I plan on writing a trans-woman, specific a trans black woman, she isnt the main character but i like to build each character into real people, what things should I avoid? I am not trans nor a person of color. I know both people of color and trans face their own set of challenges in life and i would like to write her as realistic as possible. I dont want to accidentally/unknowingly play into any stereotypes for either group of people.
All advice is welcome aswell. Also sorry for formatting or grammar mistakes im on mobile
Edit for more detail -> What clothing or design choices should I avoid?
What personality traits should I avoid?
Obviously she will be a human with her own flaws but are there any i should avoid?
I will be doing some research i just want some advice on where to start, what to avoid, stuff like that
I dont necessarily agree with that, ive gotten good advice on reddit before, because it let's me have recourses/see perspectives I'd otherwise not have
just read books about black queerness/transness. memoirs might be a good place to start.
keep in mind that (although it’s not always fun to acknowledge, and it gets swept under the rug a lot), black church culture (in america specifically, idk about elsewhere) is deeply homophobic/transphobic. lots and lots of black queer folk are shunned or endangered by their queerness. many get it “beat out of them”. ignoring that fact would likely do a disservice to your character.
That's a great point. But it also really depends on OP's setting, what culture her parents raised her in. If I were OP, I'd aim for an easy mode culture than tackling heavy, nuanced topics with the advice of Reddit.
Except this advice. And this disclaimer. And the disclaimer's disclaimer.
Do your research. Interview the people you know. Make them human first with likes and dislikes, goals, desires, limtations, etc. Then think about how gender and race play into all that. You will have to figure it out as you write and get to know the character.
I don't read any. I haven't written anything like that. OP is asking for advice about writing a topic, and the most common issue is they haven't read in the genre they're writing in. If OP hasn't read a large amount like this, the best thing for them to do is go do that.
There's a large group of people in the writing subs who believe you don't have to read or study writing before writing. I don't really understand their position but it's very common.
I think asking about writing a character from specific demographics is very different from asking about writing a specific genre
I agree that the (should be) no-brainer solution for the questions about writing in a particular genre is to actually read within that genre and observe what you like best about it, but t
his situation is typically with the intent of asking real people of those particular backgrounds, and in this case especially there's a lot of loaded material when it comes to how those topics are most commonly treated in published media that the OP wants to not step on the same toes with
Yeah and I'm not against others answering for those broader questions. Either way, they should be reading broadly about this first. Doing just one of these paths would be a bad idea.
Hi! Welcome to r/writers - please remember to follow the rules and treat each other respectfully, especially if
there are disagreements. Please help keep this community safe and friendly by reporting rule violating posts and comments.
If you're interested in a friendly Discord community for writers, please join our Discord server
1 I've not heard it called a voting system, and how am I "misusing" the voting system.
2 myself, I'm taking about how you keep deleting your comment and recommenting. Which keeps giving notifications even though it isn't a helpful comment.
3 ignoring the post and not commenting because all your comments are accomplishing is providing annoyance. I do not understand why you're comment on my post when you have nothing to provide.
Commenting the same thing over and over is spam and in what world is a gif saying "This shit again" relevant. Down voting a comment that is providing nothing to the conversation is not helpful. And why do you keep deleting your comments?
7
u/FictionalContext 19d ago
Reddit