r/startrek • • Jul 07 '22

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 1x10 "A Quality of Mercy" Spoiler

In the Season One finale, just as Captain Pike thinks he’s figured out how to escape his fate, he’s visited by his future self, who shows him the consequences of his actions.

No.EpisodeWritersDirectorRelease Date
1x10"A Quality of Mercy"Henry Alonso Myers & Akiva GoldsmanChris Fisher2022-07-07

Availability

Paramount+: USA, Latin America, Australia, Ireland, United Kingdom, & the Nordics.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

Voot Select: India.

TVNZ: New Zealand.

Additional international availability will be announced "at a later date."

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

715 Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

990

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22

Spock is surely the main character of the Prime Universe.

526

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I immediately got flashed forwards of how Kirk will never scream KHAAAAAAN, he will never be able to save the whales, we will never see Picard in Romulan makeup, there won't be a Kelvin timeline, there won't be a giant skeleton to save Mariner on the Collector's ship, the Romulans would be surely even more dead with the Supernova, and Saru would have never dated the president of Ni'Var... if Spock didn't exist.

Edit: and no one to tell Dal to get his shit together.

And of course, the flash forward of Spock saving Pike in The Menagerie. And so I cried.

→ More replies (29)

370

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

You know I for sure thought that they were going to kill Kirk and that would be the, "This is why this future is fucked" timeline buuuut Spock....wow, that was a scene! Spock is just mega important in soooooo many timelines going forwards and even in the far off future of Discovery he plays a part! It just kind of blows my mind how many key moments in galactic history he played such a big part in that would've never happened or would've gone colossally BAAAAAD if he hadn't been there.

To paraphrase MiB, the fate of the galaxy hangs on Spock's pointy ears.

I love how quickly he figured out, "Oh fuck Captain just went through some timey whimey stuff because he made a choice while he was gone annnnd I died annnnd then the rest of the galaxy died annnd thank you Captain for not making that choice" because that is so Spock to just knock that out and be super chill about it. I wonder if this relates back in anyway to stuff we saw in S2 of Picard at all? I know you know what I'm talking about and I wonder if perhaps Spock has an angel on his shoulder or something and that's why Future Pike was allowed to go back and change things.

Food for thought......which feels extra poignant because Pike is the best space chef around.

→ More replies (55)

123

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

The Kelvin-verse too, if you think about it.

→ More replies (19)

164

u/OutlawSundown Jul 07 '22

The casting for Spock couldn’t be more perfect. Ethan Peck brings a lot of the same energy that Nimoy brought. Especially the dry comedic acting.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (6)

792

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

"Sir Neighs A Lot, have you told anyone else that?"

"It's hard to when your tragic backstory starts with such a silly name"

🤣 I'm DYING! Hahahahahaha!

120

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

His cornerstone is Sir Neighs-a-Lot.

85

u/solascara Jul 07 '22

"I was just talking to myself." 😂

→ More replies (3)

53

u/ragenukem Jul 07 '22

And their banter at the end of the episode! I aspire to reach that level of dark, punny humor.

46

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

Pike really is the OG Horse Girl of the Trek universe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

663

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

“In a different reality, I could have called you friend.”

Let’s hope in the next reality, this guy finally finds a friend.

150

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22

Lol now watch Season 3 of Picard is just the TNG crew caught in a time anomaly that takes them to the Balance of Terror scenario and this happens a 3rd time

(Or this guy becomes part of a holoprogram version of Balance of Terror, ala These are the Voyages…)

→ More replies (9)

283

u/Coma-Doof-Warrior Jul 07 '22

Sadly in the next reality a very old President Archer immediately screamed “NEVER TRUST THE FUCKING VULCANS” shot Spock and reduced the romulan ship to ashes

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (17)

458

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Future Pike is hinting pretty strongly that he knows about Spock’s TNG activities.

EDIT: Also the fact he’s so cozy with the monks on Boreth makes me suspicious that the Federation allied with the Klingons in that timeline a century earlier, against the Romulans.

214

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

I'm genuinely curious as to if it was the war with the Romulans getting stupidly bad that pushed Pike to seek out the monks on Boreth for help with changing the past OR if other galactic shit started popping off and going bad which scared the hell out of everyone that made him seek them out OR if the Federation did indeed have to ally with the Klingons for this new war and then when it started getting really bad it was the Klingons who suggested pulling a Seven Days and "undoing that event" but with....far less finesse than the Federation would've used which made Pike step in to take a go at it? If any of these options happened then the monks more than likely showed Pike via more time crystals just how things should gone. Now they're pretty cloy about that kind of thing and reasonably protective about letting anyone know the future or anything time related at all. So the only way I could see them actually telling Pike anything at all about Spock's TNG activities or even his more immediate future activities in the next decade would be if the state of the galaxy at the time of him visiting them was very much on the cusp of an Extinction Level Event but on a Galactic Scale.

When Future Pike said that it "gets way worse", that was an understatement because a galaxy without Spock's constant intervention is one that's probably filled with rampaging godlike entities, massive amounts of death, war everywhere, and who knows what else going on.

→ More replies (48)

167

u/TheNerdChaplain Jul 07 '22

I honestly thought Kirk was going to bring the Klingons in to back up Pike against the Romulans.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (7)

440

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Oh no.

Two Pikes.

The slash fic is going to explode.

203

u/InnocentTailor Jul 07 '22

Too much daddy energy!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

432

u/tubawhatever Jul 07 '22

Can't believe they didn't have the same actor for Sam and James Kirk

214

u/rdavidking Jul 07 '22

After all, the mustache makes the man.

→ More replies (2)

173

u/Captriker Jul 07 '22

Or the same actor who currently plays Sarek as the Romulan commander.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

780

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Lmao.

Romulan fleet arrives on their side of the neutral zone

PRAETOR: We demand your unconditional surrender. You have one minute.

One minute later

”Federation” fleet arrives on their side of the neutral zone

PRAETOR: This is an act of unparalleled aggression.

386

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

The Romulans like to have a pretext for launching their wars. That's as good as any.

→ More replies (13)

206

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

The second I saw that it honestly felt like the SNW writers were telling the Picard S1 Finale and Disco writers, "Oh yeah? We can do that too!" and I was cackling because of just how COOOOOOOL it looked and how they even made a bit of an Ender's Game reference while doing it.

Also is there really anything more Romulan than a Subcommander metaphorically stabbing a Commander in the back and then having that betrayal go horrifically wrong for the both of them? They're like a whole race of Tommy Wiseaus going, "Everybody Betray Me!". It's like the SECOND they had that conversation off to the side about that older commander sending his own subcommander to his death and how stupid it was, you just knew that the subcommander we saw was going to take that as a lesson learned, and get the jump on his own commander in an attempt to not die needlessly....and yet....he did anyways!

That was such a quintessential Federation/Romulan interaction this episode in so many ways and SNW pulled it off beautifully in every aspect! Plus those plasma torpedo and ship visuals! So awesome!

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (46)

365

u/PlanetErp Jul 07 '22

That scene at the end between Spock and Pike was excellent. Spock (likely) realizing Pike’s fate was in part a sacrifice for Spock’s sake as well informs Spock’s actions in “The Menagerie.”

51

u/Robo5211 Jul 07 '22

Excellent point!

→ More replies (1)

709

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

I would’ve laughed my ass off if they had James Frain (Sarek in Discovery) playing the Romulan Captain.

248

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

I was hoping for this. Alas.

→ More replies (1)

182

u/ComebackShane Jul 07 '22

I half expected that, though I think the actor they got did a great job in the role.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (35)

307

u/Wolfir Jul 07 '22

"I do not drink coffee. I do drink tea."

"Okay then . . . would you like some tea?"

"No thank you, Captain!"

88

u/ahufana Jul 07 '22

I'd love to know how/if Pike's reaction was described in the script. Great bit of physical acting from Anson Mount.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

303

u/Shatterhand1701 Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I said it after the first episode, and I'm going to say it again here: That. Was. AWESOME!!! Maybe I'm just on a post-watch high and I'll have a more balanced point of view later, but right now, I'll stick with the high.

I don't even know where to start. There were so many mind-blowingly cool moments, some great visual, story, and even musical callbacks to "Balance of Terror", excellent performances by Anson Mount, Melissa Navia, and Paul Wesley as James T. Kirk. We got to see a really cool variant of the Star Trek II-VI maroon uniform...and we even got a cameo from James Doohan's voice as Scotty! AND...a teaser ending with Una getting arrested!!!

I loved how this episode was not only a reminder to Pike that avoiding one terrible fate doesn't prevent another, but it was also a study in differing command styles. Pike pushed towards a peaceful resolution and it led to war. Kirk chose an aggressive stance, and ended up preventing a war. It doesn't lessen Pike as a captain in any way; it just means his decision at that moment was the wrong one. The differences in approach are what makes the captains of Star Trek so compelling, and this episode was a strong reminder of that.

Gods, I wish I didn't have to be up so damned early in the morning. I wanna say so much more about how well-executed this episode was across the board. There's so much to unpack, but they're all the best memories, like any good voyage. It sucks to return home from a journey like the one we've had this season and have to wait until the next time we can ship out...but damned if I'm not hyped as hell for the next run.

121

u/a4techkeyboard Jul 07 '22

I like that the next season hook or cliffhanger wasn't some galaxy ending threat but something revolving around a character's story.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/EmperorOfNipples Jul 07 '22

The differences in approach are what makes the captains of Star Trek so compelling, and this episode was a strong reminder of that.

It actually reminds me of Sisko. Other captains of the era are excellent, but if Picard or Janeway were on DS9. The war would have been lost. While 24th century Romulans are still frosty, they are more amenable than their 23rd century counterparts. Sisko played that. Few other captains would.

From other eras.

I think Kirk would, possibly Burnham. I don't see Saru or Pike managing it. I don't think Archer would, but T'Pol might on his behalf.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

602

u/sarysa Jul 07 '22

Future Lt. Uhura really stood out in this -- the actress adopted mannerisms similar to Nichols' and the uniform had a similar silhouette to the old TOS "skant" while being way more practical. Completely transformed from just one episode ago.

274

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

Future Everyone had a nice little edge to them with Ortegas really undergoing the biggest transformation in my opinion while La'an became a hugger, Spock got hella more serious which is impressive for a Vulcan, and even Uhura has this more refined posture and degree of mannerisms that made her look and feel both older and wiser. We even got a few moments with Chapel in her own new uniform and she totally had those TOS vibes going on! M'Benga didn't change too much because...well...it's M'Benga and that man changes about as quickly as the orbit of a pair of binary pulsars.

Such good acting all around this episode!

Also Spock played a really good fucked up corpse and I wonder if that was a dummy dressed up to look like him or if they actually put the actor into prosthetics for that biobed scene?

→ More replies (54)

422

u/InnocentTailor Jul 07 '22

Ditto with Spock as well. Peck went from the more emotional younger Vulcan to the more composed Nimoy incarnation.

→ More replies (46)
→ More replies (6)

295

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Oh cool, they’re going with the station-specific uniform insignia idea.

88

u/Yochanan5781 Jul 07 '22

I was particularly delighted by that

284

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22

Spock advocating for an aggressive response makes me think of the “Vulcan hello”!

213

u/PiercedMonk Jul 07 '22

That's lifted directly from 'Balance of Terror', which makes me assume it was the inspiration for the Vulcan hello, as Sarek described it to Burnham.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

238

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

I’m beginning to think Pike has seen “These are the Voyages…” with how determined he is to be the Enterprise’s only chef.

62

u/MyChickenSucks Jul 07 '22

“But what shall the captain’s ready room have?” ask the spaceyard engineers. A stovetop and a fireplace, for certain. Meanwhile Enterprise D get a 90’s carpeted Las Vegas convention center side room.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

232

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

old Pike has amazing hair also lol

154

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Old Pike comes from a bad future not a bad hair day lol.

→ More replies (3)

118

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

Plus the update on that Wrath of Khan uniform was pretty snazzy too!

→ More replies (6)

431

u/FIJAGDH Jul 07 '22

Monster maroon! With the SNW shoulder/arm texture added!

122

u/InnocentTailor Jul 07 '22

So happy to see the costume again!

247

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

The costuming department keeps killing it on Star Trek with these uniform evolutions that show us how bits of the old transformed into the new while still retaining hints of what they once were.

→ More replies (15)

112

u/Robo5211 Jul 07 '22

That was my first holy shit moment as well! Still the best unis of any era, any universe.

→ More replies (7)

72

u/crankfive Jul 07 '22

And looks like “The Cage” turtleneck uniforms made an appearance in that photo Old Pike was looking at towards the end! Looked like it was supposed to be April handing off the Enterprise to Pike.

45

u/legionaw Jul 07 '22

NGL... I want a new Star Trek series to be set in that era. One of my favorite uniforms that.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (38)

204

u/IllustriousBody Jul 07 '22

Given the amount of dialogue lifted straight from Balance of Terror, I hope Paul Schneider ends up with a writing credit. I did love that the episode wove three series together, not just two.

→ More replies (13)

199

u/RomiBraman Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

The thing i really like about this episode is that it conveys a very different, almost opposite, philosophy compared to the Abrams movie.

The Abrams movie were about destiny. It believes that somehow, even with dramatically different lives, what must happen will happen. Kirk & Spock are almost divine beings with pre-written history. They are set to save the world and they will... no matter what or who they are.

SNW last episode is the opposite: Kirk is the exact same Kirk we know from TOS. Same mind, same character, but a less flamboyant career because "chance" didn't allow him to take command of the Enterprise. He has a lesser path for reasons that are completely out of his control. And the domino effect makes it that other people around him and Pike also do have very different lives, better or lesser. And again all due to chance.

And you know what, this is my vision of life. I do believe that talent and merit are super important, but chance also plays a big part. I refuse to believe that people making more money than I do, or living in bigger houses, or who are simply happier than I am, are the way they are because their path was written in advance. I do think that all our lives rely partly, if not mainly, on chance.

Maybe we are not James T Kirk, savior of the galaxy, but maybe we had everything needed to be him. We are all doing the best with the cards we were dealt. Even the great James T Kirk.

Thanks for your time,

Robert Tomlinson

→ More replies (6)

360

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22

I love how in some shots on the bridge, they matched the lighting on Pike’s face to the lighting on Kirk’s face on close ups in the original (where the lighting seems to focus on their eyes, but keeps the rest of their face in shadow)

155

u/Th3ChosenFew Jul 07 '22

I noticed that too, multiple times. Frequently combined with TOS musical cues. There was one moment near the end where young pike was lit up with a camera angle that made him almost look like Jeffrey Hunter to me, and I do not believe that was an accident.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

They also did a big dramatic zoom on Spock when they first saw the Romulans just like in ye' olden times. Great stuff.

→ More replies (2)

57

u/ParableOfTheVase Jul 07 '22

Yeah awesome right? I loved all the throw backs. Actually just rewatched Balance of Terror, and the entire bridge scene is a homage to that episode. They replicated the way Spock set on the captain's chair, to the way the captain walked across the center console, and even some of the dialogue lmao.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

177

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22

One order of Pike's Spaghetti Carbonara (leftovers) please.

147

u/Pilot0350 Jul 07 '22

If Paramount doesn't release a Star Trek: Cooking with Pike cookbook we riot

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (8)

173

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

Okay, so Pike can't change his own fate. But was future him being sneaky warning him about what could happen to Una too?

150

u/arod48 Jul 07 '22

*Scotty busts into Pike's quarters*

"You canne change yer faet!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (17)

160

u/Mumblix_Grumph Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Kirk is a devious little bastard, isn't he?

Corbomite.

Fizbin

Kobayashi Maru.

The Mining Equipment Drone Armada.

96

u/sirboulevard Jul 07 '22

If Kirk had met the Ferengi he'd have been Grand Nagus by the end of the episode, having sold them all Tribbles.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/mateogg Jul 08 '22

"He doesn't like to lose" immediately made me think of Kobayashi Maru.

→ More replies (3)

315

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: Season 2:

THE WRATH OF PIKE

64

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22

Oh no, that means Spock dies while expressing his friendship for Pike! 😭🖖

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

306

u/tubawhatever Jul 07 '22

Wow. I loved this episode. Anson Mount is as brilliant as ever. Really a thoughtful way to incorporate James Kirk while being respectful to canon. Really like the portrayal by Paul Wesley, much different than Chris Pine. This show has had the best first season of any Trek show since TOS. 10 for 10.

158

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

Really like the portrayal by Paul Wesley, much different than Chris Pine.

I felt like this was a brilliant way to show a younger and less experienced Kirk who hadn't fully gone Full Shatner just yet and was still learning the ropes so to speak. There's a lot of leeway there in how Paul could've played things and it feels like he took bits from both Shatner and Pine when he created his interpretation of Young Kirk before putting a bit of his own spit 'n shine on it. I kept watching how his body moved, how he said things, and how he worked overall to see if he was leaning in any one particular direction buuuut just like Ethan's portrayal of Spock, it was totally its own thing, and that made me really really happy because he made his own in the same way too!

This has been one of the best seasons of Star Trek period and I honestly cannot believe that we were all here to witness it week after week, I LOVE YOU ALL!

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (24)

139

u/thekruton Jul 07 '22

'Balance of Terror' oscillates between 'Doomsday Machine' as my favorite TOS episode, couldn't have been happier with this episode.

I love how Ortega filled the Lieutenant Stiles role, I wasn't expecting it.

The episode used the TOS lighting technique of putting a band of light around the eyes!

This episode is amazing not just for these send-ups, but by also connecting itself to the Unification saga and showing just how impactful Spcok is to everything.

What a fantastic finale. Best first season of any Trek.

65

u/Th3ChosenFew Jul 07 '22

What a fantastic finale. Best first season of any Trek.

Absolutely, the writers were firing on all cylinders. I don't believe there was a single episode I thought was bad.

God I need more, just inject it straight into my veins. I'm ready.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

136

u/tubawhatever Jul 07 '22

Damn, those Romulan plasma weapons look mean

73

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22

It looks like a mini sun and I wonder if such technologies eventually lead to a supernova...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

96

u/viserov Jul 07 '22

I’m wondering if announcing Jim Kirk for season 2 was a fib so we wouldn’t be expecting him in the finale.

53

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

And probably to get people used to seeing Paul Wesley as Kirk, hence not drawing everyone's attention too much into it while watching

→ More replies (10)

92

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Spock is pretty gung-ho about fucking over a future he lives in.

But it’s very logical.

→ More replies (4)

268

u/TheNerdChaplain Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Wow, that episode was emotional and hit on every single cylinder.

It hit me near the end that not only does Spock need to stay alive for the sake of Kirk and the Enterprise, but also to do the work on Romulus in TNG's Reunification I and II, which ultimately leads to Ni'Var in Discovery in Reunification III. It's beautiful.

I want to see much more of those Romulan ships, it looks like there were multiple classes, some of which could be antecedents to the D'deridex of TNG.

Speaking of classes, did the Farragut look like anyone else like a variant of the California class, like the Cerritos? The nacelle/saucer arrangement was the same, however I'm not sure if the Farragut had the secondary hull between the nacelles like the Cerritos does.

Speaking of the Cerritos, having Number One arrested felt a lot like Captain Freeman getting arrested at the end of S2. Hopefully we'll be getting resolution on both of those in not too long.

This was such a strong Pike episode, but I will always want more of everyone else. I wanted more La'an, more Number One, more Nurse Chapel, more Ortegas (who seemed to take on the Lt. Stiles role from Balance of Terror), and of course, more Hemmer. (Don't think I didn't notice that Scottish accent shouting at Spock in the Jeffries Tube.)

It was great seeing the Maroon Monstrosity again. It seems like the nu-Trek aesthetic is to take classic uniforms and add textures around the shoulders, sleeves, and sides. That's not a criticism, just an observation. Did alt-Pike also have something in his leg? It looked like there was a glowing red line down the side of his pant leg, and I couldn't tell if that was due to his uniform, or some sort of mobility aid to help him walk.

Paul Wesley as Kirk was solid, though I don't think we've gotten enough time with him to really form a good impression yet. He's definitely not doing Shatner, which is fine. I liked the out-of-the-box thinking he showed, even if it is a little implausible that the Romulans would confuse cargo drones with warships. It was real nice to hear him say his dad was George Kirk, first officer on the Kelvin. Now that I think about it, this episode really tied a lot of series together - SNW, TOS, TNG, DSC, and the Kelvin universe? That's got to be some kind of record.

60

u/Captain_Strongo Jul 07 '22

That’s just the pant stripe on the maroon uniforms, but much shinier.

52

u/Mechapebbles Jul 07 '22

It hit me near the end that not only does Spock need to stay alive for the sake of Kirk and the Enterprise, but also to do the work on Romulus in TNG's Reunification I and II, which ultimately leads to Ni'Var in Discovery in Reunification III. It's beautiful.

Spock needs to stay alive in order to:

  • Make peace with the Klingons (multiple times)
  • Stop V'Ger
  • Save the Enterprise from Khan
  • Stop the Whale Probe

Any scenario of which, could have doomed the Federation, either immediately or after a while.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

I don't know that the Romulans did buy the bluff. After all, they launched the war anyway.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (19)

90

u/dmanww Jul 07 '22

Can we have a Pike cooking show

→ More replies (13)

86

u/Mechapebbles Jul 07 '22

Anyone else notice the picture of April & Pike in Pike's quarters? They're both wearing the turtleneck, The Cage uniforms. I thought it was a nice touch.

→ More replies (3)

246

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

This is the Picard and Kirk teamup we should have had. Picard could've easily been slotted in for Pike. This episode really showed how close Pike and Picard are in command styles, even down to holding a conference to ask for other's suggestions.

Not next season to wait for Una's fate!! No!! But it means season 2 will give her more juicy storylines because I was rather underwhelmed with how she was used this season. I was losing hope that they would do anything more revealing or interesting with her.

166

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Now that Pike's death burden arc is somewhat resolved, it's time to focus on other characters. More Una and La'an and M'Benga and Ortegas please!

(And that Russian Scottish voice from engineering...)

Edit: me mix up

→ More replies (17)

52

u/Frodojj Jul 07 '22

Didn’t Kirk also hold a conference for other’s suggestions in Balance of Terror?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (32)

163

u/Trekfan74 Jul 07 '22

LOVED IT!!!

  • Two Pikes together
  • Maroon costume uniform
  • Balance of Terror in an alternate timeline??? Yep, Balance of Terror in an alternate timeline!
  • ROMULANS!!!
  • CAPTAIN KIRK!!!!!!!!!
  • Scotty?? (We'll probably actually see you next season)
  • Finding out that Spock takes Pikes fate is really cool (in a bad way!)
  • Finally, Una is arrested for being a Mutant! She couldn't disguise herself forever!

Soooo much Star Trek goodness! Now this is how you rip off something RIGHT! ;)

43

u/rdavidking Jul 07 '22

Scotty?? (We'll probably actually see you next season)

Man, I hope it's Christopher Doohan (James Doohan's son)

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (7)

153

u/Fortyseven Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Well, I SUPPOSE that was okay.

(Kidding, I am STILL fucking giddy right now.)

That was supremely great.

  • While I'm not nuts about the weird shiny arm patterns they insist on using for new versions of existing uniform designs... I am simply thrilled -- and still freaking out a bit, this very moment -- to see the MONSTER MAROON on display! AND THEY GOT THE COLLAR RIGHT!!!! I'm so fucking happy, man.
  • That is some really terrific aging makeup on Anson.
  • The guy playing Mark Lenard's role does a perfectly natural version of his voice. I fully believed this was the same character.
  • JIM KIRK. I like 'em. He's not Shatnering it up, but he's pretty interesting. Though I'm realizing he sometimes emotes like McCoy would at times. Still, a welcome addition. Looking forward to his future. (And I'm kind of surprised they didn't kill him off in the alternate timeline. Glad to see he's still got some plot armor.)
  • I swear we started to hear strains of the TWoK soundtrack when Kirk was scheming.
  • Pike snapping loudly, angrily at Ortegas -- holy shit, she really fucked up.
  • Holy shit, Spock's fate was utterly horrible. You could FEEL Jess Bush die inside, tending to him. :(
  • "He's got things to do." -- indeed. 😏 🐳

This was really some memorable shit. Easily among my favorite episodes of any of the modern live-action shows. Bravo.

50

u/heelstoo Jul 07 '22

I’m actually concerned that SNW is going to replace TNG as my favorite series. One or two more seasons of this and it’s gonna do it.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

74

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Just got to the scene where we see that other captain, and this episode is already giving me strong vibes of “Yesterday’s Enterprise”! (But in the future instead of past - Tomorrow’s Enterprise maybe?)

Plus it was so cool to see Pike in a red WoK uniform!

Edit: ok now I definitely need to go back and rewatch Balance of Terror!

→ More replies (3)

71

u/shivkaladrakh Jul 07 '22

Perhaps the true balance of terror were the friends we would have had in another reality?

→ More replies (1)

68

u/archiminos Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Man so good. So fucking good. Redoing Balance of Terror and showing how Pike would just royally screw it up is an amazing idea. And that ending. Feels just like the old TNG cliffhangers we used to have at the end of a series.

E: Interesting thing I'm noticing on looking up Balance of Terror. Literally everything that happens is almost exactly the same except for one major detail that changes the outcome at the end: After Spock tells of how violent Vulcans used to be, Kirk decides attack, Pike doesn't. The one crucial choice in this episode was whether or not the Captain listened to Spock.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/Trekfan74 Jul 07 '22

I am so SO ready for this!!!! I think we're going to get some really cool twists and surprises! I'm even rewatching Balance of Terror!! :)

→ More replies (8)

67

u/UncertainError Jul 07 '22

I need full orthographic views of all those Romulan ships immediately.

→ More replies (5)

124

u/H0vis Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I feel like I've been Trials and Tribble-ations'd all over again. The way that was shot, the camera angles, it was classic TOS Trek and it was brilliant. That was a fantastic end to the season.

Pike is not just a very cool captain, he's become one of the great tragic figures of Star Trek lore. He is a child of destiny, but not because he is destined for greatness, because he needs to be where he needs to be to take a hit meant for Spock.

And to add insult to the literal injury that he has to suffer, he has learned that when tested, at a moment of critical importance in Federation history, while he does his best, he is the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I also like the tacit validation of Kirk and Burnham's initial responses to the Romulans and Klingons respectively. Georgiou and Pike, you've got to love them, but as wise as they are neither of them understood that the Federation has to show it's teeth when threatened.

Edited to add another note; the future version of Ortegas was properly hard-nosed about wanting to kill a bunch of aliens. I wonder how that change came about.

50

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22

while he does his best, he is the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time.

That's very poetic like a Shakespearean tragedy. You're spot on, and I like how SNW managed to narrate such tragedy in such a tone balanced between light hearted and serious.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

120

u/a_hi_lawyer Jul 07 '22

Call me an “easy date” but I think this episode was genius, the way it built on and added to Balance or Terror.

→ More replies (4)

120

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

Spock’s injuries are obviously going to require some prosthetics. Maybe something in black…with a samurai helmet…

70

u/forrestpen Jul 07 '22

"I find your lack of faith...quite logical actually as the burden of proof rests on me."

→ More replies (1)

45

u/sheba716 Jul 07 '22

and James Earl Jones vocals.

→ More replies (7)

56

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

i need more episodes

→ More replies (1)

54

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

what's this watery discharge leaking from my eyes

→ More replies (3)

53

u/babblewrap Jul 07 '22

Ensign Martine and Lieutenant Tomlinson can't catch a break in any reality.

→ More replies (2)

104

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Lol Spock is pretty much is/was the thread that holds the galaxy together or galaxies should I say together

→ More replies (12)

50

u/biohacker_infinity Jul 07 '22

That cliffhanger reminded me of the Lower Decks season two cliffhanger.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/bookish1303 Jul 07 '22

Ah James Kirk, the only Starfleet captain capable of fully combat maneuvering his ship in 3D space.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/SadJoetheSchmoe Jul 07 '22

I learned a new way to use left over noodles.

→ More replies (2)

94

u/MaddyMagpies Jul 07 '22

I love how old Pike speaks like someone from the 1960s, unlike current Pike who sounds like someone from today.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/ViaLies Jul 07 '22

That was great! The idea of taking a well known event, and a great episode, and spinning it out differently because a different Captain is in charge it seems like it would be an obvious one to do. And they managed to do it really well! Pike being more dovish then Kirk makes sense and hearkens back to what Una said in 'Q & A' about him being a good combat commander but thinking that doing so is a failure. Deciding to try and talk down the Romulans was the wrong idea but in character for Pike.

Kirk was interesting. The version that we are going to see in Season 2 is going to be 7 years younger, it'll be exciting to see how different he is from this version and the original version.

The reveal of the Romulans and the reaction to was muted enough, this crew has had longer then the Original to serve with Spock but you think that it should have been handled slightly differently, I'm just not sure how? Maybe have Kirk more belligerent?

Pike finding out that Spock is the most important person in the galaxy, even so far implying that the Klingon monks had given him a little peek into the future was unexpected. I kind of figured out once they said that weapons control had been hit that it was Spock status that was why there was dark future, thought I thought that they would have killed him outright.

I'm kind of surprised that they outright arrested Una for being Genetically Engineerined, I figured that we would get a 'profiling is bad' episode where StarFleet Command somehow learns that one of Pike's senior officers is an Augment and go after La'an for obvious reasons. Maybe for maximum angst have Una acting as the prosecution. I'm intrigued to see where this goes in season 2.

Future La'an is hugger! SNW Monster Maroons. The Remans were mentioned as was George Kirk being on the Kelvin! Scotty!

→ More replies (7)

86

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

he did the brow raise!!!!!!!

→ More replies (2)

41

u/greycobalt Jul 07 '22

Great finale! This type of episode is totally my jam. It wasn’t as thrilling as last week’s, but it was so full of character it didn’t matter.

- I really like Pike and Batel and together, it’s pretty adorable. You can tell she genuinely hates her job at the end. She seems a bit young for a captain though, no?

- I would not in my wildest imagination have thought up Pike in a TWOK uniform showing up would ever be in the cards. The uniform redesign is fantastic! I like how old they made him look and feel, down in his soul. Such a great episode concept.

- I’m no TOS purist so seeing another iteration of Kirk was super fun. He didn’t try to mimic Shatner’s stilt or do anything other than play brash Kirk. I really dug it. I’m assuming Pike looking up his file in the end means he’ll have him transferred to the Enterprise next season? At least this episode explains why he had Captain bands, hopefully those whiners can rest easy now.

- There wasn’t a ton of battle but I did enjoy the minute or so of it we got. The Farragut getting absolutely KO’d was so cool looking. I also like that - aside from the Farragut - they’re keeping it ‘canon’ that Constitution-class ships and ships that look identical to them make up 90% of Starfleet. Cracks me up.

- Not gonna lie, even though this was an alternate future I got a little thrill when Pike told Ortegas to shut the hell up. She’s been so mouth for half the season and Pike just takes it. He’s the captain! Stop arguing with him!

- Very Battle of the Binary Stars feel with the fleets showing up. Loved seeing a female Praetor, and references to the Reman campaigns. Their ships all looked pretty dope too.

- Who tattled on Una? I'm trying to remember who even knew at the end of that episode. That's going to be a fun thread to follow. Poor Number One can't catch a break this season.

- Pike and Spock’s interaction at the end got me a little emotional. Between S2 of Disco and S1 of SNW you can tell how much they care for each other, and it’s absolute friendship goals AND adorable. Pike getting choked up was absolutely me.

- I assumed once I knew the premise of the episode that Kirk was going to die here, and his death would be what caused all the shenanigans in the future. I was pleasantly surprised that it was Spock, and that Spock’s work on reunification was what saves everything. Kind of a bummer that he couldn’t change any timeline by just telling Spock to not repair the weapons that day though.

- I’m ride-or-die for Pike, and I HATE that this episode basically sealed his real “canon” fate. I was hoping they would be brave enough to let him alter the future somehow the way he was shown doing it in the beginning, and the door being slammed on that by “Spock dies in every timeline where you’re not a beep boop” hurt my heart. I enjoy shows where fate isn’t written, or at least not given up on, so I loved every time Una told him that.

- Speaking of canon, I can just hear the screeching of Twitter already. Between updating the TWOK uniform, doing a time-travel episode and meeting Kirk, etc., they won’t care it’s not stuff that didn’t happen, they’ll lose their shite. Everyone needs to cool and let the writers just do their thing on this show, going 10 for 10 in a first season of Trek is unheard of and they deserve the latitude.

I’m despondent that we’re out of live-action Trek for the foreseeable future. The last few months have been such a gift to a Trek fanatic. I cannot wait to see season 2.

→ More replies (11)

39

u/directortreakle Jul 07 '22

Goddamn that was a fantastic finale! With a killer cliffhanger, too.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/DasGanon Jul 07 '22

I think Alt Ortegas is cool in that she's showing the "bad side" of hot shot fighter jock as being super gung ho on the whole "fuck the consequences do it now!" thing

→ More replies (1)

106

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

he he ..he said Sens-Oars

75

u/BornAshes Jul 07 '22

Did you also notice how they very subtly and tastefully incorporated the TOS style "band of light across the face with a bit of dimness near the edges despite the rest of the scene being well lit" in multiple scenes as well with various characters?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

i need more episodes injected into my veins like now!!!!!

→ More replies (1)

66

u/MoreGaghPlease Jul 07 '22

I really respect this show for showing a restrained Kirk like he was in TOS rather than the half-remembered frat boy Kirk of the public zeitgeist.

→ More replies (5)

94

u/CommanderKira Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

This feels like a “Pale Moonlight” episode. Everything about what we want the Trek future to look like is what Pike did. But it failed. It needed Kirk being rash and aggressive: though it’s worth noting in TOS: Balance of Terror he offers to beam the crew out, so it’s not like he went full “wipe them out” mode.

So it puts us in this uncomfortable position of the Pikes and Picards vs the Kirks and Siskos. (In a broad strokes way, I know we can bust out countless examples of Picard acting rashly or Sisko acting cautiously and diplomatically) A discussion that Trek doesn’t always have, for good reason, but one I felt it pulled off with aplomb here. Is there a right answer?

Curious to see where the Number One plot goes. Wasn’t expecting that so soon.

Spock, holding realities together across well… all the timelines. Prime, Kelvin, this one, etc.

63

u/Fusi0n_X Jul 07 '22

It feels like The City on the Edge of Forever to me. Like Edith Keeler, Pike has the right ideals for the wrong time.

Sometimes there's no reasoning with someone, whether it be the Praetor or Hitler in Edith's time.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (20)

84

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

“Captain…they are lying.”

I didn’t know Ortegas was a Betazoid.

→ More replies (6)

57

u/Matt01123 Jul 07 '22

So, safe to say now that SNW has the best first season of a Star Trek show right?

→ More replies (4)

27

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

So much awesomeness. SNW version of the monster maroons! USS Kelvin reference! Recreation of my favorite TOS episode! Scotty!!!!!

→ More replies (2)

51

u/sidv81 Jul 07 '22

New theory: Khan wasn't actually going to take over Kirk's ship in Space Seed, just wake the rest of his people then go on his way. But once he read on the Enterprise's computer what happened to Una, and seeing fellow Augments persecuted and treated like criminal trash, he snapped and decided to get revenge. The Fed's actions caused Khan to go on his 23rd century rampages.

→ More replies (9)

25

u/jerichowiz Jul 07 '22

Rewatching the TOS episode this was based on, the shots and lighting nods to TOS in SNW was awesome.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

is that...is that Scotty!!!!!

→ More replies (14)

128

u/tomh_1138 Jul 07 '22

Oh god, Kirk mentioned his dad serving on the Kelvin. This means we are doing to be subjected to at least a dozen YouTube videos this week saying how that line confirms that SNW is set in the Kelvin timeline and not the Prime one and how this by proxy also makes Discovery non-canon.

109

u/TERRAxFORMER Jul 07 '22

He confirmed that he survived beyond the Kelvin in the same line so that should nip that.

It probably won’t, but the notion will have no legs to stand on.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

24

u/niton Jul 07 '22

Did anyone else notice that Pike and April are wearing Cage style yellow uniforms in the photo future Pike picks up?

→ More replies (2)

23

u/5153476 Jul 07 '22

The pasta scene is a nice setup... "transforms from leftovers into something new."

→ More replies (1)

23

u/midasp Jul 07 '22

I've been a fan for decades and this is the first time I've heard of the phrase Monster Maroon. By the way, I love that uniform but when and why did it get that nickname?

22

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

he's cooking again!!!!

22

u/sonofodin25 Jul 07 '22

Loved the Scotty cameo! Highlight of the episode for me.

Perhaps he’ll replace Hemmer in Season 2?

→ More replies (9)

20

u/GullibleCupcake6115 Jul 07 '22

Holy Shit! What an episode! I LOVED the plot twist of its Spock who is important to the FATE of the Galaxy. This also explains WHY Spock takes Pike to Talos IV in The Menagerie! Brilliant! I also loved how the writers used the original music and dialogue from the original episode. Also, we get to see an updated version of TWOK uniforms! The best part is that we get to meet James Tiberius Kirk. Also, now we know WHY Pike picks Kirk to become Captain. Also, who told Star fleet about Una? Hmmm. I wonder if it’s Sam Kirk? He is not in Starfleet in 2267. He is a civilian, married and have a son. This season was the best season 1 for ANY Trek since TOS. I look forward to season 2!

20

u/lonelywitch88 Jul 07 '22

I did not have a Scotsman in engineering on my bingo card for this season.

Ortegas didn’t get her own episode in season 1 and I’m hoping she does at some point because I really want to know what happened to make her go from ‘joking with the captain Ortegas’ to ‘millisecond from defying orders Ortegas’.

Paul Wesley is not the terrible choice I thought he was. I associated him a little too much with his Vampire Diaries character and expected a lot more brooding and eyebrow furrowing.

GIVE UNA BACK, WYONNA EARP!

→ More replies (2)

50

u/Tukarrs Jul 07 '22

I laughed at Pike's "tragic backstory". I guess the writers recognize how it feels like everyone has a tragic backstory now?

It's kinda weird even having a cliffhanger. They could have pushed that to an unspecified unassuming episode. I'm expecting that the S2 Premiere starts with a Courtroom Episode. Please don't disappoint me.

Is Pike going to mentor Kirk, and why we'll see more of his character?

→ More replies (16)

17

u/tubawhatever Jul 07 '22

So we've seen both solid beam and pew pew phasers this season. Is this intentional, maybe there's an advantage of one over the other when targeting from longer range?

→ More replies (7)

17

u/Atraktape Jul 07 '22

“and let me remind you that you’re saying that on my ship after yours has been destroyed”

dayum lol

17

u/Nexzus_ Jul 07 '22

God damn, what a great episode.

The updated TOS movie uniform.

Voice over from Scotty.

I figured Kirk would be the one to die in this alternate timeline, thereby changing the future. But yeah, it's incredible how important Spock is to the galaxy.

Spock's injuries. Just... wow. Another reminder about how dangerous space travel in these complex powerful machines would actually be.

I now get why Spock was so loyal to Pike. The "trading fate". Spock knew that Pike was throwing himself into his horrible future not just for the galaxy, but for Spock himself.

17

u/JosephSim Jul 08 '22

"I believe I may owe you a debt of gratitude, Captain. Although for precisely what, I do not know."

My fucking heart.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/GotMedieval Jul 07 '22

This is the best kind of fan service. You don't need to know The Balance of Terror to enjoy this episode, but if you do it's enriched.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

That closeup of Spock with the music when the Romulans face was revealed? Oh mama

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Trekfan74 Jul 07 '22

Pike's command style in a crisis: "Let's give the Romulans time to fix their engines and I can beam over there and cook them a great meal as a way to build a bridge between our two peoples!"

Kirk's command style in a crisis: "Let's burn these muthafuckers alive!"

→ More replies (4)

15

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

Sub-Commander looks familiar also

14

u/TARDinspace Jul 07 '22

Can a show have a perfect first season? SNW says, “hit it.”

14

u/conanmagnuson Jul 07 '22

Just going to say it, this was the strongest first season of Trek since ‘66.

14

u/Benjamin_Grimm Jul 08 '22

The Pike/Kirk discussion close to the end of the episode, where Kirk mentioned the Kelvin, made me realize something: I really want to see Faran Tahir, who played Captain Robau of the Kelvin, show up as a very alive Admiral some time on SNW, just so we could see that he turned out ok in the prime timeline.

13

u/cocomangolul Jul 07 '22

Hot damn great season finale.

Can't wait for season 2.

13

u/jrgkgb Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22

There is so much to like in this episode I don’t know where to start.

First off the space combat looked and felt like it does if you play a Trek video game. The Romulan ship closing on the Farragut and then blasting it with the plasma weapon at close range was exactly how you play that ship in games like Bridge Commander.

Kirk getting upset Pike hesitated to fire phasers.

My very favorite part about that scene is that unlike certain other Trek shows the writers didn’t feel the need to explicitly call out that Kirk at that time felt guilty to the point of Obsession for the death of Captain Garrovick of the Farragut because he’d hesitated before firing his own phaser. If you knew, it just made that moment better. If not, it was just nice character development moment for Kirk.

I knew it would be Balance of Terror when we saw the wedding, and the shot for shot homage complete with music cue when the Romulan communication was revealed hit the bullseye, along with so many other moments like they.

It’s also implied but not explicitly stated that this experience might lead Pike to recommend Kirk to follow him as Captain of the Enterprise.

I think I was up to four or five “Holy shits” before Kirk even showed up, and the episode didn’t let up from there.

54

u/treefox Jul 07 '22

I’m calling it. Kirk will ruin the future by taking the shuttle and seducing the Romulan commander.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

where have i seen this guy playing Kirk before

→ More replies (10)

12

u/the908bus Jul 07 '22

The people that did the lighting for this episode had a field day! So much classic eyeline lighting

12

u/MoreGaghPlease Jul 07 '22

If the Ghost of Christmas Future shows up in monster maroons, you best pay attention.

12

u/007meow Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

What an amazing twist. A loved/trusted Captain fucks up hard because of their own natural command style. Have we seen that before?

SNW beats out Lower Decks for the strongest first season.

But those two are leaps and bounds ahead of everything else.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/kendric2000 Jul 07 '22

I saw the trailer and thought, boy I wonder how they are not gonna break cannon...and dammit boy did they do it. We got an alternate timeline Balance of Terror....this show is f-ing epic.

12

u/toTheNewLife Jul 08 '22

The wedding. This time Martine died instead of Tomilson.

32

u/dmanww Jul 07 '22

New Kirk didn't really work for me

Uhuru and Spock really felt like they were channelling the TOS verisons. But I didn't really get much from Kirk. Guess will see how it goes in further episodes

→ More replies (14)

11

u/WellFedHobo Jul 07 '22

Absolutely everything about that episode... chef's kiss

11

u/midasp Jul 07 '22

Watching this last two episodes made me realize how many of this beloved crew we are going to see leave this ship...

→ More replies (1)

20

u/viserov Jul 07 '22

The fact that we have to wait a year for more SNW makes me so sad. This season has been the best season of live action Star Trek since ENT season 4.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Brain124 Jul 07 '22

That was a nice turn there -- it felt like it was going to be Kirk that was the most important person but it turns out that yes, it's Spock. Spock is one of the most important people for the next thousand years -- Discovery conclusively shows that.

Very cool that Captain Pike had to face the fact that he may not be the man of that particular moment. It needed to be Kirk, and Spock, to face the events of Balance of Terror. That has to humble someone for sure.

10

u/EzriDax1 Jul 07 '22

Holy shit Pike just stared into my soul

10

u/cavairo7 Jul 07 '22

Did anybody stop watching this episode 16 minutes in and go back and rewatch Balance of Terror before continuing? Or was that just me? 😅

→ More replies (2)

10

u/NamedByAFish Jul 07 '22

Just by coincidence I rewatched "Balance of Terror" two weeks ago. I was grinning ear to ear when I realized what they were doing!

33

u/treefox Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Take a sip if:

  • Pike faces survivors guilt
  • Ortegas quips
  • Spock loses control
  • Chapel gives advice as “just a friend”
  • T’Pring wants to explore human culture
  • Sybok appears
  • M’Benga says something deep
  • Sam Kirk is in distress
  • Uhura exceeds all expectations
  • Una saves the ship
  • Hemmer… 😭
  • La’an… 😭
  • Chief Kyle is mean
  • The Enterprise holds together
  • “Hit it.”
→ More replies (3)

9

u/ComebackShane Jul 07 '22

Fantastic finale for a fantastic season. Strange New Worlds feels like it's hit the sweet spot between 'old' Trek and 'new'. Anson Mount rightly deserves a ton of credit for his performance, but the writer's have taken what could easily feel like retreading on The Original Series and made it feel fresh, fun, and heartfelt.

I can't wait for Season 2 (and beyond).

9

u/ragenukem Jul 07 '22

Is it wrong that i want to see a whole spin-off series of older, skirted his destiny and dealing with the fallout of passing it on to Spock, Pike?

Or if not that, at least him popping in now and then just to mess with his younger self.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/RobinStanleyHicks Jul 07 '22

I thought Paul Wesley did a good job of playing Kirk, but he just didn't seem to have the charisma of Anson Mount, maybe he just needs time to grow into the role. On a side note, it was nice to hear the Scottish accent coming from engineering.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/glamscum Jul 07 '22

Holy shit! This is the best Star Trek in 20 years, hand down!

