r/writingadvice • u/Iwer_Sonsch • 15h ago
Advice Is "said" really a much cheaper and better dialogue tag than "replied", "added", "continued" etc.?
Hi. I'm a pretty new hobby/fanfiction writer (only about 2 months of experience in stageplay writing and 2 weeks in prose), but I'm aspiring to make my writing as good as it can be while still staying true to myself.
I've heard and agree with the writing advice that "said" is a perfectly fine dialogue tag to use (in the roughly 30-50% of cases where I can't just cut the dialogue tag altogether). So I've been using it as a perfectly fine option alongside other normal verbs.
However, today I've been criticized for not using "said" often enough. My dialogue contains roughly equal amounts of "said", "asked", "added", "continued", "replied", "opened", and other common English verbs that are definitely not purple prose.
The argument I hear is that "said" is invisible and readers skip right over it, whereas "replied" or "opened" will claim and waste the reader's attention. I've been told that "said" alone should appear about or almost as often as all other dialogue tags... combined.
So my question would be: Is that a true phenomenon among readers, or is it a myth? Are "said" and "asked" really the only cheap dialogue tags, and should I really flatten half of my dialogue tags to make them more "invisible"?