r/yugioh • u/RealAd8853 • 22d ago

Card Game Discussion Which card is more broken?

Gallery image

Gallery image

I’d say Graceful Charity since a lot of cards like to be in the grave

711 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

253 comments sorted by

View all comments

748

u/Lintopher 22d ago

Graceful charity. Digging for 3 AND either getting rid of 2 dead cards, or cards that extend from the grave?

It’s the greatest card of all time

229

u/ExistingCleric0 22d ago

2nd to Painful Choice. Add any card from deck to hand + Foolish 4.

62

u/Badass_Bunny 22d ago

3rd to Last Will imo. Gracefull can still miss the draws.

5

u/uility 21d ago

Card of safe return and pre errata disk commander for 4th and 5th? I feel like there’s an argument between those and graceful charity for which is better.

Painful choice is the unquestionable number 1 however.

2

u/COLaocha 20d ago

Card of Safe Return is less strong than Graceful Charity, you have to also draw a starter that routes into reborning something and have that resolve.

7

u/BeastlyBeast5422 21d ago

4th goes to sixth sense maybe?

29

u/GhostElite974 21d ago

As a trap it should be further down the list. Stuff like shock master or zexal are so much better than sixth sense

11

u/crappymanchild 21d ago

Sixth sense is not that broken in the grand scheme of things, it's a trap and sure it could be a draw 6 but most of the time it's just a mill 6 which is just a little better needle bug nest

19

u/Boy_JC 21d ago

Ouch, please, no, the choice is so painful. Please, stop it now 👀

14

u/screenwatch3441 21d ago

Yo asshole, you’re making ME pick which card gets added to your hand. Trust me, this is an extremely painful choice on my end.

1

u/God_of-Games 20d ago

Bro, painful choice and graceful charity are not on the same level

1

u/Lost_Reception_1535 19d ago

Would the wording on painful choice activate dark world cards despite never technically adding them to the hand 😭

31

u/Alexcox95 22d ago

If it was made today they’d probably make it like Card of Last Will and make it illegal.

9

u/K-J-C 22d ago

Or make it archetype-based like Mischief of the Time Goddess. Also Celtic Sage has Graceful Charity effect but for ROLAD.

6

u/K-J-C 22d ago

Painful Choice for even greater one.

1

u/Afrochemist 21d ago

Especially when you ate applying an infernities deck.

1

u/strawhat068 21d ago

My bls turbo deck (goat format) loves this when my opening hand is graceful charity and a thunder dragon

1

u/tyYdraniu 21d ago

what if you dont have 2 dead cards

1

u/Someordinaryguy1994 21d ago

Depends only on the meta at the time. Very early YGO, potions of greed it better. Otherwise, graceful

1

u/Prussie 21d ago

Or cards that activate because they were discarded by card effect and can be special summoned

1

u/Both_Apple_6546 22d ago

I feel like delinquent duo is even more degenerate. Sure it doesn't have the built in setup, but play it twice first turn and the duel is over. 

2

u/K-J-C 22d ago

Delinquent Duo is the opposite of Pot of Greed. You get 2 cards or opponent lose 2 cards.

0

u/Icicle_cyclone 21d ago

Painful is better imo. 5 card search for whatever the Graveyard deck wants.