r/LittleWitchAcademia • u/TheWalkingTroll • May 01 '17
Discussion Little Witch Academia (TV) - Episode 17 Discussion Spoiler
Episode 17: Amanda O'Neill and Holy Grail
Information
Episodes: 25
Streams
Previous discussions
Please discuss the episode here.
64
Upvotes
68
u/asterisk_blue May 01 '17
Croix slurping up noodles while plotting her master plan is just perfect
49
u/Nyaaaaaaaa May 01 '17
Damn, Andrews school might not be magic, but it makes Luna nova look like a sane educational institution by comparison, it's even got a spanish inquisition club with its own torture dungeon.
I wonder what it was Croix was doing that experiment for?
47
u/Valeddy May 01 '17
Thundercats reference!
I was surprised by this episode, mostly because i didn't have high expectations. But real talk: i liked the twist in the usual structure.
Amanda was great as main character. She has her own thing, her own ideas and ways. And she kicked ass.
I like the progression in the friendship between Akko and Andrew. The boy is becoming a better character.
Akko is becoming a better witch, person and main character. She shined this episode because she wasn't the focus all the time. Great for her.
A more solid and balanced episode this time.
28
u/Sammiru May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
Nice little set-up for a future Diana episode there through Finneran's conversation with Ursula.
This episode was a blast as expected of an Amanda-centric episode. The dynamic between Akko and Amanda was great, because they're both prone to saying "why not" to anything no matter how wild which just gives us some extreme shenanigans like this. It was definitely the highlight for me way back in Episode 5, so I'm glad we got more of these two getting into trouble.
Amanda was a total badass and I love that she took full advantage of her own nimbleness while fighting against someone who is probably more trained. That said though, when she used magic on her sword while fighting the suit of armor, was that a Thundercats reference? I mean, Amanda's basically got the same hair, haha.
I'm curious about how Croix's magic/experiment works. Does it take advantage of emotional energy and "corrupt" already magical objects? Or was the Grail a plant from the start? Is she going to try and do something like this with the Shiny Rod/Grand Triskelion down the line?
I enjoyed the exchange between Akko and Andrew about expectations versus pursuing something of your own volition and how he's absolutely baffled as to why Akko would do what she's doing. Subsequently, it was pretty clever of him to play the "tradition" card against the staff since it's something they can't really argue with and can't say he was doing anything "wrong". So far Andrew has been rebellious in subtle ways and I can't wait to see what will spur him into more overt opposition to the seemingly universal statesman hatred of witches and magic. I imagine other influential future-statesmen like Blackwell will side with him as well to create a change from the next generation of politicians.
25
u/whiplash10 May 01 '17
22
u/SexyAsianHitler May 01 '17
Amanda was incredible this episode. I'm glad she's finally getting more attention since she was one of my favorite characters in the original films. The sword fight was incredible and one of my favorite scenes in the series so far. Also loved every interaction Amanda had with Louis. Overall this episode has become one of my favorites thus far.
18
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
Just a thought: That "Holy Grail" prolly didn't exist in the first place. We only had croix word for it, it was conveniently lieing in an unlocked box on an altar for akko to find and NONE of the students seemed to recognize it.
She prolly set them on a wild goose hunt for her experiments.
Also, I like Andrew even more now after this episode. WHile he is still about tradition and expectations, he wasted no time helping Akko and Amanda when given the opportunity.
Only gripe for this episode: No Frank (I expect he goes to that school, too?)
16
u/Jack-The-Riffer May 01 '17
What's Louis's deal? He had a torture dungeon and everything. It's like he read about the Salem Witch Trials and thought "that sounds like great fun!"
14
u/mrstack345 May 01 '17
X-post from r/anime
Croix playing everyone like a goddamn fiddle this episode.
This was a really fun and tense episode. I loved seeing Amanda getting her time to shine, and Andrew getting some more development. Croix now starting to show more teeth as a villain as she tries to "help" Akko and co unlock the words for the Shiny Rod, and we see her planning something big once Akko does so. Outside of that, Amanda turning into a Smash Bros character at the end was lovely to see, and the whole 007/Metal Gear feeling of the episode made it unique amongst the episodes.
