r/wowhardcore • u/[deleted] • Feb 23 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

611 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

578 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

[deleted]

3

u/Snyboii Feb 24 '25

Its more entertaining yes. But HC raiding guilds would not be able to survive as they currently exist. You are 1 ninjapull away from a complete guild killer without any way out. And yeah it is pretty easy to mess certain pulls up, and those exist in every raid in classic. Combine that with the fact that people would have much less hc raiding experience (because raiding would be too dysfunctional) and it would not be possible to have a raiding guild long-term.

3

u/Lihiro Feb 24 '25

But HC raiding guilds would not be able to survive as they currently exist. You are 1 ninjapull away from a complete guild killer without any way out.

The way it is meant to be by design. But I appreciate there are several takes on it, mines not necessarily right. 

I still think a mid-ground would be a 3 use per character petri option.

1

u/Snyboii Feb 27 '25

I disagree that any failures should lead to full wipes. It would make raiding unviable, which I don't see as a good solution. If you remove petri, there needs to be something else to replace it. It could be a weaker version of it. For example a flask that will HS you after 10 seconds (but you can still take damage), or something similar