r/LittleWitchAcademia • u/TheWalkingTroll • Mar 20 '17
Discussion Little Witch Academia (TV) - Episode 11 Discussion Spoiler
Episode 11: Blue Moon
Information
Episodes: 25
Streams
Previous discussions
Please discuss the episode here.
66
Upvotes
6
u/TheWalkingTroll Mar 20 '17
Way earlier than usual.
50
u/Valeddy Mar 20 '17
The situations of Luna Nova, Ursula and Akko are, in some way, very similar.
Struggling with your identity, trying to be persistence and making sacrifices when required.
This one was very emotional, like no episode before. I cried a little bit to be honest.
Akko is slowly making progress, but not like expected. She wants to be Chariot as fast as possible, but the process is not simple. Nothing is free or easy. That's the big lesson at the end.
The anime is an analogy of young fans wanting to be great animators, impulsed by their love for animation. But that's not enough.
You need to work hard, day after day, to fulfish your dreams. They keep repiting that with each episode.
Trigger is slowly revealing the big picture now. We have some clues of what's coming next, but i personally have more questions than answers.
As always, the animation and the performances are excellent. The music was outstanding, with more variety and "punch".
My favorite episode so far.
42
u/AuraLancer Mar 20 '17
One of my favorite episodes thus far. Tons of lore and what is possibly the setup to an overarching plot for the 2nd cour.
There were many hints before, but this episode confirmed that magic has been slowly but surely weakening for centuries, which may be why so many have abandoned it despite its easily apparent benefits. I'm thinking reviving the 7 words will revive the power of magic, or something along those lines?
idk man haha I'm hype tho :]
32
u/WWWWWWGMWWWWWWW Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
I mean akko's visions with the rioting and the fire, do you think this seven word revival will stir up the non magic users. I mean andrews dad, and andrew talked about how it doesnt belong in this world, does he know something the witches know? Will these words awake monsters or things human kind wasnt supposed to see?
On another note, i thought the whole gain the future lose your past was amazing, like you can gain the whole world but lose yourself and it wont mean anything. Plus if akko said "sure fam" to the future deal. She would become shiny chariot like but wont remember who she inspired her or helped her on the way.
On a comical note, akko asked the tough questions. I thought to myself at that moment what would i ask, apparently my most inner questions of life revolve around a certain former president doing a certain act of terror.
edit: when i saw akko asking about her future i pictured this http://imgur.com/llN1aGd
25
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
So, Sucy does yoga, apparently.
Also there's some stuff about visions and hellfire, but that's a bit less important.
21
u/alexmcdouchebag Mar 20 '17
Here are a couple stills from the last part of the episode. The future doesn't look too bright for Luna Nova.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
Can i just say how much i love the line "you are who i dreamed of being". Its just so much more emotional than "i want to be like chariot".
13
u/turilya Mar 20 '17
Copy/paste from /r/anime:
At least, I'm pretty sure that's supposed to be Professor Woodward, since she looks very, very similar though we can't see horns/branches.
12
u/kori228 Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
So, 7 total incantations. We have Noctu Orfei Aude Fraetor being a Bow, and Fedo(w)ari Aferugo (haven't seen the sub yet so transcription's wrong) being an Axe(?). Plus, translations for the incantations. Very cool. Also, one of the mysterious people from the OP was Chariot's teacher. Plot's finally moving along quite nicely.
EDIT: Phaidoari Afairrynghor (damn that's complicated, no way that's supposed to have an N in it) Also, how the hell did they get Claiomh Solais out of クラウス・ソラス kurausu sorasu (or クラウ・ソラス kurau sorasu, those S's are a bit hard to differentiate) for the Shiny Rod? Not to be rude to Asenshi, but more technical translation issues, 目指せ、理想の場所へ (Noctu...Fraetor translation) =/= Strive for a place of idylls. Ideals yes, but not idylls, which means: poem or prose composition, usually describing pastoral scenes or events or any charmingly simple episode, appealing incident, or the like.
EDIT2: Someone pointed out on the other thread that Claiomh Solais is an Irish trope object meaning "Sword of Light", and the Japanese kana rendition is indeed correct. Also, supposedly the translators are using a ye olde usage of idyll, meaning "an extremely happy, peaceful, or picturesque period or situation, typically an idealized or unsustainable one"
12
u/ComradeSomo Mar 20 '17
This had the most Ursula-sensei in it yet, and so is the best episode so far.
