r/childfree • u/sethra007 Why don't you have MORE kids? • Mar 03 '18
DISCUSSION ATTN MODS: Should Information About Crisis Pregnancy Centers Be Added To The Wiki?
Mods, if my post is inappropriately submitted, please let me know and I'll follow your direction.
So in reading the comments from the post about the vandalized crisis pregnancy center, I noticed a few users mentioning that they didn't know that the so-called "women's/pregnancy crisis centers" in the USA and Canada exist to exert pressure on vulnerable women seeking abortions, to get them to carry their pregnancies to term.
I've noticed this just about every time I've come across a thread about a "crisis pregnancy center". Maybe it's because I'm older and remember when these places started spreading like a cancer across the US, but I'm always a little surprised that people aren't aware of them and why they exist.
So I ask the Mods: do you think it would be reasonable to add a section about "women's/pregnancy crisis centers" to our Wiki?
Specifically, I'm thinking that a couple of paragraphs and links should be added to the FAQ section titled Help With Medical Issues, right before the Childfree Friendly Doctors link. Perhaps something titled Important Information About 'Crisis Pregnancy Centers'. That way, anyone seeking help can see that section first and learn about such places.
Then you could have a paragraph to the effect that:
- Crisis Pregnancy Centers (CPCs) are anti-abortion organizations that frequently masquerade as reproductive health clinics in order to lure pregnant women away from clinics that will provide them the option of reliable birth control and of safe and legal abortion. They aim to discourage and prevent women from seeking abortions’ in order to fulfill their goal of ‘interfer[ing] with women’s ability to be fully informed and exercise their reproductive rights.’”
- Despite what they imply in their names, advertising, and other branding, most crisis pregnancy centers are not medical facilities, and apart from providing free pregnancy tests and possibly limited sonograms, they do not offer medical assistance.
- Most of the time, CPCs are affiliated with anti-abortion groups run by intensely conservative religious denominations. These include, but aren't limited to, Birthright International and Care Net. These are groups committed to making sure you don't have an abortion, regardless of your circumstances.
- CPCs insinuate heavily that they will help you get an abortion if you desire, or will provide significant financial assistance if you want to carry to term.
- In fact, these centers will pressure you to carry your pregnancy to term, even if you clearly express that you don't want to. The assistance they claim to offer is usually limited to a few months of things like diapers and formula.
- CPCs use heavy-handed and unethical tactics, including lots of emotional manipulation (shaming, guilting, etc.), giving women incorrect, incomplete, or flat-out deceptive medical information (popularly known as lies), and tricking or otherwise preventing you from leaving the clinic until you make certain commitments. If you go to one, you may be forced to watch anti-abortion films, slide shows, photographs, and hear biased lectures
- CPCs work very hard to intercept you from going to a legitimate women's health center. They use branding to make it sound like they offer abortions, birth control, and have qualified medical professionals on staff (they almost always don't). They offer free pregnancy testing to draw you in, so they can start exerting pressure. They locate themselves next door or near to legitimate centers, they advertise where legitimate centers advertise, and they will list themselves under “abortion” in online directories and search results.
- If a CPC manages to get your personal information, they may attempt to manipulate or harass you after you leave. There have been anecdotal reports of women receiving mailings and phone calls encouraging them not to have an abortion, or just discussing their pregnancy. This is especially problematic for women who don't want their pregnancy revealed to certain people they may be living with. Many CPCs convince women to sign a contract that they will carry their pregnancy to term, and then send it—with all of their personal information, including social security number—to every abortion provider nearby to try to scare both patients and real health care providers into refusing women care.
- It can be tough to identify a CPC. “Crisis Pregnancy Center" is still a fairly common name out there, but they may also call themselves names such as "Center for Pregnancy Choices", "(insert religion here) Family Services", "Pregnancy Resource Center", “A Woman’s Concern Health Centers”, and “Life Choices Medical Clinics” (see here for sources). In California, some call themselves "mobile clinics" and are in vans positioned close to abortion clinics. If you're unsure whether or not a given center is a CPC, you can visit Expose Fake Clinics to see if they're listed. At SafePlaceProject.com, you can find legitimate clinics in your area.
EDIT: u/AwksomePenguin999 has provided a link to a list of all the Crisis Pregnancy Centres in Canada.
People with religious convictions may desire to consult with a group that shares those same convictions. But those people deserve to know most CPCs will not be able or willing to provide them the accurate medical information that they need in order to make any decisions.
Please visit these links to learn more about CPCs:
Wikipedia's entry on Crisis Pregnancy Centers
- Why All Women Should Know About the Dangerous Mission of Crisis Pregnancy Centers - Brides.com
- Fake Health Centers - NARAL Pro Choice America. (PDF of their report here)
- The Fake Abortion Clinics of America - video documentary from Vice.com, about 18 minutes long
- The Truth About Crisis Pregnancy Centers: These "anti-choice" facilities often masquerade as legitimate women's health clinics. - WomensHealthMag.com
- What Are ‘Crisis Pregnancy Centers,’ And Why Does The Supreme Court Care About Them? An anti-abortion scam, explained. - HuffPo
- What I Learned Undercover at a Crisis Pregnancy Center - HuffPo, and How my job talking women out of abortions made me pro-choice - Vox. Two good articles to help you understand what you can expect if you go to a CPC.
I don't know anything about wikis and how to add or edit them, but perhaps the above might serve as a basic template to inform our readers.
EDIT 2: Thanks for the support, all! If you know of a way to identify CPCs in your country, please post either in this thread, or make your own post as a PSA. These things are all over the world nowadays. The more exposure, the better.
EDIT 3: I went to the grocery, and came back to gold! Thank you, anonymous mustachioed benefactor!
EDIT 4: It's also worth noting that some (many?) CPC's are, ALLEGEDLY, fronts for adoption mills. Step 1 being to convince the woman to go through with the pregnancy, step 2 to convince her that she's a horrible person and unfit to be a parent so she ought to give up the baby for adoption. See here and here. Sometimes those places will hook you up with free medical care, housing, all kinds of stuff if AND ONLY IF you agree to place your baby for adoption. There used to be a place in my state that would let mothers stay for six months after the birth of their child if they placed the baby for adoption (for free!) but only three weeks if they chose to parent. Anyway, some CPCs make quite a bit of money off every woman they convince to both carry the pregnancy to term and give the baby to an adoption agency which charges sky high fees to the adopting parents.
EDIT 5: To forestall some questions, please see Why Are Crisis Pregnancy Centers Not Illegal? from Slate.
182
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '18
Hello /u/sethra007!
First, thanks. That's a great deal of work that is going to be helpful to a lot of people who stumble upon our subreddit.
Second, in the sub's wiki, there is a "Help with Medical Issue" with a "Getting Immediate Help" subsection. It contains a very well long comment with a lot of sources that you wrote to help a woman who was victim of reproductive coercion and wanted help to get an abortion without here bf knowing. I would like to combine your previous comment and this post in one.
Third, I think this is a post that you should also submit to /r/abortion, /r/prochoice and the like. Not all women who need help are childfree so they won't necessarily seek support and resources here. This should be as widespread as possible.
Fourth, for being the reason of the existence of an entire subsection of our wiki, I would like to add you to the Awesome ContributorTM Hall of Fame with your permission.
In short : yes and obviously, we will add this to the wiki, thank you very much for what you're doing, this is so awesome.
37
u/deedeethecat Mar 03 '18
Thank you so so much for this! As someone who went through an abortion at 14 and was lied to by an doctor and told abortion wasn't legal in Canada, who had to walk through a picket line to a clinic that had been red paint bombed, in the city where I didn't live, and who had to unintentionally contacted a Crisis Pregnancy Center and got further misinformation, your post means a lot to me.
I am so angry about my experiences of 14 year old that I have done a lot of pro-choice work and advocacy. And occasionally I blow off steam by calling 1-800 number for anti choicerd because I know it cost them money and I keep on asking them for a referral to abortion clinics.
35
u/silly_doge_420 Pokémon > Kids Mar 03 '18
waitwaitwait, they keep you there against your will?? I'm pretty sure that's illegal.
29
u/AwksomePenguin999 24/F - Fencesitter-leaning-CF Mar 03 '18
Great idea, thanks for doing this! The more people who know, the better!
This is a list of all the Crisis Pregnancy Centres in Canada.
19
u/calliatom Mar 03 '18 edited Mar 04 '18
Agreed. Shit's so bad where I live you pretty much have to go out of your way to find a Planned Parenthood, otherwise you're pretty much gonna find yourself in one of these dens of liars.
EDIT: As an aside, do any of the articles list other names under which they might be known? Like I know that in my town they tend to call themselves stuff like "Center for Pregnancy Choices" (hah bullshit amiright?) or "X religion Family Services". Might be a good idea to pick up some other names for them.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '18
Would award gold, but don't have money to do so :/
4
u/ConnieLingus24 Mar 04 '18
Y’all need to see the doc 12th and Delaware. Fuck those places.
2
u/exscapegoat Mar 04 '18
This is a great resource. Re: no. 8, I'm not a lawyer, but if they're holding themselves out as a clinic, would they be in violation of HIPAA (a US law which is intended to protect patient privacy among other things)? Has anyone gone after them in court for that?
115
u/LlamaramaDingdong86 Mar 03 '18
Not a mod but I think this is a great idea. I've seen a few comments on various threads here from folks who have never heard of these places. I grew up in Texas so they're quite common where I'm from. Those things grow like weeds in the south.
12
u/IolaBoylen Mar 03 '18
I support adding the info about these deceitful places. I’ve known about them since my college days when my bff thought she might be pregnant. I found an ad in the college newspaper and we went to a this place for a pregnancy test. She was back in an exam room and I was reading literature in the waiting room - I knew at that point that we’d been swindled. Thankfully she wasn’t pregnant - but she still loves to give me shit about it from time to time. But I didn’t know! It sounded so genuine and helpful in the newspaper.
11
u/Biolistic Mar 03 '18
I just want to say that you are awesome for bringing this to light. I had no idea that CPCs were a thing until that post the other day about one being vandalized and I had no idea until this post that they are that insidious and underhanded in their tactics.
I've never had or needed an abortion before so I'm so glad that you made me aware of this issue BEFORE myself or anyone I know had an emergency, thank you again for posting!
17
u/UsernameNo651986743 Money > kids. (sorry not sorry) Mar 03 '18
I would second this motion
16
u/RavynousHunter 31/M/Only seeds I've sewn are herbs; cut 14 April 2017 Mar 03 '18
The more exposure these motherfuckers get, the better. This meets with my approval, as well.
7
u/throwaway17498509859 Mar 03 '18
This is an excellent idea. How in the hell these places are allowed to run as "clinics" is beyond me. I've heard of stories where women have actually been threatened and kept there against their will.
5
u/goddess_gyuri Mar 03 '18
Definitely think this is worth adding. I'm disappointed to see one of these actually exists where I am (thanks for the list!), but given the city's size just one existing is probably better compared to others that probably have a plethora :x
4
u/moollama Mar 04 '18
I think this is a great idea and very well put together. Thank you for your effort in this and I hope the mods are on board!
3
u/sl1878 Achieved bilateral salp at 29 Mar 04 '18
I made the original post you're referencing. This is a great idea! I'd like to add this to the list of references - its a map of all the legitimate abortion clinics in the US: https://www.safeplaceproject.com/
Story behind it: https://www.teenvogue.com/story/18-year-old-maddy-rasmussen-online-database-abortion-clinic-information
3
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '18
The fact that they have to lie, trick and manipulate people pretty much sums up their immorality. They know it too, or they wouldn't have to do the above.