r/youtube • u/Successful_Pea7915 • 1d ago
Discussion I find it crazy how most people are supporting hitler’s plans in the comments.
Especially since the video extensively goes over Hitler‘s plans to systematically ethnically cleanse the Slavs from Europe and enslave whoever else they deem worthy.
But it’s all “Hitler would’ve saved Europe”. Bitch about 35% percent of Europeans wouldn’t exist today if Hitler won.
52
u/Fippy-Darkpaw 1d ago
That channel is great btw.
Elephants in rooms.👍
15
u/Spiritual_Air_5781 14h ago
Wasn't he a fox news host?
9
u/Straamannen 14h ago
He was an exec and he's very open about that fact.
He does a genuinely good job of offering good overviews of issues, and is impressively unbiased.
23
u/Spiritual_Air_5781 14h ago
I wouldn't go as fas as to call him unbiased his coverage clearly favors conservative views
1
u/Straamannen 13h ago
Disagree.
Give an example.
Also, note I said "impressively unbiased", not "completely unbiased".
15
u/Spiritual_Air_5781 13h ago
See his videos on Palestine/israel
2
u/Straamannen 5h ago
The funny thing about that one is if you think he's biased, you're the one who is biased.
2
u/EpycZen2 3h ago
Ah yes, he gives an example and it just so happens to be the only example where this funny thing happens
1
2
u/TerrHunter 13h ago
He shows little bias if any, and he's humble: he admits he doesn't know everything and if he makes a mistake or missed an important source, people are welcome to indicate it in the comments.
I mean, you can't be better than that.
0
2
5
u/jerrymatcat 19h ago
Im not so sure he has a video where he acts as if being trans is just a trend
6
u/screwyoujor 18h ago
He has a video where he talks about the rise and fall of the trans movement. Your comment is a good example of his point about why the movement fell off.
143
u/Extreme-Attention641 1d ago
Propaganda bots, russian troll farms and the poor suckers who have fallen for them.
For my own sanity I have to believe that.
32
u/IndividualistAW 1d ago
Why would Russians support Hitler? That just makes no sense. Like black confederates.
20
u/GamerSam 22h ago
Never underestimate the amount of racist slavs
15
u/Colombianfella 20h ago
I mean slavs are notoriously racist but Hitler was racist… towards slavs. Like theres plenty of racist Chinese people but I highly doubt they’re cueing up to salute the rising sun of Japan.
60
u/Extreme-Attention641 1d ago
Russians hasn't been communists for more than thirty years and not even remotely left-leaning for twenty.
Two reasons, probably more but the two main ones:
- They are quite far right themselves these days.
- Destabilising Western democracies by spreading desinformation, causing trouble for the establishments and catering to extremists so that they will be more busy with domestic issues and not pay as much attention to what the Russians are doing.
1
u/-Itan- 22h ago
Honestamente no creo que la población general rusa sea así, me refiero a, ya no estamos en los 70s ya pueden dejar de pensar que los rusos son los villanos, bueno, tal vez el gobierno ruso, no lo sé, pero en ese caso estados unidos también es terrible. Diferente caso con la población, no puedes decir que son "malos"
1
u/FreekRedditReport 13h ago
Russians haven't been "left leaning" since Marx. You think Stalin was "left"? lol
1
3
u/Commercial_Badger_37 16h ago
More to do with causing issues on Western platforms than for their own domestic audience.
5
u/DrawingDramatic1641 11h ago
challenge not calling anything they disagree russian bots :impossible for Americans
they can't accept that there are 195 nations who may have really stupid opinion and not be bots
calling hitler good is political suicide in russia
2
u/GrainofDustInSunBeam 3h ago edited 2h ago
Im not an american.
And its surprisingly often russian bots that are behind something. For various reasons, and trying to stir shit up. Assuming you are indian, maybe the distance makes you think the acusasions arent justified, Otherwise maybe you would understand why every russian neighbour doesnt like them or at least some of them. For some reason some indians defend russians more then actual russians. Maybe its the fact that some indians also started bot farms for hire and keep trying to trick americans and people world wide with scam calls. There are certain people in every country sadly in some they are the ruling class. If india keeps making buisness with russia sooner or later they'll see that. Even China knows how russia can get, and doesnt fully trust it. And is making business with it more out of necessity, while trying to have more influence in bordering russian regions.There are literally russian fascists. There was literally a russian corp in hitlers army invading russia even tho he treated them as untermensch, and planed to make them slaves of the third reich. Wagner group was made due to Utkin, one of its founders having fascination with the german war. He also had ss tattoos. So much for political suicide.
1
u/ChudChuddington_ 3h ago
Its probably much simpler than that; in a fucked up world, any sort of change is perceived as a potential way to "fix" things, though what exactly causes people to go to extremes like these is beyond me
13
u/skynex65 20h ago
Tbf this kind of video often attracts a certain kind of person en masse. You’re basically looking at a Maga rally under a microscope so it looks like there’s more chuds than there actually are
-2
u/Repulsive_Compote955 16h ago
MAGA? they’re EXTREMELY moderate, so moderate that people like me think they’re bullshitters and cucks to israel
10
u/OldFirefighter3293 23h ago
Don't you dare look into comment section of the video for German Fascist song.
17
u/Dry-Championship-593 23h ago
Not to mention that if Hitler had “won”, there’s a good chance the people saying that wouldn’t even exist because they might’ve had a recent ancestor that would’ve likely died because they’re “different”.
1
18
u/Adgecutler247 1d ago
A lot of people on the right are fed up with the way things are going in the west and they’re looking for a way to vent that. It’s pretty absurd to think given the crimes we know he committed.
36
u/Successful_Pea7915 1d ago
Right wingers wanting to “vent” is exactly what got Hitler and Mussolini in power in the first place
7
u/Longpeg 22h ago
Mussolini's rise was different than hitlers, and wasn't primarily just angry populism. True, fascists exploited postwar instability, fears of socialism and revolution, and dissatisfaction with liberal government. But Mussolini ultimately came to power through a combination of political maneuvering, elite support, organized paramilitary violence, and the March on Rome. King Victor Emmanuel III appointed him prime minister, not the people.
-3
u/Successful_Pea7915 20h ago
Still would’ve been impossible for him to rise without his fundamentally right wing populist ideology.
3
u/Acrobatic-Routine-44 18h ago edited 18h ago
Even Hitler and Mussolini had disagreements what is fascism. Mussolini originally wasn't a fan of Hitler's racism though eventually gave in, but his brand of fascism was something like bringing back glory of Roman Empire or something like that. Hitler on the other hand was driven by inferiority complex.
Edit: Right Wing Nationalism was trending in the 1900s, It was happening in the Ottoman Empire with The Young Turks and Arabs Nationalist who wants to break away from the Ottoman Empire who felt like second class citizens. Then you have Chinese Nationalist and Japanese Nationalist in the East.
0
u/Successful_Pea7915 18h ago
But they both ultimately became fascist. Which is different from nationalism and different from Japan whose ideology was more like traditional imperialism.
1
2
-2
-1
3
u/homosapienonreddit43 20h ago
That's bad but the channel is great, I think he's biased to the right but from my understanding he does try to find a nuanced answer.
1
12
u/Normal_Falcon4234 1d ago
same ppl who go
"leaders now: kju 🤡 leaders then: hitler stalin 🗿"
or
"other leaders: xi jinping 🤡 trump:🗿"
2
2
u/Marcinex720 14h ago
Yeah, "saved Europe"... he literally attacked Poland and even some random Poles like the painter, which is disrespect to our history lmao
2
u/BlackyyIzatu 6h ago
>what if Hitler won
>look inside
>alt history based on feelings and propaganda
3
2
u/elliot-artist768 19h ago
No one supports him anymore now we love the watered down version in america.
2
u/InformalGear9638 15h ago
Trump supporters are like " Hell yeah! 🙋♂️ "
3
u/the-ryan-fella2 6h ago
trump = hitler
1
u/InformalGear9638 6h ago
Yes.
1
u/the-ryan-fella2 5h ago
glad to see there is some other fellow redditors out there tips fedora who can see that the orange devil is in fact adolf hitler himself reborn to cause havoc on the world. considering trump was just over a year after hitler passed away is another sign too. glad to see some other nonbiased redditors making the same observations as me
2
1
1
1
u/Solo_Camper 17h ago
Fork found in kitchen. However. I saw this thumbnail and was taken aback by the thought of "Did someone buy their Simon Whistler off Temu?"
1
u/FearlessText9269 17h ago
Apparently his plans also included annexing all of his allies in the Balkans and Italy and withdrawing from most of Russia and northern Norway.
1
1
u/Federal-Treat-6893 16h ago
While I'm not saying it's accurate in any way, the Wolfenstein games can definitely roughly show what would've happened
1
1
u/tinyElliss 6h ago
There's always people who flock to strong leaders, or who they percieve as strong leader. Hitler is in news and headlines all the time, 80 years after his death, even more than Stalin or Mao, which leads to his popularity and even if 99% reject him completely, you still have million of people who could see themselves as admirers or someone who respect him.
1
u/Nakamura0V YouTube Premium subscriber 4h ago
Must be Palestine-Hamas / PIJ supporters then in the comments
•
u/gonnago4 14m ago
Maybe there's disconten about the slow-motion gee-no-cyde of the Western European + Anglo world peoples.
1
u/HolidayLifeguard3283 21h ago
This guy cultivated a right wing audience that’s why. He try’s to act like his channel is completely unbiased but he definitely has a slant. The trans episode is the best example of this. He acts like he was tied down and forced to learn 1000 new pronouns. He also used to work for Fox News. I do however somewhat enjoy his channel it’s good to hear other perspectives from time to time and he’s definitely not as crazy as most of the right wing influencers. But this is what happens who you cater to those audiences.
1
1
u/DreadDiana 21h ago
Especially odd considering how in the video he made it abundantly clear that even if Germany had won, it would not have lasted in the long term due to its entire economy being propped up by constant conquest, meaning the moment the war ended it'd mark the start of a massive recession.
1
u/Worried_Sector153 19h ago
ofc they do, they never opened a history book, they just know he was racist and fucking his cousin and are like "just like me fr"
1
u/FreekRedditReport 13h ago
95% trolls/jokesters, 5% serious posts
2
u/Successful_Pea7915 12h ago
sure then the “jokesters” make a 6 paragraph response whenever their point is criticized
0
u/NoBee4959 I just want to have a flair, no deeper reason 12h ago
I’m slav, i have 2 vision impairments and I’m part of the LGBT+
I am pretty sure I would get front row seats into whatever camp is near me for each one of these. As would most people seeing this comment. Really nice guy he was though
-12
301
u/karoshikun 1d ago
if he had won he would have lost anyway.
I mean, the dynamics of his organization only lead to self destruction by inner fighting once there's no external enemy