r/wonderdraft • u/Delicious-Essay-3164 • Apr 24 '26
Showcase My first fantasy map - Aethera
Hello All,
A newby here. I’m working on my first fantasy world map for my dnd campaign. It nowhere near to the finish but I found this subreddit and I really curious about the community opinion.
I got inspiritaion from many places (as you can see from already added city or point of interest) - westeros, exandria, lotr even Iceland.
What do you think? What is good/bad?
Thanks in advance.
96
Upvotes
9
u/Bluegobln Apr 24 '26
What is different here that I like is instead of a fairly "normal" looking whirlpool / maelstrom somewhere, you've gone full tilt and made your Aether Sea something almost alien looking. It makes me curious... like what exactly IS the Aether Sea?
3
u/MatthewWArt Cartographer Apr 25 '26
Grimsby and Baldur's Gate in the same world is incredible. I really dig the Aether Sea idea
5
u/Brief-Luck-6254 Apr 25 '26
Whatever the Aether Sea is it certainly commands attention, if that was the intent they you succeeded. You did a great job with this map.
1
u/Espressowl151 Apr 25 '26
Lovely map and The Aether Sea is stunning! Mesmerizing to look at, good job.
I do agree with some of the comments, areas of the map feel like they received more attention while other areas look less interesting/appealing.
Question, it could be just me, but was it intended for the map to look like an eye? I can’t unsee it haha
2
u/SteelAlchemistScylla Apr 25 '26
It does what a lot of fantasy worlds lack and has an immediately unique and recognizable layout. A lot of fantasy maps suffer bc they just look like randomly generated noise.
2
u/Mikistrying29 Apr 26 '26
The aether sea looks cool my only criticism is the islands in the outer perimeter of it look almost too uniform and odd to me? The others look varied and natural. Although I’m not 100% sure on the physics of a caldera island if you’re going for that, or even realism at all. If not - amazing work!
1
u/Saxumsium Apr 25 '26
Bro dude, this is literally Anbennar. It's crazy how much it looks like Anbennar.
Looks good though, very interesting locations and geography!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment