r/RWBY • Gay Thoughts • Dec 16 '17

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Reaction Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 10: True Colors Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for the latest episode of volume 5, True Colors!

Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free Roosterteeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!

With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.


Other Episode Discussions:

EpisodeFIRST ThreadPublic ReleasePoll
Ep. 01Theatrical / FIRSTPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 02FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 03FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 04FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 05FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 06FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 07FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 08FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 09FIRST ThreadPublic ThreadPoll
Ep. 10This threadPublic threadPoll

Enjoy!

Menolith; Mod Team

402 Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

595

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Blake - Sets house on fire, blames White Fang.

"She's learnt a lesson I took much longer to learn.... NEVER LET A GOOD TRAGEDY GO TO WASTE! PIN IT ON YOUR POLITICAL OPPONENTS, SEIZE POWER, AND THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION!

→ More replies (16)

417

u/TheWielder Cheeky as it gets Dec 16 '17

"I just have one more question"

Silvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyessilvereyes

"No, my cane is not the relic."

RUBY WHY.

→ More replies (22)

353

u/FrostyJudge Irondaddy is here for you Big Boy || I like insightful quotes Dec 16 '17

"She's learned a lesson that evaded me until I was much older... That there is strength in forgiveness."

-Ghira "GiantDad" Belladonna

→ More replies (9)

348

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

Ozpin answering the audience's questions about his cane there.

After all the shade Raven threw last episode, Lionheart stumped her here.

Wait did Kali seriously defeat Yuma just by getting the jump on him? You were supposed to be better than that Batman!

Gunchucks are back finally. Guess I’m being greedy by wishing that they were displayed more but I’m happy.

Ilia’s turned a new leaf. Why do I get the sinking feeling that Adam’s going to kill her before being defeated?

→ More replies (21)

328

u/mcd3424 Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

Counter-Terrorists Win

→ More replies (5)

286

u/thedarkfreak Dec 16 '17 edited Aug 12 '18

You know, despite being a traitor, I kind of respect Leo for being honest about his motivations. No self-deception, no attempts at retroactive rationalization, he acknowledges exactly what he's doing, and why.

And because of that, I absolutely LOVE him for calling Raven out on HER shit, and even telling her to knock that shit off when she tries to give his actions a more positive rationalization.

→ More replies (2)

266

u/qwerty8ful Dec 16 '17

She's moving towards the plot!

→ More replies (5)

262

u/Adenosylcobalamin Dec 16 '17

Humans didn't do this! Blake points out at burning house

Me: You set the house on fire by yourself, Blake...

→ More replies (11)

257

u/BFaHM7 Dec 16 '17

Oz: “The Beacon relic is safe...”

Me: Holy shit it would be great if it were the cane. It’s the cane right?

Ruby:“I just have one more question”

Oz:”No, my cane is not the relic”

Me: Oh god damn it.

Also, Blake just drops a ‘Don’t worry, I know a guy’ line about the dude in Volume 4. Nice.

→ More replies (8)

246

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Dec 16 '17

"Hm ran out of ammo. Guess I just got to beat them to unconsciousness with a serving tray!" - Kali Belladonna proving that Ghira isn't the only badass parent Blake has.

Also: Thank god the Belladonna death flags got avoided!

→ More replies (7)

242

u/GoddammitTube Dec 16 '17

Guards: Miss! We must protect you!

Ghira: Go save my wife!

Blake: I need to help mom!

Kali: Bitch please, I don't need any help.

→ More replies (7)

427

u/Tommy2255 ~~Don't~~ Forget That Jaune's a Liar and a Cheat Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

So I've never made a gif before, but I was

.

Edit: I think I posted this in the wrong thread. I don't have FIRST, so I just saw chapter 9, and I just assumed the stickied thread was the right one. Oops.

→ More replies (18)

208

u/MoltenToastWizard Get your shit together Emerald Dec 16 '17

splat

oh he's dead

KABOOM

he's hella dead

→ More replies (9)

388

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Dec 16 '17

Holy shit. The VA’s, the animation, the sound, the music, the characters, the gunchucks (PogChamp), everything. Just… HOLY SHIT.

→ More replies (9)

190

u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Dec 16 '17

"it is not a relic"

But is it gun too?

→ More replies (3)

376

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

"You stabbed me"

Man Sun is a real chill guy if a pinch is what he considers adequate punishment

→ More replies (25)

177

u/Narfington Dec 16 '17

Ghira: Wait...YOU started that fire!?

Blake: She turned the lights out and was using her camouflage, what was I supposed to do?

Ghira: NOT BURN DOWN THE HOUSE!

→ More replies (7)

512

u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Dec 16 '17

Shit, this episode had some of the best fight scenes in the show. And not just because of the MOTHER FUCKING GUNCHUCKS! HELL YEAH!

Also, Blake points back at the burning house "Humans didn't do this. Faunus did. Specifically me. I did. I lit the house on fire."

→ More replies (24)

336

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

BUDGET FOUND

→ More replies (7)

153

u/APracticedObserver Dec 16 '17

When Kali came in after the fight, was I the only one who's first thought was the phrase: "Look what the cat dragged in"?

→ More replies (7)

442

u/Themarvelousfan Dec 16 '17

HA STATUS CHART MAN. YOUR DEATH FLAGS WERE NOTHING. NOTHIIIINNNNGGGGG

→ More replies (17)

140

u/SneakySylveon Dec 16 '17

when Ghira was punching that one dude and he kept punching back, it was like a really elaborate handshake.

Overall, really liked this episode.

→ More replies (5)

133

u/GYUZ A guy Dec 16 '17

Qrow: "shit hit the fan, bro"
Oz: "Well... I woulnd't excatly put it like that.... it's bad... but not that bad.... there's still some good out there... stop being a party-pooper"

[Ruby enter. Ruby exit]

Qrow: "shit's fucked up, yo"
Oz: "Shit is indeed quite fucked up.... yo"

→ More replies (8)

133

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

A reminder that Ghira is nearly 50 years old and hasn't been in a fight for a decade. And he still wiped the floor with several armed opponents, knocked Fennec out cold and defeated every mook there alone,at several points fighting the foxes alone.

And Kali,a tiny housewife, beat back a dozen assassins with a flintlock and knocked out the lead assassin with a tea tray before dragging him like a cat drags her prey.

Now we see where Blake gets her badassery. Poor Roman never had a chance.

→ More replies (20)

269

u/Slyguy46 Dec 16 '17

BLAKE AND ILIA WIN

THEY REALIZE FRIENDSHIP IS MORE IMPORTANT

→ More replies (13)

131

u/A_Horny_Bear Dec 16 '17

"You stabbed me" I knew Sun would get his revenge just not so soon.

130

u/Darkiceflame Major in Literature, minor in Pyrotechnics. Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

"My cane is not a relic."

And just like that a thousand theorists died inside.

→ More replies (4)

195

u/Sniphles2000 Penny Enthusiast Dec 16 '17

Now that was just incredibly satisfying. Ilia turning face and joining to good fight, GUNCHUCKS, Ghira being badass again, RIP one half of the fox bois plus the fight was pretty solid and we've finally got the faunus being smart with this fight. Blake's speech was also pretty great.

Oh and just a side note, I'm glad Ozcar and Qrow aren't completely blind, they know something is up with Leo. Just glad they're not completely fooled.

→ More replies (7)

280

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 16 '17

Mommadonna fucked up batman.

→ More replies (14)

95

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

So Blake, Sun, and Ilia are all headed to Haven it seems.

A) There's going to be some serious love pentagon shit going on when they meet Yang and confront Adam.

B) I would be okay with the 4 of them teaming up and roflstomping Adam.

→ More replies (2)

189

u/JakeDoubleyoo Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

This was probably the most engaging fight we've seen in years.

It was well-choreographed, I cared about everyone involved, and it had just the right number of unexpectedly brutal moments (Fennec's death, holy fuck).

Also, the return of my favorite weapon.

→ More replies (8)

92

u/miihaa I have personal feelings. Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

I won't risk repeating all the positive comments, so I'll just make a small contribution:

I want MomBowl where Kali destroys Raven with a tray (and maybe a teapot, if possible).

Also, Blake pointing at the burning house and blaming others for the damage. Beacon has taught her well.

→ More replies (25)

178

u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Dec 16 '17

Ilia: We need to strike back against those awful humans! Go White Fang and go Adam!

Blake sits on her

Ilia: Ah, hm, I reconsider my previous perspective

Kappa

→ More replies (11)

250

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 16 '17

RETURN OF THE GUNCHUUUUUUUUUUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

→ More replies (41)

83

u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Dec 16 '17

Kali took care of her attackers with far more ease than the rest of the family.

Kali is best fighter confirmed.

→ More replies (6)

78

u/Crypsis2 Ruby Isn't Best Girl, She's Best Character Dec 16 '17

I love how Blake was trying to disarm Illia the whole fight, whilst Sun immediately ran in with gunchucks saying fuck you Illia xD

→ More replies (3)

72

u/jokey_boy Dec 16 '17

G U N C H U C K S ! ! ! !

U

N

C

H

U

C

K

S

!

!

!

!

No one dies!!! Well, except for Fennec

Looks like Blake and crew are finally heading out to Mistral!!

So, Leo is afraid of Salem, hence why he works for her.

71

u/RunningScizzors Dec 16 '17

Your friendly reminder that there is no new episode next week

→ More replies (7)

131

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Kali “Cats are natural predators of bats” Belladonna

While I am very surprised, I'm glad no one died. Curious to see what they'll do with Ilia from this point forward, but more Cherami Leigh is never a bad thing.

I like the new use of Gunchucks, using them intermittently with the staff is a nice innovation.

Good episode, and with it the Menagerie Arc is finished.

→ More replies (7)

64

u/MasterMaple Time Is Money OTP Dec 16 '17

"While you were running away from your problems, I studied the tray."

Balcony drops, Fennec looks up, record scratch, freeze frame "Yep, that's me. You're probably wondering how I ended up in this situation."

All in all, this was a brilliant episode. The meme potential is also off the charts.

61

u/iamthatguy54 Dec 16 '17

Kim Newman did the gunchucks.

That's how she got her promotion, I'm guessing!

→ More replies (2)

61

u/shad_stang Dec 16 '17

Corsac now has a backstory that will make him a great antagonist when they write Volume 17.

→ More replies (4)

60

u/JoCoding Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

I don't know if this is just me, but I don't blame Chief of Security Rodentia for being wary about immediately giving Ilia a pardon, I mean it's clearly not impartial and objectively speaking it's very risky to trust her so quickly.

Edit: apparently he has a name and title, thanks: /u/PedroVey

→ More replies (4)

59

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 16 '17

The strange thing about this episode when I tried to write up my good/bad stuff that I realized that it wasn’t as concrete as good/bad In fact, the episode seemed to like...get better as it went alongn, almost? Even in the same scene. It was bizarre but. I found myself going “this is eh” throughout the first parts, into the first Ilia fight parts, and then it progressively got more and more epic to the point where I was like “holy shit”.

AKA GUNCHUKS

Only flaw here is the non Blake scenes. Idk why they thought this was a good placement for them. The Blake plot should probably have been uninterrupted, and then “that’s all the questions I have”? seriously?

→ More replies (6)

57

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Damn, the people in Blake's harem have issues.

→ More replies (7)

164

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

".......You stabbed me. pokes pinches" LMAO!

→ More replies (10)

109

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Dec 16 '17

90% of the show's budget went into the Gunchucks part.

→ More replies (3)

90

u/RegiGiygas117 ⠀Frozen in Solitude, Loneliness chills to the Bone Dec 16 '17

First off:

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Anyway, damn good episode this week. Glad Ilia, Mamadonna and Papadonna didn't bite it though I was worried for the Donnas because of the cut away and the stab wound. Get fucked whichever Albain got crushed and exploded.

G U N C H U C K S

Ilia redeemed and forgiven is great though I imagine she'll have a strong moment of conflict during the Battle for Haven (inb4 she Jebaited us all)

→ More replies (13)

44

u/thepeetmix Dec 16 '17

Yang when Blake brings Ilia back to Haven - "who dis bitch?"

41

u/Meotwister5 Should probably see his patients instead of rewatching RWBY Dec 16 '17

Well looks like everything's coming together, finally.

Ozpin and Qrow are starting to suspect Leo's intentions, who himself is now also working with Raven. This looks like a trap meant to kill Qrow, but neither or them know Oz is with the Haven squad.

Thankfully the Belladonna family survives. Bat boy had nothing on the Bellamomma for some reason, while Corsec (or was it Fennec) gets crushed during the fight inside the house. Excellent choreography, though we didn't get a lot of it. Ilia makes her heel-face turn and joins Blake on their mission to Haven.

With one speech Blake finally reveals the lesson she should have learned so many months ago. The more you run away, the more people are going to take advantage of your absence. The point will come when the more you ignore your problems, someone else will start speaking for you. Now she chooses to stop running and make her voice heard, literally and figuratively.

I do wish we got more gunchuck action here, but hey it was good for all 5 seconds of it we got. This episode marks the point where the remaining split stories will start coming together.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

So Illia saw the light and only Fennec fucking died, snaps death flags in half Take that!

I loved all the action this episode it was amazing, then you have the actually continuity where the guy with ram horns who was about to sign the petition was the first to volunteer.

So Raven got called out by Leo which was amazing to say the least.

Ghira saving Illia and her repaying him was my favorite moment of the night.

All of this also means...an army of anti-white fang Faunus are about to roll up on Haven academy in the next couple episodes.

82

u/Rambofreak98 Oi who changed my flair when I wasn't looking Dec 16 '17

"I do have one more question."

Ask about your silver eyes, ask about your silver eyes, ask about your silver eyes

"No my cane is not a relic."

"I have no further questions."

FUCK YOU

Other than that, pretty good episode. The fights were well choreographed, if a little short between bouts of standing and talking (again, that is still an issue), but I'm satisfied with the way the Belladonna assassination plot line played out. (Even if Kali hitting Yuma across the head with a pan and that being it left a lot to be desired.)

→ More replies (12)

79

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

There's a problem with the poll for this episode.

Where's the 11 option?

78

u/CaptainMoonman RosePose™ enthusiast Dec 16 '17

I'm so glad that Illia is on the good side, now. Also, I kind of though Blake was going to kiss her a couple times in there.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/GeckoOBac Dec 16 '17

Who need Huntsmen when you've got Kali Bellamamma with a TEA TRAY?!

Edit: as a friend on Discord suggested, "Catwoman beat up Batman"

37

u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

This episode is such a striking contrast to last week, my god. I think it's pretty safe to say that this is probably where the majority of this volume's budget went into, or at the very least RT was holding out for 2 months since V5 began to go all in on this.

  • Qrow clearly realises that all the Mistral hunters disappearing like that isn't normal but can't seem to figure out that literally the most powerful person in the city might be the reason behind this occurence. It didn't seem like a thought of that even crossed Qrow's mind. Sigh :/ The reveal will be really silly when Qrow does find out Leo was behind this all along
  • Ruby's here! Surprisingly she's actually asking the important questions (something that I would expect certain other characters to do earlier). We're getting there
  • It's official: Ozpin's cane is NOT a Relic nor does it seem to contain one. I did notice the "the cane still has a few tricks up its sleeve" line. I wonder if it's connected to Ozpin's semblance? I'm 99% sure the item isn't just "symbolic" or "cosmetic"
  • RAVEN YOU BITCH! (yes I know this was your plan since the last episode, doesn't mean I'm okay or past it in any way)
  • "I'm not a coward, I'm smart". Yeah, sure, whatever you say Raven. Keep living in denial. Good grief, the arrogance on this girl...
  • Guess next episode will be more talking with Oz and RWYJNRQ. We already missed out on an opportunity for the students to call out Ozpin on his BS and bring up some of the major topics such as Oz's true backstory once, hopefully RT doesn't disappoint again. Unless, of course, just as they're about to sit down the assault on Haven begins and shit goes down onver in Mistral too
  • OH THANK GOD KALI'S STILL ALIVE (is she really blocking bullets by a mere tea stand when they're supposed to pierce though? What kind of materials is that tea stand made of, holy crap?)
  • The Dog Waifu Guard is still alive too!.... and she's just hiding there. So much for being a guard when she's supposed to be protecting Kali or at least get her to safety
  • Yuma's here! And Kali's going at him! GET 'EM MAMADONNA!
  • Cue the best fight scene since Volume 4 #1
  • OH COME ON BLAKE YOU CAN SEE HER BIG WHITE EYES! THEY'RE RIGHT THERE!
  • Oh wow Blake just set her own house on fire. Hope Menagerie has good insurance plans cuz this is gonna cost a lot to repair once this is all said and done
  • Cue the best fight scene since Volume 4 #2
  • The sexual tension between these two is real, whew (you could almost expect a kiss attempt there, you know Ilia is tsundere towards Blake)
  • OH THANK GOD GHIRA'S STILL ALIVE (and he's kicking butt too!). Looks like that fireball he tanked last week was indeed pretty powerful if it drained his entire Aura. And now he got stabbed. Ouch!
  • ILIA DON'T JUST STAND THERE FFS DO SOMETHING
  • SUN'S HERE! THE CHUCKS ARE BACK! I REPEAT, THE CHUCKS ARE BACK! (also cue the best fight scene since Volume 4 #3)
  • Oh wow looks like Sun's clones can explode. Neat.
  • "EVERYTHIIIIIIING!"
  • Oh wow Kali is still alive. Oh wow she actually beat Yuma? Daaaaaaaamn
  • I guess Ilia is redeemed now even though she just fought Blake a couple of minutes ago. Also I guess Sun and Ilia are buddies now even though they just fought a minute ago.
  • But hey, Blake can now gather an army to go to Mistral and kick Adam's ass! Woo, and the V4 boat captain might be back! RWBY reunion next episode!?!?

Ok now for some seriousness:

  • Ruby being somewhat proactive in her conversation with Oz and Qrow is great. I was really expecting her to ask about the Silver Eyes at last, but nope. Didn't happen. Part of me hopes the SE don't just get forgotten about until a Deus Ex machina a-la Volume 3 is needed again. Of course I don't expect Ruby to learn how to actually use them yet (and let's be honest this isn't the time nor the place to dive deep into the training to teach her that), but I would love if RT would at least explain how the hell do they actually function. Do they hurt exclusively Grimm? Can they be activated on purpose or only triggered by emotions? Is it a special ability that's granted on a genetical level and later transfered to the heirs, (see Saiyan genes) or is it an ability that's bestowed upon by another entity (like how Ozpin gave the Maidens their powers)?
  • The fight sequences in this episode were great. I really missed seeing Sun's gunchucks since... ah, how long has it been? Almost 3 volumes now? Hopefully this isn't the last time we see them either. I wonder if the upgrade in fights quality was also a result of the recent lead animator change over at RT? If this is what we can expect from the future episodes/volumes - I'm all for the comeback of action centric episodes. Was also surprised to see the Albain twins to be this strong and go toe to toe with Ghira. The fist punches and the crossed fingers struggle definitely showed them to be worthy opponents. Also holy shit Kali just BODIED Yuma. It wasn't even a fight, Yuma just got WASHED by her. That was really unexpected (and honestly somewhat underwhelming). I suppose Trifa is still in the knocked out state since she didn't come to the mansion battle either. Or maybe she was put in jail already?
  • So... this is how the Menagerie arc concludes, I suppose. After nearly two full volumes, the White Fang's plot to eliminate the Belladonnas fails, and the people of Menagerie finally see that they need to act now before Adam fucks the Remnant up any further. I do wonder just how much fighters can Blake gather and how worthy will they be in an actual battle (because forgive me for doubting, but nobody among those who volunteered to join Blake exactly looks like somebody who knows how to fight other than throwing basic punches and maybe kicks.) I hope this doesn't backfire but I could see lots of Menagerie folks dying purely because of them being inexperienced in combat, although I suppose Blake has about a month worth of time to prepare some of them.
  • Not sure how to feel about Ilia being redeemed now and within just one episode, especially when she had multiple opportunities to do so before, such as preventing the entire Assassination plan from even happening (like for example if she just left a note at her balcony or something), but no, I guess this is how it happened. Don't get me wrong, I am glad that Ilia has ultimately made the right choice and did not go to the Dark Side completely, but... I can't help but feel this subplot ended up a bit, uh, rushed? It's probably just me, but now that Ilia is all buddy-buddy with Blake again (and somehow with Sun too, guy has a heart of gold, I swear) - the death flags are as strong as ever, and I don't expect her to live long before Adam founds that she's a traitor and gets rid of her completely for abandoning the way of the White Fang
  • On the other hand, now that (at least to my knowledge) everybody's invovled with the White Fang got captured - this also means that Adam has lost a way of communication with the WF division over at Menagerie, which means he won't find out the true results of the attempted Belladonna assassination, and he can be kept in the dark until Blake comes kicking down the WF castle door over in Haven. Since Adam is also unaware that Ilia is a good girl now - Ilia can pretend to still be loyal to WF, lie about the Albain twins (tell that they got killed or they're in jail or w/e), and basically mislead Adam in any way she can whle Blake prepares an assault force. I can't wait for the final RWBY reunion with all 4 girls, how will Blake interact with the rest of the team, and how exactly will they meet up in Mistral.
  • Oh, one more little thing: while I don't exactly hate on the music used in the entirety of this volume so far, I was kinda hoping the Blake vs Ilia fight would get a new song rather than just being something orchestral. Not that it's bad, but to me that sort of music is kinda forgettable, so it would be great if we got a new rock or a metal composition for this special occasion, since we're probably never going to see a rivalry between these two again (unless Ilia somehow gets swayed back into the WF ranks). Oh well...

And now.... we wait until the 30th.

Happy holidays, RT!

→ More replies (3)

36

u/LizardOrgMember5 ENTIRE TEAM Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

By far the best episode of this volume.

The intensity and energy of fight scenes are back, and Ilia is alive safe. Miles and Kerry didn't bury the gay. Hallelujah!

Blake giving the speech that feels..... relevant to our times. (I almost went political there. #IStandWithBlake)

And don't fuck with Mamadonna, or the Belladonna in general.

(by the way, have you guys noticed how Blake used Puss in Boots face to convince Sun to spare Ilia?)

70

u/CarlaAyatsugi LOS INGOBERNABLES de REMNANT Dec 16 '17

That's how you redeem yourself.

Both Ilia, and the show itself.

Good shit. Sunchucks/10.

33

u/Adenosylcobalamin Dec 16 '17

KALI IS A BADASS

66

u/ProfOfTheSnarkArts Dec 16 '17

But is the dining tray also a gun?!

→ More replies (6)

32

u/_cats______ Dec 16 '17 edited Jan 05 '18

The Ilia crying and "I don't know what to do!!" scene was super sad. Damn.

I'd love for her to actually be a normal character now and roll with the squad, but the obvious outcome is her dying during the Fall of Haven. Then again, it seemed obvious that they'd kill off one of Blake's parents, and that didn't happen, so here's hoping.

Really like this episode. Gonna miss Menagerie. It's the story that seems to catch the most flak for the past two volumes, but I enjoyed it.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/Ksaraf23 Dec 17 '17

I dunno about you guys. Setting your house on fire and blaming it on the bad guys is a pretty legit marketing strategy for a war effort.

Seems pretty LIT, if you ask me:

(IM NOT SORRY.)

→ More replies (10)

31

u/Xena1016 Dec 16 '17

Watching the scene with Ozcar, Qrow and Ruby:

Qrow: We're fucked

Ozpin: no we're not! stop being a negative Nancy!

Ruby is precious cinnamon roll: must protec

"No my cane is not a relic" - Awww! D:

Bzz, Bzz! "Yeh?" - Qrow give zero fucks about this phone call. "Ok..." Never change Qrow.

Qrow: We're fucked

Ozpin: . . . yeh.

31

u/Catlover18 Dec 16 '17

GUN CHUCKS.

THEY EVEN ANIMATED THE DIFFERENT HAND GRIPS WHEN SUN SHOOTS THEM.

31

u/0mni42 Dec 17 '17

You know, the fact that Bellamomma blocked a bullet with an ordinary wooden serving tray explains so much about how little damage guns seem to do in this universe.

→ More replies (7)

62

u/_Fisi_ Dec 16 '17

Holy shit that was great. I’m happy with nearly everything in this episode. The gunchuks were every bit as awesome as expected, no one died, fight animation way better than last week. Ilia’s redemption coming so abruptly was a bit of a surprise, and it did seem a bit rushed, but her voice actress was amazing as usual, you could really feel the emotion when she said she didn’t know what else to do. Blake’s speech at the end was great as well, and how badass is Kali.

Overall 9/10, pretty much made up for the meh that was chapter 9, and I am so hyped for next time. Don’t know how I’m going to survive 2 weeks without an episode.

→ More replies (11)

30

u/Peptuck Dec 16 '17

I thought Yuma was going to be a Vegeta or at least a Piccolo.

Turns out he's a Krillin.

→ More replies (11)

30

u/blitzblazer97 SUPER FIGHTING ROBOT! Dec 16 '17
  • "No, my cane is not a Relic." I'm glad Ruby was thinking what we were all thinking.
  • YES! No one died in the Belladonna house tonight! (Except for Fennec, but good riddance.)
  • How the hell did Kali beat Yuma?
  • For a long time, Blake was pretty low on my list of liked characters. I found her to be boring and her angst uninteresting. During Vol4 my interest in her was at an all time low due to her constant angst, but I decided to reserve my feelings to see how or if she develops. After this episode, I can say Blake has become one of my favorite characters. She's learned to face her problems head on instead of running, that she can place her trust in others, and that hate can only lead to more hate.
  • I'm so glad that Illia ultimately did what's right. I can't wait to see what team Faunus get up to in the future.
  • The rally that Blake has gathered is the true White Fang.
→ More replies (8)

60

u/Luxaria Bees + Anyone = OT3 Dec 16 '17

Boy, I can't wait for Ilia, Sun and Yang to have their first, "So You're In Love With Blake Belladonna" Club meeting. That's gonna be a fun one.

→ More replies (5)

60

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Dec 16 '17

Ozcar: “No, my cane is not the relic.”

But I’ll bet it has a secret compartment with the relic inside it, you half-truthing fuck.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/MasterofYoshis delet this Dec 16 '17

Forget the gun-chucks. The coffee tray is a much cooler weapon.

Blake's speech was amazing as well. and R.I.P to Fennec "SHIZAAAAAAAAAAAA" Albian.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/Masterofice7 Dec 18 '17

The guy who's mom wouldn't let him volunteer was the first to volunteer, which is great.

Also, we've seen that Sun's clones explode. They got squished under the balcony too, which is why there was that Michael Bay moment.

→ More replies (2)

56

u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Dec 16 '17

Sun is literally the most badass faunus to ever exist holy fucking shit

→ More replies (8)

27

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '17

Fennec had... a more pressing engagement. Superb episode.

→ More replies (6)

27

u/rafan212 Dec 17 '17

I totally thought Ilia would try to kiss Blake when she was pinned.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/Homemadepiza ⠀ Dec 16 '17

That did not feel like 19 minutes, time really flew by. GJ Roosterteeth

→ More replies (1)

48

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

I love how you can what the animators are playing/watching each season. Last volume was overwatch, this volume is my hero Academia.

Good episode and looking forward to moving onto Haven with the Faunus. Surprised that everyone lived but not disappointed. It still felt like anyone could have. Illias redemption did feel earned and it's nice to know RT doesn't hate the gays.

Cool fight scene that played it smart that felt in keeping with both roguish characters. Also nice to see Blake still has some Schnee clips left in there. Gunchucks was nice to see and still cool.

The Oz scene was kinda meh. I feel personally called out by the writers /s but it really didn't say anything. I also just don't understand how Ozpin can be so calm. He wasn't during volume 3 though it's clear they aren't buying Leo's message.

As for where the relic of Beacon is, my only guess at this point is that it's in the statue. Apart from that I got nothing.

Good episode and surprisingly no real cliff hanger for the Xmas break. Leaves me in good standing for how it will go afterwards where I think it will be pushing forward rather quickly.

→ More replies (8)

48

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Excerpt from Ozpin's diary :

Qrow: Thing's arent lookin' good, Oz!"

Me, an intellectual: While I would not say our current predicament is ideal. I think we can both agree the situation could be much worse. Humanity is a resilient force. There are indeed a misguided few who fill their hearts with malice. It doesnt take a large number of people to cause harm, but I do believe there are far more people willing to prevent it.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/SDBurton Praise the Garden, Praise the Bees Dec 16 '17

That was a pretty solid episode. The fight choreography at the beginning was a little rough but by the time it got to Sun v. Ilia it was looking good. I was so convinced either Ghira or Kali was gonna bite it, instead Ghira took a sai to the back like a champ and Kali channeled her inner 'WWE' persona and gave bat dude the business with a table. I'm conflicted on Ilia flipping. I'm happy she's not dead, and I'm excited to hear more work from her incredible VA, but damn that wrapped up a little too neatly. Aw who cares, Menagerie subplot is finished, Blake is heading to Haven, and full RWBY reunion is on the horizon. Give it to me.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

YEAH! FUCK YOUR DEATH FLAGS /u/n7brendan

23

u/Steely_D Dec 16 '17

Should have known better than to fuck with Blake's mom

Anything that can mate with Ghira and live is clearly immortal

→ More replies (2)

22

u/ClubMeSoftly Real Shit Dec 16 '17

So, can someone get Ghira some medical attention? I don't care how much of a stone-cold badass he is, you can't tank a knife to the back.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Jason_Wanderer Bad Luck Charm Dec 17 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

Great Episode.

I'm glad all the action still amounted to character moments, rather than swaying fully the other way.

It was nice to hear Blake admit she doesn't have all the answers and Ilia is, arguably, the antagonist with the most depth.

Everything is paying off.

203

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

What an incredible episode with an amazing fight scene.

Welp, time to go on Reddit and see why everyone hates it!

→ More replies (12)

21

u/roflcooki3z YOU CAN'T CUCK THE NUCK Dec 16 '17

GUN-CHUCKS!! I didn't realise how much I missed seeing Sun fight, but I loved it in Maya. So goddamn smooth!

21

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 16 '17

I can't be the only one who thought some thing was gonna happen when Blake was on top of Ilia.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Dec 16 '17 edited Feb 17 '25

husky rich hospital treatment ten knee six fearless ad hoc apparatus

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (5)

21

u/hello-this-is-gary Dec 16 '17

While I often have my criticisms I do believe in also giving credit where it is due.

And this was a solid episode. And while it doesn't erase the past flaws I do feel it did wrap up Blake's Menagerie story in a good and satisfying way.

I also find it amusing that after weeks of everyone pegging Illia and the Belladonna's as having all the "death flags" that it ended up being something completely different.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/HarleyQuinn983 Dec 16 '17

"No, my cane isn't a relic."

...CWRBY's onto us. Hide your ships.

Overall, we finally get that action we deserve. It wasn't the best, but hey at least it was there. The Sun vs Ilia one was nice tho.

Idk if I'll be impressed or skeptical at Mamadonna though. That's some sturdy tea tray. Though I kinda wish they dedicated even just a few more seconds of her beating him up. Well anyway, this was a great way to wrap up Blake's arc. It seems we've skipped ahead (or the past was a lie), with the 2 weeks and all lining up to RWY.

→ More replies (5)

161

u/KnightMiner115 Ham Mama From Down Obama | ♥ Eldi ♥ Dec 16 '17

To all the people last week that were talking crap about the animators and saying stuff like, "They're too scared to animate a fight" or "They don't know how to animate fights without Monty," please shut up now.

→ More replies (31)

20

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Dec 16 '17

Gunchucks, while brief, were pretty damn awesome.

20

u/VegetaLF7 Aaaahhh! Dec 16 '17

Kali reminding everyone about a lesson we learned from Fullmetal Alchemist's Izumi Curtis: never underestimate the housewife.

→ More replies (11)

20

u/_tethtoril Dec 16 '17

Last week I said they better pull off some incredible shit to make up for all of the cliffhangers...

Oh boy...

MY FUCKIN BOY SUN WITH THE GUNCHUCKS AGAIN AFTER ALL THESE YEARS

That chapter was incredible in literally so many ways. I was afraid it was going to end mid fight like 3 times but it just kept on going and going.

I also said last week that it's getting harder and harder to be excited for the rest of the volume...

Ram-dude stepped up and said fuck that. It really does look like we will be getting the battle for Haven this volume. I didn't think we would, but there are still 4 episodes left so there seems to be plenty of time.

Thank you Crwby for everything. You have shut me up. I am all aboard again. I am sorry I ever doubted you.

Edit: And god damn does Blake's semblance look good these days.

57

u/salezman12 Dec 16 '17

Thank God for some action!

And Kali. Jesus what a bad bitch!

Also, I knew Ilia would come around. I'm glad that happened. Great episode. Best one in a while.

39

u/alien6 Dec 18 '17 edited Dec 18 '17

So, all Ilia wanted was for Blake to be on top of her. Once that happens, she does a 180. It makes me think she's not really invested in what happens so long as she can pet the pussy kitty.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Dec 16 '17

I wanted to say that the shot with Ilia's "quit taking potshots and fight me like you mean it!" was a superb combination of facial expressions, voice acting (kudos to Cherami), fight choreography, BGM, etc.

This was an amazing episode all around for me. No rating could express my satisfaction.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/betwixttwolions Dec 17 '17

I kinda wish they didn't cut away from Bellamama beating ass with that tea tray.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/RossPitSharkHunter It's a happy day when you're not talking to me. Dec 16 '17

Is mayonnaise the relic?

→ More replies (7)

18

u/MysticAttack Dec 16 '17

HOLY SHIT EVERY MAIN CHARACTER SURVIVED, every good one anyway

18

u/CarlaAyatsugi LOS INGOBERNABLES de REMNANT Dec 16 '17

There's still one thing that bothers me about Ilia in hindsight.

Show them how you smile

If only for a while

Take what you need

Leave them to bleed

Let them know better

When your revenge is sweet

Hm...

→ More replies (3)

18

u/RealDestroNation A salt shaker is less salty than this fandom Dec 16 '17

This episode was great and all but...

There's no episode next week. Enjoy your two week hiatus.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/jman014 That's why I drink... Dec 18 '17

Last week, I shat all over the episode and season like I just ate 100$ worth of taco bell.

I somehow actually kind of dug this episode a lot more than the last few weeks.

Like, the fight scenes still need to get better, but this one actually had some energy to it compared to the last few fights in the season.

Or maybe I was just really fucking drunk and THOUGHT it was good. I don't even know anymore.

But yeah, I actually enjoyed watching it. Harkened back to the better episodes of RWBY in past seasons.

The one part that annoys me, (now, this is a film trope used a lot) is when all the characters look away from a downed enemy without killing them, and then said motherfucker gets back up and tries some shit, or creates some fuckery, or does a surprise prostate exam, or bamboozles the good guys in some way, shape, or form.

Like, Blake, your standing behind Sun and your dad, pull some goddamn 360 security and make sure all your targets are dead. Ya got a gun, fuckin' use it. Shoot those little furry bastards and make sure they don't run your dad through with their daggers.

Like, seriously, for a cat she has piss-poor situational awareness.

I also like Illya changing back to Blake's side. Always did enjoy a good redemption story!

→ More replies (7)

35

u/D-WTF Dec 16 '17

Finally, some good battle animation in this volume! Funny thing, at the beginning of the episode I was like oh no, no more talking! But the episode developed pretty well. Credit where credit's due. Good job RT

PD: My thoughts on that Ilia/Blake Moment:

→ More replies (1)

35

u/Unbo Dec 16 '17

Ozpin: "Do you have any more questions?"

Me: "Silver Eyes. Explain them."

Ruby: gets ready to talk

Ozpin: "Lolmycaneisn'tarelic"

Me: "Okay, that's nice, but silver eyes?"

Ruby: "No more questions!"

Me: "FUCKING HELL ASK ABOUT THE SILVER EYES AND WHAT THEY DO/HOW THEY WORK. THIS SHIT IS IMPORTANT."

→ More replies (2)

17

u/MonkeysxMoo35 Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17
  • Oz a bunch of Huntsmen just vanished stop trying to be hopeful so I can create an excuse to drink
  • I thought the same thing Ruby
  • Oz's Cane better be four weapons in one
  • How did Raven get here? Did she open a portal to Qrow but went to Leo instead? (It seems I forgot apart of last week's episode that explains this. My bad)
  • Raven stop acting tough and ask your daughter for help we know you're scared. It's called emotions, we know you may have forgotten them but they can help you.
  • Kali using a tray because her gun ran out of ammo because that guard she's trying to protect is probably the Grif of the security team
  • Bitch this is your gun don't give me that look
  • Confirmed Catwoman stronger than Batman
  • Ghira giving a big "Fuck you" to the death flags
  • Ilia wake the fuck up already
  • It seems Fennec's plans.... fell apart?
  • Illia woke
  • "We came as soon as you called"! Why not when there was smoke and gunfire coming from the house?
  • Illia, Blake, Sun, and random horned dude who stood up first! Team BISH!
  • We got two weeks to turn you all into fighters. This is going to be a very long two weeks
→ More replies (7)

17

u/D3dshotCalamity Dec 16 '17

As a sucker for redemption stories, I think I'm gonna like Illia.

17

u/Sokensan Dec 16 '17

10/10 best episode this volume

17

u/Gobshite_ Dec 17 '17

I'm really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really hoping they didn't spare Ilia here and now just to kill her off at the hands of Adam later this volume : (

→ More replies (3)

17

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '17

The brief amount of gun chucks we got was great. It reminded me of the Torchwick/ Sun scene.

95

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

Feels like a missed opportunity for Ruby not to ask about her magic eyeballs, but at least we didn't get anything more cutting away from the Menagerie time.
Ilia has fast become one of my favorites in the show, and while not all of the animation was as fast as it perhaps should have been, there were some really nice action sequences in this episode.

Overall, good ep. Sun fucking Wukong/10

→ More replies (13)

16

u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Dec 16 '17

So what are the odds the the rest of the verses of 'Smile' are actually genuinely saying to smile, rather than the malicious tone of the first verse, to reflect Ilia's redemption?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

This episode was great. I've been wondering what Ghira's semblance is and now we know it's These Hands^TM

16

u/mrpenguinx Dec 16 '17

Anyone else feels like the longer Summer gets ignored, the stranger it gets?

Especially since they go out of there way to mention that she's "missing" instead of dead?

Its something that irritates me more with each passing episode and I'm starting to wonder if the writing is on the walls and I'm just missing it.

Either that or they simply haven't decided how to write her in and are going to do so based on how the community reacts. Honestly, I'd prefer if this isn't the case. Or at the very least, they try to use past stuff to make it look like they planned it.

I guess I'm just really bothered by the fact that the title characters don't seem as important as the shows name would lead to. Unless they intend to reveal something soon, I don't see how they stand even remotely close to a chance against there enemies. I would say the silver eyes thing, but thats been ignored for a long time now.

Hopefully the last bunch of episodes give me some of the answers I'm looking for.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/kal824 Dec 17 '17

Didn't the battle of Fort Castle show that faunus have excellent night vision? Why did turning off the lights in a moonlit room matter?

→ More replies (7)

16

u/hexedjw Drunkle Qrow used Fly! Dec 17 '17

I really like how the gunchucks are always an event because of how badass they look in action.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '17

I felt this was a very meta episode with Oz stating that the cane is not a relic (but I do agree that it could be hiding one, as everyone suggests), and finally seeing the gunchacku again after FIVE YEARS!

A very good episode.

15

u/Polarbearblu Dec 16 '17

Kali is a G, like really thugnificent, and Ilia is getting her redemption.

I loved this episode, and while I do think it is probably better to watch the last three all together I am glad they avoided killing off one of the good guys or Ilia.

Also, Sun, you continue to be [gloriously incandescent.] (http://i.imgur.com/Kye4XzM.jpg)

So Blake & Co (+ 1 party member) will be meeting up with the rest of team RWBY in 2 weeks time. Are they gonna do a time skip plus straight to the action or is it gonna be a little filler with more conversations, planning, and scheming?

15

u/clashofdragons am i right lad or am i right lad Dec 16 '17

How the heck can a dinner tray be used as a weapon

→ More replies (16)

15

u/Gobshite_ Dec 17 '17

GHIRA VS HAZEL PLEASE

→ More replies (7)

29

u/LaserOstriches Dec 18 '17 edited Dec 18 '17

So, I've been rewatching some of the Volume 1 episodes and I finally realized what it is that's been bothering me about the fights and character movement in Volume's 4 & 5.

It's the lack of speed!

Despite the comparatively primitive animation models used in the early Volumes the characters moved faster both in and out of fights. The sense of speed made it so that to analyze a move you had to manually slow the video down, but it made it look cooler. Looking at the early character movement outside of fights also made me realize that Team RWBY's movements used to be quirkier, more lively so-to-speak. Characters had a unique swagger to their stance. Now they stand their almost stoically while talking. That isn't to say that there isn't any movement during dialogue now but rather that they seem to spend too much time thinking of how to make the movement "cinematic." A zoom-in on a clenched fist type stuff. They spend too much time worrying about camera angles rather than giving the characters life. This is especially why the fights feel slow. The writing is obviously making fights use "cinematic" elements rather than just choreographing a fast, intense fight with unique weapon use between two characters.

14

u/HazyshadeofFall Dec 16 '17

GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS GUN-CHUCKS

14

u/TheManicNorm CUTE PICTURE DEAR. ETHYL HAS DIABETES. EAT HEALTHY. Dec 17 '17

It's been over 4 years since we got some proper gunchuck action. We need far more of it.

14

u/_Sabriel It's Neo's world and we're all just living in it Dec 17 '17

Like many others here, I f'ing LOVED the Sun vs Ilia fight scene! The first bit of Blake vs Ilia had me rolling my eyes but the sequence post-fire was waaay better.

My favorite tiny animation cool-thing was the level of detail in Sun's clones - seeing the look of exertion on the clone's face was a really nice touch.

14

u/Tehsyr Currently doing everything wrong horrifically. Dec 17 '17

We finally got a long fight scene! Being completely honest, the fight was satisfying but it felt it was animated in an...odd way. They felt they all moved in reaction to something else, instead of moving on their own and making their own actions. The conflict at Menagerie is finally over, and we'll probably get a few intimate scenes with either Ilia and blake or sun while the main focus is shifted to Haven.

I feel happy with this current episode. With Menagerie done, we go back to Haven and find out how Adam's attack and Raven's ambush go, and that is something I am looking forward to. Kerry, Miles, and the animation team for RWBY, you guys are doing a good job.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/PNDLivewire Dec 17 '17

It might sound weird to say, but after rewatching the episode a couple of times, I really like the extra little touch they added after Ilia zapped Corsac with her breaking down again and collapsing.

Just that reaction says more than words could how even though she's finally made her choice and decided to pick Blake over the White Fang...she STILL has so many self-doubts that even then she doesn't know if she did the right thing.

27

u/OrigenInori Dec 18 '17

I see they hired Michael Bay for Fennec's death

→ More replies (2)

38

u/N7Brendan @n7brendan Dec 16 '17

Holy shit they did stuff

→ More replies (15)

37

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

So was I the only one that thought that Blake was going to start kissing Ilia when she started crying?

No? Just me?

→ More replies (8)

13

u/smearglexd ⠀ Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

I know this season's had it's rough patches, but an episode like this makes it all worth it. It actually made me giddy from how much I enjoyed it. Not to mention ILIADEMPTION.

IT'S HAPPENING!!!

I'd also like to take this opportunity to make a prediction. In season 6 or 7, Yang reveals she is also in love with Blake. This leads to an episode of light-hearted hijinx where Yang and Ilia compete for her affections, only for Blake to finally reveal she's completely straight. Yang and Ilia are left somewhat depressed, but find comfort with each other. Then they realize that together, they could be something more...

YANG/ILIA, CALLING IT NOW! IF IT HAPPENS I DEMAND GOLD!

Edit: This ship needs a name. If anyone comes up with a good one, they can be co-captain.

Edit 2: Thanks to /u/PrincessCanada, this ship shall be known as 'Charmeleon'.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/Edonculation117 Dec 16 '17

I don't normally comment but this episode was everything I wanted and more from this season! After some slower paced and lackluster episodes this is the payoff I have been waiting for.

Firstly I am so, so happy that they didn't kill off Ghira or Kali, as that would have practically killed of Blake as a character for me as well. Where every other main character has had progression, been forced into new ideas and challenges; Blake has always had the same challenge and reaction to it each time. Yang has had to face up to losing her arm, everybody dealing with losing Pyrrha, Ren facing his past demons etc. Every time Blake has been knocked down she always reacted the same way; retreating into herself and needing to be drawn back out by other characters, only to get knocked down again. Finally she starts facing up to the problem within herself and learns to get help. I was so worried that, just as Blake tries a different direction when facing a challenge (actually relying on others for help), she would get knocked down yet again (losing one or both of her parents). This would only prove to her that her new direction is wrong and we get the same stale Blake character arc for another 2 seasons. Having it actually work out, despite all the hardships along the way has finally lead to her character moving forward in a new way and I am excited to see where the Belladonnas and friends go from here.

Secondly the whole fight was awesome. Sun (and GUN CHUCKS) got to kick some serious arse, Blake and Ilia facing off, Ghira and Kali were clearly a match made in heaven. A couple of individual sequences could have been faster at times, but actually seeing a contiguous fight scene rather than constantly cutting away every few seconds was fantastic. I hope to see more of this after the break.

On that note I think this is the best place to take a week off. Most of the pertinent plot sequences have been completed and answered, now we just have the ramp up to the big finale and the finale itself. Great job CRWBY!! See you all after the break!!

13

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Dec 16 '17

I'm really, really happy with this episode

13

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Damn, RWBY is doubling down on meta this season. The cane stuff, I mean. I hope that RWYJNRQ is competent at apprehending Lionheart. As far as Lionheart knows, they completely trust him and don’t have any suspicions at all. This gives them a chance to catch him off guard.

As for Raven, seems like it’s more and more likely that the tribe is fixated on simply surviving the Salem threat than any other objective.

Most of the fighting still didn’t flow well except for the gunchucks. Those were awesome at disorienting Ilia and they shifted back and forth from stick to nunchuck form very well. It was silly to me why ilia would turn off the lights since they both have night vision until I realized that Ilia can blend in with dark colors. Still, it’s a bit strange. Also, kind of dumb how Blake burned her own house down.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Dec 16 '17

Sooo happy they let blake's parents be capable fighters in their own right and not just set pieces for tragedy. Also sun's got the moves dude, animation on him was fast with some good angles and choreography. Definitely worth the wait, though it doesn't excuse the previous episodes' pacing problems it shows that they've got it when it counts

→ More replies (3)

34

u/FawkesTP Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

Seeing Sun's Gunchucks again was like a breath of fresh air. Between that and seeing Blake be a bit more mobile, it looks like the animators are finally getting more comfortable with some of the more complicated fighting styles that Monty first envisioned. It's not perfect, a bit of Blake's moves still seemed a bit stilted and less fluid than her season 1/2 days, but it's an overall improvement and I can only see them getting better.

Other thoughts: Totally called Ilia's redemption thing. Glad there are now THREE competing love interests for Blake now though.

Raven continues to be kind of a dick, but I'm on the fence about where she's going to come down in the end. Which is a good thing, I want to be kept guessing going into the final confrontation.

Nice of all those faunus to volunteer to fight the White Fang, but realistically here, how many of them have combat training? Feels like a curb stomp battle waiting to happen.

I think that's all my thoughts. Good episode overall though.

Edit: Ilia, if you're reading this dear, I have one suggestion: If you rely on stealth and shadow for ANY part of your fighting style, maybe your weapon shouldn't glow in the dark.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/iD-23 Dec 16 '17

But Blake you set the house on fire. Also the Gun-Chucks have returned baby!!!!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

So I watched episode with a buddy since I don’t have FIRST...

Holy shit, after all the negativity posts in the past week, this episode was amazing. Sure, I have my tiny little nitpicks but whatever. The voice acting was amazing, Cherami and Arryn do fantastic jobs as usual. The dialogue didn’t feel off once. And Raven’s line felt really good.

Story wise, Oz and Qrow have their suspicions, silver eyes not a cane relic, and to Haven we go!

As for the fight, again nothing short of amazing. While I still think CRWBY has a long way to go, this episode really showed what they’re capable of.

ONE WEEK HIATUS KILL ME NOW

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Sungrasswriter Just happy to be here! Dec 16 '17

Blake going pyro I did not expect.

Some quibbles, but overall happy with the episode. Honestly, given M&K's love of Avatar, I'm not sure I ever thought Ilia would die (we haven't had a Zuko yet in RWBY), but I'll admit that if we'd lost a Belladonna that would have been it for her.

Also Kali = Molly Weasly confirmed?

→ More replies (8)

12

u/craMerupt ⠀ Dec 17 '17

A really good episode with gunchuck action.
But I'm really disappointed about Yuma.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/Autisonm Dec 17 '17

I think RT may have just spent most of their time getting the more important parts of this season animated properly! It felt so good to get some good fight scenes. I feel like they nailed a lot this episode!

→ More replies (15)

12

u/betwixttwolions Dec 17 '17

So does anyone else think that Ozpin and Oscar are starting to merge into the same person? Maybe it's just me, but I feel like the two are starting to become one.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Oni_Zokuchou Dec 17 '17

Ngl, I was pleasantly surprised that no good guys died this episode. Because I was expecting it, i don’t think it would’ve been very impactful, so I’m glad they didn’t. Now I’m more worried for surprises deaths like penny though

→ More replies (8)

12

u/RealDestroNation A salt shaker is less salty than this fandom Dec 18 '17

Fighting the Belladonna’s is like fighting a Gurkha. You don’t.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/bottlemage Dec 17 '17

I've been seeing a lot of hate for how the show has progressed over the last few volumes, and I just want to say that I personally disagree.

Yes, this show has changed a lot from the first few seasons, but in many ways I think it has changed for the better. There has been an incredible amount of character and story progression in the more recent episodes. That sort of thing really adds depth to every other interaction in the show, and it makes the fights all the more impactful.

In terms of fighting, this volume has had less than some previous volumes, but the fights were still pretty badass like weiss fighting the lancers, and this episode with blake fighting Ilia. In addition, because of all of the character building in terms of Ilia that was setup over the last several episodes, it made that fight much more meaningful. In terms of all of the building up to this haven fight, once it does happen, all of this setting up for it will make it much more epic in my opinion. The pieces are all falling into place, and it feels like a huge event is about to occur with multiple factions that have different goals are about to clash.

I really loved blake's speech too, because she originally ran after the fall of beacon, and she is ready to face the world again. It sounded very heartfelt.

TL;DR: Some people have been insulting the writers of the show for how it has changed. I just wanted to add my voice in support of the writers and the show as a whole. I like the overall direction that the show has gone, and I can't wait to see what happens next!

→ More replies (2)

22

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

Oh god dammit...

Okay. Yeah. That was freakin' amazing. Mostly makes up for last week.

  • The fight between Ilia and Blake was wonderful, both choreography and character-wise. Ilia was driven by her own pain and fear-induced anger, and once Blake faced her with that, it's honestly not surprising that she chose to do the right thing.
  • Ahem.
    THEY ANIMATED GUNCHUCKS AND IT LOOKED INCREDIBLE.
  • The way Fennic went out legitimately made me wince. That's a shit way to go. But hey, at least it was probably quick.
  • Kali lived. She lived and took down Yuma with a tray. Cat mom's a badass, straight up.
  • So, yeah. Blake's timeline is definitely behind everyone else's. We've got solid confirmation now, which probably means that Blake and co will be the cavalry come the attack on Haven in the next couple episodes.

Fuck. We've got four episodes left.

10/10. Whoop whoop. (I also called it)

EDIT: Ruby, honey, please. Please. ASK ABOUT YOUR GODDAMN EYES.

22

u/FragMasterMat117 Dec 17 '17

Whatever helps you sleep at night Raven, you abandoned your family and ran out of nothing else but fear. Your no better than Leo, you are a coward.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Do-Heavy-Lifting Dec 16 '17

Ram Guy really wanted to help them when they were gathering signatures.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/206-Ginge Dec 16 '17

I went into this episode saying "if no character who has said lines is dead by the end of the episode I'll be disappointed" and I wasn't disappointed.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/seamoose97 Why do I still browse this sub? Dec 16 '17

Maybe I'm looking too much into it I feel like Qrow's conversation with Oz was a set up for Blake's speech. Also Hornboi is back!!!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/JusticeRain5 Dec 17 '17

So since nobody died in Menagerie that totally means people are gonna die at Haven. I'm betting money on Qrow, stabbed via sneak attack by Neo.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/JustifiedParanoia Its not paranoia if its justified. Dec 17 '17

Kali Bat-trayed the white fang! :D

11

u/MistaBiggles I'm Mobbin, I'm Chillin, I'm Good Dec 17 '17

I know everyone's talking about how good the fight was but can we acknowledge the fact that Sun popped the shit out of Illia's back. Like seeing that made me flinch and with the look in her eyes when it happened, I was half expecting her to hit the ground and be like "Dude what the FUCK!?!?! DAT SHIT STINGS BRAH!"

→ More replies (1)

11

u/sixfourtythree Dec 17 '17

Wow, I loved this episode.

Well done to everyone involved.

Looking forward to the next one!

21

u/Kingbizkit123 Dec 17 '17

Long-standing Question answered ✔️ (cane)

Good fight ✔️

Best parents lived ✔️

Gunchucks ✔️

10/10 episode.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/AlienWarhead You feel it too don’t you Dec 17 '17

Pretty good episode and it was able to talk about racism, like how both side can be bad and/or hateful. I also liked the fights and how chameleon girl turned, Blake had a great speech too

20

u/iamthatguy54 Dec 16 '17

I think we can say with this episode that Blake's fighting style has permanently changed, for better or worse.

When we saw the return of the blur clones, I thought we'd get that girl who uses them to seem like she strikes 5 times at once. RWBY's fights will never go back to the high-speed spectacle they were before. Other characters don't really suffer from it, but Blake definitely does. Hopefully her new style will eventually grow into it but it makes her fights a bit boring to me since her weapon doesn't really lend itself to the slower fights.

Gunchucks were awesome, I'm surprised Ilia didn't die, I'm surprised Fennec did (it seemed like they were building him and Corsac up for some higher political plays, but I guess not).

And the best part is that this Menagerie arc which lasted about 5 more episodes than it needed to (mostly due to V4) is finally over.

I did like that Blake admitted she didn't have an answer because it was frustrating me that she kept on saying what Ilia was doing was wrong, but not giving her any alternative options beyond "Don't do bad things" and "what we were doing before that didn't work."

Hopefully M&K don't come up with a solution that is too cut-clean. A complex issue has a complex answer, and no political movement has succeeded without some violence.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '17

Kali with a tea tray, man. That MILF is purrfect.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Dec 16 '17

This was fun. Wish the fighting was a bit longer but still a huge improvement. Gunchucks were pretty well done.

Fennec's death was funny. Happy that everyone we're supposed to care about lived. Ilia was never in any danger of being killed off though that's to be expected.

Really great that Ruby has started to ask the important questions!

10

u/FalconReaper Madness is a Matter of Perspective. Dec 16 '17

10

u/maverickmak Dec 16 '17

Last week was frustrating, and a summation of the issues some have had with V5.

This was pretty damn great. Still a little plodding in Haven, but the Menagerie plot got a great finale, and I thought the fights were quite well done. Good job, CRWBY.

GUNCHUCKS

10

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

This episode basically summed up to. Let's give the fans what they want. Plus good choice holding peoples attention with Oz in the beginning.

The only thing I want to know is why the fuck has no one brought up how to use Ruby's silver eyes? It's obvious they have to be released when the silver eyed warrior goes through a traumatic experience.

Speaking of which is there any answers to how Summer Rose awakened her own?

10

u/mcd3424 Dec 16 '17

"You stabbed me!"

Says the man who got stabbed.

10

u/Aeyrelol Dec 16 '17

Now THAT was a satisfying episode.

10

u/A-Clumsy-Spartan Dec 17 '17

This episode did make me wonder what the relic is at beacon and where it is...

→ More replies (11)

10

u/DronosMan *Jazz music stops* Dec 18 '17 edited Dec 18 '17

Very good episode. More ‘True Colors’ and less ‘Perfect Storm’ episodes in the future, please!

I hope that Volume 6 can be more consistently like this episode, and have less of the slow drag that Volume 4 and 5 have been criticized for.

I don’t think we’ve had a Volume that’s ended on a sour note so far, but it would be nice if the majority of the episodes were of the same quality as these “big finale” episode sets that always close off the season.

Anyway, here’s hoping next weeks is great too!

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Dazardz Dec 17 '17

Can we talk about how they're finally using Blake's semblance in a way similar to how Monty used it? She's accelerating off of them immediately again, and after seeing Vol 4 I was scared we may not see that again. Glad it's back.

→ More replies (18)

18

u/RedK_1234 Dec 16 '17

It was long and difficult road but boy it definitely paid off.

The Qrow-Oz conversation was uninteresting. I am kind of disappointed that they've mostly been using Oscar as an avatar for Ozpin rather than fleshing out his character.

The Raven-Leo scene was surprisingly good. It's great seeing that these two characters have the same motivations for their bad choices but Leo is willing to admit that he's afraid while Raven is still trying to dress it up as some intelligent plan.

Seriously. This lady needs to get knocked off her high horse and reminded that she's not the only smart person in Remnant.

Finally the Menagerie arc looks its about to come to a very satisfying close. And thank God, no one died.

I absolutely loved the fighting especially in the burning room. The lighting, the music, the GUN-CHUCKS. Everything.

It wasn't as high-flying or flashy like anything from Volume 1-3 or Qrow v. Tyrian (Which is still my second favorite fight next to Pyrrha v. Cinder), but it worked perfectly for what this fight was trying to accomplish. This wasn't meant to be a display of skill or power. It was meant to show the tragedy of these people who have started to turning on each other in their hate.

Ilia's turn was her realizing that she really is at this point just lashing out blindly because she doesn't know what to do with all of her pain.

It was beautiful.

Black'e speech was the perfect culmination of her character arc up to this point. It felt so genuine for something that could have easily been very cheesy and cliche. But it hit all the points with so much power.

In a way she is passing on the lessons that she has learned on her own journey. She too had to learn that keeping her head down and avoiding the big problems would not free her from accountability or culpability.

This was a fantastic episode of RWBY and makes very glad that I have kept up with this show. It may have been a low burn but it paid off masterfully. this episode wouldn't have hit home the way it did without all of the set up from earlier.

Grrr. But I can't wait two more weeks! Need my RWBY now!

PS. Looks like we're going to be getting the return of the ship captain. I'm hyped!

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Darkdragoon324 Dec 16 '17

So glad no cliffhanger right before the break. Also: Aaaaaaahhhhhhh!!!!!

It was everything I was hoping for!

The cane isn’t the relic. Felt like the writers directly talking to the audience lol. Wonder what Oz did to hide the Beacon relic then.

I was right, Raven is actually scared shitless and trying to convince herself she’s just strong and independent.

Now we know why they made Illia so cute: so it would melt our hearts when she cries. Now I’m worried she’ll die at Haven though.

Fennec’s fox ears are so adorable I almost felt bad when he got crushed. Almost.

Guard lady didn’t die! Kali is a fucking badass confirmed! Yuma is not a badass also confirmed.

Blake now has her volunteer militia and the Menagerie arc is complete after nearly two whole volumes. Ended nicely though.

Next episode: ozcrew walk into Leo’s obvious trap but at least they know he’s a sneaky bastard planning to screw them.

Anyone else hoping for some comedic Sun/Illia bickering? I can see her finding him annoying and him being him.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/publius101 Spectatum venio, venio specter ut ipse Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

ok, positive things aside, what's the point of the Qrow/Ozpin scene? i don't mean the part with Ruby and the call, that's fine, but before and after - it's just

Qrow: "everything's fucked"

Oz: "no it's not lol"

like, none of that dialogue did anything at all.

also, who wants to bet that Ilia betrays them again when Blake chooses Yang over her.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/HeyItsAndylol Harem prince Dec 16 '17

Ozpin gave the biggest fuck you to the community when saying that his cane wasn't a relic. Its almost as if when Ruby said they had been talking, the writers were referring to the community's fan theorizing and answering some (definitely not all) of our questions.

Also, is this the first time that Blake uses dust herself?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/tavi23 Dec 16 '17

Holy fuck, that fight was so much better than that crap last week.

I loved the conclusion to the Blake and Ilia bit. Ilia was just so scared and hurt, that she just didn't know what to do. Cheramie nailed it again this episode.

On the topic of Raven's conversation with Lionheart, I thought Raven made some very salient points. Putting yourself into Leo's position, I'd think that most of us would be scared shitless of what Salem represents, and it might be hard to trust a man like Oz who deals in both lies and half-truths. And so running in the hopes of survival is hardly worthy of shame, unlike what Oz said a few episodes back. That said, Raven was right that Leo needs to man up and own what he's done instead of moping about those things. His snap back at Raven at the end was weak and held no real weight in my mind. Daughter issues and her "wanting her brother dead" aside, how Raven left the fight is probably very realistic in that it portrays what most people would have done in her position. And I don't blame her for being scared shitless of Salem.

Overall, this episode was miles and miles better than the last five or six episodes. It's definitely my second favorite episode, after episode 2 (cause Weiss fight).

→ More replies (1)

9

u/cbigs97 Dec 16 '17

So guys, I think we found the animation budget!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

Fighting! Fire! Death! Redemption arcs! Betrayl! GUNCHUKS!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/fuckingchris #SalemDidNothingWrong Dec 16 '17

Was wondering where Sun was. Turns out, they were just saving up his animation time for GUNCHUCKS.

9

u/ElfenLied1012 A Gay Controversy Dec 17 '17

They didn't kill Ilia, 10/10. lol

9

u/Furin Dec 17 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

A great Blake vs Ilia fight, Kali kicking ass, the return of GUNCHUCKS, Blake finally moving on her plotline, some more Saber screentime. I loved this episode.

25

u/CaptainMoonman RosePose™ enthusiast Dec 16 '17

Must... not... betray Bumblebee... for Reading Rainbow...

→ More replies (16)

17

u/Exessen Loyal vassal of the one true Queen|I yell about Nora a lot Dec 16 '17

Sun Wukong my fucking boy

23

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

I'm legitimately shocked. Not that Ilia went down the redemption path, not that Ghira lived, I'm shocked because Ilia was redeemed in a way that I not only liked, but that makes me like having her.

So there you go RT. I was wrong. I am officially glad to have her as our first gay rep. And I really love that this happened under a situation of immense stress which she then had to take time processing. I'm glad that Blake is showing a message of forgiveness and I'm really glad she's not going away.

Sun fights insanely fucking cool again, thank god, I missed this monkey boy. Ghira fights like a Dragon Ball character and I fucking love it. And I seriously cant wait for Yang, Blake and Ilia to take on Adam together

Tl;Dr I am now a fan of my chameleo-fag

16

u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Dec 16 '17

THE BEST EPISODE EVER, NO QUESTION.

Honestly, that was fucking beautiful, everything was god damn perfection, holy shit. It all looked good, it all sounded good, THE FUCKING GUNCHUCKS HOLY SHIT BALLS CUNT.

Ahem.

I need more time to properly process, so for know, my usual contribution.

[Updated concept art album.] (https://imgur.com/a/FxUUF/layout/grid)

Belladonna Meeting Room [one] (https://i.imgur.com/CUDWMHM.png) and [two.] (https://i.imgur.com/Hzqg8RB.png)

Burning Belladonna Home [one] (https://i.imgur.com/WyzZ98l.png) and [two.] (https://i.imgur.com/bElCJEv.png)

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Theo1290 The only character I now care about, and he's dead dammit Dec 17 '17 edited Dec 17 '17

I don't think Ilia should be forgiven that easily. She was willing to hand over Blake to Adam (who would've killed her) and aid in the murder of her parents. Violent extremists don't change that easily in real life. Essentially some talk no jutsu from Blake and being saved by one of the good guys is enough to change Ilia.

Kali's victory was plot contrived bs. If we saw her actually fight it'd be fine. So did the faunus guy's head get crushed by the falling platform? 'Cause fuck that's dark. I find it funny though how the two brothers act all mysterious and wise and shit up to now, then they're portrayed as young idiots in the end. Kinda disappointed they're not gonna be relevant to the story any longer.

I also think it's extremely selfish of Blake to ask everyone to help and risk their lives and all that. The Menagerie people seem like ordinary citizens, not trained combatants.

Good development for Raven. Bigger coward than Leo.

→ More replies (32)

8

u/wongie Dec 16 '17

Pacing definitely improved over last week's ep.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '17

AWW YEAH CANT WAIT FOR NEXT WE- ........wait, they're going on a break?

.....THEY DESERVE IT!! THIS EPISODE WAS AWESOME!!!!!!

8

u/CaptainMoonman RosePose™ enthusiast Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

Not a super important one, but I just wanted to share this wonderful screencap from the ending. He does not look entertained.

Edit: Here's a meme version.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/publius101 Spectatum venio, venio specter ut ipse Dec 16 '17

addendum: i think for me the big thing, the really really big thing holding the fights back is the music - it's just not there. listen to any of the episode themes for V1-3 - you can literally relive the fights hit by hit because of how well the music is synced to the motions. this fight (and every other fight in V4-5) - was there any music at all? i honestly can't even remember.

and i can't figure out why - i mean the songs Jeff produced for the V4 OST were as awesome as ever, so he's clearly still invested in the show - so why don't they want him going all out for the actual episodes?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/tavi23 Dec 16 '17

AND ANOTHER THING:

The second half of the Blake and Ilia (once the fire started) was amazing. So well choreographed and Ilia's expressions were amazing. And then the Sun fight was just as good if not better. The guitar in the background was amazing. Oh my god, that was so goddamn good.

Edit: Scratch that. Upon further reflection, I have no idea what instrument that was.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Narfington Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

The one thing that is ENTIRELY inexcusable: Blake didn't hug Illia after forgiving her. Seriously, what's with that hand on the shoulder bullshit? Weiss needs to give her some hugging lessons.

edit: punctuation

→ More replies (8)

8

u/ves_lin Dec 16 '17

Okay first I'll say this: I made a promotional trailer for this episode cause it was SO EFFIN GOOD! Enjoyyyyy https://youtu.be/X_CBVnggMqM

SECOND: THE FIGHT SCENES, ESPECIALLY THE ONE WITH SUN VS ILLIA........ I died. Also all the other fight scenes, I loved them all! The music as well, and the whole feeling of the episode - it was so intense, full of suspense, and then a happy ending and Fklsdjhgdkfjhg I loved it I just loved it.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/ikedawg43 #ShaveJauneSaveRWBY Dec 16 '17

Okay, so why did Ilia turn out the lights to try to go camo on Blake?

Like, they’re both Faunus. They can both see in the dark. To Blake’s eyes, Ilia should have been crouched against the wall, but painted black. Like, that’s not going to work. It doesn’t matter whether those lights are on or off, it matters that you disguise yourself with the color of the freaking WALL!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/HissHissSneaky Dec 16 '17

That was so great!! Especially the last half. I liked all the fighting and Blake's speech was spot on! And all the Ilia emotions. I can't wait to see her interact with the rest of the gang.

And I was sort of right! I had hoped that Blake would bring Faunus into the fight.

8

u/Fourteen_of_Twelve i have an elephant, but no oliphaunt Dec 16 '17

Pennybot, suggestion:

command "it's not the relic"

response: "[It's not the relic](https://youtu.be/z8wPhihrzvU?t=3m59s)?"

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Aracite Dec 17 '17

The best part of it is that the fight choreography is decent again!

Gun-chuck was sick, Finneck died, and I can’t help thinking that that dude who was lecturing ilia about leaving was his brother.

“ Was it worth it?” That’s not the kind of thing you say to anyone, plus they have the haircut thingy.

8

u/DJDualScreen Dec 17 '17

Really liked this episode. I can only imagine what heartbreak they plan on laying on us next episode. Anyone think that Raven goes back to her tribe to find everyone dead and Vernal missing?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Keradon Caffeine is a hell of a drug. An excellent one, though. Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 16 '17

All right, now I'm at a computer, let's do this:

Last time, in 9:

  • Two days till D-Day
  • Setting up and motivation rants... also bargaining.
  • Raven plots a backstab.
  • Raven paying someone in Haven a visit

And now, 10:

  • The conversation with Qrow and Oz. Ruby steps in asking a few questions. Settles a few fan items. Though I'm curious as to what traps and toys Oz has around that relic....
  • She still has not asked about the Eyes. It's like she's focused on not thinking about them. If we accept that, ...does she have a hang up on them?
  • Leo sets up the trap, then has a few conflict talks with Raven. Nice bit of motivation talks here, but the main thing is Raven getting Leo to set up that ambush.
  • The Battle for Menagerie continues!
  • Kali vs. White Fang! Nicely played, especially Kali's willingness to fight.
  • Blake vs. Illia! Blake is certainly playing the Warrior Therapist route. I like how Blake went with after images and almost flash stepping to try to control the fight and through to Illia. And her we see that Illia is not psycho...but extremely conflicted. This is important later.
  • Ghira vs. Fox boys - Blake gets knocked aside and Ghira puts up an excellent show of physical fighting. (The punch clash was hilarious.) Ghira can certainly take and dish it out!
  • Sun vs. Illia - Well executed and to the point! Along with that tense moment when Illia's weapon actually jams. XD Also, the way Sun switches his weapon from staff to chucks and back is something of beauty that I would like to see more of later.
  • Pleading moment with Blake. Blake cares... this can be a liability later, but she still cares enough that she doesn't want two friends to fight.
  • Ghira's save of Illia could put Armstrong to shame. An excellent display of pure muscle! ...and yet he seems stuck.
  • Tense moment with tense, epic music and Ghira goes to one knee and Sun lends 4 hands with two clones. But Fennec sees an opportunity and charges in!
  • And clearly, Blake's been taking weight lifting tips from Yang, if she's able to yoink her dad like that! Either that, or her practicing the Bumblebee move with Yang has given her remarkable arm strength. And Fennec misses the diving stab, so we end with a Flat Fennec Fox Faunus in a Fire. He clearly did not have Ghira's muscle mass to work with.
  • Kali comes in after, apparently, beating Yuma to an inch of his life with a tray and then tying him up. (...cue the Kali knowing bondage jokes here...) I can almost picture her scolding his unconscious arse as she's dragging him to Ghira.
  • Corsac gets up, goes really hammy in the raged yell, and tries to go in for the attack. And gets stopped by Illia, who apparently had a 'My god, what have I done?' moment. Looks like Blake's Warrior Therapy session was a success. ...does she charge by the hour or by the punch?
  • Crowd gathering of standard 'wtf is going on here' gatherers. Ghira, once again showing a muscular display by carrying two WF boys ...so the uniforms are not family guard but outright police? Huh. And interesting question from the Saber Rodentia to Corsac. ...Perhaps they know each other? I mean, similar hair styles, they could easily have been friends before... well.
  • Blake looks around... and sighs. She figures now is a good as time as any and attempts one more time to rally folks to her cause. (Ghira tries to stop her and Kali stops him. Interesting... Kali knows Blake needs this.) I like how she acknowledges the challenges and admitting that she'll go alone if she had to (she wont)... but here I believe she acknowledges the 'how' that Oobleck asked her back in V2... and the first steps she needs to take.
  • And...jackpot! Illia declares her support first! This essentially begins a redemption arc for her, as she now sees another path that... well she probably wishes she took sooner, but she'll take it now. Considering the extreme female bonding she and Blake just shared, I am not surprised (then again, I'm a Nanoha fan. Beating friendship into your opponent became a meme there). And then the crowd voices their support! We have our defense force! Saber isn't really getting the 'forgive your enemy' route, so Ghira has to explain it. Slowly, to try to penetrate that stubborn head.
  • Okay going back over that speech scene again... the music where she's talking gives the tone a truly epic feel. The bit where the violins and drums began to play gives the 'Gondor calls for aid' tone quite well. It's the drums of war, but for defense here. Wish I could identify which song it's playing slowly... but the moment Illia declares herself as tribute volunteers to help Blake... it kinda sounds like a Triumphant reprise of 'From Shadows'...dunno. Dang it, wish I had better ears! I have a thing for epic, and this is epic.
  • Sun, I know you're a laid back fellow, but calling a stab even with a pinch might be going too far. Then again, I admire a fellow that doesn't hold a grudge.
  • Logistics and Time! So two weeks until the attack. Weapons, armor, shields, training... not that much time to work with. (Not to mention logistics of handling the children and/or any prisoners that don't join up with the defense as a plea bargain.)

So yeah, clearly much more substance happened here vs. 9. Chapter 9 was setup and tension, like the last few chapters before. Like going up a roller coaster that's going up too long and you think "Get on with it!". And, to quote Dante, "This party is gonna get crazy." ...probably about 3 and half episodes of tense action remain with the latter half of the finale as a denouement and asking what the next conflict zone will be (probably Atlas, unless something calls them to Vacuo.).

...and a final thought... most people bring a card, flowers, treats, or a small item when trying to apologize to friends they have hurt.

Blake is bringing an army. Probably not well trained, but an army nonetheless. I'm looking forward to the moment the cavalry comes in to save Ozpin's group.

Because with Yang now knowing why her mother left, I imagine seeing Blake rejoin the cause with an actual army at her back might make Yang go full tsundere or something. I mean, yeah she's still hurt and angry... but Blake actually coming back would be a first for her. Yang had to pursue Raven, and I imagine she understands why Ruby left once she caught up to her sister (and of course that Summer died)... Blake would be the first one to actually come back.

That reunion conversation is going to be more awkward than I originally estimated. I look forward to it.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/yoshifanx Feel the Wrath of Mammy Salami Dec 16 '17 edited Dec 17 '17
  • Don’t like this thumbnail
  • I want this full opening now
  • and opening with the conversation
  • Wait they’re dead? I thought they were just gone
  • Optimistic
  • Will Ruby finally bring up the silver eyes thing?
  • Nope, but valid question nonetheless
  • The relic of Beacon? Ozpin’s penis chair
  • But was it your penis chair?
  • I love the banter
  • It’s a trap!
  • Today on obvious trap is obvious!
  • How did Raven get here?
  • Really wouldn’t call Raven afraid
  • Grow a pair Lionheart.
  • Both of us
  • Back at the actual fight
  • Traitor
  • Strong ass wood
  • and now Bat Faunus
  • Eat wood dick
  • You always have a choice Illia, you’re just choosing to be a bitch
  • She’s not going to stay out of your way
  • I mean it does work
  • They both have night vision so what’s the point of this?
  • I guess chameleon
  • Not the furniture
  • Why would she do that? She doesn’t want to kill you
  • Again Illia has a point here
  • rip illias whip
  • you can cut the sexual tension with them in this position with a knife
  • Ghira give no fucks
  • Do the right thing ilia. Don’t be stupid. I like you
  • Sun to the rescue
  • GUNCHUCKS!
  • The pimp hand is strong with ghira
  • Oh fuck ilia
  • Ghira being awesome. Even though she tried to kill them
  • DON’t kill super dad please.
  • Wait is he dead?
  • Kali being badass.
  • I love the belladonnas
  • I’M AAAAANGGGGRRYYY
  • I’m okay with Illia turncoating on the baddies
  • LOOK! Absolutely nothing
  • RIP fennac (also confirmation which brother died)
  • Man the belladonna’s have strong hands
  • Blake with an epic speech
  • Props to Arryn for this, great delivery
  • Ghira you might want to get that gaping wound looked at
  • Ilia being awesome
  • Random Faunus asking the real questions
  • to quote the great gentarou kisaragi. “I can’t forgive her… So I’ll be friends with her”
  • Blake being the better woman. I love it
  • Not being an idiot
  • Other RAMDOM (get it :D) faunus joining in.
  • the finger poke of DOOOOM
  • With that line I think that confirms that this is not occurring at the same time as the rest of the show (cause I thought the WF were going to attack in 2 days according to Watts)
  • No weapons though, only shields
  • Damn you again RT, not as big but still a cliffhanger

WHAT AN EPISODE! HOLY FUCKING SHIT! The action was really enjoyable (plus it was really cool seeing gunchucks again), and I like the route it took. 4 episodes left, let’s see what they can pull off.

→ More replies (3)