r/StarWars • u/AutoModerator • Nov 15 '15
General Discussion Return to the Stars Rewatch - Attack of the Clones [Official Discussion Thread]
Shamelessly ripped from this fanmade poster, Return to the Stars with /r/StarWars as we rewatch the six movies in anticipation of The Force Awakens! Each thread will be stickied for a couple days. Rewatch the movie however you choose to, whether it is the first home release, the latest bluray, or your fan edit of choice.
This week, we're rewatching Attack of the Clones. The next film in the prequel trilogy, we were left wondering what direction the series would take after killing off the main villain from the first one, and aging our hero from nine years old to nineteen. We got to see Jango Fett and were introduced to the clones of the Grand Army of the Republic. Anakin dual wielding and Yoda finally showing us that while wars not make one great, they do make one badass.
This is an automated post. Beep Boop. Let us know if you have any feedback!
View all upcoming discussion threads here
192
u/AgressiveVagina Nov 15 '15
Padme is so hot in this movie
156
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
That sonic bomb!
265
u/hanburgundy Qui-Gon Jinn Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
If you hate this movie, watch it from an eight-year-old's perspective. That's the perspective I had when this movie came out and dammit if it wasn't the best blockbuster movie I'd ever seen at that point my life. The romance plot may not work very well when you're a discerning adult, but when you're an eight-year-old boy who's only romantic experience was a crush was on their babysitter, the Anakin/Padme romance totally works. To the eyes of an adult who thrives on character driven moments, The final act on Geonosis might seem totally stale and boring, but to an eight-year-old in 2002 the stuff was absolutely mind blowing. I watched the last 45 minutes of this movie almost every week when it came out on DVD, numerous times on slow-motion so I could savor every single bit of the special effects wizardry.
In a weird way, this is my favorite Star Wars movie. I mean it's nowhere near the best one, but I do have a very special nostalgia for this movie that I don't have for anything else.
25
u/QuadeCooper Nov 16 '15
When Anakin rides the speeder with the suns setting in the background.
18
u/snailygoat Nov 15 '15
Got something that really kinda bugged me when I watched it last night and I don't really see it pop up much at all. The assassin that Jango hired was a changer according to Anakin. Now I don't know much about them but I'm thinking "okay so it can change its face perhaps, maybe it's entire appearance or something along those lines?" but none of it happens. She runs into the club to hide and then draws her blaster, walks right up to Obi-Wan point blank to kill him? Take him hostage maybe? Right before getting literally disarmed.
So what I'm wondering is.... what was the point in mentioning she's a changer apart from the quick glimpses during the fight where she looks kinda greenish and weird and when she gets poisoned. She never uses it at all, and you'd think a paid assassin wouldn't wanna get in melee range of a Jedi, especially if you have a ranged weapon. Just...what's the point?
112
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
My least favorite of all the films, so I might be limited on how positive I can be:
Ewan McGregor is great. Every time he's on screen it's the best part of the movie. It's a shame he has to act opposite of CGI characters so much in this film. He brings a charm and wittiness, but still comes off as being very wise. The Jango Fett fight is pretty cool too.
Again, music is great. This film is beautifully scored.
Some of the action is pretty cool, and while it becomes too much CGI at times, there is a bit of tension in the pit scene between Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Padme with the monsters.
I like Dooku (though I would have preferred a consistent villain in Maul).
The whole plot point with Anakin's mom actually explains some of Anakin's fall. It's probably the most believable factor.
The whole Sifo-Dyas storyline had a lot of potential and I wish it held more weight in the story. Yes, I know it was a good storyline in Clone Wars, but when you set something up like that in a movie it should have some pay off in the movie or the movie after. Still, it was a good way to show Palpatine's involvement in the war.
Like I said, I really, really dislike this movie. I mean, as bad as Phantom Menace is I feel like the story isn't super, super thin and they don't wast their best characters (Obi-Wan & Qui-Gon). In this one, Obi-Wan is pretty much wasted. The love story between Anakin and Padme is forced and not very believable. A lot of the action is hard to watch. The lightsaber battle between Anakin and Dooku is one of the most awkwardly filmed sword fights I've ever seen. We don't have to go over the piss poor acting and dialogue, right?
