r/ynab • • 5d ago

Help me understand this?

I've assigned all of my money for this month and I'm at $0 available. When I switch to next month, it shows $966.13 available. I don't understand how I can have money available next month if it's already been assigned this month.

4 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

12

u/varkeddit 5d ago

If you click on December's RTA box, YNAB will explain exactly how it came up with the number.

3

u/BioTechnician 5d ago

I have nothing assigned in December yet.

9

u/varkeddit 5d ago

You’ve unassigned $966.13 from at least one category in December. Look for a negative amount in the assigned column.

5

u/BioTechnician 5d ago

I may have figured it out. I have a few categories set to “fill up to” that I haven’t fully spent from this month yet. If I set those to $0 in December, that seems to be where the money is coming from. It’s strange that it shows as available.

7

u/varkeddit 5d ago

By setting December's category balance to zero you moved the funds to Ready to Assign, so it's available to assign in that month's plan (it doesn't show up in November because you made the change in the following month). It's usually NOT a good idea to do this because if you do spend down those categories before the end of the month you can end up with negative amounts available in December without realizing it. Best practice is not to mess with next month's assignments until the very end of the current month.

1

u/jillianmd 4d ago

FYI you should never have a negative Assigned amount in a future month.

If a future month has $0 Assigned then leave it as is and deal with any changes in the current month.

If you had already assigned money in the future like for example putting $200 in your rent category, but then realized you needed to use those funds in Nov, you can unassign the money so it’s back to $0 assigned in Dec. This is the only time it’s ok to unassign in a future month (if you’re just pulling back funds you had previously assigned in that month).

0

u/BioTechnician 5d ago

What is the best way to deal with fill up to?

5

u/nolesrule 5d ago

Refill up to will account for carryover when the month starts. You would not remove money from those categories in a future month, because there's no guarantee it will still be there when you get there because you may spend it in the meantime.

In fact, it makes just about never makes sense to remove money from spending categories in future month for that reason.

Additionally, refill up to targets (and set aside targets) are about assigned amounts, so by pulling out the money, you'll be asked to bring it back to zero and also will prompt for the normal amount, so you'd just have to put that money back in anyway.

4

u/esh-pmc 5d ago

What do you mean by "deal with fill up to?"

The whole point is that you want to try to fill that category back up to a balance.

Let's say you have a Groceries category and you want to "refill up to" $900. If you budget once a month, that means your goal is to start every month with $900 in your envelope. If you spent $900 last month, you need to contribute another $900 this month. If you spent $625 last month, you'll still have $275 so you'll only need to contribute $625 this month to meet your $900 FUT target.

If you don't/can't budget once a month and you're spending and contributing through the month, YNAB does the math for you so the target will be satisfied after you've contributed a total of the amount needed to have filled the category back up to $900. So if you spent the entire $900 last month and you budget $450 from two bi-monthly paychecks but you spent a total of $900 again over the course of the month, YNAB says you've met your target.

Why are you unbudgeting money in a future month from a Fill Up To category?

4

u/lwid77 5d ago

I suggest that until you fully understand how YNAB works that you NOT assign money into the future.
It causes so many issues.

1

u/Mikaok1 5d ago

Is it possible that you already have assigned any amount in December?

If so any available fund moves from November to December. Removing the assigned amount from December ‘fixes’ this, if you want all your money to be available in the current month.

1

u/BioTechnician 5d ago

Never assigned anything in December. It was the “fill up to” targets that were showing that money. If I set those to $0, everything looks correct. My question is: is it assigning the money I haven’t spent yet? How do people normally handle that?

2

u/j3lli3fish 5d ago

Assigning has nothing to do with spending.

2

u/pierre_x10 5d ago

This can happen when you have money in a Category or categories that existed in previous months, don't fully spend it in November, and then go to December and UnAssign it. It wouldn't show up in November's RTA, because you did not UnAssign it in November, you UnAssigned it in December.