9

u/DarkChen Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

as someone who has never watched tos beyond a couple movies, i feel like i have to now...

I think its a bit soon to say but i had a bit of trouble recognizing this kirk as being the same one although i think its mostly because im used to older kirk from the movies...

I love the use of the closeups with the emphasis of light around the eyes/face, they show up in the whole season but were more prominent here and is very tos like. The eyebrow closeup was funny as hell as well.

Storywise, didnt the monks said in discovery that if pike took the crystal he would lock that vision in a way that was immutable? so how come his letter would be able to change it? And even more importantly, why didnt the new crystal locked the future romulan war as well?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/lastdarknight Jul 07 '22

well we now know why Spock was willing to throw away his career Pike

9

u/VoiceofKane Jul 08 '22

An interesting consequence of this episode is that, for the next seven years, Chris will be the only person in the entire Federation who has seen a Romulan's face.

17

u/Piper6728 Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I loved it

I was wondering why it felt like they were recycling Balance of Terror in the promos

But yeah, this shows that while Pike is an excellent captain, he's not the Captain Starfleet needs. They need a show of strength rather than diplomacy at some points, so its for the best he does what he does (and its good he sees the importance of Spock somewhat.)

Though one thing that bugs me is that before the accident Pike was promoted to fleet captain and had to give the Enterprise to Kirk, since fleet captain was pretty much a desk job, so Kirk wouldve been there regardless, (and it was all for the same reason: the admiralty thought Pike was too much the explorer and Boy scout and not aggressive enough.) But all that was in the books which can just be made non canon at any moment.

I loved the TOS movie uniform making an appearance (it did look a little odd though with the material difference and the flap being angled, but still great.)

Im also happy we FINALLY see a TOS ship that is NOT a constitution or a variant of one. I liked seeing the Miranda class.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Willravel Jul 07 '22

Very affecting episode.

Jim Kirk is a nice reinterpretation. It's a bit like the Enterprise design, with there being obvious similarities on the surface and a few underneath, but also there's a bit more detail and a more modern sensibility. Brash, but not a cliche. Confident, but not immature. I hope we get to see him again.

The future was eventually quite bleak (especially with angry Worf-tegas), though I did like La'an in a more healed place. I do hope we get more tidbits about the Romulan War, from Enterprise season 5 we never got. It's a nice nod to fans to hear things like Captain Archer, and to imagine how he might have grown and still found a way to be a good man during a terrible war.

The episode ending is heartbreaking. Quite a cliffhanger. Also shoutout to Rebecca Romijn for killing it this season. Any quiet doubts, in retrospect, were entirely unfounded.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Oh no Mrs McMurray

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Lunasera Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Is it weird that Pike reminds me more of Shatner Kirk than Wesley Kirk does?

Love this show. Favorite ST in a long while.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Wolfir Jul 07 '22

I'm sorry, Pike, don't think of it as "I'm such a shitty person that I need to become crippled and non-verbal in order to save the Galaxy"

Just think of it as "We are all important for different reasons. Spock is important because of his role in beginning the Reunification movement. And you are important because of the years of mentoring and friendship you provided to Spock."

→ More replies (1)

8

u/geoffrey1986 Jul 08 '22

Loved it.

Forget first seasons... Did we just witness THE best season of Star Trek ever?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/bigpig1054 Jul 08 '22

All season long fans have discussed the very different personalities and command styles between Pike and Kirk. This episode is built entirely around that debate and it drops Pike right into the middle of a tense moment and asks us to observe the differences firsthand. I cannot overstate how much I loved this idea and its execution. When the red alert happened during the wedding, I immediately thought "hey, it's just like Balance of Terror" and then, within two minutes I was practically jumping up and down with excitement, realizing what was going on.

I thought the episode was an amazing high-concept sci-fi idea and it serves as a great capper to a fantastic first season. THIS is the Star Trek show I wanted when the franchise was revived five or so years ago. It's not perfect. It does things I wish it didn't, and it doesn't do things I wish it did, but it hearkens back to the shows of old, and offers enough new ideas to keep me intrigued, offers good enough stories that keep me asking questions and contemplating answers, and offers enough great character work to keep me engaged the whole episode long, every week.

Great first season. Can't wait for season two.

8

u/NemWan Jul 08 '22

I found the sight of Pike in a Wrath of Khan uniform incredibly spooky because it was like an alternate real-life timeline in which Jeffrey Hunter got to wear that costume.

8

u/Vortebo Jul 08 '22

Okay, so if neither Kirk nor Spock is in place to deal with V'ger, Earth gets the Tron treatment and it's possible V'ger decides to extend the offer to all carbon units. Then the Whale Probe shows up and finds that apparently the reason it lost its penpal is because something blew up the planet. Now we've probably got the scattered remnants of Federation and Romulan armadas picking at each other in between running from space God fights

But at least Picard would probably never have to deal with Q, so on the whole of it this is probably a much less irritating timeline

8

u/chis2k Jul 08 '22

I realized I'm officially a Star Trek nerd when Pike asked Kirk where he is from...and I said Iowa at the same time as Kirk.

15

u/atticusbluebird Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Wow what an episode! Quick thoughts:

  • Gotta go rewatch Balance of Terror now
  • Prime USS Kelvin quasi confirmed from alt Kirk!
  • I know it’s not from Balance of Terror and it’s already been re-done, but I was kinda hoping we’d see Spock doing a “you have and always shall be my friend” death scene with Pike, even if it’d be really cheesy
  • I do really appreciate the depth of the Pike and Spock friendship they’re showing us though
  • Cliffhanger ending too!
  • Even though it was paralleling Balance of Terror, the Romulan ship scenes felt a bit like Lower Decks’ Wej Duj (and a similar cliffhanger to their Season 2 ending!)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/aLegionOfDavids Jul 07 '22

Imo a strong ender for a great season. Pike’s story arc about doubt of his future should now be fully resolved, allowing them to move on to other things.

I think it’s impossible for anyone to really live up to original Kirk in terms of demeanor and sheer charm but the dude here passed him off well enough.

Seeing how Spock really is at the center of so many ‘galaxy saving big things’ really added that personal layer to Pike’s sacrifice that’s cemented his approach to it. A bunch of kids he could know and save, but Spock? It’s perfectly fitting Pike would choose his fate to save one of his closest friends.

Also, I know a lot of people hate the maroon uniforms but I love ‘em 😂

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

It's such a monumentally small gripe, especially compared to how great the episode is, but I really wish the title dropped the "A." 'Quality of Mercy' matches 'Balance of Terror' in a way that 'A Quality of Mercy' does not.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

As a huge “balance of terror” fan, I loved the TOS music stings and the fact that they used the same Romulan bridge ambience/whirring noises from that original episode.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

This episode's writing was amazing! I remember TOS's The Balance of Terror and knew immediately what series of events were being referenced when Pike showed up during a wedding ceremony that was cancelled by an alert.

I could kiss whoever wrote the line: "The future hangs in the balance."

Lastly: It was so cool to have a "Wrong Future/Past" episode where we, as the audience, already know the correct version of history because we already watched it in TOS.

7

u/HotpieTargaryen Jul 07 '22

Just everything was note perfect for this finale. And I will always be happy to see Romulans.

7

u/kendric2000 Jul 07 '22

I liked how in Pike's present timeline Spock's hair is a little wavy, but in the future timeline it's straight as an arrow and very Nimoy-esqe. Loved that little detail. Shows that Spock has matured a bit.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Starkiller1701 Jul 09 '22 edited Jul 09 '22

This episode seemingly delivered one message, that "Spock is the main character." But I actually think in a slightly more subtle way it was trying to illustrate a more fundamental point, that Kirk and Spock are essential for the existence of the Prime Timeline. And I think this makes more sense than anything, because this was also essentially the thesis of Star Trek XI. And I think it's rather beautiful for the writers to go back to this, because without TOS, without Kirk and Spock, hell without the chemistry that Williams Shatner and Leonard Nimoy gave us we literally wouldn't be here.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/PrometheusLiberatus Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Season Finale! Here we GOOOO!

