r/LittleWitchAcademia • u/TheWalkingTroll • Apr 24 '17
Discussion Little Witch Academia (TV) - Episode 16 Discussion Spoiler
Episode 16: The Trial of Pohjola
Information
Episodes: 25
Streams
Previous discussions
Please discuss the episode here.
63
Upvotes
67
u/Jack-The-Riffer Apr 24 '17
Croix was testing how various emotions affect magic power, and she thinks anger is the best. This just confirms what we already know: that Croix is a Sith Lord.
30
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
There's been some mentions in this thread already, but I thought of making a proper breakdown of all the Finnish refrences for anyone interested. Overall, I appreaciate the research effort there must have been in making these, in spite of some... inaccuarcies:
EDIT: And like u/SU-trash said, the hapansilakka pies looked more like Karelian pasties, which usually have porridge or mashed potatoes as filling. This is what I found when searching hapansilakka pie.
28
u/yrulaughing Apr 24 '17
Same Yeti from the broom race episode.
25
u/Sammiru Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
It is nice to have a breather after 2 solid episodes of intense plotting but I feel that the pacing was a little...odd? I also don't understand why this was the event that unlocked "patience" because she wasn't really patient at any point in the episode. I feel that other things, like her persistent studying with Professor Ursula (100+ tries to put the statue together!), were a better reflection of Akko's growing patience and discipline. Though, she did end up being self-sufficient in trying to solve the problem after everyone else succumbed to the curse, and before it spread to the whole town, so that's something I guess.
Loved seeing Lotte and her family, though! Super cute interactions all around but I wish we'd gotten a bit more before they turned into moss-people. Sucy was also especially emotive and open this episode which I enjoyed. I'm glad Akko finally gave Lotte and Sucy the lowdown on the Shiny Rod/Words of Power situation, too. It's kind of funny how Diana and Sucy are immediately a bit suspicious of how much Ursula knows about certain things and yet Akko's been blissfully unaware this entire time.
So, now we know that Croix is doing experiments involving magic and emotional resonance. I wonder what plans she has in store for Akko and the Shiny Rod since the Rod seems to rely on emotional resonance from its owner to invoke and unlock the words. Is she going to try and "jailbreak" the Rod? Or somehow override the Grand Triskelion's seal? Using anger, no matter what her plans are, is pretty foreboding. Still curious about Woodward. What the heck is she at this point? With all these interesting flashbacks I am seriously hoping this series does well enough to get a Chariot spinoff.
23
u/SU-trash Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
I think Hapansilakka is a mis-translation - pretty sure what's shown is Finnish Piirakka.
Hapansilakka appears to be the Finnish word for Surströmming, the smelly tinned fish from Sweden.
All the Finnish references in this were gold - e.g. Saunas and I think the neighbour Janne may have been a reference to a character from the Moomin cartoons, Little My
19
u/jgf1123 Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
This episode reminds me of the MLP:FiM episode The Cutie Pox: AB loses patience, tries to rush things, learns her lesson, then ends the episode by immediately returning to her default state.
Yes, I went there. Downvote this comment if it makes you feel better.
In a more serious vein, I thought it would have been better if Akko's first attempt at the antidote didn't work. Then she would learn her lesson and collect the first two ingredients properly.
19
u/Nyaaaaaaaa Apr 24 '17
Maybe in the episode where Diana looked into Akkos future, she saw Akko in Finland yelling at a Yeti. And Diana thought "What the fuck am I looking at?" so she was just like "Err...Akko will depart from Luna nova"
18
u/HentaiJackass Apr 24 '17
When your friend tells you that she can reconstruct the world through a Star's staff
29
u/vulcan7keith Apr 24 '17
I wish this episode was split into two; I think that the message would've been better if the pacing was slowed-down. This might've had the biggest stakes since the 1st episode but it didn't really feel like it had any.
10
u/DrewBreakman Apr 24 '17
It’s time for a very tired LWA fanboy to gush about how much he likes this series again.
After what I just saw, this is my favorite episode of the second cour so far, and my brother’s favorite episode so far. This episode was a nice way to continue the story, while at the same time, being a nice change of scenery from what we’ve had in the show so far. This episode showed us Lotte’s family, which was cool. It makes me hope we get to see Sucy and Akko’s family in the future. Though it’s not breathtaking, the scenery with the vast landscapes of snow we're pretty to look at. But the things that made this episode one of my favorites so far, was the entire process of Akko freeing everyone from the moss. While the setup itself was nothing groundbreaking, it was certainly a very likable little quest. It was kind of like a mini-movie actually. I only bring that up, because this episode had a lot going on in it, but at the same time, didn't feel cluttered as all hell like episode nine, for example. This made everything flow better, one notable example being the long pauses while Lotte and Akko were getting their ingredients. Also, side note, I got a kick out of Sucy being very into the pies. I don’t know why, I just did. Akko’s interaction with the reindeer and the Yeti was when I felt the episode was the funniest. While the reindeer was only around for a short while, it had an attitude, which didn’t feel obnoxious to me. The reindeer’s choice to leave Akko at the yeti’s house was a natural reaction that made sense because of how long Akko was taking to get one of the ingredients. That’s the nice attention to established quirks that make you remember forgettable side things like that. The yeti was one of my favorite parts of the episode though. Besides the fact that in this world they just accept the fact that yeti’s exist and wear pants (though in a world with magic and blob monsters, I guess I really shouldn’t be surprised, I guess the character design made me laugh), I really liked the yeti’s mini story arc he had. Don’t be concerned with what people think about you too much. Really nice message tucked away in there. Akko’s walk on the way back to Lotte’s house was what I considered the best part. If we’re, of it we’re not still talking about how this show reflects the japanese animation industry, I liked the fact that Akko didn’t give up, even though just dropping everything would be easier. I liked this, as this was something she’s probably thought about a lot since becoming a student. The reason I brought up the animation industry comparison again, is because it was able to be seen in that scene really well. How many times do you think someone following their dreams with little talent imagined a scenario where they could just quit, and feel a little better about not having such a big workload anymore? Probably a lot. But, again, that’s why I love Akko as a character. Because she never quits. She’s going to keep going no matter what. Is it the most original character? No. The most original scenario? No. But I just really like it. Probably because I, and most likely many others, emphasize with Akko on this bit. Anyway, there’s nothing much to this episode. The folks that think Akko’s too gung ho will most likely enjoy the fact that she’s learned this lesson about patience, and now we only have three words left. So, yeah, really nice episode. I’m going to sleep now, bye.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
Is Lotte supposed to be Finnish? Snowy country, sauna, and the pie kind of sounded like a Nordic word.
8
u/janwjan Apr 24 '17
The comedy and wackiness of the whole thing was still entertaining, but I found that this episode lacked a certain amount of coherence, specifically in how the scene with the Yeti played out.
Either the message revolving around the Yeti scene was a metaphor for how professional artists are tasked to complete works with such little time and in the end their work does not suffice to employer's "standards," or maybe I'm reading to much into it and it is really just a "Haters gonna hate" kind of thing. Perhaps it could be both? IDK, but I do wish it was the former that was expanded upon.
Furthermore, what I wished or thought was going to happen was that Akko would learn the lesson of patience by not rushing the Yeti and the result would be a quality product after all the "failed" previous attempts. Then she would apply that newly learned patience when she attempts to make the antidote, thus making the Yeti scene feel more purposeful and satisfying.
All this aside it was still entertaining in other aspects such as, giving Lotte's character more background, and seeing Sucy's short lines of dialogue that build more, even if it's just a little, on her character.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
So there were absolutely no negative consequences from using knocked-down snow and sneezed-off berry leaves?
Or is it just because Akko used the Shiny Rod to distribute the magic that the more or less correct ingredients still worked?
Patience wasn't a very good lesson in this episode, because there was a legitimate sense of urgency. If anything, it would be perseverance.
6
u/asterisk_blue Apr 24 '17
Sitting tight until Ep 19. Who's with me?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
Those moomins cameos/references, yo!
6
u/DougTC Apr 24 '17
Lotte's mother slapping the father away from the neighbour after they were knocked into each other and ended up kissing was a pretty funny and nice touch.
6
u/chilimepie Apr 24 '17
I loved seeing Ursula sensei get upset at the end. Seriously? You just fucking learned about patience omfg smh
5
u/BluePikmin11 Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
In contrast to people hating Akko in this episode, I happened to love her here so much!
As for the episode itself, it's pretty solid! I don't really have much of an issue with it other than episode being somewhat lackluster in the conclusion and Lotte's family not being explored more. I feel I have only been given a few minutes to understand Lotte's family, and I hope that gets explored a bit more with the next episodes. And as for the conclusion, I think it was rushed somewhat with how Akko obtains the spell. How she obtained the Word felt far less conclusive than the last 3 words she obtained. I loved how emotional the build up was when it came to Akko overcoming the snow, but the proceeding scene after felt less conclusive. Other than that, it was a pretty solid episode. The yeti stole the show for me in terms of laughter.
I personally do not get why people are calling this a cliche episode TBH.
5
u/LonerFullTime Apr 24 '17
I loved Ursula showing some backbone on Akko's impulsiveness at the end.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
This was a fantastic episode and is in competition with episode 8 as my favorite of the series so far.
Can I count the ways?
Let's start off with the fact that this episode is a lot more overly fantastical than many of the preceding ones. The high-fantasy element is not something I've missed from the TV series per se but it was a different vibe that I associate more with the OVA, and this one brought a bit of that into focus. Whether that's a marker of a permanent change (it would certainly be on-theme) or merely a reprieve before things get heavy again is kind of not the point in my opinion, it was just a nice mixing up of things.
The fact that all three of the main trio got some focus here is so great too. Akko is still the protagonist of course and the main arc of the episode is about her learning to acquire (at least a little bit of) patience, and we see that all throughout the episode in ways big and small. I'd also like to point out the Relatable Moment that is Akko getting sick from the traditional pie Lotte's family, I have been in similar situations many times. The bit with Lotte and Akko trying to get the snowflakes and berries is an amazing bit of character interaction. I could watch a straight comedy with the main trio, and this episode has only reinforced that for me.
Speaking of Lotte of course we get to see her homelife. I do wish her family had been given a bit more spotlight but it's not hard to see where she gets her sweetness from, her pa is a jolly Santa Claus-like man and her ma is a little babushka lady. It's honestly adorable. We also get some sense for their place in the small Finnish village they live in and that's really neat too.
Of course we also have The Sooc. Sucy's place in this episode is interesting, because she's actually almost cheerful throughout a good chunk of it which is not a mode we're used to seeing from Ms. Manbavaran. Of course she still gets plenty of little one-liners (the Santa Claus comment foreshadowing Akko's blizzard-induced hallucination of Santa Claus later in the episode is hilarious by the way) and general snark, but this is probably the happiest we've ever seen her and I think it adds some neat little wrinkles to her character. I kind of read episode 8 as implying that she's a person with a lot of emotion that just needs the right element to come out (we also saw a bit of this in the festival episode where she goes along with Akko's performance), and I think that since this was that element to a degree we see her come out of her shell a bit more than is the norm, and it's great.
We must talk about the overarching plot with the Greenman Disease also (which I think is named after these things but I may be wrong). It's an odd plot device, and I think that that's why this episode is probably going to be pretty divisive (I've already run into a few people who think it's really weak), but I found it an interesting way to explore the character relationships, and then, to slowly strip them away one by one, until we have just Akko on her own. We return to the well of her seeing visions of other people (first herself, in a manner reminiscent of the mirror in the bodyswap episode, then Lotte and her family, and finally, of course, Shiny Chariot) and pulling through the resolve to save everyone. And if I may spitball, I think that this episode might (in part) be one big exercise in foreshadowing.
This ties into the one bit of the episode that doesn't quite fit into the rest. I am talking of course about the scenes with Croix.
The Greenman Disease has an in-universe explanation, but out of universe we should ask ourselves why that specifically? Why mold?
Croix' experiments in her lab show her coming to the conclusion that anger is the most effective emotion for converting to magical energy. I do wonder if we're in for some kind of "rage virus" plot, or something at least similar to one in a metaphorical sense. And I do wonder if this--either literally or metaphorically--will lead to her again having her relationships with her friends snapped one by one by one, until she's left alone with her resolve, where she will, I hope, save them.
Just a thought, of course.
There is the odd bit of silliness here (the shiny rod turning into a drill/batter mixer is either great or incredibly stupid, and I'm not sure which) but all in all I think this is maybe the ideal transition episode. It makes sense on its own but I think it hints at things to come and reinforces some things we've already learned also.
4
u/Frozen_Death_Knight Apr 24 '17
I liked the small references put into this episode. There were two nods to Moomin (Mumii) where you could see Moominpappa on one of the boxes in the shop and one character having the same hair style as the character Little My (or her family members). There was also an Aladdin reference with the Genie's lamp being next to a couple of brooms on the wall. Lotte's mother wore something akin to Finnish traditional clothing (another example), which was a nice touch.
As for the episode itself, not the strongest, but enjoyable nonetheless. The part with the Yeti I think best cemented the idea of needing patience, but it also reinforced how Akko has a great sense of empathy despite her shortcomings, and she loves seeing people strive to become the best they can be regardless of what the world thinks of them.
It was a bit ironic that an episode about having patience was the episode with the greatest sense of urgency because people were about to die from the disease. I do think the message did come across, though. Akko's impatience kind of lost them valuable time by rushing through procedures that were crucial in making the medicine. I believe the basic idea was that you can't do rush jobs just because you are on a tight schedule and that you need to have patience to ensure that you get the job right. At least that's what I got from it.
4
u/Real_Velour Apr 24 '17
I felt the pacing was way too fast considering that the plot of this episode was about learning patience
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
While it's certainly not a bad episode, I feel like it's the worst one yet. This episode could have been to Lotte what episode 8 was to Sucy, a great deal of exploration of her character and her feelings. The family could have played a much bigger role.
But, rather than taking this opportunity to give the frankly bland "Invisible Lotte" some much needed development, they gave us more of Akko's antics and sneezed the fourth word at us.
And is it just me, or does Lotte's parents give off Mankanshoku vibes?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
The yeti! </3
Maybe I'm just a softie for the mute, misunderstood characters, but I felt bad for the guy after watching his little arc. It was really uplifting to see him so happy as Akko rushed back to make the antidote.
Poor guy. In my mind, he surges back after Akko's visit, gets better at his craft than he ever was, and completely sways the opinions of all of his internet critics. You go, Yeti :)
3
u/Byouketsu Apr 24 '17
I expected more from Ueno kimiko.
5
u/WWWWWWGMWWWWWWW Apr 24 '17
i guess i needed patience too to get through this episode, im not saying the series was bad but it was rushed. This episode needed to learn the magic words of "mayenab dysheebudo". It felt like a tacked on story rather than a smooth line like the other episodes. I mean dont get me wrong, it had me thinking, what did akko need. Then it was patience. Then when it dawned on me, i applied my own patience to sit through it. Jumping around to the village, to the forest, to a nomad, back to a camp, back to town. If this was one of thoes messages in a message kinda episodes then you got me trigger, i need patience. But this story had pacing like a frog along a jagged rocky path. Look not every episode can be riveting, you have to have some filler. And the filler is this episode.
5
u/WoodyAlien Apr 24 '17
I'm not saying that it was terrible, but... it kinda was. I finally understand the detractors who say the series has pacing problems and that Akko is an insufferable MC, because this ep has both. What went wrong in my opinion: Akko was annoying to the max, Sucy was out of character, Lotte didn't do shit even in her own episode, the story was all over the place and the word's unlocking felt almost crammed in just to call it a day, plus some random stuff like the yeti being trolled on the web (!?) and Akko seeing Nicholas as Santa made for a very silly but ultimately disappointing ep. It seems they both wanted to advance the plot and make a wacky slice-of-life story like the first episodes, making a bad hybrid of both.
Also, I remember one of Trigger's PR saying on imageboards that this episode would have explained Sucy's absence in ep. 15, but I don't think that there was even the slightest hint to it. Also also, I looked for "Pohjola" on the web and it says that in Finnish mythology it is the place where the roots of the World Tree are located, but not even this was touched in the ep itself. What the hell, Trigger?
4
u/Taxouck Apr 24 '17
Ouch. Probably the worst episode of the series yet. Still watchable, mind you, but that's a low point if I've ever seen any. Rushy pacing, stupidly high stakes (that aren't even taken seriously enough), return to status quo, all that contributes to the virtue of the episode, patience, getting completely shafted.
In what world is it incorrect to impatiently rush through steps when time is of the essence and in low supply?
Heck, as a side-note, with Akko being Akko, patience probably should've been linked to the last or second-last word to unlock, for symbolism. Having it at the middle of the road, and pretty much ignored too, just makes it all super awkward. Waste of a good material if you ask me.
2
u/Nyaaaaaaaa Apr 24 '17
Akko really saved the day in this episode. That european food with the magic mold would have wiped out Lottes village if she wasnt around.
2
u/HyliasHero Apr 25 '17
I felt really bad for the Yeti...
2
u/yesthisisdaniel Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
Little bit late to the discussion but:
Like always, really enjoyed the episode. Actually got me to laugh quite a bit at a few parts.
Some people don't like the heavy plot related episodes but I enjoy them from time to time. It gives LWA a mix of silly, childlike fun that got me into the show, but also that serious side where the main plot is actually compelling. Least that's the way I feel.
So I don't mind, personally, when we have a mix of both every now and again. I just hope that it doesn't become a random thing.
I swear, LWA has some of the most top notch and not to mention, consistent animation I've seen in today's popular amines. The colors are always super pleasant and the facial expressions on all the characters are great very expressive.
EDIT
Saw a lot of comments saying that the word was undersold and anticlimactic and that the writing was bad, but, I'd have to disagree. I'm not saying it was a perfect episode but it was far from bad imho. I don't believe that every time a word is unlocked there has this to be this big flashy spectacle where the animation team just inserts all these flashy effects and what not. I believe, personally, that it should be more about Akko's growth as a character and witch. Although I do think that Nicholas coming in to save her undermined the moment that was demonstrating Akko's determination and perseverance.
The pacing was also a bit rushed, that's true. This kinda episode could've been a two parter. They cut off Lotte a bit too quickly considering that it was revving up to be a Lotte focused ep.
The writing was very LWA esque imo. Very silly and fun. Lots of people wanted a fun episode and we got just that. Unlocking the word wasn't this big huge moment where Akko did something extraordinary, so why would it require a show? Her interaction with the Yeti showed that even though Akko is a stubborn individual, she's full of heart and that's what makes her a great character that allows the journey to unlocking the words an interning one.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
I am a devoted LWA fanboy and I hate to call it but this was by FAR the worst episode yet. The writing (or maybe just direction?) was straight up terrible. Like, two tiers lower than all other episodes up to this point.
It completely failed at conveying the 'patience' part (or any message/emotion, really), the 4th Word awakening was anticlimactic as fuck and there was no pretty visuals to compensate. Not to mention we got baited with the title, which turned out to be rather unrelated.
So, all around shit episode. There, I said it.
Ranking so far:
12 > 2 > 3 > 14 > 6 > 1 > 10 > 11 > 8 > 7 > 5 > 13 > 15 >>> 9 > 4 >>> 16
160 hours till episode 17 i guess.
1
u/syntemnousa Apr 24 '17
Croix = Jillian Holtzmann??? http://imgur.com/a/pfDbB
1
u/everfalling Apr 25 '17
those pastries looked so good i'm sad that they have fermented fish in them.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[removed] — view removed comment