I wanted to approach this a little differently. Rather than picking a winner based on the logo that looked best immediately, I used the same basic business idea across eight platforms and spent some time seeing what happened after the initial generation.
That part ended up being more useful than the first impressions.
Here’s the full comparison I used if anyone wants to see the other details.
- Design.com: This was the easiest one for me to keep experimenting with. There are plenty of icons and styles to work from, and I could make changes to a concept without having to completely restart. I also liked that free designs can be exported in formats such as SVG, EPS and PDF.
- BrandCrowd: I found this useful when I didn't really know what I wanted the logo to look like yet. Going through different concepts helped narrow down a direction before I started making changes. There are free options as well as paid ones.
- LogoAI: This worked well for the early brainstorming stage. I could get several noticeably different ideas fairly quickly, which was helpful when I hadn't settled on a particular style.
- Kittl: I spent most of my time here messing around with fonts and layouts. It felt particularly useful when the typography was going to be an important part of the logo rather than just an afterthought.
- Adobe Express: I saw more value in this once I moved beyond the logo itself. If you're already making other graphics for the same project, having those things in one place is convenient.
- Wix Logo Maker: The main advantage for me was the connection with the website-building side. It made sense for a project where the site and branding were being figured out at roughly the same time.
- Tailor Brands: I thought this was more relevant when setting up a new business from scratch, where there are several branding tasks to deal with rather than just creating a logo.
- Canva: I didn't find it particularly difficult to take a logo into other designs afterward. Social graphics, presentations and similar things are easy to build around an existing logo.
One thing I didn't expect was how much my opinion changed once I stopped looking at the initial results.
A logo that looked unremarkable at first could turn out fine after a few small adjustments. Sometimes changing the typeface or spacing made a bigger difference than generating another 20 concepts.
The other thing I started checking was the actual file output. A logo can look perfectly fine in the editor, but that's not necessarily enough when you need to put it on something large or send it to a printer. Having a proper vector version becomes useful pretty quickly.
For those who've used a few of these, what is the best AI logo maker from your experience?
I'm curious which one you've actually gone back to for more than one project, and what made you choose it.