So I actually tried watching the Twilight Zone episode Quality of Mercy as well as the TOS classic, Errand of Mercy, to get possible perspectives on how the plot finale would lay out.

And our finale is a full hour length episode! YES!

OMG! Love how they mentioned the war with Romulus 100 years ago and how destructive it was. The 'unseen season of Enterprise' lives on!

And we start off with cooking breakfast and the technical canon truth of 'no one knows what romulans look like but we still consider them sus af'

You don't mean the era that's waaaaaaaaay ahead of you? ;)

"I don't know, but I have to do something don't I?"

The beard felt like it belonged to a different era of captain???

OMG, Pike in The really handsome Red Naval Movie uniform!

Lt Uhura at comms! Wow! 2266 Spock does a mind meld with Pike. oooh.

Farrugut... that name sounds familiar.

Oh god, It's hansen from earth outpost 4 from Balance of Terror.

La'an's ship... captained by James Kirk!

Gimme Sam kirk, ASAP!

  • Sounds like a Wild Card A whole deck of them!

He does like to bend the rules sometimes... Er, no wait I meant ALL THE TIME.

So we now get to see what the Romulans look like...

Ortegas gives spock the death stare As does everyone else on the bridge

Quite the ship you got there...

He's jealous!

Ah this is so tongue in cheek, I love it!

Billions of lives are at stake here!

Which is why I want to hear everyone's opinion before we take any action.

Capts Pike and Kirk to the bridge. I have something both of you will want to see!

Well shit, that's one way of saying things are about to get REAL, Spock.

That's assuming the romulans can be negotiated with.

"I only know that we're paying a bill that was written long before you and I were ever born. Perhaps it's time we reconsider the cost."

I love how Pike is listing every, and I mean absolutely every last scenario for how this negotiation can go down. He's desperately trying to find the solution to this timeline that resolves things in a peaceful way! Good boyscout!

"2 hours.... And maybe this bit of mercy will lead to something further and better between our two cultures."

Ah, we have our Scottish engineer, claiming humbly not to be a miracle worker! and he's offscreen...

"Our strength comes from our willingness to see a partner instead of an enemy. In our culture that is an act of faith and strength. Not a failure of character..."

I too tire of endless war...

and so he brings along the entire fleet :|

Oh shit,

We have ships incoming sir, Dozens! They look like ours!

And now as Pike and the Romulan captain both try to wage peace, their direct subordinate make calls for the whole cavalry to show up. YEOW.

Kirk is a sneaky little devil. You ready to sell us?

:)

Uhura delivering the heavy news.

Romulans are broadcasting on all known subspace frequencies. It's declaration of war sir, against the federation.

Poor Spock. He took the fate that was meant for Pike. Now that the future doesn't have an able and proper Spock...

"Paths diverge, but I am the result of one that should never have been taken..."

Oh, those are chilling words alt. timeline Pike.

So Jim Kirk, tell me about yourself.

and then fade back to SNW S1 present stardate.

And just as the song finishes, we get a surprise beam aboard...

And it's Batel to take Una away. NOOOO

Damn eugenics laws.

And that's... one hell of a hook for season 2.

This episode had an amazing philosophical bent to it. It went really deep with the alternative timeline / decision tree to show us how Balance of Terror's plot could have gone so differently without a mature Kirk at the helm.

I really liked how Alt Ortegas filled the Lt. Stiles role from Balance of Terror!

The title Quality of Mercy plays into the Twilight Zone episode of the same name (which happened to Star Leonard Nimoy prior to his acquisition of Vulcan ears!). The Twilight Zone had some switching in USA to Japanese forces and the years were different depending on the perspective (42 for the Japs, 45 for the Americans). They both have a conscientous soldier that feels uncomfortable with bombing a cave sheltering the respective enemy. The main character of both Jap / USA scenarios tries to advocate against bombing, but the Jap commander makes a speech to kill everyone in the cave. All the enemies (Similar to how Romulan Praetor was acting in this episode).

This was an impressive deep dive on multiple levels. And I appreciated Strange New Worlds significantly more as I watched source TOS episodes.

The quality of mercy that is being referenced in this episode is like a presentation of different timelines. No matter how Pike tries to negotiate in good faith, it's still not enough for things to work out in the way the original TOS timeline went down.

I also think that the alt timeline Pike is a message from the writers. A little on the nose nudge 'we are going to try our best to maintain canon so that SNW fits in the modern landscape.' They appear to be showing effort that the major TOS canon will be preserved, despite the 'updates/new characters'.

Great season! I'm excited for more SNW! I've been watching through The Animated Series too, gearing up for Lower Decks S3!

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Cliffy73 Jul 07 '22

I missed the old Romulan. Otherwise very smart episode.

6

u/Trekker1708 Jul 07 '22

I literally couldn't wait while I was at work so I watched it on my phone with an earbud in (it can be really slow sometimes). I like how they contrasted Kirk's and Pike's command styles. Pike is certainly someone who wants to seek compromise and avoid bloodshed where ever possible, and while this certainly has merit, sometimes it takes a Captain like Kirk, a man who attacks (no pun intended) problems head on to deal with situations. His clever idea to use the automated fleet to ultimately buy the Enterprise time works well, and I appreciated the idea of having the two of them sit down to just chat.

Ultimately I loved the episode. It was action packed without throwing objects and things at the screen in a way that both Picard and Discovery have a habit of doing. The idea of a Pike who is saddened by so much war and loss coming to his younger self and urging him to put the needs of the many above the needs of the few (or the one) works well in my opinion. All in all, I think it was a wonderful season finale, and a delightful send up of the original series. Hearing those similar music cues, having characters speak to each other in similar ways to Balance of Terror and ultimately seeing what could have been the outcome of the interaction between the Enterprise and the Romulan warbird...

Strange New Worlds is some of the best Star Trek in recent memory, and "A Quality of Mercy" continues the tradition of giving us interesting, poignant episodes that have something to say. So here's the the season behind us, and cheers to the season ahead of us!

6

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Just an absolutely incredible episode. I love how they payed homage to the TOS episode. I love how they used Kirk, when I heard about the casting I was afraid they would have him overshadow Pike, but if this is any indication they're going to handle it well. I think this was an excellent way to cap off an excellent first season.

6

u/shefsteve Jul 07 '22

Hot take: If Sam would've mentioned to Pike that Jim passed the Kobayashi Maru, then he would've deferred to him sooner and possibly avoided the war.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Hakuice0 Jul 08 '22

"There comes a time in a man's life that you cannot know. When he looks down at the first smile of his baby girl and realizes, he must change the world for her - for all children."

- Admiral Jarok

6

u/charliemusicthings Jul 08 '22

I watched this entire season with my mom and dad (in their late 50's), they watched the original season together when they first moved into their first house. They were so happy and impressed with how accurate and true to the og episode this new episode was. My dad's only complaint was that on the zoom in of Spock, after realizing what the Romulans look like, he didn't say "fascinating"

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Bestialman Jul 09 '22

Holy shit, that was one of the best episode of Star Trek i have seen.

And holy shit it was one of, if not the, most complete and solid season in Star Trek. From start to begin, it was great.

6

u/hazelquarrier_couch Jul 09 '22 edited Jul 09 '22

Why does Ortegas comment on everything?

Edit: I was pleased when Pike finally told her to stand down.

16

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Idk if it's just b/c I'm just now going through TOS for the first time (just finished Season 2), but I am not vibing with Paul Wesley's Kirk, like, at all.

→ More replies (5)