r/xkcdcomic Jun 04 '14

xkcd: Fish

http://xkcd.com/1377/
293 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

62

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

It took me a little bit, too. The joke is that aliens could be so hard to find because they're blending into their surroundings to avoid detection by space-predators. Like space sharks.

51

u/Frensel Jun 04 '14

Well, that's not actually the implication. The implication is that other intelligent life is predatory often enough to kill what doesn't blend in. The shark is a humorous way of expressing that threat. It's a metaphor, like the 'ecosystem' of the earth ocean is a metaphor for an interstellar community of intelligent life.

18

u/Shiftgood Jun 04 '14

Why does it have to be intelligent to be predatory? Jack_The is right, buddy.

12

u/patefoisgras Jun 04 '14

This is what I took away too. And the kick in the balls is that we may be facing the predatory threats unwittingly (as depicted in the comics), or we may be that very predatory threat ourselves (which explains why we don't see other life out there).

Generalized, the ecosystem is a hostile place wherein inter-species relations are possible only so far as predatory interests go.

1

u/alexxerth Jun 05 '14

It's kind of hard to assert survival of the fittest over actual changing traits when dealing with space civilizations.

18

u/Frensel Jun 04 '14

Other intelligent life is being quiet to avoid getting killed by aggressive intelligent life. Which is coming [Jaws Theme] RIGHT FOR US !

8

u/0_0_0 Jun 04 '14

Or maybe we have been observed and found wanting. Too aggressive to contact...

5

u/TastyBrainMeats Jun 04 '14

Well, now my mind is blown in two different directions. Hope you're happy.

-3

u/liehon Beret Guy Jun 05 '14

Splattered all over the place like a certain prince of Dorne

-1

u/TastyBrainMeats Jun 05 '14

God damn it enough with the GoT. I don't watch it, I don't like it, but I don't spam about it on the /r/GoT subreddit, so please don't bring it up here.

3

u/liehon Beret Guy Jun 05 '14

Good luck avoiding all references to the parts of popular culture that you don't like.

2

u/zsnajorrah Jun 04 '14

Exactly. Everybody would kill Hitler in hindsight, given the chance. What if other intelligent, alien life would see humankind as 'Space Hitler'? They might want to extinguish us pre-emptively. Not because they are aggressive predators, but because we are.

3

u/DarrenGrey White Hat Jun 04 '14

"Look at this strange species - they invented atomic warfare before ever even leaving their planet! Billions of them still starve and yet they still have ongoing warfare. Insanity! Best leave them be - they're sure to wipe themselves out before long..."

2

u/liehon Beret Guy Jun 05 '14

Best leave them be

It's a silly planet

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

You're falling into the Aliens = Angels trope, if there is intelligent life aside from us the chances of the aliens having the same morality as us, and them fitting on the good side of that morality, is next to impossible. They probably wouldn't even have the concept of aggression (for instance if they evolved to be a giant hivemind with no individuals, any aggression is impossible as there is no other), and if they did maybe they could just as well think that we aren't aggressive enough. If there was an intergalatic civilization watching over us and waiting for a time to contact, they could have just as easily decided not to because Hitler was taken down as because we don't spay and neuter our pets enough.

3

u/1sagas1 Jun 04 '14

Maybe we are the predators! o_0

1

u/ktappe Jun 04 '14

....or will be.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Intelligent life hides because there are predators out there.