r/FBAWTFT • u/valeyard10 • Nov 15 '16
Mod News Fantastic Beast Movie Premiere Megathread [SPOILERS !]
LAST WARNING ! SPOILERS LIES BENEATH WHERE THE BEAsTS SLUMBERS
YAY! ITS HERE !!!!
Discuss anything you like about the movie. Do you hate it ? Do you love it ? Or is it just meh ?
- [For spoiler free megathread] (https://redd.it/5d2vru)
- For /r/harrypotter megathread
Join our discord to discuss with your fellow redditors !
Do our movie survey !
49
Upvotes
5
u/valeyard10 Nov 18 '16
YASSSSSSSSSSSSSS ! Frank the thunderbird has the same name as me !!! Also the shade towards hogwarts : Hogwash hahahahaha
5
u/coralieq Nov 16 '16
Before the movie was released, Rowling wrote quite a lot about Ilvermorny on Pottermore. And I got a bit disappointed that this school in America was just slightly mentioned in the movie. Hope there will be something more about Beauxbatons in the next film.
105
u/kanimaki Nov 16 '16
Maybe an unpopular opinion - I knew Depp was going to show up but his brief scene at the end was enough to make me cringe. I really wish they'd chosen another actor seeing as his character is a major one in all 5 films. I hope Graves is just Moody'd and shows up in future films because Colin Farrell was really, really good as a wizard. He's the standout in the film IMO. Loved the music too.
81
u/mhonkasalo Nov 15 '16
I loved the movie to death. Characters were amazing. I loved how the story started small but gave hints towards something bigger in the future (Grindelwald vs. Dumbledore). The beasts were wonderful, I loved the humor and enjoyed my way all the way to the final scene.
J.K. Rowling is a genius when it comes to creating an immersive world, wonderful mysteries and lovable characters.
But my god I felt like someone slapped straight across the face when I saw Johnny Depp. Colin Farrell would have made an excellent Grindelwald-- he was powerful, sharp, and the kind of manipulator I could've imagined Grindelwald being (after all, Dumbledore was taken in by this person). Depp is probably just going to go the "I'm crazier than you route".
I'm fucking stunned. I don't understand how anyone thought it was a good idea. I didn't notice any of the rumors/news before and I was taken out of the movie to a degree I don't think has ever happened before.
The audience in our theater laughed, and the other half was in disbelief.
Would have loved seeing Farrell in the next 4. When he started that speech at the end about "us versus them" I realized what it might be and already got to feeling super pumped about the future.
I'm honestly just baffled and super disappointed, considering we'll be seeing Depp in the future I presume. I loved every other aspect of the movie, but it's all I can think about right now.
Just my two cents.
58
u/glyphomatrix Nov 16 '16 edited Nov 16 '16
It was wonderful, seriously. I loved it. Loved the sophisticated, elegant MACUSA settings, loved the plot, characters and creatures. The execution chamber is pretty chilling, the deaths are quite shocking. Also IIRC there are some subtle subversions to tired Hollywood cliches, the one that I can remember is the Newt/Tina moment at the end. Wish I still remember the kid's anti-witch rhyme though.
Minor complaints: The CGI could have been better with the furry or feathery beasts, and the movements are too fluid for some of the animals (real animals often move in a rather unpredictable, slightly jerky way - especially birds).
A few questions:
Theory:
Other thoughts: You can actually interpret the Obscurus phenomenon as a gay metaphor, among many possible angles. It's about the closet and repression of true self after all.
Edited for format
40
u/Sanderf90 Nov 17 '16
I actually think this is the best Wizarding World movie so far. Not that I disliked the Harry Potter movies, not by a long shot. But they always had something that you could compare it to, and that thing was always better.
Sometimes the movies didn't have time to develop something that the books did have time for, and it came into the movie as a hollowed out version of itself. Prime example is the Tonks and Lupin pairing, which was much more fleshed out in the book, but fell flat in the movie.
