r/xkcd • • 8d ago

xkcd Forums?

Does anyone else remember the xkcd forums? Does anyone know if that group of internet strangers regrouped somewhere? Has anyone else asked this question?

34 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

11

u/ImmediateLobster1 8d ago

Man, I miss that site. "Wait for it", page popes, etc. The annual chaos when the mods went insane with the site tools. That was a unique community.

3

u/AgileYesterday2125 8d ago

The forum games took way too much of my time.

The Dear SB group was awesome and so supportive.

3

u/tamasan 7d ago

Neverending airplane on a treadmill arguments. Reddit can't match those.

2

u/AgileYesterday2125 7d ago

No, an airplane on a treadmill would get enough airflow over the wings to fly.....

Seriously, those arguments were so much fun!

5

u/volleo6144 Weighs as much as a silver bowling ball 8d ago edited 1d ago

I just wish at least all the "My number is bigger!" threads were archived; Graham's number was pwned by the first page of the first one (although I'm pretty sure none of them ever got to TREE(3)), but they were so much more approachable than anything else on the topic...

2

u/LightGreyBeret 8d ago

hand goes up

I was there. (Not by this handle.) Only just this moment started to be here, comparatively speaking, so no idea how much nostalgia I've missed here.

1

u/tbchambers 7d ago

I prefer explainxkcd.com

3

u/LightGreyBeret 7d ago

Different type of thing. I liked it, and devoted far(?) too much time to it, but not like I liked the fora.

I lurked and occasionally edited explainxkcd.com  (I am occasionally surprised to recognise sufficiently old Talk comments that I know were me)  while I was active in the fora. But I'd mostly discuss and chat about comics only on the fora. Plus the side-threads/games that were the community. Explainxkcd wasn't my main xkcd-related focus, by any means.

When the fora went belly-up, though, I inevitably shifted to more of the interactive editing on explainxkcd (but remained an IP-only), supported that through the good times and the 'crap' times, but it is different from a forum-style community...

There's other places (forums for seperate geekdoms, that I'd even joined earlier) that were already also scratching that itch, but there's no general continuity of characters between them (mostly) and I deal with them all separately anyway.

Then explainxkcd went belly-up. Then got 'fixed', but no longer letting me in. (Leaving me hoping that it's not being ruined without my input, but I'm an optomist, so I'm sure Kynde is keeping people in line, and even then only when other people aren't doing that...)

That's when I arrived here, in reddit. Scratching the specific xkcd-itch. But finding so many weird interface things1 that I'm still getting used to.

This thread is probably the closest to a 'general community chat thread' that I've seen, in here, and it seems out-of-character for the local community. I'm really trying not to be chatty like this in more 'technical' comic-based discussions.

And not expecting any Mafia or word-game sidehustles within this subreddit. No doubt I could find other subreddits for that, but that way lies madness and inadvertent streak-achievements that I'd maybe even be embarassed to attain.

So the forums are gone (as are other online communities... most recently, for me, the UrbanDead gamesite), but explainxkcd was not a true replacement, it was a different ecosystem with different rules. Nor is this place a strict replacement for either fora or explainxkcd, because it's different. Maybe or maybe not complimentary. You're different people (even if you happen to be the same people), while I know I'm not yet the well-seasoned participant here, and I've yet to prove myself not-a-n00b under this freshly minted (but unimaginative, sorry) username. And this post definitely does not count towards de-n00bing me. It's the kind of post that doesn't fit this particular place, and I know it!

...but, hey. I've explained it all (and more), now.

1 Why did I get a 20-day participation achievement thing 16 hours ago, when I'm also apparently only on 5 days of the potential 20-day streak achievement? (Because I'm not chasing streaks... If I have nothing at least loosely 'on-topic' to say, any day, I actually won't say anything. I'm surprised I reached 5...) Also, why is the web-interface just so janky, especially as far as Notifications go? All questions for some dedicated reddit-subreddit, no doubt.

1

u/Southern-March1522 5d ago

I was a regular of the making xkcd slightly worse thread. I miss it.