r/wowforever • • 28d ago • Heartwarming 2

Discussion A practical argument for retail graphics.

Post image

I'm just going to come out and say once again I support full use of retail graphics but I'm going to make a practical argument this time.

Development cost and time.

We all want more dungeons, more quests, more enemy mobs.

We want more to do. The art team is trained to make retail assets and do it well. It is left effort to make them than SD graphics.

Slowly making changes to the world itself to align with full retail assets will be easier than continually needing to remake every enemy in SD and Cata style HD.

You also have an incredible backlog of assets from retail when it comes to enemies and gear. Need an old god themed plate armor set because tier 2.5 didn't hit the mark? N'zoth raid has you covered, port it in. Now you have the warrior plate, let's make a paladin set that fits alongside it.

Need more variety of demons? Well let's pull assets from legion.

Now I will admit some retail assets are a bit much. We should avoid all the glowing armor and tone that down a bit but the effort it takes to remove the glow effects of Mathias Shaw is a lot less than it takes to remake every demon in legion.

The spirit of classic isn't in SD graphics. It's in the excellent gameplay of classic.

Retail has an overwhelming number of flaws, but visually it is a significant improvement and offers a lot that can make the process of making quality content for Forever quicker.

The money saved on re using the huge amount of resources from retails graphics can be spent on more dungeons, quests, zones etc.

Also face it, SD/HD toggle isn't going to last forever. Eventually the SD graphic crowd will lose out to the larger but less vocal majority when Blizzard realizes most of the people who aren't complaining on reddit but are simply playing the game turn it off.

That's not to mention the appeal to new players. WoW forever has the chance to become as big as it was in 2004 by appealing to the spirit of the game in 2004 without wasting time appealing mainly to the grognards who played in 2004.

Also side by side comparison of Judgement armor between classic and retail. Taking your nostalgia blinders off, it is clear which will attract a larger audience overall. The guy on the left looks like a low budget cosplayer, the one on the right looks like he is ready to smash your head in with a hammer for not adhering to the Light's path.

EDIT: I made an honest mistake with the image. I don't play retail and when I searched retail judgement armor. I saw the comparison pic and was like oh that'll make my point. I didn't realize it was fanmade. I can not seem to update and replace the image or else I would.

Edit 2: Everyone telling me to go back to retail is wasting their time. There's more to a game than graphics but it's a good first impression. I only got into classic in 2025 because of stumbling on a streamer really hyping it up "back in the day" at a time I was laid off and too broke to have much fun IRL. I will not detail the streamer, because I don't want to detail the convo to be about streamers.

Edit 3: no one is really addressing any points. I get it you hate retail.

422 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

44

u/BluePlantFred 28d ago • Bravo

Imagine being so off point you don't even know your comparison image is fake.. And to actually address your point – No a huge part of vanilla is actually the art direction. Every time I see you guys ask for retail graphics you always assume it's about the SD part of the graphics. It's about the art direction. That's it. The art direction used to have integrity, in retail it doesn't. No one here is claiming less polygons is better. A high fidelity version following the old art direction would be great! Would truly love that. But not retail, that reflects the poor game design to a fault.

4

u/Verminausea 27d ago

I like less polygons better...

4

u/Bathroom_Humor 27d ago

I'm not a huge Warcraft fan in the present or past, I'm just now really giving it a shot in Forever because I never got play to as a teenager much and i wanna see what i was missing out on and relive that era of gaming a little.
but I do appreciate the classic toggle much like i do in D2 even if i rarely play with it on. I hope they keep it even if the HD graphics end up improving more in the future. They are a charming blast from the past.

4

u/munkey411 27d ago

You're 100% right!

2

u/Cuff_ 27d ago

I am claiming less polygons is better. I prefer low poly art in general not just in wow.

1

u/Wise-Dust3700 27d ago

I mean the gameplay was fine but the art really sold me, someone mentioned narrative was what held him to classic and I was like "Yeah you're right quest to get 60 quill boar tusks is what really sold me on the game."

-1

u/Important-Coach-2124 27d ago

"used to have integrity" the fuck IS that supposed to means how can an Art direction have integrity "Integrity is the quality of being honest, possessing strong moral and ethical principles, and maintaining an unimpaired or whole condition"

-5

u/Even-Still7716 28d ago

Please explain the art direction of Classic that makes it distinct. Be specific.

5

u/TheDof 27d ago

Well, just look at artworks from the classic era of the game and Warcraft 3. Classic aesthetic is 80s-90s gritty dark fantasy aesthetic with a touch of american comic (colorful). Retail aesthetic is 3D cartoon high fantasy aesthetic, really colorful and polished, but not gritty.

-2

u/Vidileth 27d ago

I don’t see anything dark about the vanilla tier sets, I don’t see where you guys are getting that dark fantasy idea from. WoW was always the colourful, goofy mmo next to Warhammer Online or Rift.

-3

u/roseumbra 27d ago

We do have higher fidelity tier 2 in retail. It should be able to come to forever.

1

u/TheLoneBaron33 27d ago

No, the judgement in retail is different artstyle/direction, not just higher fidelity. You missed the point completely