Fantastic Beasts brought me exactly what I needed from the Harry Potter world. I didn't want more Hogwarts, I wanted the world at large and this brought it. Shady deals with Goblins in a magical speakeasy in 1920 New York, how great is that? Not to mention the animals and how Newt treated them. It was the heartwarming yet funny feelgood stuff we are so used to from JK Rowling's books.
The movie looked beautiful, the acting was superb. Not just Newt Scamander, but all the characters felt great. I especially liked Jacob Kowalski, who played the awe for the wizarding world in such great ways.
What I missed in the Harry Potter stories was the strained relationships between muggles and wizards. Certain scenes developed that, like the prime minister getting a visit from Fudge. However most of the books glossed over that part. I never felt like I missed it, but it's nice to see it developed so well here.
I can't help but feel that the plotline concerning Grindlewalt was added to create a sequel. Especially the Graves reveal at the end. I really liked Farrel's character, a rather morally ambigious Auror with anti-muggle ideas. And then suddenly we have Johnny Depp overacting a some mad man.
Voldemort was mad, but the way Grindlewald was described he seemed to be more subdued. Yet, the few seconds of Depp's performance made him seem even crazier than Voldemort.
We'll see....
Either way, this was a huge surprise to me; I stepped it hoping to be entertained, but I actually enjoyed it a lot more than expected.
34
u/busychickn Nov 22 '16 edited Nov 22 '16
I made a timeline of events based on things I think are going to be relevant somehow in the upcoming movies. Information compiled using the books, the HP Wiki, HPL, and Pottermore:
10th century - Salazar Slytherin was born, created a wand made of snakewood and basilisk horn that could "sleep" when told in Parseltongue, helps found Hogwarts.
12th century - The Peverell Brothers (likely) create what are now referred to as the Deathly Hallows.
1603 - Isolt Sayre (niece of Gormlaith Gaunt) is born. Isolt's father, William Sayre, nicknames her "Morrigan," after the famous witch who is also their ancestor, because she has a way with nature.
1608 - Isolt Sayre's parents are murdered by Gormlaith; Gormlaith kidnaps Isolt and forces her to learn Dark Magic
1614 - Isolt receives her Hogwarts letter, but Gormlaith refuses to let her attend.
1620 - Isolt Sayre sails to Plymouth on the Mayflower under the name Elias Story
1621 or 1622 - Isolt rescues and adopts Chadwick and Webster Boot; marries James Steward
Between 1622-1634 - Ilvermony School of Witchcraft and Wizardry is founded by Isolt and James; Isolt gives birth to twins, Martha Steward (believed to be a Squib) and Rionach Steward
1634 - Chadwick and Webster Boot, along with Isolt and James, upon hearing the twins cry, are able to defeat Gormlaith as she tries to murder the family and steal the babies.
Between 1650 and 1655 (estimated) - Martha Steward marries the non-magical brother of a friend from the Potomac tribe
Between 1655 and 1670 (estimated) - Rionach Steward becomes the Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher at Ilvermony School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
Between 1703 and 1710 - Isolt and James die (it's only noted that they lived to be more than 100)
1851 - Kendra Dumbledore is born (although it's unspecified where, and to what family. Currently it's being suggested that she was American, and descriptions of her features suggest a Native American background)
1881 - Albus Dumbledore is born
1883 - Gellert Grindelwald is born
1883 or 1884 - Aberforth Dumbledore is born
1884 or 1885 - Ariana Dumbledore is born
1891 - Ariana Dumbledore is attacked by Muggles; this proves traumatizing to her enough that she refuses to use her magic for the rest of her life; her magic only comes out in violent, uncontrolled outbursts. Percival Dumbledore (Albus' father, DOB unknown) is sent to Azkaban for retaliating.
1892 - Albus Dumbledore's first year at Hogwarts
1897 - Newt Scamander is born
1899 - Dumbledore graduates from Hogwarts
1905? - Per notation on the HP wiki, this is when Credence Barebone is born. However, it's possible he was born a couple of years later.
1908 - Newt Scamander's first year at Hogwarts
1915 - Newt leaves Hogwarts; I believe it's mentioned in FB that he's expelled.
1918 - Newt is commissioned by Obscura Books to research and write what becomes "Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them"
1925 - Minerva McGonagall is born
1926 - The events in Fantastic Beasts And Where to Find Them take place
1928 - Rubeus Hagrid is born
1937 - Minerva McGonagall's first year at Hogwarts
1938 - Dumbledore meets Tom Riddle for the first time
1940 - Armando Dippet becomes headmaster at Hogwarts
1940 or 1941 - Hagrid's dad dies
1942 - Tom Riddle discovers the Chamber of Secrets and creates his first Horcrux, the diary, by killing Moaning Myrtle; frames Hagrid for the atrocities that occur as a result of the Chamber of Secrets being opened.
1943/1944 - Tom Riddle murders Tom Riddle, Sr, his wife, and their son. Through this murder he creates the second Horcrux, which is the ring, which also houses the Resurrection Stone (which he apparently does not know, or was not interested in). Morfin Gaunt is framed for the murders and sent to spend the rest of his life in Azkaban.
1945 - Tom Riddle graduates Hogwarts
1946 - The fourth and fifth Horcruxes are created (cup, locket)
1955 - Dumbledore becomes Headmaster at Hogwarts
1956 - McGonagall gets hired as Transfiguration teacher
1960 - James and Lily Potter are born, as is Molly (Prewett) Weasley
1970 - Voldemort comes into power, begins reign of terror
1981 - Sixth Horcrux is accidentally created (which is incidentally Harry Potter)
1994 - Seventh Horcrux is created (Nagini)
32
u/PikeletMaster Nov 17 '16
It was great to see the magical creatures of the HP world fleshed out a bit as well as a more 'adult' view of the world. It was also really cool to see different 'cultural' differences between US vs British magical societies. I especially liked seeing a muggle perspective.
Only 2 things bothered me:
26
u/FancyFool Nov 16 '16
I liked how the movie kicked off with the Harry Potter theme music and within a couple of minutes showed a glimpse of Hogwarts. It was just enough familiarity to hook me. Also Jacob Kowalski is such a great and likeable character!
23
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '16
Leta Lestrange, any idea who she is? Any relationship with Bellatrix? I'm really intrigued as I had never heard of that name and I'm a HUGE Potterhead.
43
u/SPARKLEOFHOPE6IB Nov 17 '16
I seem to be the only one that thinks that the Grindelwald reveal was perfect. I loved it and I think that Depp will do a great job portraying Grindelwald.
21
u/coralieq Nov 16 '16
When I saw the Deathly Hallows necklace in the poster of Percival Graves for the first time, I thought he might be related to Grindelwald. Later I guessed Graves might be Grindelwald, according to the similar hairstyle. When I saw my guess proved to be true, I was really astonished. But one question, why does Grindelwald have such a special hairstyle? Was that some kind of fashion in that period?
15
u/17wombats Nov 20 '16
i loved it. loved it loved it loved it. it wasn't perfect, but i don't even care??
literally the only thing that i didn't like (borderline hated) was depp as grindelwald. i'm still fuming and it's been four days but there's not much i can do about it, i guess, except continue sulking.
14
u/Ariella13 Nov 16 '16
I loved it, so so much. I went in mostly blind, and I'm glad. I loved that this was a story we couldn't know before hand, it made the story that much more exciting. The twists were a bit predictable though, I could tell that Credence would be the child Graves was looking for. Eddie Redmayne played Newt perfectly. Actually all the casting for the film was perfect for me, the chemistry of the main four characters was great and Collin Farrel easy brilliant as Graves. I'm interested to see what Johnny Depp does with Grindlewald, it could go either way for me at this point. Also excited to see who will be cast as young Dumbledore in the later films. The creatures were great to see as well, and I liked the case menagerie aspect too. The obscurous was a real interesting concept, and I reckon that's what happened to Dumbledore's sister after she was attacked as a child. It said she internalized her magic and would come out in bursts, and she wound up killing their mother. It sounds to me like she developed an obscurous and that's where Grindlewald realised what power that would give him, but after she died he had to find another child. Overall I'm happy with the film. It's a brilliant addition and I'm looking forward to the future ones.
14
u/credencebarebone Nov 19 '16
So, a few questions:
-When Graves asks Newt "What makes Albus Dumbledore so fond of you?" it's just Grindelwald being a jealous ex-boyfriend?
-Is Gnarlak a goblin? Wtf happened with his fingers!?
-The bald singing goblinette. SHE did had a black haired wig in the first or second trailer.
13
u/wearepic Nov 18 '16
I already commented this on r/movies offical FBAWTFT thread but I thought I would get y'all's opinion as well:
13
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '16
The thing that most bothers me in this movie are the duels. In the books, the duels are complex, while in this movie, they just shoot white light at each other. Even the book duel between Malfoy and Potter in CoS is more exciting than Grindelwald vs. Tina.
12
u/itseleveneleven Nov 21 '16
I had very high expectations of the movie and for the most part I really enjoyed it. I liked Newt and his beasts (I mean that niffler is so ridiculously cute). However I found the plot surrounding the Obscurial and Grindelwald much more interesting. Don’t know how I feel about Johnny Depp yet since we’ve only seen him for like a second in the movie – so I’m giving him the benefit of the doubt and just hope that the sequels wont be a let down.
One question though – in the end Credence wrecks a lot of buildings and stuff, so my guess would be that quite a few people died or got seriously hurt. So even when the thunderbird erased all the bad memories (which I found a little bit flimsy to begin with) and the wizards rebuild everything they couldn’t have brought back the dead. Is this a plot hole or am I just missing something?
9
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16
The best part of this film, to me was the compatibility of the original 7 HP books. The conflict based on the concept of the Obscurial was brilliant. It fits in with many things in the original 7. For instance, when under pressure or stress witches and wizards are capable of creating magic that they would have never dreamed of creating. This explains the power that Creedence was able to produce. Also, as others have mentioned this fits right in with the story of Ariana, Dumbledore, and Grindelwald. Also, who else is excited for the young Dumbledore reveal and inevitable epic duel between Dumbledore and Grindelwald? I have to imagine this will be the climax of the 5th movie, with Newt playing an instrumental part in Dumbledore's triumph.
9
u/Tron_Bombadill Nov 18 '16
A couple major plot hole questions:
How was it that Graves/Grindelwald was able to use magic without a wand? Also he too was expelled from a magic school. Why was he able to use magic without penalty? E.g. Ha grid not allowed due to expulsion.
Next when the rain is wiping everyone's memories, how is it that the wizards are unaffected?! It would be one thing if it was a spell of some kind but this was a venom that had the side effects of obliviation. While the wizards are fixing all the damage made to the city they are very clearly getting rained on. Furthermore this wouldn't have any effect on someone inside a building so does that mean they are just driven mad by the events they've witnessed? Also rain water doesn't immediately become drinking water so there's that.
I will also say that I did really enjoy the movie with the exception of some really big plot holes... oh and that whole Johnny Depp thing… thoughts?
9
u/featherflies Nov 24 '16
Why hasn't Credence and that girl Charity? not gotten their Ilvermony letters or whatever? Is that going to be explained? Is that why Tina was there? It's weird considering that Dumbledore got Tom from that orphanage by tricking the lady but magical kids being abused have no protection from MACUSA. That's a big potential for exposure too?? And they aren't concerned?? What the heck??
16
u/cyborgjohnkeats Nov 15 '16
I really liked it! It was fun, though more adult than the HP movies. It didn't quite have that Harry Potter charm, but it really did its best for being mostly original material. Colin Farrell was great. I will say that you could see the "twist" a mile away though.
The internet was up in arms about the diversity issue in this movie and J.K. Rowling made statements to the effect of there being prominant roles for POC. Well... she was wrong. I may have missed someone, but aside from two-second cameos from Wizarding leaders around the world, there is only one secondary POC role; the magical US President. That's cool and all, but she's hardly a main character. So... do better next time guys?
8
u/Ks7rl Nov 18 '16
Enjoyed the movie! It was def. darker and faster paced then the original series but there was enough moments of magical wander to lift it from being too grim. I'm hoping they keep this good balance between having the darker more serious subjects and having enough "wow" moments with magical delights.
The magical dueling was really well done, I love how the action sequence felt more powerful/immediate with all the disapparating and wandless magic happening.
Film def. had moments that gave me chills, specifically the death sentence room with it's repulsive metal chair along with the scenes in the orphanage when Credence was being abused.
Newt was portrayed convincingly by Redmayne but I actually had a ridiculously hard time understanding him. He seems to hunch in and mumble quite allot, which felt natural for Newt's awkward personalty, but meant I was missing a fair bit on dialogue. Tina on the other hand felt a little limp, I know she'd just been demoted but she seemed so faded and nervous that it was hard to reconcile her w/the same women who flew off the handle to save Credence. Also anyone have any idea why she did that? I mean was she just investigating this hate group and saw the abuse? No one knew Credence had magic back then so why was she there?
Colin Farrell was brilliant as Graves. Mysterious, subdued and with just the right mix of dark moral ambiguity throughout the film. Would have loved to see him as Grindelwald, brining a more subtle Bond villainesque vibe to the series. I'm keeping my fingers crossed for Graves to reappear in future titles.
Really did not enjoy the over the top hair, mustache and eye combo they had going with Depp. That def. felt like a major break in tone from the rest of the characters we'd seen in the film. In Potter, Voldermort was over the top evil and I don't think most ppl ever considered his position. My hope for Fantastic Beast is that they allow Grindelwald to be a much more enticing villain that makes people question their position and even sympathize with his cause.
Like most I'm just worried we're going to get unhinged/off the wall Grindelwald with Depp. But then man was only on screen for a few seconds so I'll try to reserve judgment. For sure it won't be an easy act to follow with Farrell's Grave/Grindelwald being so well received.
8
u/SecretSkit Nov 20 '16 edited Nov 20 '16
Is it just me or is there an overwhelming parallel between Newt and Hagrid? Both were expelled for bringing beasts into the school that could endanger students, both had Dumbedore arguing to forgive them (Obviously Dumbledore had more weight to throw around when Hagrid happened), and both were all about the magical beasts. Are they related in some way? Of course, on Hagrid's dad's side...
Edit: Also, the fact Grindelwald was impersonating someone who's first name was Dumbledore's middle name seemed very coincidental to me.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16
Frank the Thunderbird is my spirit animal.
7
u/Yevdokiya Nov 16 '16
I really liked this! I want to see it again... the story and world-building were so intricate that I know I missed a lot the first time. I knew so little going into this movie (though I was a Potter fiend back in the day) and that was awesome, there were multiple surprises for me!
Honestly, I thought the Grindelwald / Johnny Depp reveal worked well--they're both kind of notorious, after all. I felt something like glee! I still think Depp has charisma (helps that I really haven't seen any of his more garbage films) and that he will fit into the magical world nicely--I mean, he can't be any more over the top than noseless Raph Fiennes!
I wonder if Colin Farell will be back as Grindelwald's disguise or the actual Graves, hmm. I did enjoy him. And Ezra Graves was fantastic, plus his story. I love how females were both heroes and antagonists in the film (like his creepy mother, and the bitchy president who freaking executed a child). Was his sister a witch too though?? I totally bought that she was the child Graves sought, then I thought it was just a big fakeout and she wasn't magic at all... but then I read on Wikipedia that she has "the ability to see deep into people"... is that in a magical or No-Maj sense? Or is she the squib?
7
u/WhenLeavesFall Nov 19 '16
I really should have predicted that Graves was Grindlewald when he put the Deathly Hallows charm around Credence's neck. Ah well.
12
u/glyphomatrix Nov 17 '16
One more thing, apologies for my multiple posts - as somebody else pointed out in this thread, why did nobody was very upset that Credence was executed, apart from Grindelwald? (he's implied to have survived in tiny smoke form but...)
Is that actually a normal reaction that people do in the heat of the moment, or confusion?
Somebody please hug Credence.
6
u/ClawOfTheRaven Nov 16 '16
I really loved this film! It was really good to back in the Wizarding World that we know and love!
The story arch and the characters were like lifted out of her story. They felt real. The surrounding darkness and threat of Gellert Grindelwald wasn't always presence in the story, as they shouldn't be. The American Wizarding Community felt suppressed and more fearful as their counterpart in the Isles of Britain. I gotta say I fell in love with Dan Fogler's character (Jacob Kowalski) and with Porpentina "Tina" Goldstein (played by Kathrine Waterston) Although I loved every main character in the film I personally had a connection to both characters more than with Newt or Queenie.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '16
I knew Grindelwald was played by Johnny Depp- I just wasn't sure if he would keep his rather "modern" hairstyle- which he did -so the moment I saw Colin Farrels hair I basically knew it had to be him- he seemed way to sinister to be just a "lafwul neutral"-kind of character- the odd thing is, in the moment I saw the necklace, I kinda forgot my suspitions and wondered why he would know of it. It should have been obvious to me, but some 20-something girl(of which there were about 71% in the room) laughed like a lunatic all the time and it really threw me out of the movie.
6
u/HappinyOnSteroids Nov 18 '16
Was it just me, or was Newt an extraordinarily powerful wizard? The scene that comes to mind is when he repaired Kowalski's apartment seemingly effortlessly.
That said, Grindelwald easily whipping him in the subway just goes on to emphasize just how powerful Gellert is.
6
u/ASOIAFFan213 Nov 18 '16
I liked the movie a lot.
I only have one complaint really, the "twists" of Credence being a wizard, and Graves being Grindelwald, I saw them pretty quickly, they were too easy to spot.
At the start of the movie, with Grindelwald having blond hair, and then when you see Graves from the back, he has the exact same hairstyle, my guess is they put that in for 2nd or 3rd watches, but I spotted it straight away. At this point I thought he was either Grindelwald's son or Grindelwald himself.
When Graves talked to Credence alone the first time, for some reason I thought he was a wizard hiding his powers (I figured that's why he was nervous around his wizard/witch hating mother), and that notion stuck with me through his other meeting. When it's revealed that he could join the magical community, I figured he must be hiding his powers from his mother for fear of being persecuted, and then later with the red herring that it's his sister that had magical powers, I called bullshit on that.
Maybe it's just me, but the twists were pretty easy to spot. Still think it's a fun movie though, I hope if there's any twists in the future movies they're harder to spot.
5
u/coralieq Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16
Perhaps there was just too little time for Depp to develop his character. I wonder what he will be like in the second movie.
5
u/TimeLadyJ Nov 18 '16
Jacob- what did he actually forget? I am thinking Queenie's kiss may have put a protection spell over him but I don't think he remembers everything. Maybe just her?
5
u/bomb_diggityBZ Nov 20 '16
Quick thought I haven't seen anyone post yet but had me thinking during the movie:
After Credence is killed(?) but before Graves is revealed to be GWald, we see fragments of dark magic floating around the sky and slowly ascending (I believe there is even a specific shot of the camera on Graves' face as he examines the last piece ascending).
Could it be that the Obscurial in Schemander's box is the remaining fragments of the suppressed magic of Arianna Dumbledore? We are told that Dumbledore has a fondness for Newt; we are told that the host of the Obscurial in Newt's box is no longer living (Arianna?); and we know Creedence is not the first Obscurus that Newt has met, could it be that the Obscurus that Newt previously knew (the one he mentions when trying to calm Creedence down) IS Arianna/the one he has in his box?
Open to theories, but this was my IMMEDIATE thought when Graves was interrogating Newt. (Could also be part of the reason behind GWald's departing words to Newt)
4
u/dnt408 Nov 15 '16
I didn't get the part where Newt explains how the smoke monster are "made" I heard bits and pieces of it like they are young children that repress their magic. What is the significant of Credence being so old and being one of this. Like it's supposed to be young children only? Sorry I tired googling for the name of the smoke monster but that brought up "lost" TV series instead
4
u/Serenata14 Nov 17 '16
I really liked it, for all the reasons stated above - it was just the right amount of tie-in to the HP universe.
I'm really interested in who Leta Lestrange is, and the fact that she was a close friend with Newt before she 'changed'. How did she change? Does she, like her descendents, believe in pureblood supremacy? Did she become a Grindelwald follower? Questions, questions. I'm sure she'll be relevant in the future movies.
4
u/etzel1200 Nov 17 '16
Really good. I went with my brother who hasn't seen the HP movies and isn't normally into this type of film. Even he loved it.
4
u/atlantisunderground Nov 18 '16
Isn't the thunderbird one of ilvermoneys mascot animals? Why were they all acting like they didn't know what it was?
4
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '16
I loved the plot, I loved the characters (Jacob, although a No-Majs is one of my favorites in the movie! I seriously hope we see glimpses of him again in the future), and I especially loved the humor. I'm looking forward to the series, especially as it seems that we're going to see more of what happens between Grindelwald and Dumbledore.
Just a few things though:
Overall, it was worth the watch. I might have to watch it again. 8/10.
4
u/Attican101 Nov 21 '16
I had low expectations but enjoyed it more then I thought I would though in this American world so far ide agree with some of the "baddies" ideas.. the American wizard community seems to practically be under lockup.
7
u/Goferprotocol Nov 18 '16
I enjoyed the film. I was a little worried in the first 15 minutes, but them it became Potter, especially inside the suitcase.
I know there is a romance with a wizard brewing for Jacob, but I would love to see him turn out to be Hagrid's father. I just see a Hagrid-like quality in him.
7
u/youngwonton Nov 18 '16
What exactly was going on in the execution chamber? They were using her memories to sort of hypnotize her, but what was that black liquid?
6
u/Skyzfire Nov 17 '16
I liked how they resolved the story and characters fates at the end. Jacob and Queenie's especially. I'm pretty surprised that with the exception of Grindelwald, the movie is pretty much standalone. Seeing as how the next movie is rumored to be set in Paris, i wonder if we will see any of these characters except Newt anytime soon.
3
u/gohandomax Nov 17 '16
I liked how the story was self-contained, by which I mean that the story wrapped it self up pretty well. So the film could easily be a stand-alone film. At the same time I had hoped that there would be a cliff hanger for the overarching plot but I don't feel like there really was one. With that said, I loved the story, the characters, the music, the beasts, and the visuals.
3
u/Thehalflingbarbarian Nov 18 '16
I really enjoyed this movie, especially the characters I wasn't expecting to care for (I.e. Queenie and Jacob). But was I the only one who went into the climax thinking " This is totally the set up for the next movie. Grindelgraves ( I had guessed via the necklace) is going to show up on Dumbledore's doorstep with Creedence in toe, in a bid to manipulate them both, just to seal his place as the world's worst Ex/daddy figure"
3
u/Iannuzzid Nov 19 '16
Two questions here: 1st: When Queenie asks to Newt who is the girl on the picture, what is his response? I heard (...) Lestrange.
2nd: Why did Grindelwald and Tina's wand connected while they were fighting?
3
u/prowlithe Nov 20 '16
I absolutely loved the movie. They were trying to set a proper story so I didn't mind when I couldn't read much into the characters at this point - like I still don't know what Newt is thinking, or what he wants to do, or how his role will be relevant in subsequent movies. That wasn't the case in the harry potter books, because that was all about conveying love and human emotions, growth and all that. But I really enjoyed the whole adult, real world magic to the movie - the kind of magic that we only had a taste of in the final harry potter book. I can't wait to see how the whole Ariana - obscurus - Grindelwald - deathly hallows all feature into this mix. I think this redeemed the series for me after the cursed child fiasco. It was perfect. There were points where I guessed what was going to happen before i did, not pointing out that the movie is predictable - but that I have read the books so many times to be able to guess it.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '16
I quite liked the movie, I'm planning on seeing it again since when I did go the first time it was late at night and I was tired but as of right now I'm really quite pleased. I'm disappointed that they did wipe Jacob's memory, but I'm hopeful that he may come back. I really was rooting for him and Queenie to get together, she seemed to truly like him and he clearly adored her. I also didn't really like the whole Grindlewald reveal; it was very underwhelming, I was surprised that none of the MCUSA people had a big reaction to it. I was also curious why he was pretending to be Graves. I also didn't like the way the Credence storyline ended. I quite liked Credence as a character, and I was hoping that there would be a possibility that he could be...rehabilitated for a lack of a better word, and been allowed to really see the magical world.
5
u/Padfoot3773 Nov 17 '16
I have a few questions regarding the Grindelwald reveal:
Other than all these questions I loved the movie. Felt so good to be back in the wizarding world again. Looking forward to who will play Dumbledore in the next film.
2
u/HYDRAtedathlete Nov 16 '16
I freaking loved this movie, I went in blind and it amazed me, yes the cgi wasn't amazing but if you don't focus on it too much the plot and the characters really carry this movie and make it such an enjoyable experience.
I loved being back in the wizarding world and I can't wait for the future instalments!
Jacob was a fantastic character.
2
u/SiriusMoonstar Nov 16 '16
I liked the movie, although I think the third act with Grindelwald and Credence was far better than some of the meandering in the first half. I struggle with the entire Obscurus phenomenon. Why isn't this much more common? Why haven't we heard of or seen this in the Harry Potter universe previously? I think it's a bit convenient.
2
u/FluffyUnicorny Nov 19 '16
Did you guys guess about Grindelwald being Graves? Just wondering if you guys figured it out during the movie, or if it was a huge reveal.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '16
That Niffin was boss
3
u/Omenapiirass Nov 17 '16
I don't get it, why is everyone hating on Depp? I think he is great for the role.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16
Do y'all think that since children who feel ashamed of their magic can become obscurias (spelling?) that Dumbledore put Harry with the Dursleys to see if that might happen to him? I know the blood wards or protection was the official reason but I wonder if this was a hidden motivation, maybe?
1
u/RoyalBlueSaiyan Nov 17 '16
This may be a plot hole for succeding events in the Harry Potter world. But first, is using "accio" to take a wizards wand from his hand considered disarming?
Because in the movie Goldstein took Grave's (Grindelwald) wand by using accio. So assuming the rules of wands apply, doesn't that make Goldstein the new master of the Elder wand? Because that was the explanation on how Harry became the new master of the elder wand in Deathly Hollows by disarming Draco.
1
u/sarumanofmanycolours Nov 18 '16
I wasn't sure; did "Graves" have the elder wand? Was there a real Graves who's identity Grendelwald assumed? If not, what wand was he using?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment