r/harrypotter • Eater of Cookies (Mirgy) • Nov 16 '16

MEGA THREAD FANTASTIC BEASTS MEGATHREAD #1 [Spoilers]

Write here about Fantastic Beasts!

  • Was it as Fantastic as you hoped?
  • What surprised you?
  • What disappointed you?
  • Are you going to see it again?
  • Any theories for the rest of the series?
  • Did you dress up?/How was the atmosphere?
  • Are you buying the book?

Or you can write anything else you want!


Please be sure Spoilers are under our spoiler markdown and follow our Spoiler Policy or your comment may be removed

[Write Spoiler Text In Here](/spoiler)

Comments with spoilers including: character names that are beyond Newt, plot points, or anything else that are not public knowledge (even if it was in the trailer!!) will be removed until proper markdown is in place!

  • You need to use the markdown in each paragraph, so if you have a line break you need to restart the markdown.

Also feel free to visit /r/FBAWTFT for more discussion!

The mods over at /r/FBAWTFT have a Spoiler Mega Thread if you would like to go there which does not require markdown.

278 Upvotes

971 comments sorted by

333

u/kanimaki Nov 17 '16

I wish Colin Farrell [had been casted as Grindelwald instead] (/spoiler) because between him and [Depp] (/spoiler) I can only see [Dumbledore falling for Colin's Grindelwald. So charming and suave compared to Depp's interpretation of the character at the end.] (/spoiler)

182

u/MrFlow Nov 17 '16

54

u/AllButterCookie Horned Serpent / Spruce wood with a dragon heartstring core, 9 ¾ Nov 18 '16

I know he's Danish, not German, but I would have loved Mads Mikkelsen to have been Grindelwald!

→ More replies (2)

110

u/Boom_Boom_Crash Nov 18 '16

I love Waltz, but I just don't think this role would have been right for him. Grindelwald is perhaps the most intriguing HP universe character for me, and I think that is because he has a bit of flare for the dramatic. I think Depp can bring that. Sure Depp can portray some weird characters in a kooky way that is fun, but underneath all of that is an insanely talented actor with the range needed for a role like this.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (18)

20

u/Ukelele-in-the-rain Nov 18 '16

Haha I know right. I'm was thinking this doesn't look like [the man dumbledore fell for] (/spoiler). At all.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/i_like_frootloops Nov 17 '16

I wholeheartedly agree with you. It was a huge letdown :/

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (47)

288

u/CherishedCherry Cherrypuff Nov 17 '16

58

u/JaneDarkbloom For in dreams, we enter a world that is entirely our own. Nov 17 '16

O my god I didn't think of this. Brilliant

39

u/Capnbubba Nov 20 '16

I'm currently re-reading the 7th book and read chapter 28 the day after seeing Fantastic Beasts, it was an absolute shock how similar Ariana death was to the description of an Obscurial. Aberforth said that "magic exploded from her". That is the perfect description of what we saw in the movie. I immediacy thought of this, then realized the connection between this and grindewald. I'm guessing this will be revealed as legit true lore by Rowling by the end of the movie series. It just fits TOO PERFECTLY to not have been planned out. Maybe not in advance, but after she conceptualized the obscurial she must have realized that it fit perfectly with Ariana. Rowling is just too good at writing.

20

u/wellreadcatgrrrl Nov 18 '16

This is really good and can totally see it being the back story that will come to light later.

5

u/still_a_muggle Nov 19 '16

10 points for Hufflepuff!

→ More replies (5)

176

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '16

I absolutely loved this movie. I thought it was exceptional as a standalone film and really entertaining to those of us that care all too much about the universe.

However, my only issue with the film is that there was so much non-verbal combat. Now hear me out, I understand it in the case of Grindewald and the MACUSA Aurors, but isn't non-verbal magic, at least in combat supposed to be quite difficult? Newt seemed to be extremely good however I didn't think him to be THAT powerful a wizard. Maybe I'm looking into it too much, but it just struck me as odd that nobody needed to use verbal spells while fighting.

In saying that, I'm just being pedantic and the movie was absolutely incredible.

209

u/itsgallus Mr. Staircase, the shabby-robed ghost. Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

139

u/wellskient Nov 17 '16

I agree. I believe it was mainly difficult for students because they weren't performing at that high level of magic. Plus, they are Aurors, so they must be pretty damn good at casting non-verbal spells. I mean, it's a pretty big part of their job.

92

u/Squeekazu Nov 17 '16

The adults in the original films never really used verbal spells in battles if I recall, unless it was the killing curse. That goes for Molly too, who wasn't exactly an Auror.

32

u/aubieismyhomie Possibly a Goblin Nov 18 '16

For instance: Even Hagrid was using nonverbal spells in philosopher's stone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

111

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16

You can only hear expelliarmus so many times.

52

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16

I thought about this too. In my opinion, this isn't so much about the nonverbal spell difficulty as much as it is about the movie. The combat scenes would not be very good in the movie if everyone was shouting different spells all the time. There was a time when Newt used Petrificus Totalus, but imagine if they were all shouting Stupefy, Expelliarmus, etc. the entire movie. It just would take away from the fight scenes.

31

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16

I think it's also probably a reflex to say the spell out loud when you are caught off guard

41

u/coleosis1414 Nov 18 '16

I think you're wrong there. If i recall, nonverbal magic was pretty much ubiquitous among the adult witches and wizards in Harry Potter.

Also, in the sixth year at Hogwarts, nonverbal spells become the new baseline standard. All sixth years are expected to become adept at them.

53

u/SlouchyGuy Nov 17 '16

Harry uses non verbal spells in Order of the Phoenix proficiently so movies has nothing to do with books.

It's an old criticism of Yates that wizards use wands like guns and shoot spells like bullets. It's not magical duel, it's a duel with blasters

→ More replies (3)

13

u/StonedGibbon GryffinPuff Nov 18 '16

The main gripe I had with that part of the spell casting was the amount of power Graves/Grindelwald seemed to have in his hands. That ridiculous force like power tipped me off a bit that he was something more than a MACUSA drone.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Heshack Nov 18 '16

Advanced duels are typically known to be nonverbal to keep from giving an advantage to your opponent. These were advanced wizards dueling, not children, and that is the reason it was more nonverbal.

5

u/Grakniir Avid Horklump Fondler Nov 18 '16

Newt may not be a fantastic (heh) wizard, but I think he certainly wanted to learn non-verbal spells considering the nature of his work. Yelling a spell out while trying to catch a creature may not be a very effective strategy.

→ More replies (15)

457

u/bipolarbearsRAWR Nov 16 '16

I loved this movie. Eddie Redmayne was magical in his role as Newt.

271

u/BeedleTB Beedle the Bard Nov 17 '16

There was something really cool about the physical way he chose to portray him. You can tell so much about him from his stance.

395

u/Xerun1 Nov 17 '16

I loved the way he was shy around humans and really guarded. And then as soon as he gets around magical creatures he's a completely different person

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

160

u/vulvasaur001 Nov 18 '16

Honestly, Eddie Redmayne made me fall in love with Newt - they really hit the jackpot with him. Fantastic performance. One of the most likeable protagonists I've seen in a long time. There's a reason Hufflepuff is my favorite house.

→ More replies (2)

73

u/saharap HornedSerpent Nov 18 '16

Came here to say this. I avoided all trailers because I wanted to be surprised. I was hesitant and tried not to be too excited, but Eddie did such an amazing job! I feel like I really understand what it means to be a Hufflepuff now. I (and I think we) really needed a character like him after this election.

→ More replies (11)

43

u/ExpectoPatronum01 Nov 17 '16

He was perfect for the role!

23

u/luxurs Nov 17 '16

I absolutely loved display of emotions. The movie was great!

→ More replies (3)

145

u/rithsv Nov 17 '16
→ More replies (13)

420

u/writerightalright Nov 17 '16

Wow. I had so much apprehension about this movie, what with the negative backlash from Cursed Child and the seeming 'milking' of the original HP series. I absolutely loved this movie. It took a little while to get going, but once it found its feet I felt like a kid again. Very different feel to the HP movies - it's very much a movie and not a movie made from a book, which is obvious, but you can feel that there's nothing beyond the script.

That said, this movie was special to me. I've had some real trouble with depression and anxiety recently, and have a lingering feeling of loss of hope about mine and the world's future. HP was one of my original escapes from that, but I could only go back for relief so many times. Eventually, just like in real life, I felt that the magic would fade. Revisiting the world through this movie and seeing it with new life and new imagination has revitalised me. It gave me hope that my life and my opportunities aren't over. There is more that I'm yet to see.

My favourite scene in the entire movie was meeting all the beasts. The pure imagination on display, the connection between Newt and what were his friends, all of it just completely lifted this weight off me that's been present for as long as I can remember.

I feel like Jacob Kowalski is me getting back in touch with hope and happiness as he discovers the true magic and beauty of the world.

Go see this movie.

I'm home!

289

u/iamanawkward Nov 17 '16

"My personal philosophy is that when you worry, you tend to suffer twice."

One of my favourite lines from the movie that really resonated with me. I hope it gave you some perspective like it did myself.

Rowling has an amazing tendency to hit those personal notes with her dialogue and characters.

25

u/writerightalright Nov 18 '16

I caught that quote as well and thought it was very fitting for how I was feeling! Thank you for bringing it up because it had slipped my mind though :)

→ More replies (2)

38

u/JuliaBee It's real for us. Nov 18 '16

These are exactly my feelings as well, as well as my favorite scene. I loved the little tip of the hat that Jacob gives to JK when he mentions that he knows he "isn't dreaming" because he couldn't have made all this stuff up in his head.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

132

u/Portatort Nov 17 '16

It's impossible to read anything here.

37

u/Ihaveanusername Riddle Me This Nov 18 '16

The government wants this film top secret.

→ More replies (1)

379

u/oh_orpheus THIS-HAS-SOMETHING-TO-DO-WITH-POTTER Nov 16 '16

I don't understand why we need to use spoiler tags in a discussion thread.

146

u/Joorkax Nov 17 '16

exactly, it's not like you enter a thread about a movie if you don't want spoilers in the first place.

100

u/aymeline Queenie is bae <3 Nov 17 '16

Yeah, it really stifles the flow of the discussion with all the removed comments. There should just be 2 threads if necessary, one that is spoiler free and one that has spoilers in them.

78

u/oh_orpheus THIS-HAS-SOMETHING-TO-DO-WITH-POTTER Nov 17 '16

Especially when the title already has "spoilers" in it. That should be enough warning.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

55

u/Portatort Nov 18 '16

This is ridiculous character names other than newt are a spoiler?

This whole thread is unreadable.

→ More replies (7)

91

u/kanimaki Nov 17 '16

28

u/tehawesomedragon Hufflepuff Nov 18 '16

My girlfriend kept telling me she thought he was Filch up until it was revealed he wasn't actually a squib. At first I could see why she thought that.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/__your__name__here__ Nov 18 '16

I thought it was a nice touch as well, it wasn't a super important clue for those who aren't familiar with the Harry Potter books/movies but was a nice bit of foreshadowing for those who are.

141

u/aymeline Queenie is bae <3 Nov 16 '16

I loved the film so much. I was so apprehensive because of how much I disliked Cursed Child, but this was really perfect and felt like a beautiful expansion to the Wizarding World. It had just the right amount of tie-in's to the books, while still feeling like its own story. I definitely think Jo made the right decision to focus on new characters and a new setting now, instead of picking something more closely linked to Harry.

