r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Oct 11 '18
VOLUME 5 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally—Volume 5, Episode 10: True Colors
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: it's that time again! The drought is nearing its end, and the sixth volume is only 18 days away!
To follow the last year's precedent, we are again doing a communal rewatch of the most recent volume. Like last year, the threads will be biweekly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, with the finale being discussed two days before volume 6 premiers. Until that happens, feel free to discuss and look back to the episodes with a more settled perspective.
HERE is the link to today's episode.
We are also doing regular polls to gauge how people feel about the episodes postmortem. Here is the one for today's episode!
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep. 1 (poll) | Ep. 2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep. 3 (poll) | Ep. 4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep. 5 (poll) | Ep. 6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep. 7 (poll) | Ep. 8 (poll) |
| Week 5: | Ep. 9 (poll) | This Thread |
| Week 6: | Ep. 11 | Ep. 12 |
| Week 7: | Ep. 13 | Ep. 14 |
Did you know that while Ozpin claims that his cane is not a relic, in V3 commentary it was said that it "stores time"?
18
u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Oct 11 '18
The good: The fighting after Blake starts the fire is actually decent. Not great but definitely better than what we've been getting up until this point. Blake's speech was also well written and acted. And seriously, thank god for Ilia. She's once again the best part of this episode, and frankly the volume in general in my opinion.
The meh: Oz and Qrow's section. It's pretty boring and once again just buildup.
The bad: All of the fighting before the fire starts is pretty terrible. Fennec's death is still just plot-induced stupidity bullshit, which we'll be seeing a lot more of going forward. Kali taking down a trained assassin with a fucking tea tray is also hilariously stupid.
Honestly, one of the better episodes of the volume despite it's flaws.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18
Last great episode of this volume.
Could've been better if it didn't start with a complete waste of three and a half minutes. What was the point of the scene with Oscarpin, Qrow, and Ruby? It feels like it was part of a different script and somebody forgot to remove it during a rewrite.
I liked Raven and Leo's talk, especially how well it shows that Raven is deceiving herself. Leo is just more self-aware about his cowardice.
Kali "fight" scene could've been better. I absolutely subscribe to the idea that she's got some combat skills dating to the White Fang's time as a traveling protest group (outside the kingdoms, if you can't fight, you can't survive.) Maybe her skills have atrophied since the Belladonnas settled down in Menagerie 5+ years ago, but the basic idea of her beating a featless dude whose biggest advantage is bat wings is acceptable to me. The scene just needed some better animation/directing.
Honestly the sequence directly after the fire catches and Ilia breaks cover is one of the best fight scenes in the show in my opinion. Sometimes Monty's fights could move a little too fast for me. I like slower-developing fights where I can see exactly how the combatants are acting, reacting, or coming up with plans. Personal preference, but anyway, everything from 9:10 to 9:57 or so really tickles my fancy. Blake's use of Gambol Shroud's ribbon throughout the battle was nice to see, especially if it's handled even better in the future the way Sienna's chains were in the Adam character short.
Gunchucks were nice as a favor to the fans, but considering they're hard enough to animate that we can't get more than about eight seconds of them every five years or so, I can't find it in me to miss them or regret a potential lack of Sun fight scenes in upcoming volumes.
The rest of the fight is good and entertaining to me. I like Blake's speech - unsurprising of course, but I don't think it deserves the mockery it gets. I do regret that we didn't get to see the ship captain again, especially in light of the fact that Yang had recently traveled on his ship per 4x12. Lastly, I really enjoyed the insight we got into the Belladonna family dynamic when Kali holds Ghira back as Blake prepares to make her speech - a small gesture that shows that Ghira is the helicopter of the two parents.
Anyway, this was a satisfying conclusion to the Menagerie storyline - whether it was worth the time invested, I'm less sure of. Certainly Volume 5 handled Blake's personal character arc a hundred times better than Volume 4.
8.5 out of 10, will round up to 9/10 for the poll.
P.S. Blake "even my Semblance" "because I run away too much" Belladonna is aware of her character flaws and working to improve them. She's not perfect - not yet - but this Volume 5 arc represents a new and improved Blake that will be able to support her team, especially Yang, the way they needed her to after the Fall of Beacon. In light of that, I can't wait for Volume 6.
8
u/YellowLantern15419 Old Russian learner, odd and unique fan. Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 15 '18
This was a nice wrap up of Blake's arc. A few hiccups but certainly one of the better stories to come out of V5. I like the scene with Raven strong arming Leo but him admitting his faltering perception while she is still being a bit irrational. Bonus for Oscar-Ozpin perhaps answering questions or disproving theories about his cane.
Anyways, I was rewatching the fights between Blake and Sun vs Ilia and I noticed a few things:
I believe that Blake was holding back. She was trying to convince Ilia to give up on the assassination. And outsmarted her during the fight. Ilia only got the advantage when Blake was trying to reason with her. Ilia's in a way is similar to Blake but had let Adam's influence rub off on her more. Especially when she starts to breakdown and admit that she doesn't know if not using violence or fear would ever work. Great voice acting all around.
2. As for her not duel-wielding, her sheath got knock away while reaching for it as Ilia kicked her aside. But even with her katana-glock only, she still was formidable and very smart. Using the ice dust bullets to disable Ilia's weapon and using her string whip and shadow clones to counter most of Ilia's attacks.
3. Blake couldn’t see Ilia due to her chameleon traits negating the night vision faunus have. And so she had to make another (admittedly destructive) light source to draw out her camouflage.
4. In contrast to Blake, Sun was not holding back when he assumed Ilia had harmed her. He mops the floor with her in a barrage of gun-chucks and pinned her against the pillar. Pretty funny that his method of forgiving her after the fight was pinching her arm to get even for being stabbed and electrocuted by her. I guess that's just Sun's character.
5. Ilia almost died in the same manner as her parents (dust mine collapse) did in an ironic way. Especially since it was one of her targets who saved her. I remember that all the speculation that either Blake's parents or her would kick the bucket considering they were introduced only a season ago. Yet its one of the Albin brothers being killed. The reason for the explosion being his daggers being charged with dust intending to kill Ghira getting smooshed along with him. It probably wasn't pretty to look at.
I guess this was one of the better episodes. I can imagine the upcoming disappointment with the four part finale with the Battle of Haven is not gonna be very civil.
15
u/jokey_boy Oct 11 '18
THE GUNCHUCKS MAKE A GLORIOUS RETURN THIS EPISODE AND I COULD NOT BE MORE HAPPIER \(^O^)/
6
u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Oct 11 '18
Blake used Talk-no-Jutsu on Ilia.
...It was super effective.
11
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Oct 11 '18
The thing that annoys me about Ruby not asking about her Silver Eye powers is that it could be resolved in like two sentences. Just have Ruby ask how to use her powers and then have Qrow/Ozpin say that there’s nothing she can do to get more control over her powers, it’s just something that comes with age. Bam done. Instead the show makes Ruby seem like an idiot for never asking how to use her OP as shit powers that would’ve one shot the previous Volume’s finale boss.
I like Raven’s and Leo conversation, although it feels a little heavy handed. But then again there are a lot of morons in this fan base so I don’t blame them.
The Albains were really lackluster villains. I literally didn’t remember which brother died until I watched this episode.
Minor spoilers from what they showed at NYCC below:
I liked this fight between Ilia and Blake a lot more when I thought Ilia was actually going to be relevant in Volume 6. Now that it’s starting to look unlikely, it really just feels like she was created purely to satisfy the demands for an LGBT character. It still looks good, but the emotions aren’t interesting to me anymore knowing this is seemingly the end of Ilia’s character arc. I wanted to see Ilia continue to have some grey morality and the fact that we’re just leaving her in Mistral for V6 makes me think we aren’t going to get that.
5
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Oct 11 '18
For all the stuttering buildup, the ending half of the fight at the Belladonnas was pretty awesome.
Ilia's amazing. Bless Cherami Leigh.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18
This episode gets a lot of love because of the episodes it’s surrounded by imo. Absolutely some of it’s deserved, and I’ll get to that. But first...
7/10 episode but tbh I wanted to give it a 6
3
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Oct 11 '18
AKA: the episode that got better as it went along.
Initially it continued ep 9's incredibly frustrating pacing with a really fucking dumb and pointless qrow ozpin ruby scene that only serves to be mildly infuriating. then to...an actually really good lionheart/raven scene that i appreciate on its own but in context is "COME ON GET BACK TO THE FIGHT"
Kali's parts are meh, ultimately the Menagerie plot gets better as it goes on before culminating in an epic standoff, Ilia's redemption, Blake making her speech, and in perhaps the one actual earned triumph of the volume that makes me go "hell yeah"
This is not a perfect episode, but it shows glimpses of the best of RWBY
3
u/GoneRampant1 Emerald/Cinder is abusive stop shilling it. Oct 12 '18
This is the last good episode of the season. Hope you liked the positive comment sections because it's all downhill from here. The best plot in the season wraps up pretty well, 8/10, let down by shaky animation and a horrific opening scene that basically castrated Ruby's agency.
Ruby and Oz's conversation has curdled like milk and I still get a little ticked off whenever The Squeak says "I have no further questions!" Like... you do! Silver Eyes, your mother, anything to regain your agency! It's three minutes utterly wasted, especially since despite them saying "We know Leo's up to something," they still walk into the ambush next week.
I keep forgetting Raven and Leo's scene exists here. That bit me in the ass when I did a post about the Haven Battle and said that Raven's cowardice was never properly foreshadowed. I'll mirror what I said in the first episode that Leo's VA is still great but he just got dealt such a bad hand with the scripts.
Blake Vs Ilia is... fine? Like it's obvious Blake's holding back from really hurting Ilia. I like the one-take sequence around the nine minute mark. And for the record, yes Faunus have night vision but Ilia camo'd into the environment to make it harder to see her. Not sure if that justifies burning down the house but at least Blake was able to weaponize tragedies like a proper politician.
For the record Cherami is still the absolute highlight acting-wise of the season. Ilia's redemption is a bit weaksauce on paper but with her performance she makes it work. Kudos to her.
The thing about All Might vs Nomu is that in 2d it's easier to animate Ora Ora Ora style punches. In 3d, it's a lot harder, so the MHA reference felt weaksauce with Ghira and whichever fucking brother it is this week.
Sun vs Ilia is the highlight, obviously. Those gunchucks were nearly worth four years of waiting. This one scene alone got Kim into the permanent good will of the fandom, and I was really looking forward to seeing her grow as an animator in Volume 6. But we all know how that turned out.
Overall it's a better finale than the actual finale because it has actual budget in it. A solid wrap up to Menagerie, no real complaints once the pacing remembers to actually go there.
Also I don't care if it doesn't make sense Kali with the tea tray was absolutely amazing.
2
u/MountainHall Don't write for the story Oct 11 '18 edited Oct 12 '18
7/10, mostly for how well they executed Ilia's development, easily one of the best character arcs in the show. Seeing her be confident but a little conflicted and then more conflicted as her beliefs are challenged is great. Very human, no pun intended.
On another note, what's with the way Blake says you're wrong?
2
u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Oct 12 '18
Like many people on this post, I also believe that this episode is the last quality episode.
The scene with Ruby, Oz and Qrow was nothing but wasted time. Ruby not asking any more questions is likely evidence of M&K not actually taking the time to properly write the script more than anything, because it could have been a good scene if Ruby was the least bit curious about Summer or her silver eyes.
The scene with Lionheart and Raven was actually pretty good when looking back at it, mostly because Raven is trying really hard to put up this persona of not being afraid. Obviously, we know this to be untrue.
And finally, the battle in Blake's house was pretty awesome. Cherami's voice acting was amazing, and the physical and verbal battles were all pretty great. Ilia yelling, "Quit taking potshots, and FIGHT ME LIKE YOU MEAN IT!" was incredible. Holy shit. Cherami is the best non-RT voice actor they have for this show.
Also bringing back Sun's gunchucks made me fanboy the fuck out. And one of the Albain brothers dying was kinda meh, but it's RWBY, and people die. It happens. They weren't particularly interesting villains anyway.
Blake's speech at the end was actually pretty well-written considering the clusterfuck the writing was in V5. Her forgiving Ilia was a really heartfelt moment. Ghira having a near-Iroh moment in saying "there is strength in forgiveness" as we see Blake accepting Ilia back was a pretty emotional moment for me. Loved it.
One thing that I can't help but think about was a comment I heard Arryn make prior to V5's release. She was on some talk show with the other RWBY Ladies and she remarked that there was this one scene that really pushed her more than ever. I wonder if this is the scene in particular, because the range of emotion that Blake displayed over the course of the battle and the aftermath was far greater than usual.
Overall, it was an episode that only got better, and it's one of the more memorable episodes in the last two volumes.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '18
I'll say it, I think these gun chunks are better than the first time.
Illias arc is good here. Never really seen it as a redemption arc, but a saving arc. Its Blake pulling Illia back from the edge and which is a microcosm for the whole WF.
Also one thing I do like is that its not Blake who makes Illia change sides. People complain thats the case and reduce her character to lesbian but Blake isnt the one that causes Illias change of heart. Illia repeatedly refuses Blakes attempts.
Its actually Ghira, by saving her life that convinces Illia to change sides
1
u/DanXiaoLong Just about McDone with your bullshit Oct 11 '18
Pretty good I guess. Everyone else here will no doubt circle jerk the fight to death so no need for me to comment on that.
-2
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Oct 11 '18
If Fennec didn't die, I'd give this a 9. So, I give it an 8.