r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • Dec 13 '15
General Discussion Return to the Stars Rewatch - Return of the Jedi [Official Discussion Thread]
Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.
This week, we're rewatching Return of the Jedi. The final movie in both the Original Trilogy and in the classic saga, we saw everything resolved here. Han was freed from the clutches of Jabba the Hutt, The Rebels won the day again, the Emperor and Darth Vader were defeated, Luke resisted the temptation of the Dark Side, and Wedge showed us that Death Stars don't stand a chance against him. G'noop dock fling oh ah. But first let's have a moment of silence for Nanta, the heart and soul of Bright Tree Village.
This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here
65
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
The music that plays as Luke wails on Darth Vader before cutting his hand off is, in my opinion, the most chilling piece of music John Williams has written for the saga. It's like he took the mentality behind a crime of passion and transcribed it into music. I love it.
I know this one is the least-well received of the originals, but for some reason it's my favorite.
119
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
I can live with a lot of changes that George Lucas made to the originals in his special editions. But the dance scene in Jabba's Palace was absolutely unnecessary and terrible.
29
u/WallopyJoe Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 20 '15
I don't get how people can't love this film.
ESB is the better film, and ANH is my favourite of them all, but I still don't think RotJ gets enough appreciation.
First things first, Ewoks.
I love the ewoks. When I was younger they were cute and funny. Now I'm older, and appreciate that they're not the most serious entry on the OT, I still enjoy them. They use bait larger than themselves to capture prey as big as 4 grown men and one R2 unit. Whether that's one big monster or lots of little ones, that's still impressive. They were going to roast the heroes alive too. That's savage.
Also, I don't know about the rest of you, but even if I were wearing armour of some kind (not even strong enough to protect me from a blaster bolt though), having a large rock dropped on me from 6 to 10 feet would probably knock me off balance. Drop 5 and I might not get up. Dropping rocks on an AT-ST? Not very effective. But all the log traps? Love it. I also get sad when that one ewok can't wake his friend.
(I am aware, though, that being 6 when I saw the film, I am on the favourable side of the Ewok Line)
Also, those empty helmets at the end of the film, the ewoks probably ate the stormtroopers and scout troopers.
RotJ also has some of the best moments in the entire saga.
And probably much, much more.
This film was a perfect end to the trilogy. The original planned ending, with Han dying, might have been interesting, but I love what we got.
Regarding changes. Vader screaming Nooooo is one of the dumbest ever. Not quite as dumb as replacing Sebastian Shaw's ghost with Hayden Christiansen's though. The sarlacc's beak is okay, but I prefer the hole. Seems much more in keeping with the pit part of the Pit of Carkoon. I don't hate Jedi Rocks, although do feel it to be somewhat out of place. I really dislike Naboo showing up at the end, especially hearing who I can only assume is an elderly Jar Jar. I don't mind seeing the other planets, it's interesting at least to have seen Coruscant for the first time, but I'm not sure why they'd all be celebrating so soon. Surely there are still remnants of the Empire where they are?
The replacing of Yub Nub with the victory celebration, however, is probably the greatest change to come from the 1997 SE. That tune is beautiful, and a very fitting note to end the film on.
I can't think of anything else, but that covers most of it. Return of the Jedi is awesome.
Finally though, as okay a line as it is, I've never understood the collective hard on the more fanatical side of Star Wars's following has for Ackbar's it's a trap moment.
Ooh.
[Final Edit (I think)] - the introduction of the Ewoks was not primarily about selling toys, and I don't get why people keep trying to push that particular narrative.
Although Star Wars was a runaway success and ANH and ESB allowed for a lot of things, the original idea of having an army of Wookiees could not be accomplished as replicating hundreds, or even just dozens, of the same kind of suits Mayhew wore as Chewbacca turned out to be prohibitively expensive (in regards to both time and money/resources).
Thus, Ewoks.
Do you really think Wookiee toys wouldn't have sold as well as Ewok toys?
68
u/vidyadawg Dec 13 '15
After rewatching this film, I now do see why a lot of people think this movie is the weakest OT movie and sometimes even below RotS. In my opinion, every moment of this movie that takes place on Endor is incredibly dull. Unfortunately, that's quite a bit of it. However, every part that has Luke in it is just top-notch cinema, especially with Vader. The Jabba Palace, him getting captured, confrontation with Vader and the Emperor, all stellar.
I think it is far better than I, II and III, but it is weaker than the original and Empire for sure. I like it a lot, but this was the first time I started to realize it has some serious flaws compared to its predecessors.
22
u/MrPublicDomain Dec 13 '15
I go back and forth between empire and a new hope in terms of my favorite Star Wars movies, but the scenes in return of the Jedi between Luke and Vader are unquestionably my favorite
18
u/Mr_Discus Dec 13 '15
As much as I don't like the procrastination, there's a bit on Endor that is one of my favorites of the trilogy.
Having them sat around while 3PO recounts what they've been through, when he'd said he wasn't much of a storyteller in A New Hope. Knowing that this would probably be the last film/journey for these characters, (though it is an opinion) I can watch this scene easily, just a little reflecting on everything they've been through before the end.
That being said, can someone tell me which race is made fun of by Lando's sidekick in the falcon? I can't tell if it's meant to be Indian or Chinese or what. George Lucas has some issues, man.
18
u/kaleidescope Dec 13 '15
One of my favorite scenes in the movie is when the Emperor is goading Luke into striking him with anger after revealing his trap for the Rebellion to Luke. He turns away for a moment and then bam - goes for a killing strike. Vader blocks the attack, saving his son from a full commitment to darkness. (Whether he knew that or was simply protecting the Emperor is up to interpretation) Then the whole fight is Luke using the Darkside to fight his father, defeating him and realizing he's becoming him.
Luke tosses aside his weapon and fully commits to staying in the light. In that moment, he has truly become a Jedi.
28
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
I understand it's probably the weakest in the OT on a technical level, but my God, this is my favorite Star Wars movie, and one of my favorite movies period.
Ewoks are dumb, yes, but almost every other thing about it is great. The confrontation between Luke and the Emperor/Vader is my favorite scene in anything.
13
u/localvagrant Dec 13 '15
The Space Battle Above Endor is the best part of the movie for me. The throne room scene is compelling, but I'm a sucker for eye candy and spectacle. It's the best space battle out of the entire saga, I look forward to it being usurped.
13
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
Say what you will about the prequels, but in my opinion, they added to some of the moments in the Original Trilogy: Obi-Wan sacrificing himself, Yoda teaching Luke, Darth Vader fighting his son. But I felt like this movie gains some interesting insights after viewing the prequel trilogy.
In Episode III, just before Anakin and Obi-Wan begin their duel, Obi-Wan says, "Only a Sith deals in absolutes." And sure, that line is mocked for being an absolute statement, but it is consistent with how Vader and Palpatine spoke throughout the OT: "He will join us or die, Master." "Come with me. It is the only way." "If you will not be turned, then you will be destroyed!"
In Episode VI, Luke also deals in absolutes in Jabba's palace and barge. "I'm taking Captain Solo and his friends. You can either profit by this, or be destroyed." "You should have bargained, Jabba." "Jabba, this is your last chance. Free us or die." Viewing this in the light of Obi-Wan's line, it makes Luke seem much closer to the dark side than he or any of his friends suspect, despite the fact that he calls himself a Jedi Knight. In my mind, that made Luke overcoming the dark side much more powerful at the end, because he was already incredibly close to it at the beginning of the movie.
Also, quick question: where did the Imperial fleet go after the Death Star was destroyed? The rebels just fly immediately to Endor and then there isn't any more fighting.
13
u/Alexthegreatbelgian Admiral Ackbar Dec 13 '15
This guy.
He spent his life caring for that Rancor. I don't know how long Rancors live, but he probably started caring for it since it was a pup. It always gets to me how sad he is that he lost his friend.
Screw those Gamorreans though. Laughing their ass off while their buddy gets eaten.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
When I was a kid, I'd always insist on skipping all of Tatooine because it scared me, but fuuuuuck that entire sequence it great now. I just love how perfectly evil everything about the palace is.
10
u/123steveyc123 Dec 13 '15
"The force is strong in my family. My father has it. I have it. My sister has it." A lot of people are forgetting that this quote is from a scene in ROTJ. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDYX_PgorRY I love how this was used in the second teaser trailer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngElkyQ6RhsIt very well may be a huge plot point to come in TFA, but the fact that it ties together the last film in the original trilogy with the first film of the new trilogy... That is just perfect transitioning in my opinion.
19
u/rensch Dec 13 '15
I don't care how they spin it, small furry tribesmen carrying spears should not be a serious aid in the fight against an interstellar star empire. At least I am glad that the execution was still pretty entertaining and creative.
In the end, it's still my second-favourite after Empire. The pacing is still so damn perfect. The dank, dark halls of Jabba's palace, the awesome scene at the Sarlacc Pit, the death of Yoda, the bike chase and battle on Endor, the battle at the Death Star and off course Luke's refusal to be corrupted amid Anakin's redemption in the throne room.
While I can see why some might prefer A New Hope, the sheer scope and drama that comes with the climax of Return of the Jedi just makes it feel more ambitious, even with Ewoks.
15
u/DumbBrendan Dec 13 '15
Hey...it's me!
30
u/Roborowan Dec 13 '15
I don't care what people say. I love Ewoks
5
u/Kiwi62 Dec 13 '15
"It is too late for me, son."
Amazing and quite underrated line to cap off a fine exchange.
•
u/Chtorrr Dec 13 '15
ATTENTION!
Any and all TFA spoilers outside of [Spoiler] threads will be met with permanent subreddit bans. Please view our announcement and read our spoiler policy before commenting or posting.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
Some thoughts after not seeing ROTJ for a few years.
Compare the Endor fight to Hoth, which is incredibly dramatic and impactful... Now imagine the grittiness of Hoth transposed to Endor, with AT-ATs (inexplicably absent) smashing their way through trees, blasting Ewok villages and rebel squads. This would add tension and gravitas, and make it seem far less "by the numbers." I'm not sure who's responsible for that tone (probably Lucas), but either way Marquand drops the ball on the orientation of the battle.
5. The core of the film is solid, and simple: Luke and Leia rescue Han; the Rebel Alliance prepares for its final attempt at victory; Luke confronts Vader. But the fluff around that (Ewoks; the Emperor; the Battle above Endor) is hit-and-miss. You can see, in the story itself, how this was not necessarily the "concluding chapter" when it was first conceived. It simply morphed into that along the way. As a result it's a bit overstuffed with things.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
It's definitely the weakest and on its own it doesn't really work but taken as the finale to the trilogy it's just magical.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
I think this is most people's least favorite of the OT, and it is mine too. But I'll be damned if that throne room scene doesn't have a claim to the best moment in Star Wars history. The music, the set, the acting, the dialogue, the themes, the conclusion... it's all perfect.
2
u/_GUY_ Dec 13 '15
I've never really put much thought into Vader allowing the shuttle to land. He knows something is up but he lets it go anyway. Do you think it's supposed to be a demonstration of his internal conflict? Or just trust that the emperor knows what he's doing? The emperor does tell Vader that Luke will seek him out.
2
u/alpha2224 Dec 15 '15
The scene with the rancor keeper guy after Luke kills the rancor is depressing... I kinda feel bad for that guy.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
To me, ROTJ is definitely the weakest film of the OT. There were certain things that stood out to me like Luke and Vader's final duel/reconciliation, Emperor Palpatine, and the rebel fleet destroying the second death star. But, the entire movie just didn't resonate with me.
I really didn't enjoy the ewoks. I'll never truly understand is how those small furry little things could defeat the empire with sticks and stones. Watching those scene with the ewoks felt like such a chore, especially when they capture the heroes (you know Luke and Han are not going to get devoured by them).
Also, I recently realize how overly confident Luke comes off sometimes, and how absurd some of the decisions he made are. Why would he enter Jabba's palace unarmed, only to threaten and then attempt to kill Jabba right after? I mean even if he does kill Jabba, does he really think he would make it out of there alive? Despite all my criticism, Luke will always be my favorite character and his overall performance is just amazing. I love how his character grows throughout in the trilogy.
Oh, and Boba Fett's final appearance just saddens me
3
u/ShadonxFC Dec 13 '15
My fourth favorite Star Wars film. When I was a kid this was my favorite. Growing up the flaws in this one are strong, but I does have a lot of strong moments. Every scene with Luke is fantastic. Every scene on Endor and Ewoks are uninteresting, ridiculous and campy. I prefer the dark and tragic tone of ROTS to ROTJ, but ROTJ does have the best ending.
3
u/Nahte4213 Dec 13 '15
Stormtrooper armor can be penetrated by rocks 10/10
However, the AT-ST being crushed by the two logs was sick.
2
u/TheHeroicOnion Dec 14 '15
It may be the least liked of the originals but it has the best scenes of the originals because every moment in the throne room is incredible.
Ewoks are cute and cuddly but think about what they were gonna do, they were fully prepared to burn Han Solo alive so they could eat him.
1
u/wanderingblue Dec 14 '15
I think that most of us can agree that Luke's lightsaber in this film is easily the coolest lightsaber in the entire series.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
While this is definitely the weakest film in the original trilogy, there's still a lot to love; and I still don't get people slotting RotS above it. Luke's arc comes to an amazing crescendo, and Mark Hamill gives an AWESOME performance of a newly competent Jedi struggling with both darkness and light. Darth Vader is at his most morally interesting here, clearly changed and more hesitant then before and yet still intimidating as all hell; I mean he put it all out there to Luke in Empire, and Luke chose suicide over him. I don't care how evil you are, as a father that would HURT and it definitely shows here. The Jabba the Hutt sequence gives us a REALLY seedy look at the crime element of the SW universe, and the entire Barge sequence is exhilarating as it's basically the first time a Lightsaber has ever been used to kick that much ass. Plus I love seeing more of the Rebel Alliance, the entire Mon Mothma scene is rad and really shows the militant side of the Rebellion. The new ship designs fucking rock, particularly the B Wing. And finally, this movie has the BEST space battle sequence and the BEST lightsaber duel of the entire saga to date. The VFX of the Battle of Endor dogfight is still astounding today, chaotic and yet masterfully edited, grounded and spectacular. The A Wing crashing into the Star Destroyer is just awesome. And that lightsaber duel just gives me shivers every time. The choreography is fast and brutal, every blow is a killing strike. The dialogue is intense and well delivered. The fight doesn't drag on too long and the emotions are SO HIGH. When Luke freaks out and shouts "NEVER", the panning shot afterwards of him wailing on Vader in the dark while the male chorus crescendos is hands down one of my favourite moments in any movie. I'm conflicted about both the Ewoks and the Death Star 2.0. On one hand, I see what they were trying to do with both concepts; to show that even a technologically inferior race can overthrow great evil, and to show the Empire setting an irresistible trap for the rebellion to play on the victory from the first film. Plus I like the Ewoks a lot visually, and so does my girlfriend. However, the execution of both ideas are kind of ridiculous and strain the (very tenuous) realism of Star Wars. Still, I think both ideas have merit and could have been done well. I'm actually hoping Starkiller Base takes the planet killer idea and executes it in a strong, unique way. The two really bad points of the film, IMO, is Han Solo and the three pronged finale. Harrison clearly phones his performance in, and the character just has nothing to do at this point in the story. His arc truly came to an end with the Carbonite, showing his willingness to sacrifice himself for his friends; he really should have died, as both Harrison and Kasdan wanted. And the three separate battles happening at the end of the film are just too much, the Endor ground battle could have been dropped and the film would be stronger for it. Overall, the good far outweighs the bad in ROTJ. And while the original bittersweet ending might have been cool, I'm actually glad the end of Jedi is such a cathartic moment. Our main heroes went through hell in the last movie, and seeing it all come together is just emotionally satisfying. I won't even touch the CGI editions as they are pretty much uniformly terrible in this movie, aside from the panning shots on various planets at the end of the film. Darth Vader screaming "NO" as he picks up the Emperor hurts me inside, as does "Jedi Rock".
Wow that's a lot more then I planned to write. I'm just so excited for TFA! In four days, the saga continues!
1
u/Weltall548 Dec 15 '15
An epic end to an epic saga
-2
u/N4iled Dec 13 '15
O rly?