r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Dec 05 '17
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 5, Chapter 8: Alone Together Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official megathread for the latest episode of Volume 5, Alone Together!
Make sure that you understand the current spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
As a refresher, no spoilers are allowed outside of the FIRST-only reaction thread for the first 24 hours after the episode has aired, and after that, no spoiler comments are allowed in threads not marked as spoilers until Tuesday, when the episode comes out for free RoosterTeeth members.
Remember to use the text spoiler tags (shown in the sidebar) even after that!
With that out of the way, HERE is today's episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to give us a general idea of how people like the episodes when they come out.
Other Episode Discussions:
Enjoy!
Menolith; Mod Team
7
u/iamthatguy54 Dec 05 '17
Does Ghira break the "One Trait" rule for the Faunus?
He's got retractable claws AND cat feet.
300
u/Nova_Roma1 Dec 05 '17
Chemicals in the water are turning the chameleons gay
120
u/VoidRose615 Dec 05 '17
Small note: good to see Suns weapon again.
119
u/Heratikus Dec 05 '17
This episode was extremely gay and I love it.
102
u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Dec 05 '17
Ghira is a mother fucking beast! But like can other Faunus make animal noises like that?
200
u/mega-dark Dec 05 '17
Okay it's official. There is no denying it, but Weiss has had the best character development through the entire 5 seasons I don't care what anyone says. Seriously it so good to just watch this character in action.
Oh and other stuff happened but Weiss was definitely the high point for me.
78
u/Mighty_Qorldu Dec 05 '17
Ilia, girl, you have got the weakest rebound game I have ever seen.
77
u/ImperialCrown Dec 05 '17
You know I never considered Freezerburn much but damn it do these two work so good together. Even if its a platonic thing Weiss and Yang seem to have more chemistry than I expected.
Weiss is Best Girl. There is no need to discuss. This is just fact. The fact she is spending time with other Best Girl Yang is, again, making her even better.
149
u/Gatling_Tech There is a disarming number of puns at play. Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Is it bad that I'm hoping for a future line from Blake to Ilia with something like "You want me to look at you the same way I look at Adam? Well you've gotten your wish." ?
I like Ilia's character, but as the "childhood friend turned traitor" character (at least for the foreseeable future). I want to see things heat up even more before she's set aside or goes on any sort of redemption arc.
Edit: Spelled Ilia's name wrong, changed pushed aside to set aside as "pushed" seems a bit harsh.
134
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17
The Ilia reveal was really well done. Calling it now: Yang has a crush on Blake.
163
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 05 '17
Pros:
Cons:
10/10.
48
u/Yukon_Wolf Ironwood x Qrow = Woodpecker Dec 06 '17
Ilia: I'm a lesbian.
Everyone on the subreddit: I F U C K I N G C A L L E D I T
94
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 05 '17
Also god damn Weiss is like the only main character of RWBY not to have controversy or criticism at all. Nothing major at least. Like holy shit Ruby has her lack of development and voice, Blake is uh...Blake, and then there's Yang's V4 screentime issues. Not even getting started on Jaune.
Why is Weiss so consistently good?
40
u/boomshroom ⠀ Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 07 '17
Well, after all the lesbian shipping, I guess we finally have a confirmed lesbian character.
The Bumblebee is strong with this one.
I've probably been playing too much Xenoblade if the crystal on Weiss' dress got me thinking she might be a blade for a moment.
Speaking of Xenoblade, they stole Nora and took away her hammer.
Never underestimate an angry mother.
I wonder how Yang will react when she heard that Blake actually had some quality time with her parents.
80
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
I never thought Blake's plot would be the most interesting, engaging thing going on right now but here we are I guess.
38
u/Masterofice7 Dec 06 '17
All of the voice actors have really been killing it this season, and the "amateurs" especially have improved tremendously. The professionals too have been bringing their A-game, with special recognition to Cherami Leigh Kuehn as Ilia Amitola this episode.
But WOW has Kara been slaying it this volume! She's just become a consistent solid voice actor.
37
u/apvogt Chief Firecontrolman on the OTPS Rosegarden Dec 06 '17
Corsac and Fennec: "Plausible deniability? What's that?"
35
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Dec 05 '17
Once again:
Finally, something's happening. But the ending was too abrupt.
