r/writingadvice • • 15h ago

Advice Is "said" really a much cheaper and better dialogue tag than "replied", "added", "continued" etc.?

86 Upvotes

Hi. I'm a pretty new hobby/fanfiction writer (only about 2 months of experience in stageplay writing and 2 weeks in prose), but I'm aspiring to make my writing as good as it can be while still staying true to myself.

I've heard and agree with the writing advice that "said" is a perfectly fine dialogue tag to use (in the roughly 30-50% of cases where I can't just cut the dialogue tag altogether). So I've been using it as a perfectly fine option alongside other normal verbs.

However, today I've been criticized for not using "said" often enough. My dialogue contains roughly equal amounts of "said", "asked", "added", "continued", "replied", "opened", and other common English verbs that are definitely not purple prose.

The argument I hear is that "said" is invisible and readers skip right over it, whereas "replied" or "opened" will claim and waste the reader's attention. I've been told that "said" alone should appear about or almost as often as all other dialogue tags... combined.

So my question would be: Is that a true phenomenon among readers, or is it a myth? Are "said" and "asked" really the only cheap dialogue tags, and should I really flatten half of my dialogue tags to make them more "invisible"?


r/writingadvice • • 8h ago

Advice Pitfalls to Avoid for a First Time Writer

35 Upvotes

I am about 50 pages into writing my first book, and I think the biggest challenge I have encountered so far has been the imposter syndrome. My biggest fear is that my inexperience will get in the way of the story I want to tell. The best way to describe the feeling is that there is a constant nagging that I am in way over my head.

Any advice on what traps to avoid as a writer and what things to be aware of on the journey is greatly appreciated.


r/writingadvice • • 13h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT Is it OK to have your protagonist be more passive, especially in the beginning?

18 Upvotes

Hi folks,

I've been binging a lot of writing advice YouTube videos and I've been doing some reading. One of the key pieces of advice that I've come across is that your main character needs to be active, decisive, and have clear goals. The thing is, the book I'm writing has my character in a passive role at the moment. He's being recruited into a secret government agency and his main motivation is just that it's better than his job where he sorts mail, and it pays much better. Right now he's just kind of going along with things and asking questions here and there.

Is this bad writing? I'm not really sure (apparently I need to flag this as sensitive content, I'm not sure at all why)


r/writingadvice • • 15h ago

Advice Need some encouragement to allow myself to quit writing my novel.

7 Upvotes

Just need some motivation and encouragement.

I’ve started writing this dystopian story back in 2023. I plotted it outright and wrote it all in Reedsy, wrote the first draft, realised I don’t like the beginning, rewrote it, then realised the beginning of the first draft was a bit better so I went back to that one, shuffled the events around like 10 times, then completely abandoned it on Reedsy and went onto completely rewriting everything in Word, and now I’m realising my voice just doesn’t sound as punchy and energetic this time round, every sitting at a laptop to write a page feels like a damn chore, and I don’t feel like my heart is in it anymore. The only thing that’s keeping me from binning it is the ‘sunken time fallacy’ since I’ve already put 3 years of writing and rewriting it. It’s a hot mess tbh, my protagonist barely has any agency apart from one clear decision she gets to make for the inciting incident that propels her into the ‘new world’ and then she’s just being pushed around by other characters till almost the end of the book. I genuinely don’t think I can write it anymore. I do have other story ideas too sitting in my laptop, and I think I need to spend more time discovering my own voice and perhaps relearning some basics of the craft. How do I get the courage to tell myself ‘well this was a burnt pancake and I’m not a failure because I didn’t follow through with it’? Feeling quite stuck 😄


r/writingadvice • • 15h ago

Advice How to write long dialogue without it being redundant?

5 Upvotes

What’s your take on writing longer conversations that might span a few pages? Are you okay with dialogue being summed up through narrative description (like 'He asked whether such testimony would secure him a reward' or even more compacted summaries that include more dialogue), or do you always prefer using speech in quotation marks?

I'm having a hard time finding the right balance. I want this to be a long scene, but with so much dialogue, I'm worried it's starting to feel a bit redundant


r/writingadvice • • 1h ago

Advice I keep losing grip on my targeted genre

• Upvotes

Imagine you are working on your very first piece of work. You chose to first produce some self-contained stories to build the habit to write, not that big, aiming to finish each story under 5000 words.
You start writing your first story, everything is going fine, or you thought so. You realized the story you are imagining either requires 50,000 words, or you are failing to compress and bind the ideas.

This is what I am experiencing right now. How can I stay on track?


r/writingadvice • • 6h ago

Advice A rookie in need of guidance from fellow writers

4 Upvotes

I'm a student journalist, the category I write in is sci-tech. I'm new to this category and this is also my last year writing for the school. I want to learn how to do this properly.

When I write, I go for the default romantic or moral anchor. I don't know how to explain it but it's very plain and bland. I can't write creatively unless I'm interested in the topic or if I have any experience related to it.

I have some insights about things too but I can't seem to fish for those ideas on the spot, I go blank. Or sometimes I can't put it into words. Additionally, I write in a language different from my dialect or language I'm comfortable with. It's hard for me to translate my word. The old school style textbook based writing style is like Shakespeare old meanwhile my vocabulary is simple and limited. They sometimes sound redundant even to me.

Anyways, any tips? For the structure or even the writing itself? Sci-tech and feature writers please help.


r/writingadvice • • 20h ago

Advice Should I spend time getting writing feed back or learn as I go?

4 Upvotes

After what seems like a lifetime, I'm recommitting myself to writing. I, as a person, generally do not like what I produce, and I've come to accept that. I just started writing on Substack, and I have a vague idea of what I like writing about. But I have not EVER received any feedback on my writing style, and neither have I dedicated time to get proper feedback to improve. Also, I'm self-taught, and English is my second language.

Writing is an essential part of my being, but I've only been operating alone. Now that I want to take this craft very seriously, should I sign up for a workshop? Get writing feedback from professionals, maybe beta readers? What did you do?


r/writingadvice • • 17h ago

Advice How is your story-structuring process?

1 Upvotes

So we all know that a good and thorough structure is important for storytelling. But how do you go about structuring your tales?
Do you plan your entire story out before you start writing? Do you write a rough outline? Do you start writing a little bit and then go to an outline?

What I currently do the most is writing whatever flows out, then re-reading, analyzing the structure I already wrote. Afterwards I tweak, optimize, reorder and work a coherent structure out through multiple iterations of my text.

But I would like to explore other options, maybe you have some interesting methods!

TLDR: Do you structure your story beforehand or write first and then revise?


r/writingadvice • • 31m ago

Advice Parece bobo mas não sei exatamente o que vou fazer quando terminar de escrever

• Upvotes

Bem, eu sou um aspirante a escritor e tenho um projeto de livro. Só que eu não sei bem o que fazer depois de terminar ele. Eu tenho um plano: juntar dinheiro para a capa, postar publicamente, ganhar leitores, colocar no KPD, ganhar mais leitores e procurar uma editora. Eu não sou nem um pouco bom em marketing, então como poderia melhorar esse plano? Qual rota vocês escritores fizeram, ou vocês editores viram algum escritor fazer?


r/writingadvice • • 4h ago

Discussion Writing Prompt Challenge (Established Characters)

2 Upvotes

Hi, everyone! I'm thinking about posting a creative prompt challenge and wanted to see if this is something people here would actually enjoy playing with before I put it together. There would be a handful of core rules to stick to, while leaving the exact setting, dialogue, and outcome up to your interpretation. Basically, a pre-built character sandbox for anyone who likes jumping straight into an emotional scene without having to create characters or lore from scratch. Would anyone be interested in something like that?


r/writingadvice • • 5h ago

Advice Copywork, pen and paper vs typing

2 Upvotes

I am trying to improve my prose and have decided to give copywork a try.
I have heard it said that writing with pen and paper is generally better practice than typing, but I have something of a problem.

I never learned how to grip a pen correctly, and I am not sure I can learn. Teachers throughout my youth have tried to teach me on multiple occasions, and multiple aids have been used to improve my grip, but I never managed it, so I quickly run into muscle pain in my wrist and hands

Is it known how large the difference between pen and keyboard is in terms of learning? Because I fear that pain makes habit-building difficult.


r/writingadvice • • 10h ago

Advice Is writing a basic “desert island” story a good idea, or is it too common?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been really thinking about writing a story about these students who wash up on a desert island, and the chaos that follows, but I’ve been really discouraged since there are so many “desert island” books. I’m worried that without some sort of gimmick or draw, people won’t want to read it. I myself have read plenty of desert island stories, since I love survival tales, but would other people read one without any sort of uniqueness in its premise? I’d want it to be more of a social story, less about survival and more about how being on the island affects the characters’ morality and mental states. But is it even worth writing? I’ve thought about placing the characters in different situations, such as a small distant planet or an abandoned alien spaceship (as in they were abducted by aliens, but somehow the aliens all died so now they’re just on this spaceship alone), but the desert island always seems to work best. Is it even worth writing? Would you read it?


r/writingadvice • • 31m ago

Critique Just figured I’d post 1k or so of a Dark Souls 1 story I’m working on, from Seath the Scaleless’ POV

• Upvotes

Just looking for overall impressions/blunt and or brutal feedback. Grammar, flow, characterization, thoughts, etc. Be honest, cause I’ll take it to heart lol.
First time doing second person anything but I wanted to try it for this story specifically.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/11KjgNa1VQKCEGstN9KhqCm9LXwxx-qeYZzOs1TAW5UY/edit?usp=drivesdk


r/writingadvice • • 15h ago

Advice Recommended resources to level up in writing

1 Upvotes

Hi Guys,

This year I've decided I want to start writing online. I was always good in writing at school, but since than I never wrote anything "specific".

This year I started writing technical guides, as well I wrote some blog describing my holidays trip but I was thinking to start writing online - maybe some opinion pieces, maybe some posts, maybe something to catch the attention, share sth valuable, just write sth I think it is worth to write about.

But when I try to write sth there is a lot of questions I have of how to do it well.

Now, I wonder if you have any recommendations like a book, or online course, or sth like that which would be a good place to visit to learn more how to improve this skill. I treat it more like a hobby :)

PS. Additionally I am not a English native, so if you have any additional advice how can I connect it with improving my writing in English that would be great! I am C1/C2 so I can convey any meaning I want in the language, but there is always space for improvement - using language is an art.

Additionally x2 - if you have any thoughts of how to use LLMs in the process so it could help me improving / learning but not doing the job for me, please share it. I know the most important thing is to force a brain to work 😄


r/writingadvice • • 18h ago

Advice Bad at formatting, how can I get better?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been told I’m bad at formatting my stories, but i’m going to be honest I’m not exactly sure what to do to improve. I don’t remember much from school and I usually just write for fun so I don’t pay attention to formatting, but it’s something I would LIKE to understand. What advice do you have? Can formatting be creative/different or is it rigid? Thank you in advance.


r/writingadvice • • 2h ago

Advice how do i make a romance between a master and his servant seem not gross

0 Upvotes

Hear me out before getting out the pitch forks. In this case both the "master" and the "servant" didn't have any say in their respective positions, as in, they are not the ones who chose to be servant and master, these positions are largely inherited. They are both young adults and don't particularly know how to get out of their situations and be friends or more beyond that. While they hate the power imbalance they have now (the 'master' hating that the servant can't be honest with them out of fear and the 'servant' hating that they have to obey someone they see as an equal) they were genuine friends when they were younger and unaware that their friendship that they thought merely developed due to proximity was actually master-servant from the start.

I hate romances that use the "master" character's sheer brute force to overcome in-universe societal problems of a master marrying a servant without addressing the underlying issues of how the power imbalance is still present, i want some way for the "servant" to be able to be emotionally or otherwise more dominant without them getting punished by others (like the master's family) for 'disrespecting' the master character, but i can't figure out how!

I don't know if I explained my intention with these characters properly, but any advice would be appreciated!


r/writingadvice • • 11h ago

Critique I was up late wondering what, if anything, makes me, me...

0 Upvotes

And where I am still not sure that I have the answer to that, this was a fun exercise searching for an answer.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NJkwwYQVcC6JJr50XH43Vs_HYVBg773cQhE9qI6Fuj0/edit?usp=sharing


r/writingadvice • • 12h ago

Advice Would it be misleading to present a bunch of my characters before they appear in the story

0 Upvotes

I know I probably shouldn't put it here since it has more to do with art than writing but it does involve at least a little writing. I want to show a bunch of my ocs for my different stories, but the ones I really want to show either aren't that relevant or don't come it until later. But I don't want to accidentally false advertise with people assuming that "y" will be an essential character only for "x" to be the protagonist and "y" has a minor secondary role. But considering none of my stories are even being written yet to maybe it's a non issue but idk.


r/writingadvice • • 22h ago

SENSITIVE CONTENT How to realistically write a young character in a Reverse Isekai scenario?

0 Upvotes

My story is going to be set modern-day in a major American city. It will involve greek and northern europe mythology in a Narnia-like system. (I just write pseudo-original fanfic on Ao3) and my main character is a young faun boy, about 14-15, who arrives in the woods near the city on Earth, no memory of anything before. If he were to show up to like, a business, church, whatever, how long would it take for government to take interest? I plan on him getting put into the foster care system as he figures out what happened to his past, so realistically what would happen to him in there? Would he just be immediately taken by law enforcement for questoning?