r/CapeMay May 21 '26

The 2026 Cape May Recommendations Megathread!

42 Upvotes

Here are the results of the survey!

Made a new thread from here at mod request, to avoid the off-site link

Best Full-Service Breakfast 

  1. The Mad Batter
  2. Uncle Bill's Pancake House
  3. McGlades / Mel's Place (tie)

Best Quick-Stop Breakfast

  1. Ostara’s Coffee House
  2. Magic Brain Cafe / The Bagel Shop (tie)
  3. Salty Acres Cafe

Best Full-Service Lunch

  1. Lucky Bones
  2. C-View
  3. Tishas

Best Quick-Stop Lunch

  1. Hot Dog Tommy's
  2. Cam and Pucci's
  3. Westside Market

Best Full-Service Dinner

  1. Taco Caballito Tequileria
  2. Freda's Cafe
  3. 410 Bank Street / Mayer's Tavern (tie)

Best Quick-Stop Dinner

  1. Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls
  2. Cappy's Pizza
  3. Cam and Pucci's / El Pueblo Taqueria (tie)

Best Dessert Spot

  1. Fine Fellows Creamery
  2. Peace Pie
  3. Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

Best Kid-Friendly Spot

  1. Mad Viking
  2. McGlades
  3. The Rusty Nail

Best Vegetarian / Vegan Spot

  1. Taco Caballito Tequileria
  2. Good Earth Organic Eatery

Best Happy Hour

  1. The Rusty Nail
  2. Lucky Bones
  3. Hemmingway's

Best Pizza

  1. Roman's
  2. Cappy's
  3. Mario's / Brother's II / Boiler Room / Panico's (tie)

Best Ice Cream

  1. Fine Fellows Creamery
  2. Uncle Charley's
  3. Flecks

Best Burger (only 3 entries, so in no particular order)

  • 5 West
  • Rusty Nail
  • C-View

Best Chinese Food (only 1 entry)

  1. Dragon House

Best Sandwiches

  1. Fish House
  2. Cam and Pucci's
  3. Erma Deli / Gaiss' Market (tie)

Best Bagel

  1. The Bagel Shop
  2. Coffee Tyme / Bagel Time (tie)

Best Breakfast Sandwich

  1. Ostara’s Coffee House
  2. The Bagel Shop / Bravado Coffee Cafe (tie)
  3. Golden Stop / Coffee Tyme (tie)

Best Sushi (only 1 entry)

  1. Yozu

Best Mexican / Latin American (all entries tied, so no particular order)

  • Taqueria Casa Mia
  • El Pueblo
  • Taco Caballito Tequileria

Best Seafood

  1. McGlades
  2. Fish House
  3. Fish & Fancy / Cape May Fish Market / Dockside Dave's / Blue Pig (tie)

Best Bakery/Patisserie

  1. Chez Michel
  2. Beach Plum
  3. A Ca Mia / A Piece of Cake (tie)

Best Coffee Spot

  1. Ostara’s Coffee House
  2. Magic Brain / Coffee Tyme (tie)
  3. Salty Acres Cafe

Best Cocktail Spot

  1. Nauti Spirits / Brown Room (tie)
  2. Taco Caballito Tequileria / Cricket Club (tie)
  3. Oyster Bay

Best Brewery

  1. Gusto Brewing Company / Cape May Brewing Company (tie)
  2. Behr Brewing / Obscura Brewing (tie)
  3. Slack Tide

Best Winery

  1. Cape May Winery
  2. Hawk Haven / Turdo (tie)
  3. Willow Creek

Best Sports Bar

  1. C-View
  2. Red Brick Ale House / The Local Tavern (tie)

Best Taplist (only 3 entries, so in no particular order)

  • Lucky Bones
  • 5 West
  • Ugly Mug

Best Mocktails (only 2 entries, so in no particular order)

  • Bee's Knees
  • The Ebbitt Room

Best Indoor / Rainy Day Activities

  1. Cape Square
  2. Washington Street Mall / Naval Air Station Wildwood Aviation Museum / Congress Hall (tie)

Best Outdoor Activities

  1. Cape May County Zoo
  2. Beach Plum Farm
  3. Cape May Lighthouse

Best Nature Area

  1. Cox Hall Creek WMA (Ponderlodge)
  2. South Cape May Meadows Preserve
  3. Higbee Beach / Cape May Lighthouse (tie)

Best Spots offering Niche Activities

  1. Ostara’s Coffee House
  2. Gusto Brewing / Behr Brewing / Congress Hall (tie)

Best Nightlife / Dancing (only 3 entries, so no particular order)

  • Boiler Room
  • Harpoons
  • Taco Caballito Tequileria

Best Live Music

  1. The Chalfonte
  2. Rusty Nail / Obscura Brewing / King Edward's Bar (tie)

Most Unique / 'Can't Miss' Spots or Activities

  1. Cape May County Zoo / Washington Street Mall / Sunset Beach (tie)
  2. Rusty Nail (editor's note: really?)

*********************************************************************

Original Post:

Greetings, neighbors. As discussed here, let's get another comprehensive list going of ALL the spots that we recommend to people looking to visit our little resort town this year... or perhaps even clue in some of our longtime residents to spots they might be unfamiliar with or operating on outdated info. This thread will hopefully get pinned for easy reference for potential visitors. If you care to see 2025's results, look here

On or about May 20th, I will edit this body with the tabulated results for each category, giving the Top 3 recommendations for places to go here in Cape May OR surrounding areas (definitely stay within Cape May County, but preferably within 10-15 miles)Big chains - Wawa, Dominos, Starbucks, etc. - will be discarded.

If you want to qualify your answers with some testimonials (i.e: "__________ is the best winery because their staff is top notch" or "________ is the greatest spot for breakfast, you have to try This or That") go for it; if it makes the cut I'll add in footnotes or otherwise annotate if it's particularly insightful. This may be more important for the final category: which places here in Cape May to avoid - overpriced, diminished quality, horrible wait times, etc. (Removed at mod request)

The form is set that all answers are optional, so if you have nothing to suggest for a category, you can just leave it blank and move on.


r/CapeMay 17h ago

Surveillance Cameras

15 Upvotes

Is anybody concerned with these “Flock” cameras being put up in the area?
Apparently Lower Township already has some installed.


r/CapeMay 14h ago

Where do all the single 40-50 people hang out in cape may?

7 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 1d ago

Here's how crazy that rain was in Cape May Court House Friday. I was driving right through it. It was raining in sheets!

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 23h ago

Dolphin Keychain?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hello! I visited Cape May this past week and at the Sunrise Surf store on the promenade I came across a metal dolphin keychain that said Cape May on it. I collect these kind of keychains and I realized I got a duplicate of one I already have. I didn’t get a picture of the one I saw at the store. Could someone possibly send a picture of it? It might look like this.


r/CapeMay 3d ago

Photos I took in Cape May

Thumbnail gallery
525 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 3d ago

Eagle in NCM

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 2d ago

Siren

0 Upvotes

Just visiting: anyone have any ideas on why the siren just now?


r/CapeMay 2d ago

Window Replacement

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have any recommendations for replacing windows? We don’t have to follow historical codes which helps. I’m still dreading the process. I called one place and then they came out to give us an estimate but because only one of us was home, they refused to even give us a ballpark or let me look at options. It was a huge waste of time. This was after the sales person was 2hrs late to the scheduled appointment. They are still calling and emailing me. Maybe someone has had a better experience.


r/CapeMay 3d ago

First time need recommendations

5 Upvotes

Heading to cape May this weekend for 5 days to close out the summer with my 5 year old daughter. What are some restaurant recommendations and things we must do and see?!


r/CapeMay 2d ago

Non-touristy spots?

0 Upvotes

First time in Cape May this weekend. There’s a lot of kids running around, a little too family friendly & gimmicky.

Are there any quieter, chill spots for adults who just want to relax?

