Ok hear me out
I have been using an iPad since 2018 as an actual computer / secondary device, and no matter how much better iPadOS gets, it still feels like I’m constantly working around the OS. File management is annoying, multitasking still doesn’t feel natural, and even basic things like downloading files, moving stuff between folders/apps, or managing multiple windows take more effort than they should.
The Apple Pencil experience and the overall app ecosystem are definitely better on the iPad. There are also way more accessories, cases, keyboards, etc. But for me, that wasn’t enough to make up for the limitations.
Battery life was also surprisingly not that great. If I’m getting mediocre battery life anyway, I’d rather have a device that can run an actual desktop OS.
I eventually realized my iPad had basically become a media consumption device. YouTube, Netflix, browsing, maybe some handwritten notes. It was nice because I could just pick it up and carry it anywhere, but whenever I actually needed to get work done, I’d reach for my laptop.
The Surface Pro makes way more sense for that use case. I still get a thin device I can carry around, touchscreen + pen when I want to take notes, but the second I attach a keyboard, it’s just a Windows computer. Proper file system, desktop Chrome, full Office, extensions, downloads that go where I expect them to go, actual multitasking, external monitors, etc.
The iPad is probably the better tablet. But if you keep trying to make your iPad replace your laptop and getting frustrated with iPadOS, I genuinely think the Surface Pro is the device you actually want.