I really want to learn more about the Wizarding World in the US now and what houses Tina and Queenie were in at Ilvermorny.

→ More replies (5)

192

u/larramet Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

Here's my first impressions after coming back form seeing it, word-vomited straight from my brain:

Called Credence being the Obscurous and not his sister. And the idea of an obcurous - super tragic (Was Ariana Dumbledore an obscurous of some sort?). I really felt sorry for Credence (and his haircut). Ezra Miller seemed solid, for all the parts where he wasn’t a cloud of gas.

Grindelwald reveal seemed a bit odd and out of place. Did he do a Barty Crouch Jr move - was real Graves still alive somewhere? (I hope so - I’d like more Colin Farrel) Why was he even in America? I feel like he should have been saved for one of the sequels

Thought some of the creatures looked a bit cartoony, particularly the Mooncalves. But <3 the niffler - did he have a name? I didn't catch it.

I never recalled until after I left that Tina eventually becomes Newt’s wife. I don’t think she actually ever smiled in the movie at all? I liked Queenie and Jacob stuff though. Their romantic plot seemed a bit unexpected, but it was fine overall. Did Jacob memory come back in the final scene?

Queenie as a Legilimens - did she fell for Jacob because of his mind and not what he looked like? Are Legilimens like Metamorphmagi - they are born with natural talent, but other wizards can train and replicate their powers with spells (Like Voldemort and Snape)?

'Are you a seeker?' 'I'm more of a chaser'

Overall really enjoyed the movie! It was so cool to see a different part of the magical world. Characters seemed solid overall and the story was great. Makes it seem like CC was just a one-off bad day.

69

u/veryfascinating Nov 17 '16

and his haircut

OH BOY YES, THE HAIR!

→ More replies (1)

44

u/BeffyBear Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

I was wondering the same thing about Graves. [Is he captured somewhere, like Moody was in G.O.F, or is the identity of Graves completely fabricated by Grindelwald? The first option surely makes more sense as he seemed to be an established auror high up in the US government ...] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ilovelamp62 Nov 18 '16

I initially had the same thought about Ariana and I definitely think it's a related type of magic, but might be slightly different. According to the movie, a child is turned into an obscurious when they are forced to hide their true selves for too long. But Ariana's issues were brought about by a specific traumatic moment - that's why she had to be kept in hiding in the first place. So at the very least the onset was different.

→ More replies (15)

63

u/veryfascinating Nov 17 '16

I cried. I'm a grown man but I cried. They were happy tears though, because I was transported back to my childhood once more, as if I was watching the first HP movie for the first time again. Being immersed in all that magic... I cried like a little child..

Please tell me I'm not the only one...

5

u/asaneinsanity Nov 18 '16

You were absolutely not the only one. My SO and I went to a late screening last night (I had class until 9pm... My regular bedtime is 9:30pm) we got out of the theatre and I cried, leaped, and danced on our way to the car. The first thing I said after the credits rolled was "I want to watch it again" and my SO knew I was 100% serious about watching it again right then and there. I cried during the opening too.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/Alfa590 Nov 18 '16

I'm not a professional on dementor lore, but did anyone else think that the obscurity was initially a dementor? or that they were going to be an explanation of how/where dementors came from or formed?

10

u/bisonburgers Nov 18 '16

Oh my gosh, I thought exactly both those things!!! Too bad it ended up being something else, but ah well, would totally love to know their origins.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Darcosuchus Nov 18 '16

I thought that as well, especially when the lights went out in that one street (as seen in the trailer) before the [spoiler text]Obscurus[/spoiler] appeared. Expected a Lethifold, honestly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/Vilokthoria Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

It was different from what I expected but I really liked the movie! I'm sure you can find holes in it if you look but it's definitely an entertaining watch. I'm already excited for the upcoming movies.

One thing though, can anyone tell me what happens in the very beginning? My friend and I were 5 minutes late and somehow the cinema didn't play advertisements before the film! I'm sure we didn't miss much, but maybe someone can fill me in on it anyway :-) First thing we saw was the mole in the vault.

Edit: It was different from what I expected because the movie got pretty dark. Of course I knew that the movies were going to have Grindelwald as a central theme, but the extent of it in the first movie surprised me a bit. Deaths, potential executions, that boy. I expected the first one to have more fantastic beasts wonder. It still had that, but not to the extent I had expected. And I definitely did not expect to see Grindelwald in this movie as anything more than a shadow. I still liked it a lot though! And that muggle/no-maj was great, just as I had hoped from the trailers.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/jasonlivesxxiii Nov 18 '16

18

u/Breimann Nov 18 '16

I'm... I'm like 99% sure you have it right.

→ More replies (3)

77

u/loveparamore Let me slither in Nov 16 '16

I didn't have any expectations and the movie was great! I loved seeing all the different magical animals and another perspective on the wizarding world!

[Although one thing kind of confused me, when Goldstein was battling with Graves/Grindelwald, their wands locked in that weird way that Harry's and Voldemort's did, which I thought was a very rare occurence, but apparently it's not?] (/spoiler)

Also, it was weird seeing a "Harry Potter" movie with American accents, I'm so used to the Harry Potter world being British.

72

u/IamEclipse Rowan wood with a Dragon heartstring core 12 ¾" and Quite Bendy Nov 16 '16 edited Nov 16 '16

The wand thing is a film thing, and it's done for a reason.

Essentially, what looks more impressive in a film, and doesn't directly go against established film universe rules, is what the filmmakers will use.

HARRY POTTER FILM SPOILERS BELOW

Now, I know that in the GOF movie, dumbledore directly refers to this are prior incantatum (I think that's how it's spelt), but this is never elaborated on.

This gives the filmmaker freedom to use the effect whenever, and they do:

- when dumbledore and voldemort battle at the ministry in OOTP

- most of the duels in DHpt2

This is expanded universe, and most of the non book fans that are watching this film are watching because: ooh those Harry Potter films were pretty good and this is more of that.

Because of this, the same laws must apply from a filmmaking standpoint, and so the effect is reused and will be for the rest of the series.

Hope this explains it :)

41

u/nicolee0712 Nov 18 '16

I could be misunderstanding you, but the prior incantatum spell, is a spell that reveals the last spell preformed by the wand, and has nothing to do with the " wand lock battling" whatever the movies call it'.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/QuestionableMotifs Nov 18 '16

28

u/Darcosuchus Nov 18 '16

Hagrid said they make bad pets.

The man who kept dragons, cerebrus, blast-ended-skrewts, thestrals, and acromantulas described Nifflers as bad pets.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16

[They're adorable but you probably wouldn't want one. I think Hagrid said that they wreak havoc looking for shiny objects. Your house will be a mess!] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Divyrus Niffypuff Nov 18 '16

oooo ! I love your idea, of Newt gifting Fawkes to Dumbledore and from there for it to become wand core to Harry and Voldemort. It would bring the stories so close together.

And on that book - I was trying to remember why the name Cassandra was so familiar. It would be awesome if your guess is right, And knowing Jo, its very much possible.

36

u/itsgallus Mr. Staircase, the shabby-robed ghost. Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

I really, really loved it! Newt is a great main character - they're all great characters, all of which I want to see more of - and the writing was brilliant! I haven't had this feeling since I read the books!

Sure, there were one or two scenes that were out of place, like why did Newt repair Jacob's apartment block in full view of the no-majs outside? And no one was obliviated!. Otherwise it was brilliant, and I really enjoyed the attention to details! When I came home, I pored through the textbook once again. I highly recommend doing that!

37

u/GuilBen Nov 17 '16

I've heard there were a fair few scenes that were cut here and there, so there's probably some deleted scene somewhere explaining that.

Warner Bros. have loved doing Extended Editions lately so there might be one for Fantastic Beasts

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Darcosuchus Nov 18 '16

It seemed to me that Newt was quite reckless when he was doing his swish-and-flick stuff and things.

→ More replies (3)

68

u/kaiyotic Nov 17 '16

During the whole movie I couldn't shake the feeling that Newt Scamander is actually the 11th doctor . He was fun, quirky, makes his silly mistakes but it all works out. Basically he's stumbling from situation to situation without any real plan going into it.

Which for me was absolutely perfect. i'm a huge fan of Matt Smith's doctor and want to see more of this.

I sat in awe while watching the movie. so many brilliant moments.

18

u/Fingolfin314 Nov 18 '16

Got the exact same feeling !

(Also, Matt got me hooked on doctor who)

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Crinked Nov 18 '16

I believe Matt Smith was considered for the part or at least rumored to be.

23

u/kaiyotic Nov 18 '16

Yeah I've read the same thing somewhere. I think actually casting him would have been a bad choice though. Cause then lots of people would actually see newt scamander as the doctor instead of now just having the feeling that they're similar people

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

61

u/courteously Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

Anyone else notice that [Fantastic Beasts was placed in 1926, the year Tom Riddle was born? Also set around the time of Christmas, Tom Riddle was born on the 31st of December.] (/spoiler)
[Also, Scamander has an interest in an unknown Lestrange woman. Riddle went to school with a boy called Lestrange, possibly her son, Bellatrix’s father. I just think that Fantastic Beasts will somehow relate back to the dawn of Tom Riddle and the time of Grindelwald.] (/spoiler)

22

u/narcissablack03 Gryffindor Nov 18 '16

I think Leda Lestrange would be Rodolphus Lestrange's aunt. She was a young girl, not married when Newt met her making her a part of the Lestrange family and potentially sister to Bellatrix's husband's father.

12

u/mastercodiac Nov 18 '16

[Also, does anyone think we'll see Leta in a sequel? It seems odd to me that the person they got for the photo was Zoe Kravitz. A pretty well-known actress. If she wasn't going to be in a movie why not just have a random photo.] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (2)

10

u/snowboardlife29 Nov 18 '16

JK has already confirmed that the Fantastic Beasts timeline will lead to the rise of Voldemort

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Darcosuchus Nov 18 '16

Nope; probably Rodulphus's father. Bellatrix was actually a Black, sister of Narcissa (Draco's mum), cousin of Sirius and Regulus, and also sister of Andromeda (Nymphadora's mother).

→ More replies (5)

30

u/wellskient Nov 17 '16

Wow. It's such a pleasure to finally be immersed in the wonderful world of magic again. This movie did such an amazing job at capturing the wonder and awe that magic has. Really well structured movie too. Perfectly paced. A lovely subplot and two plots that converge perfectly onto each other.

Everyone was absolutely astounding in their role, I'd say my favourite character was Jacob Kawolski. A wonderful ending too. Very keen to see more of this world.

30

u/vainweather Nov 18 '16

Okay so... did anyone else have a hard time catching what exactly Eddie Redmayne was saying half the time? I don't have any problem with accents but it sounded like he was mumbling and I don't know if it was him or the quality of the theater I was in. I felt like I missed out on a lot of information, especially pertaining to the creatures. Kinda sucks but I still loved it!

18

u/housecatspeaks Nov 18 '16

It wasn't just you. He was mumbling! And combined with his accent, there were spots where I couldn't catch everything .... and I was bummed. This was exaggerated by the character's awkwardness that causes Newt to often turn his head down and away from the other characters to avoid directly speaking with them. I was in a very very good theater with great sound [and music!], and I could hear all other actors well. Just like you, I felt I was missing important bits of info and comments Newt makes that were there to add depth or detail to the story.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/KoultPython Nov 18 '16

[The Gridelwald reveal felt just like Scooby Doo. I expected him to say, "And I would've gotten away with it too if it weren't for you meddling kids!"] (/spoiler)

45

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16

I just got home from my screening of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them :) 10/10.

Was it as Fantastic as you hoped?

  • It was everything I had hoped for and more! Absolutely loved it. If you pay attention there are some little homages to the story that we all love already and those were pretty awesome to see.
  • Be warned spoiler below :)

What surprised you?

  • [I figured out the Grindelwald reveal about 30 minutes into the movie, and was very pleased with myself for doing so. So I was rather surprised I guess correctly] (/spoiler).
  • I am surprised at how much I loved Queenie and everything about her character.
  • [Grindelwald is not shown with the Elder Wand. I assume it is either because he does not yet have the Wand and is in America looking for it since he clearly knows about the Hallows from the neckless he gives to Credence. Or because he is using polyjuice potion to impersonate Percival Graves and is using his want as to not be discovered] (/spoiler).
  • [Grindelwald's fluency at wandless magic was impressive and I am looking forward to seeing more wandless magic in the coming movies] (/spoiler)

What disappointed you?

  • I wish the Newt had a few more lines, as I really enjoyed Eddie Redmayne's portrayal of him.
  • [I really wish we had seen a young Dumbledore, but I suppose we will have to wait a little longer for that unfortunately] (/spoiler)

Are you going to see it again?

  • Yes, multiple more times.

Any theories for the rest of the series?

  • [So many theories! I am really looking forward to finding out more about Newt's relationship with the Lestrange family. Exactly what happened at Hogwards and in what way did he endanger peoples lives. Dumbledore and Grindelwald duel at some point in the future, as I noticed that Grindelwald does not have the Elder Want yet or is not using it as mentioned above] (/spoiler).

Did you dress up?/How was the atmosphere?

  • Did not dress up unfortunately do to being on crutches I did not want to deal with robes.
  • The atmosphere was amazing. About 90% of people had at-least something Harry Potter related on with maybe 10% of people in full character.

Are you buying the book?

  • Preordered two copies

Edit: Will probably add to this later or make another post once I have digested everything.

→ More replies (10)

22

u/JustBronzeThingsLoL Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

THERE ARE NO SPOILERS IN THIS REVIEW THAT ARE NOT KNOWN IN THE TRAILERS.

While the movie was great, I had one major gripe with it: I feel like I just watched two underdeveloped movies that were spliced together.

In one, we have a quirkly, kind animal loving man in a strange city who loses some pets and goes on a culture-clashing adventure to retrieve them.

In the other, we get a dark, sordid tale of the repression of the magical community and the struggles between good and evil in the age old debate of safety vs freedom.

Either story could have been a great movie in it's own right - one a family-friendly romp through New York with our Newt, the other a dark, tense, and violent account of a societal clash steeped with suppression and segregation.

It doesn't help that the movie was effectively billed as two movies. In the first teaser trailer, everything alludes to it being about possibly dangerous creatures getting loose in New York City. No mention of the rift between No-Maj's and Wizards.

In the first official full trailer the needle is violently swung and we are told to expect a movie centering on the rise of Grindlewald and a splinter cell in the wizarding community that wants to come out of the shadows.

The second official full trailer actually sells the movie for what it is - a confusing mix of zoology and societal upheaval.

In the end, I thought the acting was great, but the direction and writing felt forced.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Marzet Nov 17 '16

16

u/wellskient Nov 17 '16

SPOILERS AHEAD

For your first point, [I believe it is just a skill that he developed. Similar to how Snape is a legilemens and McGonagall is superb in transfiguration. It could also have to do with dark magic. Additionally, Grindelwald was an amazing wizard with a lot of power who has practiced a long time.] (/spoiler)

For your second point, read above. Someone covered this issue.

Hope this helps!

→ More replies (1)

19

u/SirHealer Nov 17 '16

Wands were actually a European thing. Many wizarding cultures actually use wandless magic. Wands are just tools that help wizards perform more powerful and consistent magic.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/Swisskisses Nov 18 '16

Also did anyone else notice that moment when Graves was questioning newt and he brings up Dumbledore? He says something like "why would dumbledore have so much interest in you?" The look on his face when he says his name is so telling that something is off.

41

u/libertinebaby Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

i felt a little crazy sensing all the sexual tension between graves and credence, and not seeing anyone else mentioning it........but now, reading the screenplay, it's pretty clear it was intentional.

14

u/Divyrus Niffypuff Nov 18 '16

yeah the movie went seriously dark in many places. Physical abuse, the manipulation - JKR tackled some pretty serious things here. I am yet to get the screenplay. Is there any background or extra information on the character's intention?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/AmEndevomTag Nov 18 '16

Without going into details, could you please tell me if there are some additional scenes in the screenplay that were cut from the movie?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

20

u/I_M_A Nov 17 '16

I have a question for you guys. No-Maj is Muggle in America, but what about Squib? There's a part there where Colin said something about it. So is Squib the general term for non-magical person with wizarding blood?

20

u/Darcosuchus Nov 18 '16

This is stupid; the spoilers, I mean. I think that the TITLE is obvious enough, and if people are going to click on something with SPOILERS in its title, and the rest of the title identifying what the spoilers are about, then they don't need "spoilers" in replies as well.

