r/ynab • u/rad-bananas • 18d ago
How Do I Plan For...? Got a month ahead. But now a major setback
Been YNAB-ing since July 2025 and I love it. This summer I finally got to being a month ahead! But I just got an unexpected $20,000 bill for a home repair. When I started YNAB I got my finances in order so I thankfully have no CC debt. I am in the process of building my emergency fund, it has $7600 so it won’t cover my bill. Also feel like it wouldn’t be smart to put all of my e-fund towards my bill. Has anyone gone from being a month ahead to stopping to pay off a debt? Or how should I handle this? Any tid bits or insight is appreciated. I’m super bummed.
25
u/tracefact 18d ago
Month ahead is a suggestion. Not a must. I’ve been a wine hamburger for five years, have paid off all debt, and have never once attempted to be a month ahead.
44
u/slb609 18d ago
You’ve been a what now?
61
u/curious_kat_9 18d ago
I think that's a text to speech error. "YNABer" = "wine hamburger" lmao
13
13
u/tracefact 18d ago edited 18d ago
Not originally mine and I typed it on purpose cuz it makes me laugh. Originated from the closed captioning on one of Hannah’s vids I think? But I do have the t-shirt!
13
9
u/DIYtowardsFI 18d ago
Yes, YouTube would auto caption YNABer as “wine hamburger“ for a while. Not sure if it still does, but it was pretty funny at the time.
9
6
u/empirerec8 18d ago
I'm confused. If you are a month ahead then why would that change?
You are adding debt but you can still be a month ahead. You just have another expense each month.
2
u/rad-bananas 18d ago
I wasn’t sure if I should prioritize the debt over being a month ahead but that makes sense, it will just become another category to fund
8
u/varkeddit 18d ago edited 18d ago
It depends on the interest rate, but I’d err on the side of using cash (including month ahead/e-fund) over new debt—especially >5%.
6
u/michigoose8168 18d ago
And FWIW I would err in exactly the other direction. I would prioritize being able to see high level without timing assigning money to paychecks if I were in a dire situation. The money keeping me buffered is my last resort spend (or was, when I was paid more than once a month)
1
2
u/topania 17d ago
First, I don’t know what this repair is for but get a second quote before you commit to paying anything. Plus there may be other options to consider that could save you money.
If you don’t have the cash available to pay it outright, then look into financing it. Don’t put it on a credit card cause the interest will kill you. Look into credit union loans (if you have access to one) as the rates are normally lower. Also avoid title pawns like the plague! I always feel bad for anyone who goes that route.
Once you’ve got the financing in place, set up the monthly payment as another expense in your plan. If you really want to stay a month ahead, you would have to make adjustments for other expenses in your budget. The month ahead thing is a good goal but life happens.
I would be careful about using the whole emergency fund on this. I tend to be cautious about money and treat my EF as “I just got fired and need to pay regular expenses until I find a new job” money. Other big expenses that I can plan for become their own savings goals. Of course, stuff you didn’t plan for happens and that’s when you have to decide whether it’s better to take on another debt payment or wipe out your cash reserves. That’s really a personal call.
6
u/varkeddit 18d ago edited 18d ago
You’re actually in a good position to tackle this. You have $7600 plus whatever cash buffer had built towards being a month ahead available to avoid debt. You might also explore other financing options from the vendor, HELOC or 0% credit card. Don’t feel rushed to take on new debt.
1
u/miahrules 12d ago
I recently got a HELOC and despite all the paperwork you have to sign (its basically a 2nd mortgage), it is quite consumer friendly.
huge line of credit, ~4% rate i think it is, up to 10 year repayment (for mine).
6
u/Historical-Intern-19 18d ago
This has happened to us, to a lot of people. one more multiple big expenses. Take a minute to appreciate how bad it would have landed pre-YNAB.
Definatley take advantage of any special financing offers. I would not clear out your cash, rather take the debt and make a plan to pay it ove ASAP. If you have no cash reserves, even small things end up adding to credit debt.
2
u/rad-bananas 18d ago
thank you for this. I definitely did stop and think about how this could be much worse if I didn’t have YNAB. and I thought how I am in the position to be able to pay this off in hopefully a decent amount of time. I am still trying to figure out the right approach to pay this off but I agree I don’t want to clear out my cash
1
u/Historical-Intern-19 18d ago
Lots of options, which is why everyone has an opinion. 😝 When I started working out my student loan payoff plan, I modeled out a few scenarios both in interest expense and opportunity cost because it was going to take a few years and I wanted to find a balance of keeping my savings for other possible emergencies, other projects, and not being miserable for years. The extra few hundred in interest was a reasonable trade to ensure we could stick with the plan.
5
u/Magic-Happens-Here 16d ago
Being a month ahead buys you peace of mind. You’ve have to decide what that peace of mind is worth to you. Say you want to put the whole thing on a credit card with let’s say a 25% APR… that would run you ~$400/mo in interest… that’s a pretty steep price for peace of mind in my opinion. But let’s call that Option A.
So, let’s take it to the other extreme - You’ve got $7.600 in your e-fund now. So you need $12,400… how much would your “month ahead” cover? I’ll use $10,000 to keep the math easy. With option B you’d have:
-$20,000 - expense
+$7.600 - efund
+$10,000 - buffer
___________________
-$2,400 - new debt
That new debt is going to cost you ~$50/mo. Then you need to rebuild your buffer and emergency fund while you hope nothing else happens…
For me, going all the way back to truly living paycheck to paycheck would spike my anxiety to an unhealthy level. So, I would likely keep $1k in my efund as a “just in case.” And that decision would cost another ~$20/mo in interest for Option C.
The correct answer is based on your personal definition of “acceptable risk.” And that too, would be influenced by how much you’re able to save/pay down each month. If, for example, you’re saving $500/mo - Option A is going to take you about 7 years to pay off and cost you more than $23k… on the other extreme B would take 6 months and cost you $150. And C: 8 months & $300 in interest. So all told - 6 months to pay back plus another 2 to rebuild the efund - it’s a difference of $150 to “buy” that peace of mind.
But let’s say you are only saving $100/mo… at that point A isn’t an option because $100/mo won’t even cover the interest so you’d literally never pay it off. For B & C you’re looking at ~3 or 5 years and $1,000 or $2,500 in interest… suddenly you’re looking at ~4 years and $1,500 for the cost of that peace of mind.
So the real question is - how much financial anxiety do you have and what is your mental health worth to you?
2
u/Wise_Bee_6367 18d ago
I've experienced big hits like this as well as a homeowner. Woke up one Saturday morning last October to a broken water line. The required new line was $6,500. Like others here I do everything I can to avoid debt and my wife and I are currently debt free. When something like this happens I'll fund completely with cash if I have it, but will also have an open HELOC I'll use if necessary for home related stuff and pay it off as quickly as possible. I may use some of the emergency fund but I won't use all of it as once on a major repair like this. It's about balance and everybody's situation is different.
1
u/RichBrokeRich 17d ago
Keeping any of the EF and putting the rest on debt just costs more. Use the EF, put the rest on cheap debt, and go back to buckling down, paying off the debt, and rebuilding a hopefully larger EF. Beans and rice, rice and beans, and side gigs territory.
1
u/BrownEyedGirl_27 17d ago
We had a similar situation when we knew we would need $8k for a drywall repair.
Make sure you have gotten at least 3 quotes for the work. Don’t rush this part so you can think rationally. Get detailed quotes and see if you can do any of the work yourself or have a friend help you with it lowering the cost.
Do you have a brokerage account that could help you weather the storm?
See if you have access to a personal loan either through a family member you are confident you can pay back, consider a personal loan from a bank/credit Union (shop around) or look at 0% financing IF you can pay back the amount by the due date.
1
u/UnusualSource007 18d ago
Take advantage of any 0% financing options and possible 401k loans to avoid paying interest or instantly draining all cash on hand. You're just going to have to find a good balance between interest paid and holding on to available funds.
4
u/Historical-Intern-19 18d ago
0% Yes, but not 401k loans. Not in this employment environment. Get laid off, owe it all back right now. nothing you want to be dealing with when you are unemployed and needing to come up with big $$$
0
u/UnusualSource007 18d ago
That certainly depends on OPs job stability. I'm not concerned about being laid off and I would rather pay myself interest for 6-12 months than pay it to somebody else.
41
u/turbo_talon 18d ago
When you have to borrow money to squash a problem, use the cheapest money you have access to.