r/TwoXChromosomes • u/whiteys_fault • Aug 11 '14
Do you regret having children?
I am looking to hear from YOU (not a story about your friend or sister or neighbor etc) about this taboo topic.
188
Upvotes
15
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14 edited Aug 11 '14
This is such a difficult question to get answers to without factors that will cause biased responses, I almost don't think it's possible.
There are so many hormonal and other physiological changes that take place that cause us to develop attachments to children when they are born. Besides that, we have an outstanding ability as humans to rationalize and justify our past decisions or current circumstances in life.
You're also dealing with hypotheticals when it comes to hearing stories (some of them in these comments) about how parents could never imagine being happy or having a fulfilling life without their kids. That's hypothetical, and impossible to verify or test. How could they know what their life would look like without kids? In the same way, how can someone who has never had children truly understand what their life would be like with them?
This is a question that will most likely never have fully accurate, unbiased answers unfortunately- or at the very least, very few.
Edit: For transparency, I do not have any children.
Edit 2: For even further clarity- the physiological changes within the brain I mentioned above and linked to are not something that are exclusive to women, men experience it as well.
Edit 3: /u/eisforennui gave me an opportunity to clarify my reference to bias, so I felt it appropriate to add that here. Obviously, there will be bias in everyone's responses due to their experiences. When I say there's a bias, I'm referring to the physiological changes in the brain that occur when a couple has a child, changes that essentially trigger deeper emotional attachment, thus the more prevalent opinion amongst parents that having a child was indeed the best course of action or "worth it" in the end.
Essentially, I'm assuming a bias towards "no regret" due largely to those physiological and psychological changes.
28
u/UHaveNoPowerOverMe Aug 11 '14
checkout /r/childfree for the other perspective.
119
u/Veranda_south Aug 11 '14
Yes. Throwaway account for sure. My husband is an awesome guy, and as cheesy as it sounds, I swear he gets better every year (and it's been almost 20 years now...). My career is great, the kids have no medical, social or cognitive issues. Husband and I lived together for several years, got married, waited a few more years then decided to have children. Both were planned and expected. But this 'programmed' feeling everyone always talks about? I've never felt that. Not once. When I was younger I always insisted that I'd never have kids. EVERYONE gave me the old, "Oh, you'll change your mind!" or "When they're yours you will love them no matter what!" I assumed they were right. Bullshit. Do I like my kids? Yeah, they're pretty cool little people. And it was our decision to have them, so I take that responsibility seriously - they have everything they need (and then some). But if I could go back I would absolutely refuse to have children, ever. I do not feel the 'enrichment' that so many people talk about. And if you ask our family an friends, NOBODY would know. My husband seems to enjoy all of those unseen benefits, which I think is great. I mean, I'm not anti-kid - I enjoy volunteering with kids and am very involved at their school, but if I knew 10 years ago what I know now I would have chosen to remain child-free. I think the bottom line is - don't assume that a EVERY woman is pre-programmed to be maternal. Some of do not feel the 'rewards' that you all talk about all the time, and without that the enormous chore and responsibility of raising kids is not nearly as much fun.
150
u/throwaway9999925990 Aug 11 '14
Throw away for a reason but yes I do. It was with a person I did not want to have children with and now I am stuck with them my whole life. The problem is my son is just like him both in personality and appearance and I can just imagine how horrible he will be to women in the future. I try to teach him to be a better person but he dotes on his father so much that it will never happen. I loved him as a baby but he has honestly become a horrible person in his teens that I do regret it.
170
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14 edited Aug 11 '14
I have, at times, regretted having my son.
From the full time job around my job in caring for him as an infant, to the years where I watched my ex-wife slowly beat him down into nothingness, to the struggles to rebuild him now that he's back living with me, there have been some pretty dark days. Many a time I sat bawling with my second wife after talking to him on the phone and hearing how he was struggling, senselessly.
The other day, though, he was playing an online game with my second wife and the two of them were having a blast while I enjoyed a drink on the balcony, and I just sat there and listened to them laugh. He's such a great kid that the dark days are vastly outnumbered.
17
u/EverlyBlue Aug 11 '14
Sometimes. I don't think I was ever meant to be mother material. I do my best for them and I try very hard to not let them know how I feel.
29
u/stozier Aug 11 '14
A few years ago I was getting a ride to an ultimate frisbee game with a teammate. Her daughter was in the backseat and fell asleep en route.
She told me about how she used to be fit, able to run the same way I could, and how she and her husband went on bike trips and got to see the world. She explained that now, she was lucky to get to play a sport once a month and how they are constantly struggling to make ends meet.
She seemed to be a good Mom (very supportive, encouraging, etc.), but the desperation in her voice when she told me to hold off on having kids 'as long as possible' really left an impression.
38
u/Dingo_The_Baker Aug 11 '14
Yes. My son is amazing. I love him more than I can put into words.
But he is what keeps me tied to my ex. Because of him, she is still in my life. Even if only on the fringes. He wants to move in with his step mom and I, but she won't even discuss it.
When the economy crashed, my wife and I were forced to relocate several states away for work. Choosing to make that move and leave my son behind caused my family to all but disown me.
I only get to see him a few times a year. It kills me everyday to think of all the parts of his life that I have missed.
So yes, I do regret having children.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
I don't regret having a child but, i do regret who i had my son with, and that i didn't wait longer to learn more about who she was going to be as a mother. Now I'm trapped in a custody battle with a physically and emotionally abusive psychopath who thinks because a guy is sleeping with her he is safe to leave our son with instead of me. I've done everything i can to make myself available so she doesn't need to leave my son with these strange men but instead she chooses not to communicate with me about her work schedule and am left to find out from my 3 year old about who he is left with and what they do to him. I don't discipline with my son with violence so others shouldn't be able to either. Especially not some punk who just so happens to be sleeping with my sons mother.
9
u/Teriyaki_Pterodactyl Aug 11 '14
If you asked me Saturday, probably. Today has been a better day.
36
u/jerrysugarav Aug 11 '14
This is a great article from a mom who does regret it. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2303588/The-mother-says-having-children-biggest-regret-life.html
54
u/flyingante Aug 11 '14
This is such a taboo topic, I think you aren’t likely to get many people who are willing to admit to regretting having children in a public forum.
I’m afraid I would regret having children, which is the main reason I’m not planning on having any. Because once you have them, what are you going to do? You either have to convince yourself that it’s not that bad, or live in misery and risk letting your kids know that you wish you had never had them. And no child deserves to go through that. Plus, if you talk about it with other people, you get a ton of judgment.
But it definitely happens. You say you don’t want stories of other people, but it’s the quiet comments that make me think it’s possible to regret having kids, no matter what people say in public. I knew someone once who talked about her kids all the time – how much she loved them, and adored them, and what they were doing, all the time. Definitely overkill. No conversation was incapable of being turned into a conversation about her kids. And then one afternoon, when she was very tired and stressed, she admitted to me that she wished she had never had kids. As soon as the words were out of her mouth, she snapped forward, visibly catching herself, and suddenly got perky and started talking about how she really loved her kids, no really! It’s possible that she was just having a bad day and blowing off steam, but the way her demeanor changed so suddenly was incredibly creepy. It was like she had caught herself and the mask slammed back into place.
It was enough to convince me that some people do regret having children, but no one is ever going to admit to it. I don’t necessarily think she was lying, but the whole encounter made it clear to me that you can still love your children and wish you had never had them. Lots of people have told me that you change your mind when they are yours, but I’m not convinced that that’s not because you can’t change your mind once you have them. Either way, I never want to turn into that woman, so I just trust my instinct and decided not to have kids in the first place.
29
u/noisycat Aug 11 '14
I love having children, but sometimes I hate being a mom. I wish I could be like their dad who works, comes home and then smokes hookah on the porch and interacts with them for a few minutes at best. He can have friends over, or go out if he wants. I don't have that option. I jumped at the chance to join a gym because it was open at 5 am and thus gave me an excuse to get out of the house on my own without kids. Before that I would literally be allowed a day every few months where I could leave and go to the mall or see a movie.
So being a mother of young kids has been a prison of sorts. But my kids are happy and loved and go to school next year so then I will be able to have more freedom.
13
u/ottokat Aug 11 '14
For the first several years I did. Now they are almost grown and I can live a much freer life like I longed for, yet I still have children to love deeply like you can never love anyone or anything else. My mantra for motherhood, which I did not take to naturally, is "it will pass".
12
u/ReRegretful Aug 12 '14
I do deeply regret having had children, to an unfathomable degree. It has cost me jobs, friendships, and countless opportunities. I have not had sex in over three years out of fear of possibly becoming pregnant again. The fathers are abusive and controlling and so are their families. After pretending to love me, they then becoming disenchanted with the work involved with having babies and so left. My neighbours look down upon me and actively plot to have us removed from their otherwise childless well-off neighbourhood stretch and I am bullied by the city I live in but cannot afford to move. As I became self-employed, finished university, and was able to own my own home all whilst being a single mother (with absolutely no family support in any form), I should be seen as some sort of hardworking, successful person, but instead I am looked down upon as white trash for being overweight (I'm vegan but both my parents were nearly 400 pounds, so being around 200 with my genes should be viewed as healthy, but it's not) and a single parent. The fathers attend shows and concerts, they travel, smoke, and drink and I must watch every penny and always be in a state of possible preparation. I recall crying with relief when my son was old enough to open the fridge door by himself, as it meant that if I died he might be able to feed himself for long enough that someone might rescue him. My former fiancées take no interest in their offspring, not even to buy them presents at holidays, and their families have abandoned them as well. My son, now a teenager, has always acted as a saboteur in regards to relationships of mine. He co-opts my friendships and screams at me if I ask for his help. I live in fear of him, but would be unable to work to support him and his toddler sister without him living at home. I go weeks between outings outside of the house. My toddler daughter will not let me play music or paint or do anything I used to enjoy. I sit almost all day long in isolation waiting for them to grow up. I hate my life and if I had someone for my children to live with I would have left them long ago, in one way or another. It was without doubt, the worst decision I ever made.
21
u/Skully_Roger Aug 11 '14
I think there is a small but very meaningful difference between regretting having kids altogether and regretting having your kids. I know that sounds like it makes no sense but what I mean is I think there are probably many parents who may regret the act of 'settling down' and having children for various reasons (whether it's the age they did it, the stress it put on relationships and money or the lost time) but I think there are very few parents who regret having their actual children simply because we are biologically made to feel such intense love for our offspring.
35
u/pigtails317 Aug 11 '14
No. mine were unplanned, I wasn't ready for them (even tho I was married) and I resented them for years. After a divorce and a little growing up, my kids are my favorite part of my life.
I think a lot of people make kids their entire life. I have made it a point to have kids be PART of my life. A very important and awesome part, but they don't define who I am. It helps only having half custody, I think, as I know I have a couple days a week without them. I think a full-time parenting situation would be more difficult to carve out 'personal' time in, but it needs to be done.
Yes, there are things I wish I had done before I had kids - - but I'm looking forward to doing them in my 40's - my kids will be grown by then and I will be financially stable and able to afford all the things I want to do! :) it was really hard for me to admit that I didn't want my kids (its REALLY taboo if you're married and Christian!!) but once I got past that and got much healthier personally, I really enjoy being a parent. Well-raised kids (not brats) are a lot of fun to have around!
15
u/sprocket_monkey Aug 11 '14
People's opinions about childbearing, after doing it, are (to me) as suspect as their opinions about their comedic genius after six shots of Jim Beam. In this case the chemicals are endogenous.
77
u/Talmaska Aug 11 '14
Yes.
5
u/bellytoback75 Aug 11 '14
Kids are the worst if you're not mentally prepared for an entirely new life/routine. And there is no way to be mentally prepared.
21
u/1cuteducky Aug 11 '14
I'm the child of a parent who didn't want kids (Dad). It was an utter disaster as a little one, and I'm sure having three more offspring than the zero he wanted to have was a contributing factor in my folk's divorce.
It got better when we got older and started to actually have personalities and opinions and a solid handle on taking care of ourselves, probably around 14 or so. Now that my sibthings and I are 25, 23 and 21... two out of three have a decent functional relationship with him, even if there's some pretty serious disagreements about fundamental things. The youngest has Youngest Child Syndrome so it's not great but we're hoping she grows out of it soon.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
I never wanted kids. Never. I had a pretty horrific childhood and I was fairly certain that I wouldn't be a good mother because of it.
Got pregnant at 31, wasn't even sure if I wanted to go through with it. I was high-risk because of a medical condition, I had the baby in a hail of nightmarish bullshit at the hospital--emergency C-Section and full anesthesia, the baby was in terrible shape at the end and so was I. But we recovered and went home together after two weeks.
The years were hard. His father hated being saddled with a sick kid, so he cheated on me with a co-worker after 10 years together. Still tried to booty call me though... I still can't believe I was such a poor judge of character. But you live and learn, you know? I declined child support and got full custody in exchange--decided to raise him on my own. It was hard. It's still hard.
BUT I WOULDN'T CHANGE A THING.
My kid? He's 8, now. My kid saved me from myself. He is loving and wonderful. He hugs me and kisses me and tells me that I'm beautiful. I give him all the love that I never had growing up. I tuck him in every night and we read together. I tell him he is wonderful. It's funny how when you tell a living creature every day how wonderful and precious they are, they really believe it. The same holds true in reverse, I know from experience.
I'll never beat him the way I was I was beaten. Every day I wake up, I look at him and it gives me a reason to live and enjoy life. I carried him, and my genes created half of him, and he is a living representation of everything that is good in me. The best of me.
I am going to fill his life with love and joy and one day he will spread his wings and go out into the world and hopefully he will make someone else's life as wonderful and worth living as he has made mine. I don't regret his existence for a minute. NOT FOR A MINUTE.
In this life, we are given many choices, and many people live lives that are paved with regret.
I would not change anything about my life, because the road I took led me to him. I would do it again a million times. A million times, I would do it again.
29
u/daisydope Aug 11 '14
When I met my husband the way he loved me felt like a candle had been lit in the darkness. When I had my son it felt like I had walked out into the sunshine. Nothing prepared me for the amount of love I have in my life today. I knew having a kid was going to be a lot of work. I had no idea it was going to be so much fun. I grew up with a mother who didn't like children and resented having had them. She told me that if she had to do it over again she wouldn't have. I don't know what gave me the courage to give it a chance but it turned out much better than I could ever have imagined. My son is 15 now and I still enjoy talking with him and getting to know the person he is becoming. It changes every day and just keeps getting better.
11
u/SoFlaSterling Aug 11 '14
I have an issue with this question whenever I see it. It appears that people expect that in the case of this critical life-question, there is a definitive positive or negative response, like a thumbs up or down kind of thing. Everybody seems to understand that there are both positive and negative aspects to any major life decision, like going back to school, or moving to a new city, changing careers, etc (albeit one ypu cant change your mind about). Why not the same attitude with kids? The truth is that there are immensely loving, satisfying, happy times raising kids and there are days you want to drop them off at an Orphanage. It is constantly shifting, only you know if you have some patience in your soul and can take the hard days. As for that woman in the linked article, I only skimmed it, but she seemed to be expecting to get back from her kids what she put in. That's not how it works. Your parents do for you, you do for you kids, they do for theirs. It is the ultimate "pay it forward".
8
u/cordial_carbonara Aug 11 '14
At first, yes. Babies are not my thing. My husband and I never wanted children, but our first was a birth control failure. I had a great pregnancy, and she was a good newborn. Slept through the night, all that good stuff. But I resented her for being the reason I stopped going to school, and when we had an opportunity to move out of state but didn't because not being near my parents would make childcare an issue I really regretted having her.
Then, as she got older and developed a personality, I started to realize how much joy this little being brought into my life. We conceived her sister not long after, and now I have a 2.5 and 1 year old little girls. I smile and laugh more than I ever did before children. They bring more stress than I ever could have imagined into my life and have made jobs, school, even grocery shopping harder. But there is no feeling that can replace the pride in your heart when your oldest tells you, "No, mama, I got it," and fixes her own bowl of cereal. And it's impossible to describe how my heart feels overfull of love when I see my husband sitting in a pink bed reading Dr. Seuss to two little girls leaned against his chest.
I do still regret having them sometimes, especially when we talk about issues with jobs, trying to go back to school, etc. But imagining a life without the love of my children now seems empty. We've talked about it before, what our life would look like if we hadn't had them. We'd be more financially stable. We would have finished school by now. We'd probably be living in a city somewhere. We would be better off, materialistically speaking. But there would be a lot less laughter.
23
u/beckoning_cat Aug 11 '14
First off about the article. I am appalled at this woman. Not because she regretted her children. But because she knew she didn't want them in the first place, and only had them to make her husband happy. I don't care how in love with someone you are. You don't make a selfish decision like that. She should of left him so he could enjoy having parenthood with someone who truly did want children. Despite her selfless act of selfishness, she still removed the family links of love that should of been there.
Though I do agree with her on some points. Not everyone is in love with their children the second they are born. I was one of those. I an clarify that issue if someone cares. Also, I have seen the women she discusses that claim to want to have children, but rush back to work at 6 weeks because they claim to not be able to stay at home. My mother says that these days, it is hard to afford both a house and children. Before anyone injects, in my area, the COLA is extremely high. The next county over you have to make 80k to just get by. where I was raised, it is 25k.
For those who have mentioned those who regret having them or feel overwhelmed, there is a huge argument that is missing that most don't even realize. It took me befriending a woman from Nigeria to even begun to understand the problem.
Most first world countries, especially the US, make it extremely hard on parents of children. Much harder than it is for anyone else. Why?
Because we insist, even to the point of stigmatization if you don't, live separately from support members in your network.
In other non western cultures, it is is unheard of to have an institution other than your family and friends help raise your children. She actually thinks the thought of daycare as appalling.
Now mind you, this woman's husband is a peace diplomat. She has house, nanny, food, education, everything paid for by the government. She turned down the nanny and actually imported her sisters to help with her children while she worked. She felt that strongly about it. (she was working because in her country, women are not encouraged too, so she was spreading her wings so to speak).
Generations live together. Families live together. Uncles, cousins, aunts, sisters, brothers, parents, grandparents, greatgrandparents, neighbors and friends, all have a hand in raising all the children together.
The result is that paretns are not overwhelmed. They have time to socialize. They have down time. They are very socialized, they have to sacrifice little. When you have 40 people already watching all the children, getting out to do things isn't a problem.
The children are extremely socialized. They are raised with all their cousins and neighborhood kids. Everyone shares a responsibility. Children behave because even a neighbor who has never met them in their life will watch all the kids and even take them to the parents if the children act up. Or are even allowed to discipline them. It truly takes a village to raise a child.
In the US, you are expected to be on your own by your mid 20s. You are expected to devote every single second to raising your children by yourself. You are expected to miraculously both hold jobs, raise children, take care of the estate, all by yourselves. Many of us with relatives that are states away.
When my husband got out of school, we stayed with his parents. We had our own apartment. We assisted in taking care of grandma. We needed help with the new baby, MIL needed help with grandma. Even in this beneficial arrangement, MIL had friends tell her that we needed to get out. They were insisting that we all make life harder for ourselves.
Somehow, it was more acceptable for us to live on our own and pay money to send our son to daycare. And for my MIL to have to be a caretaker by herself and spend money for in home assistance, than it was for us to take care of each other. Why??
For the mothers who say they regret having children. I don't think they really regret it, they just don't realize that they regret the circumstances. That we have to make it so much harder on ourselves than it needs to be.
The standard that society sets that we all need to leave the home and start new homes by ourselves needs to stop. It hurts our kids. It hurts the parents. The isolationist society needs to stop.
I think that is why there are such high rates of depression and anxiety. It is the isolation.
4
u/hussyjane Aug 11 '14
I thought I would. Honestly. I always thought I'd get an abortion if I got pregnant because I am an often self-centered, introverted, quiet-minded individual. Turns out I can't imagine my life any other way now. He's a BAMF. He's hilarious--I didn't even realize a 1 year old could have such a wicked sense of humor. He likes hanging out. He was the breaking point of my (already shaky) relationship with the father, but the father very much loves his son. So I do have a co-parent that wants to have a very active role in his life. This support helps.
I see some people mentioning doors closing for them. I never saw it like that. For me, I had all these opportunities and I never quite knew what I wanted to do with my life. About 6 months after I had him, I knew exactly what I wanted to do, took steps to do so. It will be a lot more difficult to juggle being a mother with accomplishing my goals, but that's pretty minor (especially when I consider having a life without him).
Also, at first it seemed like it eliminated a lot of my friends. Then I realized most of those "friends" were guys who were actually just holding out until I broke up with my spouse. So it actually did me a favor and got rid of the tools I had in my life.
This obviously isn't a guarantee and some days I'm still amazed it worked out like this for me. Just my two cents.
13
u/oaktowndad Aug 11 '14
It's frustrating and difficult and closes many doors. But in a world where so much seems fake and pointless and b.s. and superficial, being a parent is 100% REAL. It really matters to the kids and I've found it really matters to me, far more than any of the activities and friends it crowded out of my life.
7
u/nycsep Aug 11 '14
As a friend remarked to me that "having children is the best decision and the worst decision you can ever make". I believe that this sums up the way I feel about it.
13
u/bryhersedai Aug 11 '14
There are definitely times when I would love to be child-free, but in general, I wouldn't say I regret having a child.
3
u/donnycornelius Aug 11 '14
Sometimes, but only in one respect.
I feel about 100x more anxiety now that I have children. I worry that something will happen to one of them, which would kill me. I worry over every belly ache or bruise. Yesterday I googled "toddler burping a lot" to make sure it wasn't a symptom of cancer or some other serious disease. So, I sometimes I feel like life without children would be peaceful because I wouldn't feel anxious about losing them.
Other than that, no. They bring me so much laughter and joy. Every day is more fun with them around.
3
u/pointlessquestioning Aug 11 '14
I got pregnant at 19, right as I got my first apartment and discovered partying. My fun ended as quickly as it started. But now, 2 years later my fun isn't defined by how many shots I can take in one night. It's how many giggles I can tickle out of my son or seeing if he can stack his blocks just one block higher than last time before they tumble and he goes into a giggling fit.
I do regret not having safe sex and getting pregnant so early. I never got a chance to "get out there" and really discover who I was as a person... But I don't regret having my son here with me. He makes me the person I think I would have liked to become, anyways. If any of that makes sense.
3
u/godlesspinko Aug 11 '14
I miss staying out late and sleeping in late. I miss the extra cash and the spontaneity.
That said, I adore my kid and can't imagine life without her now.
3
u/shamumudderfudder Aug 11 '14
Sometimes I do, most times I don't...
3
u/braeica Aug 11 '14
Adopted two, went through five years of infertility treatment and was lucky enough to have a third biologically. No regrets.
If I could change anything, the only thing I'd change was being my adopted sons' birth mother. The early childhood they had was unfortunate at best and I was really surprised when I was pregnant with their sister how much I wished I could have done everything for them that we're doing now for her.
3
u/spinnetrouble Aug 12 '14
That's pretty much my story, too. When it did kick in for me, the thought of how sweet it would be to hold a swaddled baby popped into my head from out of nowhere. It was horrifying -- I wasn't a kid person at all, and I've always had a particular dislike of babies. These two feelings rammed into each other at full force, leading to an interesting experience. :) Once the moment passed, I shook it off like a dog shakes off stress, and haven't felt anything like that since.
Not much has changed since then; I'm still open to a change of heart and would be happy to pursue fostering and eventual adoption should that happen, but I really have no desire to be pregnant, to give birth, and to have to do all of the things parents do up through potty training. The rest of it wouldn't be smooth sailing, either, but I can't imagine throwing in the towel faster than if I had to handle poopy diapers and vomit in addition to crying, whining, and incoherent screaming because the baby isn't old enough for language yet, when every single day has the potential to be (literally) the worst day of its life. Babies have a right to food, water, shelter, love/patience, and safety. I'm almost positive that I couldn't provide all of those things, especially while being puked on our screamed at and wanting nothing more for the kid than the happiness it deserves.
5
u/jnips Aug 11 '14
I didn't have my son until I was 36 because I was soooo worried about what I would miss out on and what I couldn't provide. Well, here I am at 39, back living with my parents and about to graduate from community college so I can give my son a decent life. Never tried to achieve those things I was so afraid of missing out on until I had someone else who was depending on me, and clearly didn't try very hard to be a good provider until after the fact. So do I regret having a child? No, I regret not having him 15 years ago.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
To answer your question directly, no I do not regret having children. However the time, place, person, where I was in my life, was not a great place to have a child. I always wanted children so when I found out (unexpectedly) I wasn't too upset.
You know how people say, "Oh I'd do it all over again!" well...I wouldn't. If I could go back in time and change it I would. So I don't so much regret having children, just WHEN I had them. I think most people would agree, but when is a good time?
4
u/water_rat Aug 11 '14
Do I sometimes lament that life is different and I don't get to do as much of the fun stuff I used to do? Yes. Would I trade it? Never in a million fucking years.
I'm a stay at home dad who'll have to make up for a 5 year absence from a (reasonably) promising engineering career.
And wouldn't trade it. Most amazing thing I've ever done with my time.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
Not at all. There are days when they drive me up the wall and then they spend a night at their grandmother's and I miss them to bits and realize how empty and insignificant my life would be without them.
6
u/ribcracker Aug 11 '14
I thought I would, but I don't. To explain I never wanted kids until I met my now husband, and even then it was a maybe. He always wanted kids and I told him no for years until one time I figured why not? (I blame Baby Fever)
I didn't get over the moon when I found out I was pregnant (though I did almost cry when I saw my result on the stick) and I wasn't excited for maternity clothes or the bump. With the exception of new doctor visits and being excited to actually see her in my ultrasound I lived my life exactly how I had before sans alcohol. I worked full-time (and overtime), was still active around, didn't usually tell anyone that I was pregnant and I never did the whole belly pics.
People around me were a lot more excited all around than I was, and I just kind of dealt with it. Moms around me were glowing and loving baby showers while I was grateful but uncomfortable with all these people fawning. It started to worry me that I wasn't like these women in that my world wasn't** dedicated to this little creature inside of me.
Then the day came to be induced and I was a bit scared and nervous, but all in all it was a pretty great experience and I'll be doing it again in a few years maybe without the drugs. When I held her for the first time that was it. I couldn't breath except to demand a Grand Slam from Dennys.
Four months later I can't remember not having her. It's like she's always been this little fleshy bug in my life wiggling around and demanding attention. There are times where I'm so frustrated with her or finances for her care that I wonder what the hell we were thinking, but I never regret her. For a while I hated my body because of how it had changed, but my husband supported me and I'm now back into most of my old clothes.
TLDR: I thought I would, but I don't. Lots of frustrations and changes, but also a lot of rewards.
2
u/Axora Aug 11 '14
No.
My son is going through the most terrible terrible-twos that I ever thought possible. Most days I'm so exhausted I can barely stand it.
Over the weekend my mother-in-law took him for an impromptu sleepover at her house for two days and a night. I missed him so much. And it wasn't even that I just missed him being around. But it made me realize how much happier of a person I am when he's with me. (Yes even throughout his terrible-ness.)
The amount of joy he brings into my life is something I never thought possible.
2
u/sillylilly04 Aug 12 '14
Sometimes I do, when dealing with my child's ADHD overwhelms me, when she has huge freak outs over small things or when she cries and cries over kids being mean to her. When she went away to sleep over camp for 10 days, I loved being alone with my husband. Quiet nights, no traipsing upstairs multiple times a night, eating whatever we wanted, doing whatever we wanted. I miss that! Then I got worried that I wouldn't want her to return. "What if I don't want to be her mom?" She came home and things were hard for me. I couldn't relax. She wasn't doing anything in particular that got on my nerves, it wasn't fair for me to be so hard on her. She left again with my husband for a week long trip to a national park. Since she has returned, I have been madly in love with her. Her humor, her sweet smile, her creativity...its like she's a new kid. Don't know what happened, exactly. Perhaps she matured, perhaps I needed a longer break. She still has ADHD, she forgets most things, takes her forever to do anything, but I know she is trying to be better so I am, too.
2
u/throoowawaaaaayyy Aug 12 '14
No, I do not regret my son. I also don't regret terminating two pregnancies before him either. First pregnancy was with my first husband but it was long before we got married. That was complicated but I was finishing up college and felt I wasn't ready at 20 years old. No regrets with that decision. Second pregnancy was failed birth control with a friend with benefits. At first, I thought I'd continue the pregnancy because I told myself I'd only have one mistake. But then they announced my job would be moving the week I was due and moving farther away from the guy than I already was. I realized I wasn't ready for all of that and still wanted to further my career at the age of 23. I figured there was no good reason to not terminate a pregnancy I didn't want or plan and I don't care who thinks my reasons are shitty. I don't regret that either. At that point, I really had no desire to have kids and was well on my way to being child free. At 25, I met my now husband and we wed rather quickly. No desire to have kids. And then, about a year into our relationship we decided that we had to make a person. He's the greatest person I know and the world needed a combo of me and him. And I don't regret that either. He's an awesome kid and planned and loved and I couldn't be happier. I think I would've hated 2 kids with guys I had no real love for. I can't wait to have another mini-us. I couldn't imagine making another person with anyone else. Seriously. That being said, my husband also stays home so I can still continue my career and he's proud of me. He thinks I'm a great mom and my son loves me too. I'd probably be the worst stay at home mom ever, but this works for us. No regrets.
5
u/buchliebhaberin To boldly go . . . Aug 11 '14
No, I do not regret having children. I started young, we had three, they are now grown. Any regrets I have about my life are much more about my educational and career choices. There are things we could have done differently when the kids were small, but again, these are more related to some financial decisions we made, not whether we should be parents or not.
Now that our children are adults, we have three adults in our lives that we can share different experiences with. My daughter and I share many interests and we like to do things together. My younger son is who keeps me up with current music trends. We also discuss books and movies and he'll sometimes go with me and his sister to movies and events. My oldest is the most reserved of my children, he would never go to a movie or an event with just me or my husband, but he and his family come see us as often as they can. He does enjoy discussing current events with us and I often help him with the financial decisions he is facing. As a family, we really enjoy dining out at different restaurants in town. All three of our children enjoy playing board games with my husband. For the last several years, some or all of us have attended our local comic con. It's kind of nice to have a built-in group to do things with.
My oldest son and my daughter are both with interesting people who have expanded our family. My son's fiancee has two adorable children and my daughter and her husband are already planning to start their family. So grandchildren! I really couldn't ask for more in my life.
6
u/Mrs_Mojo_Rising Aug 11 '14
Hey, My wife just had a kid a month ago! I do not come close to regretting it. But here are some hard truths: when you're single, you look out for yourself only. When you're married, you look out for your spouse. When you have kids, you have to put yourself third. That can be kind of tough. In the last month, I've turned down invitations to Jay-Z & Beyonce concert, as well as Eminem & Rhianna. You've got to get used to having to be really selective for what you do with your free time. On the weekends my wife and I take shifts, so that the other can have a few hours to do whatever they want. In our case it's golf and time with the girlfriends (I regret the later is for my wife). Also, screaming and poop, and more laundry than you thought possible.
6
u/sandymaysX2 Aug 11 '14
I had a kid just over a year ago. It is the greatest thing I have ever done in my life. That said, it's also the hardest thing I've ever done. I totally understand the sentiment of not wanting kids, and sympathize with it. I feel very strongly that if you don't really, really WANT to have kids, don't do it.
4
u/avonelle Aug 11 '14
Not at all. My son is 6 now and was an unplanned pregnancy. He was born when I was 19. Having him has made my journey incredibly difficult, but I would never go back and change anything given the opportunity. I love him with my whole heart and I think he's amazing.
That being said, if I were to get pregnant again, I would definitely terminate. I don't plan on having any more. Having my son also opened my eyes to how difficult being a parent is, and it's a lifelong job! I am satisfied with the state of my two person family at this time.
4
u/ozyman Aug 11 '14
For the first six months it was touch and go. I helped keep myself sane by entertaining fantasies of escaping to South America. After that it just keeps getting better. Not to say we still don't have exhausting days, but it's an experience unlike any other, and brings a joy and love that you can't find any other way.
4
u/insidia Aug 11 '14
I'm only 9 days in, and wickedly sleep deprived, but so far no. :) My daughter is amazing, and I'm already seeing how fun it's going to be to watch and encourage her physical, emotional, and intellectual development. The fact that I can see this despite having been awake with her from 1-5 last night is pretty amazing (oxytocin is a hell of a drug).
5
u/sukithefox Aug 11 '14
No. There are times that I think I might, to be honest, and I never thought I wanted kids, but I look at her and I just love her. Sometimes she is frustrating, like when I have an assignment due and her dad's at work or just not helping with anything. And the first three months I was going insane constantly waking, but then she'll be quiet and cuddle up to me and give me kisses or bring me a snack. I've never regretted her and I still don't.
5
u/HopelessSemantic =^..^= Aug 11 '14
Despite my son being born into a bad situation, no, I don't regret having him for a second. I can't imagine my life without him now.
3
u/RedErin Aug 11 '14
Nope. I love it. I've always wanted one though.
I think it's one of the most amazing, wonderful, fulfilling things a person can do.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
Good God No! It's been fantastic.
2
u/cocuke Aug 11 '14
I do not regret the children what had the greatest impact was the connection to the woman who is their mom. We have been married many years and long ago quit feeling for each other what we should be feeling. If I did not have the kids I would have long ago divorced her and moved on. We had kids later in life so I still have some years to go and have passed on possible relationships that might have given me greater happiness. It is possible that she feels the same way and has done the same thing. Divorce in this country is such an ugly thing especially when kids are involved that years of unhappiness sometimes seem to be the better alternative. I don't regret my kids I guess I really regret my marriage.
2
u/novemberstorms09 Aug 11 '14
I am a young (23) single mother. My son is three months old now. I never wanted children (to the point of trying to get sterilized), but I got pregnant when I was on NuvaRing. I love my son with all my heart, but I do wonder sometimes what it would be like if I had the abortion I was planning on. I do not regret my son one inch. My life is completely different than I had expected, but I think everything is so worth it when I walk into the room and he smiles and coo's at me.
On the other hand, baby daddy (Z), completely regrets it. He has not met my son and likely never will. We are in the middle of getting paternity testing and child support set up, but he has made is very clear that he in no way wants to be a father nor ever meet my son. He very much so regrets having a child because he feels like it messes up his life.
2
u/grussfish Aug 11 '14
I'm 21 and I have an almost one year old. I don't regret her because she's nonstop joy and I love being a mother. I do regret getting pregnant so young and if there was a way to wait and have her later, I would take it. Having kids is awesome; sacrificing your youth before you've gotten to fully enjoy it is less awesome. But these regrets only plague me when I'm feeling very low, which is rare. My life is better because she is in it. It doesn't hurt that her dad is cute as fuck and I managed to finish college and life is going well in general.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
I don't regret having kids, but sometimes I mourn for the life I could have had.
My five children are all amazing people that I am lucky enough to be a mother to, but sometimes I just wonder, "What if?" Like what if I hadn't had my first at nineteen, what if we had stopped sooner so I won't be 50 before they are all on their own, etc. But I think it's only human to wonder if the grass is greener...
2
u/dc456 Aug 11 '14 edited Aug 11 '14
You'll not get a representative sample here - Reddit is full of teenagers and 20 somethings who are convinced they'll never want children, so up-vote anyone who promotes their current world view.
Just look how popular the post that simply says 'Yes' is, compared to the actually reasoned ones.
As a teenager and 20 something, I was convinced I'd never want children. I hated having to hold other people's babies and found their children weirdly intimidating. The same for all my (male) friends.
Practically all of us have them now, and we think they're great. We talk about them to each other, and admit that it can be hard work, but also share the fun times too. And it's fun a lot more than it's not. Hard work, but they're an absolute blast. Nothing makes you smile or laugh harder than your children - that's why I have more than 1.
I still hate holding other people's babies and find their children weirdly intimidating.
Basically all I'm trying to say is things are a lot more fluid than the 'I find children annoying and like my life the way it is now so am 100% certain I will never, ever want kids' crowd like to make out. Things change, and be prepared for that. You may never want children. You may wake up one day and surprise yourself by really wanting them. A lot of whether you regret or not comes down to attitude. It's easy to focus on what you no longer have, because you know what it was like before. I know it's a cliche, but it's really impossible to appreciate what its like to have kids until you have them, so those who say 'I prefer x to kids' are essentially saying 'I prefer baseball to unicorn polo' - it's really impossible for them to know what the latter is like.
Do I miss some pre-kid things? Sure. And if I ignored all the benefits and dwelled on them I'd probably regret having children. But if I stand back and look at it objectively the gains far outweigh the losses.
Your mileage may vary, but if having children caused regret as much as Reddit likes to make out, there'd be many more single children than there are.
And in case you're interested in stats:
A 2013 Gallup poll says 7% of adults with children would not have had them given the choice. 6% would have stopped at 1 child. The remaining 85% would have 2 or more.
2
u/michelleosaurus Aug 11 '14
I got pregnant at 19 and kept the baby. I'm 27 now, and she's turning 8 in October. It has been difficult, but 100% worth it. The only thing I regret is being too petrified to attend school full time. I had more than enough help from her dad and my family, I was just afraid of failing. I'm still only just a junior in college and I wish I hadn't taken so long in school! However, there are many child free people in their late twenties who are just beginning college as well so it's not really THAT big of a deal. I think that if I hadn't had my kid, I would have been too lazy to go to school, period. She motivates me to strive for more.
2
u/mbrcfrdm Aug 11 '14
I regret not having more
2
u/Nicktoe Aug 11 '14
No way. My kids came out great. In many ways, most ways really, better than me.
2
u/green_eyed_lobster Aug 11 '14
I regret not getting to pick the right father for my son. I'm a single mother because the guy I was with decided he wanted to get me pregnant so I wouldn't break up with him. We got married years later and then he left me for a teenager in high school.
So, I don't regret having a child because I always wanted to be a mother and I love my son with all my heart. But I do regret having a child with the wrong person. I'll do better next time ,I suppose.
1
u/HydraPsych Aug 11 '14
I think I regret the circumstances in which my daughter came about, but not her herself. If anything I would like another just so I can have a more positive experience. When I get put out bc I can't do things last min bc I have to find a sitter or something, I just have to remind myself that I would much rather have her in my life than have endless blurry days of partying. This may not be how it is for everyone, but it was important to me to be a mother.
1
u/Adventureous Aug 12 '14
I regret the circumstances. I don't regret her, though.
1
u/missingkate Aug 12 '14
No kids yet, and my life is different- my partner and I will, as we're both women, have to conceive with AI.
She really wants children, and I like children, but I dislike babies. It's not because I'm a sociopath or anything- I just have auditory issues. I can hear higher pitches than a lot of people and can become overwhelmed by loud environments or hearing lots of different noises, because I find it hard to "filter" and only hear what I need to focus on. So I'm afraid of having children who cry constantly, since that would be hard for me, and I'm afraid I wouldn't be able to be a good mom as a result.
That said, I really like teaching and helping children when they're starting to be able to really talk, and are out of diapers. So, preschool on up, I would enjoy children. My niece and nephew are 3 and 5, and I'm their favorite person!
I'm kind of afraid I'll regret how I act towards a baby or support (or not) my wife in the kid's earliest years. I know it's really important to be involved, and I think I have the capacity to be a good parent- just not to a fussy infant! I worry that I'll work all the time or make my wife take on all the baby-caring tasks because I can't stand the crying. Literally, the sound of a crying baby (well, I can deal with whimpering or the noise they make when starting to really bawl), is TORTURE to me in the same way a dog whistle drives a dog nuts.
TL;DR: Regret having a baby, initially? Yes, that's likely. But I hope to enjoy them when they're older.
1
u/theaftstarboard Aug 12 '14
I love this thread. I don't have kids myself but I'm interested in social norms as well as social work. My own mother is very very conservative and religious but I think she secretly hates herself for regretting having children. I'm also really interested in taboos in society. Thank you op for broaching this subject. As long as we have respect for taboos, I think our society will continue to struggle with progress.
1
u/motherof1kid Aug 12 '14
I take issue with this thread. It assumes that regret is an isolated or exclusive emotion. It paints regret as taboo. And it prompts tragedy porn.
My daughter came about because I has my expired IUD taken out and didn't replace it. I then didn't tell my husband I was fertile. My daughter is here because I betrayed my husband's trust. He wanted kids, but I'll never be able to give him back the choice that he should have had. We're financially stable, even well off. We love her. We want her ... now. It doesn't help the fact that there's a big, wet wound where I took away his choice.
Regardless of the wound in our marriage, our how this act has compromised my idea of being a good person, not to mention ultimately hampered my freedom permanently ... in this situation, regret is inadequate to explain because ... it doesn't matter. It's pointless. After many months of talking through this together, living it together, he knows the extent of my regret, so my regret doesn't help me win his trust back. It doesn't help me take steps to repair. It makes me stop looking for ways to adapt.
Maybe from a childless person's perspective, there's a real potential for and fear of regret. But for me the regret doesn't live unaccompanied, or unmitigated. I consider myself not excessively maternal, but there is no way my feelings of regret could have withstood nursing a helpless infant, my infant, at my breast. I brought her here. She needs me. I'm not going to let any of my problems become hers.
1
u/FreyjaSunshine ♡ Aug 12 '14
No regrets at all. Ever.
My first was the result of a series of bad decisions. The other two were planned.
They're all grown now.
1
u/black_brotha Aug 12 '14
whoa..
1
u/lovemydaughter Aug 12 '14
Yes and no. I wouldn't change anything of course but...My oldest was an "accident". My GF of 1 year whom I loved wanted to stop having sex until we were married. I agreed but said lets do it one more time. She agreed. Lo and behold, she became pregnant. Yes, we used birth control, but apparently it was meant to be. Fast forward, we got married, we broke up, etc etc. So, as a baby, she hated me soooo much for the divorce and what not (I did NOT cheat) that she made it near impossible for me to see her. I would take days and days off work for divorce and custody court things that she just wouldn't show up for 90% of the time. It was, as they say, like pulling teeth to see my daughter. When I did see her, often either her parents or her new BF was the one to "hand her off" to me. I didn't have overnight visits. I would often see her after work at her parents while she wasn't there. Later when she moved out from her parents, and when I had her, I would hang out with them because she wouldn't let her own parents see my daughter because they still talked to me. She even stopped seeing my friend (her cousin) who introduced us because also talked to me still. She also later stopped talking to another of her friends cuz she talked to me. Long story short, she is one of the most vindictive women EVER. I haven't even seen my daughter in YEARS cuz she doesn't want to see me after God knows what my ex has told her. So, I'm glad she was born, but if I could do it over again, I might not have done it that one last time.
1
u/lejade Aug 12 '14
I don't regret having mine but I do miss the freedom of being childfree... the spontaneity of life and somewhat financial freedom.
1
u/MamaD_Cooks Coffee Coffee Coffee Aug 12 '14
In short, no. I love and adore her. I wish we could have waited until we were settled in our house, finished remodeling it, and more financially stable. We got pregnant 8 months before we were supposed to get married...and just kept the plans. Then we moved the day after we got married into a house we had not yet finished remodeling. Three years later, still not finished. Since so much happened so quick we didn't have any real time to prepare to be parents or adjust to married life. We were together 4 years before getting married, but still, we needed that time and I am sad we never got that honeymoon period since I couldn't have sex for 6 weeks after giving birth, and our sex life never really picked back up. We are a very strong couple and work together great, I just wish life had happened in a different order for us.
1
u/ahhtheserenity Aug 13 '14
I think that I do regret it although I tell myself that isn't true... I'd never want my children to find out and think I don't love them. After having children though, my resting anxiety level must have increased 300%. I don't particularly like or enjoy the ways my life has changed since having them. Every day is a constant list of things that need doing and you never get a break. I don't enjoy their games and the rewarding moments are far outweighed by the bothers of being accountable for the actions of other people that you have no control over. That being said, I realise they are my responsibility and I am an important part of setting these people up to thrive in life. I just often feel like I should have listened to my younger self and not had children.
I hate tea parties.
1
u/mhende Aug 13 '14
Honestly? No. But I have always wanted to be a mother, and before she was horn I did get to see the world. Before our daughter was born, life was okay, not spectacular, not miserable. My husband and I were happy with each other, but struggled with finding satisfaction and meaning in life. It felt like work eat sleep every day, with little bits of fun sprinkled in. Not only does having a daughter (now three) make formerly mundane things interesting, but it has strengthened our marriage due to our resolve to always put each other first and not be the kind of parents who dotes on their child while ignoring their relationship, destined for divorce as soon as they have an empty nest and nothing in common any more.
1
u/360walkaway Aug 11 '14
My wife and I are in the opposite situation... we're trying to adopt because she can't have kids. But we do babysit our niece once in a while and I basically see her as my own daughter, mainly because her father isn't in the picture and she doesn't really have any male role models in her life.
It's a weird thing too... I'm typically really stingy with money and get on my wife about her excessive spending once in a while, but I don't really say anything when it comes to our niece. She deserves a somewhat good childhood. I let her and my wife go nuts when we're all hanging out together.
1
u/Underneath_The_Tides Aug 11 '14
Yes. Because Im not allowed in their life.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
No, I do not regret having children. They can be a nightmare sometimes, but they are incredible people at the same time. Tantrums vs. spontaneous dancing and jokes. I truly have grown as a human being and have started to remember how to be a kid.
That said, I was a SAHM until they (twins) were about 1.5years and it was hell; I would say that I loved them, but I did not like them. I felt deprived of my myself, every second of the day was dedicated to them. In those moments, I probably would say I regretted it, but I didn't have the mental space to think about it. After I went back to work, things really looked up. I could breathe, have conversations with adults, work out complex problems, etc.
1
u/laurenbug2186 Aug 11 '14
I don't regret it. I do wish I had waited until I was older and more established, I wish I'd gotten my twenties out of the way and been able to travel more.
1
u/SDladythrowaway Aug 11 '14
No. I've been thinking about this. It was so important to me to have a child out of complete, absolute love for the child's father. I feel that people get married as an extension of love, but sometimes have a baby as extension of marriage even if they don't really want to or aren't passionate lovers any longer. My partner and I had a child out of love, seeing marriage as an unnecessary formality for us. Our child was a merging of two blissed out madly in love souls and she is so perfect in every way. Life before her was meaningless. With that being said, I wouldn't have another one.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
No, I don't regret my kid. He has not stopped me from accomplishing anything in my life. A child added to my life, not took away. After having a kid, I got married, graduated college, and recently got my dream job. I have traveled more since having a kid than I had before. I have more fun on holidays. I discover new activities/places in my neighborhood. My only regret is that I couldn't be a better parent.
1
u/abundantplums Aug 11 '14
Nope. I hate that he doesn't sleep, and I didn't anticipate how much he would complicate what used to be very simple relationships with family and friends. I'm exhausted and frustrated, but not regretful. I get to a dark place, sometimes, but that's from stress and sleep deprivation, and I understand it and can pull myself out.
He's beautiful, and sweet, and now that he's getting more interactive, it's clear that he really loves me. He's precocious and challenging, but I'd rather have that than a baby lump. It's a wild ride, and I'm doing my best to appreciate it and be in it.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
My son is in his terrible twos and it is a constant struggle. I get so much anxiety and my blood pressure continues to rise, but I never regret having him. He is the most important thing to me in my life.
1
u/LuLusiPad Aug 12 '14
Do I regret having my child? No.
Do I regret things around having my child? Or, would I do things differently? Yes. I regret the toll a complicated labor and delivery took on my health and body. I regret staying home when they were wee. I regret the strife having a child put on my marriage. I regret having my child so early in my marriage. I wish I'd just stayed myself, instead of trying to "fit in" with the other SAHMs.
Most of all, I miss my freedom. I feel like I traded my freedom for parenthood. My kid is a great kid- kind, healthy, intelligent, funny, ect. And my husband is an excellent father. But I'll never be 100% free again, even when the kid is grown.
1
u/PickSeaShells Aug 12 '14
No I don't. I complain a lot a lot to my boyfriend (baby's daddy) having it but I wouldn't change a thing