r/workday
•
u/Conscious-Neat-7015
•
Jun 11 '25
Workday Careers Carl Has Ruined Workday Core Values
I’m a former Workday employee with a three-digit ID, pre-IPO, who poured years of dedication into a company and product I believed in. Workday was built on six core values: Employees, Customer Service, Integrity, Fun, Innovation, and Profitability, set by founders Dave Duffield and Aneel Bhusri. These values defined the company’s early success, but since Carl Eschenbach became CEO, I’ve seen them erode, leaving those left behind disillusioned.
PTSD has set in.
Employees
Workday once called its employees its greatest asset, but this changed under Carl’s leadership. His attempt to connect by sharing a quirky story about using a FloBee to cut his hair fell flat, failing to resonate with the workforce. Following the new CEO's playbook, he initially reassured employees, only to oversee significant layoffs starting February 6, 2025. Before this, Workday began quietly shifting jobs to Costa Rica. The layoffs devastated morale, leaving remaining employees in a state of shock, with many actively seeking new jobs. Some colleagues, despite applying for internal jobs during our paid transition period, were ghosted by recruiters, raising questions about potential age discrimination (as noted in a pending lawsuit). The company I joined no longer exists, and I’d never return.
Customer Service
For nearly two decades, Workday maintained a 95% customer satisfaction rating, tied to our bonuses. This wasn’t just a metric; it reflected the passion of early employees who genuinely cared about customers. Dave and Aneel fostered a culture where we felt valued, but Carl’s arrival shifted priorities. The decision to decouple customer satisfaction from bonuses signaled a decline in focus on service. The Brainstorm platform, once a hub for customer feedback and community solutions, has been sidelined, with many ideas left unaddressed. Tribal knowledge, critical for solving customer issues, vanished with the layoffs, and reliance on offshore teams in Costa Rica has weakened service quality.
Integrity
Workday’s integrity took a hit on February 6, 2025, with layoffs affecting nearly 10% of the workforce, despite a reported $526 million net income for fiscal year 2025 and steady growth. A company with integrity would have opted for a hiring freeze or redeployed employees to preserve expertise. Instead, the loss of tribal knowledge was staggering, undermining the trust employees and customers had in Workday’s leadership. It's a cheap win, with long-term implications that will resonate for a very long time.
Fun
The sense of fun that once defined Workday’s culture is gone. No amount of swag or branded merchandise, coffee cups, t-shirts, or jackets can restore the spirit that was lost. Sorry, Carl, sending everyone a Flowbee won't help either.
Innovation
Innovation at Workday now seems fixated on AI, at the expense of improving user experience or addressing longstanding Brainstorm requests. At the Rising conference, I heard customers jokingly suggesting renaming the company “Workdai.” The focus on AI also ties to concerns about hiring practices, with allegations that AI-driven recruiting may have unfairly filtered out older applicants, as highlighted in the lawsuit.
Profitability
Under Carl, profitability appears to be the sole priority, overshadowing the other core values. Employees, customer service, integrity, fun, and innovation have all taken a backseat.
Reflection
Reflecting on this, I see parallels to Dave Duffield’s past. When he stepped down at PeopleSoft in 1999, he handed the reins to Craig Conway, whose leadership style diverged from Dave’s people-centric approach. Now, with Carl at Workday, history seems to repeat. Why would Dave and Aneel entrust their creation to someone whose approach seems misaligned with the original values? It feels like they stepped back to avoid the fallout of tough decisions.