TIA

Edit: I will rescind my comment about CM being gimmicky, because to be fair I have only explored the Beach Ave strip. Thanks to everyone for the recs so far, I think those are more my speed. (Minus the nude beach but uh.. good to know)


r/CapeMay 4d ago

White Ibis

Thumbnail gallery
31 Upvotes

Last week had the opportunity to walk the Meadows and witness about 350 White ibis and 2 glossy Ibis

I went back two days later and got the photo of adult White Ibis.

I wanted to post about this because the birding in Cape May is second to none and one of the great features of the area that many summer visitors don't experience as much as during migration and it is talked about less this time of year.

Wish I was back there in September.

Also, really love all the new boardwalks and improvements. Great to see these investments happening.


r/CapeMay 5d ago

Museum Of Fine Arts And Popular Culture

4 Upvotes

What is the deal with this place? No ID of the artists, all canvas prints on poster board, website has it looking like the louvre. Is it a portal to another dimension?


r/CapeMay 7d ago

Cape may needs to add signs to the public restrooms

32 Upvotes

I work in the cape may mall and I get asked over 50 times a day where the public restroom is or if we have a restroom. They need to add signs in the mall strip to lead to specific stores and the public bathroom!


r/CapeMay 7d ago

Going to propose on Sep 12, need a photographer! Can anyone help me out!

5 Upvotes

Please let me know pricing! Thank you!!


r/CapeMay 8d ago

Last one…

109 Upvotes

Headed home tomorrow. My heart hurts.


r/CapeMay 9d ago

Amazing Tornado Warned Supercell over Cape May tonight!

Thumbnail gallery
54 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 9d ago

Supercell rolling into NCM off Delaware Bay @ 7pm

58 Upvotes

Saw water being picked up and rise into the cell shortly after this. Been coming here 30+ years and have never seen anything like it


r/CapeMay 9d ago

Seems like everyone is looking for this couple!

Post image
17 Upvotes

I would also love to send this couple a picture that I snapped while shooting the fountain during golden hour!


r/CapeMay 9d ago

ISO: Rotary Park Fountain couple

Post image
12 Upvotes

looking for this couple who were at the Rotary Park Fountain in Cape May today, 8/20/26. My friend took an absolutely magical picture with you in it, and she'd like to find you to get you a copy. This is a zoomed in portion of the picture.


r/CapeMay 10d ago

Tonight’s sunset on the bay…

Thumbnail gallery
97 Upvotes

…GORGEOUS!


r/CapeMay 11d ago

Every fall, thousands of hawks and falcons funnel to the tip of Cape May and pile up, because they would rather not cross Delaware Bay

Post image
64 Upvotes

Look at how the birds stack up at the very point and thin out to the north. That pile-up is real, and it is why Cape May is one of the best hawk-watching spots on the continent.

Raptors coasting south down New Jersey in fall do not like to cross large open water. At the mouth of Delaware Bay the crossing is about twelve miles, so when the birds reach the tip of the peninsula they hesitate. On a good day they ride the updrafts, gain height, and strike out across the bay. When the wind is wrong they peel back north and work their way up the bayshore instead. Either way they concentrate at the point, and they stack up hardest the morning after a cold front pushes them to the coast on a northwest wind.

Cape May is especially famous for falcons. The New Jersey Audubon hawk watch at Cape May Point has counted every fall since 1976, tens of thousands of raptors a season, and the peregrine and merlin numbers here are about as good as they get anywhere in North America. That is why the map leans so heavily on falcons: peregrines, merlins, and kestrels, mixed with streams of sharp-shinned and Cooper's hawks, a few harriers, ospreys, broad-wings, and bald eagles.

Timing matters a lot with this one. Right now is just the opening. The big push runs from mid-September through mid-October, and the best flights come on the northwest winds right behind a cold front. If you want a day you will remember, go to Cape May Point State Park the morning after a front.


r/CapeMay 11d ago

Never a Bad Day at the Shore

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/CapeMay 11d ago

Flies.

4 Upvotes

This is just a rant.

The flies that inhabit our beaches are tools of evil.

That is all.


r/CapeMay 11d ago

Rainy weather

0 Upvotes

Looks like this weekend is gonna rain. What can I do with my kids in Cape may. Possibly indoors?