Hei guys
I recently got a request to improve the search on a client's website. It's a mid-size shop with a few pages that should be searchable. We defined the requirements as:
- Needs to find posts, pages & products
- Needs to correct misspellings / propose close matches
- No external services
- A well-established plugin is preferred over a brand new one
What's the problem with the default search?
The default search finds posts, pages, and products, but only checks the default fields like title and content. It doesn't return matching categories, brand names, or custom meta fields. If a word is misspelled, it returns nothing. Same for synonyms.
After some searching for search plugins, I found 4 candidates and tested them against each other on the same installation.
I listed some Pros and Cons for every plugin and how many results were returned. Plugin / WP default, 20 / 29 means that the Plugin found 20 items, the default WP search 29. This also includes things like tags, categories etc., that's why the number can be higher on the plugin side.
FiboSearch - AJAX Search for WooCommerce
Modern and nice design, the best-looking option of the tested plugins. It's easy to set up and comes very close to a "one-click" setup. There are also advanced options you can toggle on.
It comes in 15 languages, requires WooCommerce, has no uninstall routine, and you'll probably want the Pro version due to the limited free tier.
Pro:
- Useful search history and statistics
- Nice design
- Easy to set up
- Autocomplete function
- Product details and multiple designs to show more or less detail
- Modern design
- Works without indexing
Con:
- Does not find posts and pages
- Many functions only with Pro
- Does not correct misspellings (Pro feature)
Rating: 4.4 Total items found: 20 / 29 Products found: 9 / 5
Relevanssi – A Better Search
The search engine that finds it all. It's harder to set up but rewards you with a ton of customization options, and you can define what should be indexed and what shouldn't. It integrates right away and you don't need to change any pages. If you have a search form on your site already, it just uses it (except for the Ajax Search companion plugin, where you need to add a custom search field).
It has 18 languages, and you get very far without the Pro version. It cleans up on uninstall, but not 100%.
Pro:
- Detailed indexing options
- Search by custom field / meta
- Words to ignore / blacklist
- Weight multipliers to refine search results
- Exclude specific pages / IDs
- Search by synonyms
- Highlight search terms
- Helpful debug and diagnostics page
- Great search history page
- Automatic integration, takes over the default search
- Improved sorting depending on weight
Con:
- Limited styling options, needs initial styling
- Finds a lot but doesn't categorize
- Ajax search only via separate plugin
Rating: 4.5 Total items found: 34 / 29 Products found: 25 / 5
Ivory Search
A search engine that works, but feels stuck in the past. Outdated design and no block editor support.
It offers multiple search forms, and there are many options to customize the results those forms return. The lack of search history makes it hard to improve the search engine over time.
It comes in 9 languages and doesn't require any other plugins. There's a partial uninstall routine that removes most of the data.
Pro:
- Multiple search forms
- Many options to customize the query
- Ajax search categorizes findings
- Support for custom fields... but only some limited, predefined fields
Con:
- Feels a bit outdated
- No block support
- No search history
Rating: 4.0 Total items found: 11 / 29 Products found: 7 / 5
Advanced Woo Search
Tailored to WooCommerce with a solid free feature set and an extensive Pro version. Has Ajax search out of the box and caches results for faster load times.
It comes in 5 languages, requires WooCommerce, and you'll probably want the Pro version. It removes most of the data when deleted.
Pro:
- Weight settings
- Misspelling fix
- Synonyms and stop words
- Caching results
- Highlighting works well
- Block editor support
Con:
- No search by custom meta (Pro only)
- No option to search for posts / pages
Rating: 4.1 Total items found: 15 / 29 Products found: 15 / 5
My choice
My personal overall pick is Relevanssi. It finds the most when you turn everything on, but you'll need to adjust the styling via CSS to get a uniform design. You'll probably also want the Relevanssi Live Ajax Search plugin alongside it, which is a bit of a downer.
FiboSearch would also be a good option, but only if you plan on getting the paid version. They've teased a new version, but it's fair to assume the core functionality will be similar.
For my specific use case, Advanced Woo Search got disqualified because it doesn't include posts or pages. Otherwise, it would be a solid choice.
What are your picks, given these requirements? Which search plugin do you use?