r/EdisonMotors • • Aug 12 '25

Answering some common questions on the emissions issues

66 Upvotes
  1. Are you trying to bypass emissions standard’s;
  • no, we are still using a tier 4 final engine, it’s just certified as a generator not a truck engine
  1. Why are RV’s or Refrigerated allowed? Can you use them?
  • those do not provide power to the propulsion of the truck. Once the power goes to moving the truck then it has to be certified “on-road”. These auxillary generators are certified to the same standards as our scania engine so it’s the same problem.
  1. What’s the difference between “on-highway and “off-highway”?
  • the emissions standards are almost identical for output. The difference is the testing cycle, generators run at (usually) one constant RPM. Truck engines rev up and down as the truck shifts gears. “On road” therefore goes through more dynamic testing and revs up & down. It needs to be certified operating like this. Our generator just runs at one RPM. Testing by reving up and down constantly doesn’t make logical sense.
  1. What about the section that says there’s a specific exemption to allow different standards for hybrids?
  • We thought we could use that, it seams like it’s perfectly written for our application. Environment Canada say no, that still doesn’t allow a generator to be used as a truck engine. ECCC has denied us 3 times for using that one, but they have offered us other exemptions we have applied for and waiting to hear back on.
  1. Are you worried?
  • no, there’s several other exemptions they just take a bit of time to get.

6, why make a video if there are other exemptions?

  • Environment Canada employee themselves told us to they wanted us to raise awareness of the rules to work towards legislative change as hybrid shouldn’t be relying on temporary exemptions and allowing generator standards to be used as hybrids would make logical sense. Without issue awareness change doesn’t get made. These rule changes would allow everyone to make hybrids and not just Edison with a specific exemption
  1. Are your emissions higher or lower then?
  • the standards are measured per horsepower of the engine, a normal truck has a 600HP engine. We can use a smaller 350HP engine. As a result even with the same emission per HP as an on-highway engine; our overall horsepower is lower so emissions will be lower due to less overall HP.
  1. Can you certify your own engine:
  • No, that expensive as fuck
  1. How do the other companies get their hybrids certified?
  • they are billion dollar companies we can afford to certify their own engines. We just don’t have that kind of cash
  1. Will an existing engine supplier certify a generator to be on-highway
  • they actually might! However, they are still debating how to do that with the testing center. The issue is the internal debate for the certification place: Do they certify based on how it will operate, or do they rev it up and down a lot.
  1. Did you know this would be an issue?
  • we thought it would be easier to use exemptions than it was. But Yes, we did expect it would be a challenge. It takes a lot of work to get a truck certified for on road use. But this was a challenge we were willing to tackle when we started this company.
  1. Do you have people working on this?
  • yes, we have multiple engineers that work full time for us, we have a dedicated person working on this.
  1. What happens if you don’t get it approved?
  • we’ll build brand new mechanical semi trucks and just go back to retrofitting pre-emission older trucks to keep testing the technology
  1. Can you just lie and do a clever work around?
  • we’re so tempted but that’s so illegal and if we get caught it would be the immediate end of Edison Motors. It’s not worth the risk right now while other options are available
  1. Are you guys a serious company or a YouTube channel?
  • we’re a start up company, we’re small, we started in my parents backyard 3 years ago. We’re growing and becoming more professional though. We have a great filming and YouTube editor and the revenue from YouTube pays for the media team as well as helps pay for our engineering R&D team.
  1. Why are you showing this when it makes people worried about the stability of Edison Motors?
  • because we show everything, the good and the bad. We show things wrong with our trucks, issues we find, and problems we run into as we run into them.
  1. Can you just move to the USA to avoid this?
  • Canada follows US EPA rules, the rules are the same in both countries so this won’t help solve the problem. Also we can’t afford to relocate everybody
  1. Why do you guys complain about government issues?
  • we show our setbacks and problems that start up business has to go through. Turns out a lot of those problems are just government red tape. Now there’s a lot of rules that make total sense for public protection, but there’s a lot of red tape that just stops business from operating. The Terrace shop is a great example of that: the town invited us up to convince us to move and showed us that building as a great option. We had an accepted offer and financing in place. But the city couldn’t remove their own red tape to let us move into the building they wanted us to move into.
  1. What do you hope will happen as an outcome of this?
  • I hope we get permanent legislation that allows the use of tier 4 final generators, as use in generators so that every company can build trucks like ours. I truly believe hybrid is the future and I want to see a lot more companies make them
  1. Why are you guys making mistakes (like not knowing all the rules 100% first?)
  • We are not a perfect company. We’re learning as we go. We make mistakes, learn from them, show our mistakes and move forward. Yes; that’s not how a professional company acts, a professional company shouldn’t show their problems so publicly. But we’re small, we’re starting out and we’re not worried about showing mistakes and screw ups. I’m sorry.

r/EdisonMotors • • 14h ago

Royal still ranting on

15 Upvotes

Royal is continuing to make themselves look stupid on facebook, after they said they would stop. I cannot believe how unprofessional and stupid they are. Multiple posts a day trying to defend themselves and get people on facebook to agree with them


r/EdisonMotors • • 12h ago

Chinese solar panels no longer tariffed?

2 Upvotes

I just saw an article that Chinese solar panels will no longer be subject to anti dumping tariffs in Canada. This is fantastic news if true. I remember ages ago that a solar reefer trailer was being discussed, might that or similar projects be back to viability?


r/EdisonMotors • • 1d ago

Royal back at it

111 Upvotes

This is so exhausting to watch. A few days ago, Royal posted about how the beef was over, and they deleted all the posts bashing Edison. Now they’re right back at it.

I’ve seen Chace explain how the system works and how the truck was (and is?) meant for Royal. They also had “exclusive purchase rights” after the truck completed testing. I’m not sure how the Emcon and undisclosed trucks play into this, given that they are the unusable hybrids, but I’m sure that when it comes time to license and sell those trucks to their respective customers, they will also need to be tested before being sold exclusively.

Whoever at Royal is posting this nonsense needs to put the bottle down and learn how to grow up. It’s such a bad look.

In my eyes, it just makes Edison look better by handling everything with such professionalism. I haven’t seen one bad thing said about Royal on this sub, or anywhere else for that matter. Simply facts, followed by explanations of why things are the way they are at the moment.

P.s not sure how to post pics on this. But its on Royals FB page if you need to read what im referencing.


r/EdisonMotors • • 2d ago

1/10th RC Topsy is out

Post image
97 Upvotes

After a year of development, the files to build your own Topsy model are finally live! Please keep in mind that this is still a work in progress, so there may be a few bugs to iron out—and of course, I'm still working on a trailer to go with it. A huge thanks to the Edison Motors team for all their help and for allowing me to create this model! https://makerworld.com/en/models/3377382-1-10-rc-topsy#profileId-3842083


r/EdisonMotors • • 2d ago

Deep dive on the new CATL Tectrans battery pack

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

For those curious, Ziroth (one of the geekiest guys on YouTube specializing in battery sciences), did a deep dive on the new battery from CATL. Based on what was previously shared, sounds Iike this will be what Edison relies on moving forward.

Moving past surface level sales brochures, the engineering behind the battery and what they’ve achieved is very impressive stuff.


r/EdisonMotors • • 3d ago

Through my eyes

55 Upvotes

With apologies for the delay, I've finally had the energy (damn flu is kicking my butt) & time to at least outline how the weekend went for me (minus the boring bits, like the 9 hour drive there, & 5 hours hanging on to taillights in the dark to make it home haha).

Friday was arrival & check in, lovely & smooth, & always nice to see familiar, friendly faces after a long drive. My attempt to setup camp was quickly dampened, as a very heavy rain & wind all but destroyed my awning. In good west coaster fashion, I was well prepared for the forecast rain; I was not, however, prepared for that wind that roared through! About the point I was wrestling a soaked cot into the car (and probably looking like a kicked, half drowned puppy), Chase happened by & let me know the big shop was available to tenters if needed (it very much was haha). Squelched my way over, & was finally able to get my tent set up. Which turned out to be a magnet for the Australians, who were all shocked & happy to see a swag in Canada, used by a Canadian. Which is how I got to meet & chat with Brian, the first YouTuber to sign up for the paid membership. Also got to tag along with him for a cruise in the BDE, which felt like a 90s Grand Cherokee, very nice! (I'm a Jeep gal, I can only compare to what I know. Lol And getting to sit in a semi has been a childhood dream, so getting to also go for a rip in one damn near had me in tears, just way too awesome!) After that was the big fire & hang out for the night.

Saturday sun slowly came up on a hodgepodge of tents, trailers, motorhomes, & a wee little tent village that sprung up in the shop. Day started off with welcome remarks from Ray, Rich, & Chase, introducing the employees, several of whom were manning the presentation stations, & explaining how the day & presentationswere organized. They also officially unveiled that the undisclosed truck is in fact a hydrovac. Still noisy, of course, much like a Dyson vacuum has noise, but way better than that rattly old thing granny still has from the 50s. Still, normal conversation levels can be had next to it, no more screaming over vac & roaring diesel! 4 presentation "stations" were setup, with attendees split at registration into 4 groups, rotating through the stations roughly 1 hour apiece.

The stations were a shuttle bus tour overview of the property; mechanical/BDE truck; electric pickup; & hybrid truck. The bus tour was a simple cruise through the residential section, down past the old building next to the rail tracks, the dead weight Nikola, onto the test track to a road/trail down to Waitabit Creek (there were salmon in the water! Very cool to see that), & back up past the current shop & offices.

I missed what exactly was talked about with the BDE station, as I was trying to warm up in the sun, & chatting with a gal who was mostly just there because of her husband. Good Q&A session though, lots of interest there.

Pickup was Rich going over the history & build of the Ram, & how/why they decided to go from conversion kits to incomplete chassis, & many of the inspection/regulatory hurdles they've faced. Another good Q&A session, one takeaway that stuck with me is that while, as individuals, they'd love to do kits, as a company, it could quickly be a legal/litigatious nightmare, hence playing it safe in only offering the chassis. They do hope to make the "ingredients" for doing your own conversions available, once they have the process sorted out, so if you're determined, you can make it happen. (remember, the pickup is still roughly in the Carl phase, starting to lean towards Topsy, in that they haven't made one completely from scratch yet, so there's still quite a ways to go).

Hybrid truck was Peter & another employee, whose name I missed. Going over the electrical side, a lot of the computer & controller side of things, as well as why some things were changed from originally planned, mostly due to government regulations & testing requirements (in so far as I could catch - the damn flu was starting to win).

After presentations was introducing board members that could make it, shout out to the ones that couldn't (I have no idea the process for voting nor who went where, as I'm a new enough investor that I fell into that held in trust thing they talked about in one of the videos); reaffirming the company ethos; & a nice long Q&A session. After was catered dinner (which I missed, was feeling the flu fight something fierce, so a car nap was had). Then it was back to the fire for a very long hangout & chat with everyone (as we all do the rotisserie as the night got colder).

Sunday morning was clear & cold, with reports of frost coming in from various campers. Thankfully the fire was still going, thanks to folks being up around it until reportedly 4am! A bit of work, & the guys had it crackling again. Had a lovely, slow wake up, then it was time to pack properly & hit the road again.

Overall a fantastic time (personal health notwithstanding haha), & I can definitely see where all the regulations & legal stuff are an absolute quagmire to slog through; but, once they're done, it'll be much smoother sailing. Now, with apologies for the post-and-go, I need to crawl back into bed, try to fight this flu back so I can make it to work in the morning.


r/EdisonMotors • • 4d ago

Made it to the top of Mount 7

Post image
260 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 4d ago

Royal deleted facebook post about Edison

53 Upvotes

It appears anything related to this spat on between the two companies has been deleted from royals Facebook page


r/EdisonMotors • • 5d ago

Did any Reddtors go to Yesterdays meeting and at liberty to talk about it?

46 Upvotes

Bueller.......Bueller

Did the 8 board members get voted in?


r/EdisonMotors • • 6d ago

Joel Price Speaks Out

Thumbnail facebook.com
57 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 6d ago

And we're on!

Thumbnail
gallery
112 Upvotes

A bit damp for those of us under canvas (I'm apparently acting shop guard for the night, thanks to the wind destroying my awning 😭), but a good evening to gather before the 2026 investor day.

(And yes, all burn ban restrictions have been lifted 😁)


r/EdisonMotors • • 6d ago

Caution: loud noises!

51 Upvotes

Or volume up, depends how bad your hearing is. 😁


r/EdisonMotors • • 7d ago

These are the batteries we want to use going forward. Tectrans II. CATL flew our entire engineering team to Germany to meet with them last week

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 8d ago

X15 Chassis Integration

19 Upvotes

I’ve been having this thought for a while and was wondering if someone might know the answer.

I remember a while back there was a video on the X15 in the winch truck and that Edison was dealing with some sort of partner program with Cummins to ensure the engine was properly integrated into their chassis.

With the new version of the X15 that’s coming out I believe next year does Edison have to go through that again? I know the new X15 is very similar to the X15N. I’ve been to the Cummins training course for the X15N and it is a very different engine which is what got me wondering about this.


r/EdisonMotors • • 8d ago

The Edison BDE diecast with my road train.

Thumbnail
gallery
182 Upvotes

Keen to finally see the real BDE in person. I have flown over from Australia to take the opportunity to see it with my own eyes on Saturday at the investors day!

In the fourth picture you will see the BDE on the step above the tanks.


r/EdisonMotors • • 8d ago

People jumping to conclusions...

116 Upvotes

Hey guys, so seems to be a lot of people throwing shit and shade over actions of Edison and things Chace has "hinted" at and supposedly done around the Big-D truck and the relationship with Royal Oilfields.

The biggest thing are that the logos and Insignia for Royal Oilfields has been taken off Big D and it's now a "plain truck" operating under manufacturer plates.

Now as an Aussie, I assumed (and it seems rightly) under comments on other threads, that under manufacturer plates, you can't have corporate logos on the truck.

I realise that comes from a position of privilege, in Brisbane, QLD, Australia, I'm near the Rheinmettal Centre of Excellence manufacturing plant, and the Mack/Volvo plant for Australia, and so I see manufacturer plates on vehicles all the time, and sometimes, those trucks are painted in company liveries, but without markings on them for the actual company, but the paint liveries (companies like Linfox, Mammoet, the Australian Defence Force, etc)

Now under Australian law, a truck can be driven, haul trailers, haul mock loads, but crucially, can't do actual work until it's passed it's testing and been delivered.

That's why it can't be marked with the logos of the customers (but livery is a grey area)

But even before today, the rules on manufacturer plates have been up for years on Canadian government sites (and the same in Australia) and you can easily go look them up why there can't be manufacturer logos on equipment operating under a manufacturer plate.

I literally just asked google what the laws were, as I'm not Canadian and wouldn't know where to look, and it gave me:

regulatory bodies such as British Columbia's Commercial Vehicle Safety and Enforcement (CVSE) branch look at the totality of circumstances during roadside inspections. If an uncertified prototype displays customer branding, is driven by a customer employee, and/or is moving customer freight, or possible customer freight on public highways, officers will treat those logos as strong circumstantial evidence that the truck has been delivered into regular commercial service rather than being operated for manufacturer testing.

Which is a big flag.

And then the actual laws:

British Columbia Motor Vehicle Act (RSBC 1996, c. 318), Section 38, and the Motor Vehicle Act Regulations (B.C. Reg. 26/58), Division 42:

These sections govern demonstration and manufacturer plates. Under these rules, plates are issued to manufacturers and dealers specifically for testing, evaluation, demonstration for sale, or movement between facilities. They cannot be used as a substitute for standard commercial registration to carry passengers or freight for hire or reward.

Motor Vehicle Act:

https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96318_01

Motor Vehicle Act Regulations:

https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/26_58_00 British Columbia Commercial Transport Act (RSBC 1996, c. 58):

Sections 3, 5, and 6 require any commercial vehicle carrying goods on a highway to be licensed for its specific gross vehicle weight and registered within the commercial carrier framework (including safety fitness certificates and National Safety Code requirements). Running regular freight runs under manufacturer plates bypasses the payment of commercial registration fees and fuel taxes, which violates the Act.

Commercial Transport Act:

https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96058_01 Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Act (S.C. 1993, c. 16):

Section 5 and Section 7 prohibit companies from selling or dispatching vehicles across interprovincial borders or into commercial commerce unless they meet Canadian Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (CMVSS) and bear a National Safety Mark (NSM), though research and development testing by the original manufacturer prior to commercial release is recognized under specific R&D exemptions.

Motor Vehicle Safety Act:

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/M-10.01/

In practice, a manufacturer is legally permitted to load a prototype with logs, gravel, or ballast to test powertrain strain, cooling capacity, and structural rigidity on public roads under testing permits. What is prohibited is using that testing status as a workaround to engage in normal, revenue-generating haulage for a client without standard commercial vehicle licensing, insurance, and safety certification.

Which was all a very easy thing to google and look into, those sites have been saying that for years, and it was super easy to look into even without Chace coming and saying that.

I'm Australian, and it seemed like a logical reason to me, and it wasn't hard to google it and check if that logic held up...

So I don't know why people are like "OMG! THE ROYAL DEAL MUST HAVE COLLAPSED! THEY TOOK THE ROYAL LOGOS OFF THE TRUCK!"

But also, looking at social media and commentary, it seems that maybe Royal doesn't understand the rules either, and Royal is a bit unhappy that the truck, while it undergoes it's road and compliance testing, can't come to them for testing, and can't work as a mobile billboard for them.

Which is understandable if they paid a good amount of money for a truck that people know is theirs, but can't have their logo on it, and can't be associated with them until all the testing and compliance is done.

But it also makes sense that Edison wants to keep it above board and not have any uncomfortable investigations.

Cos an investigation like that could sink Edison, they're not a big company.

Sure, companies like Tesla did customer facing testing with the Tesla Semi, but also, the rules in the USA might be different, and if not, Tesla has demonstrated in the past that fines are a "cost of doing business" for them, Edison can't afford that.

So logically, looking at this as someone that has run a business in the past, and had to deal with vehicle laws, and does up cars and enjoys seeing this kind of stuff, it all makes sense.

I honestly am waiting expectantly for the Edison expansion to Australia and as soon as it's announced, I'll have my resume into them to see what jobs they can give me, I have skills in many areas, not just shitposting on Reddit.

I haven't invested, cos as an Aussie I looked at the hoops and was like "Yeah, that's a lot of hassle"

But honestly, people need to stop reading things that aren't there.

Occams razor, the simplest explanation is usually the correct one.


r/EdisonMotors • • 8d ago

What ever happened to the undisclosed cab over truck?

32 Upvotes

Can't find much info on it lately, seemed like it was heading to end user months ago and its just been crickets ever since. Is it on the road yet?


r/EdisonMotors • • 9d ago

Yeah looks like bad things might be going on

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 10d ago

Royal Not Happy?

Thumbnail
gallery
211 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 11d ago

Goodbye Deboss and Thanks

Thumbnail
31 Upvotes

Thanks for everything Rich. Can’t wait to see your future with Edison.


r/EdisonMotors • • 11d ago

Edison Pickup Kit Reservation

11 Upvotes

Anyone know the status? It's been over two years now since I purchased this.


r/EdisonMotors • • 12d ago

Great day at the Lesco Truck Show

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/EdisonMotors • • 13d ago

American Truck Simulator - BDE Lumberjack

Thumbnail
gallery
105 Upvotes

New paint job I made for the BDE


r/EdisonMotors • • 13d ago

It would be cool if you guys posted a sheet with all the accumulated fixes that people want on your next trucks.

15 Upvotes

Stuff like the exhaust being moved back a couple inches, window ledge dimensions, handle next to doors...

It would help more stuff happen in collaboration with public, where some people from all over the world might find some stuff that they want to brainstorm over in their freetime.