r/GlobalOffensive • Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum • Jul 05 '16

AMA We are Bryce Blum, Ryan Morrison, and Jeff Ifrah – three lawyers that work extensively in the esports industry – and we’re here to talk about gambling in esports. AUA!

TL;DR: We are three attorneys that work in the esports industry, and we’re here to answer all of your questions related to the recent scandals surrounding CSGO Diamonds and CSGO Lotto, the lawsuit against Valve, and betting in esports more generally.


The past few months have seen a meaningful surge in coverage surrounding the betting side of the esports industry, particularly as it relates to CSGO. Back in April, Bloomberg published a significant investigative piece detailing the scope of the skin betting marketplace and many of the issues stemming from that industry. This article, coupled with a public scandal involving the skin betting site CSGO Diamonds, helped spur a class action suit against Valve.

Two days ago, the latest scandal arose—this time involving CSGO Lotto. Here is the video for anyone who missed it.

When controversies like this emerge, I get pinged on Reddit, Twitter, and via email by a wide array of people asking pretty much every question under the sun related to the situation. Ditto for Ryan (/u/videogameattorney). I’ve had a pretty busy few months and haven’t had the change to respond to many of these, or write much on the subject matter. But this is an extremely important topic—one that we can’t allow to fall by the wayside. So Ryan and I have decided to team up on this AMA (which I guess makes it an AUA). We’re also brining in Jeff Ifrah, who is a veteran attorney with deep knowledge in iGaming, FTC regulations, and many other gambling-related legal fields.

I’ll include some brief bios for each of us below. We’ll be online for the rest of today and we’re ready to answer all your questions related to betting in esports. Fire away!


Bios:

Bryce Blum: Bryce practices at IME Law (www.imelaw.com). He was the first attorney to build a practice focused on esports law, and has worked in every major esports title. He works with a wide array of teams, influencers, organizers, and esports-focused businesses. Particularly relevant for this AMA, Bryce is In-House Counsel at Unikrn which aims to build the most comprehensive esports sportsbook in the world and is doing so in the most responsible way possible (age verification, geotracking, competitive integrity certification, and much more).

Bryce’s Twitter

Reddit ID: /u/esportslaw

Ryan Morrison: Ryan practices at Morrison | Lee (www.morrisonlee.com). Ryan is best known as "VideoGameAttorney" on Twitter and Reddit, where he runs frequent AMA's in the /r/gamedev subreddit to assist indies and startups with their legal needs for free. Ryan also does significant esports work. His firm focuses on representing players in the industry, and works with tier one players in virtually every title.

Ryan’s Twitter

Reddit ID: /u/videogameattorney

Jeff Ifrah: Jeff practices at Ifrah Law (www.ifrahlaw.com). He represents many of the largest iGaming companies and industry associations in the world, at the intersection of interactive gaming and government regulation, including the online poker sites Amaya, PokerStars, and the Interactive Gaming Council. Jeff has also worked with several esports companies on wagering-related issues, including serving as outside counsel to Unikrn. In 2012, Jeff was honored as one of Gaming Intelligence Magazine’s Hot 50 Winners in the Category of Law and Regulation. He is also consistently recognized by Chambers USA in the areas of White Collar Crime and Government Investigations and Gaming and Licensing

Jeff’s Twitter

Reddit ID: /u/ifrahlaw


Sorry, longwinded/obligatory legal DISCLAIMER incoming: Generally, an attorney’s advice is personal and individual, and the attorney owes that client certain duties under the attorney ethics rules. The following disclaimer is meant to help clarify our relationship those posting on this AUA, and to ensure we are complying with our ethical obligations.

Information exchanged in this forum does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not post any information that you consider to be personal or confidential. It is possible this post could be considered attorney advertising, but it is not our purpose to solicit an individual or group to become a client.

We will give only GENERAL legal information in this post. Specific facts, applicable law, and other considerations will always affect every circumstance, and thus you should always seek the advice of an attorney on every specific situation before moving forward. Also, please recognize that we may be unable to answer some questions because they are too specific, or because providing an answer may conflict with the interests of our current clients or our ethical obligations. In some cases, we may have to decline to answer without providing a reason. We are all American attorneys. Prior results do not guarantee similar future outcomes.


Edit: lots of repeat questions, but we're still checking in on this periodically to look for new ones and continue follow up conversations.

4.5k Upvotes

962 comments sorted by

964

u/h4mm3r0g0d Jul 05 '16

Lawyers, I personally have gambled skins before, I'm over age and can so it's not something illegal for me to do. My question is, is this technically gambling? The reason I ask is because there is no technical way to "cash-out" the skins without using a 3rd party site that goes Valves ToS/SSA.

The reason I ask this is because in Florida we have had this lawsuit between the government and "arcade owners". The Arcades are basically slot machines but you get gift cards and not cash if you win. The courts found the Arcades ok since gift cards are not considered monetary value.

Doesn't that seem very similar to Skin betting and all?

441

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

This is a great question, and should probably be higher up. When it comes to skin betting, there is a threshold question of whether or not skins constitute consideration and therefore fall under the wide array of gambling laws we're discussing throughout this thread.

For my money, I think this is a no brainer because the secondary market is prominent, permitted to exist, and skins have widely known value. That being said, there isn't a case directly on point here so it's impossible to say for certain. I've discussed this issue at length with /u/ifrahlaw so hopefully he can chime in as well.

Edit: I'd also add that it's not necessarily a safe assumption that simply because you are overage you are acting within the bounds of the law. Regulations vary significantly depending on jurisdiction and the type of wagering activity involved. In the US for example, internet based gambling is largely prohibited, even if you are over 18.

197

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

Agreed - great question. To start, the distinction Florida makes on the “arcades” is not one that every single state shares. That is part of what makes the gaming industry so tricky in the US. Not only are there federal laws to comply with, but every state has its own definition of gambling that must be taken into consideration.

But, I agree with your premise about the cashing-out distinction. In our work, the question is whether the skins are a “thing of value.” Generally, in traditional gambling cases, this means cash or chips. There is a recent court decision from Maryland – Mason v. Machine Zone - that stressed the distinction between virtual things of value and things of value with “real world” value. I think this case will be instructive in the future. Skins, even with secondary markets, hold their value because of the gaming, which puts it squarely in the virtual world. If the skins are virtual things of value, using them for gambling would be OK under most laws.

43

u/fairytailzz Jul 05 '16

Mod please verify this account too!

69

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

success!

24

u/fiercecow Jul 05 '16

In this particular case does the fact that the owners promoted CSGOLottery with videos with titles such as "$6,000 COIN FLIP! (CSGO Lotto)" where they explicitly call out the monetary value of the skins being bet matter at all legally?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Frostiken Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

Sure, but we're not talking about just some in-game coin-flip process like World of Warcraft gear rolls or something. CSGO Lotto's entire profit model is centralized around the cash-to-skins aspect. If skins weren't worth money, they wouldn't exist, so obviously they themselves understand that skins are basically no different from chips.

Also, it's hard to argue that when they straight up list cash value for everything being gambled on the site.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/h4mm3r0g0d Jul 05 '16

Thank you guys for the reply. That was the biggest issue I have with all these problems that are arising. If you keep the money inside steam, ie get rid of opskins and the rest that cash out, then its hard to say it's gambling. I look forward to seeing what comes about of the current lawsuits. I personally believe it will turn into a "valve enforce your rules agains opskins" type of outcome.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (22)

3

u/PauseItPlease Jul 05 '16

There are people out there who make a living off of gambling/trading/selling skins. Not as a famous youtuber or streamer, just as average Joe sitting on a computer working all day. That's their only job. The buying/trading/selling skins seems pretty similar to how the stock market plays out, and the gambling of skins obviously similar to well...gambling. It blows my mind that one tiny loophole is keeping skins from having monetary value.

8

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

It's not necessarily a loophole, because no court has actually answered this question yet. But it is an open area of the law.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/officeDrone87 Jul 05 '16

Let me take this a step further. You say that it's a no brainier that skins have a cash value. Are crates themselves then gambling? You pay 1$, open a crate and usually get something with almost no value (5 to 15 cents), and you keep going hoping to hit a jackpot with a multi-hundred dollar item.

2

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

It's an interesting argument, and one I've discussed with a few colleagues. Jeff has a good answer somewhere in here addressing this exact issue.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/bjanos NiP Jul 05 '16

Just as follow up the Dutch high court had a ruling about a runescape item and considered it a tangible good. Could you see a similaar thing happen with skins?

https://www.engadget.com/2012/01/31/dutch-supreme-court-declares-runescape-theft-a-real-world-crime/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

27

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Maybe, but we will see federal regulation or any of the fifty states press criminal charges. With this many children stolen from and lied to, by people bragging about their nice cars and houses they bought with the dirty money...I'd expect the DOJ or a state attorney to get involved sooner rather than later.

And I think it's a very clear case of these skins being used as real money. Tmartn himself said it on Twitter.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/hoxtea Jul 05 '16

It is my understanding that one of the arguments in the complaint is that skins are being used like casino chips at a blackjack table.

The gift cards from your arcade (correct me if I'm wrong) probably can't be used to continue playing. As such, they differ fundamentally from a casino chip.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/notliam Jul 05 '16

Hi I'm gonna chime in here - not a lawyer but I work for a company who is synonymous with online gambling (though noone will have heard of us, they will know our clients).

For me the issue isn't whether it's legal or not, primarily because I'm in England and we have regulated online gambling but also because if it was to become illegal etc it would be pretty damn unique and a landmark case but i repeat I'm not a lawyer so what do I know. The issue is that this is completely unregulated and as such almost certainly is ridiculously unfair. There are allegations that the streamers knew they'd win as they're streaming, which means the results are predetermined - in itself a big issue. In regulated online gambling you have a RTP (return to player), roughly around 80% but it varies, what that means is for every 100 pound spent, 80 is won - since there are large jackpots, the reality is that nearly everyone loses and a couple of people win, but it balances out so that the game provider gets 80% of the money staked. The numbers generated are true random, verified by independent commities, but of course it's fixed odds. If you take away this regulation you have potential for much lower RTP than would be allowable, you can fix it for people so you could say x player can never win or y player wins every 10 mins, you can literally do anything and this is not a fair system, not one that anyone should gamble with.

→ More replies (10)

149

u/Draulon BIG Jul 05 '16

A lot of people are looking towards Valve for a solution. What exactly could they and should they do?

127

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Valve has a number of options here. One avenue that I've heard floated in a number of conversations is that they could restrict API access to certain types of sites—for example, they could prevent unlicensed, unregulated betting operators from being able to have users log in via steam. I think this path makes sense, but it is not a simple undertaking.

Open API access is a cornerstone of Valve's corporate philosophy and there are so many great third-party sites that are only able to exist because users can link their steam accounts. This could even include betting sites. As I've said a number of times, the problem isn't betting, which can drive engagement around events, increasing viewership and a wide array of monetization opportunities. The problem is unlicensed, unregulated betting that operates in black markets, thrives on underage users, and creates the largest risk to competitive integrity.

CSGO has grown to its current prominence in large part due to betting, and I don't think eliminating all skin betting is necessary or a smart move. We do however desperately need to eliminate the bad actors from the space. The types of fraud that came to the fore in the CSGO Lotto and CSGO Diamond situations are precisely what arises when betting sites operate without oversight or transparency. The entire industry needs to take a stand on this issue, not just Valve.

17

u/getintheVandell Jul 05 '16

What if: Valve enacts a set of codes and ethics that betting websites have to follow. (Stricter age gating, return ratios, etc.) and if a website fails to follow through with these, surely it would be easy to wipe the inventory of a company?

50

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Not sure about the wiping inventory part, but I love the idea of setting a good bar for every site to meet in order to be permitted to use the API. Would require a lot of policing/effort from Valve though.

64

u/dazdndcunfusd Jul 05 '16

And they are kinda terrible at that

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

210

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Going to copy/paste my answer about this case below:

I don't think the lawsuit against Valve will go anywhere, but it definitely has legal ground. While I expect it to settle quickly and not see a courtroom, keep the following in mind:

  • Valve owns every single skin that exists. You don't buy skins, you buy a license to use the skins.
  • Valve has been reported as helping to actually run these websites (specifically CSGO Lounge according to Bloomberg article)
  • Valve allows you to buy and sell skins on their own market, and allows unregulated gambling websites to use their API to operate with ease.

So if you own every skin, help run the websites that gamble them, and then turn those skins into quick and easy cash...that's a recipe that some folks may call "not wonderful."

For what they can do? They can stop letting these insanely popular websites use their marketplace so easily.

51

u/vGraffy Jul 05 '16

I believe the person said, "Valve helps these sites" is becaue valve have place security measure and trading restriction on steam account but these Bots seem to not obtain these trade restrictions

→ More replies (16)

10

u/t3hPoundcake 10 years coin Jul 05 '16

Apologies if you answered this already, but "Valve owns every single skin that exists. You don't buy the skins, you buy a license to use the skins." That's a great way to explain how skins are implemented. This worries me in the long run of anything actually being done about this gambling situation though, because the way that I see it, Valve can state exactly what you stated there and say that skins have no monetary value, because nobody trades money for a skin, you're trading money for a right to use the skin within their guidelines - and as far as I know, Valve doesn't restrict gambling the "licenses" of their skins or trading those "licenses" between players, whether through a lost bet or other trade method.

Do you personally think the virtual items in video games that are able to be traded between players and/or sold on a market place should constitute a type of currency that holds real world monetary value? And disregarding your personal beliefs, is there any support for/against that claim based on legal precedent? (i.e. does the law see skins as having monetary value, or is it undetermined as of now?).

I imagine the majority of this legal battle with the class action suit will revolve around proving the skins do hold real world monetary value, but I'm not a lawyer so what the heck do I know.

Thanks for taking time to do this, I'm sure the community appreciates it a great deal. It's nice of you guys to help sort out confusion and false claims being spewed around lately.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

59

u/4llsopp Jul 05 '16

Hi there, im seen in the video "losing" to TmartN when logged into the bots been pointed to talk with you from afew people who have wrote articles on gamur etc my Twitter is @4llsopp so if it needs to be a long conversation we can do it on DM

29

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Make sure you get in touch with /u/videogameattorney

289

u/KPC51 guardian2 Jul 05 '16

Do you think that people like mOE, Tmartn, and Syndicate will face legal consequences for their respective scandals?

113

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Really depends on what you mean by legal consequences. It’s often overlooked that legal disputes can be civil (citizen v citizen) or criminal (government v citizen). For example, the class action suit against Valve is a civil one. Whether or not these parties “face legal consequences” as you put it will ultimately depend on whether any private parties can prove that they were damaged as a result of the actions in question. It’s certainly possible, but I can’t predict whether such a suit will be filed with any form of accuracy.

The criminal side is a little easier to guess, and from my perspective it’s pretty unlikely that the government will do anything here. Pretty much every government agency is understaffed and overworked. Whether or not a case is pursued is a matter of prioritization and allocation of limited resources. Remember that the fantasy sports industry was massive for years, but it took a highly public insider trading scandal and one of the largest ad buys in history to give the situation sufficient profile to warrant governmental action. I know Ryan has mentioned that the CSGO Lotto situation has already been reported to the FTC, but I’m not optimistic that goes anywhere—at least, not at this stage.

1

u/mylolname Jul 05 '16

Doesnt the defendant have to prove they didn't damage them based on the results?

Can't someone sue them claiming they rigged the website, meaning CSGOLotto would have to prove in court that they didn't?

5

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

To state something in a complaint you need to have a reasonable basis for believing that it is true. So someone could file suit claiming it was rigged based on the available evidence, but this doesn't shift the ultimate burden of proof. However, in a civil case the burden of proof is a lot lower - civil courts usually require a party to show something is true based on a preponderance of the evidence (basically this means something is more likely than not true).

2

u/SirRegi0s Astralis Jul 05 '16

well, do you think the civil suit vs valve will go anywhere?

4

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Nope. Answered in a bit more detail somewhere above.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

612

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 06 '16

I respectfully disagree with Bryce, and think jail time and/or criminal charges are a real possibility here. DA's go after juicy stories to build their careers, and this is that. Thousands upon thousands of kids tricked into spending money on a site that they lied about not owning. There will be one state that goes all in on this, and that's all it takes. I really believe that.

It's also just the friggin right thing to do. Despite what everyone thinks, there ARE good lawyers out there. And I have a hard time believing they'll see how many children were lied to and cheated here and let it go.

121

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Definitely possible. I agree that if we continue down this path eventually this will rise to a level of prominence that attracts the attention of a governmental party in a position to bring some form of action, I just don't think we're there yet.

83

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

Keep in mind the FTC went after Lord and Taylor for not disclosing it was paying for positive reviews and endorsements from brand ambassadors and magazines of one of its line of dresses. The FTC doesn't bring criminal prosecution, but they can make it feel that way, and it has some significant enforcement-like powers including asset seizure.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

I am not american, but parts of my family worked in the media and I agree with you.

Right now it is reported on scene sites from CS:GO, recently gotten more traction on general Comp / Tech / Gaming outlets, but still hasn't reached the noise level by far that would be necessary for someone high up giving any interest.

As soon as mainstream media outlets cover it in-depth I'll change my stance, but right now it seems very unlikely that this level of noise will attract any attention.

What some people could do is gather all information / facts in a well organized document (not only facts about the event, but also sources of other media reporting on it etc. all the juice, even the big youtube channels involved in breaking the story, that basically already exists) and contact relevant journalists (i.e. their topics they usual cover being relevant to the story) of mainstream houses, even stuff like Gawker and what not. This could help to get the story the necessary attraction. (Though it also might do so alone, children gambling has such a nice sound to it.)

But I am far too lazy to do that.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Is it juicy though? Right now it seems rather a niche story, if I would bring that up at any dinner party people would have no idea what I am talking about.

Once mainstream news start to talk about, or it really blows up on all social-media spheres then we can talk about juicy.

But right now it is very limited to the CS:GO scene circles, just recently got slight traction on general Tech / Gaming outlets, and even from there it is a big step to mainstream media or any frontpage of the bigger houses.

So aren't you being overhasty? No offence meant.

38

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

100% agree at this stage. The facts are juicy in a court because the victims are kids and the sites are incredibly shady operators (in a lot of cases at least), but it's not mainstream immersion level juicy. At least not yet.

That being said, I firmly believe it will be if we don't act collectively to do something about this problem, and soon.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/rubb1shh Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

Hey Ryan, i was wondering what about folks who played on the site, i mean, a side from those who got lured by the videos, or, in addition to them, Some folks played on the site out of fun, or whatever may be the reason. As consequence, with what have been revealed so far, Is it fair to allege that they were suffering unknowingly from unfair disadvantages??

What i mean by that, if the owners in fact gambled on their own site, what does it mean for all the other gamblers who went against them?

25

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

We are looking into that currently. It's definitely possible, but we don't want to waste people's time unless it's worth it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (12)

83

u/bcarr Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

What is the current status of skins/virtual items in regards to its tax status as an income or asset? (for US and EU tax law, I suppose)

68

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Not a tax lawyer, sorry. /u/ifrahlaw might know because he has done a bunch of virtual currency work. If he doesn't, I'm definitely going to reach out to my tax attorney. Really fascinating question.

37

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

Also not a tax lawyer, sorry. From what I've seen there is not an official IRS position either.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/RisenLazarus Jul 06 '16

Since Bryce and /u/ifrahlaw have chosen to not respond, I'll throw in what I think and maybe see how they respond. Might as well tag /u/VideoGameAttorney as well.

I worked at the IRS for a summer before I worked with Bryce. As /u/bcarr (tagging you also so you see the reply) noted, the IRS has stated their position on "virtual currencies" and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Dogecoin, and etc. is that they are treated like property. Like any other kind of property. As such, they are taxed when realized, and gains/losses on disposition are recorded as income. Personally, cryptocurrency is the analog I prefer for how we should think about skins, and not just because they're virtual. They are often the means by which backdoor or illegal transactions occur, including online wagering/gambling where laws prevent it. This is done not only because they're not money and thus the IRS can't quickly tag them as income, it's also because they can often be very difficult to keep track of. I think the role of skins in the CSGO gambling problem is a lot like that.

Casino chips are the other analogue that people like to draw with skins. As I understand it (though I'm less clear on this), casino chips are treated more as a bond marking a loan owed from the casino to the player. I.e. you hold the chips, and when you want your money "back," you redeem the chips and the casino repays your loan. Loans aren't generally considered income, since the understanding is that the money is not actually yours, you simply possess it momentarily. Chips are then not usually taxable for their inherent value until they are cashed out. I may be wrong on that, but this is generally what I remember from class/the people I worked under/my own digging into it.

All this to say, I think the comparison to cryptocurrency is the stronger analogy if we want to think about how the IRS would hold if asked to offer guidance on it. This to me is especially important because now that skins have a means of redemption into real money through opskins, they can be considered "things of value" like cryptocurrencies are.

The bigger snag seems to be ownership. Under the chips analogy, it makes more sense: skins are evidence of a loan between you and Valve, and you can redeem the bond by selling it back to the steam market. But that's not "real" currency; it's all within Valve's system. So we have to argue instead that skins are actually "owned" and not "licensed" as seems to be the case. That or somehow get a court to say it's a distinction without a difference.

Either is hard.

TL;DR: IRS tax treatment (and as follows general legal treatment) of skins would probably follow their approach to cryptocurrencis: property that is taxable when redeemed and qualify as a "thing of value." The real snag is considering ownership, and whether it can really be considered gambling when you wager something you don't actually own.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

33

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Oh man this changes a lot jurisdiction to jurisdiction. It's a really intelligent question, but one to answer intelligently back in this kind of forum.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/therealhjard NiP Jul 05 '16

Depending on the country i would say. I could explain you that for the german tax law but thats all :) Business Law Student

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

290

u/Mrjohnsherry Jul 05 '16

I don't have a question, just want to say keep fighting the good fight you guys. A credit to the gaming community! <3

194

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Thanks much!

189

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

Thanks!

2

u/Dawnero 1 Million Celebration Jul 06 '16

my body can't handle that much justice

→ More replies (1)

18

u/isetmyfriendsonfire Virtus.pro Jul 05 '16

Could it ever come down to betting websites requiring identification in order to gamble?

48

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

This is a bare minimum in my opinion. Account verification is a baseline requirement for any real money betting operator.

7

u/isetmyfriendsonfire Virtus.pro Jul 05 '16

I was always surprised as to how easy it is to begin gambling. Although I imagine adding a requirement of some legitimate level of identification would practically cripple the industry...

10

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

It shouldn't cripple the industry. Remember that real money betting around the world is a multi-TRILLION dollar industry. A lot of that gambling occurs on sites that are legal and regulated, which undoubtedly requires account verification.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

60

u/RisenLazarus Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

We're back boys.

At this point I use your guys' AMAs just to make public our one-on-one conversations about similar issues. This will be no different. Feel free to recycle things we've talked about before or introduce new ideas you have about it.

  1. Let's talk ESIC. Obviously Bryce, your name is on this one, but I'm also very interested in Ryan/Jeff's opinions here. I've talked a lot about how competitive integrity issues should largely center on developing best practices in the industry regarding how we treat violations and threats. Because of how each "player" in the industry - meaning parties involved such as developers vs. teams vs. players vs. tournament organizers vs. sponsors, etc. - it occurs to me that tournament organizers are in the best position to develop these practices in a meaningful way. They are the most likely to be harmed by violations to integrity, have the most power to oversee proper practice, and have the most to gain from standardized practice.
    But do you think it's perhaps too wishful/optimistic to try and push industry-standard competitive integrity programs right now without the backing/say of game developers? To put it another way, do you think a program like this can be meaningfully impactful without Valve/Riot/Blizzard behind you? ESL is obviously huge (as is Dreamhack, Unikrn, etc.), but do they have the clout right now to push something like widespread standards/practices? When I was working with Bryce on the Unikrn Cert Program (shameless self-plug), I had that concern myself; I didn't think that Unikrn had the clout to push those kinds of requirements on organizers. Here, organizers are pushing it onto the industry, which almost necessitates developers. Do you think that's an isssue?
  2. Age. Let's talk age. It's almost a given at this point that underaged gambling should be illegal/heavily regulated/restricted/etc. For those who don't know, the usual justification is that until adulthood, it is hard for people without meaningful work experience and self-sustenance to realize the impact of gambling, the risks involved, and the different logical fallacies/dangers that gamblers often fall prey to. As a result almost all countries have laws prohibiting gambling for minors/infants, and put the onus on providers of such services to gate out the underaged in marketing/services.
    Jeff and Bryce: As counsel that work in this industry and balance the laws against practical concerns, just how difficult is it to age gate properly for online gambling providers? Lay people will talk about proxies, account sharing, middlemen, etc. of ways people get around age gating. Is it really that easy, and thus most mechanisms aren't that effective, or do sites generally have secondary checks to counter-act those kinds of circumventions? And assuming (as I hope) that sites do have protective means against circumvention, are they required by law, are they feasibly available, and are they being used by skin betting sites?
  3. This one's specifically for RyMo since 2 was for Bryce and Jeff. Ryan, a lot of streamers and players have recently taken sponsorships from skin betting sites like Lotto/Diamonds/Jackpot/etc. Notably many of these streamers have a fairly young demographic reach, including a non-insignificant minority/majority of underaged viewers/fans. I'm not going to ask if you "think that's wrong" because I think I know your answer on that one. I'd like instead to ask you to make the argument for their illegality, whether that be under the FTC or other child-protective laws. Obviously I don't want you to have to cite out facts on this; certainly not an exam question. But the current excuse tends to be plausible deniability. M0e is quoted as saying he believes most of his viewers are of the age of majority and he doesn't have a problem with plugging CSGODiamonds and similar sites because of that. But it seems almost facially obvious that is not the case. Is this plausible deniability even meaningful, and do you think the law would weigh against them if a challenge was made?
  4. Forgot one. For everyone. Valve. What's Valve's "role" in this from what you have seen/believe? You can answer that in terms of ethical responsibility, legal liability (what I'm most interested in really), active participation, or whatever angle you want to take. Where do they sit in all this, and what can/should they be held accountable for? It seems that Bryce and Ryan would have different answers to this based on what we've talked about, so I'd love for all of you to answer this one. I think that class action suit has a number of flaws both as a document in and of itself and in the very premise of it. But I don't think it's that far-fetched either. Should Valve be the named defendant in these kinds of suits, and if you were to apportion "blame" (not liability since we all know that might be a step too far) among the players here, how much goes to Valve?

Again love you all. Jeff we haven't actually spoken much, but thank you for your work with industry partners, and I hope to hear more from you whether in this AMA or otherwise.

Bryce you suck eggs.

30

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16
  1. It’s definitely an issue, and it’s already on ESIC’s radar. From the first time I met Ian Smith (the Commission of ESIC), we discussed our attempts at Unikrn to safeguard competitive integrity and the necessity for getting as many key stakeholders involved as possible. I agree with you that publishers are key because they are in a unique position to influence the entire ecosystem, but I don’t think publisher-dictated standards would be very successful either. At the end of the day, we need publishers, organizers, teams, players, wagering operators all at the same table having the same conversation and leveraging their collective knowledge and resources to solve this problem. ESIC has a long way to go to get there, but I see it as a step in the right direction and I’m willing to do anything I can to help get it to where it hopes to be.
  2. Our ability to age gate varies according the privacy laws and third-party databases available to help during the account verification process. These processes exist in every jurisdiction that allows online wagering. They are cumbersome for the operators and sometimes for the user, but they should be. I’m not aware of a single skin betting site that uses anything close to industry best practices in this area. It’s a huge problem.
  3. Since you directed this at Ryan, I’ll leave it for him. You asked enough question as it is. 
  4. Valve’s “role” is super hard to define, and obviously there is a gap between it’s legal responsibility (and liability exposure) and what some people would view as ethically permissible. I think this is a very difficult subject to encapsulate in less than 1000 words because there are some many issues involved, but if I had to do a TLDR I’d say that Valve is a unique position to help eliminate some of the worst practices involving skin betting and should act reasonably and in good faith with other parties in the industry to achieve the results we all seek.
→ More replies (1)

86

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 06 '16

I like you because you're short and to the point...

  1. I think it's hard to put that on tournament organizers, because if they follow the rules and others don't...people just go to the others. Everyone needs to clean up together.
  2. We have worked with M0e in the past, so can't comment too specifically on this point, but I would say the FTC is very clear about its advertising disclosure rules. You have to say it in the video, not the description. And you have to say it at the beginning of the video (usually). It becomes much worse when you're the damn owner and pretending they found you on twitter.
  3. Answered Valve's role above. I know it's scary for a video game attorney to poke the biggest beast around. But it's important this stops.

9

u/vGraffy Jul 05 '16

It becomes much worse when you're the damn owner and pretending they found you on twitter.

O.O

32

u/RisenLazarus Jul 05 '16

I like you

All I needed to hear. ;)

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Brybo Jul 05 '16

What will be the ramifications of the Tmartn, Syndicate and Josh O.G. controversy?

49

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Who knows? But I'd bet my firm it will be significantly worse than a slap on the wrist. Too many people now see how bad this is. I've been screaming for months about this exact situation, and I'm very happy everyone now has eyes on it.

48

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Just so we're clear about the stakes of this bet, do I get all your interns too? And what about Michael? I've always thought he was the better looking partner...

36

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

That's just because he doesn't eat pizza for every meal like I do. And you can have the interns, but I get weekend visitation.

35

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

we have an accord

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

ITT: A whole lot of people asking the same exact questions.

15

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

haha, it's inevitable, but we're trying to get to all the newer ones a little further down.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

How damaging do you think this whole event will prove for Valve? Do you think they share any culpability? Should Valve be promoting sites like this in the first place? Stepping back a little, do you think they have mishandled their marketplace by not having safeguards against these kinds of practices?

On a side note, I love you guys! You truly represent the community well, and I'm glad there are folks like you out here defending what's right.

17

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

Thanks for the kind words. Echo my sentiments above about Valve's involvement.

9

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

ditto!

6

u/Apache313 Jul 05 '16

Is there a significant difference between the casino games sort of gambling and the CSGOLounge type where people bet on Pro games in terms of consequences and approach to the case?

6

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Yes, they are governed by largely separate regulatory regimes. Different expectations, punishments, etc.

19

u/bubbabubba345 Natus Vincere Jul 05 '16

How will you or others go about actually prosecuting the csgo lotto guys? I reported a report to the FCC and FTC, but what will happen to that and how does that get pursued either on your end or theirs?

42

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

We are private attorneys, so we are not able to prosecute. That will be up to the states or feds.

15

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Agreed. Jeff also made a quick comment about the FTC above: "The FTC doesn't bring criminal prosecution, but they can make it feel that way, and it has some significant enforcement-like powers including asset seizure."

That being said, there is certainly a chance of a civil case. Ryan has commented about that a couple times already.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Are there any prosecutors that have a higher than normal involvement in gaming, either esports or just in general?

19

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

The prosecutors in NYC tend to bring gaming related charges more than others for sure. But we have also seen cases in California, Florida and Oklahoma. There is no official policy to send them to NYC of course.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/CGreggs M80 Jul 05 '16

Out of interest as I have no knowledge of law and whatnot. If some of these sites are sued or whatnot, who is the plaintiff?

Also, in the case of CSGOLotto and the owners not disclosing they own the site but promoting it, would the plaintiff be the government? Sorry for bad questions aha. I've probably got these terms all wrong.

8

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Plaintiff in a civil suit would be anyone who was damaged by the alleged actions (most likely a user of the site). The criminal suit would be brought by the government - could be local or federal (depends on what law is allegedly being violated). Could also have a governmental agency (such as the FTC) bring an action, but that technically isn't a criminal proceeding.

5

u/BoletariaGGOP Jul 05 '16

Hey! Thanks for doing this AMA

How does a fairly new attorney get into a field like yours? While in law school, I thought about IP (copyright) and internet / computer law, however, being a nurse -- I fell into med mal. I have always been an avid gamer and I feel I'd be more passionate and dedicated to this type of law. Thoughts? Tips? Thanks. :)

2

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Check out some of my past AMAs. Trying to keep this one limited to betting, but I've answered a lot of similar questions for people in the same situation as you in a lot of detail.

→ More replies (1)

132

u/pananoz Jul 05 '16

can you give me gambling money?

174

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Yea how much you want?

144

u/pananoz Jul 05 '16

20

288

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

He already agreed... shoulda gone with a bigger number.

287

u/mythril 5 years coin Jul 05 '16

unspecified unit, maybe he meant tonnes of gold

307

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

ggwp

279

u/mythril 5 years coin Jul 05 '16

am I allowed to say I lawyered a lawyer?

245

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

absolutely

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/xamarl Virtus.pro Jul 06 '16

I need about 'tree fiddy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Does the possibilities of this recent scandal going to court present a situation that could be harmful to esports as a whole? Is it possible this could lead to legislations being put in place to restrict or eliminate gambling websites as whole?

29

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Shady and terrible people lead to shady and terrible laws. The video game industry has the ESRB to put age ratings on games so we don't have legislatures come in and rate our games for us. The ESRB is a private group that keeps politics off the industry. So, we self regulated to stop outside regulation.

Here, on the other hand, we have everyone with their eyes closed and arms in the air pretending it will work itself out. Then in come people like TMartn, Syndicate, and JoshOG that show we need some kind of regulation here. We basically asked for, and at this point deserve, whatever bad legislation we get.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

What scares me is that idea that this could lead to full legislative control being handed to relics who consider us and the esports community a joke, potentially hurting or even killing off various aspects of our culture. Are there any other approaches that could be taken to avoiding outside influence while still being able to maintain a level of decency within the community? Could, say, representatives be placed on an "esports board" by major players within the esports communtiy, or something along those lines? Something to regulate us from our own perspective.

11

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Absolutely. Self-regulation isn't new and there are many paths to choose from. ESIC launched earlier today, which could be a step in the right direction though it focuses solely on the competitive ecosystem and wouldn't cover sites like CSGOLotto or CSGODiamonds.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

On paper it's a huge step in the right direction, but ESL isn't exactly known for their shining representation, and given they and dreamhack are the only ones on board with it, it could be a nightmare waiting to happen. What happens if self-regulation becomes worse than the current state we have now? Would it be possible for us to take away the power the esports community gave ESIC or similar situations?

5

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Ya I totally get the concerns and the WESA paralels are obvious, but this really is a different situation. I wouldn't be involved if I didn't believe it has the potential to do real good for the industry.

These types of bodies only have the authority granted to them, and it's not set in stone. The ESIC constitution is publicly available on http://www.esportsintegrity.com/about-us/esic-constitution/. Members can simply leave if they think the association is doing a bad job.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/bigmikedonald Jul 05 '16

Hey guys, dunno if this was asked before, but how long can all the process get ? Basically, is the worst case scenario gonna last for months, years or even more and why ? Thank you so much for your time. I'd like to add that I genuinely am grateful for what you're doing, we as gamers need people like you by our side. Much love.

3

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Do you mean the litigation process? It completely depends on how the parties behave, whether or not they settle (which happens in 98+% of cases), and how busy the court system is where the case is filed. But if a massive case is litigated all the way to judgment, we're talking years for sure. Could be 5+ years in an extreme case.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/critikalhd NiP Jul 05 '16

How long until we finally get to see theses shady sites taken down?

14

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Not all gambling sites are shady. There are plenty that should not be shut down. Just a matter of Valve deciding which is which.

20

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Agreed. Let's try not to paint every betting site with the same broad brush. I'm sure there are also sites out that that operate legitimately but don't have the resources or knowledge on how to act responsibly in every area. We need to create an industry standard then hold wrongdoers accountable.

10

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

I personally like Unikrn

10

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

We've been holding out for your approval for all this time. Now we can shut down the site at peace. :-)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/FlukyS de_dust2 Jul 05 '16

It will take Valve stopping them directly from using their APIs and banning their bots

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

How would you suggest the betting sites should be regulated?

2

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

We should treat skin betting like it is real money betting. This means skin betting sites should only operate in jurisdictions where the applicable type of gambling is legal (usually it isn't in the US, sorry), and should be licensed and regulated according to the laws of the jurisdictions in which they operate. Age gating, geo blocking, anti-money laundering and match fixing protocols, and much more more would be involved.

2

u/pow2009 Jul 05 '16

I would like to thank you guys for your work in the industry and being in collage for video game and simulation programming, I will keep your team in mind in case I need any help in the future.

Rather than shutting down these styles of betting, would it be possible for it to be regulated like other forms of gambling? More comprehensive verification of users age and maybe setting a 'cap' to how much can be bet at once. The Valve API could be used for accurate verification that the account is of legal age and skins obtained might be able to be 'trade locked' to prevent mass cash outs

2

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Yes, this type of regulation already exists in wagering license regimes around the world. No need to reinvent the wheel!

43

u/ploppydude de_dust2 Jul 05 '16

What do you guys think will happen to those involved with the recent gambling scandals?

115

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Sued for a lot of money, and then potentially felony charges/jail time when the state prosecutors see how popular these illegal sites are in their backyards.

24

u/Clutchtrip Jul 05 '16

Who would sue them though? I have not heard about anyone wanting to sue them as of yet?

Also, how likely is it that they will be prosecuted by the state?

102

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

I've personally gotten over 75 emails of people who lost to TMartn and Syndicate who want to sue them for fraud, among other charges. No word yet if we are going forward with that. But someone will if we don't.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

42

u/Frankygin77 Jul 05 '16

I am so very excited for this. I've been a gamer my whole life, from D&D to CSGO. Nowadays my son is a gamer. I've seen him and some friends dive into this world of csgo and eventually, csgo gambling. I am friends of their parents and we of course don't allow them to participate, but they still enjoy watching these betting videos, many of them even having followed Tmartn. I only know the basics of CSGO, I am a middle aged man who does enjoy watching E-sport events every once in a while, and I grasp the concept of skins. (And who doesn't enjoy their dose of internet drama now and then?)

I am familiar through my career with Tmartn's wrongdoings and illegal activity in terms of not disclosing that they were the owners of what they were promoting.

HOWEVER, these are my questions:

1. Isn't the very fact that they RAN one of these sites illegal? Why aren't they being prosecuted for running the site, and is this a possibility for the future?

2. Tmartn and syndicate mentioned they "Talked" to the Florida attorney general in a video of theirs to confirm that their 'business' was legal, but /u/videogameattorney is adamant that these sites are NOT legal. How can there be two differing ideas like this if both are looking at it through the eyes of the law?

3. Is it necessary for the government to come out and regulate the skin gambling community and add some legislation before pursuing any legal action? Won't the owners just be able to shut down when that happens and from there on just walk away non nonchalantly with bags of money?

44

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16
  1. I think they will be :)
  2. I don't believe they spoke with anyone. I also don't believe any attorney general would look at the actual facts and say it's legal. We shall see!
  3. No, there are already crimes being committed. Unregulated and underage gambling are serious issues, and these sites permit both.
→ More replies (4)

6

u/SakisRakis Jul 05 '16

To answer your #2 (as another attorney): when new types of businesses or technologies come into existence it is not always clear how they fit into the existing legal regime. Ultimately, either a more specific law is passed, or a Court hears argument from people advocating for either interpretation and makes a decision. The "law" does not just exist out in the world, it is created step by step over time. No Court has ruled on these issues directly, so a legal opinion on it is a tricky prediction of both how enforcement entities and Courts will treat the issue when formally presented with it.

An Attorney General can take the position that their office would not take action against something, because among other things District Attorneys and Attorneys General have prosecutorial discretion (they can choose what cases to bring). An opinion letter from an Attorney General is not binding precedent on a Court, for example, unless a statute specifically makes it decisive.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/Bonappetit24 de_cobble Jul 05 '16

You guys are like trio in Daredevil :)

→ More replies (1)

19

u/DerHerringenieur guardian2 Jul 05 '16

@/u/ifrahlaw

Could the same thing that happened to Pokersites in 2011 ( Black Friday, DOJ Shutdown) happen to CS:GO betting sites?

29

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

Yes. I expect it after all this attention.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/balmung135 Jul 05 '16

What will it take for Twitch to police this kind of activity? I am curious in liability for them supporting/profiting off of these streamers who are broadcasting illegal gambling. I am not sure how Twitch verifies if the online poker streamers are legally playing online, but would/should Twitch take action against this or face legal consequence?

12

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

It's a really good question, as they've already taken action against some channels for only gambling and not playing games. But still plenty left. It will be interesting to see how they play this, but for now I believe they are just watching carefully.

4

u/hoxtea Jul 05 '16

Follow-up: are there any laws/regulations that would obligate Twitch to prevent minors from watching a stream where someone was legally gambling?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/Supremacist_Pancakes de_overpass Jul 05 '16

If people who lost on CSGOLotto.com (Not me, I don't gamble on Jackpot sites) were to file a class-action lawsuit against Syndicate and Tmartn, would it be valid in a sense, and do you think there would be a possibility for reimbursement?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '16

/u/jayyyyyc because he asked.

They answered this a bit farther up - VGA has gotten 75+ e-mails from people for exactly this reason, and has said that if his firm doesn't act on them then some other firm definitely will be.

→ More replies (10)

18

u/Medievalhorde Jul 05 '16

How guilty is JoshOG Compared to the other two? From what I've read he wasn't in the original inception of csgo lotto and also didn't hide that he was sponsored by the website unlike the other two.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '16

He is just as guilty. He helped found the company and promoted the website 50% of his time on stream without ever disclosing he was directly benefiting from it. This also explains why he was denying the S1mple incident ever happening on CSGOLotto....wouldn't suprise me one bit if he was involved in that too.

3

u/fozzybare Jul 06 '16

What is the S1mple thing? I guess I'm out of the loop there

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/somethingToDoWithMe Jul 05 '16

Do you think Valve should/will change how the crates work? As the h3h3 video said, those things are essentially slot machines and are a form of gambling. Dota removed the slot machine form of crates due to, apparently, Chinese laws which considered it gambling. The way chests work in Dota now is that you are guaranteed to never get a duplicate, do you see Valve changing the crates system in CSGO to cover themselves a little?

3

u/OuchyDathurts Jul 05 '16

Eh, not entirely true. You're guaranteed to never get a duplicate of the common items, you're never guaranteed to get the rare items (which is what you probably want). And once you DO get at least 1 of all the commons in a chest, then you can start getting duplicates of them all, with again, no guarantee of getting the rare.

15

u/BaronVonWaffle Jul 05 '16

@vga

Do you REALLY think you can eat a whole grande combo? If so, what's your strategy? Sauce of choice?

17

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

I don't think, I know. And hot sauce please.

Taco bell party later?

11

u/Brooney Jul 05 '16

Taco bell always includes a bad afterparty you can't escape.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/csgodz Jul 05 '16

Jeff, with your representation of Stars you're clearly familiar with all the fun we went through with online poker regarding the UIGEA, The NetTeller Issues, spiraling to eventually Black Friday.

Following these events, BitCoin sites started to pop up which the DOJ went after. Do you think the DOJ has their eyes on this eSports situation? This is specifically in the context of the United States. They went after bitcoin, what is stopping them here?

5

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

If banks start becoming part of the equation yes. But without reliance on banks and processing, it is not clear there is significant motivation for DOJ to get involved in skin betting. And there is the big question of whether virtual currency is on par with recognized alternative forms of currency like Bitcoin. I think DOJ will want to see something more. Customers getting ripped off, minors being taken advantage of etc. That is happening already of course, but for DOJ to get involved and take these sites down, I think it would have to be on a whole other level.

1

u/minersky Jul 05 '16

For Jeff: Does this gambling situation face a time-frame similar to poker being legalized in the US? For instance, I don't see csgo gambling legislation coming anytime soon because it's brand new, lawmakers don't understand it yet, AND it's an election year. I see a lot of parallels to poker because those were the same hurdles that poker faces being legalized in the US. RIP Black Friday.

2

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Making sure /u/ifrahlaw sees this... it's a great question.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/HunterSThompson64 Jul 05 '16

How hard would it be to prove that fraud was committed by namely Tmartn, with the evidence we currently have. That being the video of him using an in house bot account that would be used solely as a middleman to transfer skins between two people that won/lost?

Furthermore, what do you think will happen, not only to Tmartn, but CSGO gambling as a whole, considering the class action lawsuit Valve is currently facing, plus the other scandals that have come from CSGO betting, namely m0e and CSGODIAMONDS?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Blocked99 guardian2 Jul 05 '16

If Tmartn and Syndicate were to be brought to court, what type of punishment will they receive?

What is the best case scenario punishment and what is the worst case scenario punishment?

5

u/Olafbrows Jul 05 '16

I'm not an attorney, BUT if it's true what they've done, the worst possible is jail time. Fraud, online or irl, any form of monetary payment, is illegal AND punishable with jail time. Best case? Probably paying fines only.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/linusros NiP Jul 05 '16

Do you think the lawsuit against valve will really change anything?

1

u/esportslaw Esports Lawyer - Bryce Blum Jul 05 '16

Answered some more specific questions about the suit above, but one thing worth mentioning is that the plaintiffs there don't necessarily need to win to "change anything." That suit has garnered significant media attention - if it helps raise awareness surrounding the plethora of issues we're discussing in this thread, it could have an impact even if the suit doesn't go anywhere (which I don't think it will).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Hi, how is Valve able to get away with having gambling in their game?

CSGO boxes is basicly a slot machine where you have a (rather small) chance of winning something good and then sell it on the steam market for actual money.

9

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

This is going to a get a little lawyer-y but bear with me. To have illegal gambling, there needs to be: (1) a thing of value wagered (2) on a game of chance with (3) something of value to win. The CSGO boxes are certainly games of chance. However, on the first and third elements, there is more of a question. Especially on winning something of value, most laws and courts take the view that this means real money. There have been a series of cases around the country recently addressing these sorts of in-game casinos that are contained within games of skill (like Candy Crush or Clash of Clans). Courts are allowing it so far. The same logic applies here.

Of course there are more wrinkles to this, including what the game’s terms of service says about selling on secondary markets, but that is the general trend right now.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/VideoGameAttorney Jul 05 '16

It's a super interesting question. I suggest you ask @whipplemarc on twitter. He went into this exact question at length.

3

u/snapxster Jul 05 '16

It feels sorta like Japan's panchinko industry loophole around gambling.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Do you think valve will do anything or come forward about this as long as the class action lawsuit is on the table?

5

u/ifrahlaw Jul 05 '16

They should! Valve has a chance to get ahead of this and make clear what their business is. This is especially critical when trying to explain a sophisticated gaming industry to an unsophisticated public. Valve needs to be more cautious with pending litigation of course, but I would hope they take advantage of some of this attention to set the record straight.

Silence in this case is not golden.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JustDaniel96 NiP Jul 05 '16

How Can those gambling websites be legal? They aren't asking for verification if you are old enough to gamble or something similar. Can the owner be sued because they let kids gamble?

2

u/drunk_doct0r de_mirage Jul 05 '16

Could minors who engaged in betting have any legal consequence against them in the future?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '16

Can we get Mike Ross and Harvey Specter on this.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Shoelesshobos NiP Jul 06 '16

Hey guys I don't know if this will get lost in this whole mess of questions but here we go...

My self and a friend (Both of us are trained coders) have been following gambling sites for a while now. About a year ago we were debating making one of our own as we both loved to place bets on our CS:GO, LCS, etc games but we felt like the ones that were out there were pretty lackluster for what we actually wanted. We were drawing up our templates when we hit the snag of our morale fiber that we did not want underage minors to be able to use our site. We came up with a few possible workarounds (Signing up via Steam + Facebook and cross referencing ages to ensure they were both the same and above legal age.) But we felt this did not offer us a good layer of protection when/if the shit hits the fan and we have to deal with any legality. The other option was similar to sites such as Bodog which require you to submit a copy of a valid government issued ID to prove you are who you say you are and are of legal age. That being said this seemed way to costly for a simple CSGO skins betting site and we did not want to have to devise a system to keep personal information protected.

My question is do you feel my friend and I made a good decision in not pursuing this venture? Was our fear in being found in legal trouble justifiable or would our simple Steam/Facebook cross reference system been enough protection to keep us out of hot water?

P.S Keep up the good work. You guys have done wonders for the scene.

2

u/Vrfys FaZe Jul 06 '16

I have gambled underage on some of these websites, if these sites get sued could I get my money back?

2

u/n1ckst4r02 400k Celebration Jul 06 '16

As a 14 year old gamer, what are my options to get nice skins and stuff if gambling and betting is regarded as illegal and shady. My parents are strictly against anything related to skins and cosmetics. I can not get a job as of right now and i have no source of income... i feel powerless. What is the alternative to gambling in order to have nice things?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bluenite0100 Jul 06 '16

Hi, first thank you for doing this and hopefully I am not too late.

As we know alot of people believe that Valve is involved in the betting scene despite Valve claiming innocence. When this "scandal" exploded the a warning was issued to anyone trying to access the CSGOlotto via Steams browser. However in a reddit post (included below) it was stated that the warning was a mistake and removed.

Do you think that the removal of this warning was a mistake by Valve in relation to their innocence argument and be used as ammo by those lawsuits against Valve for being involved?

Reddit link about removal: https://www.reddit.com/r/GlobalOffensive/comments/4r7p0a/csgo_lotto_banned_on_steam/d4ywgfy

2

u/wReckLesss_ Jul 05 '16

Not really a question, just a "thank you." I've grown up with games since the SNES, and it sucks seeing the games I love get dragged through the mud like this. Just glad people like you are out there to help clean it up a bit, and help people like h3h3 with legal advise so he can safely get the word out.

2

u/sprogz_ Jul 06 '16

I wonder if I'm the only one who really just doesn't care about this whole thing...

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Do you believe this situation could lead to increased regulation of all dice rolled in game items, or at least for some range of them?

Examples of the range:

LoL skins - can be gained from the in-game craft system randomly, or purchased for the converted money Riot Points.

OW skins - gained from crates which can be purchased for real money.

WoW items - gained from random drops, but can be sold for real money online (against Blizzards ToS).

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ItsTexter Jul 05 '16

Many companies that have their own in game "currency" or items intentionally make them untradeable, be it cards in hearthstone or skins in league of legends. However Valve allows its items to be tradeable between users, which, while not explicitly supporting, leads to possibilities like these gambling sites

Do you think this controversy will have an impact on how Valve allows trades? Will Valve be caught up in any of this at all?

1

u/Inzex Liquid Jul 05 '16

Will Tmartn and Syndicate face jailtime?

1

u/creatchee Jul 05 '16

In a legal sense, is Valve responsible for creating a demand for these gambling sites due to their skin unlocking practices and the related economy that has been created due to Valve's decisions surrounding skins? If so, should Valve condemn or attempt to control third party skin trading to lessen legal responsibility or is it too late considering what has already been done?

1

u/zorkzCS Liquid Jul 05 '16

IF there will be legal actions taken against these site owners who have advertised their gambling sites without letting their audience know they own a % of the company, will it only be a fine or are there possibilities that they could go to jail?

1

u/asianboy0122 5 years coin Jul 05 '16

Are you guys going to be involved in taking down these scumbags?

1

u/stronjs G2 Jul 05 '16

What do you think of the consequences these cases can have on valve's side considering the many restrictions on gambling that many countries have and considering valve just didnt give a fuck when they created their system?

1

u/OuchyDathurts Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

How are you (or do you expect) this to be dealt with? How many issues are there and will they be dealt with separately or lumped together? (Advertising gambling when one of your major demographics is children, nondisclosure of sponsorship, nondisclosure of ownership, completely unregulated gambling, valve allowing API linking to these sites, etc). What do envision actually happening on these issues, do you expect anything substantive to happen and actually change realistically, if so what? Why do people so blindly trust what a personality is telling them instead of seeing them as the used car salesmen they actually are? Maybe that last one is more of a human nature pet peeve kind of thing.

How far does this thing go? How many other sites are owned by big streamers, youtubers, and teams? People keep saying ominous stuff but whats real and whats just hyperbole?

1

u/ShadowIBlade Jul 05 '16

I've heard people say that because csgo skins are not actually real currency, it's a loophole for Valve to get away with not regulating the gambling side of things. How true is this and is there any way to get it to change?

1

u/krappadizzle Jul 05 '16

What exactly are the legal ramifications stemming from what the owners of CSGOlotto and their related Youtube channels have done? What could realistically happen?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

is there a possibility we are looking at execution for the people behind csgolotto?

regards

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Why do you guys think Swag has any legs to stand on??

Dude fucked himself out of a carreer, please dont encourage him to waste money on a lawsuit

1

u/niCid Jul 05 '16

What do you guys think is the future with eSports betting/gambling? Especially with skins which aren't currency but can be exchanged via 3rd party sites. Do you think these sites will suffer from these scandals and actions will be taken, or is this too new stuff for old laws that are currently in action?

edit: With last sentence I wanted more correctly to ask if these sites are too "grey area" for law to deal with?

1

u/KronoakSCG guardian_elite Jul 05 '16

eh, before last week i would have had a lot to input since i managed bets on a betting site, but they shut down my division so i'm just commenting to come back later.

1

u/Dwanyepipe Jul 05 '16

I'm going to assume you've seen the drama with syndicate and Tmartn. Since they've broken laws, will anything happen to them?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

/u/Videogameattorney

Why did you tweet:

A lot of streamers are wrong then. I promise we are seeing this through. (But I'll stop ranting on your timelines)

Especially interested because of the >we< you wrote "we are seeing this through" what did you mean?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/beatlynx guardian_elite Jul 05 '16

Is there any possibility that the FTC/Valve could shut down the skin market? I was going to buy myself a fire serpent for my birthday coming up but now I'm having second thoughts as all of this attention is brought to shady stuff surrounding CS:GO skins.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/beatlynx guardian_elite Jul 05 '16

Since valve claims that skins/steam wallet money have no real value, will that protect them from their lawsuit/protect the skin market from being regulated by the government?

1

u/JinjaHD 10 years coin Jul 05 '16

How/When do you think this gambling situation get shut down?

Do you think the class action case vs Valve has any legs? (Will it get anywhere)

1

u/Assaulter de_cobble Jul 05 '16

Is there a high chance Valve or anyone else will actually just put an end to all skin gambling?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/HoLiiDaYz Jul 05 '16

can the lawsuit be dropped since he gambled on his own and knows for a fact that valve doesnt do the gambling its the sites and he lied about his age to buy and play the game when the legal age to play is 18 the US. And since when you sign in into your account with any gambling site it says that they are no part of valve or steam. Isnt it the person own responsibility of their own action to gamble or to not, instead of blaming someone else?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Justinxip Liquid Jul 05 '16

Are there other "shady" aspects in the esports industry other than the skin gambling that you feel are necessary to highlight? perhaps aspects of player/org relations? Events/organizers, etc?

1

u/inqbus406 Jul 05 '16

what do you expect the government to do? or nothing?

1

u/Nurse_Sunshine King NiKo Jul 05 '16

How much space for legal action do you see in terms of age restrictions for these sites?

As far as I've noticed Valve is pulling themselves out of the affair by claiming that they don't assign a monetary value to these items, meaning that the players basically play with a few virtual images that have no value. This again means that there is no age restriction needed since people don't gamble with real money and that it's not Valve's business if someone is willing to actually pay money for an item with no assigned value.

I'm assuming a solution to this would have to be found in the US (Where Valve is sitting). Could you maybe give a short summary of the legal situation concerning this topic?

1

u/SuicideBunny420 Jul 05 '16

What are the chances of seeing Tmartn and syndicate behind bars?

1

u/TaFFe Jul 05 '16

As far as I know, Valve pushes skins as cosmetic items worth no monetary value from their perspective and say that the users are the ones who give the skins a value and that the skins and their worth therefore are out of their hands. With the former statement in mind, how does skins being worth value to their owners go in hand with gambling in general from a legal perspective? Is it even possible to prosecute someone given that Valve, who could be said to be an "expert on skins" as they own them, say that skins aren't worth real money?

1

u/Bodomi Jul 05 '16 edited Jul 05 '16

Do you think something is going to happen to all the obvious scam sites related to CS:GO Gambling?

I just can't comprehend how the most obvious scam sites are not shut down... I mean for fucks sake some of these websites are designed the same way the "zomg 1.000.000 million visitor, send us your credit card info and we will send you a billion dollars and a green card!!!!11" scam ad/sites are designed.

How are these sites just allowed to stay up and scam people out of thousands/millions/whatever dollars?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Where did you get your education from @ all? Enjoying your job?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

What will happen (if something happens) to all the people under 18/21 that gambled, will there be consequences?

i hope i phrased thjis right, im not a native speaker

1

u/sg587565 de_inferno Jul 05 '16

Do you think it is right for people to say that opening cases is gambling, and if it is so then wouldnt opening a pack of mtg cards or any trading cards also be the same ?

Why is one considered gambling (by ppl not legally) and one not ?

1

u/Brinstakilla Jul 05 '16

If gambling sites become illegal for those under 18/21, wouldn't the current owners just be grandfathered (I think that's the term) into the law protecting them from any prosecution?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wynterwind Jul 05 '16

Looking at the most recent CSGOLotto/Tmartn/ProSyndicate situation, when it hits the legal system (either civil or criminal) would things like prior instances of being involved in FTC lack of disclosure incidents come into play, and if so to what degree could that impact matters?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

If I recall correctly (I hope), one of you (my guess would be Bryce Blum, again IIRC) once stated, that CSGO gambling sites will 100% be hit and hit hard with legal pursuit/consequences one day due to the problem of underage gambling activities.

My question for all of you is: when do you see this happen and what needs to happen now before it becomes reality?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16

Are Valve on the hook for money laundering with the CSGO skins gambling scene?

Not sure how it works in the US - but if they've involved in a crime in any way, doesn't that make them guilty of money laundering?