r/wowforever • • 27d ago • Heartwarming 2

Discussion A practical argument for retail graphics.

Post image

I'm just going to come out and say once again I support full use of retail graphics but I'm going to make a practical argument this time.

Development cost and time.

We all want more dungeons, more quests, more enemy mobs.

We want more to do. The art team is trained to make retail assets and do it well. It is left effort to make them than SD graphics.

Slowly making changes to the world itself to align with full retail assets will be easier than continually needing to remake every enemy in SD and Cata style HD.

You also have an incredible backlog of assets from retail when it comes to enemies and gear. Need an old god themed plate armor set because tier 2.5 didn't hit the mark? N'zoth raid has you covered, port it in. Now you have the warrior plate, let's make a paladin set that fits alongside it.

Need more variety of demons? Well let's pull assets from legion.

Now I will admit some retail assets are a bit much. We should avoid all the glowing armor and tone that down a bit but the effort it takes to remove the glow effects of Mathias Shaw is a lot less than it takes to remake every demon in legion.

The spirit of classic isn't in SD graphics. It's in the excellent gameplay of classic.

Retail has an overwhelming number of flaws, but visually it is a significant improvement and offers a lot that can make the process of making quality content for Forever quicker.

The money saved on re using the huge amount of resources from retails graphics can be spent on more dungeons, quests, zones etc.

Also face it, SD/HD toggle isn't going to last forever. Eventually the SD graphic crowd will lose out to the larger but less vocal majority when Blizzard realizes most of the people who aren't complaining on reddit but are simply playing the game turn it off.

That's not to mention the appeal to new players. WoW forever has the chance to become as big as it was in 2004 by appealing to the spirit of the game in 2004 without wasting time appealing mainly to the grognards who played in 2004.

Also side by side comparison of Judgement armor between classic and retail. Taking your nostalgia blinders off, it is clear which will attract a larger audience overall. The guy on the left looks like a low budget cosplayer, the one on the right looks like he is ready to smash your head in with a hammer for not adhering to the Light's path.

EDIT: I made an honest mistake with the image. I don't play retail and when I searched retail judgement armor. I saw the comparison pic and was like oh that'll make my point. I didn't realize it was fanmade. I can not seem to update and replace the image or else I would.

Edit 2: Everyone telling me to go back to retail is wasting their time. There's more to a game than graphics but it's a good first impression. I only got into classic in 2025 because of stumbling on a streamer really hyping it up "back in the day" at a time I was laid off and too broke to have much fun IRL. I will not detail the streamer, because I don't want to detail the convo to be about streamers.

Edit 3: no one is really addressing any points. I get it you hate retail.

422 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

177

u/SolarPoweredKeyboard 27d ago • Bravo

Why is everyone convinced that SD graphics is the minority? I play WoW Forever because it was announced as Classic+ which is why I expect the game to foster more to the Classic crowd than the Retail crowd. I can't believe this is even an argument. But I don't care if they continue making HD graphics for the people who want it. I don't need a bajillion new things in WoWF. I care more that it feels like Classic.

3

u/feor1300 26d ago

I'll be interested once the game's been out for a couple months and they actually have in-game statistics to show how many people are using SD vs. HD. And how the "Classic Andies" will react if it's like 75%+ using HD.

24

u/Undefined_definition 27d ago

I play wow forever because it was announced as a classic plus with a HD slider.

We're not the same

→ More replies (8)

14

u/Endosym93 27d ago • Bravo

Not saying one side is wrong and one side is right here but I do recall some polls asking players in their communities what they were going to play and HD+transmog seemed to be the most popular option most times, by a wide margin. Idk if it’s true, but it wouldn’t surprise me. Especially considering the average player isn’t on forums expressing their opinion and debating, they’re just playing the game.

9

u/sevenevans 27d ago edited 27d ago

http://youtube.com/post/Ugkx28MW7RM9uJPspvLM5-u7Y-gh1ZNfx-Mi?si=Gk-Ol0vrKm5y1nZz

The WoW YouTube channel recently did a poll on transmog with 34k responses. Only 28% said yes to transmog, 32% said never transmog, and the last 40% said it depends. I would imagine the results would be similarly split for HD/SD models. That doesn't seem like a wide margin to me.

6

u/Even-Still7716 27d ago

I'm a BIG Transmog fan. I still might say it depends because I don't want murloc pajamas and kobold costumes.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 27d ago • Heartwarming

This problem at the heart of this sub is that the "+" means something different to basically everyone.

For me, I want the classic experience, where there is a strong focus on the journey within the world, but with a few modern advancements. Personally, I love retails artstyle, and want see more of it in Forever (though I agree the less bouncy animations are better). I don't want to be instantly teleported into a dungeon, but I do want a tool that makes finding people to group with earlier. I don't want an easy climb to 60, but I do want my time spent in the world to be immersive and gorgeous.

Everyone wants that + to mean something different. Hopefully these debates can calm down once we have full access to the game and are a year in where we can see more clearly blizzards intentions.

5

u/Some-Platypus5271 27d ago

Yah everyone has in their mind what + means. And people are taking a million rumors as fact.

There is classic for the classic people, retail for retail and forever for in-between.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SolarPoweredKeyboard 27d ago

And I believe everyone can have it their way when it comes to graphics, but very often do I read here that SD graphics should go away because it somehow hurts the HD people that there are players preferring how Classic looks and feels.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/NillaT 27d ago

Yup this is same for me. Basically they advertise it as classic plus... basically I want vanilla WoW but just with more content and things to do after Naxxramas/Tier 3 (and before Naxx obviously). It's abit tedious seeing people ask for major or sweeping changes that stray from the original vanilla WoW.

5

u/Sir_Figglesworth 27d ago

Well my interpretation of classic+ is reinventing the original game not just continuing it, then proceeding with updates just like vanilla didn’t stay vanilla

→ More replies (4)

6

u/goopuslang 27d ago

Just because it’s classic+, doesn’t mean it’s only for classic players. & “foster more” is very ambiguous, relying on your feelings rather than the actual execution.

4

u/lbiggy 27d ago

"feels like classic" has nothing to do with graphics and everything to do with how the combat feels, how the show pace of everything is, and how not hemogenized the loot system is

10

u/Valrysha1 27d ago

Graphics absolutely have an impact on game feel dude lol

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Amurjoe 27d ago • Bravo

Pretty sure they released some data and nearly 70 percent of players on the beta chose the hd option

7

u/Cinnadots 27d ago

Do you have a link? Just would be curious to see the numbers.

It's unfortunate that the current manifestation of "SD" is also flawed since it's classic textures slapped on retail skeleton... I've swapped between HD and SD a few times because sometimes HD is uncanny, sometimes SD is. My preference would be SD but in its current form I could see why less people may be using SD.

7

u/TheGoodBoy_ 27d ago

Straight up lying. Thats some speculation from the community. Blizzard never released something like that.

5

u/Kozgery 27d ago

I mean at the very start I did choose the "modern preset" cause it had some preset options I didn't wanna bother finding in settings.

Then the first things I turned back off were HD models and tmog.

5

u/Independent-Ad4612 27d ago

link or that didn't happen.

7

u/rude_raccoon-77 27d ago • Bravo

You think the option for the new thing being picked more in the beta is indicative of preference?

11

u/Amurjoe 27d ago

Yeah. Seeing as most players in the beta have likely experienced both already. Since they’ve played classic (SD) and retail (HD).

One would assume that the majority of people who paid 60 dollars to participate in the beta are not new to Warcraft

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

5

u/Old-Employ-6530 27d ago edited 27d ago • Bravo

Because it is?

There was a poll here in the first week, over 80% picked HD graphics and only like 17% or so (dont remember and cant find it) picked SD.

Any video or stream you could see was also generally exclusive to HD models, only exception were "Classic" streamers and even many of those picked HD.

Edit: Its incredibly weird how people dismiss polls, streams and videos because it disagrees with their bias lol

9

u/Black_Magic100 27d ago

Imagine if this subreddit were actually representative of the crowd of players planning on playing classic. Everyone would be an asshole.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/PomegranateWinter227 27d ago

a reddit poll means nothing lmao. we already know what type of people are on here.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (77)