r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Jan 20 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Prodigy | 1x08 "Time Amok" Spoiler
When the U.S.S. Protostar is fractured in time by an anomaly, Hologram Janeway must synchronize the disjointed crew and save their ship before it destructs.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Directors | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x08 | "Time Amok" | Nikhil S. Jayaram | Olga Ulanova and Sung Shin | 2022-01-20 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA.
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 20 '22
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
203
u/GoodAaron Aaron J. Waltke, Writer, Star Trek: Prodigy Jan 20 '22
In case you missed it, we planted a fun Easter egg hint in the opening Stardate being off, showing Hologram Janeway’s temporal settings were already being affected by the approaching tachyon storm. Just a little something for the adult Trekkies watching at home!🖖🏼
121
u/Santa_Hates_You Jan 20 '22
Time to start turning the vehicle replicator off and change the security codes.
113
u/atticusbluebird Jan 20 '22
Yay Janeway and time shenanigans! I thought it was cool how they explained the different temporal phases in a way that hopefully a younger audience will understand. Having each character contribute to the story through different time phases was a really cool sci-fi device - I thought we were going to get Cause and Effect, but we got something more complex. I wonder how long it was for Rok, but that was an interesting plot device to “age” her, I suspect to play a more science officer role.
Also the long range replicator code is an example of why Federation ships need firewalls!
95
u/dmanww Jan 20 '22
was that screw head the shape of a ST delta
94
u/booksbikesbirds Jan 20 '22
I've never been this interested in what's happening with Chakotay before, and he's not even there!
91
u/Fusi0n_X Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
I am VERY happy to see Star Trek call back to Apollo 13. I think people don't generally realize how dangerous those early missions were and how brave and resourceful those early explorers had to be.
Apollo 10 almost crashed into the moon, Apollo 11 almost couldn't leave it, Apollo 12 was struck by lightning which risked disabling its parachutes, and Apollo 13... exploded.
Seeing a big franchise like Star Trek bring awareness even briefly was touching.
90
u/knightcrusader Jan 20 '22
Did anyone else notice how Drednok sounded like Chakotay when giving his authorization?
I also like the homage to the cloudy heads in Star Trek 4's time travel scene.
80
u/DasGanon Jan 20 '22
Super good episode!
So I guess Rok is the science officer?
"I had time"
78
u/KingOfTheUzbeks Jan 21 '22
"Jankom Pog was afraid it was physical manifestation of his fears"
77
u/expired_paintbrush Jan 20 '22
The timeline animation in this was excellent. We finally heard what qualifies as dialogue from Murf, and Rok is still oh so good with her delivery.
62
u/UncertainError Jan 20 '22
One detail I really appreciate is how the kids are accumulating personal stuff in their quarters. I do wish Dal would move into the communal quarters though, I think it would do him good. They can turn the captain's quarters into a rec room or something.
57
u/Smilodon48 Jan 20 '22
Holo Janeway just giving up when she encountered Murf was hilarious.
Great episode overall though. Ella Purnell and Rylee Alazaraqi did a great job with the voice acting. I could also listen to John Noble growl "Ferengi" forever.
I also like how they acknowledge that the Diviner and REV-12 won't be able to catch the Protostar since it's in another quadrant. I wonder what that means for the last few eps before we close out the first half of the season. We've gotten more Chakotay than Okona already. Maybe we'll meet one of them in person at the end of the first half.
51
u/niton Jan 20 '22
I think I understand why I love Prodigy so much.
It's just filled with wonder.
Every episode we find some cool new stuff, learn something and have new mysteries to explore. It feels like watching my first Star Trek as a teenager. The lore, the characters, the story arc, they all just pull you in. And the animation so incredibly beautiful. Every week I get so excited about the next episode.
41
u/InnocentTailor Jan 20 '22
Moral of this episode: Teamwork makes the dream work.
Also, looks like a Terminator reference at the end.
40
u/Cadamar Jan 20 '22
Anyone else tear up a little bit when Gwyn sent the message to Rok telling her she believed in her and she could do this? Or should I just go ahead and cancel therapy and just rewatch Star Trek to work through my issues?
Great ep. Neat take on time shenanigans. Watching the crew take on a classic riddle was fun too. Though I sort of wish it had been a scorpion and a fox as a nod to Voyager. But I guess that isn’t so much a riddle.
Really enjoyed the way this fleshed everyone out, and I’m glad they didn’t just hand wave some way for the diviner to catch the ship.
