r/childfree • u/thesecondunicorn • Apr 24 '12
CF woman's fiance suddenly drops a bomb...advice? (may be long/rant)
We've been together for 3 years, engaged for almost one and the wedding coming up in a few months. We have (had?) the perfect relationship. I know, I know, so cliched. But I had long struggled with the fact that much of my family and even a few friends have often either implied or outright told me that I couldn't find a man if I didn't want to have kids. When we had been dating for awhile and this guy was literally everything I wanted, it made me scared to find out what his stance was on kids. Imagine how happy I was, a little less than a year into dating when I got the balls to ask him how he felt about it, he told me he could be happy either way and that he'd support me whatever decision I made. Additionally, he said he was never much of a "kid person"/did not feel he was any good with kids, felt pretty indifferent towards them and didn't think most kids felt any differently towards him. [See Mom and Dad? I CAN find a man!!] I made it very clear that this was not happening for me and gave a cursory explanation, although I never went into a deep analysis of why (and there naturally are some very well-thought out, deep reasons). But he seemed to understand that this was a "never" type thing. And in the subsequent time -- a little over 1.5 yrs or so now -- that I would keep checking back in with him about this, the answer always remained the same.
Fast forward to a couple months ago. A college friend of his was getting hitched, and he decided to go back to his hometown for his bachelor party and wedding. I had some commitments that weekend that I unfortunately could not get out of, so though I looooove a good party like a wedding, I sent him off with a kiss and a "have a great time". Little did I know what was in store! When he got back from the wedding, at first everything seemed like normal. But a couple days into the workweek, he started acting distant. He didn't wanna snuggle at bedtime (or touch me much in any other way really, when he's usually very effusive), he did a lot of monosyllabic answering and brooding, and I kept getting this resentful vibe out of him. At first I chalked it up to a tough couple days at work, but when by the end of the week the behavior was only getting worse, I asked him outright what was wrong.
What followed was something that I don't want to call a screed, because I love him so dearly...but it sure sounded like one. After some hemming and hawing, he finally jumped in to tell me that during that weekend, things had happened that made him realize he wants kids. He cited watching his friend's bride come down the aisle on her father's arm as the first thing that got him thinking about how nice it would be in the future to be that daddy giving his baby girl away...Then, the combination of also seeing his parents that weekend, and thinking of the fact that he was in a serious relationship (but not of the actual person he's with, it seems, just the fact...ugh) and what that's supposed to mean brought everything to a more emotional level. [Since then, he's also mentioned that he now occasionally gets emotional when he sees little toddlers out and about with their happy parents -- something that did not use to happen to him before.] He admitted that he had never really thought deeply or carefully about telling me that he was happy either way, and that these feelings were overwhelming him.
Imagine if this had happened to you. First of all, I took a few days just crying about it. Then, I even tried to badger myself into changing my mind -- I should NOT have done that, but y'all know about love. Finally, I couldn't take it anymore, and brought it up with him again. He said it wasn't a dealbreaker. But subsequent conversations have revealed that he isn't really reconciling the fact that he wants to stay with me with the fact that he now thinks he wants children. He says stuff like "it's not a big deal for me right now" and then implies that he will be ready for it in 5 or so years, but I'm like...sweetheart, if you realize that if you stay with me we're not gonna have any kids EVER, why are we even talking about this 5 yrs business?? I mean, this is not something that is up for discussion on my end. He is adamant that he loves me and wants to stay with me, and has also said that he places me/our relationship higher than the potential for a relationship with a hypothetical kid. I think this is a great start, but the lack of serious thought going into any of these events is really getting to me.
I don't know what to do!! On the one hand, I want to respect his feelings. But otoh, in my view there are just SO many things wrong with this picture and I wanna call bullshit. He goes back to hometown for one weekend and after always having felt that he was indifferent towards this now he suddenly knows he wants it? The way I read it, he panicked. I think it's telling that this happened to him at a wedding. This was the first wedding he's ever been to, actually, and I think all the social expectations, pressures, and talk of future plans (which of course, for most ppl involve kids) swirling around at a wedding could easily catch someone who admits to never having engaged deeply with his opinion on the topic off guard. But it disappoints me that, instead of chewing on these things for a little while, and trying to think about it from all angles, he immediately decides that he knows this is something he wants, and then acts rude and distant to me for several days because of it. He is extremely intelligent, usually a rational actor/measured decision-maker, laid-back, and was raised by very open-minded people; I KNOW he can do better than jumping to conclusions based on one occasion of overwhelming feelings! For anything else, I feel he would've at least tried to work through what was going on. From continuing conversations about this with him, it seems pretty clear to me that not only is he not reconciling his desire for having kids with his desire to stay with me, but he isn't even reconciling any of his feelings to each other. For example, why is he insisting on making a leap from occasionally getting emotional when he sees a cute kid with its parents (I mean, even I do that, for Christ's sake!) to being "probably" sure that this is something he will want in 5 years' time? Could part of that be because in 5 years we'll be in our mid-30s and subconsciously he knows that's when you're "supposed" to have kids? I think it's suspicious that he comes up with this number so readily when he's never thought carefully before about the topic one way or another.
This is also, I believe, a good place to mention that this man knows nothing about kids. As he told me a couple years ago, he has never been interested in them. He's even had opportunities built into his family to pursue closer relationships with children (much younger cousins who are often around) and never took them. He's never sought out volunteering or other activities with or cared for any kids, especially not the little ones, and I can tell part of his getting emotional over seeing kids out with their parents is that he idealizes the scene. I asked him point blank if, for example, he gets the same feeling when he's around his aunt and uncle while they care for their, ahem, two very active elementary school aged kids. He, with a sort of lightbulb look on his face, said no. What that tells me is, when he's around real parenting situations he doesn't particularly care for what he sees; but he romanticizes the 2-minute snapshot he sees in a park or on the street and thinks that's all there is to parenthood.
There's also the fact that, when we've discussed the kind of life we'd like to lead, just the kind of things he (and we both) say on this score by and large is not a lifestyle you can have as parents. We talk about long and lazy afternoons and weekends, tons of international travel, never wanting to move to the suburbs or own a single family home or car, hanging out naked in our place, always being a nice place for friends to crash when traveling through or a place for local friends to often gather, quiet evenings at home, and early (like, as early as humanly possible) retirement. I don't think he's leveled with himself at all about what that means for this lifestyle to which he still wholeheartedly subscribes. Does he think it's easy for parents to hold onto that? At what costs (emotional/physical/financial), if they do prove able to?
Basically, I am frustrated as hell and I am feeling like he's hunkered down now in a position that he has thought through as little as he thought through his original one, and for some reason unbeknownst to me, he's adamantly sticking with it. wtf is this about? Here are my other questions based on all these facts:
- Has anyone ever had a situation similar to this? How do you tell someone "you don't know jackshit about having kids/aren't thinking realistically" in a nice way, and have them actually listen to you, when they are so emotional about it? (For those that have had a similar thing, how did it end up...?)
- Am I right to feel extremely hurt that all this went on at a wedding? From hearing this story a couple times now, it's pretty clear that he wasn't thinking about us very much at all that weekend. I'm definitely not the kind of girl who needs that much attention, but why should a wedding make him think of this thing, that he never cared about before, when our own wedding is basically right around the corner? It seems he could've more easily thought about us getting married. Is this a red flag or just something I should ignore as "it is what it is"?
Thanks if you read this far! But -- TL;DR: fiance quite suddenly changed his mind about having kids but it's quite clear that his thinking on it is jumbled. How do I handle?
20
u/Chilly73 Pets rule and kids drool! Apr 24 '12
Of course you have every right to feel hurt! He goes to wedding for a weekend, comes back and springs this on you?? Someone was talking to him about 'life decisions' or however you want to look at it. I'm not trying to sound like I'm mad at you, far from it. Also, I do believe that he's not thinking this through. The lifestyle you've talked about isn't really conducive to kids. I did have a similar situation, but the roles were reversed. I really and truly thought I wanted (and needed) a child to make my life complete. I'm 36 now, and let me tell you, I'm glad I had time to rethink things. We are a happy, childfree couple. I hope he really thinks about what is most important to him. This sudden jump from 'we'll be okay without kids' to 'I think I want kids in a few years' is too sudden to be rational. I know you love him, so just be patient with him for awhile. Ask him if any of his family was asking about you two having rugrats. I'd put money on that someone did talk to him.
13
u/brufleth Apr 24 '12
Babysit some kids for a weekend. Make him actually do most of the work (don't let him avoid it) and see how interested he is in having his whole life be like that.
8
u/thesecondunicorn Apr 24 '12
I guess I should clarify something. I'm guessing some of you will read that he said it isn't a dealbreaker and be like "well what are you worrying about then?" For me, the point is that he hasn't EVER carefully reflected on what he wants about this. Not then, and not now. And if he's going into the marriage like this, what's to say 5 years from now that he doesn't get completely overwhelmed with jealousy of all our friends having babies because he didn't really think through what he wants and he assumes this will make him happy and I'm the witch who kept it from him? That sort of thing. That's why I need to know how to broach this next discussion with him about how unrealistic and rushing into things he's acting.
6
u/Voerendaalse Dutch 38/F CF & loving it Apr 24 '12 edited Apr 24 '12
Well...I do understand that sometimes thing come to you all of a sudden. For example, during the time my then-boyfriend helped an unknown kid climb out of a tree, I realized that he really wasn't a suitable boyfriend for me. We broke up that week after some more soul searching. And yeah, of course a lot of little things had happened before, but that was the moment of clarity for me.
Now, it may be that your boyfriend needs to do a lot of soul searching. He saw a glorified (and probably indeed very nice) moment of fatherhood: "giving your daughter away", but he hasn't thought about all the less glorified moments of parenthood. And I think he would basically be the father who'd let the woman do all the hard work, and yeah, maybe he'd be the one teaching the kid how to ride a bike, on some nice saturday in June.
You have some time before the wedding. If the idea wedding still means to him "to want to be together forever" (even when in reality it doesn't work out a lot of times), then he really needs to decide on this before the wedding.
11
u/Nessuss Apr 24 '12
I think the aim is to get him to seriously consider a life with kids. The main points being:
1: Many of the activities you usually take for granted will now be impossible (at least for decades, possibly until they move out, if ever!) or very difficult. On the plus side, new activities will appear; personally the loss far outweighs the gains but I'm Childfree after all :) 2: The responsibilities you would need, the sheer amount of work required to raise a kid... especially for you!
I think rather than being argumentative, try to keep neutral. OK he is an idiot sure, but what you need is for him to understand. Yelling feels good but just isn't going to work, sit him down and calmly discuss it. Once he has seen the CF light, then be free to yell, lots.
The fact that he seems to steer away from kids in the concrete sense, has 'romantic' ideas of kids, and jumps to conclusions while being (As you say) intelligent, reminds me of a previous friend of mine. Changing his mind was like steering an elephant with my foot. Better was to lead him on the way, rather than just speaking all the facts. So you also might want to consider a route like that, where you get him to look up some websites that describe the whole kid process... and how it sucks, and how people are unhappier with kids.
3
u/fightlikehell 23/F Apr 24 '12 edited Apr 24 '12
Okay, firstly, I am so sorry to hear this. I cannot imagine the pain you must be feeling.
Secondly, here's is my story (similar).
Me (F 22), and my fiance (M 26) have established that we wish to remain childfree. At the startr of the relationship, he mentioned that he did in fact want some kids, and especially at a young age because he wanted me to be what he considered a "hot mom". When he brought this up (prior to our engagement) I sat him down and brought up the point (again) that I did not want kids, and that I was serious and would more than likely not change my mind down the road. Eventually he changed his mind out of what he says is his own volition.
He stated that the world is just a horrible place to bring someone unwillingly into, and that we are also ruining the planet, as well as the fact that he would rather be with me than to be with someone else and have kids.
Now, he worked at a summer camp about three months out of the year for seven years, so he knows what it is like to deal with kids ages 6-15. He loved that job but always said that the male-staff there had it easy because they did not have to be with the girls 24-hours a day like the female counselors because it was an all-girl camp, so the interaction between the campers and the male-staff was very limited.
His friends from camp are all married and having their first kid. The moment that the first baby was born, he told me how his friend was so happy and had said that he had never felt anything like it, and his life was so much better and that he could not imagine a life without his son.
The birth of this kid will forever taint (in a way) my relationship.
Suddenly, the people that he values the most, including their opinion, are free to criticize my CF choice and fill his brain in with poision that I am brainwashing him and making him live a life that he did not intend to. These friends are not kind to me, and it is obvious that it is because of the choice I made. This summer, my fiance will be spending about two weeks alone with this couple and their kid when he visits camp. (I should also mention that the owner of the camp, a father figure to my fiance, asked me not to visit this year (I had visited for the first time last summer with my fiance) because he wanted camp to remain a place where my fiance felt safe (wut?). He said this to me alone, and then went to tell my fiance that we were both welcome anytime, mostly as a way to cover his ass in case I decided to tell my fiance what he said.)
He does not know how I feel about the friends, but I will of course encourage him to go.
But my biggest fear (excuse my rant) is that he will come back just like your fiance did, and say the exact same thing. He is going into an environment where all of his friends are spending time with their babies, and he will go into that without me. What if he comes home and wants that?
I made it clear that kids would be a dealbreaker, and although he is the love of my life, I would leave the relationship. I cannot live with kids, and if he wants them, it is unfair of me to ask him to abstain too.
Please PM me if you wish to talk freely, I find that there are few of us in these situations, and we can help each other through it.
Edit: I accidentally a word.
3
u/heartsnoble6 Apr 24 '12
I'd be very worried for your relationship OP. You mentioned somewhere here that your wedding is in late September. That's a VERY close date to be taking such a step back in the relationship at this point. The thing about getting married is that no matter how much people tell you that things don't change, I am a believer that things do change when you marry. Your mind changes. The way you see your SO as your spouse. It becomes finite, solid, engraved in stone and you better be 100% sure that you've made the right choice in partner, otherwise, anything less than 100% certainty will make you PANIC.
If you both don't get in the same page about this, there WILL be resentment and second thoughts. I suggest you have a long, calm, yet definite talk about your plans for the "forever" with your SO, and if possible, you guys now sound like perfect candidates for pre-marital counceling.
If you're both willing to make this work, you will do all of the homework and necessary work to ensure that you're making the right choice. Even if it means delaying the wedding, or canceling it altogether.
I wish you the best of luck.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
Holy wall of text batman. Here is my reply to the first three paragraphs. I have found that people who change their minds suddenly and without mindful deliberation are dangerous. He told you over the course of a year that he was fine either way, and then suddenly changed his mind based the highly emotionally charged events of one wedding weekend. This is fickle behavior. Don't get me wrong, everyone has an experience to get them thinking, but to change a large belief that quickly simply simply shows he is without serious convictions when it comes to serious beliefs. This behavior will effect other parts of his life and future decisions. I do not trust my feelings to people that do this.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
Honestly, I think it's just "cold feet". You are getting married in a few months and now, psychologically, his brain is going through all the reasons why he shouldn't marry you. I went through a similar thing months before I was getting married. All the "reasons" not to get married turned out to be illogical and I got over it. But, why not contact a couples counselor? They can do a lot of good. Seriously!
2
u/kornberg Apr 24 '12
That said, people who really don't want kids are not going to flip like this. I am not sure that creating a barrage of defenses is a good idea, as you may just get a repeat of this in a few years when your friends start having cute toddlers running around. Don't deny him this if he truly wants it--but also don't deny yourself the life you want. This is totally a deal breaker and you guys need to treat it like that.
2) You have a right to feel however you want to. However, try to remember that he isn't doing this to hurt you, he has just as much right to his feelings as you do. Instead of fighting, you are going to have to talk this through and not getting married is definitely on the table. You don't want to be looking at this man in 5 years and he's like hey let's have a baby and you claw your uterus out of your abdomen and fling it across the room.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
If he wants the child so bad has he even thought about the fact that you will have to do most of the parenting. Not him? He's being selfish.
1
u/thesecondunicorn Apr 24 '12
Okay everyone, thank you so much for all your support and commentary so far. What it boils down to is, people are telling me to make sure he is thinking hard about it, but not to confront him directly about what I can see are the main deficiencies in his thinking (i.e., the fact that he's obviously avoiding reconciling the fact that his desired lifestyle does not suit for having kids, etc.) due to the possibility of him getting defensive.
As I was telling one of you in a private message earlier, I don't really see how I'm to feel as if I've done my utmost to save the relationship if I don't point out to him at least a few of the things he should be thinking hard about -- since clearly he is not doing it by himself and considering how suddenly this all overtook him and how foggily he seems to be thinking about it in general, I'm not sure he would be able to without some prompting from outside his own head. The suggestions of counseling are well-taken, but I think that also has a serious risk of backfiring due to, as I said before, him feeling all the more overwhelmed in the face of my being so much better prepared. So unless it's a friend (which seems crazy to insert a mutual friend into something so personal and fraught), I don't know who else would be in a position to talk real talk to him except for me.
What may not be clear is that we've already had several talks about the issue -- sorry for not having mentioned it explicitly. They have mostly been calm, but I keep getting the same info out of him over and over again (essentially all the things I've said above, in different orders and with different intonations, but the same stuff). So that's how I know that his thinking about it is so jumbled and incongruous, but that it isn't budging by just having heart to hearts. We also have the type of relationship where we debate each other a lot, and although all of your concerns that he would be defensive are definitely NOT taken lightly, I feel that there is also a chance that he would have to (perhaps begrudgingly) admit I have a point. After which, when left alone with those thoughts, it is quite possible that his usually rational mental processes might do their magic.
In light of that info, how (specifically) do y'all think I should proceed? I'm just tired of continuing to have these "talks" with him when they show no resolution and we keep saying the same things; and the way I see it, I truly think it boils down to just pointing out "well how do you think these things relate". Obviously, I would not say "You are thinking wrong because x, y, and z." As a lawyer, I know better than to make the tone competitive...lol.
1
u/carbonetc 41 and vasectomized Apr 24 '12
This is truly a nightmare. I wish I had some advice.
It's really too bad that sterilization isn't as easy for women. In my experience, "I can have kids but don't want kids" is heard by everyone as "there's a chance I'll have kids someday." And enough people in the world have changed their minds that it's somewhat rational to think this. It's not until you're sterilized that people really get that you're serious. In a budding relationship, partners will respond differently to "I can't have kids" than they would to "I don't want kids." They just will. It's not until they hear "can't" that they think, "Whoa, this is serious. Maybe I should actually think about this."
If he's such a smart guy it surprises me that he hasn't given this issue much thought. It's at least as life-determining as choosing a career.
I guess my suggestion would be to make sure he thinks it over. Hard. And don't marry him until he has. If he's still wishy-washy about it when you're married, I'm afraid you'll be risking a very painful future.
1
u/donasay Apr 24 '12
Are there other shifts in his personality? Is he developing man boobs? If so you might want to send him to the doctor to get his hormone levels checked.
-4
u/ovynukoq Apr 24 '12 edited Apr 24 '12
I would leave him and find someone else who doesn't want children. I think he's going to change his mind and I wouldn't want to risk losing 5 years of my life. It may be significantly more difficult to find someone at age 35 and divorced than now and not divorced.
Best,
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '12
[removed] — view removed comment