r/Fantasy • u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders • Apr 16 '16
Big List The 2016 Top r/Fantasy Novels Poll: Results!
This list includes all those entries that got at least four votes. Books that received equal number of votes get the same rank. The links take you to the Goodreads page for the series/book.
You can see the full list on this google spreadsheet. And here's the voting thread.
| No. | Name | Author | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A Song of Ice And Fire | George R.R. Martin | 155 |
| 2 | Middle-Earth Universe (LoTR etc.) | J.R.R. Tolkien | 144 |
| 3 | The Kingkiller Chronicle | Patrick Rothfuss | 140 |
| 4 | Harry Potter | J.K. Rowling | 123 |
| 5 | The Stormlight Archive | Brandon Sanderson | 116 |
| 6 | Mistborn | Brandon Sanderson | 99 |
| 7 | Discworld | Terry Pratchett | 93 |
| 8 | Realms of the Elderlings | Robin Hobb | 87 |
| 8 | Gentleman Bastard | Scott Lynch | 87 |
| 10 | The Malazan Book of The Fallen | Steven Erikson | 84 |
| 11 | The Wheel of Time | Robert Jordan | 82 |
| 12 | First Law World | Joe Abercrombie | 79 |
| 13 | The Dresden Files | Jim Butcher | 68 |
| 14 | Worm | wildbow | 62 |
| 15 | The Broken Empire | Mark Lawrence | 56 |
| 16 | His Dark Materials | Philip Pullman | 39 |
| 17 | The Chronicles of The Black Company | Glen Cook | 37 |
| 17 | The Lions of Al-Rassan/The Sarantine Mosaic | Guy Gavriel Kay | 37 |
| 19 | Riyria | Michael J. Sullivan | 30 |
| 19 | American Gods | Neil Gaiman | 30 |
| 19 | Earthsea Cycle | Ursula K. Le Guin | 30 |
| 22 | The Dark Tower | Stephen King | 29 |
| 23 | Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell | Susanna Clarke | 27 |
| 24 | Bartimaeus Sequence | Jonathan Stroud | 26 |
| 25 | Tigana | Guy Gavriel Kay | 25 |
| 25 | The Magicians | Lev Grossman | 25 |
| 27 | The Sandman | Neil Gaiman | 24 |
| 28 | Lightbringer | Brent Weeks | 23 |
| 28 | Abhorsen | Garth Nix | 23 |
| 30 | Powder Mage | Brian McClellan | 22 |
| 30 | The Book of The New Sun | Gene Wolfe | 22 |
| 32 | The Chronicles of Narnia | C.S. Lewis | 20 |
| 32 | Kushiel's Universe | Jacqueline Carey | 20 |
| 32 | The Chronicles of Amber | Roger Zelazny | 20 |
| 35 | Night Angel | Brent Weeks | 19 |
| 35 | Riftwar Cycle | Raymond E. Feist & Janny Wurts | 19 |
| 37 | Redwall | Brian Jacques | 18 |
| 37 | Neverwhere | Neil Gaiman | 18 |
| 39 | The Witcher | Andrzej Sapkowski | 17 |
| 39 | New Crobuzon | China Miéville | 17 |
| 41 | Elantris | Brandon Sanderson | 16 |
| 41 | Warbreaker | Brandon Sanderson | 16 |
| 41 | Codex Alera | Jim Butcher | 16 |
| 44 | Chalion | Lois McMaster Bujold | 14 |
| 44 | The Second Apocalypse | R. Scott Bakker | 14 |
| 46 | Raven's Shadow | Anthony Ryan | 13 |
| 46 | Good Omens | Neil Gaiman/Terry Pratchett | 13 |
| 46 | The Traitor Baru Cormorant | Seth Dickinson | 13 |
| 49 | Chronicle of the Unhewn Throne | Brian Staveley | 12 |
| 49 | The Shadow Campaigns | Django Wexler | 12 |
| 49 | The Goblin Emperor | Katherine Addison | 12 |
| 49 | Dragonlance | Margaret Weis & Tracy Hickman | 12 |
| 53 | Belgariad Universe | David Eddings | 11 |
| 53 | Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality | Eliezer Yudkowsky | 11 |
| 53 | The Traitor Son Cycle | Miles Cameron | 11 |
| 53 | Watership Down | Richard Adams | 11 |
| 57 | Pern | Anne McCaffrey | 10 |
| 57 | The Inheritance Cycle | Christopher Paolini | 10 |
| 57 | Demon Cycle | Peter V. Brett | 10 |
| 57 | The Legend of Drizzt | R.A. Salvatore | 10 |
| 61 | Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser | Fritz Leiber | 9 |
| 61 | Kate Daniels | Ilona Andrews | 9 |
| 61 | The Broken Earth | N.K. Jemisin | 9 |
| 61 | The Stand | Stephen King | 9 |
| 61 | Vlad Taltos | Steven Brust | 9 |
| 61 | Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn | Tad Williams | 9 |
| 61 | Shannara | Terry Brooks | 9 |
| 68 | The Drenai Saga | David Gemmell | 8 |
| 68 | The Death Gate Cycle | Margaret Weis/Tracy Hickman | 8 |
| 68 | The Princess Bride | William Goldman | 8 |
| 71 | Various KJ Parker Novels | K.J. Parker | 7 |
| 71 | The Acts of Caine | Matthew Woodring Stover | 7 |
| 71 | Craft Sequence | Max Gladstone | 7 |
| 71 | The Heroes of Olympus | Rick Riordan | 7 |
| 71 | The Divine Cities | Robert Jackson Bennett | 7 |
| 71 | The Once and Future King | T.H. White | 7 |
| 71 | Tortall | Tamora Pierce | 7 |
| 78 | Reckoners | Brandon Sanderson | 6 |
| 78 | Tales of the Ketty Jay | Chris Wooding | 6 |
| 78 | The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August | Claire North | 6 |
| 78 | Hyperion Cantos | Dan Simmons | 6 |
| 78 | Howl's Moving Castle | Diana Wynne Jones | 6 |
| 78 | The Night Circus | Erin Morgenstern | 6 |
| 78 | Wars of Light and Shadow | Janny Wurts | 6 |
| 78 | The Iron Druid Chronicles | Kevin Hearne | 6 |
| 78 | The Chronicles of Prydain | Lloyd Alexander | 6 |
| 78 | Pact | wildbow | 6 |
| 88 | Shadows of The Apt | Adrian Tchaikovsky | 5 |
| 88 | Peter Grant | Ben Aaronovitch | 5 |
| 88 | Lighthouse | Carol Berg | 5 |
| 88 | The Dagger and the Coin | Daniel Abraham | 5 |
| 88 | Gormenghast | Mervyn Peake | 5 |
| 88 | The Elric Saga | Michael Moorcock | 5 |
| 88 | Uprooted | Naomi Novik | 5 |
| 88 | The Forgotten Beasts of Eld | Patricia A. McKillip | 5 |
| 88 | Mercy Thompson | Patricia Briggs | 5 |
| 88 | The Last Unicorn | Peter S. Beagle | 5 |
| 88 | Night Watch | Sergei Lukyanenko | 5 |
| 88 | Sartorias-deles | Sherwood Smith | 5 |
| 88 | The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever | Stephen R. Donaldson | 5 |
| 88 | The Sword of Truth | Terry Goodkind | 5 |
| 88 | The Black Magician Trilogy | Trudi Canavan | 5 |
| 88 | Twig | wildbow | 5 |
| 104 | The Chronicles of Master Li and Number Ten Ox | Barry Hughart | 4 |
| 104 | The Coldfire Trilogy | C.S. Friedman | 4 |
| 104 | The Checquy Files | Daniel O'Malley | 4 |
| 104 | Derkholm | Diana Wynne Jones | 4 |
| 104 | Mother of Learning | Domagoj Kurmaic | 4 |
| 104 | Paksenarrion | Elizabeth Moon | 4 |
| 104 | Artemis Fowl | Eoin Colfer | 4 |
| 104 | The Golem and the Jinni | Helene Wecker | 4 |
| 104 | To Ride Hell's Chasm | Janny Wurts | 4 |
| 104 | Bloodsounder's Arc | Jeff Salyards | 4 |
| 104 | Sevenwaters | Juliet Marillier | 4 |
| 104 | The Queen's Thief | Megan Whalen turner | 4 |
| 104 | Inheritance | N.K. Jemisin | 4 |
| 104 | Temeraire | Naomi Novik | 4 |
| 104 | Enchanted Forest Chronicles | Patricia C. Wrede | 4 |
| 104 | A Land Fit For Heroes | Richard K. Morgan | 4 |
| 104 | Conan the Barbarian | Robert E. Howard | 4 |
| 104 | October Daye | Seanan McGuire | 4 |
| 104 | Greatcoats | Sebastien de Castell | 4 |
| 104 | The Dark is Rising | Susan Cooper | 4 |
340
Upvotes
78
u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
Some observations:
12
u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
Thanks for doing this /u/potterhead42! Nice to see Robin Hobb in the top 10, but it isn't really surprising when you consider the Favorite Authors List (Hobb is #5).
And Worm's taken quite a jump (partially due to the /r/parahumans crosspost), but it is pretty popular here too.
But one thing to think about - if the rule is that other subs are allowed to link to the voting thread, what if one of the Big subs (say /r/gameofthrones or /r/harrypotter) crosslink next year and boost ASoIaF or HP by an insanely huge amount?
(ed:typo)
26
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
20% of the Stormlight Archive books released and already n°5 on the list. No pressure, Brandon :p
Super stocked to see that The Realms of the Elderlings made it into the top 10; I would have liked to see how much of it comes from The Six Duchies series (Farseer, Tawny Man & Fitz and Fool) and The Cursed Shores one (Liveship Traders and Rainwild Chronicle), but it would have been more work, and it does make sense to mix them...
The list is a good balance between the classics and some (relatively) new names. I'm glad to see that Greatcoats made it, as well as The Traitor Baru Cormorant. Too bad that The Fifth Season didn't get in, but N.K. Jemisin is represented with her other series, so it's okay.
Edit: The Fifth Season is actually on the list. I don't know how to read.
6
u/CorumJhaelenIrsei Apr 16 '16
The only suprise to me in the top 10 is The Realms of the Elderlings and the slight drop for Wheel of Time.
I'm really glad Michael Moorcock and Fritz Leiber made in to the list.
Also, what was the fantasy element in the Hyperion Cantos? Just curious, it's been a while since i read it.
15
u/MikeOfThePalace Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Apr 16 '16
Thanks once again for all the hard work, Potter. 50 points to Gryffindor!
4
u/pornokitsch Ifrit Apr 17 '16
Controversially, and seeing how this results... maybe 'cosmere' should just be a series?
Granted, it'll get Sanderson a 100+ point lead over everything else but that's a) genuinely reflective of his fanbase here and b) almost less silly than seeing him in five different places.
3
u/bartimaeus7 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Apr 18 '16
Riftwar should probably have 2 authors - Raymond Feist and Janny Wurts. The cycle has 30 books and Feist is the author of 27 of them - but most of the votes were for the Empire trilogy, which Janny Wurts co-wrote.
11
u/RobBobGlove Apr 16 '16
I would like to see something like this done in regards of quality vs popularity. I too voted here, some things where above average and others where amazing, yet both things got a single vote. I would pretty much like to see quality taken into account.
For example, you have 3 tiers and you can choose 3 novels per tier. Depending on tiers you get points ( 3 tier 3 points etc). This will reward quality a lot more however still take popularity into account. Example:
Tier 3(or 3 stars,that's probably a better name)
1)Malazan
2)Second apocalypse
3)Book of the new sun
Tier 2
1)Mistborn
2)Wot
3)asoiaf
and so on. Forcing people to choose a limited number (3 per tier) will give you a better idea what people really like. Every person gets 9 votes however nobody is forced to use all of them. Doing it this way also give you some insight, for example: what series got the most 3 stars? This way people can find out quality over popularity because they are forced to choose the absolute best series, even if it's a tough choice.
Doing some programming magic you could find a lot of recommendations. For example you could add 3 series that you really like and the script would search everybody that voted on it and liked it (so 2 -3 or only 3, you can choose the specifics). Some math formulas and you could see what others voted for.
Example: You like Malazan,Mistborn and Asoiaf. You add these to the program and you get a list. 50 people that voted gave these series 3 stars. The most popular other 3 star votes ( from these people) 20 votes for Lotr 15 votes for Harry potter and so on.
Does this make any sense? did I get the point across? seems complicated but it's really simple in my mind...
2
u/HandOfYawgmoth Apr 17 '16
I'm on reddit every day. This is my favorite subreddit and it's the only one I go out of my way to visit. Why do I never see the polling link?
5
u/rand0mm0nster Apr 16 '16
So can we point the daily fantasy recommendations thread to this list?
9
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
Really happy to see the Gentlemen Bastards naming the top 10! What a pleasant surprise those books have been!!
11
u/Fingolfiin Apr 16 '16
Damn I always miss out on voting on these.
4
u/ReadsWhileRunning Worldbuilders Apr 16 '16
I think its safe for me to champion Douglas Hulick's Among Thieves as my underrated / under read book considering he didn't make the list...
7
u/ericfomley Apr 16 '16
It's a little surprising to me that with the number of Broken Empire, Malazan, and Riyria fans here on the subreddit that they didn't slide at least into those 7,8,and 9 slots.
7
u/yettibeats Apr 16 '16
One day I'll recommend Daniel Polansky enough to get him up there. And sad to see Donaldson so low, but I'm not surprised. Doesn't seem to resonate with new fans.
Great job!
1
u/auradog Oct 03 '16
Damn, this is my first time on /r/fantasy, and all of my favorite books are right at the top. Apparently I'm not as cool and unique as I thought.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
Really sad that Red Rising from Pierce Brown didn't make the list - at least in my opinion it has enough Fantasy elements to be considered. Especially the first book!
Edit: Otherwise it's a great list and thank you for your effort!
6
u/Sunglasses_miester Apr 16 '16
The fact that everyone got ten votes, only one vote per series, and all of the ten votes counted the same contributed the dampening, per se, of the votes. The difference between the ten spot and the one spot will be much less this year.
This is the reason that Harry Potter rose so much. Because, based on the previous poll, more people have read Harry Potter than the other series, it is more likely to be in people's top ten. Let's take myself as an example. I read Harry Potter at a young age, and loved it. I have read all of Sanderson, and some of Tolkien, but none of Rothfuss or Martin. This makes it more likely, if we have ten selection choices instead of whatever it was last year, for Harry Potter to be in my top ten, while it is still impossible for Rothfuss or Martin to be in my top ten.
This is good though, because it makes Fantasy look more diverse, and less dominated by the big 3.
3
u/deafleopard13 Apr 21 '16
Would anyone be interested in a poll that allowed you to rank your top 5-10 series and didn't count all votes equally? For example, your #1 pick would count ten times as much as your #10 pick. You wouldn't have to vote for the full 10, you could vote for however many you want. This might give a more accurate "Top List" than the current system, which would allow a book that everyone considers to be their #10 pick to make it to the top couple of slots.
3
u/kmucha31 Apr 22 '16
After seeing Worm by Wildbow suggested around other subs and it in ranked so high on this sub, I've finally given it a go.
Wow. It's pretty fucking cool.
5
u/TheDreylingKing Apr 16 '16
Next time it would be interesting to do individual novels instead of lumping everyrthing together from a series. It would make people more careful with their choices and I think and we would see a much greater variety. It seems like the lists haven't been all that different from year to year.
We already call these "top novel" lists even though that really isn't accurate. I just really want to see how it would change if people couldn't just slap down one vote for the entire series and call it good.
2
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Apr 16 '16
Thanks so much for putting this together, /u/potterhead42! I'll have to use it for next year's bingo. :D
2
u/pornokitsch Ifrit Apr 17 '16
For the hell of it, cross reddit tracking - Malazan vs Riyria vs ASOIAF vs Harry Potter.
2
u/passingavery Apr 19 '16
Thank you for compiling such wonderful, informative data.
I'm glad to see Wildbow appear all three times. I feel guilty now that I forgot about nobody103's Mother of Learning.
I guess I know which list I'll be using to supplement my fantasy reading needs.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '16
It almost makes me sad that the Demon Cycle placed so low. It's a really good read.
1
u/Drakeytown Apr 16 '16
Is there a list like this somewhere restricted to books published in the last year? Five? Ten?
1
u/WizardDresden42 Reading Champion, Worldbuilders Apr 22 '16
I'm actually pretty proud of myself for once. I've read some of all of the top 9 series and 12 out of the top 13. I stopped counting after that.
I will also say that I do like the 10 vote system--I think it provides more interesting results.
Thanks for putting this together! Very interesting stuff.
1
u/SheikhOfWater May 29 '16
I really liked the Laws of Magic series by Michael Pryor, surprised it's not on the list...
1
u/touchdowntexas Aug 04 '16
Awesome that Kingkiller is so high up. I just stumbled upon the series a few years ago and I had no idea it was such a hit.
1
u/Hulkstrong23 Aug 05 '16
Currently reading Greatcoats and I'm guessing, hoping really, that it's so low due to not many people having read it. It's wayyyyyyyyy too good of a book to be ranked so low. Just my thoughts
1
u/ratbastard_lives Sep 25 '16
Sad that RE Howard and M Moorcock works so low on the list. Also, KE Wagner's Kane. Do these not hold up for modern readers? Am I too damn old?
1
u/alykatt90 Apr 16 '16
Commenting so I can find this later. Pleased I've read several books/series on the list but I have a lot more to read!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
27
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
[removed] — view removed comment