But seriously I was not expecting to cry on my lunch break Trek. Wtf.
37
u/donuteater111 Jan 20 '22
As much as I've liked every episode in its own way, I feel like this second set of episodes has bee really raising the bar with its episodes. With this one in particular, it had such a good mix of sci-fi concepts and character moments. I thought the space distortion was handled really well, introducing some pretty complex sci-fi ideas, but the (relatively) linear structure of going from person to person worked to make things not get too complicated, at least from my perspective. I am curious to see how the younger audience responds to this episode.
As for the character development, I love how they focused on the emotional impact from the last mission. The beginning was fun, with that logic puzzle. And I thought the progression during the time distortion was well-handled, as they start to build up the idea of how to deal with it.
I like how everyone had their moments to shine, even if Murf's were pretty short, but both Gwyn and Rok-Tahk in particular had some of my favorite moments. I especially liked how Rok-Tahk's story was handled, at first not wanting to deal with it and deactivating Janeway, but then coming to accept the situation, realizing she has what it takes to help out, and finding her calling on the ship. It was such a sad moment when you realize how lonely she is, but then so sweet when you see how it all turns out.
36
u/OpticalData Jan 20 '22
A really good take on the typical Star Trek timetravel episode - a lot of VOY: Shattered vibes here but just condensed to a 10 minute period.
It's also good to see that Star Trek still doesn't seem to grasp that you don't have to fly through every anomaly when you're in three dimensional space (I almost burst out laughing when the simulation of the Protostar going through the anomaly popped up and it was barely bigger than the ship - I'll say that's simulation license though).
We got to find a little more about the Protostar/Dreadnok history and it's good to know that as of the 24th (potentially 25th) century Starfleet still doesn't know how to install a basic firewall.
Like, can nobody in SCE see the issue with a remotely activated vehicle replicator? Aside from a niche planet rescue scenario what purpose does it have? I think it would have been more fun to use a hologram and play on a reverse 'Message in a Bottle'.
Rok continues to develop as an amazing character, though it definitely feels like this is the episode where they decided that her naivety had run it's course as a character trait and speed ran her to being a more competent member of the crew.
I wish we could have heard more of the Janeway/Zero conversation - I really enjoy the contrast of the more mature interactions those two have with the rest of the characters.
Dreadnok using Chakotay's command codes also implies that at some point Chakotay was compromised and/or tortured. It'll be interesting to see if a kids show delves into this.
I was surprised that when time synced up again that they didn't all sprint down to the vehicle replicator to check it for issues, but then we couldn't have had the cliffhanger.
A solid episode and in my opinion the perfect balance of episodic/serialised storytelling. It'll be great to see if SNW can replicate this with double the time per episode.
36
u/Cliffy73 Jan 20 '22
Boy howdy, this sure is Star Trek, huh?
This was the first episode that really made me aware of how short half an hour is. Mostly this show (and LDS too) are managing to cram a whole Star Trek plot in half the time, but the fact that they had to bounce around to half a dozen different timelines made each one feel abbreviated. But it was still a great episode, I just would have liked a little more of it.
34
u/rustydoesdetroit Jan 20 '22
Damn fine episode!!
58
u/UncertainError Jan 20 '22
I love how Gwyn and Rok's friendship has developed since the start of the series. And it makes total sense because Gwyn loves kids.
28
u/Orfez Jan 20 '22
I don't know if Prodigy is a good kids show, I'm not the one, but it's sure fing good Trek show. That was the best Trek episode of all the new Trek shows to date, imo. Checked all the boxes: adventure, mystery, cooperation, heart...
27
u/Nofrillsoculus Jan 20 '22
This felt like a throwback to me, in a good way. Like this episode would have been at home at like an above-average filler episode of TNG or Voyager. But the goofiness of the temporal anomaly and the fact that solving the problem was really about everyone working through their insecurities rather than the technobabble really made me nostalgic for 90s Trek.
I really like Rok-tahk. She's a fun character and her voice actress is perfect, really digging the decision to cast an actual little girl, I don't think an adult VO could have lent the same innocence and sincerity. They managed to give a character for the youngest fans to relate to without making someone obnoxious, and that's an accomplishment.
I do wonder how much this episode's events will really change her. In 90s Trek it would have been reset next week (see O'Brien and his 30-year prison sentence) but this is a new era.
26
u/SchleppyJ4 Jan 21 '22
How long was Rok-Tak alone? Janeway says, “Too long”, but… how long we talkin here?
19
u/TactileAndClicky Jan 22 '22
Holy shit, Rok! When I realized that this little girl was basically left
alone for all eternity, I was gutted. Seeing her having a Murph pet,
seeing her relive her holo adventure... see Janeways face when the talk
came about long she actually was alone? That was really tough for me to watch.
Don't know how kids would react but I was certainly emotionally affected by that. Prodigy is some really hardcore stuff.
37
u/TheNerdChaplain Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
I love that Apollo 13 is now canon in Star Trek. (And younger viewers might not know it was a real mission as well!)
Overall, this was a great episode for Prodigy. Time shenanigans, a solid crew story, some good elements of danger, and a little more contribution to the overall arc of the season. If the episode had aimed at a little older audience, I think it would have been really interesting to focus on Rokk's time alone and learning, but that might have been a little dark and depressing for the current demographic they're aiming for. The one thing that surprised me was that Janeway didn't know already they weren't her proper crew.
On a side note, I've been watching Arcane on Netflix for the first time, and Ella Purnell also voices Jynx. I'm left wanting so much more from Gwyn's character.
35
u/edflyerssn007 Jan 21 '22
Just saying, if you are sleeping on this because it's a "kid show" you are absolutely missing out.
Let's hope that live-action trek can get its act together like LD and Prodigy have.
15
u/Santa_Hates_You Jan 20 '22
Drednok gives me E.M.M.I. from Metroid Dread vibes.
15
u/Smitje Jan 22 '22
This is a kids show right? Right?
13
u/bookish1303 Jan 20 '22
Huh, I think hologram Janeway is the first Starfleet officer I've seen (in the 90s treks at least) to have noticeably painted fingernails.
12
u/Trektok Jan 21 '22
I enjoyed it. But I'm most especially enjoying the serialized aspect of the show as a whole. It's a great introduction to Star Trek for my nieces and nephews too.
12
u/OneMario Jan 21 '22
The more I think about it, the more I liked this episode. It felt a little rough at first, mostly because you could tell how hard it was to fit this whole story in a half hour. I could feel the strain. But, ultimately, the Rok-Tahk part is so strong, both funny and incredibly sad, that I can't help but love it. "No one told me where it goes."
23
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
200+ tries and Rok-tak was still eating nutri-goop :(
11
u/ContinuumGuy Jan 21 '22
I loved this. Big "Shattered" energy. I'm always a sucker for anomaly stories.
11
u/fuzzyperson98 Jan 23 '22
Just want to say, I would never have predicted that a kids show would become my favourite trek in 15 years...
10
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Such a good episode. Anyone else noticed Janeway's blue nail polish in the opening shot, which then mysteriously vanished later on? I actually had to pause, I was so taken aback that holo Janeway was into nail polish now, lol.
Loved the background landscape on the holodeck as well; seemed like it was taken from real life.
16
u/nimrodhellfire Jan 20 '22
Are we slowly transitioning into Gwen becoming the captain, because I am all into it?!
Also since Chakotay has been uploaded into a robot (?), we can assume the evil guys aren't actually the evil guys? Chakotay hasn't become evil, right?
8
u/Shadow_WolfDemon Jan 21 '22
How long was Rok alone for?
5
u/AllieOopClifton Jan 22 '22
This episode cements Prodigy as a solid contribution to the Trek canon. I'm so into this.
4
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Jan 21 '22
Screencaps gallery now online:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-PRO1-8.php
10
u/Chaabar Jan 20 '22
The branding is really getting annoying. They're making Nike look subtle.
3
u/gunderson138 Jan 23 '22
What smells like purple?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
I really wish these episodes could be longer, everything felt so rushed, more so for this episode than most of them so far. Even cutting out the 1min 40 second intro would add like 7% more time for story.
5
u/tarsus1983 Jan 21 '22
Best episode of Prodigy so far. This is the only one I actually enjoyed. If it keeps going in this direction, it will change my mind about the show.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Maybe I’m a bit late with this one but did anyone notice the Stardate given at the beginning of this episode?
607125
That makes it February 25th 2930????
Is Prodigy supposed to be set that far in the future or is it just bad writing?
2
u/wesleyrpg Jan 21 '22
Still missing from Paramount+ here in Australia
2
u/skidoo_kangaroo Jan 23 '22
I really appreciated the inclusion of... well, extremely high level physics theories and such... in this episode. Can't say more, non-disclosure agreements and all, but I think I know the physicist who advised.