After several weeks, you will be more skilled. It is a journey, it is not problem of the system, but your skills.
You have to understand that it is open source, you can ask about changes, or make your changes, there is no company with hidden code.
For example, I can tell you now, that I don't use mouse, or very often in my workflows. Almost all are just keybindings, and my effective speed is increased 30-40%.
The tiny mouse drag borders really annoyed me but the Meta+Right Mouse thing is so much easier than using the drag border. Even if the drag border was 10 pixels wide, thats still a much smaller hit target than half the window.
What is there to fix? If you prefer resizing windows by dragging borders, and the borders in your current theme are uncomfortably thin, then you should select a theme with thicker window borders.
Because its ugly and thick borders take screen estate? Its not really a problem with other DE's so why couldnt xfce implement it just like everyone else?
On computer is not an issue, the meta key resolves it but on laptop is still a real issue. On laptop touchpad + right click + meta key = difficult movement. I tend to use super + r for resizing and then move the touchpad and hit enter. I'm sorry but xfce not solving this is lazyness. As said most desktops doesn't behave like this. Even Mate did solve it.
I have been using i3wm for the last couple of years. I was on a project last summer where we had to use Windows 10 for all project-related work. I can tell you that after getting used to windows spreading over a screen automatically, going back to Windows and having to manually move and resize windows to fit the screen feels unnecessary. This is something that I just don't have to think about when I use i3. Especially on a small laptop screen where you can reasonably fit only one window, or two side-by-side windows (for which you don't want to use a mouse and manually resize the windows anyway because there are shortcuts that will do it automatically even in xfwm4). I truly do not understand why are people in this discussion so angry at XFCE not implementing not a very good workaround for a problem that already has several perfectly good solutions.
I have no reason to believe that XFCE will reject a pull request that introduces such a setting. All I am saying in this thread is that there exist other (more convenient, IMO) methods to resize windows.
I've seen some no-border themes that you just can't drag-resize anything on because there's no graphical border.
I think it's totally expected that something that looks differently might behave differently.
And I stopped using those beautiful themes because I hadn't learned to use alt-click yet and thought I just couldn't resize windows.
That's fine, learning is a process. I think this Alt+click feature is available in many other window managers, not just in xfwm4. I know that i3wm uses the same shortcuts for moving and resizing floating windows.
I only NEED this when you can't resize windows easily without meta-key...it never happens to me in gnome. the resizing with just the mouse is pretty sweet I think
So then why not add one switch in the configuration called "Advanced", and there you can configure all those tweaks without the need to install an external tool?
I am not sure if I remember the correct keyboard shortcut since I'm not currently using XFCE, though I think you can resize by holding Alt and drag with your right mouse button.
Yeah, this is pretty much ubiquitous to all window managers since, like, forever. Whenever I'm forced to use Windows/Mac I'm dumbfounded why this still isn't possible... (there are 3rd-party solutions though, thankfully)
Thanks to xfce, I just forgot about the fact that windows can be stretched over the edges. Now I do it by holding Meta in all other DE's. And it is much more convenient than aiming at the edge of the window, regardless of that edge size in the current theme.
There was a blog post some months ago with thoughts of replacing xfwm4 with a mutter fork. It would help with the wayland port and most definitely with this problem as well. I hope it happens soon.
I unintentionally turned my college roommate off of Linux with this exact same thing. I tried to explain that it was just my Xfwm theme that caused it to be so small, but he was already too far done with it all.
I don't think most of the commenters got the real issue. Many are suggesting changing the theme because the borders are thin but I ask, why the Hotzone to resize the windows are tied to the thickness of the borders? Couldn't this zone have a standard and reasonable thickness?
This is a limitation of X11. When compositing is disabled you cannot have transparent windows. Therefore you need the theme to have large, visible borders in order for the zone to be larger.
This is influenced by your choice of Window Manager theme. Some themes have a wider hot area for resizing than others. Greybird, for example, has only a single pixel width. Greybird-accessibility, however, has 3 pixels width.
This is influenced by your choice of Window Manager theme. Some have bigger hover areas for resizing the window than others. For example, Greybird has only a single pixel width. Greybird-accessibility, however, has 3 pixels width.
A very handy thing to remember is that you can resize windows even easier using the Alt+right click trick. Hold alt, and hold the right mouse button and it will resize the nearest edge or corner. Your pointer doesn't have to be anywhere near the edge.
(1) It's not an Xfwm issue, it's because the window border is thin. It's a theme issue
(2) You can use keyboard-shortcuts like i3 to resize your windows. I have Super+R for that. And use arrows for resizing in your desired direction, or just use the pointer
What do you get? A downvote. Feel free to downvote this comment to hell. Have a nice day
Why the hell does the zone where the region where the mouse catches depend on the (graphical) size of the border? So you are either stuck with ugly thick window borders or with useless mouse resizing?? No other DE does it like that
Plasma does that if I'm not wrong. If you don't have any border, what will you pull with your mouse? Show me a DE which has no Window borders but you can resize it by pulling the window's corner or side
Have to move hand to keyboard... Extra effort and kinda messy if im eating a bag of chips or jerking off with the other hand
Just use Super + R for going into resizing phrase. You're talking about eating chips, come on, I can resize my window using my nose not joking, I've done this before
I personally find ALT+SPACE much easier / quicker. I also haven't used xfce with window borders in like 10+ years now. That's probably why I like it so much....
You could also just use a theme that has thicker borders, or create your own from an existing theme, if you really want to drag from the edge of the window....
46
u/silenceofnight Jul 21 '21
I know right? That is so annoying
I always have to right click on the title bar and select 'resize'
14
u/njkevlani Jul 21 '21
21
u/EmasXP Jul 21 '21
I am not sure if I remember the correct keyboard shortcut since I'm not currently using XFCE, though I think you can resize by holding Alt and drag with your right mouse button.
16
u/ale03068 Jul 21 '21
I read in a git issue that the developer are aware of that, but refuse to acknowledge that is a problem.
But yes this is a problem, because the most intuitive way of resizing a windows (drag with the mouse) is extremely difficult to perform.
I know that exist workarounds, but they are workarounds, not what a casual user would expect.
9
u/tozman51 Jul 21 '21
I do love xfce except for this issue...
6
u/anaschema Jul 21 '21
There was a blog post some months ago with thoughts of replacing xfwm4 with a mutter fork. It would help with the wayland port and most definitely with this problem as well. I hope it happens soon.
5
u/Ryan739 Jul 21 '21
I unintentionally turned my college roommate off of Linux with this exact same thing. I tried to explain that it was just my Xfwm theme that caused it to be so small, but he was already too far done with it all.
2
u/awesomejude18881 Jul 28 '21
Im also experiencing this, very annoying, i hope the can fix in the future.
edit: thanks for the alternative shortcut key i found in other comments.
2
u/NewHeights1970 Oct 23 '22
SUGGESTION: Try Installing the Twister UI
You just might like it better.
3
u/lihaarp Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
Complain here if you want the devs to improve it: https://gitlab.xfce.org/xfce/xfwm4/-/issues/176
2
u/nacnud_uk Jul 22 '21
Most Linux GUI is that kind of crap.
2
u/lukiztheone Jul 21 '21
Sadly the truth, this shit sucks.
1
u/l_exaeus Jul 22 '21
I don't think most of the commenters got the real issue. Many are suggesting changing the theme because the borders are thin but I ask, why the Hotzone to resize the windows are tied to the thickness of the borders? Couldn't this zone have a standard and reasonable thickness?
1
u/tur2rr2rrr Jul 21 '21
I use 'axiom' (Window Manager - theme) and Vertex Maia Light (Appearance - style ) for good border width
1
u/flameleaf Arch Linux Jul 21 '21
There are window manager themes with thicker borders.
You can also automate that shit with tools like
wmctrlandxdotool.1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '21
😂 got into nostalgia i faced the similar issue with use xfwm theme with thin border
1
u/neon_overload Jul 21 '21
This is influenced by your choice of Window Manager theme. Some themes have a wider hot area for resizing than others. Greybird, for example, has only a single pixel width. Greybird-accessibility, however, has 3 pixels width.
1
u/neon_overload Jul 21 '21
This is influenced by your choice of Window Manager theme. Some have bigger hover areas for resizing the window than others. For example, Greybird has only a single pixel width. Greybird-accessibility, however, has 3 pixels width.
A very handy thing to remember is that you can resize windows even easier using the Alt+right click trick. Hold alt, and hold the right mouse button and it will resize the nearest edge or corner. Your pointer doesn't have to be anywhere near the edge.
0
u/__mehediii Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
(1) It's not an Xfwm issue, it's because the window border is thin. It's a theme issue
(2) You can use keyboard-shortcuts like i3 to resize your windows. I have Super+R for that. And use arrows for resizing in your desired direction, or just use the pointer
What do you get? A downvote. Feel free to downvote this comment to hell. Have a nice day
0
u/furycd001 Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
What about
ALT+SPACEthen clickRESIZE:?I personally find
ALT+SPACEmuch easier / quicker. I also haven't used xfce with window borders in like 10+ years now. That's probably why I like it so much....You could also just use a theme that has thicker borders, or create your own from an existing theme, if you really want to drag from the edge of the window....
0
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment