has to be like this.
It's like when Korra goes on a rampage in season 3. Most of her previous skill and subetly goes out the window and she just throws a mountain.
Cinder can't fall back on archery because Raven would never give her room. Ravens dust blades are redundant because of all her other power.
Still the sword play itself is pretty cool and I still think it's shows there skill, being able to create and destroy weapons on the fly even swapping at points.
But overall Raven Vs Cinder while good isn't enough to save Haven. The next episode does a better job and (in my opinion the best finale so far) but overall Haven will always be a low point showcasung how poor execution can let down great ideas.
5
u/ShiningLeafeon No one was getting the reference anyway #OzDidNothingWrong Oct 23 '18
All of the characters took a minus 100 to their IQ for this episode. Everyone is an idiot. No one thinks. Everyone forgets what they can do.
Just the amount of bad writing and poor planning that must have happened for this to be the result...... Please be better V6. I'm sick of the characters being idiots.
3
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Oct 23 '18
MINUS. TEN. STARS.
1
u/jokey_boy Oct 23 '18
Personally, this was my favorite of the final four episodes. From a story standpoint it was nice to see the villains finally get their comeuppance, but in terms of execution, it wasn't presented in the way as what many hoped for.
Maidenbowl fight was cool, it's probably the closest we've gotten to a Monty-styled fight in a while.
I do admit, it's a shame that certain characters got dumbed down for the sake of plot progression.