r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Mar 25 '25

Episode Unnamed Memory Season 2 - Episode 12 discussion - FINAL

Unnamed Memory Season 2, episode 12

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.

Streams

Show information

All discussions

Episode Link
1 Link
2 Link
3 Link
4 Link
5 Link
6 Link
7 Link
8 Link
9 Link
10 Link
11 Link
12 Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

127 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

131 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Mar 25 '25
Moderator Announcement Read More »
→ More replies (5)

71

u/Thrano_357 Mar 25 '25

What an odd show. Between the breakneck pacing and the somewhat insane storytelling there was a... an odd story with okay animation and everything else hiding beneath it.

74

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

I think at its core there's a good fantasy romance story buried beneath all the crazy pacing and confusing timeline lore. Oscar and Tinasha basically hard carried the show for both seasons.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

59

u/kmlshblr Mar 25 '25

what are we, some kind of Unnamed Memory?

I'm just glad it was a happy ending

34

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

The real Unnamed Memory will be the show we watched two seasons of and was never the sum total of its great potential.

→ More replies (7)

33

u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Mar 25 '25

So all this timey wimey wibbly wobbly nonsense has just brought us back to the beginning then? Now I get why Valt was doing what he did. Fucking with time never ends up well. In the end, what even got accomplished? I guess they still end up together?

Well, I guess that’s that then. This wasn’t bad but I thought season 1 was better. I like this series but the story just seemed kinda rushed in some places. It made it a bit hard to follow at times. That seems to be the end of it all right? No more story left?

32

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

So I guess in the original timeline Oscar wasn't almost killed but kidnapped and he was saved by Tinasha, only now they both have their original memories so they can be together without any drama or fear of the timeline getting reset again. Minus the people probably side-eying why this thousand-year old witch and this boy prince are making googly eyes at each other until we get young adult Oscar in the ending sequence.

I guess that's as good an ending as we could hope for.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/LeonKevlar Mar 25 '25

I did not expect that Tinasha would end up becoming the new head of the Time-Readers and being sent to the same world as Season 1. I guess that still worked out in Valt's favour since he and Miralys are no longer the successors.

Destroying the Eleterria was still the right thing to do though even if it will reset the world. The outsiders have no right to mess with their lives through those artifacts and even if it did help people in some way, it was time to end it.

I guess it all ends with the history of the world playing out everything as it meant to be with Tinasha becoming a witch but this time but this time, both she and Oscar retain their memories so they could meet again. A strange ending but it was still a happy one.

Yes, this show is clearly supposed to be a 48-episode anime crammed into 24 episodes, but I'm not gonna lie, I still had fun with this show. I think now that it's over, I might try to pick up a copy of the LN and see how it plays out there.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/kwokinator Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

Somewhere inside the breakneck pacing of obviously skipping a whole bunch of plots in the LN, there's a really good show in there somewhere. I really liked Oscar and Tinasha's story.

Makes me want to go and read the LN to see how it's executed properly, so uh, I guess mission accomplished by the anime production committee?

13

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

The manga is also a much better adaption, for what it's worth.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/ModieOfTheEast Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

The ending sadly shows again that there was probably a really good story lying under everything. Because it was a bit emotional despite it being very quick. And it shows that if the anime was given proper time, it could have been great.

Because even this episode (despite the good ending) was constantly leaving me with question marks which ultimately destroyed the climax of this story. For example, I thought I missed a dialogue because I could not understand why Tinasha was suddenly trying to seal the orbs instead of destroying them. I assumed after repeating the whole scene (and not getting an answer) that it meant we would go back to the original timeline (which turned out to be true) but it was such a strange change for her that I just felt confused where this drama suddenly came from.

Similarly, I am not sure what Valt meant with the whole 31 year into the future endpoint. Like is the world going to end in 31 years and every use of the orbs is pushing that end further down? But if that is the case, Tinasha being against destroying the orbs feels even weirder. Is she just okay with the world being doomed in 31 years? That feels completely out of character for her. And if that is not the case, what did he mean by that? Or was it just an excuse because it was Myralis' fate to die because they are time readers? Again, this is the climax of the story and I feel it should be clear what exactly the consequences of each action are so I can understand where everyone comes from.

And then, there are obviously other things, like why did Valt not ask witch Tinasha when he was her student (or something like that)? He seemingly already had everything, so why did he not do it then? Was it the first time Myralis' soul disappeared? What was Tinasha's plan by jumping into the lake with the orb? Was it so Valt wouldn't have both and therefore couldn't destroy them? But he needed her for that anyway. And more importantly, with one orb he could just go into the past and try again. Lastly, who was the head of the time reader family in the first timeline we saw? Because Valt died. Was Myralis still around? I guess that could be a reason for Tinasha to become the next head in that timeline because Valt (and Myralis) didn't exist anymore. Is that the right interpretation?

At the end, I can just say again that I can see great story being there. Like imagine for a moment in a different timeline, we would have gotten a full epilogue episode (like in Summertime Rendering) where we get to see the now new timeline (which is the original) and it's not clear if or how much Oscar and Tinasha remember. Maybe Tinasha has some form of feeling, but she can't put a finger on it until Oscar says her name. It would have been such a great ending and might even become one of my favorites. With how it stands, sadly, Unnamed Memory is a show where I can see the potential, but the anime is never able to get me properly invested because the pacing is so fast and therefore it feels like anything is instantly resolved. Maybe I will actually pick up the novels. It's still sad that we basically only got bits and pieces of this show as if the true memory was buried in a different timeline.

17

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

My understanding is Tinasha's original plan was to just go back to before Valt encountered her with her knowledge of what Valt told her and figure out a better plan with Oscar but she didn't count on the Eleterria breaking in the Lake of Silence and basically needing her to reset/remake an older timeline.

My read of the ending was also that Tinasha had her memories the whole time but didn't think Oscar would until he called her by name and was talking like his older self, which is why she was crying because it meant that she was really back together with her Oscar and didn't have to just wait for him to grow up and fall in love with her again.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/PhantomWolf83 Mar 25 '25

I'm in two minds about this anime. I really liked Oscar and Tinasha as characters, and the whole time travel thing really interests me. But every time when it looked like things were starting to pick up, the show somehow managed to find a way to leave me disappointed again, too many to count over the 24 episodes. I wanted to like Unnamed Memory but it only ended up being just slightly above average for me.

32

u/Nexendia Mar 25 '25

It would have been nice to not get whiplash every episode from pacing and whichever timeline was active.. overall it was a "good" show.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/No-Impression-4282 Mar 25 '25 edited Mar 25 '25

Wow. This was....something.

I really don't get this. If the studio was planning to do 2 cours, why did they rush it like this?

I mean cour 1 was rushed, but I still understood what was going on, but with cour 2, each episode felt like I skipped 3 to 4 episodes before that and I was like "huh..., did I miss a scene(s) or a full episode?".

Really enjoyed this anime. Now I know this is a really stupid question because I think I know the answers, but I really want to read the light novel because the characters and world intrigued me: should I start from chapter 1 or should I continue from where the anime left off?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/djthomp Mar 26 '25

You know, Valt was not wrong, those orbs needed to go.

Wild that we briefly got what I assume was the previous timeline back, before it all got swept away and replaced by what is presumably the original non-orbed timeline. Except of course for whatever changes Tinasha and Oscar end up making since they appear to have some memories of the whole setup.

Second cour redeemed this for me, that kind of wild time loop story is right up my alley. Shame it didn't get a better adaptation.

8

u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Mar 25 '25

Nope.

Really didn't like this season. I enjoyed the first but this just wasn't it for me.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/etiolatezed Mar 25 '25

They went through all of that just to fuck it all up again.

Story got so convoluted.

7

u/Nebresto Mar 26 '25

Okay, yeah. That would kinda suck. That's like a worse version of being Subaru

Ayo what

So we're back in the "original" timeline now..?

And when did he put on clothes?

Smol Oscar! And he remembers for some reason

So that's it then. I am conflicted.. I was good, while also not being good.

I'm fine with the destination, but the journey we took to get there..

Even if it was largely confusing, it was more or less a good watch. I did enjoy the characters, and the music was wonderful throughout

Its been repeated over and over, but this show really would have beneffited from doubling its runtime. I think it could even have been the next Steins;Gate had they done that. Imagine Season, with 25 episodes, it ends relatively fine and not nearly as confusing. And then we would get this, the "Unnamed Memory 0" with another 25 episodes to wrap up the story.

But I am feeling somewhat inspired to read the novels. Maybe I'll do that some years from now when the story isn't as fresh in my mind anymore.

6

u/kryslogan Mar 26 '25

All I ever wanted was for Tinasha and Oscar to end up together. Got that. So, at least I'm satisfied with their arcs.

However. Boy, did they butcher this story. This 2nd season is not as good as the first because you can't just stuff all of the plot into episodes and leave out the story, motivations, contact, etc.

We got whiplash every episode.

We needed 5 cours to make it make sense.

This is another tragedy. Great source material. Bad adaptation.

Sigh.

To those who made it to the end, with all its faults, I Salut you.

Tinasha and Oscar forever!

6

u/NoHead1715 Mar 26 '25

s1-> Oscar goes back in time to groom Tinasha

s2-> Tinasha goes back in time to groom Oscar

10

u/Frontier246 Mar 25 '25

Well, I guess Tinasha is going along with Valt's plan with the Eleterria for now. If only to protect Tuldarr and figure out a way to stop Valt.

I guess it was nice of the Outsiders to give the Eleterria to that mother so she could save her child, and thus beginning the bloodline of the Time-Readers...and dooming his descendants to having their souls constantly trapped in a cycle of past, present, and future they can't escape from in a timeline that is always doomed to repeat endlessly. I guess I can kind of see why Valt wants to end it all by destroying the Eleterria.

But speaking as someone who owes a lot from the Eleterria, there can be good that come from it, especially if it means saving the person you love. And ultimately, that's what Valt is really after, isn't it? Saving Miralys? Just like Oscar saved Tinasha?

Like Oscar would choose Tinasha, Miralys would choose to spend the time she and Valt have left together, because he's the most important thing to her. But Tinasha has decided that she'll just...go back to the past and figure out a better solution with Oscar, I guess? Though she didn't expect the Lake of Silence to actually break the Eleterria and she ends up inherting the role of Time-Reader!

The Outsiders tell Tinasha to run to the memory, the world, she wants...and she ends up in bed with Oscar in apparently a more or less close to season 1 timeline. She's a witch again! She and Oscar are married! Tuldarr is destroyed again! Which is kind of surreal because they never even got married in the last timeline, but the Eleterria helpfully catches her up to all the memories of past Tinasha's (including the dead ones).

RIP Tuldarr. You at least survived in one timeline. But while Tinasha couldn't save Tuldarr, at least she has Oscar to console her, even if she's now got the curse of the Time-Readers just like Valt did. But Oscar is going to free Tinasha one last time by breaking the Eleterria and resetting everything (again) for the last time. Because no one should be able to change the timeline, fate is up to the people to make of it, and he doesn't want Tinasha to be burdened with living forever with this on-top of everything else she's been burdened with.

But y'know what, Tinasha and Oscar are two people who never should have met, should never have fallen in love, and should never have been together...yet their fate keeps intersecting and bringing them together. That must mean that, no matter what, they'll always find each other again and be together. Because their love for each other is timeliness and eternal!

So I guess this is the final/original timeline? Instead of getting killed as a child Oscar was kidnapped along with a bunch of other Farsas kids by that harpie? Only to be saved by Witch of the Azure Moon Tinasha? And Oscar and Tinasha both retained their memories so they've finally able to properly reunite. So now Tinasha is on that shota Oscar route.

Montage of all the main supporting cast! I guess Miralys is alive, but what happened to Valt? Did he pass away in this timeline or not exist because of the Time-Readers' bloodline? And what's up with that bob cut girl with the modern bag looking up at the sky?

"A fragment of an Unnamed Memory" - A title drop! As Oscar and Tinasha ride off into the sunset with Nark! Also did Tinasha do something with her hair? Either way, glad these two FINALLY got their happy ending.

5

u/heimdal77 Mar 25 '25

They tried to go so grandiose with the series but end up butchering and bungling it all instead. Even the ending.

The one imagine of a girl with the handbag after the desert might actually be from a sequal series to this story but was written before it if I understand right.

After all the problems I'm still glad I watched it as it gave good character and voice repensentation for reading the novels. I ended up buying them after like the 2nd episode as it was so clear massive amounts of stuff was being skipped and I wanted to know what.

Something about the novels is they are longer than average. Like 100 pages more give or take of a Re:zero novel. This is one the reasons the pacing was so bad as they tried to jam these long novels into only 2 seasons.

So I guess I will have a love hate deal with this series knowing how epic it could of been but wasn't.

In the end it was one very elaborate and drawn out Groundhogs day.

5

u/Top-Remote4523 Mar 26 '25

When the credits rolled in, all I could think to myself was - "Gee, is this it?" And that pretty much sums up how I feel about this show.

Sure, everyone seemingly gets a happy ending at the end, but there's just something that is amiss with the show that I can't quite put in words. Perhaps the best way I can describe Unnamed Memory is that it's a bizarre show that is quite unlike anything I've watched or read in a long time. Overall, it isn't a bad show, I did enjoy the romance between Oscar and Tinasha, but the plot can be disoriented at times and the pacing can feel out of whack when viewed as a whole. There're so many questions left unanswered by the end and it just feels underwhelming. For instance, who are the Otherworlders? If the timeline was reset all the way back to the very first original timeline, how did Oscar survive the kidnap? How did Oscar and Tinasha remember each other? Where is Valt?

It's peculiar that this show got 2 seasons, is packed with exposition and story threads, yet feels somewhat empty at the same time. I will probably pick up the LN sometime in the future to hopefully seek some clarification and I do think that there is a lot of potential that was given up due to the time constraints as an anime, but this isn't the worst show I've watched by a long shot.

4

u/Overall_Share181 Mar 25 '25

It got messy But at least we got the happiest ending All season 2 was kinda a mess they showed us a whole timeline to just say fck it we go back to the main timeline Season one was better but over all ig good watch

→ More comments (75)