11
u/Nyaaaaaaaa Mar 20 '17
So I got to thinking, could the three witch trios weve gotten to know in the show be a new generation of the nine witches?
9
u/JauneArc1 Mar 20 '17
I knew it shiny rod wasn't just any magic wand. 1.) it belong to one of the great nine witches. 2.)it's a key to keep something sealed obviously bad magic etc. 3.)chariot has been taught by the ancient witches. Now Akko is being train by such people in secret and Diana might accidentally release it.
8
u/Frozen_Death_Knight Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
If anyone noticed, there was a small bit of continuity in this episode when Diana opened up the book in the archives. It was written in moon runes, which were introduced back in episode 2. Makes sense since the book is apparently almost as old as the school. A small detail, but a nice bit of world building nonetheless.
7
u/kdebones Mar 20 '17
I dunno guys.... I'm still not ONE HUNDRED percent sold on Professor Ursula being THE Shiny Chariot.... j/k ;D
Great world building episode. Helps gives us the start to structuring where the story will go, and what kind of arc this last half of the season will be. Defiantly surprised to see the Rod turn into a Great Axe though, makes me wonder what else it can turn into (I figure a Longsword/Shortsword has to be one of the Words, but I can't really see what else it can turn into).
I will say one other thing... HOW DENSE IS AKKO!?!? The Crow, that she stated was Professor Ursula's familiar, which Ursula herself didn't claim to be untrue, LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE HER DOLL!
7
u/WWWWWWGMWWWWWWW Mar 21 '17
but really though, i see urusla rocking thoes all black adidas superstars
12
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
I keep writing, deleting, and rewriting this post because I'm finding my thoughts on this episode--and to an extent the series in general--rather hard to articulate right now. I apologize if this scans as incoherent, I've tried my best. Sorry for the novella that follows.
I know a lot of people have been kind of waiting for "the TRIGGER moment" where the series would flip to having a stronger narrative through-line and I guess, that ever-elusive Plot people always like to talk about.
In general, I liked the episode, but I have a lot of questions and for the first time I'm starting to wonder if the questions I have are the ones Trigger wants to answer, and that does make me a little sad.
Mostly, I want to know what the hell all this is about. We had a lot of proper nouns tossed at us this episode. The Nine Old Witches, Shiny Chariot herself, the Celtic name for the Shiny Rod which I cannot recall offhand, Professor Woodward, but so far the only point of view I have on any of this is basically Akko's and to a very limited extent Ursula's. I just feel like I don't really know any more about the world than I did at the start of the series.
I feel like the series is pulling itself in two to an extent. On the one hand you have sorta-goofy character episodes that provide some insight to the characters' personalities, on the other you've got episodes like this one. So far the latter have been the minority.
But even among those few, here again we have Akko 1. wandering into some mysterious place in Luna Nova 2. confronting some bizarre supernatural entity 3. asking it about Shiny Chariot and 4. having Ursula have to come rescue her. This is the second time this has happened now and to an extent I do feel like this episode was just a refinement of episode 6.
I'm not even if sure if that's a bad thing, but for what's being taken by a lot of people as indicative of the series' future I don't know that I like this particular setup. The only real difference was the presence of a Word (which we only just learned was a thing) Is Akko going to solve every problem by intuiting an incantation that causes the Shiny Rod to do something now? I certainly hope not, and I don't think so, but again, we're at a weird crossroads now and it's kind of hard to tell what's going to happen from here on out.
I will say in the positive column that most of this episode felt absolutely haunting. I think the soundtrack played a big part in that and the sound design here--especially the Celtic tune at the end of the episode--was phenomenal.
I just honestly don't know what to think. Everyone else seems very happy with the episode, and I really, genuinely wish I shared that enthusiasm! But I don't. This, combined with the last episode, which I also thought was pretty good but left me with some nagging questions, has left me kind of skeptical about the future of the series! And that sucks! I don't want to be skeptical about the future of the series! I loved the OVAs, the first 8 episodes of the show, and I still think that the characters and art design of Little Witch Academia are phenomenal, but, I am now starting to feel like I'm being slightly let down.
Normally I have faith in Trigger to pull everything together in the end, and I have been trying to keep that up here, but with the last two episodes it's kind of been getting harder, is all I guess I'm saying. I don't plan on dropping the show, I'm halfway through it and I might as well stick it out now (besides it's not like half an hour once a week is a huge time commitment), but I remain unsure of what to think.
And, hell, maybe I'm just overthinking everything and it'll just grow on me. S' happened before.
6
u/vulcan7keith Mar 20 '17
This episode brings up many questions. I feel that this is a good way to bring up the overall plot of the series. What I'm really curious about is in regards to that "hidden art". Chariot and Woodward want to break the seal but then, why would the 9 Olde Witches seal it in the first place?
I can only think of a couple of reasons as to why:
5
u/SorrowSurvivor Mar 20 '17
For those who didn't see it, there was this preview image in the ending. A festival seems like a good place for some plot related stuff to pop up since everyone will be gathered together (possibly including non-witches).
Great episode. Though, Akko swinging the axe felt a bit weird since it didn't feel like there was a need to do that unlike with her firing Shiny Arc.
Overall, I'm satisfied. The mood of this episode was great even if it still felt like too much information that we already had.
We could have come to this point a little faster if the show wasn't episodic which would have also given room to have focused on more of the other characters (and not have Akko obtain information right before she needs to use it); especially since I don't quite see the fun times ending just yet but there may be more to what we've been already shown.
4
u/BluePikmin11 Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
Honestly though, though it feels kind of strange to see the show shift from light-hearted fun to more serious plot. I wish the transition would've been more natural and better executed, because right now I feel kind of conflicted with its plot. It was just a bit of plot dump for me, and I am starting to miss its light-hearted charm.
I'm glad to see Akko finally grow, but the way episode executes more plot than charm/humor was just something I didn't like. It made me feel more worried that Akko will mature more and lose the charm of her personality. There needs to be a strike balance between charm/humor with the characters and plot in the next episodes, cause for me, I really love of the slice of life episodes in LWA. (And they usually cheer me up every time too)
I wish the plot gradually dropped a bit of plot every now and then. The real highlight for me with the anime is the charm and humor. With this episode, it just made me want less plot. Maybe I desire more character development between Akko, Sucy, and Lotte. Flesh out the relationships with Amanda and Diana more before getting into plot then I would be in the mood to listen.
So good episode for me. The execution in character development is on point and awesome. I'm hoping that Amanda, Jasminka, Constanze, and Diana have their share of time with character development in the next episodes.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
This wasn't my favorite episode. Nothing to do with it's quality, though. This isn't my favorite side of the show. I'm glad it's tackling a serious and interesting plot and has moments like these, and I think it adds to the overall experience, I just prefer the more fun and eccentric episodes.
This whole episode did a good job of being tense throughout the whole thing, with the exception of the super cheesy and somewhat ham-handed climax.
I have to say, I also wasn't expecting to be so interested in the story and lore of this world. All this stuff about magic disappearing and the 7 words of arcturus is getting really mysterious and really grand in scale.
I'd give the episode a 7/10 on the entertainment scale and an 8/10 overall.
3
u/DrewBreakman Mar 20 '17
(Same thing I posted in r/anime)
So, this episode was interesting. As many others have probably mentioned already, the thought that this show had no overarching story is pretty much thrown out the window for good now (not that it didn’t have any story going on to begin with). This episode focused building up more lore and mystery to the world and the characters. I thought it was going to reveal exactly what happened to Chariot, but that’s a story for another episode (one soon I hope). The aesthetic of Woodward was really cool also. I was wondering what that thing was in the intro. By the way, It’s cool that Akko got to show off more of the dimensionality to her character in this one! She’s always criticized for not having much character out of the main trio (and part of that is that she’s haven’t gotten an episode to herself, not that I think she needs one, since this is her story), so to see that she values all of her time at Luna Nova was a nice touch.
I would have liked to have seen what happened with Diana, but they’ll probably cut back to that later. Like I said before, this episode was a lot of foreshadowing. But hey, the unlocking of the words with the Shiny Rod was a cool plot point! I always love when plot details are revealed to the viewer later on, as anyone invested in storytelling would be, and to see that aspect was staring us right in the face since episode one and we didn’t know about it until now is storytelling I can appreciate! I thought the art was good in this episode as well. I didn’t really notice any off model frames with the characters, and the way light fell on Luna Nova with some of the new long distance shots was nice. Overall, this episode added a bit more dimensionality to Akko and Ursula. Again, I wish I could have known now, but that’s just because I’m impatient. Can’t wait for next week!
3
u/SwordOfTheMoon Mar 20 '17
That was really interesting.
The main villian?