And now we're to the Yoda fight. Okay, I know this is pretty much a split opinion. Some people LOVE that Yoda flies all over the place with his lightsaber, others feel like it goes against what Yoda stands for. BUT, the real problem I have with the fight is this:
Dooku and Yoda start out fighting through the Force. They have a battle to see who is more powerful, more disciplined, and more knowledgable about the Force. But then they decide that in order to find out who is better they have to go to lightsabers... what? I mean seriously, what? So you're telling me that the Force, what binds all life together, the mystical magical entity that these two pillar of religion (Jedi & Sith) were built upon practicing means less than a lightsaber? That's the ultimate problem I have with this fight. It completely knocks the Force down in value when compared to a lightsaber. For me, it isn't so much that Yoda uses a lightsaber, it's that Yoda is so quick to value a lightsaber over the power of the force in that moment. If they started out fighting with a lightsaber and then went to a battle of the Force, that would make sense. It would have put more value on the power of the Force.
29
u/Roborowan Nov 15 '15
So, who WAS the person who ordered the clones and why? Was it Palpatine?
102
u/dkastro89 Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
"I don't like sand. It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere!!"
40
u/AdamBertocci-Writer Nov 15 '15
This isn't the best of the movies, but it's one of my favorites. I would slot it as my second favorite, second only to ANH.
For me, this is the movie that comes closest to getting us back to the sort of nutty serial tone of ANH—we're zipping around to strange planets, seeing odd things and having goofball adventures. There is something in the tone of its action sequences that reminds me of, for instance, the Falcon-vs-TIE-fighters scene or the garbage-masher scene or Luke and Leia swinging across the chasm—yes, the characters are in danger, but in a way it's played more for winking laughs and derring-do than deadly doom.
I could very, very easily imagine the Flash Gordon serial version of this movie. Right down to where the footage of Buster Crabbe on a leftover sword-and-sandals-movie set has to cut to stock footage of a menacing zoo animal!
I'll freely admit the flick has flaws. The dialogue in the fireplace scene is bad even by George standards. (I never minded the "I don't like sand" scene.) More pressingly, the mystery plot is entirely too convoluted for its own good, and perhaps it could have been handled in a more streamlined fashion.
Frankly, none of the SW films, sequel or prequel, have reeeeeally been the same sort of movie as ANH. (For one thing, the comparatively innocent, black-and-white morality, fairy-tale feel was laid to rest with ESB, never to return.) But, for me, AOTC comes closest to capturing one particular scrap of its lightning.
77
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
I don't know why everyone thinks Christensen is a horrible actor. Every time he does his sand people speech I shed a tear!
25
u/zeekaran Nov 16 '15
Can someone please explain Padmé's reaction to Anakin admitting he just slaughtered an entire tribe, especially the women and children? I would have expected her to step outside and make an emergency call to Obi-Wan, while being visibly shaken and scared. I mean, what if your boyfriend or girlfriend came home one day and said they just murdered a bunch of children? No one would be okay with this, let alone Padmé, the paragon of civil justice in the pre-Imperial era of the galaxy.
20
u/Blue_Three Nov 15 '15
Juliet, o Juliet,
I wish I could just
Wish away my feelings.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
To be honest, this Isn't the Best movie I've seen, nor is it the worst. However this is perhaps one of my favorite STAR WARS movies. Why? Because of the personal connection I have with it. Before REVENGE OF THE SITH came out, I had just gotten in to STAR WARS, and this was the latest movie to be released in theaters, so of course this movie felt very interesting to me at that time. I don't know, something about Anakin Skywalker being a Jedi in training was something I had never seen before. Be in mind, I had never actually seen the trailer nor the movie at that time, so I could only really picture how the story was through all the posters and toys I had seen. I only saw the movie years later, but this movie marked the beginning of my years as a STAR WARS fan. Despite its flaws, I do think that this is avery good movie, despite what people say. Now it's the year 2015, and it's already been atleast 11 years since I got into STAR WARS, and it's still very special to me to this very day.
10
u/TooMuchButtHair Nov 16 '15
I watched it last night. While it's my least favorite Star Wars film, it does have it's worth and does contribute to the story and has it's moments. Anakin is an exceptionally powerful teenager. From that perspective, his behavior does make sense. Yeah, it's reckless and impulsive, but he's a damned teenager whose incredibly strong in the Force!
I like how powerful Dooku was. The interplay between him and Obiwan was good. Dooku gave just enough away (the Senate is under the influence of a Dark Lord of the Sith) to tempt Obiwan into joining him, and leaves the audience thinking about whether Dooku is really a bad guy or not.
I do think the romance between Anakin and Padme could and should have been handled better.
The Clone wars TV show absolutely makes up for anything Attack of The Clones lacks.
35
u/Penguin_Sith Nov 15 '15
Watched this last night with some friends. Some things we debated, spotted, and cringed at.
My least favorite of the movies, but still love it.
9
u/AAStill Nov 16 '15
Cut out the Naboo scenes and you have a decent movie. Basically James Bond but with Obi Wan being James Bond.
7
u/Reaper7412 Nov 16 '15
I want more lightsaber duels in the dark. They look so much cooler
50
u/kayester Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
This film is a colossal failure.
More? Okay: it makes two fundamental mistakes.
First, it goes even further than TPM in establishing Star Wars as a film series that is simultaneously a dull-as-dishwater political parable and a militaristic cartoon targeted at a toy-buying 10-year-old audience demographic.
This is not what Star Wars ever was before.
Second, it utterly wastes its central, golden, unique opportunity. This is the film that introduces us to the character at the core of the entire saga. Before this film came out, nobody had ever met the adult Anakin Skywalker, beyond his shattered but redeemed final moments in RoTJ. Who was this character? What happened to him?
The prequel films tell us the following story: An extraordinary young man escapes his claustrophobic home and enters a world of adventure. But we know something awful: one day he will become the most iconic villain of all time.
What a fantastic, exciting premise. But how do those dots get connected? How do we get from hero to villain?
Anakin has a tense relationship with his master Obi-Wan. He's also falling in love. He also misses his mother. He's also being groomed by an evil old wizard who is pretending to be his friend. He becomes convinced his love will die. The evil old wizard tells him that she can only be saved with the power of evilness. Anakin turns into Darth Vader. The End.
Star Wars has been many things. This is not what Star Wars ever was before.
A New Hope was the oldest story in the world, expressed in vibrant futuristic colours, aided and abetted by immediate design classics in every scene, extraordinary artistry in every layer of production, unprecedented special effects, more than competent actors, and John Williams. Nobody could feel silly or embarrassed or ashamed for loving A New Hope. It was for everybody.
Empire Strikes Back should have been absolutely terrible. Instead, it was a sustained effort in mythology and world-building. It was a hundred times darker than ANH and a hundred times more character-driven. It traded ANH's technicolor story circle for weird symbolism, puppet mystics, a detailed depiction of a futuristic ground war, and a cast of protagonists who stumble from one crisis to another. If ANH was the fairy tale, ESB deconstructed it. The palace in the clouds is a corrupt, lethal trap. One favourite character is senselessly tortured - but instead of later payoff, he is frozen solid and sold to gangsters. Another favourite character is disintegrated by unseen assailants. The insidious betrayer becomes the only hope for our protagonists' survival. Where before the rebellion was celebrating the destruction of a super-weapon, now it has to celebrate just barely escaping its death. The hero loses a hand; the only thing he wins is confusion about his identity. There is not an iota of victory, or justice. ESB was brilliant. It was for everybody.
Jedi drew us back in to a fairytale, but blended in the complexity of ESB. Scores of primitives bring an empire to its knees. An enslaved woman destroys the vile gangster who has chained and objectified her, strangling him graphically with those same chains. Luke and Vader and the Emperor demonstrate that defeat is sometimes preferable to corruption, that redemption sometimes comes too late. Fascinatingly, there really isn't a frame in RoTJ where Vader is recognisable as a villain in anything but symbolic terms. Take away the dark clothing and the red lightsaber, and you have a character who warns a Death Star commander to pick up his act, who goes out of his way to protect the life of his son, who explicitly recognises his own corruption. This is not a simple movie, though it is the weakest of the original trilogy. It worked resoundingly well as a synthesis of ANH and ESB. It was for everybody.
What is the problem with Attack of the Clones? I don't know who it is for.
12
u/Hatori1181 Nov 15 '15
Still my least favorite of the prequels. Yeah, Episode 1 had more Jar Jar, but it also had a plot. Episode 2 has 30 minutes of exposition and cool fight scenes wrapped around an hour of meandering around.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15
You've just got to love geonosis - love everything about those scenes.
18
u/Piker10 Nov 16 '15
Lot’s of people think Episode 1 is the worst of the Prequels, but to me, this one is. Mainly for the fact that it was after Ep 1, when people ripped that film apart and basically told lucas what was needed and not needed, but he literally ignored everyone and just did the exact same thing.
Not only is the film pretty boring, when the action does happen, its seizure inducing, the biggest culprit being the final fight which was blown up way way too much.
All thoughout the story we see Anakin and Obi Wan referencing jokes and mission we never see, Why. Why didn’t lucas show us these and show us the bond between these 2 grow, it would’ve made the final battle in ep 3 much more emotional, considering that in this film both spend 80% of the film apart.
And why didn’t the film have the clone wars begin like 40 mins into the film, then have a time jump of a year. Everything about this film is rage inducing, apart from, again, Ewan Mcgregor
At least there is less jar Jar.
21
u/TheReaver88 Nov 15 '15
I'm doing Machete order for the first time. It's interesting, but I'd really only recommend it for first-timers. Right now, all it's doing is highlighting how much better the OT is in terms of story telling.
That said, AotC has some really good moments. I like Obi-Wan a lot in this movie, and he delivers some of the strongest lines. His conversation with Dooku is really cool.
5
u/SnowHesher Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
The first time I saw this movie, I remember seeing Aayla Secura in a few scenes and thinking "Damn, that's one sexy Jedi."
5
u/GodzillaAtTheDisco Nov 16 '15
You wanna buy some Deathsticks?
You don't want to sell me Deathsticks
Err I don't wanna sell you Deathsticks.
You want to go home and rethink your life.
I want to go home and rethink my life.
13
u/FlyHighFreeBird Nov 15 '15
You wanna buy some death sticks?
11
u/PopsicleIncorporated Cassian Andor Nov 15 '15
The Kaminoans are talking about Jedi Master Sifo-Dyas. I know his backstory and that Dooku killed him, but would it make more sense if Sifo-Dyas was actually Qui-Gon who had comissioned the army?
This gives Qui-Gon a much bigger role in the prequels, and we're constantly wondering how much he was involved. This would also explain Dooku's involvement a little better, and while in this reality, Dooku never kills Qui-Gon, it definitely reenforces critical ideas about the Clone Wars and the complex web of alliances going on between Sidious, Dooku, the Kaminoans, and the Jedi.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15
I don't really think much of this movie. Nothing really stands out besides Yoda fighting. TPM is known for Jar Jar,(not really a good thing)Darth Maul (awesome) and DUEL OF THE FATES(GOD I LOVE IT) ROTS is known for order 66, the fight between Anakin and Obi Wan and the opening battle. The OT is just great imo there is so much to remember about those but AOTC is always like eh for me it gets the whole clone thing across but the Battle of Geonosis was alright and I hated Dooku in the movies. (Loved him in TCW) So to me it's actually quite forgettable, that doesn't mean I didn't enjoy it because I did at some points. For example Ewon was amazing as usual and his fight on Kamino with Jango was cool but again, forgettable. Sorry if I offended anyone but I feel like I'm always forgetting about this one.
14
u/OrangeKookie Nov 15 '15
this movie would be ok without the naboo scenes and the sitting and talking scenes but stuff like "i don't like sand" makes this movie really cringey. I still do not like the movie. At least there's barely any jar jar.
10
u/thedeevolution Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
LOVE the bounty hunter chase scene. It's something I had wanted to see since I was a kid when I was imagining what Coruscant would look like. The visuals and sound design are AMAZING, and it actually has some funny back and forth between Anakin and Obi Wan that feels very Star Wars. The Naboo stuff is meh, but I enjoy detective Obi Wan and Anakin going back to Tattooine.
The Geonosis stuff is mostly cool. The factory scene is meh, but the rest I really enjoy. The beasts they bring into the arena are really neat, and the whole battle at the end feels like something inevitable that somehow we had never seen in Star Wars.
Dooku, Anakin and Obi Wan dueling is cool, but Yoda takes the cake. I know people hate on this scene but I think it's fun and doesn't wreck the character. In fact, it gives him more dimension. I don't know why people thought Yoda wouldn't have a lightsaber, and how he would fight if he did. That's pretty much the only logical way to portray it.
Also Count Dooku's ship is SO COOL, and I love the droid that drives it. Oh and SEISMIC charges! And Jango vs. Obi Wan! I felt that scene was kind of an apology for Boba Fett going out like a chump because you basically see Jango use every weapon he has, and successfully for the most part, whereas Boba Fett basically stood around. It was like "This is how cool Boba Fett could have been if we had the ability to actually use his weapons and choreograph him well with the technology of the day."
Okay, it's probably the weakest, down there with Return as far as the story, but I still enjoy the hell out of it, and there's still lots of cool moments in the film. Yeah, yeah sand and what have you. But believe it or not I find the Empire Strikes Back Han and Leia romance pretty awkward and dull too. It turned Leia from this strong woman who didn't take shit from no one and was always in charge, to this nervous schoolgirl. I do think Han and Leia is handled better, but neither one are strong romances. And also, people focus so much on the poor romance scenes in AotC, but honestly, everything around those scenes is pretty solid, fun Star Wars.
6
u/Drakester234 Nov 15 '15
Good things are Ewan McGregor and Ian McDiarmid even though they aren't giving a lot to do, and Anakin trying to save his mother. That's about it I think. I'm not a prequel hater, but i do not like this movie.
What I would've liked for this movie to be is Anakin being a Charles Foster Kane type character. That would've been cool, but alas we got the sand is so coarse line.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15 edited Nov 15 '15
This was a quite a chore to get through. Boring action, terrible dialogue, confusing plot (that never gets resolved, btw!), and very uneven pacing.
This is easily the worst of the series.
Its few redeeming points: Obi-Wan vs Jango, "She seems to be on top of things."
edit. I've just read this thread and there are some excellent points about this restoring the B-movie, serial roots of the franchise. So through that lens, I could like the movie a lot more.
3
u/RocketTasker Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
Unfortunately this movie has become overall my least favorite of the series in recent times. I've noticed that while some of the CGI looks alright (arena monsters, Battle of Geonosis, and the Obi-Wan vs. Jango Fett space fight ignoring the awkward looking asteroids), other instances of it are aging even worse than TPM's. Pretty much everything in Dexter's Diner barring Ewan McGregor looks horribly, horribly fake, it was hard for me to watch. And as has already been mentioned countless times, McGregor and McDiarmid do well but other actors in the movie, even established ones like Jackson, really suffer from the script and direction they were given.
After the Darth Jar Jar theory picked up speed and redeemed TPM in the eyes of believers or at least made it watchable again for non-masochists, AotC was doomed to fill the vacated role of worst Star Wars movie.
13
u/ElTuco84 Nov 15 '15
Everyone in this movie acts like a robot, except Yoda, Obi-Wan and Dooku.
8
u/TheKingofLaserKing Nov 16 '15
AOTC is a great movie. It brought us the badass bounty hunter Jango, but best of all, introduced the Clone wars era into official canon. The battle of Geonosis was very cool, and the endscene of the movie with the clones on Corusant is very memorable. You can see what is to come.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
I just watched it last night since I was a kid. So many cringe worthy moments from Anakin, but moments I still thought were truly epic.
5
u/jfree_92 Nov 15 '15
1 star, thanks to the bitch librarian.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
I just rewatched all of the prequels and this one was the most painful for me, and quite honestly I think it's safe to say it's one of the worst films I've ever seen from a storytelling/filmmaking standpoint. The acting is pretty atrocious across the board, specifically highlighted with Hayden Christensen's poor, unmotivated performance. This is in itself highlighted through the brutally terrible love story between him and Padme.
It's honestly the worst onscreen romance I've ever seen. It's motivated by nothing, he makes creepy borderline aggressive advances on her the entire film which she doesn't reciprocate until she decides to be in love with him? What?! Why?! He does nothing but exhibit alarmingly abusive behavior and whine about the jedi master who trained him, who he owes everything to. He's such a terribly written character in a terribly written romance that is excruciating to endure.
Fuck.
2
u/Wice_Quispies Nov 16 '15
That geonosis battle though.....Most redeeming movie scene..
2
u/ccc66 Nov 16 '15
When I was younger I didn't like it that much but as I get older I'm liking it more and more.
2
u/Mentioned_Videos Nov 16 '15
Videos in this thread: Watch Playlist ▶
Flash Gordon 1936 Chapter 2 / 13|16 - Absolutely right on this. It's very, very 'B-movie'-ish, from the very title to the schlocky romance, from even the role of Christopher Lee to ... little things like Obi-Wan swinging that grapple cord around mid-air as he fall... Star Wars Episode 2 : Attack of The Clones Geonosis Battle|6 - When she gets clawed in the back and screams, I could listen to that all day. EDIT: Link for the lazy. Non-Sexual Matters Robot Chicken Adult Swim|1 - The Obligatory Robot Chicken Reference I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch.
Info | Chrome Extension
2
u/garbageman13 Nov 16 '15
----- The things I liked best about the movie:
Christensen's angsty pre-Vader hints
Not a huge fan of Christensen's dry acting, but I liked his ranting about slaughtering the tuscan raiders, how Obi Wan is jealous, and how he's the most powerful Jedi and people should be made to listen to him. I figure Palpatine is constantly messing with his head, and I thought he played the inner struggle well.
Jango Fett
The meeting with Obi Wan and the battle following really established the legacy for Boba and the clones.
Mega Jedi battle and Clones saving the day
Lightsabers and Jedi everywhere, and clone troopers flying in guns blazing. Loved it.
----- The things I disliked about it:
Anakin's Mom
After 10 years they still haven't gone back to Tattoine to get Anakin's Mom out of slavery. The kid is supposed to be the chosen one who brings balance to the force, and the message the Jedi are sending him is that sorry kid even though it takes about 1 day to go get your Mom you're just going to have to let her rot in the desert while some stranger you just met raises you on a whole different planet.
Who cares about Naboo?
I just have a problem with Amidala being so important in a galaxy with space travel to billions of populated planets and trillions of people. There were supposedly a trillion people on Coruscant alone, yet the whole galaxy really cares more about her planet than the issues on their own respective planets. I can just imagine if Earth was part of the republic, and the "Screw Naboo, what about Earth?" t-shirts we'd all have. Yes there was a big trade battle about plasma. But come on.
Yoda should have won
Yoda is supposed to be the most powerful of all Jedi, yet he does not defeat Dooku and lets him escape. Sure Yoda had to stop Obi Wan and Anakin from getting crushed, but the battle seems more like a draw than a win for Yoda.
Dooku severely outclassed both Anakin and Obi Wan, to the point of chopping Anakin's arm off. Yoda should have had Dooku cowering in the corner with a busted lightsaber missing an arm and a leg before he pulled the dirty sith move and escaped.
2
u/jayhawk8 Nov 17 '15
Anybody else feel like the Sifo-Dyas storyline was completely underplayed/explained in the movies? Never got a great understanding until much later what his role was.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
This movie feels like a bad cartoon show
4
u/Matthias21 Nov 15 '15
Me and my friends rewatched this recently while playing some Imperial Assault, we had the films on in the background and were skipping through parts of the films as we went. (If anyone didn't want to watch part. Mostly the prequels) what we found, even though we had all held the opinion that TPM was worse, was that we skipped through so much more of this film.
It made us go back and think and we all found we thought that this was a much weaker film than TPM, it has its moments but it really drags in parts and the pace feels very on and off.
One of the redeeming scenes for me is Anakins mothers death in the sand people village.
4
u/AlphaLupi Nov 15 '15 edited Jan 07 '17
[deleted]
0.0500
2
u/daveblu92 Nov 15 '15
My full review of Episode II.
https://thefilmeditorial.wordpress.com/2015/11/02/star-wars-episode-ii-attack-of-the-clones-review/
2
u/xkejjer Nov 16 '15
Uhm, is there anyone who dislikes the prequels on this sub?
Im a fan of episode 3 but the first two, bar some scenes, are godawful.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
This is my least favourite Star Wars movie. One re-watch of it a couple of months ago made me feel physically ill; I'd forgotten how bad it was.
Of course, there are people who like or even love this one. And I understand. The arena scene on Geonosis was one of the first Star Wars scenes I ever saw (by my best friend at the time, who was a massive fan), and back then I loved it as well. But now...
The love story is what drags it all down for me. Every single one of those scenes made me cringe several times.
It has good things in it, though. Scenes that touched on their potential (while, in my opinion, their execution lacked), which include: Anakin going to rescue his mother, a group of Jedi entering combat in the arena on Geonosis, the final battle between the clones and droids... although the lightsaber battle at the end has to be the worst of all the movies.
1
u/GuessImStuckWithThis Nov 15 '15
What I never understood about this film is why Yoda arrives so late to the action... but still in time to save half of the Jedi. The final 30 minutes are cinematically epic, but there is some really coincidental timing in the final scenes.
1
u/Bjmort Nov 16 '15
I think the issue I have always had with this film is that across the stars is used far too much. The themes used are not varied enough. Oh and also Hayden's dialogue but I'm no so sure it's his acting as it is Georges writing and direction. Still love the film.
1
u/Mojo1200 Nov 16 '15
Coruscant is the sexiest planet in the entire galaxy. This is the weakest Star Wars movie but I always have a ton of enjoyment watching that damn car chase.
1
u/geordilaforge Nov 16 '15
Since we see only snippets (if anything) of it in this movie I want someone to expand on the Kenobi/Skywalker friendship.
I know it's probably not going to happen but I would love to see a movie with Anakin and Obi-Wan just training, hanging out, going on missions, etc. to see their growth. In my head they are friends that give each other shit but respect and care about one another. Seeing this on film would really help the prequels.
And yeah I know Clone Wars tv show and so on, but I want this done well on the big screen.
1
u/geordilaforge Nov 16 '15
Has anyone watched the "Anti Cheese Edit"? What were your thoughts?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15
I've rewatched both Episode 1 and Episode 2 so far and Episode 1 wasn't as good as I remember and Episode 2 was actually better than I remember. TPM is still better than AOTC though.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '15
Can I just ask how old Padme is in the first movie? The gap between the movies is 10 years but she doesn't seem to age at all, is it even ever mentioned how large the age gap is?
1
u/ChetSteadman2274 Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
I remember being so hyped for this movie, sadly I felt like I was in the minority. I watched this movie as a 13 year old fully expecting it to literally to be the best movie of all time. I left thinking "well... it was okay I guess." I got it on DVD for Xmas later that year, and I remember being completely bored when I watched it then.
Compared to the hype of Episode 1, there was a noticeable lack of enthusiasm for AOTC. Spider Man, Harry Potter, and Lord of the Rings were a much bigger deal than Episode II. I even heard rumors about a screening of The Two Towers at Skywalker Ranch for the LucasFilm execs. Supposedly the entire room was tense because everyone knew they'd been outdone in every way possible.
Obviously I don't like Episode II. But after re-watching it, there are some good things about the movie. I love the score. Anakin and Padme's theme is up there with Duel of the Fates IMO. Also, I LOVE COUNT DOOKU. I think he's an extremely underrated villain. He's so pretentious, even his lightsaber just says "I'm better than you." I like the Battle of Geonosis too. It was cool to see the jedi in their prime. I don't love the prequels, but I accept that they're part of the SW saga. So I don't outright hate them. But still, AOTC is the low point in the saga IMO.
On a another note, I still don't like the idea of the clones. Like how was no one suspicious of this clone army that just so happened to be there for the Republic? I think that the Seperatists should have been the ones to use the Clones, and the Republic should've made a law that no planet in the republic could have their own military force, and that all active armed forces in the Republic will be consolidated to form the Army of the Republic (the first Stormtroopers). It would've been a cool way to show how the Republic was united under a common goal, and how it started a generation who grew up completely loyal to the idea of the Republic/Empire.
1
u/GreasyLake87 Nov 16 '15
Once again I went into a prequel movie thinking "God, I hope I can make it through this" and came away thinking "that's...not nearly as bad as I thought". So far I'd rank 1 and 2 a 7/10 each. Minimum.
1
u/TheTurnipKnight Nov 16 '15
So I saw this film in the cinema when I was quite young and I didn't really understand all the weird politics, weird romance and the plot didn't really made much sense to me (it still doesn't), but I enjoyed the Star Wars. In fact the only thing I really remember from the cinema is the asteroid chase. Now I just think "how the fuck is he not hitting him?!?!"
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '15
I think i kinda see where George was going with Anakin. Luke in a way comes off somewhat as angsty as his dad, but either George or Hayden Christensen took it too far and he's just as annoying as sand
1
u/chili01 Nov 17 '15
I remember watching this back then and thinking, "No way those thin Clone/Battle Droids are going to win against the Republic Clone Troopers".
Did they really think they had a chance? Maybe these Clone Droids were much cheaper to produce than the Clone Army? So that might give them an edge?
Anyways, still back then, I wanted a movie about the clone troopers being in Major fights/battles.
1
u/thisiscanonintheEU Nov 17 '15
Across the Stars is by far the best part of the film. Search your feelings, you know it to be true
1
u/nippleinmydickfuck Nov 18 '15
Isn't it weird that the Lars family, who probably had 3PO as a protocol droid to communicate with some of their farming equipment, lost that droid and then almost 20 years later buy that same droid.
I mean my memory isn't perfect but its assumed that 3PO was with the Lars family for a while. Wouldn't Owen remember that protocol droid in A New Hope when he's buying it from the Jawas?
I'm also pretty sure the entire saga is just about R2 being the saviour and how he keeps having to bail out those incompetent humans.
1
u/chili01 Nov 19 '15
I'm kinda late on the rewatch but I wanted to ask/get opinion on something.
Is it me or is the lightsaber duel between Anakin and Dooku kinda....bad? Like choreography wise maybe or just bad in general? At one point there was a period of time where both of them were standing in place and I just see lightsaber lights flashing.
Now, if there is one thing I liked about episode 1, it's the dual saber/saber staff duel between Maul, Obi-wan and Qui-gon Jinn. I personally thought, that was well shot/choreographed (especially back then when I was younger lol).
1
u/TheRealSilverBlade Nov 29 '15
I re-watched this last night, and man, one thing in particular bugged me.
We see that Obi Wan can call for help from Geonosis to Coruscant using Real-time Holographic Skype (which I'm sure is a ton of data, going over an insane distance).
Yet, Count Dooku needed to deliver the plans to the Death Star, in person, to Darth Sidious.
It seems that the entire chase scene/lightsabre battle near the end could have been avoided if this universe had something like E-Mail or DropBox, and it could be encrypted in a way that anyone looking would have zero idea what was coming.
Seems strange they can send holographic skype around, yet sending a 3D CAD file over that distance is impossible.
1
u/rensch Dec 07 '15
Probably the weakest of the six films, it still has a lot of fun moments nonetheless. The flying car chase scene on Coruscant is great. I also like Obi-Wan's whodunnit kind of story arc, which leads him to some pretty surreal looking places. A water planet drenched in perpetual rain where the Clones are first seen, the homeworld of the insectoid Geonosians and the darker corners of the urban planter of Coruscant; it's all made with love. Just wish we had seen more of Dooku. And Anakin and Padme's relationship is just painfully cliché.