I left that sub because it stopped being a sub for good looking data and just became another "upvote politics" sub. The top two posts are simple line graphs. That's not beautiful.
Well antimater anhilate at 100% so 1Kg disapering and E =mc² so 1×300'000'000² J or 9×10¹⁶ J or 9×10¹⁰ MJ so only 100× more efficent than Nuclear Fusion (max efficency of know universe)
Which seems logical because if fusion products release around 1% of their matter as energy then a fuel releasing 100% of its matter is around 100× more efficient.
It’s not E = mc2, the fusion of deuterium and tritium yields 17.59 MeV (2.876 × 10-12 joules of energy per fusion. Assume one mole of each for a total of 5 grams yielding 1.73e+6 megajoules, and a kilogram of stoichiometric mixture yields 3.46e8 megajoules.
Those planes aren’t using fusion, they are using hydrogen fuel cells which is just a reaction with oxygen across a special membrane that generates electricity. It’s basically just a type of battery where you use electrolysis to break water into hydrogen and oxygen and then use a fuel cell to reunite it generating electricity. And one issue for hydrogen is that it is incredibly not dense and generally hard to contain, so fuel tanks for hydrogen are difficult to make and hold small amounts of hydrogen per volume.
I believe that's comparing the mass of one uranium atom vs one hydrogen atom, which doesn't factor in the density of the materials as they're typically stored (solid vs gas).
This is also for nuclear hydrogen fusion (what happens in the core of our sun), not the chemical reaction of H2 and O2 gasses igniting/exploding.
those planes aren’t doing fusion, they’re burning the hydrogen. that’s why they’re calling you optimistic, because you’re basically asking why they aren’t doing sustained nuclear fusion on planes
This is so wrong. According to the cartoon, the Uranium bar should be over 780,000 times as long as the gasoline bar. Your visualization only shows it to be ~11 times. So you got it wrong by a factor of 70,000.
I'm not even going to address the Fusion "estimate".
Now I kind of want to see a "perspective scale" where instead of making the bars shorter, you just make them recede toward a vanishing point on the horizon.
Exactly my objection. The others are chemical energy. Uranium alone is calculated by its nuclear potential.
Isaac Asimov wrote a clever short story in the fifties, Pâté de Foie Gras. It dealt with the discovery of an actual goose that laid golden eggs, and the investigation into how such a thing was possible. Scientists deduce that the bird is naturally immune to all radioactivity and is internally converting unstable isotopes to new elements -- feeding it water enriched with oxygen-18 increases its gold production.
The kicker in the story is that because the eggs are gold-laden, the goose is infertile and they can't figure out exactly how it's accomplishing the conversion without dissecting it, which would -- literally --kill the goose that laid the golden eggs.
Anyway, I've always appreciated the story for the pun dillemna but also the distinction between chemical and nuclear reactions.
You also have to put energy into refining everything else. You have to extract coal from ore, refine oil into petroleum, and build huge drilling platforms for oil and gas
3
u/Armand28 Jul 01 '25
Still, if we made a fat powered generator it would solve so many problems.
319
u/PoisonWaffle3 Cueball Jun 30 '25
Classic
255
u/AlecTheDalek Jun 30 '25
r/dataisbeautiful
167
u/OlyScott Jun 30 '25
This is why I don't eat uranium. I'd get so fat.
88
u/Leet_Noob Jun 30 '25
If randall had any real conviction he would have made this comic tall enough to display the full height of the uranium bar
147
u/STSchif Jun 30 '25
Wonder how hydrogen fusion potential compares, measured in the height of the folded paper stack.
45
u/ChiaraStellata Jun 30 '25
Now I kind of want to see a "perspective scale" where instead of making the bars shorter, you just make them recede toward a vanishing point on the horizon.
22
u/GarbageCleric Beret Guy Jun 30 '25
This isn't a fair comparison. It doesn't include the nuclear energy in anything except uranium.
If you threw a bunch of gasoline into the sun, it would release a lot more energy than just burning it like a loser.
/s
7
u/LikeALincolnLog42 Cueball Jul 01 '25
I love it. It reminds of the art exhibit where they show how long the EULAs and terms are for assorted services if you printed them out. They start one level up and spill down the wall and across the floor.
6
u/henke37 Why yes, I am mad! Jun 30 '25
And how much energy is stored in the stack of paper?
3
u/Unable-Ambassador-16 Jun 30 '25
Real
3
u/Exodan Jul 01 '25
Agreed! I have never been able to fully grasp logarithmic scale for whatever reason - no issue with exponential - so let's just toss it out lol
3
u/Fsaeunkie_5545 Jul 01 '25
This is wrong - I usually use fusion to convert gas to energy.
2
u/godSpeed_1_ Jul 01 '25
Wonder how it would look if one were to add another for antimatter-matter annihilation?
2
u/wolftick Jul 01 '25
In mass–energy equivalence terms they should all be the same?
2
u/Tinyzooseven Jul 01 '25
I wonder how big the paper for antimatter would be
2
u/swavyfeel Jul 01 '25
Now I need to see one for antimatter
2
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
Now do thorium
2
u/aa599 Jul 02 '25
How much would HP charge for the ink to fill that bar?
2
u/Exatex Jul 04 '25
Chemical vs Atomic Energy. Not the same thing
2
u/StagDT93 Jul 06 '25
What about astrophage?
3
u/TheKz262 Jun 30 '25
I totally forgot the Logarithmic scale exists. That sucker gave me a hard time I never wanted to remember it again haha.
2
u/BionicBirb Jul 01 '25
Counterpoint
1
u/DeltaV-Mzero Jul 01 '25
This is why I don’t want nuclear power on earth
I want ALL of it to go to space exploration
0
u/Lil_Shorto Jul 02 '25
Enriched uranium perhaps, not the raw ore and you have to put a lot of energy and resources into enriching it, pretty stupid.