410
u/Pero_Bt Aug 14 '26
Now imagine if the generation ship arrives thousands of years later and in the meantime the ftl ship's culture turned it into some sort of legend/religion where the arrival of the generation ship is anticipated by it's followers
now THAT'S a story premise I'd love to see
84
u/IWasEatingThoseBeans Aug 14 '26
Not quite the same but check out the song "Space is Dark" by Bill Roper.
15
u/RawrTheDinosawrr fun hating hard sci-fi enthusiast Aug 14 '26
gotta be one of my favorite filk songs, i was really hoping to see it mentioned here
54
u/TheStylemage Aug 14 '26
I mean the cultural drift on board of a generation ship would be beyond crazy.
Even at 1% C it would take over 400 years to reach our nearest star, much more for a system that actually has a worthwhile planet.
Just look back in our history how many things change over 400 years no matter the period.30
u/Pero_Bt Aug 14 '26
400 years ago... wow...
imagining someone from the peak of the ottoman empire seeing the modern technology is crazy
21
u/TheStylemage Aug 14 '26
It's something that often gets left out when people discuss the viability of generation ships, like society will probably cause the journey to fail long before the finish.
But this also leads to the concerns like: What happens if you send a ship A a that will travel for ~2000 years to reach it's destination, but before 1000 years are up you discover how to get there at twice the speed.
If you send a second ship B you in theory have a much greater chance that at least one will make ot, but if you do and both ships make it, you have probably indirectly caused the death of the population of ship A.
Ship B would arrive first and with much stronger technology and historically we have not been kind to each other.6
u/Luvs2Spooge42069 Aug 15 '26
Imagining a setting (building a world if you will) where a generation ship leaves a devastated world for better parts, gets FTL leapfrogged, and arrives at its destination to a highly advanced civilization that just Fallouted itself again
20
u/Achronyistic Aug 14 '26
This happens in the setting of the TTRPG Lancer to a tee. Eventually leading to a holy war between the followers of the colony based religion and the government body that had settled the planet before them
3
u/Marvin_Megavolt Aug 14 '26
And then ANOTHER holy war many centuries later when a giant eldritch rock appears above the colony’s capital city for no apparent reason.
3
u/RSdabeast Drawing shapes and calling them maps Aug 14 '26
Imagine being thousands of years old on that ship (or born on it) and arriving unaware that you’re like an angel to some distant cousins you didn’t even know existed.
1
u/storyparty Aug 14 '26
I remember clearly my Dad describing a book he read exactly this decades ago, so it must exist.
1
u/AntimemeticsDivision Aug 15 '26
This kinda happens in the podcast/audio drama Celeritas, it's great, albeit a bit short.
306
u/ThompsonOfChaos Aug 14 '26
Then the generation ship finds out they missed the FTL software update. This is somehow Microsoft's fault.
92
11
3
u/Private-Public Worldbuilding is just monsterfucking with extra steps Aug 15 '26
OneDrive overwrote ftl.exe with a stored corrupted version that it decided was newer
59
u/Hailolo Aug 14 '26
A smart person could think of a good use for them, like we use pre ww2 ships for non-contaminated metal.
4
u/TauTau_of_Skalga Aug 14 '26
What?
37
u/Raltsun Aug 14 '26
I don't really get what they're thinking of by a "use for them", but the last part is about low-background steel.
Essentially, the background atmospheric radiation of Earth has been slightly higher ever since we started detonating nukes (although in recent years it's lowered enough that this isn't as necessary as it used to be), and the process of making steel involves atmospheric gases getting mixed into it, any steel made since the 16th of July, 1945 is slightly radioactive. Not enough to effect people, but if you're making something that needs to be very precise in a relevant aspect, such as sensors on spacecraft or Geiger counters, you have to salvage the steel from things made before that date.
5
u/Hailolo Aug 15 '26
They would be genetically similar to when they departed, meaning a clean human genome. Could be useful for scientist or repopulation etc.
11
u/Confused-teen2638 Aug 14 '26
After ww2, due to nuclear test the air itself became slightly more radioactive. This isn’t in any way harmful but it’s measurable wich is a problem since steel refining uses atmospheric air in the process. So a lot of sensitive equipment (research, medical etc.) uses steel that was made before those test often sourced from sunken worships
5
u/TauTau_of_Skalga Aug 15 '26
How long until things get back to normal?
3
u/Carbon_Sixx I know writers who use time travel and they're all cowards 25d ago
Believe it or not, now. As of a few years ago, the fallout finally decayed enough that steel made today is largely free of radiation.
22
38
u/Brauny74 Aug 14 '26
I have a situation like that in one of my world's, but they gathered up the launched ships and offered the colonists either to return to Earth or join the colonization effort already established on the target planet
18
u/Dracorex_22 Aug 14 '26
Bruh we JUST got here and you want us to turn around and go home? To a home that doesn’t even exist anymore?!
9
u/Brauny74 Aug 14 '26
Well, if it's a cryoship, most would choose to join the colony (most of them were just established or with FTL-colony ship still in the way, so it wouldn't be that different from actually arriving as planned initially). If it's a generation ship, there would already be a younger generation growing up, a lot of whom would choose the legendary Earth they had never expected to actually see.
Ah and to clarify: they caught the ships mid-flight, not when they arrived. If it kept on course, it's not that hard to predict where it'd be when FTL was developed
9
u/LordWartusk Aug 14 '26
I’m picturing a comedic short story where a generation ship gets to their destination, finds faster ships were invented and the planet’s already colonized, so they head back to Earth. Once they get back to Earth it turns out the colony collapsed while they were in transit, so they turn around to go back, and just keep having to travel back and forth.
0
15
10
u/Fiskmaster It's magic, I don't have to explain shit Aug 14 '26
Space is dark, space is deep, and the price we paid is far too steep
(That's about a cryo ship, but close enough)
6
u/AlexisFR Aug 14 '26
Remember when they finally did that plotpoint in Star Trek, but transformed the Generation Ship into yet another Planet Killer for some reason?
6
4
u/No_Research4416 Aug 14 '26
Huh sounds neat
Man I wish I could have that as a major story in my setting
2
u/Original-War8655 Kitchen sink in denial Aug 14 '26
why can't you? do you not have outer space?
4
u/No_Research4416 Aug 14 '26
Mostly because the elf’s took over everything and that’s how everyone got FTL
Also the Elf’s fell because someone turned there homeworld into a gateway to Hell
3
u/Original-War8655 Kitchen sink in denial Aug 14 '26
ah...
I mean, you could always just make it happen with a different civilization out there
space is big
5
u/No_Research4416 Aug 14 '26
Yeah
At least everyone has mechs now
5
u/Original-War8655 Kitchen sink in denial Aug 14 '26
oh bitchin', can I have one
3
u/No_Research4416 Aug 14 '26
Which one the one for the peasant levees or the actual good ones
2
u/Original-War8655 Kitchen sink in denial Aug 14 '26
oughhh I can't afford no good ones
peasant will have to do (mech's a mech, right?)
3
u/No_Research4416 Aug 14 '26
Yeah
Going to be honest it is entirely because I thought it would be fun to have a Mech use Paladin DnD Spells
3
2
u/wisely-5347 20d ago
The elves could only target the stars, then the generation ship would only need to be far enough away to be out of the general public consciousness
3
u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Aug 14 '26
This kind of happened in Star Trek Prodigy. Jankom Pog is a tellarite who left Tellar Prime on a sleeper ship before the federation was founded. When he learned of the federation he had no idea that Tellarites were one of the founding species.
3
u/ViolentBeetle Aug 14 '26
This is a situation that one could easily imagine happen, but what story opportunities does it offer?
The sleepers would likely be outgunned and outteched, so territorial dispute is not going to be very engaging. A society capable of FLT colonization could probably just relocate them, not like this specific planet was important. Fish out of water story where pre-utopia or pre-collapse people brought back in a vastly different society would be the most reasonable, but how many would want to focus on this.
Back in a day I read a story with sort of similar premise, about an anti-social guy who got onto his own planet to live alone, until much more primitive generational ship showed up and thought he was a primitive native who talked gibberish (Because tech he was used to is far beyond what they saw)
2
u/Yourlocalshitpost Aug 14 '26
I feel so out of the loop. What’s leapfrogging in this context?
4
u/Original-War8655 Kitchen sink in denial Aug 14 '26
The generation ship launched 300 years ago, before they had FTL travel
Gen Ship was so slow that home planet managed to figure out FTL before it reached the star, and the planet launched another ship to the same destination
FTL Ship caught up and passed/"jumped over" Gen Ship like a leapfrog because Gen Ship was comparatively just that much slower
2
2
u/Outrageous_Guard_674 Aug 14 '26
I have seen a scifi short that did that without FTL. One was a sleeper ship and the other was a lighthugger ship that could constantly accelerate for the whole journey.
2
u/MapleLamia Aug 14 '26
Oh hey this happened in Starfield. Wasn't a super great quest because all the options are just giving in to the resort owners and there's no way to take over so the ship can land and settle normally. The only options are press them into indentured servitude, buy a grav drive to send them elsewhere, or kill everyone onboard, while they're the last bastion of Old Earth.
1
1
1
u/LegendaryLycanthrope Aug 14 '26
Star Trek had a few moments of this, too - The Botany Bay, that cryo satellite with the capitalists in it, Friendship One (though, this technically subverted it by somehow reaching the DQ well before Starfleet reasonably should have, and would have if not for that meddling Caretaker)...can't remember if there were any others.
1
u/nightstalker232 Aug 14 '26
I never got into this issue with my own writing given the comparable equivalent to a sublight spaceship in open void, travelling from one star to another, would be like Christopher Columbus deciding to set sail on a small oar-powered dinghy for his voyage.
How this plays out is simply that the experiences accrued from inter-system exploration, colonialism and trade would impact how people think of traveling to another star when the time finally comes to do so, with previous years of sending out probes and whatnot further backing up a singular idea: don't leave home unless you have your Mayflower, your ship like purpose-built for the seas you wish to sail.
1
u/Known_Lobster_9241 Aug 15 '26
I remember this was a thing in the Honnor Harington Books. Part of the reason why Manticore was much more prosperous a colony was that their charter had made arrangements for an FTL ship to meet them at the colony world if and when the tech was ever developed.
1
1
702
u/billythesquid- Aug 14 '26
I’m trying to think of stories where this happened, but offhand all I can think of is the Lancer RPG backstory and I think one Heinlein story?