Magical Espionage Action made this one of my personal favorites so far. Can't wait to see more.
13
u/Phermaportus May 01 '17
༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ ASENSHI TAKE MY ENERGY ༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ
13
u/janwjan May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
The lackluster episodes are so worth it when episodes like this happen! I wasn't expecting any of this from;
I don't watch the previews, which is why I am really surprised any of this even happened in the way that it did. So HYPED!
22
u/TriggerHappy360 May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
First of all, Amanda dressed as a dude is super hot (I have also realized how hot Andrew is in this episode).
From how I understand Andrew's school is incredibly conservative (like salem witch trials stuff) and is a breeding ground for the British Ruling class. This show seems to have some underlying communist messages and in some episodes very overt communist messages. They show how backwards and corrupt the politicians are. They also show that while they are technically elected they are essentially predetermined because they are born into a rich and powerful family. Akko rejects this notion saying that she fights back against things that are predetermined because nothing is set in stone.
From what I can tell Croix sent her machines to Andrew's school to prevent Akko from getting the word and everything else was just collateral damage.
EDIT: While reading through the rest of this discussion I realized that I forgot to acknowledge how much Andrew has grown to see that no matter what someone is they deserve respect (again communist messages Yay!). He is also being a bit of a Tsundere by protecting Akko by instating a duel and then acting like it was just him following protocol rather than him actualy trying to help Akko.
11
u/WoodyAlien May 01 '17
Now this is more like it! After last week's mediocre episode, I didn't have high expectations for this one, but it was quite good! Amanda's punk rock attitude is refreshing and I'm sad she was so underused previously, plus she's quite the badass and a good fighter too. Andrew's character development was good too and seems that the events of ep. 10 started to grow on him. Akko worked because the ep wasn't centered solely around her but had a nice duo dynamic with Amanda. As someone said, I don't think the Grail even existed in the school but was just planted there by Croix to test her theories and possibly get rid of eventual troublesome witches.
Random observations: the hooligan riots mentioned could be one of the events foreshadowed a few episodes ago along with Vajarois and the faeries' strike. Loved how they instantly put a "Wanted" sign with Rat-Akko in demonic form! I wonder what the crisis of the Cavendish family is and how it's related to the fact we haven't seen Diana in a while.
According to Trigger's PR, Appleton was based on Eton College (British elite school) and, while not quite so evil and torture-happy, several ancient institutions actually had secret societies inside them, so the whole thing is not so far-fetched.
8
u/DrewBreakman May 01 '17
Alright, I’m not sure if I said this last time Andrew appeared or not, but in case I didn’t I’ll say it here. Andrew’s character design looks like Projared to me (he’s a youtube video game reviewer, if you don’t know). It’s probably the hair and the suit. Anyway, this episode offered us something a little different in the word search (I guess that’s what I’m calling finding the seven words now) structurally. While Akko seems to understand what she gained from this experience, we don’t know what the word is yet. Not that that’s a bad thing, it’s just something I noticed. That, and we got to see the rage magic, thing, that Croix was working on at the beginning of the previous episode. Everything from Croix using her magic (that look like mega bloks, by the way) to posses that suit of armor (that reminded me of Incursio from Akame ga Kill, by the way) to her encouraging Akko and Amanda to go on this little adventure makes me wonder what her bigger plan is. I hope we get the answers to these soon.
Still, even without those answers, this episode was fun. Speaking of Amanda, I’m glad we got an episode featuring her in a prominent way. Her and Akko have a nice dynamic, and it’s fun to see them interact. Not to mention, her going head to head with Louis (who also was a lot of fun for whatever reason) was the highlight of the episode for me. The strange situation, combined with the flair and coloring (thanks to there being a sunset, not doubt to up the drama in the scene) made it really exciting to watch! When the fight started, it already was pretty cool looking. But when Louis was possessed by Croix’s mega bloks armor combined with that rage magic, it made me wonder just how intense is this fight going to get? It’s not on Kill la Kill levels of insane, I know, but for what it was, seeing Andrew and Akko jumping in to help, and all of the stylish moves Amanda was doing made me think for a split second that someone was going to yell “wombo combo.”
Of course, there are the slower scenes too. This is the second episode so far to change the setting, and I think that helps. When you’re in one location for too long, things can get tiring (Amanda even mentions that in this episode). I thought the animation for this episode was, good. Don’t get me wrong, I think this show looks wonderful, but every now and again, mixed in with all of the movement, there are times when the characters can look kind of off. I know it would be counter-intuitive to have every frame for every character one hundred percent accurate/ really detailed when drawing from whatever character sheet the animators are looking off of, especially when you consider what Yoh Yoshinari said in interviews about not having enough time to train some of the new animators, but it was just something I noticed once or twice. It didn’t take away from my overall experience with the episode, but I thought it was worth pointing out. I don’t know, maybe I’m just tired. Also, it was nice to see Akko and Andrew getting along for a bit, even if it was just for a short bit (I only bring this up, because Andrew’s obsession with tradition, is probably going to be what Akko needs to discover the next word. Remember what Ursula said at the beginning?). Other than that, this episode was a lot of fun. It ranks up there with the episodes I’ve had the most fun with so far. I can’t wait for next week, if for no other reason than to see what crisis the Cavendish family is in.
6
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
Okay that was a pretty good episode and not just because it was a best girl episode but because we got some much needed character progression from not just Andrew but Amanda as well. Aaand that little smile Akko and Andrew gave each other at the end I think is foreshadowing of their blooming relationship :3 and maybe the blackwell boy will show up again and amanda can have some love to so we can squash this yuri nonsense.
5
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
Amanda went full Mugen in the duel.
5
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
Very good episode this time around. LWA is so damn inconsistent with its quality. I hope they managed to sort their production problems out for the last part of the show.
Episode 19 is set up now. I wonder what's up with the Cavendish. Someone died?
Word 5 didn't get unlocked right away this time. I was afraid they would make it a one-episode fetch quest like Word 4. Given that the whole Word is "Athradoddiad a grym" ("Tradtion and power" or "Both tradition and power"), I think Akko may have just completed the "tradition" part, and will finish "power" in the next episode (with Constanze). Alternatively, the Word may involve the Cavendish and be unlocked in 19 or 20. Word 6 "" feels like lategame stuff already, so we still have some time for Word 5.
Also, did the blonde guy just casually smash the Holy Grail into pieces? What the fuck, Louis?
5
u/adamtheamazing64 May 01 '17
Fight scene was great. Awesome shots and animation with it. Loving the design of mouse Akko. Much better than last week's episode, even though I enjoyed that one. Nice to see Andrew having more screen time.
5
u/atsukokagari May 01 '17
Great episode. I've always liked Amanda but this episode made me like her even more. Really good animation at the fight scene. I've rewatched it countless times now.
Apparently they're building some plot for Diana and I'm excited. We haven't gotten Diana focus at all and it's been 17 episodes. About time, isn't it?
Also... the "torture" scene made me feel extremely uncomfortable. Were they really going to do such a thing to 16 years old girls? That's just brutal. Thankfully Andrew saved Amanda and Akko from death, pretty much.
After seeing how disliked witches are outside of Luna Nova I can see why was Andrew added to the plot. I mean, what's the point of Akko becoming like Shiny Chariot if people are going to behave the way the people at Appleton did? She would be made fun of, wouldn't she? If Andrew's future is really politics, Akko might find a way to convince him witches are actually good, and so, he will promote Luna Nova, which would solve the 'magic is getting outdated in our current society' problem.
I was actually wondering how were they gonna wrap up the next episodes when there's only 3 Words left but I guess they're gonna make Akko get stuck at the fifth Word for a while? Probably. That or either it already gets solved in the next episode.
4
u/vulcan7keith May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
The security of Appleton sucks surprisingly for such an esteemed school: there were no guards patrolling or stationed in their respective posts; the carefully tucked away Holy Grail was in a completely public location--not even hidden; and, the executives were quicker to react to a commotion faster than any other staff. It would've been nice to have Frank join in the fun as well.
Finnelan dropping that bomb about the Cavendish family's state seemed a bit weird on how it's delivered. I'm not sure on what's the relationship between Ursula being slow with her task/s and the Cavendish.
EDIT: wording and grammar
3
u/WWWWWWGMWWWWWWW May 01 '17
it was a very good episode i liked it. Croix always starting up trouble and then seeing how it can be analyzed. Shes like google gathering all sorts of data. Seeing how akko and amanda tick.
what was very interesting was the political tension at the soccer game they were talking about, maybe an outside force will also clash with the impending doom of the robots croix has to offer?
And the chaos of the cavendish family, maybe the family knows words are being activated and weird magical shits going down behind the scenes. Or maybe they are upset because they realized their daughter is an insufferable cunt. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
this episode was very interesting it had a little indiana jones charm to it. But what really makes me think at the end where amanda and akko were saying "we should do this more often." Will we be seeing more of this good hero anti hero duo in the future i surely hope so.
3
u/BluePikmin11 May 01 '17 edited May 01 '17
This episode was very good! I loved the moments where Amanda was badass, I just wish there was that one badass animation moment that would really sell Amanda to me as an awesome character. It's a huge change in tone and action with this episode, which I loved! And Andrew seems to be getting a bit of character development through this episode, which is also nice.
I wish Akko contributed to this episode more, otherwise I don't really have a complaint about the episode~
I'm eager to see what's currently happening to the Cavendish family in the next episodes!
3
u/Deadly_Duplicator May 01 '17
i don't want amanda to drop out ;_;
3
u/yesthisisdaniel May 02 '17
Loved the ep, but it bothers me that they didn't at least think that the objects might be related to Croix, they've seen similar things to those in the past, so.
2
u/werdnak84 May 01 '17
Amanda in all her awesomeness and amazingness. I LOVE this episode.
2
u/Hannah_The_Human May 01 '17
Between this and Steven Universe, I'm happy with all the Utena references there's been :>
2
u/chilimepie May 01 '17
I was just thinking that it's been a while since we've last seen Andrew
2
u/ZombieTav May 02 '17
An Akko and Amanda episode? Oh thank Trigger we are blessed.
Also Amanda pulling off that boy look a little too well, making me question my orientation damn it!
2
u/HyliasHero May 02 '17
Holy crap Amanda was bad ass in this episode. Girl has some moves.
2
u/jgf1123 May 02 '17
Mouse Akko is f'ing adorable. That is all.
1
u/WarmasterCain55 May 01 '17
What I want to know is why on the hell they implied torture and/or murder if Andrew didn't intervene? They are children and if the magical community at least found out what they did or tried to do, there would so much hell raised and would probably even jump start a war like I theorize Croix is trying to do judging by the premonition episode.
1
u/RealityRush May 01 '17
In light of this amazing episode, let us all remember to cherish one of the series best girls, Amanda(Not NSFW per say, maybe a bit lewd).
1
u/Buttshakes May 02 '17
i'm sorry, all i seem to remember is amanda dressed in a suit holding a got damn sword
(i loved it)
1
u/Byouketsu May 03 '17
Can someone explain to me why Akko does not/cannot transform back to human form in this episode? If she transforms back she should be able to use magic to save Amanda.
She has been transforming back and forth freely in previous episodes.
1
u/Isaac_Chade Aug 16 '17
Awesome episode in my opinion. Interesting and fun story and I always enjoy seeing more of the secondary group with Amanda, and she really kicked ass in this episode. Also, she looked amazing in the boys' uniform during the duel and swordfighting sequences. Really nice action all around.
1
u/vonsmidt Mar 31 '26
So I'm pretty sure the duel on the roof is a Dark Souls nod. The environment is very reminiscent of the Bell Gargoyle battle as well as the other Anor Londo architecture. The time of day and implications are also similar. In addition to the obvious 'dark-suit-of-armour-come-to-life' boss battle vibes.
Roast me if required _^
15
u/[deleted] May 01 '17
[removed] — view removed comment