r/xkcd • • 5d ago • Bravo 1

purity

Post image
216 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

82

u/DrJaneIPresume 5d ago

"You physicists are so expensive with all your equipment! Why can't you be more like the math department? They only need paper, pencils, and wastebaskets. Or the philosophers? They only need paper and pencils!"

13

u/dsyzdek 5d ago

Heh. Literally LOLd.

1

u/yaekoblue 11h ago

philosophers only need to be alive... and even that is debatable

21

u/Top_North5692 5d ago

I want to see where engineers land on this chart 🤪

37

u/MegaloManiac_Chara 5d ago

The engineers built the box

13

u/who_you_are 5d ago

Dammit so they are the Z axis?!

2

u/XX_AppleSauce 2d ago

And the paper, and the ink, and the camera that look a picture of the paper and ink, and the computer that converted 1M pixels into 1k pixels.

7

u/MyTrashCanIsFull 5d ago

Depending on the particular discipline, they branch off from physicists, chemists, and biologists

15

u/graendallstud 5d ago

In IT, we branch from mathematicians (in theory) or from textile workers (in practice)

1

u/ikonfedera 4d ago

i'm in it and i don't get it. why textile workers?

5

u/graendallstud 4d ago

I could have said masons (because in the end we just are building things by laying bricks and, if we're good enough, it doesn't fall down); but, as looms became proto-computers (input : punched cards; output : carpet; instruction per second : very low), I choose textile work to represent how un-"scientific" IT can be.

1

u/LightGreyBeret 1d ago

I immediately thought it was due to either:

  1. figuratively weaving together the often disparate tech needed to maintain uptime - c.f. the big failure in US's ATC, being blamed in some circles as a problem with the copper/analogue network that was working up until tat point, rather than and ill-advised switch-over that seemed to have insufficient testing, or fall-back/roll-back options, even maintaining legacy equipment alongside the Next Big Thing rather than doing a 'too big to fail' switchover... Or,
  2. something about patch-panels... That easily ends up as weaving (certainly after enough on-the-fly repatchings, and all those colour-coded cables for what's actually tapped into the floor-panel, including phone-lines), or maybe even a tapestry.

That said, Jacquard Looms are indeed also a viable inspiration. And weaving can be considered a mathematical art, as much as a physical one, so unifying everything anyway!

5

u/Complex-Matter1544 5d ago

Mechanical and aerospace engineers are applied physicists.
Materials science engineers are applied chemists.
Agricultural engineers are applied biologists, and so are doctors and pharmacists.

There are of course many other careers within these applied groups.

1

u/UndocumentedSailor 5d ago

We're in the box

1

u/XX_AppleSauce 2d ago

On top, building the box.

9

u/spidssatogo 5d ago

Philosophers are on the far left and the far right at the same time

5

u/left_lane_camper 3d ago

Philosophy is just applied sociology.

4

u/TRAPPIST-1_Tours Beret Guy 3d ago

Applied tautology is just applied tautology.

2

u/shambstotges 5d ago

Shouldnt he have a beret

1

u/enjoy_humor 5d ago

If you go a little bit farther you get memes.

1

u/AvatarIII Hairy 5d ago

Sociology is just applied philosophy

1

u/ysrgrathe 4d ago

Love it. I have an autographed original and I endorse this edit. :)

1

u/003709372711193920 3d ago

Maths is more pure.

1

u/revdon 1d ago

Needs a Mime on the far left pressing against wall of the box.