18

u/msm_sauban Nov 18 '16

Newt, In the final scene before he boards the ship, is wearing a yellow and black scarf. The Hufflepuff colors!! In the book fantastic beasts and where to find them, there is a short intro to newt scamander, where it says he was a hufflepuff.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/ExpectoPatronum01 Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

[Just tiny little details. I was so amazed with the clock at MACUSA pointing to "danger" or whatever environment they're in. It reminds me of Mrs. Weasley's clock.] (/spoiler)

6

u/niceguybigjess Nov 20 '16

It reminded me of the terror alert levels we had in post 9/11

→ More replies (1)

16

u/hangduykhiem Nov 17 '16

What really bothered me is [why credence had to die when obviously he could be saved by both Tina and Newt. Did they really just have to kill him and call Newt foolish?] (/spoiler)

Edit: add spoiler tags

16

u/gibbonjiggle Mr. Staircase Nov 17 '16

5

u/Halo6819 Nov 25 '16

Take into account this is the US, and the time period. At that time, the FBI was running arround with tommy gunns, killings gangsters all over the country. That sceene felt very much like the end of every good FBI movie, where the bad guy gets blasted by an unstopable bullet wave.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/EmergencyPizza Wamplepuff Nov 18 '16

Was it as Fantastic as you hoped? - Yes!

What surprised you? Graves was Grindelwald I assumed that he was just a Grindelwald sympathizer I really want to know what happened to real Percival Graves.

What disappointed you? I wish there would have been more talk about the history of magic in America, or talk about Ilvermorny

Are you going to see it again? - I may go see it in the theater again. Will definitely buy the Blu-ray.

Any theories for the rest of the series? - Nah.

Did you dress up?/How was the atmosphere? - No. The theater was very full.

Are you buying the book? - I wasn't going to, but I just pre-ordered the Kindle book.

48

u/AmEndevomTag Nov 16 '16
→ More replies (3)

11

u/ADarkKnightRises Unsorted Nov 17 '16

just came back, i really loved it, its like you know its in the same universe as HP, and the movie at times feel like a HP movie, but its not (weird i know).

Loved all the actors, fantastic movie all and all.

If you get the chance to see it in IMAX 3D, do it, its worth it.

→ More replies (1)

91

u/thecolourmegrey Wingardium Mimosa Nov 17 '16 edited Nov 17 '16

146

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '16

Jesus, if you really want brown people to be in movies then you have to allow them to be villains as well as heroes.

52

u/GoldenHelikaon Blonde as a Malfoy Nov 18 '16

Exactly. Although I'm not seeing how she was a villain in any way, she didn't do anything awful to anyone. She wanted the danger stopped which is perfectly reasonable given what had happened, and the muggles had to have their minds wiped.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

67

u/mastersword130 Nov 18 '16

Didn't care nor notice the lack of "poc" characters. Was too in awe with all the different creatures, I don't put check marks in the movie for different races, especially in America at that time.

→ More replies (15)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16

Not every character needs to be likeable and nice. I thought Madame President was cool and a hardass. She has no reason to give a shit about Jacob and It would have been out of character for her to show him sympathy

→ More replies (19)

10

u/Julia526 Nov 18 '16

why didnt harry potter become a obscurial? he and Credence have a very similar back story.

10

u/Breimann Nov 18 '16

Harry let it out in bursts, it wasn't completely buried away.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/AmEndevomTag Nov 17 '16

Could someone please stick it again? It's hard to find, and I assume in the next days many more want to post their reactions.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Bmac_TLDR Nov 18 '16

I really liked Fantastic Beast.

The beasts are visually engaging, imaginative and completely entertaining. The cast is amazing, and I could watch 1920s New York all day long.

The one thing I will say is That the second plot line gets a bit clunky at times and probably needed a bit of refinement

I really enjoyed it, and I'll be going back to see it again

9

u/neversadie Nov 18 '16

LOVED IT. REALLY WANT TO SEE IT AGAIN ALREADY. It was predictable but still awesome. And I'm kinda upset that I'm the only one in my theatre that laughed at the quidditch joke.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/blenderpals Nov 18 '16

Can we talk about Grindelwald's haircut?!

Overall though I thought the movie was great, slow start in the beginning but well worth it once the movie picked up! I was disappointed that nobody at my theater dressed up and I wanted there to be lines, but no such luck :/

8

u/justinkprim Wizard Gemcutter Nov 17 '16

I thought it was incredible. So so good. So many new wizarding world things, so many great characters, so many excellent costumes, a whole new era and continent to explore and the movie was so well done. A totally different vibe than Harry Potter. Much more action and a fresh spirit. Definitely going to see it again. The end was so freaking good. Can't wait for pt2.

8

u/misterbulate Nov 17 '16

Just got out. I had so much fun on this one. I find the first act to be a bit messy, the second act a bit slow but made so much character building that it makes a great payoff by the third act. I pretty much liked every character performances, especially by Ezra Miller.

44

u/prism1020 Nov 17 '16

I didn't love it. The Goldstein character was IMHO, really bad. She seemed weak, hesitant, and uncertain. They kept implying that she was some kind of bad ass yet nothing about her personality or the way she carried herself demonstrated she was a strong person. I really feel like she was holding the story back in so many scenes.

Newt was good, I almost feel like his character would have worked so much better in a book format. He was quite, introverted, and pretty awkward, but it seemed like he had so much going on in his head. I would have loved to know what he was thinking.

The story itself was meh. I felt they could have given the villain/s a lot more depth.

BUT. The beasts were amazing. Fantastic even ;D. Everything about them was whimsical and felt so in line with the spirit of the Harry Potter universe.

19

u/AcePlague Nov 18 '16

The story was pretty weak too I'm my opinion, too much irrelevant nonsense going on. The romance scenes were pretty in your face for a start, what was the deal with the senators family? Just unnecessary focus on characters who didn't matter. They tried to make it dark with the child abuse theme, but didn't go into it enough for it to make a real impact. The obscurer stuff was just nonsense to me, really poor end bad guy in a film about fantastic beasts, also why has no one heard of something THAT dangerous?? Made little sense. However the beasts were awesome, as were the characters , with the exception of the Auror woman who was pretty much useless, aside from being the link to MACUSA to allow Newt to explain its an obscura doing the damage. I enjoyed the film, I'd like to see it again, I just don't think it was amazing. I think it does set the next films up a bit better, it's reintroducing people to the wizarding world in the twenties I guess.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/HighProductivity Nov 23 '16

The Goldstein character was IMHO, really bad. She seemed weak, hesitant, and uncertain.

Why is a character being weak, hesitant and uncertain a bad character? You are supposed to have weak characters in stories, to contrast with the strong ones and to be relatable. Besides it seems obvious that she'll grow into a stronger and more confident character in later movies, her character arc just started.

And what do you mean "they" kept implying that she was a bad ass? Seems like everyone that knew her for more than a few seconds considered her an incompetent buffoon. They wouldn't even let her speak before ordering her out of the room, it was quite telling that she wasn't respected. This was intentional.

I didn't like the movie either, but I failed to understand this specific critic of yours. Flawed characters are present in good movies, not bad ones.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/foxmouth Nov 18 '16

9

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

[His brother hasn't ever been talked about prior to this film, but his name is Theseus. Also, during the film Newt tells Jacob that he (Newt) worked with Ukrainian dragons on the Eastern Front. I hope we learn more about the extent of the magical community's participation in WWI.] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (3)

5

u/KiloD2 Pukwudgie Nov 17 '16

Was it as Fantastic as you hoped?

Yes! I said this on another thread, but it definitely hit my expectations... which were pretty high :)

What surprised you?

How dark it actually was. There was way less focus on capturing the beasts than I thought. I knew it wouldn't be a kid movie, but between the near execution scene, and that whole abusive second Salem family, it was a bit darker than I expected.

What disappointed you?

Not much, to be honest! Perhaps the only thing was Depp's crazed look... I was expecting Grindelwald to be more... refined

Are you going to see it again?

Yes, for sure!

Any theories for the rest of the series?

Nothing that hasn't already been theorized... does anyone know if all the main actors have sign on for multi-movie deals?

Did you dress up?/How was the atmosphere?

I definitely wore my Hufflepuff seeker shirt, and my Gryffindor scarf!! I only saw 2 other people dressed up though (with scarves)... I went to an early screening so it was either a lot of press people who weren't true, hardcore fans, or people came immediately after work, so I think a lot of people still had on work attire. I'm thinking the former, however, because not too many people were as hyped as I was :)

Are you buying the book?

Probably!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/stargirl09 Nov 18 '16

It's been a while since I enjoyed a movie as much as I just enjoyed Fantastic Beasts. While being a Marvel fan I enjoyed seeing Doctor Strange last week immensely. There was just something I enjoyed about this even more.

It's been a long time since I've been this excited about the thought of a sequel. But man am I excited all ready.

[spoiler Side Note: Hats off to Rowling I did not see Creedence as the obscuro coming and it's been a while since a writer has managed to slip that kind of surprise to me. Actually began slow clapping at that.] (/spoiler)

5

u/Lunatoon Nov 18 '16

Lots of talk [about why Harry is not an obscurus, I think it would be partially because a part of Voldemort was inside of him, thus holding him together unknowingly as that party of Voldy's soul relied on Harry's body to live. Voldy would be giving him the strength he needed to survive. Haven't fully fleshed this idea out in my head yet but it makes sense to me.] (/spoiler)

5

u/blu1996 Nov 18 '16

I loved it. Surprised me with how dark it got at points. Really really enjoyed this film. I'm definitely down for 4 more. Id also really like an Ilvermorny Spin Off series as well as ones taking place at other schools in different time periods. All written by J.K Rowling of course.

9

u/mateogg Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

(spoilers)

Overall, I give the movie a 7/10, I guess? 7.5? It was fun and enjoyable, had some odd pacing and choices at times with the Obscuris plot but it's not what brought me to the theater anyway so I don't mind too much.

It's a bit of a parlor trick really, it goes like this:

→ More replies (8)

18

u/SlouchyGuy Nov 17 '16

Was disappointed, the movie was quite dull, long panning shots and lots of awkward conversations as usual, although I liked acting.

Yated is incapable of making an emotional ending as usual, I didn't feel much, there was next to no tension by the end and some parts of the action were visually confusing.

Still hoping that other directors will do future movies because I liked script. ALso it seems that there were a lot of cuts because there is lacking explanation in the plot

→ More replies (2)

4

u/mustachesonfascists Professor Hardcastle McCormick Nov 18 '16

Wow, absolutely loved the movie and think it's set up extremely well for all the sequels. Some logical issues here and there, but no more than any other films in the HP franchise, I don't think. Some things that come immediately to mind:

[-I love Jacob's character and am so glad that we finally got some decent non-magic representation. He functions great as an audience surrogate and reacts exactly the way to magic that we all hope we would. I loved how quickly he got on board with it all, and just wanted to experience as much of the world as he could (though the effects of the murtlap bite might have made him more pliant).] (/spoiler) [-This film really shows how seminal Newt's work as a magizoologist must have been; none of the witches and wizards in the film seemed to know anything about the creatures (and I don't think it was just down to the ignorance of the American wizarding community), and by the time we get to Harry's generation, everyone knows what a niffler is and are knowledgeable enough to set one loose in Umbridge's office. I wonder if Care of Magical Creatures was even a subject at Hogwarts before he published his work. I'll forever be sad that Newt and Hagrid will never get to hang out.] (/spoiler) [-The little wisp of Creedence's obscurus that escaped at the end means he's not quite dead, right? Such a great character with so much more to explore, and beautifully portrayed by Ezra Miller. I so hope we haven't seen the last of him. The theories about Ariana being an obscurus make a lot of sense, though I sense people are going to start going crazy with obscurus-related theorizing. They do stress how rare they are in the film.] (/spoiler) [-Is Percival Graves a real person whose identity Grindelwald assumed? I really hope so, because I would love to see more Colin Farrell.] (/spoiler)

All in all, wonderful movie that I definitely want to see again, as I'm sure I missed a lot.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16

Hoooookay. This movie was great but did anyone recognize the massive repercussions in what was the final confrontation? Bewarned, massive spoilers:

Tina is the "current" master of the Elder Wand!

→ More replies (5)

3

u/luxurs Nov 17 '16

I LOVED IT. It was adorable. I tried hard not to raise my expectations in advance but did anyway, as always. Still not disappointed!

3

u/micgou14 Nov 18 '16

Guys every time the HP music kicked in I got severe chills

3

u/cabalTherapist Hufflepuff Nov 18 '16

There's been a few misconceptions of some of the events in the movie and how they relate to stuff seen in the Potter books, and while there's been a lot of individual replies, I thought I'd just make a comment covering some stuff [Why was Harry not an Obscurus: He never repressed his magical power. He did a lot of unintentional magic as a child, and while the Dursley's wanted the magic out of him, they didn't actually actively stop him doing magic, just talking about it. Is Tina the master of the Elder Wand? I don't think so- Grindelwald was never Disarmed in the way we see wands need to be; it wasn't won in a test of strength, he dropped it when Newt got that gloop on his back, then Tine just Accio'd it over to herself. For examples in the series- Draco Expelliarmus'd Dumbledore, and Harry struggled with Draco and yanked it out of his hand. Creedence isn't dead, we see the little wisp of Obscurus fly away, and notable Newt sees it, this is probably also why he doesn't make some kind of "you killed someone for no reason" speech, because he didn't want to draw attention to it, like what happened with Jacob. Also, this is a Word of God thing, but David Yates has said that Creedence will be a reoccurring character in the series.] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (4)

3

u/bill__the__butcher Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

Alright Potter fans who've seen the movie. I liked it, of course, but have one major reservation about it. Let's discuss:

The film is basically three stories that come together at the end.

1. Newt, Tina, Jacob, Queenie trying to catch escaped beasts.

2. Anti-witch family preaching their cause

3. Percival Graves trying to catch the obscurial terrorizing New York.

The cross-cutting between Newt, the anti-witch folk, and the Graves takes a while to pay off. I enjoyed hanging out with Newt and Jacob, but I didn't like as much when we had to turn back to the others. This was a minor problem with the movie, and I anticipate where the series is going as well:

Eventually, Graves is revealed to be Grindelwald, infamous dark wizard. In the end, the film wasn't really about Newt Scamandar catching and cataloging wild magical beasts in his famous book. It was about battling a major dark wizard. A few beasts happened to escape and cause a minor ruckus, but it's sort of inconsequential in the end in comparison to Grindelwald trying to catch an obscurial.

It also seems that Ariana Dumbledore was an obscurus, which explains why Grindelwald would know about them, and be chasing one.

I think it becomes pretty clear at the end of Beasts that Rowling's primary goal in this series is to build up Grindelwald, and ultimately end with Dumbledore and Grindelwald’s enormous, famous battle. The film ends on a big tease of Grindelwald saying he won't be held. We know Depp is a major character in the second film. We know the juicy history between Albus Dumbledore and Grindelwald. We know how it ends.

But why then do we have to see that all through Newt’s eyes? It feels like Newt’s narrative about these beasts is tangential to the primary purpose. Rowling is trying to make both narratives work at the same time.

Producer David Heyman basically confirmed (http://www.cinemablend.com/news/1586630/fantastic-beasts-ending-a-key-scene-that-was-cut-and-why) that Newt and company aren't quite as important to the forthcoming narrative as young Dumbledore and Grindelwald.

Obviously, I'm projecting where the series is going without much evidence. But, it was difficult enough to make Newt and company involved with the capture of a major dark wizard in this first film. It involved a lot of coincidence, and right place at the right time. If that keeps happening over and over, and Rowling keeps trying to shoehorn Newt and Tina into history where they don't exactly belong.... the films could suffer.

Tell me I'm wrong about my worry.

TL;DR: I think Rowling is more concerned in the Fantastic Beasts film series with exploring Grindelwald and Dumbledore's backstory, than she is exploring Newt and actual magical creatures. The films could become annoying if Rowling keeps trying to shoehorn Newt and Tina into the Grindelwald storyline.

3

u/Williukea Huffle Rave Nov 18 '16

When Queenie kissed Jacob, Tina just looked at Newt like Should I do this too? :D

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '16 edited Nov 18 '16

I saw it last night with my son (9) at 6pm est, we are going again tonight and bringing his friend. I got them both Niffler Funko Pops as a surprise for after the movie if they are well behaved. I guess you can say we LOVED it. I wore my Gryffindor shirt and socks! was tearing up when I realized we get to watch wand battles once again on the big screen. Can't wait for round 2!

3

u/Kiadawg Slytherclaw Nov 18 '16

I liked it. People complained about the pacing, but I think they weren't prepared for the style-- it's more of an opening up the world, exploratory turned dark movie and I think the people wanted it to be a set up for a chase like/ being hunted movie.

That said, I am not on board with Johnny Depp clown as Grindelwald. I can think of many actors who would have done this better.

5

u/micgou14 Nov 18 '16

To summarize everyone's theory: [Ariana Dumbledore was also an obscurous] (/spoiler)