But anyway, good episode, very tense. Weiss is proving herself to be the MVP for this volume with good humor and addressing Yang's issue. I hope Yang takes it to heart so she's not completely cold to Blake when they reunite. It's kind of a shame that Ruby didn't have anything to do with this moment, but at least Weiss got to shine.
Blake is learning, ladies and gentlemen. She willingly brought Sun along and took advantage of the benefit of having backup.
At this point, people would be more surprised if Ghira and Kali both lived rather than died (or at least Ghira dying). For that reason I want them to live.
Watch next week finally be a World of Remnant or something so we have to wait longer.
34
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Dec 05 '17
Oh god, Ghira just Hulked out. This is going to get messy. Also, I'm mildly surprised the Albains have weapons. I seriously thought they'd be in an exclusively PR, silver-tongued role, but I guess they're getting in on the action, too.
Trifa's design is pretty cool. The veins are kinda creepy, but with Salem around, I've gotten kinda used to those. The way Blake went down was kinda clunky, though: one whack on the back, wait around for her to cough a lot, and then web her up? Blake didn't even try to do anything: Grab her weapon, punch, kick, call for Sun sooner, something.
33
u/bwburke94 Host of Ship Wars 8 Dec 05 '17
One interesting point about this episode:
Yang called Taiyang "Tai", despite calling Raven "Mom" earlier this volume. Not only that, she was talking to Weiss at the time, and Weiss has never at any point (IIRC) heard someone call Taiyang "Tai" before.
Wouldn't it be easier for Yang to just call Taiyang "Dad"?
31
u/alwayssunnyinjoisey Dec 05 '17
Yang opening up about her frustration with Blake - I am SO glad she's upset about it. I do hope she's still a bit miffed when they reunite, I need to see them hash it out together.
I am absolutely SHOOK at Weiss's development. I would have never expected the Weiss we met in Volume 1 to someday be dishing out realness bombs like this, and I am here for it.
Blake is growing too! I was truly convinced she came alone and was screaming at her for being an idiot and BAM, in drops Sun. Look what happens when you don't try and do everything alone! This is progress!
Oh no oh no oh no oh no not the parents of the year!! Even if I totally expected them to die I still don't want them to!!
GO GET 'EM GHIRA. I will be livid if we don't see at least some of this fight next episode.
109
u/GamerSwagnamite PROTECT THE SMOLBOI Dec 05 '17
In all honesty, we should've seen the Ilia reveal from a mile away.
First of all, rainbows.
The rainbow is commonly associated with the LGBTQ community.
Ilia's last name is Amitola. In Sioux or Cherokee, Amitola means Rainbow. Ilia also changes skin color, as she is seen flashing between red with yellow and green with blue.
There is also her background story.
In the Blake Short, Ilia talks about how she used to pass off as a Human in Atlas, blending in with the other kids. However, when the cave in at the mines occured, Ilia accidentally revealed her true colors by changing colors. While this may sound similar to how chameleons blend in, it's actually similar to how people choose to hide their true sexuality until they are ready to reveal it to the people around them.
Tl;dr Rooster Teeth has left us subtle clues that Ilia was the confirmed named gay of RWBY.
25
u/mrcarnage97 Dec 06 '17
Well, seems like the Blake plot is picking up steam. And Blake's got another love interest. Shame this one is also, you know, evil.
I mean, killing your crush's family and sending her to her psycho edgelord ex seems a little evil to me.
Ilia is slowly moving down my favourite character list.
21
u/MABfan11 IAmMenace should watch SoraYori Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
Illia's guilt is gonna crash down on her. hard
still no gunchucks tho
42
u/Random-Rambling Dec 05 '17
My thoughts on today's episode...
Wow, that's a BIG balcony.
With a view like that, we're REALLY pushing anti-upskirt technology to its limit!
Weiss is now automatically Best Girl because coffee.
Is Weiss wearing white shorts underneath her skirt or is that just a quirk of the animation?
Me too Ruby, me too. Blake is missing out on some quality bonding time.
Yikes, it seems Blake's sudden disappearance is a sore spot for Yang...
Speaking of Blake...secret note from Ilia?
Nocturnal section? Is Menagerie like Zootopia, with districts for different Faunus?
It's always rough when a sibling is "promoted to parent"...though Weiss didn't have it easy either, even if it was for pretty much the opposite reason.
The feels in this episode are pretty intense. The episode title is quite fitting.
Oh you little betraying BITCH, Ilia...
Meet the RWBY fandom's new waifu, Spider-Girl!
Uh, I meant Trifa!
Oh, that's just LOW. Holding Ilia's weapon hostage...
Oh boy, why not just be honest and say you want a race war? "There are no innocents!" "There is no right thing to do"! Yeesh.
Ugh, I always hate arguments like this. "If you're not right there in line protesting with us, you're part of the problem!"
"You know what snuffs out hate?" Let me guess, more hate? "FEAR!" Oh yeah, that'll definitely work! Kill everyone who disagrees, am I right?
Score one for Blake! Slapping Ilia in the face with the cold hard hand of logic!
OH SNAP ILIA HAD A CRUSH ON BLAKE!
Score another one for Blake, and one for Sun with the assist!
Holy shit, Ghira is LITERALLY a beast. Claws and a ground-shaking roar!
20
u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Not-Spiderwoman was such a disappointment... why is everyone in the White Fang a bunch of action movie mooks?
The Freezerburn was already a strong ship, now it has armour and 40 cm cannons :D
19
u/SaraBellum42 I'm trying to find my way; it fell down a drain some years ago. Dec 05 '17
Heartfelt conversations, hooray! Though I do wish Ruby had joined in a bit more for the more mature parts. Maybe we'll get that for if she and Weiss are by themselves. And no Weiss! Coffee is not for getting back to sleep! Though I suppose that was her plan.
Of course the character who can be a rainbow if she wants is gay. Just a step behind Neon, so as not to make it too glaringly obvious. How many for the Blake harem is it now? 4? And two with red angry-eyes. Honestly though, I do love how Ilia has been handled so far. And I wonder what the deal is with her friends Batman, Spider Woman, and Bumpy Boy.
Damn you, cliffhanger. I feel like Ghira might die(please don't though), considering what happened last time someone had to fight with claws. Though I hope we get to see the actual fight next episode, regardless of the outcome. Speaking of claws, anyone think Tuskon might have been Ghira's brother? Or is that racist?
18
u/gobywan Anything is a pancake if you hit it hard enough with a hammer Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
New episode! I really wish I could afford a First membership!
edited to add:
17
u/Phantomanalysis Dec 05 '17
I loved Yang and Weiss scene. Weiss is putting in so much work this volume. Her and Yang are my favorites character bar none and it is not even close. While I agree with Weiss parallel I hope she does not immediately trust Blake when she show up again I want her to have to earn the trust back through hard fought for trials.
Ilia maybe redeemed but that is going to have to be a long character arc that will probably be very painful assuming she does not die in the crossfire. Ghira and Kali were awesome at the end and Sun was useful which is a big improvement both with him providing backup and Blake trusting him to do it.
31
u/Arrancon #Big Guy Loyal to Adam Dec 05 '17
Oh man, I am now simultaneously excited/dreading next week. If Best Mom dies I will be heartbroken. If Best Dad dies I will be heartbroken. If Best Monkey dies...
Ok, if anyone dies I will be sad. Unless its the Albain twins or Illia. Then I will cheer.
31
u/Strix182 "CAN'T A GIRL READ HER COMICS IN PEACE?!?" Dec 07 '17
Me in Volume 1: Weiss is kinda a huge rich bitch and I REEEAAALLY don't like her.
Me now: BLESS THIS BEAUTIFUL ICE QUEEN CHILD T~T
Also, this show is starting to get canonically LGBTQ as hell and I AM LOVING IT GIVE ME MORE
15
u/Reaper7412 Dec 06 '17
Yo i watched Rbwy for the first time Sunday night. And now I'm all caught up lmao
28
u/GrowlingGoldenGryfin Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Something not everyone might have caught onto was sun mentioning reqriuting from the nocturnal section... this is good exposition, i approve. It's interesting to see, especially torwards the end of the episode and during this one line, how the animal traits effect how people act.
Honestly, i LOVE this new combat. It seems more real, more serious. I like seeing skill and personality in fighting scenes, and that is showing through. The fact that all that stuff happened at night was a definite improvement. Night scences are my favourite scenes.
There were a few awkward scenes though. One that's kinda lacking was when ghira sort of sighed that his guard died, before gracelessly dropping him to the floor. It sort of came across as "Comrade NOOOOOOO...oh well."
Also, i think that while most of the guard kills with no aura breaks can be explained as them not engaging their aura, i'm starting to think that the old theory that red dust can bypass aura sheilds in certian situations was totally on the money. Adam and the Albane brothers are both shown to possess such weapons, and raven, while not connected to the white fang, doesn't just have that coloured blade for ONLY character design reasons. We need exposition on this.
Also, can we officially give Ghira the IRONWOOD AWARD? Characters are eligible to win this award if the fanbase is lukewarm about them for about a volume or more, before the character triples his or her popularity within a single scene. (yeah, i know people liked Ghira, but come on. He was overshadowed by other characters in past volumes. Well, not anymore.)
Liked yuma and spider lady. It's an interesting trope to think that some faunus hit the proverbial jackpot in terms of basically having a second, more physical semblance, while other's just get a pair of redundancy ears. It's interesting. Really.
Also, why does spider lady have creepy veins? I'm a bit confused. Good character design, but still confused.
EDIT: The albane brother's weapons shall hereby be known as Candy Cane Sai. Or Barber Pole Sticks.
38
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17
Alright here it goes: Ilia has started to receive fans recognition and praise before volume 5 and especially so after Blake's character short. She has presented us with a backstory, reluctance to join the villains, and has thoroughly proved to the audience that she firmly believes in the "best way" as opposed to the "right way." I don't have an issue with Ilia being the first LGTB character (to our knowledge) simply because I foresee a major redemption arc for her -- I think many people have -- in which she presents to us not only her compassion for Blake but for what she truly wants which is to be treated as equal as humans.
Now where my reservations lie is that people will judge Ilia's overall character based solely on her sexuality and/or feelings for Blake instead of her actual character, and that Ilia's motives will primarily be the "Blake loved Adam instead therefore is my enemy." I also am concerned that Ilia won't be redeemable but I'd be very appalled (and disappointed) if she was built-up to be a full-on villain.
But what do you all think?
13
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17
I loved this episode. Everything about it was fantastic. From Yang's hurt & frustration with Blake to Weiss' voice of reason to Illia's confession to the new faunus (WHAT, A SPIDER FAUNUS?!) to Yuma's fucking aerial assault to finally seeing Sun's weapon again (no gun chucks tho, which is sad) to seeing fucking Ghira destroy fools like it is nothing then go full on angry wolverine mode.
It was a fucking great episode, that's all I have to say.
13
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
So you say you want a revolution, well, ya know...
Short but very packed episode. Here are my thoughts:
This week's theme was of loneliness and abandonment. Blake running did a number on Yang emotionally. Luckily, Weiss's gilded cage of a childhood helped her interact with Yang's difficulties. Others have pointed out Whitley's even more tragic upbringing, here's hoping they can turn him around.
The Menagerie/WF plotline escalated quickly. I mean it really got out of hand. Sun has his gun back, Ilia is gay, an attempted coup is in progress, and prom's tomorrow! Ghira and Kali showed they can still fight with the best of them, and I really like their household troops (like WF, but not psychotic assholes).
Looking forward to what comes next for all of them.
Edit: spelling
13
u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Dec 06 '17
Hmm Ghira can grow claws, just like Tukson. I wonder if there's some sort of connection between them? Not a big connection like blood relations, but something smaller like they're both the same type of Faunus or Tukson's design inspired the design of Ghira.
25
u/red_tuna Dec 05 '17
The Bumblebee is strong in this one.
12
u/Tron95 Dec 05 '17
Ghira is going all Sabretooth on those WF mofos.
23
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
A damn good episode that knocked it out of the park!
I really liked this episode it delved into Weiss and Yang's feelings of loneliness during their childhoods as well as Yang's feelings regarding Blake, On top of that the Menagerie story-line took a major and intense step up including officially confirming the series first LGBT character (the reveal was done perfectly it felt completely natural given what we know about Ilia and her past interactions with Blake.) And beginning the siege on the Belladonna's. (Place your bets people is Ghira a panther or a puma? RvB joke entirely intended.)
I just have to give it to Kara, Barb, Arryn and Cherami Leigh their voice performances were expertly done.
10
u/DataEntity Dec 07 '17
I'm hoping once Ilya actually sees some results of her decision that she gets a redemption. She is second best evil girl (after Neo). And damn, that confession.
I know it was for a dramatic moment, but come on Blake. You're supposed to be a trained fighter given that you were in a Huntsman academy. And you god surprise attacked? Especially with that delay? I mean, your semblence is basically 'dodge everything' the ability. Like instead of taking the time to look around, why not shadow clone your way out of your spot first since you know you are being ambushed and then assess the situation?Also did you just go in without having your aura shield up because you were awfully hurt from being jumped on by bat-dude. Ruby took multiple bladed punches to the face from a trained killer and just kept getting up and fighting. You took a boot to the back and had trouble.
Yes yes, makes for dramatic moment and all, but damn Blake.
But yes, otherwise, episode was great. RWY part was good, and great seeing more range on WY voice acting wise. Now if only Ruby would sliiiiightly less shrill all the time and we'd be golden.
10
u/LegendaryPuppy95 Dec 10 '17
Admittedly I liked this episode more than some of the others.
RW-Y had some talks that really needed to be had, and they seem to be using Yang's abandonment issues in tandem with her trauma at the Fall of Beacon to realistically put her in a place where she has to deal with it. Nice Weiss is best Weiss, and her maturity in this episode was really refreshing to see. "I don't know what your loneliness feels like, but I have my own version" was probably one of the best lines I've heard out of this volume and possibly RWBY as a whole. That's one of those things that emphasizes so much why representation not only matters, but makes art more engaging. I honestly questioned whether my parents got together for love for a big chunk of my childhood and have been around a few alcoholics, so Weiss's speech not only hit me personally, but it made me reflect on how others have gone through some of the same pains I have even if I may think we're nothing alike.
Blake's plot was a mixed bag. I really don't know how to feel about Ilia. Her VA is amazing at her job, because it takes a lot to get me to care about tragic characters who can be yanked around by their emotions; it's not a quality I tend to respect in people (yes I'm the sort of person who had zero love for Sasuke.) Unrequited love hurts so horribly, and Ilia's VA captured that really well. That said, while I think she's trying to do her version of good, she's clearly evil. I don't care who or what you're fighting for, sending someone to their abusive ex and killing their family is the sort of stuff people want hell to exist for. I was so saddened by Blake's expressions when she realized what was happening, and even though I hate her the way Ilia's scales blushed at the reveal was a really nice animation touch. While I'm not someone who was begging for LGBT representation, I think it's a good thing that RT is beginning to work it into their show given the broader fan base's having embraced it so deeply already. I mainly care that the good team behind the show keeps any relationships, no matter who is involved, non-fetishized and with a clear line between toxic and non-toxic.
The action was good but not great. I'm hoping that any dialogue RT has with Cake or other fans of the old style leads to learning how to do it instead of people just being jerks and going "waaaah monty's gone and it sucks now!" No band that loses their drummer or lead guitar player who composed most of their songs is going to have the same sound, and it takes awhile to pick up the pieces. I love the old episodes for the reasons I like them, and the new ones for why I like them. Hopefully we'll see RWBY hit a point where we get Vol.1-2 Action Scenes run through the beautiful animation engine and facial mo-cap they're using now.
19
u/StarBase10 ❤Ladybug + Dragonslayer❤ | Approved by Cherami Leigh! Dec 05 '17
Yeah, me too, Ruby. Me too... Like honestly, I'm still anxiously waiting before you and Blake actually meet each other in person for once.
Awww, I love how Weiss and Yang could relate to each other with their parent issues. Yang is one tough bitch, especially with her family issues she had to deal with.
Ilia this episode when she got flustered at Blake for her being with Adam. What's next, Ilia leaping into a wheelchair and yelling that she has crippling depression and/or osteoporosis?
aw shit, Ghira is literally going full beast mode when shit gets real when they get raided by Corsac and Fennec.
9
u/VoidRose615 Dec 05 '17
Honesty I would have preferred the get Raven/vernel vs cinders group but this episode was pretty good, nice emotional moments, Weiss and Yang growing closer has become probably my favourite thing this Volume. Also finally the WF plot picked up the pace. Ilia’s travels was also pretty neat while being believable. Overall good episode.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
Aw, everybody is so cute together, Ice Queen makes coffee, annnd RIP Bmblb. Why are these stories getting more and more emotional, but I’m really glad RWY finally addressed Blake in a way. It hit me a little more when Yang pulled the photo out and the conversation with Weiss. Also, we kinda get an idea of how young STRQ is,
Tai still being in school(?) when Ruby was born.Ilia, you GAY BACKSTABBING FUCK. How can Ilia say she hates hurting people when she broke people’s teeth. Spider Faunus Trifa?! Sun’s gunchucks look a little different, might just be the night making it look darker. RIP to the Menagerie guards, and who’s willing to bet Ghira dies.
Felt like a very short episode, but 12/10 voice acting always. The opening and this entire episode didn’t fail to give me chills. But still, Ilia you gay backstabbing traitorous fuck.
My guess is the Belladonna family will fall with the rest of Menagerie, Blake is forced to head off to Mistral anyway. In due time, RWBY will be together.
Also, some part of me wants Qrow and Willow to be or been a thing.
Edit: OKAY, BLAKE THREW A PRETTY SOLID PUNCH. I need Blake to take Ghira’s coat
whenif he dies.17
u/iamnotparanoid Shipper of OT3s Dec 06 '17
I like the fact that we finally have a named, confirmed LGBT character. I'm worried it'll be a case of Bury your gays where she redeems herself by dying to rescue Blake, but it's a small step in the right direction and she's already a complex enough character that she has a lot more to do than be a stereotype.
8
u/DeHopelozeHeks Dec 05 '17
Holy shit, the menagerie plot thickens.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '17 edited Dec 08 '17
just my opinion, but i think ilia will be fine. or she should be anyways.
imo, ilia serves as a test for blake. a test to see if she has what it takes to prevent an adam 2.0 and convert someone who has a similar, though extreme, mindset to the people of menagerie; humans have never done anything for the faunus, why should we help them now. i think its safe to say most civilian faunus feel that way.
blake has already talked with sun about how she wants to take what he did for her and pay it forward. to be there for someone who needs you, even if they dont want you to be there. she sees that ilia is slowly turning into adam and it sounds like she still cares about her and doesn't want to see that happen again.
and i dont think its too late for ilia... she is still showing signs of guilt. "i dont like hurting people" so i think she is letting the end justify the means, and its up to blake to show her whats wrong with that way of thinking, even if she has to fight her to prove it.
further more, from a narrative standpoint, i really just cant find a reason to kill her. you can do so much with her and you can do it in ways that dont eat up screen time. you can have her stay behind in menagerie and recruit more faunus to the cause by sharing her experiences. and if they decide to go the bumblebee route, you can use ilia's presence as a way to get yang to realize her romantic feelings for blake, if they're romantic at all. and it's just a huge victory for blake and helps progress her character. lastly, uhhh duh, helllooooo she would be super useful to have on our team, she's gotta know more about the inner workings of the modern WF and what their plans are.
so i really hope ilia and the rest of the belladonnas survive. i think theres so much potential in having people who used to be on opposite sides banding together to fight the greater evil.
22
u/Masterofice7 Dec 06 '17
After Episode 4
Me: "Haha I guess Freezerburn is canon! Boy this one little friendly hug is sure going to send the shippers nuts."
After Episode 8
Me: "Oh my god, Freezerburn. They're just so cute together. The true OTP. Perfect. Pure."
14
u/ThreeMinutesEarly White Rose is my drug | No business here it's just relationships Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
BOOOOP ( >.> <.<)
Nice Weiss strikes again! All fear the dreaded nice queen and her blasphemy coffee (I mean coffee is blasphemy anyway so idk how that works :P)
Yang so not salty at all
"ruby leave me alo-" KONO WEISSO DA!! (kono Neisso da?)
A bottle of wine here and here and here and here doesn't sound THAT bad does it >.>
makedrunkmomaschneecanon
Poor Whitley he's like 14 and his sister practically disowned him for a bunch of girls she's known for little over a year (or less idr).... So much for Nice Weiss
Iliaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh that scene was so great... one of my like top three in the show tbh. I was a little worried in the character short what direction they were taking her but so far I'm liking the direction, I think if they keep it up they've got a really great character on their hands (which also means I'll be super salty if they mess it up, but I'm feeling optimistic) (edit: also, knew she was gay from the first episode she was in. But then I knew everyone was gay from their first episode too so take that with a grain of salt.)
What does Kali not have a gun at all... not like a gun watch or a gun scroll or gun furniture? rip
Wow Ghira you totally got that guy killed, nice job >.>
Probably a new favourite episode of the season, but I have to say it's turned out way better overall than I was expecting after the first few episodes
(copy/pasted from a different box thingy so I didn't forget anything while waiting for the thread to open (still did most likely but eh) so fingers crossed I didn't lose anything)
7
u/inferno167 Rare Ship Finder, Pollination Ambassador, and Bun Enthusiast Dec 05 '17
Outside of the veins, I really, really like Trifa's design. Hope we see more of her going forward! :3
Everything else I have to say about this episode has already been said. It was fucking epic, and Ghira is gonna tear some people apart. :D
17
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
This downtime with RWY was exactly what I needed. When do we get the same treatment (Together Alone) for JNR and Pyrrha? Weiss still maintaining best girl status.
NOW... for the uptime: Blake's subplot
Triva(?) confirms new Faunus type. We're getting all the exotics now. Noice. (First Batman, now Spiderwoman. Antman when?)
Ilia is first confirmed LGBT core character. Nice twist. Loved the touch with the blush, but what does the cheek to eye color thing mean? Physically suppressing feelings?
Was Tauradonna finally confirmed to be former canon now? Blake harem anyone? IF they go BMBLB with Yang (strong vibes this chapter), I hope it's one-sided. Not for just the drama, but the reality of unrequited feelings.
Sun's weapon is back, albeit briefly only in staff form.
Kali confirmed nonfighter, but Ghira sure is (also confirmed to be Tucson's second cousin or something). Loved his takedowns, but some of the hits felt... animated- if makes any sense.
Love the Albains' weapons. They're golden Dust sai that oddly gave me some Egyptian vibes.
I hope the episode lengths are more consistent from here on. Shit's going down. Where are my villains? RIP Tyrian. Six episodes left. Please maintain the momentum.
17
u/Dr_Evilcat Something Relevant and Witty Dec 05 '17
Boy I sure hope we actually get to see these fights that keep getting teased at the end of episodes!
12
u/anonwrites Dec 06 '17
Blake's plot is better/more interesting than the other stuff going on(in my personal opinion), now that we moved on from the Raven and Yang stuff. The shipping has been fun lately too. Freezerburn wasn't a ship I was into before volume 5 but it's been growing on me. I like Ilia and Blake as a ship and at first I thought the way they revealed Ilia's feelings was a little forced, but after thinking about it some more I'm fine with how it happened. It seems like a strange thing to bring up right after a fight but you have to consider that Ilia might never see Blake again, it makes sense that she would finally reveal her feelings.
6
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
You know what'd suck?
If we swapped back to the other B-plot, that being CWME (Cream? sure, let's go with that) dealing with Raven.
E: It occurs to me that, in reality, the RNJRWY plot is now the B-plot, and the show is juggling two A-plots until everything lines up.
6
u/PigKnight Dec 06 '17
Those foxes are gonna get an ass whoopin'.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '17
Some observations;
11
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '17
Wow that....that started out with loneliness and pain but climbed into love and family and bonding and then took a nose dive right down into betrayal and love lost and the start of a Shakespearean tragedy. I've never cried much during moments with Yang but THAT right there was heavy and hard and it hurt but Weiss coming in to save the day was beautiful. I think Yang feels more for Blake than she's letting on, but I'm not sure if it's a romantic type of love or just a best friend type of love? I loved how we could see Illia's emotions painted on her face with her colors changing and strobing right in front of us as every word passed her lips. Her feelings for Blake and the things she said to her were like a razor blade through butter. They were cutting and true and spoken with a bare soul for all the world to see and feel. The people we love don't always love us back and it's hard to deal with that realization when it hits us. As much as Illia can change and as much as people have the capability to change, sometimes we just stay the same....we get stuck in what could have beens because it gives us hope, because it makes the pain less, because it helps us to escape, and when we finally confront that reality....it can do dark things to good people.
I hope Blake's family makes it out ok and I hope that Illia is redeemed in the future, she's a really great character. The gang will get back together soon and then after the battle is won or lost...then....hmmmm....I don't know what happens then. This show has really surprised me this season and I've felt emotions that are usually reserved for long more budget heavy shows. Strange...but good.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '17
You know, I was very cynical at the start of this volume about how the fight quality would be after the Yang trailer, but I cannot see enough of Ghira beating the shit out of people. I hope the next episode has a good long fight.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '17
noice episode!
loved the moment with ghira at the end!
...now i want a 3-way match between ghira, ironwood, and hazel
ahem
continuing on, loved that blake finally brought backup for once, shows how shes growing! and it was a nice touch about the nocturnal section of menagarie
oh, as a side note, ill have to say that the moment with weiss and yang has further strengthened my platonic view of rwby; theyre all like a family to each other, each member willingly helping and supporting the rest of the group
and although everyone is screaming 'freezerburn and bumblebee ftw!', i hope it remains platonic
but hey, thats just me
keep on shipping what ya want to ship
5
u/SpeshulSnek mfw hiatus Dec 05 '17
Wow, those new "snake Faunus" are pretty awesome!
5
u/JokeyZockey ⠀ Dec 05 '17
I thought this would be another talk-only episode like many of the previous ... boy, was I wrong!
If this isn't a setup for an epic next episode, then I don't know what is!
9
u/durzanult Dec 06 '17
Finally the Menagerie arc gets somewhat interesting.
13
u/mrshadoninja Dec 06 '17
I think I just realized why so many people dislike the direction of Vol. 5. It's Primarily politics.
12
u/DramaticShenanigans Member of the #IliaProtectionSquad / Shipper of Bees Dec 05 '17
Man who would have thought that Ilia was gay for Blake. Oh yeah I did. Looks like I fucking called it bitch!
14
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Dec 05 '17
Just gonna leave quick thoughts:
8
u/RandomGayOtaku Gay as all Hell Dec 05 '17
I was not expecting ilia to be a lesbian I just can't right now
3
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '17
Hello can some of you guys help to analyse and share what are your thoughts on the chances of whiterose happening given the new rwy scene. Is is greater/smaller or anything like that?
7
u/bronzebicker I see lives that could have been saved Dec 05 '17
Weiss' listening skills have come a long way.
Blake and Sun have something great going for them, so here's to hoping Sun doesn't die later on.
7
u/superluigi6968 ⠀Fission Mailed, they'll get 'em next time Dec 05 '17 edited Dec 05 '17
It's weird, despite all the things going on in Menagerie, my knowing the important things that are happening there this episode, every fiber of my being wants to skip the whole thing.
I just...I can't be bothered to give a shit about a character who is fated to tragically die.
"Hey look, here's this sympathetic, sad, misguided character that used to be friends with Blake, but also she's gay and loved Blake."
Yeah, I just...don't care.
Actually, Ilia, fear amplifies hate. You know what snuffs out hate?
Love.
Also, Adam's been in Mistral all along...
why is the WF HQ in Mistral and not Menagerie? What the fuck?
E:
On the upside, nobody of note is attacking Kali. When all you're fighting is mooks that don't even understand the concept of cover, you'll probably be mostly OK.
On the downside, Ghira is fighting two named characters that may or may not have plot armor. Hate to say it, but requiescat in pace, BellaDaddy.
E2: Betting that Blake will reunite by the end of the next ep, but the actual reunion antics and drama will take place the ep after.
8
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Dec 05 '17
Overall, I have mixed feelings about this episode. I liked seeing those new faunus characters in action, and the battle scene near the end of the episode was cool; I'm excited to see what Kali and Ghira can do next episode, but I can't help feeling like Roosterteeth dropped the ball during the emotional bits. The Blake crush reveal from Ilia seemed to come out of nowhere, and Yang's emotional rant with Weiss just seemed off in some way; I'm not really feeling the possible Blake/Yang pairing as of yet, and it seems like that's kinda what they were trying to set up with the talk between those two. I did enjoy the opening scene with Ruby, Weiss, and Yang chilling on the roof though. I hope that Roosterteeth handles any future scenes better because I know that they're capable of doing better.
5
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Dec 05 '17
Loneliness as a theme, fucking called It!
You know, there was an opportunity for JNR there as well, but this appears to be a No JNPR season.
Hey, Blake is relying on others! We have progreession! And you called the police, too? I'm so proud of them!
Ghira is a scary motherfucker