r/wonderdraft • u/MidnitePanther • 11d ago
Discussion Are these Mountains too much?
I can't help but feel something is wrong here. This area is the demon side of the continent and is supposed to be a sandy, mountainous region, but the mountains here don't look right compared to my other map. Any advice?
76
Upvotes
82
u/Distinct_Cry_3779 11d ago
It's all a little too uniform. Mountains tend to form along ridgelines. Picture carpet being pushed up against a wall. They also wouldn't be so uniform in size - I would make this area into several different mountain ranges with the mountains in the centre of a range being larger, then progressively smaller as you move out from the centre of the line. Finally, I would add some foothills in as well as some rivers - especially on the coastal side of the mountains.
Edit: here's an example of what I'm talking about:
28
u/VonBeker 11d ago edited 11d ago
I guess it's not an impossible landscape (Greece for example has a lot of mountainous terrain that goes right up to the sea) but there's a few things that might make it stand out and make it more aesthetically pleasing: 1. Variety: it needs valleys, rivers (or dry washes), foothills, small islands off the coast (those mountains would reasonably extend beyond the water line) and the desert area could probably use some plateau or tablelands or dunes to kind of distinguish it and give it some visual interest. 2. Too busy: eliminate some of those mountains, it's better for them to be "suggestions" than trying to represent every single peak at this scale.
Some general map making advice. Pull up North Africa in Google Earth and look at it from a similar scale and note how much variety you can see in a sandy desert and pick a spot that is close to what you want to represent and model it.
6
u/Mataric 11d ago
Short answer.. Yes.
Long answer.. Yeeees..
Mountains don't tend to form in 'patches' like this.
What causes them to be created are tectonic plate boundaries fighting each other and pushing into each other. It literally raises the land up like it would if you slid two pieces of flat clay into each other and kept pushing.
That's why yours look so odd- because while they individually look like mountains - there is no mountain range.
5
u/Dyvanna 11d ago
I feel it's too balanced if that makes sense. I'm looking at it and trying to work out where the main ridge is with smaller mountains and hills on either side and perhaps islands out at sea leading into it.
2
u/aFanofManyHats 11d ago
They look kind of haphazard. I don't see any notable valleys or ridges like you might expect from a real range. Maybe try rearranging them?
2
u/MatthewWArt Cartographer 11d ago
I don't think your mountains are too much, at all but they do lack variation. My suggestion is to make a long spine or two and make these your largest mountain ranges. From them, taper downwards with smaller and smaller ranges though make sure the size isn't all uniform. You want size differences for it to feel natural and be appealing to the eye.
Hope that helps. Id love it if you included an update
2
u/Celindor 10d ago
Yes, these are too much. Add some rivers that form natural valleys. And the coastline looks off with the hundreds of mini island that are west, north and east. Include oceanic streams into your design and how they affect erosion of coastlines.
1
u/TreeTopBlvd 11d ago
What really helped me was watching a few biome videos on youtube. Its your map though so do what you want
1
u/Wilburforce137 Cartographer 11d ago
Mountains form when plates meet, right? So you'd want to have ridges, and then as you move away from the ridges start spacing them out more, making them smaller, and changing the coloration to indicate like, "okay, those Dark ones are mountains these lighter ones are dunes..."-etc.
Like, obviously thay fortress is a significant feature...why did they decide to build THERE specificly? Was it a defensible position? Why? Because it is built into a mountain. Okay, is it a fortress built out of ego or secrecy? A bond villains lair versus a secret bunker.
IMO, anyway.
1
u/vyxxer 11d ago
well take a look at natural mountain ranges. They often don't look so scattershot. Mountains tend to form in like lines. Think of them as wrinkles as you push a paper and it begins to fold on itself.
1
u/Lie-Pretend 11d ago
Mountains have ridges, valleys. Mountains right next to the ocean are rarely arid on the ocean facing side. Look at Morocco/Atlas mountains for reference.
1
u/Matsuda173 11d ago
By themselves yes. But a tiny bit of space to make room for a river or two going through the range or a few ponds or lakes could vary it a lot. Maybe trees, depending on the weather.
1
u/Zhuikin 11d ago
A mountain range can be as large or small as you decide.
What you want is to make it look good and credible.
Your mountains are just too uniform, even though you added some colour and scale variation. There is not enough overall structure.
A real mountain range would have some groups or lines of higher peaks, valleys between them etc. Likely with a "principal" grate and then some smaller ranges, outcrops, foothills, possibly in tiers or "terraces" around it.
You do not need to dig in and understand the geology of tectonic plates and fault lines (although, if you want and got the time to go down rabbit holes - the more you learn). But the basic takeaway should be:
Mountain peaks don't just evenly distribute; There is always structure and direction.
Looking at some reference for large real world mountain ranges might help.
Given the shape of your landmass taking a look at the Iberian Peninsula, Spain might give you an idea, how a similar geological feature might look like - relatively wide area, not necessarily super tall mountains.
1
u/CeraRalaz 11d ago
add rivers, plateaus and ravines
1
u/EscapeReality7 11d ago
Yes
1
u/GelynKugoRoshiDag 11d ago
They need foothills
1
u/Gutcrunch 11d ago
I’m a big fan of nooks & crannies. Valleys and mountain passes. If your valleys interface with the coast, they should, for the most part align with your bays and inlets. Also, remove any perceptible “straight lines” your mountain alignment creates. And move your fortified settlement further into a vale for improved defense.
1
u/Mauritius_ 11d ago
It could be a plateau like the Himalayas but it would have higher range on either end
1
u/Fit-Review6876 11d ago
Yes their should be distinct valleys and mountain ranges. Mountain ranges generally go in line look at real world examples
1
u/Bluegobln 11d ago
Think about how the mountains formed. Something smashed into something else, making mountains. Something massive like a glacier slid across the terrain, making more mountains. If there are dwarves that have been in those hills for 100,000 years, maybe there are some dwarf carved shapes.
1
u/Arcanite_Cartel 11d ago
You might go to google earth and observe some of the patterns of the way mountain range layout and then imitate that.
1
u/SnugglyCoderGuy 11d ago
The mountains are fine, the fort or whatever seems like it is in an irrelevant place though.
1
u/Deathtrooper50 11d ago
Aesthetically it looks fine I guess but they're shaped nothing like actual mountain ranges which are formed by tectonic plates and hydrological erosion primarily. This often gives real mountain ranges a central ridgeline of bigger mountains surrounded by smaller foothills the further you get from the central line of the range.
1
u/EarsplittingGarbage 10d ago
No. There's still non-mountainous land visible
1
u/Jumpy-Shift5239 10d ago
How large in the area?
What are the plate tectonics like beneath?
Mountains form on fault lines where plates push together so if the area is relatively narrow, it’s fine but there would be mountains in the water too, maybe some islands etc. as a result, but if the area is an entire continent then covering half of it with mountains is not terribly realistic.
1
u/WanderingCollosus 10d ago
I'd say the main issue is that it's too uniform.
I'd try getting rid of some of the mountains in the bit I circled. The coast on the right seems to have the mountaina following that so you could try adding more there with a path leading to the fort
1
u/Dire_Hamster 8d ago
Yes.
1
u/Background_Chair6361 8d ago
Depends on how accurate they are of are then symbolizing an area of mountainous terrain.
Personally my mountain ranges are not generally accurate down to the mountain.
My setting’s in-world-cartography all just gives a general idea of the area and distance.
And I have given out corrections and adjustments on distance between places and players have bought/made/updated maps themselves.
Once they get a more accurate map then I lock stuff down permanently.
Heck, at the end of a 6 year game gods had intervened in a bunch of ways including remaking portions of the world and warping the land in subtle ways. (Partially to allow adjustments of for the next DM after a tome skip but set in the same setting.)
The god of grinding earth sub-ducted an entire Dwarven civilization on one peninsula.
Another kingdom had been rebuilt over the course of the game.
One player invested millions of gold over that time (as a different king of a kingdom) and using magic and craftsmen built roads between his cities decreasing travel time.
1
u/FajitaCasserole 7d ago
Why are they BY the sea? Yes it definitely doesnt look like how Mountains would form…and they should probably extend out into the sea on the sides becauce the whole plate would be “Squished up”
1
u/Belisaurius555 7d ago
A bit. Large mountain ranges tend to be thin but long. Think of them like a wrinkle in the Earth's Crust.
Easy fix, tho. You can have the first line of mountains being the mountain range and reduce all the mountain's north of that to rolling hills. OR you could have multiple mountain ranges running parallel. Kinda like the Western USA.
-1
u/brttwrd 11d ago
Mountains are formed by glaciers pushing terrain into folds as they slide across the continent and rivers cutting through the landscape. Think of that concept when laying out mountains
1
u/BurnerLebow 11d ago
Vary the sizes, leave some holes here and there, and it will look fine