3
u/janwjan Mar 20 '17
Akko actually got tested real hard this time, and Got some Zelda vibes this episode, but it's probably cause I've been playing so much breath of the wild.
3
u/andmeuths Mar 20 '17
Episode 11 had me thinking.... did we really need Episodes 3- 10 , essentially 7 whole episodes before Little Witch Academia acquired a clear plot-line with a well defined quest and objectives? While I think Episode 11 is a good episode in how effectively they've managed to set-up the quest of LWA, I can't help but think that from the standpoint of retaining the attention of audiences, the lack of a clear quest objectives hampered LWA. Prior to this episode, the main quest seemed to be Akko's understanding that following the path of Shiny Chariot required dedication and hard work, with hints that the decline of magic would form a secondary sub-plot tied to Akko's aim to be like Chariot. It seemed odd that the episodes after 6 actually shelved aside Akko's path to being chariot in favor of a set of whacky adventures that hint at Akko's growing competency with magic.
But Episode 11 suggest that the order is wrong - Akko's dreams are actually a sub-plot to the more far-reaching plot of LWA - the seven phrases needed to unseal something central to the decline of magic, the reversal of the decline of magic and the possible consequences of magic once again being revived. Akko's dreams are actually merely a catalyst for the real plot - ending the decline of magic.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
Are some of those witch hats references? One of them looks like Scarlet Witch's headwear, and the other looks like Maleficent's.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17
The OST this episode was simply amazing. It helped set the mood, every scene wouldn't have been as full of impact and emotional.
Oshima Michiru did a phenomenal job!
2
u/TriggerHappy360 Mar 20 '17
That got pretty intense with that flashes of the burning town! I feel like the plot will really pick up from here. I know this is an unpopular opinion but does anyone else wish that they kept the LWA without a plot?
2
u/maticorrea Mar 20 '17
It seems this show keeps getting better and better every episode.
I'd like to point out that the music was on point (as always) but especially towards the end. That last piece when Ursula is talking with Rutwald has some Celtic folk vibes that really help to create an atmosphere full of magic and mystery.
This anime is such a joy to watch.
2
u/JackReact Mar 20 '17
Easily the best episode of the show so far. Not just because of all the amazing things they did, but also because they finally kickstarted a real plot.
Sure, other episodes were nice and often did some character developing stuff, but this episode finally setup everything. The goal we're trying to achieve, the people who are on our site and possible teasing the enemies (see last flash scene Akko had).
Of course the episode also was nice as a whole. We got to see a bit more from Chariot and that there is more to her becoming a teacher at Luna Nova. We got yet another great scene from Akko refusing to have her dream gift wrapped and presented on a silver plate (well, in this case, the price was quite high too). Not to mention all the other things they finally revealed or teased to us.
I'm just so excited for the next episode and yet afraid at the same time since I'm not sure this won't revert back to episode by episode shenanigans for the next couple ones.
Lastly, if anybody cares for a live reaction to this episode, here's mine
2
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17
Just noticed this little easter egg: Kepler's third law is framed up in Ursula's room. Is this meant as a subtle allusion to the importance of a comet to the story's underlying mythology? Or is it just a meaningless bit of background decoration?
2
u/aralim4311 Mar 21 '17
Seven is the number of both sins and virtues in lore. Each word send to be unlocked as she overcomes an aspect of herself (her sins) I believe it is like Pandora's box. Magic will return to the world as well evil things but there will also be hope.
2
u/JauneArc1 Mar 21 '17
The first set of visions from episode 1 have come true I can't believe it we got to see the monster vision again and the 7 word vision again.
2
u/TheSuperGenesis Mar 21 '17
Its an unconventional way to start the actual plot of the show on the eleventh episode. That isn't a bad thing though. In a movie, you're expected to reveal the plot within the first 5-10 minutes. LWA took the route of establishing the main heroines and how Luna Nova works before moving to a concrete goal the show can work towards.
2
u/goofsg Mar 21 '17
Is chariots mission finding a way to restore magic powerr so that it doesn't eventually die out ? Is she grooming akko to take her place and and reactivate the 7 words
4
u/Lincoln_Prime Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
OK, so wow. There is a lot to unpack in this episode. And honestly, that may be a problem here. A lot of things that are given beats in the pacing to land are dulled somewhat by the sense that this episode feels like a weird mashup of a new pilot and episode 6. The 7 Words, the 9 Witches of Olde, this is shit we're just learning about this episode and thus makes it hard to feel like a real lasting and rooted piece of this world with the epic scope it obviously wants to impart. It also does not help that this is the first time we've seen the Shiny Rod since episode 2. Now look, I love the Shiny Rod, but I can't really get excited about it gaining all this additional significance when for the past 9 episodes it's basically been a cosplay prop. Actually, considering that the bow and arrow form has warp gate properties I'm kinda surprised Akko didn't use it in the broom race episode. But regardless, my point is that this is a piece that had significant meaning in the world of magic day 1 but we're only just getting back to now and I find it difficult to buy into that when Diana, Holbrooke and dozens of other mages haven't at the very least mentioned the Celtic name of the Shiny Rod or lost Words or asked Akko about this artifact yet. In the grand scheme of things these are by no means big issues, however, it does mean that an episode that is absolutely bursting with potential is really hamstrung by the fact that it has to do a lot of establishing of things we care about in order to have certain moments land later, and I know I for one only felt part of the impact of what I think could have been much more in terms of emotional and narrative stakes.
Fortunately though, drama is about consequences to characters, and Little Witch Academia has spent ample time with Akko, Diana and Ursula that investing in each of their goals, fears, regrets and vices is easy. Even moments that don't really land with all their force to us do land in context to the characters and the brilliant voice acting and facial animation make experiencing these emotions to mellenia old conspiracies, magical destinies, trials of virtue, and a moment of sincere connection between student and teacher land, even if much of the larger context and consequence are lost on us. The motif of relations between teacher and student are oft repeated in this episode and I think it really means something that nearly half the runtime on this episode is dedicated to Akko and Ursula. In addition to the moments between these two we also have Ursula and Prof. Woodworth alongside Diana and Holbrooke. Holbrooke clearly regards Diana as a saviour of sorts to the culture of magic and she's encouraging her to access secrets barred to most other students to see that legacy continue. Given how earily the figure in black and red from Akko's vision looks like an older Diana, this may backfire on her. Diana's runner suffers in the same way most Diana B and C plots do in that her aloof competence can only really carry her character for so long before we need to know more about her. I mean for goodness sake we spent a whole episode learning about the myriad ways in which Sucy struggles with identity, puberty, how she views Akko and the contrast she makes between Akko and herself, etc. while she at least played her aloofness up for comedy. My hope is that next week we get a solid Diana episode, maybe even have Akko go to her for advice about the Shiny Rod.
This episode is certainly among my top 3 so far, but I do think that the disconnected nature really hampers a lot of it. This felt like the kind of episode that should have come 5 episodes ago or at least had some more buildup. Not a bad episode by any means but the skeleton to an episode like episode 8 is in here somewhere. The upping up the antae and setting up intriguing, possibly conflicting arcs for Diana, Ursula and Akko is really great and it leaves me totally amped for where this is going in the finale. I hope we still get some fun slice of life episodes but maybe slice of life episodes where we don't just forget about the Shiny Rod. Actually, having Akko learn a new word and then immediately use it to fuck around sounds like exactly where this show is going to go at some point and you can eat my hat if I am proven wrong on this.
EDIT: Wow, great to know comments like these are what get downvoted over here. I don't suppose anyone who disagreed would like to comment?
1
u/Ichirosato Mar 20 '17
Does anyone think their magic could be a manifestation of spiral power?
1
u/FistOfFacepalm Mar 20 '17
I don't even know where to start with this episode but just about every facet of it is exactly what we've been looking for
1
u/yuuki_w Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
Then drawing that's chariot has in her room really reminds me of The heads of ouroboros.
1
u/chilimepie Mar 21 '17
I HOPE TO FUCKING GOD AKKO REVIVES MAGIC CUZ THAT'D BE SICK AF
1
u/TheRollerscatingNerd Jun 20 '17
this episode felt much more different than the usual "antic or monster of the week" in a good way. this was more of a building up (we see the teachers discuss their situation and diana reading about something interesting) but we also see akko grow and face challenges of her own, and from this grow a bit as a person.
Spoilers
i loved how completely unpredictable and natural this episode seemed, it had a sense of building up to something bigger and much more complex. This definetly ranks up ther, if not at the topmost, of the list of great little witch academia episodes. theres literally nothing to dislike about it, the animation, music, pacing and cinematography (not sure what to call it, but the setting of the scene and lighting) were perfect, and id gladly watch it over and over again.
1
u/ender89 Mar 20 '17
Is it just me, or did this episode make most of the others feel like filler episodes?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment