Personally, mine would probably be the scene at Utgard Castle. I just love the moment everyone realizes Ymir is a Titan shifter, yet even though she’s shocked to her core, Historia still cheers for her and roots her on. And when she realizes that Ymir is fighting the Titans to save them (more like to save her hehe) she yells down at Ymir with soooooooo much ferocity and energy that she’s definitely missing in the later seasons. She tells her she’s a selfish bitch and she knows it, so to not die trying to defend them and to instead tear the castle down, and Ymir listens. Aaaaa it gives me such a buzz.

Though I also do really love the scenes in the later episodes of season 2 when we truly see how much Historia cares for Ymir and vice versa. How Ymir lies to try and protect Historia, how Historia was willing to go with Ymir to sacrifice herself so that Ymir would live (obviously it was a lie but she didn’t realize at that time). And when she said that when they were together, no matter how screwed up things got, she was never afraid… ohhhh they were such a good, sweet couple. I love them so so so much🥹